View Full Version : The Shredder Strikes- what the shell?
Coola Yagami
07-28-2004, 07:27 AM
In the beginning of the ep, the tmnt were training with their weapons. Suddenly Leo jumps into the scene with his Katanas. Now what the hell happened here? Leo does some ...'slicing' that somehow knocks Mike, Don and Raph back, without even cutting them or their weapons or anything. Now what in the hell happened there? I know you can't show Leo cutting up his brothers, but why the hell did the show have him apparently slice and dice, and use that to send his brothers flying back. Did Leo borrow Kenshin's inversed blade or something?
Whitewolf89
07-28-2004, 09:43 AM
Have absolutely NO clue. I'll have to watch that ep again to see just what the heck you're TALKING about.
Leonardo_the_sword_master
07-28-2004, 09:50 AM
i know what he is taling about. well he could ahve hit there weapons but not hard enough to break them and thne knocked themback.
heretic888
07-28-2004, 02:46 PM
It was a plot device, don't think too deeply into it.
You wouldn't likely see a scene like that in something like the comics.
Spitfire
07-28-2004, 02:49 PM
Its like in Monster Hunter where Leo had no sword when he was out in the barn but for a few seconds they showed him with Swords looking at Raph. The show has a few errors but thank god none are as bad as the old show. The old show had errors all over. Mis colored head bands and the one that urks me the most other characters have the others voice. In the very first episode Don has Raph's voice........
J Legault
07-28-2004, 03:00 PM
It's just a cartoon, leo does that "Slice & Dice" thing allot of times, he did to the Foot Ninjas, but you don't see any of them with cuts at all, since the show isn't suppose to be too gore like.
But some scenes contain some vilents, cartoon violents, but not real time violents.
heretic888
07-28-2004, 03:01 PM
No, it wasn't an "error". It was a plot device. Its extremely unlikely Leo would be able to take any one of them that easily in an one-on-one battle.
The whole POINT of Leo "beating" the four of them so easily was for him to learn a lesson during the episode (i.e., ego takes a backseat to what's important).
Ryona
07-28-2004, 03:08 PM
The series really should correct things like that by having Leonardo use bokkens (wooden swords) instead of his "real" swords when they train. Leo is really good but there is always the chance that an accident can happen and he could end up really injuring his brothers... or worse.
rayfillet101
07-28-2004, 03:11 PM
He could poke an eye out! I think master splinter trusts the turtles enough and he knows they know what they are doing. Training with each others weaopns, maybe I wouldnt give them the real thing! :lol:
heretic888
07-28-2004, 03:14 PM
The series really should correct things like that by having Leonardo use bokkens (wooden swords) instead of his "real" swords when they train. Leo is really good but there is always the chance that an accident can happen and he could end up really injuring his brothers... or worse.
Well, realistically speaking.... NONE of them are good enough to take down the other three in a 4-second span. This was obviously nothing more than a hasty plot device intended to teach Leo a lesson later on.
Maybe Leo was using the blunt end of his katana. The opposite side of the sharp end.
DrSpengler
07-28-2004, 07:11 PM
It's just a cartoon, leo does that "Slice & Dice" thing allot of times, he did to the Foot Ninjas, but you don't see any of them with cuts at all, since the show isn't suppose to be too gore like.
But some scenes contain some vilents, cartoon violents, but not real time violents.
I think he was looking to have a thought-provoking discussion. I'm fairly sure he knows "it's just a cartoon". :roll:
Krow gave the response I was thinking of. Probably only one edge of his katana is sharp, while the other is blunt. He probably hit them with the blunt end really hard, which would give enogh force/pain to send them back. That's probably what he does whenever he's fighting Foot Soldiers and they just stumble back and go unconcious after he aparantly "slices" them. He just whacks them with the blunt edge of his katana in non-fatal locations that would render them unconcious.
Coola Yagami
07-28-2004, 10:10 PM
In part 2, Shredder did a very noticeable punch to Leo (or Mike, I forgot) with his blade hand, which is um... impossible to do without slicing the hell out of the turtles' face. Man,, such things like this can be avoided, especially sinde this version of the Shredder has one bladed hand.. they coulda drawn him doing that with the normal hand.
Perhaps Shredder had blunt-edged blades on that side. Those things ARE pretty thick. Maybe only the sharp ends are on the tips and the bottoms.
DrSpengler
07-28-2004, 10:44 PM
In part 2, Shredder did a very noticeable punch to Leo (or Mike, I forgot) with his blade hand, which is um... impossible to do without slicing the hell out of the turtles' face. Man,, such things like this can be avoided, especially sinde this version of the Shredder has one bladed hand.. they coulda drawn him doing that with the normal hand.
Well, before I go and look that up, do you remember what part of the body he punched? If it was the face it's possible they just rolled with the punch and only the lower portion of his knuckles managed to catch their flesh. But if it was something like their stomach then yeah, no way they'd get hit like that without being cut up.
Ryona
07-28-2004, 11:05 PM
Didn't Shredder hit him with the palm of his hand? I remember it being like that.
Leonardo_the_sword_master
07-28-2004, 11:17 PM
Didn't Shredder hit him with the palm of his hand? I remember it being like that.
yes you are right if not, then that was in the other epasode when leo first meats the shredder.
Coola Yagami
07-29-2004, 12:03 AM
No. I know there was a scene with Shredder smacking a turtle repeatedly with his palms. But there was another scene where you just see a flying shredder 'clawed' fist hit the screen, and the turtle was sent flying, this was near the end where shredder was knocking them against some wall one by one until all 4 tmnt were down. they never showed exactly where the punch hit the guy, but you can't ignore those long ass claws.
Ryona
07-29-2004, 01:18 AM
Maybe Shredder hit the shell (Plastron or carapace). The TMNT's shells are very thick and strong.
heretic888
07-29-2004, 09:44 AM
Maybe Leo was using the blunt end of his katana. The opposite side of the sharp end.
No. It was just a plot device. Don't think too much into it.
Krow gave the response I was thinking of. Probably only one edge of his katana is sharp, while the other is blunt. He probably hit them with the blunt end really hard, which would give enogh force/pain to send them back.
You've obviously never been hit with the flat side of a katana, then.
It hurts, but its not enough to knock you down without seriously damaging the blade. Katana blades were not intended to be blunt weapons (there are bokken and shinai for that), they are cutting and slicing weapons. Trying to "knockout" someone with a sword is about as logical as trying to pierce someone's skin with a chain.
DrSpengler
07-29-2004, 11:36 AM
Maybe Leo was using the blunt end of his katana. The opposite side of the sharp end.
No. It was just a plot device. Don't think too much into it.
We covered this before, the point of the thread IS to "think to much into it". Try and have a thought-provoking "fun" conversation.
Try it sometime.
J Legault
07-29-2004, 12:38 PM
Again, the cartoon can't be too gore like. The battles are violent only cartoon violent, but not gore violent.
heretic888
07-29-2004, 01:28 PM
We covered this before, the point of the thread IS to "think to much into it". Try and have a thought-provoking "fun" conversation.
There is nothing "thought-provoking" about any of these conjectures. They're only the kind of ideas that people that have never handled (nor been hit with) a sword could possibly make. Its about as plausible as a serious debate on why the Powerpuff Girls don't have fingers.
Leo "beat down" the other three in about three seconds because that's how the writers wrote it in. It is unlikely he could ever actually do that in a so-called "real fight", no matter how good he may or may not be. It was obviously a plot device intended to put Leo on a pedestal, from which he would be subsequently knocked down by both Splinter and Shredder.
Don't take it too seriously, guys. Its a cartoon. :wink:
DrSpengler
07-29-2004, 01:57 PM
There is nothing "thought-provoking" about any of these conjectures. They're only the kind of ideas that people that have never handled (nor been hit with) a sword could possibly make. Its about as plausible as a serious debate on why the Powerpuff Girls don't have fingers.
Leo "beat down" the other three in about three seconds because that's how the writers wrote it in. It is unlikely he could ever actually do that in a so-called "real fight", no matter how good he may or may not be. It was obviously a plot device intended to put Leo on a pedestal, from which he would be subsequently knocked down by both Splinter and Shredder.
Don't take it too seriously, guys. Its a cartoon. :wink:
We're all aware it's a cartoon. We're just trying to have some fun, Captain Bring-Down. :wink:
What the hell's wrong with my theory, heretic? Leo uses his swords on enemies WITHOUT them getting tore up. How ELSE can that happen? Leo not taking very good care of his katanas? Impossible. What's up with you, man?
heretic888
07-29-2004, 05:01 PM
What the hell's wrong with my theory, heretic? Leo uses his swords on enemies WITHOUT them getting tore up. How ELSE can that happen? Leo not taking very good care of his katanas? Impossible. What's up with you, man?
"What's up with me" is that I know how swords are actually used. If you aren't planning on slicing and dicing, then don't use a blade. Its that simple.
Well, okay, but the basis of this thread is that Leo DID use the blade and nothing happened.
raphael_is_cool
07-29-2004, 05:42 PM
No, it wasn't an "error". It was a plot device. Its extremely unlikely Leo would be able to take any one of them that easily in an one-on-one battle.
The whole POINT of Leo "beating" the four of them so easily was for him to learn a lesson during the episode (i.e., ego takes a backseat to what's important).
<ahem> Kinda like Mikey and Raph in 'Meet Casey Jones' or 'Raphael #1' don't you think? A plot device is all it is
heretic888
07-29-2004, 06:01 PM
Well, okay, but the basis of this thread is that Leo DID use the blade and nothing happened.
Yup. And my reply is that its a plot device. :D
<ahem> Kinda like Mikey and Raph in 'Meet Casey Jones' or 'Raphael #1' don't you think? A plot device is all it is
That was partly a plot device, since it was meant to reveal Raphael's "darker" side in an overt fashion. But, it was also more than a two-and-a-half second blurb in a cartoon. :wink:
Some plot devices really suck, don't they?
heretic888
07-30-2004, 09:07 AM
Some plot devices really suck, don't they?
I would say that if an event is nothing but a plot device, then it most certainly does "suck". Meaning, it was just haphazardly tossed in to tell the story of that particular arch or issue or episode. A 4 or 5 second blurb fits that bill --- a five minute battle does not.
Laterz.
raphael_is_cool
07-30-2004, 02:39 PM
A blurb like Leo beating all the others at once? Would it have been okay if it lasted a few minutes then? You don't make sense half the time
heretic888
07-30-2004, 02:56 PM
A blurb like Leo beating all the others at once? Would it have been okay if it lasted a few minutes then?
Sure. If it had been done realistically, with concern for detail, and not just haphazardly tossed in to set up the story-arch... then, sure.
You don't make sense half the time
More than likely, you just don't understand the concepts I'm discussing.
raphael_is_cool
07-30-2004, 03:03 PM
Leo "beat down" the other three in about three seconds because that's how the writers wrote it in. It is unlikely he could ever actually do that in a so-called "real fight", no matter how good he may or may not be. It was obviously a plot device intended to put Leo on a pedestal, from which he would be subsequently knocked down by both Splinter and Shredder.
And now you say that it was just a quick 'blurb'. Try using a correct word for this, although I can understand a blurb (by the sole definition) is usually a summarisation of a book. Thus you might imagine this is a summerisation of the fight. But you've already said it's unlikely he could ever beat them all.
That is an example of you not making sense
Coola Yagami
07-30-2004, 09:56 PM
he's just sayin leo can't beat all 3 of his brothers in a few seconds with no problem at all, but suddenly he can for the sake of the story.
heretic888
08-02-2004, 02:08 PM
That is an example of you not making sense
Actually, my use of the word 'blurb' was something of a pun. I apologize if the meaning was misinterpreted. :roll:
he's just sayin leo can't beat all 3 of his brothers in a few seconds with no problem at all, but suddenly he can for the sake of the story.
Exactly.
Kazari
08-02-2004, 02:09 PM
Sometimes I believe that Leo could beat all of his brothers during the beginning of the show but as the show developed I see how the turtles are becoming stronger in their fighting so if Leo had to verse all of his brothers at once now it wouldn't be as easy.
Bottom line: This particualr part of the show was friggin' ridiculous and is causing us to argue stupid points about blunt edges of the blades and weirdo plot devices. I say we just drop it. Nothing is going to change the way the show was done.
Kazari
08-02-2004, 04:02 PM
Yeah true. A lot of people are critical of everything that is shown in episodes.
heretic888
08-04-2004, 07:19 AM
Yeah true. A lot of people are critical of everything that is shown in episodes.
It's no really so much that at all. The post that started this topic merely asked how what Leo did is possible. And, the answer is it isn't. That isn't a criticism per se, just an observation. There are many improbable or impossible things in other fictions, that's not a bad thing.
Laterz.
Kazari
08-04-2004, 07:45 AM
I know that Heretic. All I am saying that people observe things and then sometimes are way too critical.
Coola Yagami
10-19-2022, 02:22 AM
I noticed that overall, the 2K3 show did that a lot.
Luckily the 2K12 show didn't do that kind of nonsense except for the one episode where Xever ran up to a turtle with his knives, slashed towards the camera, and the turtle was sent flying back as if he were punched.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.