View Full Version : Do we need Shredder for "TMNT2" if it comes out?
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
03-25-2007, 04:03 PM
I would say no, but we can't rule him out. It's so good to see this one doing well at the box office, but i wasn't surprised at the critics malice. But it seems the TMNT are trying to take a different route, to be more concentrated to the comics and the comics weren't all about Shredder y'know.
ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
03-25-2007, 04:06 PM
No, they don't need him. In fact, I had an idea for a TMNT 2 that's 99.9% Shredder free.
They can do it.
VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 04:08 PM
I don't mind him being back just hope it's done creatively with the clones etc.
Ecto Jedi
03-25-2007, 04:09 PM
I don't mind him being back just hope it's done creatively with the clones etc.
I second that. Or perhaps have Karai don the Shredder armour?
VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 04:13 PM
I second that. Or perhaps have Karai don the Shredder armour?
well if we get city at war mixed with return to new york we could very well see both. I'd really like them to throw baxter into the mix though.
Whitewolf89
03-25-2007, 04:25 PM
Personally, I say no, but after what Karai said the guys close to the end of the movie, and Raph's reaction of "She doesn't mean............." (at least, I think that's the way the line went), I just have a hunch that Ol' Tin-Grin MIGHT just be making a come-back.
Which SO doesn't need to happen. But I'm just afraid that it will. DESPITE the fact that they CAN get along without him in every episode and/or movie. Which both the TV series (2k3 AND Fast Forward) AND the comics HAVE proved, more than once.
blueoakleyz
03-25-2007, 04:26 PM
I would say no, but we can't rule him out. It's so good to see this one doing well at the box office, but i wasn't surprised at the critics malice. But it seems the TMNT are trying to take a different route, to be more concentrated to the comics and the comics weren't all about Shredder y'know.
TMNT5, not TMNT2 (please god don't let that be a trend)
well as an 80s cartoon and toy and movie fan let me tell you, the comics werent that interesting.. Shredder is a must! but not the 2k3 Shredder... something more like the one from the movies would be nice
Peanut
03-25-2007, 04:29 PM
I wouldn't mind either way, but you know who the next movie needs? Tatsu!
Katie
03-25-2007, 04:34 PM
LOL Tatsu.
He could be promoted to Shredder. :lol:
TMNT2: The New Shredder
Ecto Jedi
03-25-2007, 04:35 PM
Which SO doesn't need to happen. But I'm just afraid that it will. DESPITE the fact that they CAN get along without him in every episode and/or movie. Which both the TV series (2k3 AND Fast Forward) AND the comics HAVE proved, more than once.
I don't get it...I find Shredder an excellent villain. He looks cool, he's bad-ass (in the 2k3 'toon, anyway) and he's got a wicked name. I mean, the character practically has his own mythos -- anybody who's ever seen the Ninja Turtles knows about Shredder. And from what I've heard, that's what moviegoers want to see. So why not include him in a sequel? If they find a nice, plausible way of bringing him back (e.g., "Worms of Madness") then why the f*ck not?
VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 04:39 PM
I wouldn't mind either way, but you know who the next movie needs? Tatsu!
I think Lairds replaced good old Tatsu with Hun :ohwell:
ToTheNines
03-25-2007, 04:43 PM
Alot of my freinds are casual TMNT fans, and they ALL wished that shredder would have been in the movie, I didn't mind since i knew we were getting a good one anyways. Either way, I don't think we NEED Shredder to get better box office numbers, but I could be wrong.
jignat
03-25-2007, 04:56 PM
Unfortunately, ive been seeing sentiment from casual turtles fans that Shredder has to come back. They felt that this was a good bridge film and that like Batman Begins, save the prime villain for the sequel(dark knight has joker).
Im almost positive WB will lean on Munroe to include shredder for the financial gain.
However , im curious if shred is the villain, then some thoughts:
If they bring Saki back somehow, and then have him die a comic book style death, then people will be more entrenched in the "tmnt need shredder to be successful" train of thought. Also, the methods of resurrection are limited that can work.
-If Karai dons the armor a la 03, im worried the general people would scoff. She didnt come of as that intimidating in tmnt in th elimited time we knew her.
-Also, would LAird even approve of it. As we know he was a mjor force in pushing for a non-shredder villain for this movie. Hopefully, munroe will still consult with him and not bow to studio politics.
--Third, I really would like to see some other classic villains introduced into the movieverse. Granted, maybe some of em would be hard to center a filmn around, but they could be working for Shred or being a kind of wild card , a thirs side of the equation(Rat king maybe). Or maybe have a brief intro involving turtles defeating baxter before the main plot starts.
ToTheNines
03-25-2007, 05:03 PM
I dig your baxter idea dude.
Spawn Guy
03-25-2007, 05:14 PM
TMNT5, not TMNT2 (please god don't let that be a trend)
well as an 80s cartoon and toy and movie fan let me tell you, the comics werent that interesting.. Shredder is a must! but not the 2k3 Shredder... something more like the one from the movies would be nice
Can we just stop with the whole "This thing needs to come from the first movie" thing?
And as a guy who's actually read the comics, the cartoon was pretty sterile.
ToTheNines
03-25-2007, 05:16 PM
Sterile:lol: nice one
Spawn Guy
03-25-2007, 05:19 PM
Well, when you get around to it, Shredder himself was pretty sterile. He's the evil ninja guy who killed Yoshi and Splinter hates him...and that's about it.
Shredder was unable to have children?? I had no idea...
Do we need Shredder in the sequel? No. But, do we want him in the sequel? I wouldn't mind. I'd actually prefer him to another brand new villain. We all know that expanding the rosters wasn't too well-received regarding Garbageman and Nano, so I think Max Winters' generals were just lucky in that respect.
Sliced
03-25-2007, 05:45 PM
What would be good for a sequel ?
a) Shredder
b) Triceratons
C) Bishop or/and Baxter
D) Karai as Shredder...
E) Multiple villains (Slash, bebop/rocksteady, leatherhead, rat king..)
etc...
We do have alot of choices. This sequel could be like the upcoming spiderman 3. You could throw in 2-3 villains or have what alot of fans are just waiting for... Shredder, bebop and rocksteady. This is still way ahead of us though. Still plenty of time to ''analyze'' this villain(s) thing.
Brandatello
03-25-2007, 05:46 PM
shredder probly got a vasectomy in his college years to minimize the problems...:) :lol:
Spawn Guy
03-25-2007, 05:51 PM
Shredder was unable to have children?? I had no idea...
I know. His kid in the Image series? Big continuity error.
Do we need Shredder in the sequel? No. But, do we want him in the sequel? I wouldn't mind. I'd actually prefer him to another brand new villain. We all know that expanding the rosters wasn't too well-received regarding Garbageman and Nano, so I think Max Winters' generals were just lucky in that respect.
Meh, I know Garbageman and Nano weren't all that inspired, Nano more because once you saw one episode you'd seen them all and Garbageman is pretty self explanitory. I also know Shred head is THE TMNT villian, I just wish it was for the right reason. "He wuz in da cartoon11!1" dosen't count.
Quiet_Guy
03-25-2007, 06:01 PM
I wouldn't mind to see Bishop. I also wanna see Leatherhead even though he is a good guy.
Tinuvielsdreams
03-25-2007, 06:23 PM
I would love to see city at war done ( I liked that story arch in the comics and the series), but Bishop could have a lot of possibilities.
Maybe that would be a great way to get all the extra characters we want to see come in...
SLASH!!!
03-25-2007, 06:48 PM
For a sequal to TMNT I would do what Batman Begins did and have multiple villians. Two which are pawns of the main bad guy.
I would have the foot bring back Shredder in a believable way and have him begin to plot his revenge. He employs scientist Baxter Stockman to use his mousers to help search the sewers. In the sewers the foot find Leatherhead an intelegent mutant Aligator (who would need a new origin, but I would want it to involve the ooze, maybe the ooze that mutated the turtles leaked into another part of the sewers.). The foot trick Leatherhead into helping them fight the turtles. Though in the end he sides with the green team.
ZariusTwo
03-25-2007, 06:57 PM
I'll go with a more reallistic approach, they'll probably adapt "City At War" at best, with Shredder manipulating all sides into eliminating the other, and Splinter will be haunted by The Rat King's aparition after an early demise in the movie.
VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 07:01 PM
Shredder was unable to have children?? I had no idea....
ummm when was this said..ever?:o I seriously don't remember reading that and I've got every comic book!:o
I'll go with a more reallistic approach, they'll probably adapt "City At War" at best, with Shredder manipulating all sides into eliminating the other, and Splinter will be haunted by The Rat King's aparition after an early demise in the movie.
man I sure hope so! I want cristopher walken to play rat king!:lol:
ToTheNines
03-25-2007, 07:04 PM
He was joking about someone calling him "sterile"
VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 07:05 PM
He was joking about someone calling him "sterile"
ah ic I got confused for a damn second there because everyone was taking him seriously...I was like ummmm ok that one some how slipped past me.
Must be part of Peter Liards re-writes to the old comics!:lol:
Kendamu
03-25-2007, 07:10 PM
I'd like to see Shredder. Needed? Hardly. Would it be awesome? Totally!
invictus1002
03-25-2007, 07:13 PM
the next tmnt needs shred dude because many casual fans were dissapointed he wasnt in this one. shed is pretty bad ass and after being defeated twice by the turtles he should be absolutely furious if they bring him bak
Ecto Jedi
03-25-2007, 07:14 PM
I'd like to see Shredder. Needed? Hardly. Would it be awesome? Totally!
...Amen. :)
Starkiller
03-25-2007, 07:18 PM
From a fangirl point, I'd say another Turtles movie could definitely work without Shredder, much as I'd like to see him on the big screen again. However, from a Box Office/money making point, I'd say yes the Shredder might have to be included in order to pull the crowds in and get people excited again. Most of my mates have said they weren't that crazy about the new TMNT film due to the lack of Shredder. The Turtles themselves were enough to pull in old fans this time around, but will it be enough to rope them in for a sequel?
Although, they could go with Putrescent's sig and make zombies the villain - everyone knows that Zombies bring in the crowds! :D
VaughnMichael
03-25-2007, 07:24 PM
the next tmnt needs shred dude because many casual fans were dissapointed he wasnt in this one. shed is pretty bad ass and after being defeated twice by the turtles he should be absolutely furious if they bring him bak
you said the main word right there "Casual" those fans don't even really care that much about the property of tmnt.
I'm really glad they didn't and wont make movies for the casual person.
The casuals are the ones who more than likely wait to down load the movie or even wait till its on dvd complaining why isn't shredder bebop and rocksteady or some other 80's character in the movie.
I'm not say you when I say this next part but people really need to get over the 80's it's now 2007 and I'm quite thankfull that the turtles have moved on now if only half the fans would.
Although, they could go with Putrescent's sig and make zombies the villain - everyone knows that Zombies bring in the crowds! :D
yay hehe I would love that seriously but I'd be so scared of one of the characters we love being turned into a zombie. Could you even imagin zombie michaelangelo with his appetite!:o
PrivateRadio
03-25-2007, 08:19 PM
I'm kinda weary about bringing Shredder back. The best thing about the Shredder stories is the genuine fear and desperation in them. I really wouldn't want brand new Shredder stories because I don't have faith in someone putting something together that works better than Return To New York and everything that happened before it.
Leonardo getting jumped by the foot and Shredder I think is a HUGE factor in it. Instantly Shredder is made a terrifying force because he completely trashed the most effective member (and the leader) of the team, an inch from death, as his warning shot. You can't really do that in another movie because and that'd just seem redundant after what happened to Leo in this movie. You can do what they did in the first movie and have Raph get jumped instead, but it'd just be what the first movie did and it would maintain this huge focus on Raph that this movie had. Beyond all that, unless we get our PG-13, you can't really have an effective beatdown like that happen the way it should. Donatello can't be victimized because he's commonly shown to be the weakest fighter on the team and Michelangelo is portrayed too innocently (which I actually loved in the new movie) to have that happen to him.
Of course, you wouldn't have to play out Return To New York so closely, especially since the first movie covered a lot of it, but what I'm trying to say is I get worried that we'll have another ******** Shredder like we got in the 2nd movie. The Shredder's power is in him being a really terrifying villian. He does awful ****, and no one's ever really sure he can be beaten, or if they'll survive the encounter. I would never want that kiddified, and he's really not a necessary villian unless they capture that.
and I'd vomit all over the theater if they make Shredder anything like he was in the 80's cartoon. That would be a ****ing tragedy.
I made this WAY too long. The other thing is I think it was an awful idea to have Splinter be the one that kills Shredder in the first. It's like, after Leo kills Shredder in Return To New York he says "Our destiny is complete" or something along those lines. The Turtles weren't trained to protect New York, that just sort of happened. The Turtles were trained to stop and kill Oroku Saki. I really hope they never do anything like that again.
and yeah, if I made it sound like otherwise, I completely love and adore the first movie. okay, I'm really done now, sorry it's so long.
*EDIT: Oh wow, I'm not gonna change it all but I didn't know this board censors stuff so much. Otherwise I wouldn't have all these asterik words everywhere, haha.
ToTheNines
03-25-2007, 08:22 PM
Dude, I think Kevin M. is smart enough to avoid the 80's approach for The Shredder
PrivateRadio
03-25-2007, 08:24 PM
Dude, I think Kevin M. is smart enough to avoid the 80's approach for The Shredder
Obviously.
I was directing that more towards people using "Shredder ruled in the 80's cartoon" as a point towards him being in the sequel.
My doubts about Shredder aren't in Kevin as a director, more of the writing and the limitations and guidelines the movie will have to follow.
ToTheNines
03-25-2007, 08:26 PM
Oh, sorry pal. I see where your comin from
PrivateRadio
03-25-2007, 08:28 PM
Oh, sorry pal. I see where your comin from
it's cool. by the way, off topic and all, but is your name referring to the Only Crime album To The Nines?
ToTheNines
03-25-2007, 08:29 PM
For sure man, I can't get enough of them!
Mr. Snackpants
03-25-2007, 08:38 PM
I personally dont care. I'd be cool to see Shredder in cgi. But if not, Karai or whatever would be fine.
But thinking about casual tmnt fan who went to this movie....they are probably upset about no shredder. they also probably didn't like too much, maybe too kiddy. But if a sequel came out advertising shredder, people who would've skipped out might come see it and give it another chance.
Just a thought...
tekninja
03-25-2007, 08:41 PM
I would preferre not to see shredder. I agree with earlier post about somehow incorperating rat-king, baxter and leatherhead. maybe not necessarily all three together. shredder could have had something started but never got it completely finished and so karai had to carry out the plans. that way you could have shredder in a little bit with a minor flash back story, but not overdoing his character to much.
Willis
03-25-2007, 10:52 PM
I would like to see Shredder return, because if your going to base the history of the turtles from the first three movies (as they appear to in TMNT).. I say that plot hole from Turtles:2 about Super Shredder dieing is big enough to drive a Semi into. It would be more surprising to have him not come back.
BUT, two conditions.
1) The return of shredder is not lead onto until it actually happens... so the audience (and turtles) never seen it coming. It's not something stupid, nor is it rushed.
2) He's not the only bad guy. I seriously think it would be impressive to have an alternate evil. Either where the evil forces join to fight the Turtles.. Or their goals clash and now we have a three way FFA.
PrivateRadio
03-25-2007, 11:46 PM
2) Or their goals clash and now we have a three way FFA.
that's sorta like City at War. That'd be awesome.
jignat
03-26-2007, 02:59 AM
Warning: the following is a really stupid plot idea of a tmnt sequel. It makes the 80s toon look like macbeth. Read only if you're bored
One thing I think would be neat is to do something similar to the bond movies.
and have tmnt take down the mousers right as the film starts up and Baxter.then have the intro , then do a sewer lunch/relazxing with everyone to set up the basic character refreshers while adding humor. In thiis scene, the tmnt are light hearted, but Splinter is unusally restrained. The night before, he had a premonition that he would be killed by the one of the turtles , but he cant tell which one...!!!
Have KArai lead the foot clan trying to come up with a scheme to defeat the turtles. but somehow a brekaway section of the foot disagrees with her leadership between tmnt 07 and forms a rival foot clan(with shredder elite designs) (city at war element)Anyway, this escalates into a ninja war, then also purple dragons are exploiting the chaos, etc Tmnt have to fight both sides, . Suddenly tmnt are captured by the karai-led foot clan, but after one of the turtles saves her life from the elites, she reluctantly teams up with them .
Anyway in all this splinter is abducted by acreepy bandaged dude seemingly of his own accord. As the "elite" foot fight KArai/turtles , Rat Kings takes splinter to an abandoned water tower to tell of how he was just a homless man in nyc kidnapped by the govt and genetically altered to be a weapon. However when he didnt manifest any abilities he was discarded in the sewers. Soon he begin to grow insane with only refuse , and rats.In time he is able to subconciously influence the rats to do his bidding. While he relates this to splinter, Splinter is entranced by his words. Rat King declares that the surface dwellers must know true chaos and suffering like he did.
Rat Kings and Splinter *under his control) and some homeless/bums/ break into a research lab and steal an experimental weapon that when coupled to a huge power source , would reduce nYC to a post-fallout state. In KAraias base and the elites base, a mysterious note is left making it seem as if the other wishes to surrender and to meet atop the channel 6 tower. When both groups arrive , they are surpised to see Rat King, Splinter, and an army of thugs/bums all unde rRat Kings control. 4way fightinitially ensures, During the fight, it is revealed by Rat King that he subtly mincontrolled the "elites" to break away from KArais group in order to start the chaos.The elites realize thier folly and fall back under karai, making it a 3 sides battle
Rat King activates his macguffin with a 10 minute timer. His thug/s bums are attacking the foot clan and are not skilled but outnumber the foot/tmnt.
Meanwhile Splnter is still under RK's control attacks Leo and is about to choke him to death , while Raph tries to wrestle him free. But Leo is about to die , when Raph does the unthinkable and stabs Splinter straight in the gut. In splinters mind, the premontion scene plays out, and Splinter collapses, hemorrhaging , but back to his senses, while Leo slowly gains conciousness from oxygen loss, and Raphael sheds a tear.splinter doesnt die.
all this madness attracts the police who begins firing haphazardly at everyone. The foot clan flees, the bums are killed in ahila of bullets and some flee. Only the tmnt , splinter on the ground in shock, and Rat King raving that humanity must be reborn into suffering. Raphael with his rage, and Mike engage Rat Kings in martials arts battle. Rat King mixes grappling with ninjustu. With leo/splinter out of commission, Don separates the experimental weapon from the channel 6 generator, but the weapon will still destroy everythng on th eimmediate vicinity (As opposed to the whole NYC). Raphael and Mike at one pont get the upper hand on Rat King and are about to kill him in a fit of rage. when Don tells them that if they dont get out of here, theyll all die. Leo manages to get up with Dons help, and Splinter is carried by Raph off the roof by grappling hook as the wepon explodes destroying rat king.
After all the chaos, Splinter is healing at the lair. Leo is at the lair on O2 , but otherwise unharmed. The next day at the top of the Channel tower, police and forensics are analyzing what happened. Rat Kings body was blown up into small unrecogniziable fragments. all his remains are catlaogued and bagged. However one elder Asian w/glasses forensic scientist keeps some in a small vial in his pocket.
Later on in the evening, he leaves work, and enters a ginormous skyscraper with lots o hitech security(fingerprint, retinal scan, etc) .He is standing in front of a grand platform with 3 shadowy figures:
Forensic: I was able toretrieve a small sample of the anomaly. It showed great prowess among the telepathic arts and may posses more talents
Shadowy figure 1: You have served us well. Will it be compatible w/the WORMS?
forensic: I will need further testing but the surface PCR tests show high compatibility w/ the masters DNA.
Shadowy Figure 2:Then begin the procedure at once
Forensic: Yes sir
shadowy Figure 3: With this, we shall eliminate the girl and restore honor to the most respected organization on the planet. The freaks will soon be a mere stain upon the tapestry of time. We shall taste victory once again.
poobone
03-26-2007, 03:09 AM
whatever they do, I hope it's better than Max Winters and the 13 monsters. That part of the movie was just boring and derivative. I'd rather see shredder come back than a new, original villian that's lame like this one.
Shark
03-26-2007, 06:33 AM
I'm honestly sick of Shredder (1980's cartoon, new toon, both of the first movies). But seeing him in a CGI film would be interesting. Didn't Kev say he wanted Shredder for the sequel already? Although Karai already hinted at his return sadly.
Just thinking of it now. I'm no fan of casual fandom... or casual anything for that matter. But, what would it hurt to appease them to gain their viewership? For the sequel, there should be the serious version of well-known characters from the original cartoon series. No, I don't mean Krang or Bebop or Rocksteady. I mean the original comic characters who were reinvented for the classic cartoon (i.e. Leatherhead, Rat King, Baxter, etc.). The name of the characters alone will draw the casual fans' attention. Then, to appease the almighty Laird, we can see some more brand new characters. These are the main characters for the majority of the movie. At the beginning, there will be an indication that Shredder has something to do with the movie. But, he won't be physically present until the last minute (maybe even a Dr. Claw-type appearance where all you see is his arms). This will be like foreshadowing of what's to come in the next installment. Perhaps they can even shed a bit more light on what the orthodox backstory is for these movies (including where April got her mad skillz from).
Ninjinister
03-26-2007, 02:46 PM
I wouldn't mind Shredder in the sequel. But Leatherhead is the character I'd like to see the most in a movie. CGI giant mutant gator? Thank you very much.
jezza
03-26-2007, 03:03 PM
Looking back on the film, I kind of wished they had done a Batman Begins and restart the whole franchise so we can see a more steady story line. To me Spiderman has the most well linked and interesting storyline of any late comic book movie and as a result feels like it can go on forever. I would love to see that from the TMNT movies.
ToTheNines
03-26-2007, 03:19 PM
Not me, I'm glad we got to skip the origin story and Shredders "first appearance" this time around. Between all the mediums of TMNT we've seen it all atleast 4 times.
BradsOneManBand
03-26-2007, 03:37 PM
i think it would TOTALLY rule to have Shredder, Krang, Bebop, and Rocksteady in a sequal! i'd be soooo super stoked on that! even if Shredder didn't appear in it, the other 3 could be done SO well in CGI. just imagining it makes me giddy Erma receiving some Valentines from sailors! ha
Revan
03-26-2007, 03:40 PM
Looking back on the film, I kind of wished they had done a Batman Begins and restart the whole franchise so we can see a more steady story line. To me Spiderman has the most well linked and interesting storyline of any late comic book movie and as a result feels like it can go on forever. I would love to see that from the TMNT movies.
Agreed 100%. Also the Superman movies should be redone. I love Chris Reeve and Superman: The Movie (original first movie) is in my top 10 favs of all time but everything after the first movie was pathetic. They could be done so much better if they were to be remade.
Chris
03-26-2007, 04:36 PM
I'm all for Shredder in the sequel.
Think about it, in the movies he's been beaten by Splinter and dropped a pier on himself. The TMNT have never actually beaten him in a straight fight in the films and the CGI in this film proved that such a fight in the next film could be the ultimate movie TMNT Vs. Shredder fight.
Hopefully the next film will take elements from Return to New York and City at War. As cool as Rat King would be I hope they don't try and fit him in as well, in a 2 hour+ movie (like Batman Begins) they can do multiple villains, in a 90 minute CGI TMNT film Shredder, Karai and the Foot with elements of two major comic story arcs is more than enough for one movie
I also hope that they recreate the Leo Vs Shredder duel and have the guts to end it right (even if it is silhouetted or just off screen). And then burn the body like RTNY so he can't come back and future sequels will then be free to move forward.
RskimB
03-26-2007, 04:48 PM
Looking back on the film, I kind of wished they had done a Batman Begins and restart the whole franchise so we can see a more steady story line. To me Spiderman has the most well linked and interesting storyline of any late comic book movie and as a result feels like it can go on forever. I would love to see that from the TMNT movies.
I think the loose sequel thing could have worked if Kevin had been more firm about it. If he instead decided to incorporate everything from 1 & 2 or just 1 I dont think we'd be as critical. But he sort of dances picks and chooses to incorporate certain elements from the trilogy. A total restart isnt really necessary the origin has been worked into the ground. The original has all the elements you need to work off of and if he wanted Kevin could have completely ignored the sequel and probably still resurrect Shredder through clones as the comics did. So what if he was cremated, in the comics the Foot used the remaining chunks of Shredder :D
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.