PDA

View Full Version : What if TMNT never existed before this movie?


xChri5x
03-28-2007, 12:27 AM
Would the movie be doing better or worse? Or even the same?

I'm thinking it might have done worse, since there would be no old fanbase or cult following but at the same time it might have done better since there would be no comparissons to past TMNT outtings. Plus it would be something new and fresh.

(Sorry if it's been asked before)

Lone Wolf
03-28-2007, 12:55 AM
What a strange question. That is like asking what if Superman never existed before Superman Returns or Batman before Batman Begins or, if you ask Richard Roper, the Brady Bunch before a Very Brady Movie.

Note: Edited for accuracy.

Bry
03-28-2007, 01:36 AM
...or, if you ask Roger Ebert, the Brady Bunch before a Very Brady Movie.
That was Richard Roeper, actually. Ebert's still on a leave of absence due to medical problems from last year.

(I do agree that his statement was rather dumb, though.)

Lone Wolf
03-28-2007, 02:10 AM
That was Richard Roeper, actually. Ebert's still on a leave of absence due to medical problems from last year.

(I do agree that his statement was rather dumb, though.)

Thanks, fixed it. Guess I am still having flashbacks to the first movie review.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
03-28-2007, 02:41 AM
I think if there were no TMNT previously, this movie would have been easily brushed off. No one would have given this movie a second look.

Without that prior history, no one would bother with this movie. It's the concept really. If no one knew about the characters already, I don't think hardly anyone would take it seriously.

Plus, this movie would be changed significantly if there were no TMNT previously. This would be an orgin stroy, rather than reintroduction.

Ballerninja
03-28-2007, 06:41 AM
Wow, I don't even want to think about that! I almost said that I would probably hate the movie because it shows Ninjutsu practicioners in a comical light, but then I realized that TMNT was the reason I started getting into ANY martial arts in the first place, especially Ninjutsu! The TMNT are responsible for pretty much every aspect of my personality and lifestyle today. Given, it's evolved a lot, but most of my interests grew from a seed planted by those four brothers and their lovable master Splinter. Ha, saying "What if TMNT never existed?" is like wiping one of my parents out of the picture before I was born. Scary scary thought. :cry:

But, from a less sentimental standpoint: I agree that the movie would not have done as well. The 80's were a goofy time where the TMNT origin story fit in nicely. Anything with "Ninja" in the title would do well, especially with kids. It would have been a mediocre success, I think. Some kids would want to see it, but not a load. All three times I saw it in the theatre, the mid-twenties crowd greatly outnumbered the children.

Willis
03-28-2007, 07:00 AM
Ha, saying "What if TMNT never existed?" is like wiping one of my parents out of the picture before I was born. Scary scary thought. :cry:

Haha.. actually your not alone. At least for me I'd have Sonic, Transformers, and an assortment of PC games to fall back on :lol: ..

But back on track.. It depends on what side of the coin your looking at.

If your talking about the movie, exactly how it is (minus the homages to past Turtle movies) ... I think it would be ok, but take longer to get the rating it does now. That fan base really rushed the desire to see it. Otherwise it would be a slow start and once people see "hey its not so bad" it would get there. But this movie has some issues, and that would play even a bigger role without the fanbase.

Now if your saying a TMNT movie in general.. same basic plot of 13 monsters but maybe some more content, a few alterations to add some background to the turtles.. ASSUMING they would add more then 90 minutes to the running time.. it would be a good movie indeed. But if they tried to cram even MORE into those 90 minutes.. it would not be pretty.

gobo
03-28-2007, 11:41 AM
If there was no previous knowledge of TMNT before the movie, there would be no TMNT faithful to create the hype. Only the die-hard fans of Sarah Michelle Gellar, Patrick Stewart, and Kevin Smith would be assured to see it. The fans of Lawrence Fishburne too, but they'd probably be disappointed. Any of those people who like comic book stories would probably like the movie and give it praise. But, they'd surely feel ripped off for a more detailed origin story.

Revan
03-28-2007, 02:01 PM
I don't think the movie would have worked at all for one main reason.

The origin of the turtles has been driven into our heads throughout the numerous mediums. Throughout the first movie we are given a detailed explanation (Splinter tells April in the old lair) and then again in the second movie (Splinter tells Keno in April's apartment).

We are told in the OT in the piolot and I'm sure a few more times in later episodes though I can't remember them specifically.

2k3 they explain it to April and Casey.

Mirage Comic... obviously

So as fans, we know going into the movie who the turtles are and their peculiar origin. I think it would have taken a long time to fully explain to the audience how the turtles came to be. The opening voiceover would not have satisfied my had I not known anything about the boys prior to see TMNT.

Dragnskull
03-28-2007, 04:32 PM
if the TMNT wernt around in the past, then what would have happened, is the tv industry would have created the 80's toon here in the 2k, and the sweep of TMNT would just now be going into overdrive...and we wouldnt be the older generation as we are today

but it WOULD happen :P

the movie that was released woudlnt have been this new CGI movie, it would have been a live action :P