PDA

View Full Version : Comics vs. the New Series


John 14:6
04-06-2005, 04:58 PM
Sorry if this has been discussed before...

I know the original TMNT TV show had a lot of differences from the original comic, which I never read. I read that the new TV series is much more like the comics, but I just heard that the Shredder was not an utrom in the comics. Is this true? What other differences are there?

Thanks!

Duke
04-06-2005, 05:43 PM
Although the new show is based off the comics, there are some major differences. Oroku Saki was a man, who died in the very first issue of the comics. The whole Oroku Saki/Hamato Yoshi backstory has major differences. There is no bishop, notes from the underground, or battle nexus stories/characters in the comics. Plus many other noticable differences.

ZariusTwo
04-06-2005, 06:40 PM
Sorry if this has been discussed before...

I know the original TMNT TV show had a lot of differences from the original comic, which I never read. I read that the new TV series is much more like the comics, but I just heard that the Shredder was not an utrom in the comics. Is this true? What other differences are there?

Thanks!

www.ninjaturtles.com

Read the comics section for MIRAGE Volume One, you'll get a pretty good idea of how different the comics are.

CyberCubed
04-06-2005, 06:53 PM
Except ignore every issue from #22-#44, those are all guest writers and not part of Mirage Continuity.

The new show as Peter Laird describes it, "is an adaption of the original TMNT comics with new stuff added"

Basically it's a new take on old storylines.

Aztec General
04-06-2005, 09:55 PM
Yeah, this is the Mirage series "with liberties". I actually like the story that the new show is telling BETTER than the overall comic storyline. It's more interconnected and interesting. That's not to say that I like the new show better than the comics...just that I like the storyline better.

R-iZZy
04-07-2005, 12:28 AM
I haven't seen much of a difference from the first volume of the Mirage comics and the new series, besides the fact that Shredder is an utrom in the show and a human in the comics, plus some new characters were added to the show.

But a lot of the stuff might seem a bit familiar: Renet, Lord Simultaneous, Savanti Romero... even some stories are similar. Leo getting his shell kicked and April's place being invaded by The Foot. The new series is definitely a homeage to the old Mirage comics.

ZariusTwo
04-07-2005, 07:36 AM
I had no idea there was a great deal of non-cannon stories in Volume One, considering how crap most of them were, I'm glad.

Jester
04-07-2005, 10:34 AM
there is one character who only appears in the mirage story origen...can you name him??
Oroku Saki's older brother Nagi who wished to wed Teng Shen
Oh, and John...u can read the complete 1st issue of Vol one on the official site...:D

CyberCubed
04-07-2005, 05:07 PM
I too like the new show better than the comics. IMO the only thing the comics does better is obviously the realistic violence, showing the TMNT actually cut the Foot soldiers, etc.

Other than that, the continuity in the comics was always messed up, with a bunch of crappy guest writer issues in the middle that Peter Laird declared "non-canon".

raphaelprime
04-07-2005, 08:30 PM
shredder was as tough in the Mirage comics as in the show, only in the show he's lasted longer than in the comics where he only lasted 21 issues.

Another major difference is how the TMNT met Leatherhead....in the new toon they met him in the sewers tryin to build a transmat, after mikey spotted him helping Don..in the comics(Tales of the TMNT vol. 1) they met him while he was bein chased by a hunter, which became the episode "Hunted" in season 3 which takes place well after they have met Leatherhead.

ZariusTwo
04-07-2005, 10:40 PM
shredder was as tough in the Mirage comics as in the show, only in the show he's lasted longer than in the comics where he only lasted 21 issues.

Yet he only appeared in six.

raphaelprime
04-07-2005, 10:49 PM
that is true, i wasnt really thinkin bout how many he'd been in just goin for how many had passed before his death, lol, but yeh he's only in 6 of the actual issues.

Spitfire
04-07-2005, 11:12 PM
From the comics I read it seems like a few of the episodes are based off episodes. Like Reality Check for Mikey had to have been based off #7 of Volume 4 and almost all of Season 1 and 2 were based off the Volume 1 comics

John 14:6
04-08-2005, 05:28 AM
shredder was as tough in the Mirage comics as in the show, only in the show he's lasted longer than in the comics where he only lasted 21 issues.

Another major difference is how the TMNT met Leatherhead....in the new toon they met him in the sewers tryin to build a transmat, after mikey spotted him helping Don..in the comics(Tales of the TMNT vol. 1) they met him while he was bein chased by a hunter, which became the episode "Hunted" in season 3 which takes place well after they have met Leatherhead.
I actually had that issue!
I haven't looked at the links here yet so maybe it's covered in one of them, but I read at some point in the comics Shredder was dead and his body was being controlled by alien parasites. What's that all about? When I first found out that he was an utrom in this series that's what I thought they were talking about...

ZariusTwo
04-08-2005, 07:47 AM
I actually had that issue!
I haven't looked at the links here yet so maybe it's covered in one of them, but I read at some point in the comics Shredder was dead and his body was being controlled by alien parasites...


The worms are not "alien", there a combination of magic and science that consume dead flesh and reform as a new version of that body and person.

raphael_is_cool
04-08-2005, 08:48 AM
As for tough...if memory serves, in the comic doesn't even Casey Jones nearly take the Shredder down in one issue (#11 'The Silent Partner', the sequel to Leonardo #1, I think)?

But overall in the original comics he does seem a lot more lethal.

Or he at least gets a few good hits in

I think I prefer a lot of Volume One to the new show but there were so many lame issues by guest writers. While it was Laird and Eastman it was brilliant and their issues usually had the best art.

But I also love the new show's take on things. It's refreshingly different yet still retains some of the great elements that have always made the ninja turtles appealing.

Anarchistguy
04-08-2005, 09:19 AM
Also, Casey Jones and Raphael are WAY more agressive in the comics than in the new show.

raphaelprime
04-09-2005, 12:27 AM
From the comics I read it seems like a few of the episodes are based off episodes. Like Reality Check for Mikey had to have been based off #7 of Volume 4 and almost all of Season 1 and 2 were based off the Volume 1 comics

yeh i just seen 'Reality Check' for the first time today and soon as i seen it i was like Volume 4, lol, i thought that was pretty good episode tho.

Lone Wolf
04-09-2005, 01:39 AM
I am currently re-reading volume 1, and I have to say the series has taken the plot of the comics and done a splendid job of adapting and building upon it.

I think it is interesting how they have placed emphasis on certain aspects of the Turtles' personalities (Mikeys sense of humor, Don's love of science and reason) and tuned down others (Raphs aggressiveness, mindlessness, and overall wild streak; Mikeys abstract/artistic sensibilities).

Personally I find Raph a lot more likable in the animated series; in the comics, he comes off as an angry, delinquent child with a lust for chaos and destruction (at least in Volume 1). In the cartoon, he is more like a pragmatist with a temper.

Heh bringing this up reminds me of Mikey's quote (from "Nano" if I remember correctly) that describes the comic book Raph more accurately than the TV raph: " Like when Raph goes solo... he becomes mindless, unmotivated..." :lol:

raphael_is_cool
04-09-2005, 03:59 AM
Raph does seem a little better in the new series than in the comics. Although he didn't always end up as the 'first guy to rush in and get hit badly'.

But even now in the recent Tales issue (vol 2, #9) he seems to have mellowed out. Or at least the writer (Lawson, who gets a lot of kudos from me) decided to do something different to having him always punching and breaking stuff...he's even sat reading a book while he could be watching The Simpsons!

John 14:6
04-09-2005, 07:46 AM
Also, Casey Jones and Raphael are WAY more agressive in the comics than in the new show.
There was that one episode early on where Raph blew up and tried to attack Mike but the others stopped him. Raph then took off to do some soul searching and cried out from the rooftops, "What's wrong with me?" (I could really identify him with him and felt for him there as I have the same issue from time to time.) Raph met up with some kid in crisis and started telling him about how he had to keep his cool. Raph has been pretty mellow ever since.

Was Casey in the comics anything like Casey from the original series? I know he married April in the comics so he couldn't have been that crazy. (Unless that was a guest writer or something...)

Anarchistguy
04-09-2005, 08:37 AM
Even though he's with April in the comics, he's not the bumbling idiot he is in the new show.

John 14:6
04-11-2005, 05:11 AM
I see the Rat King mentioned quite a bit lately. Was he in the comics? If so, how did he compare to the Rat King from the original series?

ZariusTwo
04-11-2005, 06:53 AM
I see the Rat King mentioned quite a bit lately. Was he in the comics? If so, how did he compare to the Rat King from the original series?


He first appeared in the original Tales of the TMNT comics, died in the same issue, and mainfested himself as an apparirtion to Splinter during "City At War"

raphael_is_cool
04-11-2005, 12:55 PM
He first appeared in the original Tales of the TMNT comics, died in the same issue, and mainfested himself as an apparirtion to Splinter during "City At War"

I still don't understand why it shows him falling and sounding like dying, yet the last panel shows him alive and well.

And then he reappears as an apparition.

Was Casey in the comics anything like Casey from the original series? I know he married April in the comics so he couldn't have been that crazy. (Unless that was a guest writer or something...)

In bits he was. One issue where they're hiding out in Northampton has him and Raph messing around 'doin' projects, doin' projects' in the same way him and Don do in the film. But he's not quite so stupid...except when he's a mutato head, but that was a guest writer and stuff

Ace Duck
04-17-2005, 11:45 AM
Even though he's with April in the comics, he's not the bumbling idiot he is in the new show.

No kidding. For me, this is one of the (very few) disappointing aspects of the new series.

John 14:6
04-17-2005, 04:24 PM
I haven't checked out the web site yet because I don't want to spoil any future episodes for myself and... because I'm lazy :oops:
So a couple more questions... Were Hun or Karai in the comics, or did Shredder have some other main Foot cohorts. And what was Stockman like in the comics? Was he more like the original series' Stockman or this one, did he work for the Shredder, and did he go through all the same torture?
Thanks!

raphael_is_cool
04-17-2005, 04:50 PM
Karai came along for City at War just like in the new series. She was in charge of the Japanese Foot Clan but I can't remember if there was the shredder past. I don't think there was.

There was no Hun.

Stockman was sort of the same in his first appearance, except there was never a connection between him and the shredder in the comics, but he did end up in a robot body (I think).

Also, the elite guard were kinda in the original comics as well. Just never such a big part early on.

John 14:6
05-14-2005, 10:03 PM
Since Shredder wasn't an Utrom in the comics, was Hamato Yoshi a guardian? What was the Utrom storyline like in the comics?

Coola Yagami
05-14-2005, 11:23 PM
Since Shredder wasn't an Utrom in the comics, was Hamato Yoshi a guardian? What was the Utrom storyline like in the comics?

Shredder was a human that was killed in the first issue. The Foot rebuilt a clone of him that was killed by Leo beheading him.

Karai appeared afterwards to regain order in the Foot. She led the Japanese Foot, and I don't remember if she had connections with Shredder or not since he was already dead at this time. In City at War, the Shredder Elite (Foot Elite in the show) were running around killing other Foot members and Karai wanted them dealt with. Since the Shredder Elite was mainly after Leo, Karai worked a deal with the turtles in which they'd help each other defeat the Elite in exchange for the Foot never bothering the TMNT again when she led the Foot.

As for Baxter, basically the same story in his first appearance, but he was never involved with the Foot. He later escaped prison and put his brain in a robot body, out to get revenge on April.

The Ultrom plot was kinda/sorta like 'Search for Splinter/Turtles in Space/Secret Origins', except Shredder and Foot weren't involved. In the comics the whole Ultrom plot happened shortly after they first ran into Shredder and Baxter. The Ultroms later appeared in Volume 4 where they announced their existance to the world and left Earth open for alien and mutant turtles to wander the streets openly.

As for Hamato Yoshi, he was just a regular human that was killed by Shredder long ago. The cartoon made him of greater importance with him winning the Battle Nexus and being a Guardian and all that.

John 14:6
05-17-2005, 05:34 PM
Great info, thanks!

Aska_Badoura
05-18-2005, 03:34 PM
Karai was pretty high up in the heirarchy of the Foot, above the Shredder, in fact. The Japanese Foot thought he was nuts (which was of course entirely unfounded...not. ;)), and so when he died, they wasted no time sending somebody to take control of his offshoot, and bring some sanity to it. Theoretically, the NYC Foot would be honor-bound to obey them. But it turned out the Elite were as nuts as the Shredder was, and refused to follow any other Foot official. The regular Foot ninja were subject to them, hence the infighting. Of course, in the new show, the Shredder is the founder of the Foot, so the heirarchy thing was rearranged, making him in charge of ALL of it, including Karai. Not much of Karai's past was revealed, although she did have a daughter, who was killed in an attack by the Shredder's Foot. Obviously, that's not the case in the new series (wouldn't that throw a wrench in the works? http://www.geocities.com/jafarnut/blink.gif I don't wanna even go there... :roll: )

Hamato Yoshi was actually a member of the Foot (he was a Foot in the original 'toon too, wasn't he?), or at least a rival to Saki's brother Nagi. It's pretty much like the first movie, except that Nagi was the one 'in love' with Tang Shen rather than Saki, and threatened her when she chose Yoshi over him. Nagi attacked her, and Yoshi killed him, then fled to America with Shen. Saki wasn't terribly happy, and went after Yoshi and Shen, killing both, inadvertantly setting Splinter free, blah blah blah, you know the rest. :)

Um, you know, this is crazy, but I've never even actually read any of these, myself... this is all the stuff I've soaked up over seven years of TMNT web surfing. Scary what you can learn through the internet without ever picking up a comic.. :goofygri: