PDA

View Full Version : Is it any good?


Kenton
08-25-2005, 12:14 AM
Well because I hear that the new TMNT would not be like the old ones, I decided that they wouldn't be good at all and I would hate them. So I never watched an episode. I want everyones honest opinion if the show is good at all. Maybe I will even watch it this saturday.

Spitfire
08-25-2005, 01:13 AM
It's more mature then the old show. It's darker, espcially the newest season, and it takes the show in an almost opposite direction. It's nothing like the old show as you mentioned. The turtles are more devopled singlarly as opposed to a group. It has way more story and each episode adds to the series. Everything is mostly explained and if not right then it will be later. I'm a hardcore fan of the old series but I have grown to love this new updated more mature TMNT. And I like it much better then the old show now.

MrPliggins
08-25-2005, 01:18 AM
If you're hardcore into the old show and would be disappointed at change, you probably won't like this show. This show isn't as goofy as the old one, it has more action and fighting. Similarities are that many of the same characters are there and the Turtles basically have their same personalities. Gone are the pizza and cowabungas.
Shredder is a totally different character, but we won't get into that.
I think you should watch it this saturday and form an opinion for yourself. I say it's a good show but everyone has their own tastes.

lilonardo
08-25-2005, 02:03 AM
I say give it a chance.
You may be able to get some episodes cheaply soon on the new DVDouble shots range.

ZariusTwo
08-25-2005, 11:21 PM
Well because I hear that the new TMNT would not be like the old ones, I decided that they wouldn't be good at all and I would hate them. So I never watched an episode. I want everyones honest opinion if the show is good at all. Maybe I will even watch it this saturday.

The series is undeniably the only consistently excellent american cartoon on telivision besides Justice Leauge Unlimited. Period.

Whilst it does not follow the comics to the letter, it has advantages in storytelling and direction that very few series now rarly take, its' only flaw is arguably that the humour sucks, the theme song is abysmal, and Mickey could very well fall off a bridge and nobody would notice.

I would'nt recommend it over the original cartoon, which I still beleive is superior through little more than innovation and comedy, but it still blows a great deal of series out of the water

Ryona
08-26-2005, 01:24 AM
Well because I hear that the new TMNT would not be like the old ones, I decided that they wouldn't be good at all and I would hate them. So I never watched an episode. I want everyones honest opinion if the show is good at all. Maybe I will even watch it this saturday.


Your attitude towards the new series is pretty silly if you ask me. Just watch a couple of episodes and judge for yourself whether you like it or not. It's that simple.

Mandi-chan
08-27-2005, 05:44 AM
It rocks! I highly suggest you watch it.

Ironfist
08-27-2005, 06:47 AM
The new series rocks!
espically the ones with the fugitoiad & unlike the old series you'll see our hocky-fan cassey a lot more.

Tinuvielsdreams
08-27-2005, 09:49 AM
I personally can't say enough good things about the new series. We even watch it while we work in my animation classes.
I watched the original series from the time it came on to the time it went off the air, and I appreciate both of them for their differences.
The impression I get from people I talk to who haven't watched it is that they seem to think it is just some random remake of the OS. Considering how often that happens to cartoons I understand why they might think that, but it's really not.
I think this one does justice for the comic fans, and gives it that edge it deserves. I still buy and watch the first series and I love it. They are just two different portrayals.
If you are a fan at all you should give it a chance. I think you will find something about it you like. :)

Jester
08-27-2005, 11:51 AM
I respect both as 2 totally diffrent series. I love the OT because it's part of my childhood, it's the TMNT as I met them and it still makes me smile. The NT however appeals to the adult TMNT fan in me, with it's darler, more comic/movie-esque tone. Do I like it better....No....I like them both equally for diffrent reasons. I would highly recomend this show....it may be diffrent, but it treats the TMNT well and that's what matters.

XERO
08-27-2005, 03:36 PM
This show is one of the few cartoons today that can emotionally scar you. It's got action, comedy, drama, tragedy, adventure, nature, philosophy, education, good, evil, and the way of martial arts perfectly based on opinion.

The only thing wrong is that I'm not in it. :P

But seriously, you should give it a try. I mean, everything you can ever ask for out of TV cartoon, it's all here. But most importantly, it's all fair. Everybody gets what they wants, but also, we get suprises thrown in that might test our patience with the way it might go. But that's what it's all about.

I really believe you should watch it. The old cartoon will forever be a classic, but we were kids at the time it became a phenomenon. We're all older now, and the new TMNT cleanly represents that.

Remember this, Kenton; Things Change... ;)

OA
08-27-2005, 03:47 PM
I enjoy(ed) both shows immensly, for very different reasons... I say you should give it a shot...what have you got to lose?? :)

ZariusTwo
08-27-2005, 03:54 PM
I really believe you should watch it. The old cartoon will forever be a classic, but we were kids at the time it became a phenomenon. We're all older now, and the new TMNT cleanly represents that.

Remember this, Kenton; Things Change... ;)

...Or things don't, depends on preference, and TMNT now still does'nt come close to the original, nor will the original be topped for me. This is'nt bias talking, this is pure objectivity.

Gargoyles represented exactly what TMNT is doing right now when we were 13, or 12, right around when the original was still airing, so I fail to see the point of that, it looks more mature now because, arguably, its' one of few series presently with a brain cell, you throw it in B:TAS, or 90's Spidy,it'd be a fish in a pond, rather than a whale in a teardrop

Buslady
08-27-2005, 05:06 PM
My opinion on the new toon TMNT.....


I love them all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

And Raph is a god.

tee hee:P

shuriken
08-27-2005, 07:41 PM
Give the new toon a chance. I know I didn't want to at first after suffering through the next mutation but hey, this is indeed one of the few good cartoons out there. The next season should be kick ass. :D

Kenton
08-27-2005, 07:47 PM
I missed it today, went to the city. So I will have to watch it tomorrow ( I have seen it on another channel then Fox on Sundays ) I think I caught parts of it before and it just didn't seem right because they weren't eating pizza left and right, and they just looked different. I believe I saw part of an episode at a fighting tournament? And there was a statue of Splinter that Leo was looking at and then some things appeared, thats all I can remember :|

XERO
08-27-2005, 08:26 PM
That was an episode from late in the 2nd season. :D

To truly understand the stories, you should start with the first episode. This is a serial cartoon, where the story is always moving forward, and each episode expands the plot in someway. Some connect with others, some come to an end, and others remain unsolved until the next season.

As for the pizza, they do eat it. In fact, there's always scattered pizza boxes around the lair in most episodes.

Master Splinter is a lot more involved in this cartoon, as well. A LOT more.

You should watch it as soon as possible. I insist. And whatever you need to ask about the cartoon, I'll do my best to answer. :)

Kenton
08-27-2005, 08:32 PM
Cool. Are there any season DVD's out? Or maybe a better question is DVD's with the first episodes?

XERO
08-27-2005, 08:36 PM
They're not actually season DVDs per se.

Just 3-4 episodes each. I think the total is 21, but I'm not sure.

I tape them instead. :P

Kenton
08-27-2005, 08:43 PM
Thats a better idea then buying dvds lol. I think I saw some today, but I didnt bother buying them. Maybe I will search ebay a little bit later. Should if I like the show anyway, gotta wait till tomorrow to find out :D

Sage Ninja
08-27-2005, 11:29 PM
...Or things don't, depends on preference, and TMNT now still does'nt come close to the original, nor will the original be topped for me. This is'nt bias talking, this is pure objectivity.

Gargoyles represented exactly what TMNT is doing right now when we were 13, or 12, right around when the original was still airing, so I fail to see the point of that, it looks more mature now because, arguably, its' one of few series presently with a brain cell, you throw it in B:TAS, or 90's Spidy,it'd be a fish in a pond, rather than a whale in a teardrop

wow I completly agree with this. TMNT is probably one of the few decent American cartoon out right now.

I would recomend this toon to any one, and I'm curently force feeding a buddy of mine to the new series just so he can get over his narrow mindeness over the series.

nWoCHRISnWo
08-28-2005, 12:24 AM
I would say the new cartoon is a complete masterpiece, and as close to perfection as a cartoon can get in my opinion. I've been in complete awe ever since the very first episode first aired, with only few dissapointments.

Aska_Badoura
08-28-2005, 12:32 AM
If you like the movies, especially the first one, with its balance of humor and drama, I think you'll like this show.

Give the new toon a chance. I know I didn't want to at first after suffering through the next mutation :lol: Yeah...
Gargoyles represented exactly what TMNT is doing right now when we were 13, or 12, right around when the original was still airing, so I fail to see the point of that, it looks more mature now because, arguably, its' one of few series presently with a brain cell, you throw it in B:TAS, or 90's Spidy,it'd be a fish in a pond, rather than a whale in a teardrop*blinks* I was 11 or 12 when TMNT first became a phenomenon. Gargoyles came five years or so after. Er, that was irrelevant, but the thought just kinda startled me. :tconfuse:

The trend started in the mid 90's, when people started to take animation a tad more seriously. The going's been slow, but shows have been getting more serious over the years.

My taste for the old show has dwindled quite a bit over the years. Probably because it seemed like all my local station would air was "The Big Cufflink Caper" over and over again. I think I had it memorized. :p (Transfarmers, LOL... a David Wise in-joke, I suppose) I do still definitely appreciate a lot of the parody that went on in the old series.

Kenton
08-28-2005, 12:41 AM
This is off topic but quick question..I don't remeber this show but I have some on tapes. There was a show about Mario, from the video games. And I have some shows recorded from when I was a kid. Just wondered if anyone else has ever watched that or if it came out around the same time as the turtles.

XERO
08-28-2005, 12:48 AM
The Super Mario Brothers Super Show? I think it came out after the old cartoon.

Mandi-chan
08-28-2005, 05:10 AM
[QUOTE=nWoCHRISnWo]I would say the new cartoon is a complete masterpiece, and as close to perfection as a cartoon can get in my opinion. I've been in complete awe

I completely agree with you, this series is indeed a masterpiece. It has blown me away numerous times, and always pleases me. Too bad it has crappy dvds! No matter what anyone else says I'll always stand by this show, I'm obsessed with it and I'm proud of it! :D

MasterMole
08-28-2005, 07:08 AM
Yea, such a great show with strong storylines & great animation. But, by damn, why can't Cartoon Network see this and air it on Toonami or weeknights? Hopefully they will sometime in the next year. Maybe as the new movie draws near.

ZariusTwo
08-28-2005, 09:36 AM
The Super Mario Brothers Super Show? I think it came out after the old cartoon.


[I]Mock the Mario
Swing the arm, out and out
Sex? Why yes enter Super Mario
I s*it for Mortal Kombat
Here comes the Mario

http://sexmario.ytmnd.com/ :lol:

Kenton
08-28-2005, 11:20 AM
Yeah that Mario show :lol: Back to me getting on topic though today I get to see the episode where the turtles befriend some professor who is also known as..lemme go check the quide again...Ok they befriend Professor Honeycutt also known as the Fugitoid. Good episode?

ZariusTwo
08-28-2005, 11:25 AM
Yeah that Mario show :lol: Back to me getting on topic though today I get to see the episode where the turtles befriend some professor who is also known as..lemme go check the quide again...Ok they befriend Professor Honeycutt also known as the Fugitoid. Good episode?

Probably one of the better parts of the abysmal Turtles In Space arc, I suggest skipping that s*ite, and watch Secret Origins, its' the ideal story that explains the main characters and where they came from as far as this series goes, not to mention it pays homage to the classic, original series

Kenton
08-28-2005, 11:29 AM
Well everyone here seems to like this new toon a lot so I am going to watch it today, and next Saturday. Purchase some DVD's later on too ;)


I didn't want to double post, so heres my thoughts of the new TMMT:

It really is good. While watching I enjoyed it alot. I think it would have been even better if I knew what was happening, because I think I was stuck into the middle of the series. Good episode, I laughed so hard when they went into that planets sewer and Mikey saw the old turtle walking with the four rats, and one of the rats says "Cowabunga!" Oh man, that was funny. I need to watch some episodes from the beginning though. Hope I can find them!

XERO
08-28-2005, 04:11 PM
Yep, you should start with the first episode. I have the tapes, too, but I can't help you with that at the moment. Sorry. Perhaps you should get the DVD's. :P

But I'm glad to hear you like it. Keep watching. It gets better. 8)

Kenton
08-29-2005, 11:37 PM
Any idea if they will release season dvds? Or have they already?

Mandi-chan
08-30-2005, 03:06 AM
I'm glad you're enjoying it, if I remember correctly I started watching the series around that point too.

There was a half season box set for season 1, but that's the only one and I doubt there'll ever be more. The dvds are good up until a few disks into season two, that's when they began releasing eps out of order (it's gotten wosre since then too).

Space Lieutenant Josh
08-30-2005, 06:09 PM
Yeah, I prefer this new series to the old one immensely. An evolving plotline is always pretty worth it. Makes it a lot easier to watch a ton of them in a row.

The old one's fun, though.

Jo269976
09-03-2005, 01:53 PM
this series is way better IMO but some jokes are funnier in the old series

Gary
09-03-2005, 02:10 PM
I find it very hard to watch the old series as I grow older. The dialog gets to me.

I recently took the first season of the old series, and the first DVD of the new series to my friend's house, and had him watch the first episode of each. Long story short, he has now seen every episode that there is a DVD for, and doesn't care to see the 18 episodes of the old show.

R-iZZy
09-03-2005, 05:51 PM
When it comes to humor: the original series really topples the new series in that category.

But when it comes to action, adventure, and a good story: the new series pretty much has that down.

In all honesty, humor-dominated cartoons are so cliche nowadays, and with this turn of the new series, I've appreciated it a lot more. The new series delves more into each individual character and their personalities, many stories each connecting to each other in one way or another, and not to mention, A LOT more maturity in this show. Considering how violent the original Mirage comics were, I'm surprised at how great the new series is emulating it, even in watered-down form.

I'm a huge fan of the turtles, I LOVE these guys..... but this new series is better than the original series.

Dan
09-15-2005, 06:36 PM
[I]Mock the Mario
Swing the arm, out and out
Sex? Why yes enter Super Mario
I s*it for Mortal Kombat
Here comes the Mario

http://sexmario.ytmnd.com/ :lol: I had no idea Ron Jeremy was the german Mario.

Gary
09-15-2005, 06:44 PM
When it comes to humor: the original series really topples the new series in that category.It's painful for me to even listen to a conversation in the old series. How was any of it funny?

ZariusTwo
09-15-2005, 07:19 PM
You know, not really related to anyone here, who actually can appreciate both series, but I think a TV.Com reviewer said it best when people who thrash classics, or "downsize" them in comparison are only doing it because thats' the present trend, whilst the original series was'nt always consistent, in an objective view, its' first three seasons are great, it just sort of really dips after that until season seven, then eight

The new series' second season I was'nt a fan of after City At War, it just became needless fillers and anti-climaxes, "Rouge In The House" should have been bette, "Big Brawl" was bland out of its' earhole, so both series have their strengths and there flaws.

Ryona
09-15-2005, 07:46 PM
It's painful for me to even listen to a conversation in the old series. How was any of it funny?

Oh, come now... Have you even watched the original series?

The original series is pure gold when it comes to humor. There was a great deal of comedic brilliance in the series.

I love the new series for it's drama and action, but it can't hold a candle to the comedy value in the original series.

ZariusTwo
09-15-2005, 07:47 PM
It's painful for me to even listen to a conversation in the old series. How was any of it funny?

The humour for the original TMNT was ahead of its' time, implimenting many off beat culture references, and fourth wall breaking humour when the decision was made to lighten it, all the new series can deliver is TRUE cringe-inducing and half-assed references to The Matrix and Star Wars.

And clearly you follow the trend I was talking about

Masked Ninja
09-15-2005, 08:16 PM
The humor isn't a centerpiece in the new toon (probably considered in the "action/adventure" genre) as it was in the old (comedy/action). I like some of the one-liners in the current toon (and yes, I do appreciate all of the Star Trek/Star Wars references).

But the humor element was much more important in the old toon. Sure, it's hit-and-miss sometimes, but for the most part it's hilarious stuff. Almost everything that comes out of Raph's mouth is good material, as I recall.

OA
09-15-2005, 08:37 PM
The original series is pure gold when it comes to humor. There was a great deal of comedic brilliance in the series.

I love the new series for it's drama and action, but it can't hold a candle to the comedy value in the original series.

I couldn't have said it any better...

Mandi-chan
09-16-2005, 09:30 AM
The humour for the original TMNT was ahead of its' time, implimenting many off beat culture references, and fourth wall breaking humour when the decision was made to lighten it, all the new series can deliver is TRUE cringe-inducing and half-assed references to The Matrix and Star Wars.

And clearly you follow the trend I was talking about

I don't want to get into an agrument with you, but what "trend" are you talking about? Just because someone doesn't like the humor of the old show doesn't mean they're following a "trend". He didn't like it, and other people have commented that they don't like it, what's the big deal?

Also, what's wrong with the new toon's humor? Besides being funny and timed well?

Masked Ninja
09-16-2005, 11:55 AM
Maybe I'm less cynical, but I like the humor from both shows. The old turtles are adorable and the new ones look like they could kick some serious shell - both fit their purpose. The old toon has nostalgia value for me, but I have to say the new toon takes the spot just above it for me. The animation and character development are much better.

...though in spite of the terrible animation, the old toon theme owns the world. *is torn*

Gary
09-16-2005, 04:04 PM
Oh, come now... Have you even watched the original series?

The original series is pure gold when it comes to humor. There was a great deal of comedic brilliance in the series.Yes. I have the first two seasons on DVD, as well as the rest of the series on a few disks, though I only made it half way through the third season. Maybe I'm just not as easily amused as some people.

And clearly you follow the trend I was talking aboutI'm not comparing both series. I can't stand the terrible dialog. One episode seems like it is on for an hour. I've ahd this opinion before the new series came out. I tried to watch a few of my old TMNT tapes and could barely finish them.

ZariusTwo
09-16-2005, 04:56 PM
I don't want to get into an agrument with you, but what "trend" are you talking about?

Read my post prior to that.

Also, what's wrong with the new toon's humor? Besides being funny and timed well?

Its' crap, stupid Matrix references? That would help if anybody besides the hardcore fans gave a damn about those movies, attempts at saying Cowabunga and getting it cut off is lame, Mickey is cringe-worthy half of the time with every bad joke he utters, I'm not sure what you define by "timed well", I'd rather sooner suggest your watch has stopped. ;)

Captain_Apollo
09-16-2005, 06:04 PM
In any event, TMNT is as much about action as comedy. I'm just glad the new series follows the darker tone of the original comics, and isn't some goofy spin off like the 80s cartoon.

Then again, wasn't the 80s cartoon supposed to have more action until some parents complained about too much violence in the pilot?

ZariusTwo
09-16-2005, 07:06 PM
"Goofy" is'nt even a bad term for anything TMNT related. There Turtles. Ninja Turtles. How anyone can say that is'nt goofy in itself with a straight face is beyond me. What matters is the execution of that premise, but lets' face facts, its' still an unreallsitc, goofy concept, and thats' half the freaking fun of it.

Then again, wasn't the 80s cartoon supposed to have more action until some parents complained about too much violence in the pilot?


The first five episodes, despite characteristic changes, were almost exactly in tone with the original comics. Elderly women holding machine guns and Ninja Pizza Bakers with swords? Framing Yoshi for attempted murder? You had a quality there that animation fans point out to this day as rare and unseen at the time. The original series was the 80s' equivilant to HBO Spawn back then

I hate the original being lumped in as "consistently goofy", you look at the first three seasons and that is'nt or rarly the case, it was blended with action AND comedy given an objective look, blame seasons 4-6 for tarnishing the perspective of the series as it became more commercilist.

Jester
09-16-2005, 08:44 PM
I love the 2 animated series for 2 totally difrent reasons:

Old Toon: It's what made me a TMNT fan, it's the TMNT I remember and though some of the jokes are dated, most are spot on and still make me laugh. I can't wait for the other 8 seasons to be released on DVD, so I can watch them all again.

New Toon: It's darker, it's more action packed and character driven. It's a TMNT cartoon for the adult TMNT fan. It focuses more on the action.than comedy, which works, much like the OT's focus on comedy worked for it.

That's my feeling on it, 2 diffrent shows for 2 diffrent moods.

BigApple3AM
09-16-2005, 08:55 PM
In the old toons defense the TMNT was originally a parody. Many of you know that it's dark and gritty, but what the majority don't know is that it was almost and exact parody right down to the art style of certain popular books at the time.
http://img294.imageshack.us/img294/2245/01cover2rs.jpghttp://img294.imageshack.us/img294/8166/b31870017bv.jpg
(Notice the similarities like the bloody sword in the title, the text of the title, the one color tone cover, the art style, the black border, even the writing is mostly based off Frank Miller works. If you don't know who he is, he created Sin City.)

The old comic was a parody which was like one big in joke, with lots of action, and to anyone who didn't follow comics in the 70's/80's it would just seem all action and no comedy.

The old cartoon was some action, and all humor. This was the kind of comedy that was as basic as it gets, where pretty much anyone can realize that it's a fun show and not meant to be taken seriously.

The new cartoon is almost all action with some jokes thrown in to get a quick laugh, I've never actually laughed or chuckled while watching the new show, just oooh'd and ahhh'd at the aweosme action and cliff hangers.

Does one need to be better than the other? No. I do take a preference to one of these over the others, but really my opinion shouldn't matter so I'm not even going to tell you. What I will tell you is that different people will be drawn to different mediums, and that's what is great about TMNT. There's something for everyone (except perverts, sorry no Ron Jeremy's appearing in TMNT any time soon).

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
09-16-2005, 09:57 PM
All I can say is, watch the new series, it's pure gold. I can honestly say it tops the old series in every way except for the comedy. The new toon has better animation, writting, character representation, and a much darker tone that stays ture to it's comic roots.

And to ZariusTwo: What do you mean Matrix refrenceS. The was only that one Matrix refrence in the entire series. As with that one Star Wars refrence(which was actually very funny).

Jester
09-16-2005, 10:58 PM
I can think of at least 2 matrix refrences....

Donnie's A room full of guys who all look alike and a bo staff....

and Donnie calline Leo Neo....

Captain_Apollo
09-17-2005, 02:48 AM
"Goofy" is'nt even a bad term for anything TMNT related. There Turtles. Ninja Turtles. How anyone can say that is'nt goofy in itself with a straight face is beyond me. What matters is the execution of that premise, but lets' face facts, its' still an unreallsitc, goofy concept, and thats' half the freaking fun of it.

Okay, then how about cheesy? I understand the 80s cartoon is not supposed to be serious, but I didn't always find it funny. Sure, there are plenty of funny scenes and lines, but it slowly became way too cheesy for me.

Plus I don't like how they explain the mutation process. I believe they explained that anyone who touches the ooze turns into whatever he or she is hanging around the most. I also don't like the fact that Splinter was originally a human in this one. I like the pet rat story much better.

Buslady
09-17-2005, 08:57 AM
This is off topic but quick question..I don't remeber this show but I have some on tapes. There was a show about Mario, from the video games. And I have some shows recorded from when I was a kid. Just wondered if anyone else has ever watched that or if it came out around the same time as the turtles.


Mario bros was earlier than TMNT...I think .....my kid loves the mario stuff... X.x...

My first real dose of TMNT was the old toon. I loved it back then in high school. But now, it's almost embarrasing to watch. My kid drove me nuts watching the dvds, I buy those cause he likes them and well, it's TMNT...and they're cheap. But I can't ignored the old toon, thats where it started for me. Then I bought comics...then the movie came out....

How funny that a parody turned out to be something that a huge fanbase can take totally seriously!

The current show is so damn good. I like that all of the eps are connected, it's not a 30 min commercial and none of those annoying "community announcements" at the end. Ugh i hated those.
All of the stories go together. Characterrs are portrayed as they should be. Stories are derived from the books (hell we even get a monster turtle...at least it's not Raph) it just makes the toon a supplemental to the comics. I look forwards to Saturdays again too. Wheee!
ok well, whatever.

and there's no such thing as a "filler" episode. standalones are necissary

ZariusTwo
09-17-2005, 10:18 AM
Okay, then how about cheesy?

It gets definalty more commericilist around Season four, but I would'nt use the most cliched criticism of any animation fan and call it "cheesy", given the new cartoon can have that in spades

If I was talking in that langauge, I'd say "Big Brawl" was one of the "cheesiet" finales of any series I've every watched. Mostly because "tournaments" were the backbone of every series airing at the time on 4Kids or otherwise. Beyblade, Yu-Gi-Oh, you name it. And none of them were ever any good. Tournament finales just drag with no real story other than "lets' fight", in light of Seasons one and three, Season Two is by far the worst TMNT season of this present incarnation after "City At War" so yeah, having it hailed as Jesus does irritate me sometimes.

To be fair though, the majority of fans pretty much hate Turtles In Space and the Dimensional arc except for "Same As It Never Was", so they know what suits their expectations, and what does'nt.

Whats' sad is that some fans still think both series can be compared. They can't, its' impossible, there both two VERY different series, therfore putting them both aside causes less arguments, and when attacking someone for not liking the new series and preffering the original, they go back to the trend I was talking about and just run down the original without being objective, although some are capable of that, some are'nt. And that just is'nt what I would call fair, or needed.

Masked Ninja
09-17-2005, 10:31 AM
Tournament finales just drag with no real story other than "lets' fight", in light of Seasons one and three, Season Two is by far the worst TMNT season of this present incarnation after "City At War" so yeah, having it hailed as Jesus does irritate me sometimes.And yet there was the plot against the Daimyo int he background, along with the framing of Splinter. I know, that's not the most original subplot either... but at least it wasn't solid fighting for four episodes. Gave us more chances to see Usagi and Traximus too. The thing that bugged me so much about the tournament was not that Mikey won, but how anticlimactic it was.

But I do agree that season 2 is my least favorite. It has more dumb one-shot episodes than the others, and fewer awesome episodes. As for the "Reality Check" arc, I love SAINW (duh) and I'm on OK terms with the two-episode conclusion. But Mikey and Raph's episodes just didn't do it for me.

Season 1 - awesome. Season 2 - a few good episodes, but eh. Season 3 - pretty good. Season 4 - It looks like there's gonna be too many weird critters popping out of nowhere,but I love the tone so far.

ZariusTwo
09-17-2005, 10:42 AM
But I do agree that season 2 is my least favorite. It has more dumb one-shot episodes than the others, and fewer awesome episodes. As for the "Reality Check" arc, I love SAINW (duh) and I'm on OK terms with the two-episode conclusion. But Mikey and Raph's episodes just didn't do it for me.

Season 1 - awesome. Season 2 - a few good episodes, but eh. Season 3 - pretty good. Season 4 - It looks like there's gonna be too many weird critters popping out of nowhere,but I love the tone so far.


We'll see, the tone of the stand-alones (I said filler earlier by accident) is pretty much more comedic right now from what I've read, that is'nt a bad thing, so we'll see what happens when we get around to SOTSA.

Captain_Apollo
09-17-2005, 11:35 AM
I understand that the whole tournament setting can be extremely cliche, I think it works in TMNT because
1) The show centers around martial arts. And how can you have a series with martial arts and not have a tournament at some point.
2) The show only has a tournament once, to my knowledge. It doesn't abuse it like so many other shows.
3) It didn't take 80 jillion episodes to complete the tournament like some other shows, which will remain unnamed. *cough*Dragon Ball and Dragon Ball Z*cough*

I understand you can't compare the 80s to the 03 cartoon. That is like comparing apples to oranges. However, people are entitled to their opinions, and people are entitled to like one and not like the other as well.

Now I don't think the 80s is a horrible show; there are a lot of things I like about it. It's just that I have X amount of money and X amount of time, so I would rather have the 03 series.

ZariusTwo
09-17-2005, 11:43 AM
I never said "Big Brawl" was a frequent torunament finale, but at the time, various series had thier finales dedicated to it, so it felt "samey"

Now I don't think the 80s is a horrible show; there are a lot of things I like about it. It's just that I have X amount of money and X amount of time, so I would rather have the 03 series.

...Currency is alphabetical?

That'll be three B euros :)

R-iZZy
09-17-2005, 09:24 PM
It's painful for me to even listen to a conversation in the old series. How was any of it funny?
Are you serious? The humor in the new series, most of the time, seems so forced. The original show had witty puns and snappy comebacks, throughout. There are a handful of Raph quotes that could keep me on my backside.

syk_skillz
09-17-2005, 10:18 PM
Are you serious? The humor in the new series, most of the time, seems so forced. The original show had witty puns and snappy comebacks, throughout. There are a handful of Raph quotes that could keep me on my backside.
It just depends on the type of humor you like. The humor in the new series is a bit more mature then the old series. The humor from the old series was more looney-tooney if you know what I'm saying compared to the new series. I personaly like both series but often find myself laughing more at the new series compared to the old cartoon when I was a kid.

Mandi-chan
09-18-2005, 07:00 AM
It just depends on the type of humor you like. The humor in the new series is a bit more mature then the old series. The humor from the old series was more looney-tooney if you know what I'm saying compared to the new series. I personaly like both series but often find myself laughing more at the new series compared to the old cartoon when I was a kid.


I agree with this guy.

When I fisrt got my hands on the old toon I was embarrassed to be watching it and hated it. I've learned to like the series, but won't deny the fact that I still feel embarrassed while watching it (with the exception of the red sky stuff). To me the humor of the old toon (as well as the old toon itself) is more suitable for the little kids. More appropriate for them. I think the old toon's cute, but it isn't really my cup of tea. I don't love it, and I never will.

Darker toned stuff is more my kind of thing, serious mature shows. So naturally, I find the new toon very appealing. I like its humor, and don't feel that any of it is forced.

So yes, the way you enjoy the humor (and the series themselves) depends on what you like, or your personality. I do like both, but not equally.

I agree with Zarius too, you can't compare the two shows and you shouldn't. It's not fair to either of them because they're so opposite, they're not the same thing.

BigApple3AM
09-18-2005, 10:24 PM
Embarrased of the old toon? That's like being embarrased of watching anything from the 80's, which just proves to me that you're probably 15 or younger meaning you never lived through the 80's and just wouldn't understand. Not knocking you that I was plopped out before you, but don't knock something you weren't around for.

If anything I would be embarrased of this new toon, at least the old one is considered a classic and is acceptable to watch because everyone writes it off as nostalgia now. The new one means you still like cartoons and might as well be watching pokemon, yu-gi-oh, sigma sux, and whatever else this company is producing for Saturday mornings.

I'm totally kidding. I understand where you're coming from but I just can't relate.

Mandi-chan
09-19-2005, 02:52 AM
LOL, no problem.

I don't hate the old toon, I do like it. But, again, it doesn't really appeal to me that much. I do like funny stuff, but it's different with the ninja turtles. It's weird for me to watch it when the other representations of the green team are generally serious.

BTW, I'm 19 years old :D .

StealthNinjaScyther
09-19-2005, 01:45 PM
I just found some of my tapes of the old toon. First I watched some eps from the 4th season I think. Not too impressed, in fact I only vaguely remembered the episodes, and I see why. Perfectly suitable for kids, but there was relatively little humor that still appealed to me. There were a few funny things, such as McDonald Crump and comedians modeled after some popular ones from the eighties. Otherwise there were mostly bad puns, especially in the episode where Raph goes and becomes a stand up comic. Then I watched some of the eps from seasons 1 and 2. Now those ones I had an even better recollection of, and I think I know why, the writing and story held up rather well, though the season 1 eps still seemed quite a bit better than the season 2 stuff. Actually to be honest, I can't even remember any of the episodes that I watched when I was younger other than the ones I have on tape. I guess part of that is because I was so young at the time, in exactly a month I'll be twenty, but I don't know, is that supposed to make me feel older or younger? Anyway, I'll definitely check out picking up season 1 of the old toon, possibly 2 as well.

I haven't seen that much of the newer series either, I started watching when it started, but it didn't really catch me so I gradually stopped watching, though mostly because I couldn't be arsed to get out of bed on weekends. I only just started watching again after I saw that it was on one morning and started to watch. I must have picked the right day to start since that particular episode turned out to be the same as it never was. Since then I've been keeping up and I like what I've been seeing.

But still, I'd have to agree that you can't really compare the two series, I mean putting the old season four eps I've seen against the new series season 4, it's mind boggling how different they really are. Actually, thinking about it, it might be really fun to take episodes from each series and splice them together to help illustrate this difference. Now that could be interesting. :D

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
09-19-2005, 05:48 PM
I agree with this guy.

When I fisrt got my hands on the old toon I was embarrassed to be watching it and hated it. I've learned to like the series, but won't deny the fact that I still feel embarrassed while watching it (with the exception of the red sky stuff). To me the humor of the old toon (as well as the old toon itself) is more suitable for the little kids. More appropriate for them. I think the old toon's cute, but it isn't really my cup of tea. I don't love it, and I never will.

Darker toned stuff is more my kind of thing, serious mature shows. So naturally, I find the new toon very appealing. I like its humor, and don't feel that any of it is forced.

So yes, the way you enjoy the humor (and the series themselves) depends on what you like, or your personality. I do like both, but not equally.

I agree with Zarius too, you can't compare the two shows and you shouldn't. It's not fair to either of them because they're so opposite, they're not the same thing.

I have the dvds of the first two seasons of the old TMNT. I can still stand to watch it(even though some of the dialouge and the many voice and color flubs make me cringe). But I love this new series much more. So I'm with you in saying the darker tone is much more appealing.

And your also right in saying that the two series(though both being TMNT), are much more diffrent than similar.

R-iZZy
09-21-2005, 05:18 PM
It just depends on the type of humor you like. The humor in the new series is a bit more mature then the old series. The humor from the old series was more looney-tooney if you know what I'm saying compared to the new series. I personaly like both series but often find myself laughing more at the new series compared to the old cartoon when I was a kid.
Of course the humor in the old show was "looney-tooney", the show itself was more "looney-tooney" than action-packed. That was pretty much more of its purpose, humor. The new show has great humor, too. But a lot of the times, I'm hearing jokes from Mikey that fall flat. In the old tune, they used situational humor that I felt, was a lot of the time, timed right.

I can't really find humor superior in a serious show, because in serious/darker shows, you aren't set in a mood to expect jokes... you expect more of grim stories and serious action... while in shows like the original series, it keeps things light so that you can be more vulnerable to jokes. It worked, in my opinion, more than 75% of the time.

Not knocking your opinion, because I hear you. It truly is all about what humor you like, but I felt the cartoony attitude was always a good route to go for bringing in more humor. The humor, that I laugh at, in the new show mostly show what you'd hear in the old show. For example: Leo catching the note that was attached to an arrow in The Shredder Strikes (Part 1) and then saying, "A note... or as Mikey would call it, [Mikey impersonation]AIR MAIL![/Mikey impersonation]"

^ A pun that had something to do with the situation... that was what I felt the original series was known for. And that's what I thought made the original series better, just timing the right jokes in the right moments. I see that in the new show a lot, as well, just not as frequently. A lot of the time, we hear weird random jokes from Mikey that come outta nowhere. "With both legs busted, I'm STILL all that and a bag of chips........... mmmm, chips!"

That's what I mostly hear in the new series, and I guess that kind of humor doesn't appeal to me. Not to say that's the type of humor that dominates the show, but it's jokes like that that really stand out, to me, more than the few great ones they have.

Gary
09-26-2005, 03:02 PM
Are you serious? The humor in the new series, most of the time, seems so forced. The original show had witty puns and snappy comebacks, throughout. There are a handful of Raph quotes that could keep me on my backside.Yes, I am very serious. I find very little humor in the old show. I don't even find much humor in the new show. I don't wathc the Ninja Turtles to laugh. I like the story and i'm curious to see where it goes, and what happens. When I watch the old show, many times I don't even care what happens, I just want it to end.

When I fisrt got my hands on the old toon I was embarrassed to be watching it and hated it. I've learned to like the series, but won't deny the fact that I still feel embarrassed while watching it (with the exception of the red sky stuff). To me the humor of the old toon (as well as the old toon itself) is more suitable for the little kids. More appropriate for them. I think the old toon's cute, but it isn't really my cup of tea. I don't love it, and I never will.

Darker toned stuff is more my kind of thing, serious mature shows. So naturally, I find the new toon very appealing. I like its humor, and don't feel that any of it is forced.

So yes, the way you enjoy the humor (and the series themselves) depends on what you like, or your personality. I do like both, but not equally.
I almost completely agree with you.

ZariusTwo
09-26-2005, 05:07 PM
...Times like this, I'm glad people don't like the new cartoon as much as the original...

I just feel the irony of having a community called "The Technodrome" has to have such an intense division of the fanbase, not just with the original fans and new cartoon fans, theres' heated topic everywhere now, its' not as wholesome a place as it used to be, just a bunch of people either following a trend or using a bad choice of words to put thier show or writer above the other, and people like me who have to put up with it