Human Baxter vs Fly Baxter

[Weird Pizza]

Who do you like best?

I love the alien crystals episodes, they are probably my favorite out of anything the turtles released. They rank up there with the first Season in terms of good story and solid writing.

So of course as you know human Baxter is in there. However I love the fly episodes as well! He is a great character there! It kinda brings him to a level to be recconed (SP?) with!

I think the fly thing was more then perfect for him! So even though I like his human form I am going with the fly
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y152/CorysNothing/Baxter.jpg

[Utrom]

Human Baxter was a much better character as he was an actual threat to the turtes. After he was mutated, his fly "persona" began to dominate his mind, reducing him to a complete idiot. When Baxter was an actual human, his intellect was a force to be reckoned with, and, as we saw in the Eye of Sarnath episodes, he was not afraid to take advantage of Shredder when he got the chance. Leaving him as a human would have definately provided a great deal more potential for the character.

However, "Enter: the Fly" is one of the greatest episodes of the original toon, not only for the incredible story, but also for the scene where Krang tried to incinerate Baxter. That was an extremely graphic scene, and although it was made obvious with the continuous showing of the fly, the fly transformation sequence was pretty amazing. The only other appearance of the fly that I enjoyed was the episode "Return of the Fly", mainly for the excellent writing. The whole development with the alien computer was dragged on way too long and was simply stupid to begin with, and I absolutely loath "Landlord of the Flies" for the error in continuity.

Bottom Line: Human Baxter takes all.

[Lady Venus]

For me it was really hard to chose between both.

[Sage Ninja]

both. Human Baxter Stockman had a formindiable intelliect and was one to be rekoned with and is inventions where awasome, but he was to much of a ass kisser to be taken seriously sometimes, to be honest, his groveling was annoying and kind of diminshed his character.

Fly Baxter was creepy, he had that whole tragic OMG, i'm a freak of nature in pain and alone, thing going for him. And even though his idiotic regressed intelligence of a fly persona was annoying and dimed his character a bit, he was quite a bit more aggressive and vindictive toward Shredder and the Turtles than what he was before. Fly Baxter was the "revenge" character, which was good.

[AquaParade]

At first, I almost picked the fly form of Baxter, just because back when I was a kid, he just seemed a lot more fun compared to human baxter. Now that I think back though, Human Baxter really could have branched out from Shredder and become a seperate enemy of the turtles later on in the seasons which would have helped mix up the show a little bit so we didnt have to see Shredder trying to take over the world every episode. Think of how cool it would have been if Human Baxter had his own base with all of his technology in it, that the turtles would have to infiltrate every once in a while:)

[The Green Ranger]

I like Human Baxter better. intellegance can beat physicality even if most dont believe it.

[Zack Dogg]

I enjoyed him much better in his human Baxter form. I couldn't believe that he could tolerate being constantly harassed and insulted by some insane Japanese man. It was satisfying to see him to betray Shredder in "Curse of the Evil Eye" and I thought that he should've stayed against him.

"Enter: The Fly" disappointed me as he only went back to Shredder's side after he sold him out for Rocksteady and Bebop, only to be deceived by him so easily. He must've suffered a case of amnesia after transmutating into a fly.

[Ryzar]

Human Baxter better in cartoon because he made more inventions and was more of a threat to the Turtles.

But Fly Baxter better as an action figure... to get wasted by the Turtles action figures! :D

[CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy]

Baxter the Fly i chose. Bitter "revenge" villains are cool to me.

[Sage Ninja]

The reason why I like fly Baxter a bit better than human Baxter is because he was so bitter and vengeful, and had a gripe against Shredder which I thought was cool. Human Baxter although very intelligent and was insane was to much of a wuss for me to take to seriously.

Question, what was baxters last appearence in the series, did he die?

[MutantMistress2013]

I can go with the fly.

[Pterobat]

By a very slight margin, I go with human Baxter, and I've been trying to figure out why for a while.

I think it's because becoming a fly is just one part of the character's larger story, which is one of almost pure failure. Becoming a fly is just the climax of a total trainwreck of a life, and because Baxter is shown as a human and a fly for almost an equal amount of time, I see him as a human who happened to become a fly, rather than just "that fly".

Plus, he's a never been a mutant anywhere else, so human Baxter fits more with the character as a whole, even if he's also not white anywhere else.

I will say, though, that to argue that human Baxter is a more effective villain is not true. Yeah, "Curse of the Evil Eye" was damn great, but other than that, human Baxter was just making inventions and complying with the Shredder, being weak and goofy and silly. Just how I likes it--but let's not pretend it was something else. He fell into dumpsters and got pizza thrown at him....

Human Baxter can actually be quite stupid regardless of his engineering skills, which includes his oversights in "Curse of the Evil Eye" that lead to his downfall.

Baxterfly is actually more effective as a villain, especially in his early episodes. He's much more active and, at first, independent. When he gets dumber and has that funny co-dependent relationship with that computer (which is an awesomely weird story, by the way), he's still physically strong and still manages to be a decent foe for the Turtles.

Though for me, the point is not whether Baxter is a good villain, but if he's an entertaining character. Baxter in the cartoons seems to always end up representing failure, and that's very fun to me--I don't want him to be something stronger.

Oh, and he didn't die in "Revenge of the Fly"--the writers just stopped using him. Which kinda sucks, but nothing about his status quo would have changed if he'd been used more often, especially not becoming human.

At least we dodged a possible "dark" Baxterfly for Red Sky, which would have likely sucked. :P

[The Sewer Lord]

Human Baxter was a better character and a greater threat. Although I do like some of the Fly Baxter episodes.

[Shark_Blade]

Fly Baxter is the coolest.

[DonatelloNinja82]

This was a hard choice, but in the end I went with human Baxter.

[Berserker]

Human Baxter unless Fly Baxter is made into a tragic character that you feel sorry for rather than just mutant of the week. 2k3 show did an excellent job of making Stockman more tragic, despite the fact that he not turn into a fly.

[Original TMNT Cartoon Fan]

Human Baxter was a much better character as he was an actual threat to the turtes. After he was mutated, his fly "persona" began to dominate his mind, reducing him to a complete idiot. When Baxter was an actual human, his intellect was a force to be reckoned with, and, as we saw in the Eye of Sarnath episodes, he was not afraid to take advantage of Shredder when he got the chance. Leaving him as a human would have definately provided a great deal more potential for the character.

However, "Enter: the Fly" is one of the greatest episodes of the original toon, not only for the incredible story, but also for the scene where Krang tried to incinerate Baxter. That was an extremely graphic scene, and although it was made obvious with the continuous showing of the fly, the fly transformation sequence was pretty amazing. The only other appearance of the fly that I enjoyed was the episode "Return of the Fly", mainly for the excellent writing. The whole development with the alien computer was dragged on way too long and was simply stupid to begin with, and I absolutely loath "Landlord of the Flies" for the error in continuity.

Bottom Line: Human Baxter takes all.

"Enter the Fly" is also one of the most important episodes. Here, Shredder re-unites with Bebop and Rocksteady, bringing back the concept that will last until the end of season 7.

[Galactus]

I kind of feel similar about this issue as I do about the Neutrinos.

"Enter the Fly" and episodes with Baxter coming back for revenge for being turned into a fly were generaly really good but as a character I think he was better off as a human.

That being said I did enjoy fly Baxter and he had a great design.

[tone-master21]

Went with Baxter as a fly.

[Mzx10484]

Baxter as a fly is an amusing character with intelligent foundation in the OT !!

[Raphael Let It Go]

Fly Baxter from the original series.

[Jester]

http://cache.ohinternet.com/images/7/78/I-like-turtles.jpg
I like Baxters....

[Original TMNT Cartoon Fan]

Human, all the way.

[Krang100]

The episode "Enter the Fly" is one of the most dark episode of the show, Baxter was actually executed, if it weren't for the fly, Baxter would get killed, even the audience can see the execution in process, as well, the audience can hear his laments.

Another thing I complaint about Baxter in 2nd season, he very often tells Shredder "master", Baxter was actually a scientist, not an "Igor/Renfield", writers tried to make him subservient, but wasn't necessary to humiliate the character make him Shredder lapdog, the positive side is his high intellect but he was too weak to confront Shredder (Excepting in the Curse of the eye of Zarnoth), it would be better if Baxter didn't tell "master" a least.

Baxter fly would be better if he kept his intellect, but when the show progresses, he turned dumb and clueless, but a least he was too strong to confront Shredder and his cronies.

[Pterobat]

The episode "Enter the Fly" is one of the most dark episode of the show, Baxter was actually executed, if it weren't for the fly, Baxter would get killed, even the audience can see the execution in process, as well, the audience can hear his laments.

Another thing I complaint about Baxter in 2nd season, he very often tells Shredder "master", Baxter was actually a scientist, not an "Igor/Renfield", writers tried to make him subservient, but wasn't necessary to humiliate the character make him Shredder lapdog, the positive side is his high intellect but he was too weak to confront Shredder (Excepting in the Curse of the eye of Zarnoth), it would be better if Baxter didn't tell "master" a least.

Baxter fly would be better if he kept his intellect, but when the show progresses, he turned dumb and clueless, but a least he was too strong to confront Shredder and his cronies.

I dunno, Baxter's simpering always made perfect sense to me. Even the first time we see him, when he falls in with Shredder, he ends up standing there like a deer caught in the headlights, and looks too scared to do anything. Turning into a whining henchman is just a few steps down from that, and is probably the easiest of his changes to figure out.

My thought is always that Baxter thinks he's a super-genius but makes a lottttt of bad choices, and never really earns the assumption that he should have more dignity than he does. ("I'm a scientist!")

"Curse of the Evil Eye" is just his One Good Day. Because everybody gets one.

I think this is why I like Baxter better as a human: because he's much easier to laugh at as a broken wreck of a human being, those kinds of characters are always funny to me. Baxterfly is just the endpoint of an already terrible life. :)

[oldmanwinters]

Whatever one makes the best action figure.

[billbot85]

I like Baxter both as the fly and as a human. I feel he was an interesting character on the show in both ways, since he always had interesting inventions. I may have liked him a little more as the fly though, since I remember more of those episodes and the video games as a kid.