PDA

View Full Version : This Movie Is Lost Potential....


Spitfire
03-30-2007, 10:47 PM
I read the prequel comics based off the film, and I gota say it makes me 2nd guess the movie.

In Mikey's it's very kid-ish and I can see it matching the film well. Raph's on the other and was very off beat.

It was dark and very violent. They were throwing ninja stars into people, killing people, Raph throws his Sai into someone and in one part Raph impales someone with his Sai.

Also The man who gives Raph his Nightwatcher costume gets shot and is bleeding everywhere and Raph tracks the men down and murders them
Makes me think the movie should have been PG-13. I mean if those comics were intended to be prequels to the movie then any kid who saw them after enjoying the film would probably want to read them, and if they can read these violent comics they can handle it in the movie.

Anyone else get the same feeling?

Roseangelo
03-30-2007, 10:51 PM
Anyone else get the same feeling?

No, can't say that I did.

Spitfire
03-30-2007, 10:53 PM
For some reason after reading that comic it just made me rethink the movie and how they seriously toned the violence factor down. I bet all the stuff they did cut out of it to make it 80 minutes was mostly fight scenes. The end seriously lacked some epicness in terms of a last battle.

Fledermaus
03-30-2007, 10:53 PM
hmmm... now I think I'll go buy the prequel comics. Impalement is fun...:evilgrin:

Spitfire
03-30-2007, 10:54 PM
hmmm... now I think I'll go buy the prequel comics. Impalement is fun...:evilgrin:

Their cool, the art sucks in my opinion but their defiantly cool stories and help with the movie.

Fledermaus
03-30-2007, 10:58 PM
Amazon doesn't seem to have em... :( Where'd you get yours?

Waitaminnit... Jim Lawson? I can't stand his stuff any more.:dead:

Well, if the stories are good... sure why not? :ohwell:

Spitfire
03-30-2007, 11:06 PM
Amazon doesn't seem to have em... :( Where'd you get yours?

Waitaminnit... Jim Lawson? I can't stand his stuff any more.:dead:

Well, if the stories are good... sure why not? :ohwell:

It's not done in Lawson's ass style though. It lacks detail in some parts but it holds the shape of the new movie.

I got mine at a comic shop next door to where my friend works. Well he got them there, he had bought them and he gave them to me because he read them already. But that's where I get my TMNT comics, because the store by me sucks and doesn't carry them.

The Shelf
03-30-2007, 11:11 PM
Waitaminnit... Jim Lawson? I can't stand his stuff any more.:dead:

Well, if it makes you feel any better, he's only doing the Raphael issue. He's not part of any of the others, I don't think. On top of that, I couldn't tell that he had anything to do with even the Raphael issue. It doesn't look like his style at all. Personally, I don't understand why everyone hates his art so much. I love the way he draws the turtles in Volume 4. A lot of people seem to dislike the angular look of the humans, but it doesn't bother me. The only complaint I've ever had is in a couple issues he has one or two of the humans doing the chameleon thing with their eyes. In one close-up of April, one of her eyes was looking straight while the other one was looking slightly down. It annoyed me, but other than that, I've had no complaints.

Galactus
03-30-2007, 11:12 PM
I suppose we could have had a PG-13 film but then the movie wouldn't have been #1 at the US Box Office or be making any kind of a profit. We're better off with were we are now.

Spitfire
03-30-2007, 11:14 PM
I suppose we could have had a PG-13 film but then the movie wouldn't have been #1 at the US Box Office or be making any kind of a profit.

Doubtful, the main pull for TMNT is teens and adults. They make cash off kids to but I mostly see adults buying the figures and comics. And mostly teens watch the show*It's popular in high schools around here* and I see them buying the DVDs most of the time.

And when I see 90 10 year olds in 300 I start to think plenty of kids would go see a PG-13 turtles movie too.

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
03-30-2007, 11:29 PM
I agree a pg-13 would have done just as well, if not better at the box office. PG-13 seems to be the ideal rating for a lot of studios. And what I mean by 'if not better'...well maybe the extra jump in rating could have made a little bit more jolt in the storyline and got people even more talking/telling their friends.

Wow Spitfire the Raphael comic had killings?!? Weird how a prequel comic based on the movie is THAT more violent than the flick itself...but sounds very cool indeed :D
Too bad the movie wasn't more of that...although it would split a lot of people. Nice to hear bout that comic though Spitfire, thanks.

iris
03-30-2007, 11:39 PM
You fellas sure love it when Raphael impales things.

Roseangelo
03-30-2007, 11:40 PM
Adding more violence into a movie just for the sake of more violence doesn't necessarily make for a better movie.

Spitfire
03-30-2007, 11:43 PM
Adding more violence into a movie just for the sake of more violence doesn't necessarily make for a better movie.

No but it makes it more entertaining and I bet less people would say it was "boring" which is what 90% of the critics who gave it a poor review said the problem with it was.

It was 80 minutes, felt like 2 hours, and had the poorest excuse for a last battle I've ever seen in a movie.

Adding enough fighting to make it PG-13 would have been genius. PG-13 is the ultimate rating. It can have the darkness to be R rated but not enough swearing and violence so kids can still go see it. It's perfect.

Fledermaus
03-30-2007, 11:47 PM
You fellas sure love it when Raphael impales things.

Who doesn't?!:evilgrin: Those sais look pokey for a REASON!

Adding more violence into a movie just for the sake of more violence doesn't necessarily make for a better movie.

Well... depends what you think is better. I think a teense bit more violence, somewhat longer fight scenes would have made this movie... I dunno. I'd have liked it more.

Man... wouldn't that be PERFECT if the director could release some (original?) version of the movie... maybe added back essential stuff, cool fights and whatnot... all the stuff he had to take out to make it a PG movie.

I think I'd melt...:evilgrin:

iris
03-30-2007, 11:48 PM
Well, it wasn't boring for lack of violence. The editing disobeyed the "make me care" rule of filmmaking. People who already cared about TMNT liked the movie. Most of the people who didn't, didn't see the point. What would have made the biggest difference was emphasizing the danger posed by the enemy, an aspect which got like two minutes out of the whole movie.

iris
03-30-2007, 11:49 PM
Who doesn't?!:evilgrin: Those sais look pokey for a REASON!

Man... wouldn't that be PERFECT if the director could release some (original?) version of the movie... maybe added back essential stuff, cool fights and whatnot... all the stuff he had to take out to make it a PG movie.

I think I'd melt...:evilgrin:
*covers her innocent young eyes and cloises thread blainndly&*

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
03-30-2007, 11:51 PM
Yes violence can be very fun and entertaining :D

And if I saw a big walking talking turtle with a sai impale someone....boring would be the last words coming out of my mouth hehe.

But I also understand what you are saying Roseangelo. If there was more violence it would be better if there was meaning behind it...like giving Raphael more personal demons to fight, or giving Leo even more of a reason to go after and try to stop the Nightwatcher. To be against how he does things. Violence can be a great dramatic anchor.

Spitfire
03-30-2007, 11:52 PM
Yeah that to, but I'm male. And me being male means I have an unexplainable desire to see people get the crap kicked out of one another or to see people get stabbed and decapitated. I can't help it, I can't understand, it's just there.

And that need for violence always drives me to point out when a movie doesn't contain enough of it. Only one movie has ever contained so much it began to bore me and that was 300. But other then that violence always entertains me. And seeing the TMNT kick the crap out of some Foot Soldiers is what I want to see. But do I see that? No I see them fight the Foot for a minute to a POD song. A scene I saw before I even saw the movie as a preview.

Fledermaus
03-30-2007, 11:55 PM
Well, it wasn't boring for lack of violence. The editing disobeyed the "make me care" rule of filmmaking. People who already cared about TMNT liked the movie. Most of the people who didn't, didn't see the point. What would have made the biggest difference was emphasizing the danger posed by the enemy, an aspect which got like two minutes out of the whole movie.

Very true. I've already said a countless number times what the movie lacked. But one of its strengths WAS its being edgier than past movies. For me, action has a pretty big role in TMNT. I love watching the turtles getting beat up and beating each other up and just... fighting. YEAH!!! :evilgrin:

To make the movie great (that is, accessible to people besides TMNT fans) they'd need to go back to the beginning and fix the freakin plot, re-cut, re-edit a LOT of things. I think it's unrealistic to expect that kind of improvement for a DVD release of the movie.

But yes... the fights are SO important...

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
03-30-2007, 11:57 PM
I can't say I felt anything like that.

iris
03-31-2007, 12:12 AM
To make the movie great (that is, accessible to people besides TMNT fans) they'd need to go back to the beginning and fix the freakin plot, re-cut, re-edit a LOT of things. I think it's unrealistic to expect that kind of improvement for a DVD release of the movie.

Really? I don't think it needs that much work. Just a few reminders of that whole "evil army threatening to emerge from the depths of hell" plot point that I completely forgot about during two viewings of the movie.

Not that I expect that on the DVD either. I'd certainly settle for a few more fight scenes. ;)

Hyper Metal Sonic
03-31-2007, 12:15 AM
So, any recommendations on where I can find said comic books?

Fledermaus
03-31-2007, 12:20 AM
So, any recommendations on where I can find said comic books?

Maybe the local comic book store will have them. Maybe it won't. You could trust whatever random assortment of comic book retailers exist online. I have no idea who to recommend. And of course, there's ebay.

I really wish I could just order it from the publishers, but I didn't see a single movie comic on the official TMNT website.

Hyper Metal Sonic
03-31-2007, 12:25 AM
Well I can think of only one comic book shop in the area and I don't think I've ever seen TMNT anything there...though I've only been there once.

Spitfire
03-31-2007, 12:28 AM
I had to find a shop that special orders stuff. They have them regularly since the movie was announced.

Ninja Tiptup
03-31-2007, 12:39 AM
Spitfire, you and I both know the only people that would know where to find or care about the prequel comics would be OG TMNT fans. From the 80s or at least 90s. The kids had other promotional deals like McD's (by the way the Leonardo toy is the best McD's toy I've seen since the 90s good detail and he slashes his sword!) and toy sales stuff.

I believe I heard if they got a sequel they'd get a PG-13 rating. I don't think PG-13 would have improved this movie at all. What would it accomplish? Better fights? Leo VS Raph was amazing. I agree the ending fight was pretty pathetic but adding more violence would not have improved it. If you want violence you have to have a story that suits that violence. Something like City at War or Return to New York (which btw would be GREAT sequels for this movie). The plot in this movie was about fighting monsters and devided families. How would that lend itself to more violence much less bloody violence? It was a good family film that had more moral fiber than any previous TMNT movie IMO. I don't consider that a bad thing but I would like to see a PG-13 TMNT some day.

I know you want TMNT to be respected like other comic icons or at least like Hellboy (with TV-14-V animated films and such) but TMNT has found a notable success with children in several generations now and the concept lends itself well to childrens entertainment. Mirage TMNT series 1 is freak'n great but something on that level will probably never happen at least as far as aiming for the mainstream. The most you can hope for is for TMNT to die out with children audience entirely and if that doesn't sink the franchise entirely then there might be a slim possibility of niche TMNT products (say a TV-14-V animated movie like Hellboy just got) for the hardcore fans.

You're not going to get that from TMNT yet though so stop dog'n on things that don't suit your ideal of what TMNT should be. You know some people didn't even read Mirage TMNT and they think the 4kids show was terrible compared to the 80s cartoon (oh the misguided fools). But their image of TMNT is no less genuine than yours or mine. So please give it a rest you're only frustrating yourself for no reason.

Fledermaus
03-31-2007, 12:41 AM
.............. But I don't really care about any version of TMNT except for the one I think is coolest......

Yeah. Definitely goin' to bed. Someone attack me if I write another pointless post. :P

Spitfire
03-31-2007, 12:46 AM
The plot in this movie was about fighting monsters

This sums up my point, fighting monsters. Which they didn't do hardly at all in the movie.

I don't want more violence persay. I want more action. That would be the proper word. No I don't expect Raph to impale people with his sais in the movie. But I do expect some more or longer fights. The story was there but all the action felt like it was missing. It was there just lacking.

As for kids getting the comics, there's a comic chain called Legends and I'm not sure if they have them in your areas, but local malls have them and there are kids in there all the time. They have the TMNT prequels right next to the register on display. So saying kids won't get their hands on them is pretty far off.

Mr. Stay Puft
03-31-2007, 01:17 AM
And that need for violence always drives me to point out when a movie doesn't contain enough of it.

Kind of off subject, but a perfect example of that is The Hills Have Eyes 2. I went in expecting something gorier and more disturbing than the first, but instead, I got a 2 hour yawnfest. Needless to say, I was disappointed.

poobone
03-31-2007, 01:43 AM
wated potential.... um, no. I'd like to see a PG-13 turtles movie, but I know that realistically it will never happen.

Willis
03-31-2007, 03:35 AM
This is one of the epic downfalls of Animated Series's.. They never grow up. Even though other media's and the true die-hard fans DO grow up.

Now this does not mean gore, or adult content. But a more serious outlook on crime and "justice" would be appreciated.

This is the TEENAGE mutant ninja turtles. When growing up I didn't know of one teenager who hasn't seen violence, sworn, or lacked the impulsive urge for revenge.

Yeah that to, but I'm male. And me being male means I have an unexplainable desire to see people get the crap kicked out of one another or to see people get stabbed and decapitated. I can't help it, I can't understand, it's just there.

*raises hand*.. Guilty! :lol:

Warhorse
03-31-2007, 04:01 AM
The post starte now has me wanting to look for these prequel comics, and this sucks, because the Turtles are in high demand around here, but shortly stocked in the comic book stores.

But I agree with the people who think this movie would have faired better being a PG-13. Most of the people in the theater are of the late teens, twentiesh crowd. I don't want a blood bath, but it would be nice to see the Turtles less restricted in showing their weapons. It's kind of one of their signatures.

And I really wanted to see Leo fight that guerilla in Middle America, not just hear it. We got to see good introduction of Mikey, Don and certaintly Raph (not that I'm complaining, because Raph's my favorite) but Leo could have had a more dynamic impact in the beginning by showing him fight the warlord.

Seiza
03-31-2007, 07:11 AM
And I really wanted to see Leo fight that guerilla in Middle America, not just hear it. We got to see good introduction of Mikey, Don and certaintly Raph (not that I'm complaining, because Raph's my favorite) but Leo could have had a more dynamic impact in the beginning by showing him fight the warlord.
I thought it was a pretty good intro. We actually got to see some ninja-y techniques on Leo's part (okay, so it was just a log and a rope... certainly no Sexy no Jutsu, still... it's the idea of using the surroundings to his advantage *cough*). The warlord didn't look threatening, so I doubt the fight would've been all that impressive to watch. What the scene left unsaid was pretty cool.

I was happy with the earlier fight scenes, even the length. Get in and get out liek teh ninjaz. But the final battle really could've used some extra time, if only to give the turtles a little bit more trouble with the Generals. The way it panned out, it looked like smooth sailing right up to Casey and April's return. :|

'Course, I'd never say no to more fights. :D

Aignatius
03-31-2007, 10:09 AM
Raph impaling people is certainly nothing new. That is if you've read the Mirage comics from the early 80s.

Seems people out there (at least those who have complained about the turtles being too violent) forget that the turtles are not the ones who initiate the violence, the violence is brought upon them and they deal with it in ways they deem appropriate.
I'd have a problem with Turtles going out and looking for fights... well, other than Raph... but there's always some sort of lesson from vigilantism.

Raph is the only turtle featured in Bodycount, which is a comic filled with violence to epic Heavy Metal proportions. Can't imagine why, since Kevin Eastman and Simon Bisley did that series. :D

Let's just say... the TMNT have never been pro-violence, per se.

The Shelf
03-31-2007, 10:43 AM
Raph impaling people is certainly nothing new. That is if you've read the Mirage comics from the early 80s.

Seems people out there (at least those who have complained about the turtles being too violent) forget that the turtles are not the ones who initiate the violence, the violence is brought upon them and they deal with it in ways they deem appropriate.
I'd have a problem with Turtles going out and looking for fights... well, other than Raph... but there's always some sort of lesson from vigilantism.

Raph is the only turtle featured in Bodycount, which is a comic filled with violence to epic Heavy Metal proportions. Can't imagine why, since Kevin Eastman and Simon Bisley did that series. :D

Let's just say... the TMNT have never been pro-violence, per se.

I agree. When people told me that the comics were way more violent than the cartoons, I always imagined the turtles running out and murdering people just for the heck of it, but the comics really aren't that violent. Yeah, they'll kill bad guys, but they'd never hurt a fly otherwise, er, well, you know what I mean.

Mr. Snackpants
03-31-2007, 11:14 AM
Doubtful, the main pull for TMNT is teens and adults. They make cash off kids to but I mostly see adults buying the figures and comics. And mostly teens watch the show*It's popular in high schools around here* and I see them buying the DVDs most of the time.

And when I see 90 10 year olds in 300 I start to think plenty of kids would go see a PG-13 turtles movie too.

This is why I thought it would be a good time for a more mature tmnt. The new cartoon introduced the tmnt to a new generation, but it wasn't even close to the "hugeness" of the '80's cartoon. The fans of the old cartoons are now teens and young adults. So the major fanbase are older and more mature now...why not make a more mature tmnt? A pg-13 tmnt is my dream, I want to see more serious, ninja combat :D .

Like you said, there were young kids at 300. There were 8-9 year olds at Blades of Glory last night. A pg-13 rating would not hurt sales, if anything it would improve them.

Youal
03-31-2007, 12:00 PM
I'm pretty sure there were more violence in the movie but it was cut down to get an PG rating. If you watch the futurette video, there is a split second of Donnie is about to whack the big hammer guy with his bo right after he poke his feet. That part wasn't in the movie. Mikey using his nunchucks were not shown, the cameral would move away from him to hide it.

Willis
03-31-2007, 03:37 PM
Mikey using his nunchucks were not shown, the cameral would move away from him to hide it.

Alright, I can respect the fact that some nations in the world hate the nunchucks. But I don't get why in this modern-age world why everyone else needs to suffer. They need to grow up and understand it's just a TV show / Movie.

When it comes to movie length and rating (which defines content), who has the final say-so?

Mr. Snackpants
03-31-2007, 04:48 PM
Alright, I can respect the fact that some nations in the world hate the nunchucks. But I don't get why in this modern-age world why everyone else needs to suffer. They need to grow up and understand it's just a TV show / Movie.

When it comes to movie length and rating (which defines content), who has the final say-so?

Yeah and just because it doesn't show the nunchucks making contact with the bad guys doesn't mean squat. You see him twirling them around and you see the result. Even someone with half a brain knows what happened. It's just pointless censorship.

Raph'N'Roll
03-31-2007, 07:23 PM
Yeah I agree Spitfire, the movie is lost potential.
People I work with didn't like the movie at all, they were fans as kids, and they didn't know what to expect from it.
They all thought the monster story was ridiculous/messy, and the fact that Leo didn't know Raph was the Nightwatcher didn't make any sense(I really hated that, and was bewildered, it had more of an emotional impact if Leo did know, and that he went out to get Raph back in the team)
Before I actually seen this movie, I was fantasizing that this would be the TMNT movie that would make all my TMNT doubting friends wake up and take the Turtles seriously, and for them to think that this was a bad ass movie that they would watch again.
I was so looking forward to this movie, and now that I've seen it, I'm disappointed.
I hope there is a sequel, but it'll only work if Kevin Munroe learns from his mistakes, because there's some dreadful pacing issues, and lost potential fight scenes.
Who knows though, as far as the main stream media are concerned the Turtles are still kiddie fodder, and no movie has yet to change that.

Nightwatcher
03-31-2007, 09:01 PM
I do think the last fight with the generals did seem a tad too *easy* for the turtles. I mean the generals just take it to the monsters and they don't even hit the turtles once? Doesn't really make sense. My friend said he wished the generals would have turned to mortals after the portal closed with all the monsters and then the turtles could have fought them, which would have been cool. The ending would have been pretty different though.

Lastly I think they could have done with less monsters. Especially considering some got no backstory and about 5 seconds of screentime. I think they could have cut it down to about 7 or 8 and maybe it wouldn't have felt like that part of the plot was so tacked on in certain areas.

Raph'N'Roll
03-31-2007, 09:07 PM
Nightwatcher: I do think the last fight with the generals did seem a tad too *easy* for the turtles. I mean the generals just take it to the monsters and they don't even hit the turtles once?

I agree, it seemed like the Turtles were just going through the motions, the Generals represented no threat at all in my opinion, and the end was predictable and obvious.

ToTheNines
03-31-2007, 09:27 PM
Well, General Aguilla says "We're going to enjoy this". This suggests that they were just toying with the TMNT, they really had no reason to kill them and they are immortals so when they fight it dosen't need to be taken seriously. Now that I bring this up, I realize they actually shouldn't have fought at all, instead they should have went after the Foot, CJ, and April.