PDA

View Full Version : Comicbooks recommendation


Mutant_Power
11-17-2005, 09:58 AM
I want to start collecting TMNT comics and I would like you to give some recommendations. ¿Which of the currently published books is better? What about back issues. I want to receive recommendations based on both art and story

DrSpengler
11-17-2005, 10:38 AM
Tales of the TMNT is the best book out right now and the easiest to just ick up and read at any point (all stories are self-contained episodes). Volume 4 is pretty mired in continuity, and hit a low-point for quite a while, but it's picking up at a steady pace. If you can find the back issues or at least read the issue summaries at the TMNT's official site, then you shouldn't have too much trouble just picking it up and following along.

The art in volume 4 by Jim Lawson is (in my personal opinion) borderline atrocious. If you ever pick up his volume 1 TMNT stuff, like City At War, it's fantastic. But these days...not so much.

So that's one more thing Tales has going for it. Lawson does sevral issues for the book, but not ALL of them. Several artists, both newcomers and experts, work on the book as a way of exposure into the medium. So the titles stays fresh every issue.


As far as back issues go, you really can't go wrong with most of volume 1. I highly recommend the first 10-15 issues (including all the mico-series) as that's the classic TMNT, with storylines that have been adapted into both the first movie and the new cartoon. Some of the stand-alone stories here and there can be a little goofy, and some of he guest artists can be a little awful, but for the most part the enire volume is a great read.

And, of course, if you like the current volume of Tales then I recommend you pick up the short-lived first volume of Tales.

I've never had the pleasure of reading Volume 2 (the color volume), Volume 3 (the Image series, not in continuity) or any of the Archie stories. So I can't really remark on their quality.

lambofun
11-17-2005, 10:54 AM
Tales of the TMNT is a sweet comic book series to read.

zkarlette
11-17-2005, 07:24 PM
Its fun to watch what other artists can come up with

twopinacoladas
11-30-2005, 02:03 AM
Tales, you should be able to find most issues two were sold out... but you dont need any back story and most are stand alone issues with exception to a couple of them. They have been very good for the most part and the art has been a nice change from Lawsons in vol 4 it seems very fresh and a pleasure to read imo.

If you are looking at any of the older books in the future I would recommend 1-11 as its the stuff that both Easman and Laird did its my fav stuff from TMNT comics. 19-21 (all vol 1 btw the offical site has a good listing of the books) was also very good, the City at War arc was good imo but was fairly long I know most of this stuff is hard to find though. Ebay is good for the old stuff especially graphic novels, www.milehighcomics.com is where I found a few books that were harder to get...

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
11-30-2005, 11:45 AM
If you like a good long story, read TMNT. But if you do, try to trackdown earlier issues. That way, you can stay in the loop.

Also the new Tales is great. My recomended issues are The Worms of Maddness two parter and The Quick and the Dead.

Ryona
11-30-2005, 04:25 PM
Here's my tip on what not to pick up...

The Image TMNT series.

This series was complete crap. The only thing it had going was that the art was pretty nice.

BigApple3AM
11-30-2005, 06:09 PM
Image wasn't crap, not even by a longshot. I used to love it when it was coming out monthly, I missed issues 2 and 3 for some reason, and since I was like in Jr. High the only way I could get them was to sell lemonade. I sold absolutely no lemonade that day... though I remember someone stopping in a limo, I got excited, and then they asked me for directions (and did not buy lemonade).

I eventually got the issues, but man was that sucky. Anyway... back on topic (sorry for the rant) at the time it was the only way to get a healthy dose of turtles as everything else was cancelled and Peter and Kevin wanted nothing to do with the Turtles. The book was interesting as a long "what if?" sort of book, the main thing that hurt it was terrible shipping scheudles. It never was on time, especially not towards the end of the run. It handled the turtles in a very serious manner (too serious?) and put them where they should be, fighting street punks and crime lords, rather than utroms and underground monsters. If you don't take the book too seriously and realize that it isn't part of mainstream tmnt continuity then you should be able to enjoy it even if the dialogue was a little too early nineties (even though it was made in the late nineties, it was Image which was seriously stuck in the beginning of the decade).

If I had to recommend a book it wouldn't be tales or the current book. They're based too much on acquired taste (though I enjoy both). I'd recommend going and filling in back issues of the original mirage series (the earlier the issues the better, except for city at war which is the end of the run but it also pretty good).

However, I need more input. What exactly are you looking for? Cartoony, humor, action, violence, drama, mystery, etc...
If you want a continuation of the original turtles show with a bit more maturity added in then I recommend archie. That series is almost as if Marvel had done the book.

Overall I recommend issues 1-12 of the original mirage series. It's possible you can find a trade paperback on eBay containing those issues. You really can't go wrong with these as they're what created, defined, and made the Turtles a billion dollar property.

BartAllen
12-11-2005, 01:07 PM
Here's my tip on what not to pick up...

The Image TMNT series.

This series was complete crap. The only thing it had going was that the art was pretty nice.
hmm. can we have examples of its crappiness?

I for one loved the volume 3 series. it gave the turtles a real grittiness that it needed, but im also glad that it isnt in continuity either, the stuff that the turtles went through was really tough. but i will say this. if you want realistic fights and not have the good guys always winning, then buy vol 3, if your more of an original show fan. or archie fan. DO NOT pick this volume 3 up.

BigApple3AM
12-11-2005, 06:13 PM
Don't the coil force figures remind you of the image series?

http://img368.imageshack.us/img368/1672/coilraph3eq.jpg