PDA

View Full Version : splinter is flawed (only for die hard fans)


Gokhan
08-22-2004, 11:15 PM
ok i love the tmnt more than anything. i know its a comic an cartoon but i was thinkin at work today since i was bored an i never realized it until now.

i can accept splinter mockin the movements of his master learning basic hand to hand,but the weapons an stealth techniques throw me.

its not as if splinter had weapons to train with an while yoshi was out doing his stealth splinter was at home. this is a terrible flaw. so how is it he taught the tmnt how to use weapons an can beat all of them while armed wit weapons wit his walking stick?

KROW
08-22-2004, 11:33 PM
Well, Leonardo has a collection of books on weapons. Where do you think he got those? Perhaps from Splinter, who took them from Yoshi and into the sewers? And as for Splinter beating them without a proper weapon, I'm not even going to answer that one. I'm sure someone else will give you a much more thorough explanation on the fighting ability of Splinter.

Gokhan
08-22-2004, 11:44 PM
ok since we seem to want to be a smarty pants. leo may have a collection of books but who had to read to him when he was little? im sure he didnt. an dont u think people would have seen a rat carrying books? he still would have to learn to use them himself to be able to teach someone

i know splinter can beat any of the tmnt i was just using that as an example.

Spitfire
08-22-2004, 11:50 PM
Okay maybe just you know maybe Splinter learned weapons trainning when the turtles were little(You know they didnt always have weapons) and then taught them from that.

Gokhan
08-22-2004, 11:52 PM
what dont you people understand he has had no previous weapon experience an yet talks as if he is a true ninjisu master

Spitfire
08-22-2004, 11:53 PM
Okay didnt his master train with weapons though? With that case Splinter wouldnt need a weapon he could copy the movements Yoshi did witht the weapon in his cage and then train with a weapon later

malignant
08-22-2004, 11:53 PM
what dont you people understand he has had no previous weapon experience an yet talks as if he is a true ninjisu master

What dont you understand?...Its fantasy.

Every Comic based character ever created has flaws.

KROW
08-23-2004, 12:26 AM
HEY! Ever see a rat's tail? I think a rat can carry some books with it. And the ooze that mutated Splinter also increased his intelligence. Perhaps that's how he learned to read, savvy? And learning how to train by Yoshi by mimicry is basically good enough for a friggin' animal.

XERO
08-23-2004, 12:40 AM
For the weapons theory, Splinter must have just took small objects or sticks that resembled Japanese tools and trained himself.

He was a very special rat after all, even before he mutated.

Just my thought. :D

Leonardo_the_sword_master
08-23-2004, 05:50 AM
*slaps head* OK first off splinters weapon isn't jsut a stick u morons its a Jo look it up, and sercondley yes Leo had books and splinter COULD read them.

GK Punk
08-23-2004, 06:30 AM
*slaps head* OK first off splinters weapon isn't jsut a stick u morons its a Jo look it up, and sercondley yes Leo had books and splinter COULD read them.

"OK First off" Don't insult the other users unless you want a warning.

Gokhan
08-23-2004, 07:11 AM
Okay didnt his master train with weapons though? With that case Splinter wouldnt need a weapon he could copy the movements Yoshi did witht the weapon in his cage and then train with a weapon later

i thought of dis. but watchign somethign an actually doing it is different. i mean we watch the olympics an see the gymnastics. does dat mean by watchin a tape over an over im gonna go outside an tumble like those girls?

Leonardo_the_sword_master
08-23-2004, 08:19 AM
*slaps head* OK first off splinters weapon isn't jsut a stick u morons its a Jo look it up, and sercondley yes Leo had books and splinter COULD read them.

"OK First off" Don't insult the other users unless you want a warning.

yes sir (((not joking)))

KROW
08-23-2004, 09:46 AM
Okay didnt his master train with weapons though? With that case Splinter wouldnt need a weapon he could copy the movements Yoshi did witht the weapon in his cage and then train with a weapon later

i thought of dis. but watchign somethign an actually doing it is different. i mean we watch the olympics an see the gymnastics. does dat mean by watchin a tape over an over im gonna go outside an tumble like those girls?

No. Mimicking it and practicing it will. Didn't I say that? Watching something will not make you able to do it, unless you're the Taskmaster.

Kali
08-23-2004, 05:23 PM
Well if we're going to discuss this as if it wasn't fiction...

Like they said, Splinter learned through mimicry and practice. It's also quite possible that the style of ninjutsu practiced by Splinter, and taught to the Turtles, is not exactly like what was practiced by Hamato Yoshi. I doubt, even after Splinter's mutation, that he remembered everything he witnessed. That he could even do everything he witnessed, but he probably adapted it. But that basic knowledge, supplemented by books, practice, and determination, could explain his skill.

BTW, I don't have all the comics, but does Splinter actually ever claim to be a master of ninjutsu? I assumed his Master title came from his teacher status.

Hamato Inya
08-23-2004, 06:13 PM
i read in one fanfiction that Splinter was Hamato Yoshi i think that was true in like a comic, but that would explain why he knew weapons and stuff... so they may have based everything else off of that

Leonardo_the_sword_master
08-23-2004, 06:16 PM
i read in one fanfiction that Splinter was Hamato Yoshi i think that was true in like a comic, but that would explain why he knew weapons and stuff... so they may have based everything else off of that

thats how it was in the old cartoons and in some cmocis.

Doppleganger
08-23-2004, 06:19 PM
read in one fanfiction that Splinter was Hamato Yoshi i think that was true in like a comic, but that would explain why he knew weapons and stuff... so they may have based everything else off of that


Yeah that was also part of the old cartoon. Splinter was once Hamato Yoshi and got mutated after he gathered the turtles, touching the ooze in the process and was near a rats. So he mutated into a rat.

As for the discussion I'll say the tired saying. "It's just a cartoon." In the old cartoon he was a master of ninjitsu because he practiced as a human. In the new one he learned by mimicking Hamato Yoshi. He was probably intelligent enough to learn with weapons after awhile. We all could in theory but with a lot of practice.

Hamato Inya
08-23-2004, 06:19 PM
so do you think that they just based the movie stuff and the new cartoon stuff off that idea... but he was Hamato Yoshi's pet?

Doppleganger
08-23-2004, 06:21 PM
I'm not sure. I think the movie was somewhat inspired by the Mirage comics. And that's where they got him mimicking.

Ryona
08-23-2004, 06:38 PM
I'm sorry to say this, but some of you have really got to do your homework on the TMNT. TMNT has a long history, all the way back from 1984 as nothing more than comics. Splinter was ALWAYS a rat! Only in the old series and the Archie comics was Splinter once human.

Anyway....... Back on topic. I know that I read that Hamato Yoshi would take Splinter with him to the dojo where he and his fellow peers would train. So, I imagine that Splinter learned a Hell of alot from the dojo by witnessing all the events that went on in there. Plus, Splinter is very resorceful. Like it was said, He probably used whatever he could find in his cage to use as crude weapon replicas.

Albrecht
08-23-2004, 09:08 PM
It is possible to teach your self how to use a weapon its not that hard, I mess with nunchucks alot, I am actually pretty good with my right but I often hit myself with my left. :lol:

And who ever said that splinters "walking stick" is a jo staff, youre kinda right, thats what I wish it was and it pretty much is but in most TMNT universes its thicker at the top than it is the bottom so its not actually a jo (i think)

Ryona
08-24-2004, 03:27 AM
You make a good point, Albrecht. In any case, the interesting thing about Taijutsu is that it's very adaptable with weapons. the stances don't really change. Ichimunji no kamae unarmed is still ichimunji no kamae with a bo. Hira no kamae unarmed is still hira no kamae with a pair of ninja-to.
Also, strikes, defences, movement and such are still very simular with weapons as they are without weapons in Ninjutsu. One who trains in the art of Taijutsu can pick up pretty much any object and use it as an effective weapon corresponding with the unarmed techniques. :wink:

As for Splinters "walking stick" the fact that it's thin at the bottom and thick and bulbous shaped at the top is to make it look like an old hermet's walking stick/staff. It's just for the sake of apperance; to make Splinter look like an old wise sage. Regardless of it's odd shape, it can still be used as a weapon. I would say that it's more like a hanbo rather than a jo. :)

Leonardo_the_sword_master
08-24-2004, 06:57 AM
Ryo and ablerchet (sorry 4 miss spelling) you to hav ereally good points, but who knows it mayb e a Jo staff it may not. but if i had to pick one then i would say Jo staff.

the Dark Knight
08-25-2004, 04:28 AM
Boy, guys, I don't know. I can buy that a bunch of turtles can mutate into jive talking humanoid turtles, and that a rat can mutate into human form, and I can buy a bunch of other humanoid mutations of creatures like alligators and rabbits and frogs and whatever, and I can buy that an entire alien race of beings who resemble brains can come down to earth and live amongst us in secret. I can believe all those things, but boy, once those mutant turtles start using weapons, WOW!!! That just throws me for a loop!!! Totalllly unbelievable.

Leonardo_the_sword_master
08-25-2004, 07:20 AM
Boy, guys, I don't know. I can buy that a bunch of turtles can mutate into jive talking humanoid turtles, and that a rat can mutate into human form, and I can buy a bunch of other humanoid mutations of creatures like alligators and rabbits and frogs and whatever, and I can buy that an entire alien race of beings who resemble brains can come down to earth and live amongst us in secret. I can believe all those things, but boy, once those mutant turtles start using weapons, WOW!!! That just throws me for a loop!!! Totalllly unbelievable.
OK???!!?!?!?!?! *looks around confused* did any1 else understand him?

the Dark Knight
08-25-2004, 01:55 PM
it's called sarcasm, dude.

Leonardo_the_sword_master
08-25-2004, 05:31 PM
it's called sarcasm, dude.
thats not what i ment........... i ment icouldn't understand what u ment?

Red Lioness
08-25-2004, 06:47 PM
You ever seen two rats fight? It wouldn't take a whole lot to call them martial artists. And on the stealth side of things: he's a rat. You don't have to teach a rat to be stealthy. That's how they've survived over the millenia.

Leonardo_the_sword_master
08-25-2004, 07:59 PM
You ever seen two rats fight? It wouldn't take a whole lot to call them martial artists. And on the stealth side of things: he's a rat. You don't have to teach a rat to be stealthy. That's how they've survived over the millenia.
DING DING DING DING!!!! and that is the correct answer.

cqb101
08-26-2004, 10:47 AM
Boy, guys, I don't know. I can buy that a bunch of turtles can mutate into jive talking humanoid turtles, and that a rat can mutate into human form, and I can buy a bunch of other humanoid mutations of creatures like alligators and rabbits and frogs and whatever, and I can buy that an entire alien race of beings who resemble brains can come down to earth and live amongst us in secret. I can believe all those things, but boy, once those mutant turtles start using weapons, WOW!!! That just throws me for a loop!!! Totalllly unbelievable.

I know. People need to stop taking things so seriously. Splinter having martial arts training is flawed and foru mutated turtles isn't?

the Dark Knight
08-26-2004, 09:21 PM
I know. People need to stop taking things so seriously. Splinter having martial arts training is flawed and foru mutated turtles isn't?


DING DING DING!!! WE HAVE THE CORRECT ANSWER!!!

That's exactly what I meant. Spinter learning martial arts is far fetched, but mutant turtles and aliens aren't?? You gotta be kidding me.


by the way, cqb101, I love your Tarantino themed avatar!

cqb101
08-26-2004, 09:57 PM
LOl, thanks! I like your Bubba Ho-Tep sig. Bruce Campbell is the man.