PDA

View Full Version : a more adult turtle show?


Ra
03-18-2005, 05:58 AM
i was just wondering. people are saying one or two things are wrong with this show, so this thread is for people to discribe 'the perfect show'. here are my two cents -

you know how the new show is - Stockmen coming back after contless times of coming back and cheating death, characters seeming 'immortal', Mikey not able to say 'Dead' without struggling to find the words for it. well, i'm just seeing if anyone wants turtles aimed at adults like the old Mirage comic used to be

make characters *sneezestockmencough* go away and stay away with the shadow of death over them, more blood shed, Casey and April actually KISSING!, maybe the introduction of Shadow, at least one drop of blood after a huge battle with about 50 foot per turtle, and nicks and cuts if anybody gets hit after fighting with a guy weilding an axe. maybe some other universal characters (Image, old toon, ect.) and maybe the turtles dealing with things like love. i'm well aware that people like the turtles the way they are, but i'm just wondering

so, what do ya think?

Kazari
03-18-2005, 06:34 AM
I like the new show but this wouldn't be bad with more violence LOL

Mecha Cow
03-18-2005, 07:25 AM
Normally, I would say no to the 'darkness', but in TMNT, it actually fits.

I think the show is fine the way it is though. I just saw 'Same as it never was' and it definately proves that they can bend the rules a little when needed. I hope they do that more often (Only when it helps the story of course). I don't think blood and gore is nessecary, but I'd like it if characters would actually die when needed (Shredder). And since when can't they use the word 'dead' in cartoons? The gasping gets a bit annoying.

PizzaPower
03-18-2005, 07:39 AM
oh yes they sure do end the rules as much as they can. Expeccally in "Hun on the Run"

MrPliggins
03-19-2005, 06:05 PM
There is no option for this, so I will just say it: I like the show just how it is.. I think it is dark enough and always pushes the bar higher. It's amazing the stuff they can get away with sometimes.

ZariusTwo
03-19-2005, 06:53 PM
LOVE? That never works with the Turtles, hell I can't even stand Regenta right now

MrPliggins
03-19-2005, 10:40 PM
Yeah, it only worked in the old toon, because it was a goofy show anyway. Raph/Mona Lisa... Leo/Lotus...Leo/Mike/Raph/Irma....some funny stuff. But yeah, new show turtle love just doesn't seem right. Don/ April? no way... it would never be done, but I don't know if Casey / April is much better...

ZariusTwo
03-19-2005, 10:42 PM
Yeah, it only worked in the old toon, because it was a goofy show anyway. Raph/Mona Lisa... Leo/Lotus...Leo/Mike/Raph/Irma....some funny stuff. But yeah, new show turtle love just doesn't seem right. Don/ April? no way... it would never be done, but I don't know if Casey / April is much better...


Actually, I think the writers wanted to pair Irma with Donatello, due to a few "hints" in the original series

MrPliggins
03-19-2005, 10:45 PM
Actually, I think the writers wanted to pair Irma with Donatello, due to a few "hints" in the original series

Ah, now that you mention it I do remember those hints... I was just thinking of the episode Green with Jealousy when I mentioned that above.

Doppleganger
03-20-2005, 08:03 AM
I agree with MrPliggins the show is great just the way it is. No need for gore in it.

Lioness-Goddess
03-20-2005, 08:53 AM
Yeah, I think the show is fine. It's kinda hard to be a ninja without ANY violence, but for now it's okay.

IceFlash78
03-20-2005, 10:57 AM
Well... I think TMNT is excellent the way it is, but to make it completely adult (or atleast an teen show) a few changes coudl be made...

1) Blood.. I don't mean that the writers should add GORE and stuff, but I think they should have blood on swords or on the bodies if they've been slashed. But if blood looked corny or unrealistic, then I would say do without it. That, and I rather like the "slash with the black screen" myself. I would NOT want they to show the ACTUAL slash. I just think a little blood after the slash (or the black screen effect) would be appropriate.

2) I don't mind the "Shell" thing, but...nah.. forget it.. If they did redesign the TMNT, I would maybe subsitute the words "Shell" with damn or hell or whatever or Crud with Crap... I kinda find it lurdicious that Hun, this HULKING BRUTE would say crud instead of crap... But I don't mind it the way it is now.

Basically I htink my suggestions are just like Ra's suggestions.. I like the idea of actual ROMANCE/LOVE between April and Casey. Overall, the show is excellent the way it is now. I think all of these changes coudl be made if the show was geared toward teens (which it is) and not adhere to kids' rules (4Kids' rules), which even though the show was psuhed boundaries and is very dark, is still "kiddie" in some other aspects (i.e., April/Casey, "SHELL" etc, etc,). However, I would not support any changes that would negatively affect the future of the Turtles.. I don't want Network execs/mothers who can't control their kids by themselves to cancel the show because its too adult...TMNT is kinda in risk right now, with Same as it never was and hun on the run and other violent episodes... I love it too much to see it cancelled prematurely...

Gemma
03-20-2005, 11:26 AM
The only thing that bothered me was when Leo was beaten up in Shredder Strikes Back. He was slashed at, kicked, punched and God knows what else when the Elite were finished with him, then thrown through a window. All he had to show for it was bruises. Ugly dark green perfectly circular bruises. I know its a kids show mainly but even kids know that that kind of punishment would leave a bit more of a mark than that.

John 14:6
03-20-2005, 02:17 PM
Yeah, it only worked in the old toon, because it was a goofy show anyway. Raph/Mona Lisa... Leo/Lotus...Leo/Mike/Raph/Irma....some funny stuff. But yeah, new show turtle love just doesn't seem right. Don/ April? no way... it would never be done, but I don't know if Casey / April is much better...
And didn't Michealangelo and that Nuetrino girl like each other? :D

Rikirk
03-20-2005, 02:43 PM
Yes...a more adult TMNT would be very cool.

Dont get me wrong, I still like the previous two series, but they are "Kid-ified", or rather dumbed down. I understand the reasons for doing this...if it was the other way we would have kids wielding swords and sais and running roughshod thru the streets,...(wait..doesnt that happen now in some form or another...but I digress)

A more mature show would be interesting, hey..just look at Adult Swim...If im not mistaken that series gets rather high ratings and is quite popular.

Maybe the Japanese animation companies may latch onto this idea and run with it. They tried it with Sonic the Hedgehog...why not TMNT.


My 2 cents...
subtract 1.99 tenths of a cent due to taxes.

creativerealms82
03-20-2005, 02:45 PM
It could use some blood. I mean the turtles take a lot of punishment and even get slashed by weapons from like to time. A few red Scratches would not hurt. Blood would really have helped 'Same as it never was' I mean those clean bodys after they got fatally sliced my a sword is just not going to Happen, especially Raph who did not instantly die.

As for love the upfront Casey/April pairing and the probably limited to just a few hints Leo/Karai pairing are enough for me. I don't expect the writers to go any further on it then they all ready are.

Anarchistguy
03-20-2005, 03:12 PM
Heh...I just noticed TMNT is the ONLY bloodless ninja TV show I've ever seen. It's weird.

CyberCubed
03-20-2005, 03:37 PM
I say take it to the level of the Mirage Comics. Blood without going overboard.

For example, Leo and Raph should actually use their weapons on the Foot inflicting wounds on them. The TMNT do that in the comics all the time. Also the TMNT bleeding in heavy battles would be a nice touch.

Relationships for the TMNT however, has always been awful. Regenta sucks, Ninjara was OK by herself but I hated her as a girlfriend of Raph's, Mona Lisa was meh, etc.

I just hate the idea of the TMNT with love interests, I don't know why.

marleynaki
03-20-2005, 03:43 PM
yes!!! i will like see more violence....

Sewer Bull
03-20-2005, 04:28 PM
More raw language. Don't mean cursing and swearing a lot, but sometimes it is stupid to hear them (especially Raph the badass) using childish language instead of even "damn" or "hell" or some other which are not too vulgar. "Shell" is nice, especially when they say something like "oh shhh... ell".

Best wishes,

Robweiller

Hannah
03-20-2005, 04:33 PM
Maybe the Japanese animation companies may latch onto this idea and run with it. They tried it with Sonic the Hedgehog...why not TMNT.


Because, Sonic is from Japan, and the TMNT are not.

Ra
03-20-2005, 11:15 PM
Well... I think TMNT is excellent the way it is, but to make it completely adult (or atleast an teen show) a few changes coudl be made...

1) Blood.. I don't mean that the writers should add GORE and stuff, but I think they should have blood on swords or on the bodies if they've been slashed. But if blood looked corny or unrealistic, then I would say do without it. That, and I rather like the "slash with the black screen" myself. I would NOT want they to show the ACTUAL slash. I just think a little blood after the slash (or the black screen effect) would be appropriate.

2) I don't mind the "Shell" thing, but...nah.. forget it.. If they did redesign the TMNT, I would maybe subsitute the words "Shell" with damn or hell or whatever or Crud with Crap... I kinda find it lurdicious that Hun, this HULKING BRUTE would say crud instead of crap... But I don't mind it the way it is now.

Basically I htink my suggestions are just like Ra's suggestions.. I like the idea of actual ROMANCE/LOVE between April and Casey. Overall, the show is excellent the way it is now. I think all of these changes coudl be made if the show was geared toward teens (which it is) and not adhere to kids' rules (4Kids' rules), which even though the show was psuhed boundaries and is very dark, is still "kiddie" in some other aspects (i.e., April/Casey, "SHELL" etc, etc,). However, I would not support any changes that would negatively affect the future of the Turtles.. I don't want Network execs/mothers who can't control their kids by themselves to cancel the show because its too adult...TMNT is kinda in risk right now, with Same as it never was and hun on the run and other violent episodes... I love it too much to see it cancelled prematurely...

yes. this is what i mean - make it abit more life based. i like it though, don't get me wrong, but just show at least one drop of blood would really make me happy :)

and also, the last option on the poll is supposed to be "don't change anything". if anyone can change it i would be really grateful :)

U2WaTCHer
03-22-2005, 11:36 AM
well no one remembers they did say "dead" last episode and they used the word "kill" massive times in a few episodes back god I can't remember what one but I swear "killed" was used a lot and I know the last one def someone said someone was "dead"

longing for leo
03-22-2005, 08:49 PM
sounds like we've all got the same gripes about the show, but i'll add my 2 cents anyway.

blood: i agree that the show would be better w/ some. i don't think blood should be shown just for the sake of having it but i do think that in some cases it is absolutely necessary. for example: in same as it never was, every1 died w/out a scratch; they just dropped dead. now, how confusing must that be to kids watching the show? i mean come on, it's like the turtles were just sleeping. like stabbing, slicing, or shooting some1 will do nothing more than knock them down. no big deal. i think the kids need to see blood to understand that their heros really are hurt & aren't gonna be able to jump up & be ok. how can the kids understand that blows like those mean suffering/pain & that the person cannot come back unless they are shown that the blows really do harm? heros bleed too. our boys in green aren't invincible. kids should learn that no 1 is.
i know i've gone on a rant about it already, but i just want to add an anecdote. my younger cousin use to be really into power rangers. whenever we would all get together & play house or whatever, he would always be 1. & it the middle of our game he would get into it/excited & start flailing his arms ninja style or even grab a "sword" (stick) & start swinging it around. a couple times he accidentally hit one of his sisters or cousins. now please don't get any ideas, he's not a violent person. he's a pre-teen now & hasn't done anything like that for many years. but my point is: he didn't ever think that he could actually hurt any1 cause he saw the power rangers fight w/out any1 ever bleeding or anything. so... that's why i think blood is important for kid's shows when it's justified.
any1 agree?

personally i really like the darker/more violent eps. season 3 has been by far my favorite. so, while it's good to have light eps, i hope that this trend of more darker 1s continues.

it's probably just me, but i wish they would have less eps centered around space & weird aliens/creatures. some are ok, but the whole fugitoid arc kinda bogged me down. my favorite types of eps are those in new york w/ ninja enemys. i understand that they can only do so much in ny & i don't have any ideas, so i shouldn't complain.

i agree that the turtles having girlfriends probably wouldn't work. i don't really think that leo should go out w/ karai (especially after her future self's dispicable behavior in sainw), but i would like those little hints explored a bit further.

Red Lioness
03-22-2005, 09:38 PM
I agree with the blood thing. If they can have a perfect robot copy of Splinter get torn limb from limb by a Triceraton, I think they can show a little blood. You think children never see blood? Show me a playground where no one has ever skinned a knee or busted a nose or whatnot. Blood is what happens when you get hurt. It's a simple fact.

As for the love interests . . . . I agree that girlfriends wouldn't really work in this series, but it would be nice if the brothers at least had an interest in pretty girls. I mean, they are teenage boys, after all. You wouldn't even have to have any contact between a turtle and the girls; I think it would be pretty cool if they had an episode where one of the guys got all cow-eyed and moony over some girl they just saw on a regular basis.

Kinda pathetic, creepy, stalker-ish, but cool.