PDA

View Full Version : 2nd best film overall, TMNT 2007 or Turtles 2(1991)?


jignat
03-25-2007, 01:35 PM
IF you ask most people, the concensus is the first film is the best.
However on some boards, some people felt turtles 2 (91) was superior to the new 07 flick.
So i wanted to see how hardcore fans thought. Imo this is better, but i can see how kid nostalgias may influence peoples thoughts.

discuss.

Spitfire
03-25-2007, 01:40 PM
I need to see this new movie again. I watched #1 before seeing the new film and I like 1. I think the epic battle at the end kinda dwarfed what the new movie had to offer for an ending.

As for 2. I always liked 2 more then #1. It had more of everything. It wasn't darker but it had more action and it was funnier*Atleast when I was little* Plus Shredder just looked bad ass.

I like #2 more then the new movie but as far as if I like the new movie more then #1 I'm unclear.

PrivateRadio
03-25-2007, 01:41 PM
Turtles 2 was a joke. TMNT murders it.

Raph'N'Roll
03-25-2007, 01:45 PM
I never liked Turtles 2, most of the humor and dialogue was completely cringe worthy, and the fights were pretty lame, out of all four movies I think TMNT has the best portrayal of the Turtles personalities.
The Turtles in movie 2 all seemed a bit goofy, particularly Donatello, he was behaving like Mikey in some scenes, going completely out of character sometimes, and the survival of Shredder from the garbage truck was ridiculous.

Revan
03-25-2007, 01:50 PM
As for 2. I always liked 2 more then #1. It had more of everything. It wasn't darker but it had more action and it was funnier*Atleast when I was little* Plus Shredder just looked bad ass.

Ditto. Couldn't have said it better. When I was younger, I just wanted to laugh and watch mutated turtles who knew karate. haha. Movie two was very appealing to youngsters which is why I loved it. Now, looking back, I see thats basically all it was.

NT 07 is perfect for the fans who have grown up and are not thirsting for a darker movie. I wonder what young ones thought of the movie. I hope they found it funny and interesting. Hopefully a new generation of NT fans was born on friday!

Fledermaus
03-25-2007, 01:50 PM
I thought that the turtles were portrayed better in TMNT -- more lethal, less goofy. Melike.:D

Technically, though, I don't think TMNT was better than the first turtles movie. I stand by my opinion that they are equal on a quality level. I simply prefer the 2007 movie because I find that CG animation is the right balance for TMNT -- this movie achieves a look of both comics and realism, where it shines that is. I'm also considering what this movie had against it, so I went in expecting to see what you'd expect from a low budget, first-time director and animation company from China that I've never heard of.

Raph'N'Roll
03-25-2007, 01:58 PM
Neutrino: Ditto. Couldn't have said it better. When I was younger, I just wanted to laugh and watch mutated turtles who knew karate. haha. Movie two was very appealing to youngsters which is why I loved it. Now, looking back, I see thats basically all it was.

Really?
Man I remember feeling very disappointed when I went to see it, I think I was 11 at the time.
I loved the first movie and number 2 just felt like a step back, I've always liked The Turtles a little edgier.

TerranigmaFreak
03-25-2007, 02:01 PM
and the survival of Shredder from the garbage truck was ridiculous.

I don't understand what's so hard to believe about that. People survive from disasters much worst than that, I don't see how a garbage truck (a truck full of bags of trash) can't break his fall.

Spitfire
03-25-2007, 02:09 PM
Really?
Man I remember feeling very disappointed when I went to see it, I think I was 11 at the time.
I loved the first movie and number 2 just felt like a step back, I've always liked The Turtles a little edgier.

I like the turtles to be dark as well. But some movies hold over good childhood memories. And TMNT 2 is that right there.

I was 3 maybe 4 when TMNT 2 came out. I wasn't old enough to see 1 in theaters so I only saw it on VHS. I loved 2 it was great. I liked 1 too but I watched 2 alot more. Because it was more fun like the cartoon series. And that's what I wanted.

Then I got older and more into movies. TMNT 1 I noticed as being dark but in terms of a movie it was horrible. I love it for it being TMNT but as a movie it's not really a good movie*None of the TMNT films are*. And Feildman's Don was horrid. He sounds like a chain smoker.

TMNT 2 stuck as being my favorite because of how fun it was. It didn't take itself seriously and that's why it worked. TMNT 1 tried to be dark and edgy but it couldn't break out. It was trying to be what it couldn't. TMNT 2 was just slap stick and knew it was silly and ran with it. I liked that better.

Don't get me started on #3 I hated that even as a kid.

PrivateRadio
03-25-2007, 02:19 PM
I don't understand what's so hard to believe about that. People survive from disasters much worst than that, I don't see how a garbage truck (a truck full of bags of trash) can't break his fall.

Of course that could break his fall, no one doubts that.

but then Casey turned on the compactor. I'm not a doctor or anything, but I don't think a cool helmet could protect you from a garbage compactor.

Raph'N'Roll
03-25-2007, 02:23 PM
Spitfire666xXxXx:TMNT 2 stuck as being my favorite because of how fun it was. It didn't take itself seriously and that's why it worked. TMNT 1 tried to be dark and edgy but it couldn't break out. It was trying to be what it couldn't. TMNT 2 was just slap stick and knew it was silly and ran with it. I liked that better.

Yeah I suppose there was a bit of a conflict going on in TMNT 1, sometimes it was serious, the fight with Raph on the roof of April's apartment, and then it got a bit silly, the fight between the Turtles and the foot at the end of the film.

I agree with you on Feldman, he didn't suit Donny at all.

LogicDonny
03-25-2007, 02:29 PM
The 2nd one was a little too cartoony compare to the first 1. Guess they were trying to make it just liek the cartoon.

I watched the 3rd one yesterday on YTV. :sick: LOL the movie makes me like ugh.. this is terrible. the way they look and talk. Don't look any good as the first 2.

When I see the new one tomorrow, I will forget the 3rd one even existed.

TerranigmaFreak
03-25-2007, 02:29 PM
Of course that could break his fall, no one doubts that.

but then Casey turned on the compactor. I'm not a doctor or anything, but I don't think a cool helmet could protect you from a garbage compactor.

It crushed his helmet, that means nothing. Wouldn't be hard for it to fall off his head after falling from so high.

Revan
03-25-2007, 02:32 PM
Really?
Man I remember feeling very disappointed when I went to see it, I think I was 11 at the time.
I loved the first movie and number 2 just felt like a step back, I've always liked The Turtles a little edgier.

Well I was only 5 in 1991 so I was all about comedy. Only after I grew a bit older did I realize the sillyness of the whole thing.

Jester
03-25-2007, 02:32 PM
I never liked Turtles 2, most of the humor and dialogue was completely cringe worthy, and the fights were pretty lame, out of all four movies I think TMNT has the best portrayal of the Turtles personalities.
The Turtles in movie 2 all seemed a bit goofy, particularly Donatello, he was behaving like Mikey in some scenes, going completely out of character sometimes, and the survival of Shredder from the garbage truck was ridiculous.
He especially did that in TMNT 1. I gotta say for my money the family dynamic is best used in the first movie. if i had to rank them it'd probably be, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 1 and TMNT on about equal footing, with the original trumping the new. TMNT 2 and 3 the same, because thought TMNT 2 has the better costumes, TMNT has the better story and action.

PrivateRadio
03-25-2007, 02:36 PM
It crushed his helmet, that means nothing. Wouldn't be hard for it to fall off his head after falling from so high.

He was in there too.

Mr. Snackpants
03-25-2007, 02:36 PM
It crushed his helmet, that means nothing. Wouldn't be hard for it to fall off his head after falling from so high.

What are you talking about? You said someone could live from a fall like that because trash bags would brace your fall. Then this guy told you Casey turned the compactor on.

Sliced
03-25-2007, 02:36 PM
I would say it was equal with number 2, but not better. I really liked TMNT, but the overall movie just felt like a rushed and unfinished project to me. Too many things to see in a very short time. Some awsome moments were seperated by very rushed action scenes or empty dialogues.

So for that and some more that I haven't stated, I just think that this movie is way better than the 3rd, about as good as the second, but is still nothing compared to the first. Just reduce the number of monsters to 3 (J.devil, Bigfoot and Vampire succubor) and you just gained some more time, maybe like 10-15 minutes, for more elaborated dialogues or more screen time for the foot and Karai who were really just a joke in this movie. Or even add up some more background for the generals...

This movie had the potential to be better than the original tmnt, something I thaught was near impossible to do, but it just had those major flaws that kept the movie from being better than what we had on big screen.

Jester
03-25-2007, 02:39 PM
Heck, had they made it 120 minutes instead of just 85 they probably could have done that was well.

Raph'N'Roll
03-25-2007, 02:49 PM
Sliced: I really liked TMNT, but the overall movie just felt like a rushed and unfinished project to me. Too many things to see in a very short time. Some awsome moments were seperated by very rushed action scenes or empty dialogues.

It felt rushed to me also, the monster story was very messy with way too many characters complicating matters.
Karai and the Foot were severely neglected, I didn't like that.
I still think it's better than TMNT 2 though.

Jester: He especially did that in TMNT 1

I felt Don was even more goofy in 2, dancing with the floor mop, tickling the robber with a feather duster.

Sliced
03-25-2007, 02:51 PM
Heck, had they made it 120 minutes instead of just 85 they probably could have done that was well.

Forget it, no way they could had done that. There was a budget to respect, and the success of the movie was all but garanteed. It was an already big risk to make this movie, would have been worst to do it a 120 minutes movie.

The animation in this movie was perfect, this is about the best CGI (Minus Final fantasy) I was given to see in my life. This will have a Oscar nomination for sure. But given the restrictions they had.. The sequel might be a 2 hours movie, now that would be possible. Maybe not a $100 million sequel, like Kevin wants, but maybe a $70 millions, depending on the success.

jenna
03-25-2007, 02:54 PM
It felt rushed to me also, the monster story was very messy with way too many characters complicating matters.
I still think it's better than TMNT 2 though.

Agreed. I'd say TMNT 2007 just behind film 1. Would be better than if the narrative was fuller. Film 2 is very nice and cuddly and good laugh (especially with wine!) but not quite a cinematic masterpiece. Film 3 doesn't factor.

Aztec General
03-25-2007, 03:16 PM
No competition. TMNT by a light year.

RskimB
03-25-2007, 03:46 PM
I've said it many times but TMNT(2007) >>> TMNT 2 & 3.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
03-25-2007, 03:51 PM
Personally, I'd put the new movie on the same pedestal as the first. In fact in some aspects I consider it better. So overall, I'd say second best is TMNT 1.

gobo
03-25-2007, 05:03 PM
Secret of the Ooze was great fun, but it was a guilty pleasure for me. The first movie was so message oriented that, while it didn't absolutely wow me, I respected the shell out of it.

The messages in Secret were so sparse, random and fickle that I just found it to be more of a thrill ride than anything. Of course, I could have done without the cheese brought by Niller Ice, an artist that was obviously destined to be a one-hit wonder and the butt of many a joke. But, I'm not so upset about that since it could have been much, much worse. But, the movie ended immediately after Tokka & Rhazar were turned back into regular animals. ... Okay, it wasn't. But, I sure wish it had been! :D

So, TMNT (2K7) absolutely triumphs over The Secret of the Ooze in that there wasn't as much wrong with it. Secret was just the victim of thick-headed producers who thought that throwing money at anything can make it perfect. While that method improved a few things, it still felt too rushed. While TMNT also gave the impression that it was condensed, it seemed like it didn't lose any meaning by never slowing down for more than a few seconds. Instead, I think there's no way it couldn't have benefitted from the quicker pacing.

...

So, um, yeah... This new film is now my second favorite Turtles movie.

LogicDonny
03-25-2007, 05:26 PM
TMNT2 had too much pizza in the movie. remember in the opening credits all the people eating pizza then we have the turtles having tons of pizza boxes as well as Keno the Pizza Delivery Boy delivering pizza when the next door neighbor of Aprils wasn't home he was there giving her the pizza instead knowning how much of a great customer she was despite it's the turtles that eaten it all the time.

How much pizza consuming was there during the new TMNT?

Also at the end of the first fight with the robbers at the beginning of the movie, the turtles took the pizza and left money! Don't you think the turtles would have gotten fat by now?

kerfootw
03-25-2007, 05:30 PM
Well they work out a lot so it helps in burning it off. Besides, they must have some good metabolism because I eat as bad as they do and I look anything but fat as does my friend Charles and he and I are 21 and 20.

And boy does New York eat a lot of pizza. Its only rival must be Chicago but boy, that pizza business in those two places must be nuts!

Lone Wolf
03-25-2007, 06:15 PM
I think TMNT is easily the best TMNT movie ever, but I still love and respect the first movie.

But Secret of the Ooze?!

Please... we have Vanilla Ice rapping about the turtles, who find the badguys at their super-duper secret hideout which is next to... a warehouse style nightclub. And then the turtles start dancing along. Okay. Also no character development, and they try to overcome their enemy with... donuts.

Yeah, it is really close between these two films.

SOTO can be fun for nostalgia, for kids, or light humor. But to say it is actually a
better movie...wow. Go ninja go ninja go. :dead:

Kendamu
03-25-2007, 06:56 PM
Turtles 2 was a joke. TMNT murders it.
Quoted for truth.

Mandi-chan
03-25-2007, 07:02 PM
I loved this new movie!

I wish we could have seen more of Donnie, Mikey, CaseyXApril, and Karai though...but it wasn't really necessary for the story this movie had to tell so I didn't mind. After all, there's a good chance we'll get a sequel out of this and with that more screen time for the others!

I thought the movie was perfect honestly. The tone, animation, characters, action, and storyline were all excellent!

I love TMNT (1990), but personally feel that TMNT (2007) was better.

Now, I don't know about the rest of you...but I honestly don't see this as a sequel to the 90's movies even though the director refers to it as a loose sequel.

It is a different animal from the first movie (which was a different animal from it's crappy sequels), and I just didn't see it as a continuation of that film.

For starters, the TMNT are all the same age (roughly a year or so older actually) as they were in the first film....which took place in 1990. Shouldn't they be in their 30's now? Also, cell phones like the ones we have today in the new millennium didn't exist back then. Add to the fact that the Foot seemed more like the organization from the comics rather than the street punks from the first movie, the TMNT themselves were much more badass, and April has a different job.

I love both movies, but honestly can't see them connected to one another at all besides a couple of homage’s made to the first film and the same title...and that's not a bad thing either.


My score for the movie is a 10 out of 10, and I can't wait to see more of this new movie series!

Time Mistress
03-25-2007, 07:15 PM
I'd definately put the new movie up there with the first as well. TMNT 2 has great individual scenes and lines in it, but as a whole I prefer the new movie.

Revan
03-25-2007, 07:22 PM
I love both movies, but honestly can't see them connected to one another at all besides a couple of homage’s made to the first film and the same title...and that's not a bad thing either.

I agree with you. This new movie was in a league all its own. But you have to admit it was good to see Splinter's wall-o-fame. I just got a good warm fuzzy feeling when I saw that. They kept their older audience in mind.

RskimB
03-25-2007, 07:56 PM
I watched to TMNT 2 before I went to see the new one. From the opening moments I already regretted it, I like camp but after all the momentum they have from the 1st movie the sequel is a tremendous letdown. TMNT 2 is ridiculously cheesy(sound effects, Tokka & Razah, etc) , totally toned down for kids, tries to be more light hearted and humorous and fails, and the whole dance scene and Ninja Rap is just awful not to mention ooc for ninjas. The new movie is easily an improvement on the last two installments Munroe would have to try really hard to make a move worse than 2 &3.

Sliced
03-25-2007, 08:30 PM
I really hate that wall of fame. Why ? You can a see Triceraton breathing mask, a laser blaster and mousers. What the hell are those things doing there ??? It just destroy this whole ''sequel from the previous film'' thing.

Is this movie also taking in account the 2K3 cartoon ? If so, shredder's helmet is not supposed to look like that at all. Its clear that this helmet is supposed to be the helmet from the first movie. And what about that Triceraton equipement... and of course the mousers.

Its just not making sense for me. That's why I dont really consider this a sequel to the 3 previous movies.. But more of a new series of TMNT movies. Because if this is really a sequel to the previous movies, man did we missed alot or what ?

PrivateRadio
03-25-2007, 08:32 PM
I really hate that wall of fame. Why ? You can a see Triceraton breathing mask, a laser blaster and mousers. What the hell are those things doing there ??? It just destroy this whole ''sequel from the previous film'' thing.

Is this movie also taking in account the 2K3 cartoon ? If so, shredder's helmet is not supposed to look like that at all. Its clear that this helmet is supposed to be the helmet from the first movie. And what about that Triceraton equipement... and of course the mousers.

Its just not making sense for me. That's why I dont really consider this a sequel to the 3 previous movies.. But more of a new series of TMNT movies. Because if this is really a sequel to the previous movies, man did we missed alot or what ?

that's not really a big deal. The wall was like Kevin's nod to every kind of Turtles fan, from fans of the comics to the movies. It doesn't matter what continuity the movie's based in because the only past thing it relies on is the Shredder being dead. The Shredder's dead in every continuity.

wyze2099
03-25-2007, 09:09 PM
Now, I don't know about the rest of you...but I honestly don't see this as a sequel to the 90's movies even though the director refers to it as a loose sequel.

It is a different animal from the first movie (which was a different animal from it's crappy sequels), and I just didn't see it as a continuation of that film.

For starters, the TMNT are all the same age (roughly a year or so older actually) as they were in the first film....which took place in 1990. Shouldn't they be in their 30's now? Also, cell phones like the ones we have today in the new millennium didn't exist back then. Add to the fact that the Foot seemed more like the organization from the comics rather than the street punks from the first movie, the TMNT themselves were much more badass, and April has a different job.

I love both movies, but honestly can't see them connected to one another at all besides a couple of homage’s made to the first film and the same title...and that's not a bad thing either.

I got the same impression as well. The feel of TMNT is so different from the live-action series that it seems more like a separate continuity in which vaguely-similar events happened. While it's mentioned that Shredder is gone and the Foot are supposed to be out of business, it's never explained how, and the defeat could have easily happened in a different manner. The time scepter is seen in Splinter's display case, but that could just as easily have been the result of an encounter with Renet, as in the Mirage comics and 2K3 cartoon. April and Casey are a couple, which seems to follow the live action movies, but it also follows the Mirage comic and 2K3 series.

As for the contemporary things like the cell phones, though, I don't think that necessarily indicates that TMNT is in a separate timeline from the movie. The live-action movies seem to take place in the early '90s for no better reason than they're the "present day" in which the movies are set. The details are dated by today's standards, but they never set out to be a "period" movie. Setting the new movie in the mid-to-late '90s would cause the filmmakers to have to use a lot of dated references. So my guess that TMNT is meant to be set in the "Present Day", which happens to be only a couple of years down the road from the "Present Day" established in the live-action movies. I'm using a similar conceit in my "Shadowed Alliances" screenshot comic, which is set a matter of months after the second and third movies, but makes some more contemporary references. So those details aren't quite as much of an indicator as one might think.

BigApple3AM
03-25-2007, 11:35 PM
I like TMNT 2 for a lot of things, but yeah it was just too silly sometimes. I love silly but I mean it wasn't the good kind of silly. TMNT 1, TMNT 4, TMNT 2, TMNT 3 is how I'd rank them. I think the new guys did a good job but there were way too many slight annoyances that I think could have been easily fixed that I'ev already posted before. I expect TMNT 5 to be better than TMNT 4, but I'm not sure anything can beat TMNT 1 at this point, it was just really really well done for what has become a kiddy oriented franchise.

poobone
03-26-2007, 03:20 AM
IF you ask most people, the concensus is the first film is the best.
However on some boards, some people felt turtles 2 (91) was superior to the new 07 flick.
So i wanted to see how hardcore fans thought. Imo this is better, but i can see how kid nostalgias may influence peoples thoughts.

discuss.

Here's the order, best to worst:

TMNT
TMNT 4
TMNT 2
TMNT 3

Wes
03-26-2007, 05:30 AM
After I saw the new movie, I left disappointed, but thinking that it was better than TMNT II, but certainly not the first film. However, after rewatching both the original TMNT and TMNT II this weekend, I've concluded that the new flick is inferior to both of them. The Turtles were certainly less goofy in the latest film, but this movie's story and characterization of pretty much everyone except Leo and Raph was really lacking (especially where the villains are concerned) -- areas in which TMNT II more than held its own. I mean, the plot wasn't particularly groundbreaking (Shredder returns, creates mutants to fight the Turtles -- pretty much his MO in the cartoon -- and so forth), but it certainly didn't feel like it was just tacked on.

TMNT II also introduced Tokka and Rahzar -- two pretty memorable characters that I still recall fondly sixteen years later (though that could also have to do with their nifty toys and inclusion in the TMNT III and TMNT IV video games, to say nothing of the fact that I've watched the movie again several times since then). And Super Shredder! Yeah, there's no reason his suit should have been mutated, but I still remember my jaw dropping when he rose up and started smashing through the docks. By contrast, if I hadn't played the game based on the new movie, I wouldn't even remember the names of the stone generals -- and I just saw the new movie three days ago.

Anyway, to sum up, tone and visuals are pretty much the only things that TMNT 2007 has going for it -- and these are ultimately pretty superficial. In terms of a compelling (if goofy) story, compelling (if goofy) characters, and memorable (if goofy) scenes (ninja rap, anyone?! :lol: ) TMNT II has this one licked.

Lone Wolf
03-26-2007, 11:46 AM
I expect TMNT 5 to be better than TMNT 4, but I'm not sure anything can beat TMNT 1 at this point, it was just really really well done for what has become a kiddy oriented franchise.

I agree with you that TMNT 1 was really, really well done, but I am confused by what you mean as to TMNT "becoming" a kiddy franchise. Since the comic was licensed for the toys and original toon, it has been an all-ages property. How has it, in the year 2007, with much a much darker cartoon and movie having been released in recent years, "become" a kiddy oriented franchise?

As far as this "ultra dark" interpretation of the first movie goes...Dude, a slice of pizza "humorously" falls onto Splinter's head in the first movie. Mikey jumps up like a cartoon character when he hears April has Pizza in her apartment. The whole final fight scene with the foot is whole lot kiddier than any fight scene in the new TMNT movie (just listen to the music!).
Who watched the old toon (by and large), college students? Uh, no. Little, tiny, kiddy kids watched it.

The first movie made an awesome 135 million at the Box Office. It got there by and large because of the 5-10 year olds (us) that saw it a billion times in theaters and that will forever remember it as the perfect cinematic masterpiece we experienced it as at the time. In the year 2007, the franchise isn't becoming anything it hasn't been, except for perhaps darker (as a whole) since its late-80's early-90's incarnations.

shuriken
04-01-2007, 07:46 PM
TMNT-1 Is my favorite, sure it has some flaws and Corey Feldman makes Don too Mikie-sh(hey I crewated a new word he-he) but overall the story, action and the setting was just awesome.
TMNT-2 Is my 2nd favorite. Why? Yes it was sillier, yes the Whole Vanilla Ice next to a Foot base is ridiculous, but hell if you take yourself TOO seriously thet sucks out the fun of the movie. Besides I have alot of fond memories from the movie and I even knew all the words of "Ninja Rap" at one time. So sue me:P . But I also thought that the animatronics were way better than the first.
TMNT-2007 Liked it. GCI was amazing. Story was a bit lacking, seemed a bit rushed at times. I thought this movie was pretty silly and had some funny moments, but I will never say that 2007 beats TMNT2.
TMNT-3 Its pretty bad. Hated it as a kid. I've come to terms with it now, I just watch it to make fun of myself. God and the costumes were like:dead: . UGHGHGHH.

Time Mistress
04-01-2007, 07:48 PM
Here's the order, best to worst:

TMNT
TMNT 4
TMNT 2
TMNT 3

Same for me.

Shark_Blade
04-01-2007, 07:56 PM
Turtles 2 was the first tmnt movie I've ever seen, so I like it more than the new tmnt movie I guess.