View Full Version : Donatello - awesome in the new film
jenna
04-12-2007, 05:22 PM
Hey guys
I'm going to bed now but wanted to start this topic to discuss good old Don... and then I can read all your comments tomorrow (time zones, blah) ;)
Did anyone else think that new movie Don was reminiscent of 1987 toon Don? He seemed to have a similar intolerance to others who are less gifted in the intelligence area about him. He was certainly more commanding ("Out of my way, please!") and a bit snappier than 2k3 toon Don (who is very gentle and unconfrontational).
On top of this I really loved how his whole character came across, like he was impatient... like he is so bored with IT support that he just isn't intellectually stimulated anymore. Then of course he got a chance to be doctor / scientist and came to life.
It only really just crossed my mind and I was interested what everyone else thought.
Well, good night.:sleep:
CyberCubed
04-12-2007, 05:27 PM
My thoughts on Don in the new film was that there wasn't enough of him to judge. He seemed to start off with a role equal to the other Turtles but as the movie went on it seemed like they just forgot about him.
In all honesty I thought all the Turtles were portrayed very well so Don came across as really well done, both in terms of voice and personality. The problem is we barely saw him, even in the fight scenes they focused more on Leo/Raph than Don or Mike.
If there is a sequal Don better have a bigger role.
It kind of reminds me of TMNT 1, y'know? Don's role in that movie was relatively small as well (compared to the whole Leo/Raph thing), but then in TMNT 2 Don's role was much bigger, and he had a huge part with the whole TCRI thing and the Professor. I especially liked Donny being disappointed that they were an "accident" which is IMO one of the best parts of the second movie.
Cascadia
04-12-2007, 05:35 PM
We did not see much of him in the movie. But he was definitely snappy at Raph at the beginning.
triplexxx
04-12-2007, 05:37 PM
Well, I think there was enough of Donatello to get a good exploration of his character, and jenna pretty much summed it up. Not to mention, I thought his dialog was pretty interesting and catchy and it really caught the eye:
*"This as Winter's name written all over it."....how do you figure?....yeah?........"Because THIS has Winter's name written all over it"
*it looked like your mom dude......"Yeah that would make her your mom too, doofus."
*"Within hours we'll lose the city, within days the country, and within weeks...the world."
Swany
04-12-2007, 05:41 PM
I was gutted there wasn't very much Donnie in the movie. There was oppertunities for more of him in the movie though. There was obvious conflict between him and Raph. Aslo being the second oldest (?) he had to act as oldest brother while Leo was away and me most mature, probably the reason why he felt he and Mikey had to get jobs to contribute to the family. (I hope im correct in assuming their ages)
There was few wee bits though, although he had few lines, there was little things like expressions and gestures.
Cascadia
04-12-2007, 05:43 PM
well, according to the creators, Donnie is the 2nd oldest. Mikey is the youngest.
Avatar Yuffie
04-12-2007, 06:24 PM
Well he just doesn't have enough screentime. Even the fight scenes doesn't feature him much.
But of all the Turtles, Don is my favorite, so I like the part that he was being impatient by Raph... heck I'm surprised they even had a confrontational interaction at the start of the movie. We could really see he was struggling to be the big brother after Leo, but can't shake the feeling he's failing miserably, since he's easily intimidated.
Well I can only hope he and Mikey gets some attention in the future.
Jo Dawn
04-12-2007, 10:52 PM
Did anyone else think that new movie Don was reminiscent of 1987 toon Don?
Not at all. I loved this Don. Completely different.
well, according to the creators, Donnie is the 2nd oldest. Mikey is the youngest.
Indeed.
And as for the thread title... Well, of course Don was awesome in the movie (though they needed more of him... More!). He is Don, of course. ;)
Shark_Blade
04-12-2007, 11:16 PM
Yeah, I would to see more of Don and Mikey in the cgi movie dvd soon (and Mikey fight scenes better be in it too, I was gutted his weapons were cut out from the movie because of silly stupid law):(
ToTheNines
04-13-2007, 09:06 AM
Mike DID use his chucks, I wish everyone would quit sayin they got cut out.
Revan
04-13-2007, 09:40 AM
^ Yes they were in the film but we did not get to see them in all of their whirling fury.
I thought the way Don was portrayed in the movie was unfair. It made him seem like a wet blanket. :ohwell:
You thought he was like OT Don? I don't see it. But I did think he was great in this flick. I never caught myself thinking about whether anything was in-character, and I'm usually more critical of that in Donatello.
I also liked Splinter's little lecture to him about being strong. That was awesome. I think Mike was the only one who didn't get a lecture!
I thought the way Don was portrayed in the movie was unfair. It made him seem like a wet blanket. :ohwell:
Oh gobo, don't be such a stick in the mud! :x :ohwell: :lol:
jenna
04-13-2007, 03:07 PM
You thought he was like OT Don? I don't see it. But I did think he was great in this flick. I never caught myself thinking about whether anything was in-character, and I'm usually more critical of that in Donatello.
I didn't think he was the same as OT Don, merely that there were moments of reminiscence. Don was very much his own character in this film (all of the turtles were, rather than replicas of previous incarnations, but yet not out of character) and I liked him more and more the more I saw it... a lot of mores in that sentence... I found him to have more depth on further viewings and one of those elements reminded me of OT Don.
Shark_Blade
04-13-2007, 03:22 PM
Mike DID use his chucks, I wish everyone would quit sayin they got cut out.:roll:yes mommy.
Anyway Mike didn't use it to it's full potential. Even his screen time for action is very short compared to other turtles.
Sage Ninja
04-15-2007, 02:04 AM
Hey guys
I'm going to bed now but wanted to start this topic to discuss good old Don... and then I can read all your comments tomorrow (time zones, blah) ;)
Did anyone else think that new movie Don was reminiscent of 1987 toon Don? He seemed to have a similar intolerance to others who are less gifted in the intelligence area about him. He was certainly more commanding ("Out of my way, please!") and a bit snappier than 2k3 toon Don (who is very gentle and unconfrontational).
On top of this I really loved how his whole character came across, like he was impatient... like he is so bored with IT support that he just isn't intellectually stimulated anymore. Then of course he got a chance to be doctor / scientist and came to life.
It only really just crossed my mind and I was interested what everyone else thought.
Well, good night.:sleep:
I agree, I really loved his portrayal in this movie. I think the movie-universe finnally got it right with Donatello this time around. they didn't put in any added character adaptors in order to sell his character and kept him true to his intelligent personality. I was all around very pleased with his character.
I also liked his some what smart-ass like personality. :D He wasn't so soft spoken that he didn't voice his thoughts and I completely ate up his little banter with Raphael. They just seemed so at odds with each other personality-wise that they played off each well. I hope to see more of that in any future sequels :)
I just hope that if we get a sequal that he gets more screen time and is fleshed out more. As much as I liked what I saw I would have liked to see a bit more of him.
Seiza
04-15-2007, 02:33 AM
^Ah, "smart-ass"! Yep, I was looking for the word to describe this Donatello. Especially during his bit with Raph, he sounded every bit the "smart-ass-I'm-a-genius-and-I-know-it" type. Not completely big-headed or proud, of course, but... when someone's a genius, no use beating around the bush about it.
He was certainly more commanding ("Out of my way, please!")
And yet polite enough to use "please". :D
Sage Ninja
04-15-2007, 02:49 AM
he sounded down right disdainful during his spat with Raphael. His whole demeaner was just lofty superiority and disapproval when he was talking to Raphael.You could just hear it in his voice, that he was fed-up with Raphael's antics. I also liked that Don and Raph seemed to not like each other too much, and seemed to try to provoke each other a little:D loved Donatello's:
"Well I know your temper and rogue attitude has always been a source of contention to this team" LOL , I just love the words he uses, like he is purposely useing words he knows Raphael might not understand to talk down to him.
Seriously they got to have more Don and Raph banter like this in any supposed sequals. I think setting up their very diffrent persoanlites could make for some good love/hate character interaction between the two.
Sewer Bull
04-15-2007, 02:52 AM
Seriously they got to have more Don and Raph banter like this in any supposed sequals. I think setting up their very diffrent persoanlites could make for some good love/hate character interaction between the two.
Amen to that. There was definitely not enough Don-Raph interaction in this movie. And it all looked so promising in the beginning
Swany
04-15-2007, 02:47 PM
After the talk with Splinter. Everything just seemed resolved. "Be strong when they rare weak" then that was it. No more Donnie!
I feel there was a few parts where Don could have done/said more, maybe.
Warhorse
04-15-2007, 03:22 PM
he sounded down right disdainful during his spat with Raphael. His whole demeaner was just lofty superiority and disapproval when he was talking to Raphael.You could just hear it in his voice, that he was fed-up with Raphael's antics. I also liked that Don and Raph seemed to not like each other too much, and seemed to try to provoke each other a little:D loved Donatello's:
"Well I know your temper and rogue attitude has always been a source of contention to this team" LOL , I just love the words he uses, like he is purposely useing words he knows Raphael might not understand to talk down to him.
Seriously they got to have more Don and Raph banter like this in any supposed sequals. I think setting up their very diffrent persoanlites could make for some good love/hate character interaction between the two.
Yep, agree with you here. Donny and Raph are such opposites, it's just an attraction to watch them interract when they do. (Kind of like watching the team work displayed between the two on the FF episode this weekend!)
Cascadia
04-15-2007, 10:58 PM
Yep, agree with you here. Donny and Raph are such opposites, it's just an attraction to watch them interract when they do. (Kind of like watching the team work displayed between the two on the FF episode this weekend!)
Much agreed....we never really got that kind of interactions between them in the original movies.
Spitfire
04-16-2007, 12:40 AM
And as for the thread title... Well, of course Don was awesome in the movie (though they needed more of him... More!). He is Don, of course. ;)
Exactly, but if they make a sequel I'm sure it won't be so Leo and Raph focused. They already sorta "did" that. So yeah we can hope for more Don.
But even if Don is my favorite TMNT Raph and Leo are the main characters of the universe and that's not going to change.
Tinuvielsdreams
04-16-2007, 08:37 AM
Don had a nice background moment here and there...
I really like his bo twirling during the roof conversation when he Mikey is hanging upside down and Leo is talking about getting in shape.
Answering the phone for the Cowabunga Carl party line...
They definitely let his personality shine in the explanation of the stone in Raph's shell and the dart from his arm, and then in the lair he explained the star alignment theory.
When he over the big brother role with Raph at the beginning, he was very much like a Leo using big words...lol
True they didn't show him all that much but when they did they showed him well I thought
Spawn Guy
04-16-2007, 08:58 AM
I like this version of Don mainly because that is how I write him.
Tinuvielsdreams
04-16-2007, 09:02 AM
Yeah I see him being kinda snappy and definitely witty,
I love how you write Spawn Guy :D
Jo Dawn
04-16-2007, 10:41 AM
True they didn't show him all that much but when they did they showed him well I thought
Very true. What they did show was perfect... So much so they have us clamoring for more!
Now... Isn't that the sign of a good writer and actor (as it were)? ;)
jenna
04-16-2007, 01:11 PM
I like this version of Don mainly because that is how I write him.
Ooh, you write stuff? is it available online for us to read?
he sounded down right disdainful during his spat with Raphael. His whole demeaner was just lofty superiority and disapproval when he was talking to Raphael.You could just hear it in his voice, that he was fed-up with Raphael's antics. I also liked that Don and Raph seemed to not like each other too much, and seemed to try to provoke each other a little:D loved Donatello's:
"Well I know your temper and rogue attitude has always been a source of contention to this team" LOL , I just love the words he uses, like he is purposely useing words he knows Raphael might not understand to talk down to him.
Seriously they got to have more Don and Raph banter like this in any supposed sequals. I think setting up their very diffrent persoanlites could make for some good love/hate character interaction between the two.
Well, I don't think Don was using big words on purpose; those are normal words to him. But the calm, matter-of-fact pronouncement was definitely calculated. I'm sure Raph would much prefer if Don yelled and took a swing at him instead of dissecting the underlying themes of their family history. Raph doesn't know how to win that kind of fight. And Don knows it. :evilgrin:
They don't understand each other most of the time. But as much as they disagree, they're unable to strike hard at each other's weaknesses. Don isn't that moved if he loses a sparring match to Raph, and Raph isn't that moved if he loses a debate to Donnie. So you never know quite how their interaction will go. And it's fascinating. To me, anyway. :embarass:
The Don-Raph spat could have been, move for move, a fight between me and my brother a few years ago, when we were that age. It was exceedingly well-written, from Don's supercilious attitude to Raph's attempt to use physical intimidation as a trump card.
Not to mention the resulting draw:
Raph: *self-satisfied smirk*
Don: "That doesn't prove anything!"
So very perfect. :lol:
Tinuvielsdreams
04-16-2007, 05:09 PM
Very true. What they did show was perfect... So much so they have us clamoring for more!
Now... Isn't that the sign of a good writer and actor (as it were)? ;)
Yes it is, I can't say enough about the acting, and I definitely wanted more!
MoreCowbell5263
04-21-2007, 09:25 PM
WOW, I was complaining a lot about how ripped off Don was for screentime in this, but you guys have made some really great points! Donny was perfect in every scene! He was portrayed fantastically by Mitchell Whitfield, and his personality was pure, 100% Don. Especially at times like
"Get out of my way, please!"
Pure Don, he has something that needs to get done, but can't just push Raph out of the way without being somewhat polite, Pure Don.
You guys have made me feel a lot better about Don in this movie, Don being my favorite Turtle. And I would love a sequel with more of him in it. Everything he did was perfect according to Don, I loved every second of him in this movie, and I have you guys to thank!
triplexxx
04-21-2007, 09:38 PM
See, Donatello got his chance to shine in the movie too. His fighting skills top-notch, and his personality a perfect fit.
Rooish
04-21-2007, 10:02 PM
Not to mention the resulting draw:
Raph: *self-satisfied smirk*
Don: "That doesn't prove anything!"
So very perfect. :lol:
Aw, I was disappointed there. I thought Don lost because he couldn't think of a snappy enough comeback. He was doing petty damn well against Raphael until then. At any rate, it's definitely my favourite portrayal of Don ever.
jenna
04-22-2007, 09:51 AM
At any rate, it's definitely my favourite portrayal of Don ever.
Me too. The perfect balance of various different character traits we have seen over the years. Just came back from watching the film for the 7th time (ouch!!) and paid a lot more attention to Don when he was in the back ground this time. He is consistently fascinating to watch. Just because Raph and Leo are the focus doesn't mean Don is doing something interesting behind them.
Aw, I was disappointed there. I thought Don lost because he couldn't think of a snappy enough comeback. He was doing petty damn well against Raphael until then.
I think most people would agree with you. But if you look at it from Don's POV, either nobody won or Don had an edge because Raphael's "point" was more of a non sequitor than something that could prove Don wrong. All I'm saying is that nobody's ever going to win a fight where the participants have completely disparate definitions of what it means to win.
MoreCowbell5263
04-22-2007, 12:04 PM
I have a question, I brought this up on imdb and got a few responses, but a lot of the replies seemed blinded by their die-hard fandom of one individual turtle rather than trying to prove the best case scenario.
Who is the second in command? Like, if something were to happen to Leo, and Leo either died or was incapacitated or just left them, who would take over as the new leader, or who would make a better leader?
I ask this because I noticed at the beginning, Leo says, "Donnie's probably got everything under control" which kinda sounded to me like Leo sees Donny as kinda his replacement or second in command or next most responsible person. But near the end of the movie, Raph seemed to take over in the plan to get their brother back. I agree Raph has a lot of good qualities, but I just think, and I'm trying my best not to be bias because I like Don, but Don just seems the more logical (pardon the pun) choice for the next leader. I'd really like to see a situation in a future sequel (not necessarily the next one) where someone has to take over as the new Leo and see how they fare. There was an episode from the old cartoon where Leo left because he was questioning his instincts, and the other three took turns being the leader, and they all had problems where Leo was strong in, it's one of my favorite episodes. Anyway, I know it's off-topic, but I thought I'd hear opinions from people on a Ninja Turtles website.
Warhorse
04-22-2007, 12:12 PM
I have a question, I brought this up on imdb and got a few responses, but a lot of the replies seemed blinded by their die-hard fandom of one individual turtle rather than trying to prove the best case scenario.
Who is the second in command? Like, if something were to happen to Leo, and Leo either died or was incapacitated or just left them, who would take over as the new leader, or who would make a better leader?
I ask this because I noticed at the beginning, Leo says, "Donnie's probably got everything under control" which kinda sounded to me like Leo sees Donny as kinda his replacement or second in command or next most responsible person. But near the end of the movie, Raph seemed to take over in the plan to get their brother back. I agree Raph has a lot of good qualities, but I just think, and I'm trying my best not to be bias because I like Don, but Don just seems the more logical (pardon the pun) choice for the next leader. I'd really like to see a situation in a future sequel (not necessarily the next one) where someone has to take over as the new Leo and see how they fare. There was an episode from the old cartoon where Leo left because he was questioning his instincts, and the other three took turns being the leader, and they all had problems where Leo was strong in, it's one of my favorite episodes. Anyway, I know it's off-topic, but I thought I'd hear opinions from people on a Ninja Turtles website.
While Don would be the most logical choice, Raph's personality would be more fitting of a leader type. This is my opinion though. Donny's personality is just far more passive than Leo's and Raph's, more aggessive nature, and I have seen the aggressor's lead over the passive. It's jsut the way commanding circles work, I guess.
Cascadia
04-22-2007, 12:14 PM
Donnie is much too passive to take over in a leader's position. Raph can be a leader if he does not let his temper get in the way.
triplexxx
04-22-2007, 12:16 PM
The thing about the leadership position is it can't really be occupied by one alone. Leonardo generally leads, but he depends on Raphael's strength and Donatello's smarts, and Michaelangelo's speed in order to carry out his strategy. Raphael and Donatello, strength and smarts, would make a good combination for leadership. I'd say they about tie for second-in-command. In that OT episode "Take Me to Your Leader", Donatello and Michaelangelo actually showed they could be pretty decent leaders. There have been a decent amount of times in the OT and NT when Donatello needed to be the one to come up with the strategy. In "Touch and Go" and "Nobody's Fool", Michaelangelo led in the fight against touch and go, but required a partner, Splinter and Leonardo, respectively, to carry the plan out. Leadership isn't really effective when performed alone.
The bottom line is: they couldn't have decent leadership or function properly unless all four are together.
Cascadia
04-22-2007, 12:20 PM
So, what you are saying is that they are weak when alone but strong when they are together.
triplexxx
04-22-2007, 12:25 PM
So, what you are saying is that they are weak when alone but strong when they are together.
That's the way the movie and that OT episode "Splinter Vanishes" showed it to be.
MoreCowbell5263
04-22-2007, 12:31 PM
There were a lot of people that saw one way or the other, but after a while, people started saying that probably the best solution was if Don and Raph had like equal power in leading, which made me feel bad for Mikey. But the idea was that Leo is basically a good mixture of both Raph and Don, he somehow managed to get a blend of their personalities yet without their flaws. He thinks things over and doesn't just go straight into a fight without a plan (Don), yet he's very brave and doesn't always try to talk things over without fighting (Raph). At the same time, he doesn't have their flaws, he doesn't over-think a situation and not act (Don's weakness at times, Raph's strongpoint), but he also has more control over his temper and aggression (Raph's weakness, Don's strongpoint), but not complete control.
I see Don and Raph as the yin and yang, or like Leo's conscience. I can imagine Leo questioning what to do in a situation, Don in an angel outfit on one shoulder saying to talk things over and try to avoid fighting and Raph in a little Devil outfit on the other shoulder stating reasons why fighting is the only solution in a situation like this.
I'm not saying I want Leo to not be leader and someone else to be, but my general idea would be Don and Raph as partners. I can't imagine Raph taking orders from Donatello, he probably sees himself as Leo's replacement in the future, but Donatello may have a lot of good characteristics, but may not necessarily be ready for leadership. I don't think Raph would put up with Don as leader and he'd go off fighting crime on his own again, leaving just Don and Mikey as partners. Don being leader may result in that, or him lacking the offensive instincts and desire to go in and fight. But I think Raph's instincts are not nearly as good as Leo's are, and he might lead the others into danger that might not result in their victory at times because of his aggression.
Another good point that was made was that the characters would probably change a lot in the event of Leo's demise. They all imagined Raph would probably work harder on controlling his temper, and Don would probably try to be more aggressive in battle and rely on his instincts rather than his inventions at times. But, Raph and Don sharing power would work wonders, but I do feel bad for putting Mikey off to the side.
Revan
04-22-2007, 12:42 PM
It really a tough question to answer.
Raph expresses his desire to be top turtle in "Tales of Leo" and also his desire to lead himself in the new movie. We know Raph has authority problems and, this is just my opinion, I don't think Don would be able to handle Raph's rebel side. Had Don been in Leo's place on the rooftops, Don would have cracked under the pressure of the situation. I don't think Don would have even been able to fight Raph. Probably would have backed down and just let Raph have his way.
I'll halfway agree with triplexxx in that Don and Raph would share responsibility. But I don't think they could both lead simultaneously. When Leo goes down. It'll be Don+Raph. Don would hold all authority during pre-mission strategy. Then when they engage the enemy Don would have to hand over authority to Raph who can think on his toes (even if it may be hasty). Better to think fast and sometimes kill a few foot ninjas than to think to slow and get yourself killed.
Who is the second in command? Like, if something were to happen to Leo, and Leo either died or was incapacitated or just left them, who would take over as the new leader, or who would make a better leader?
At this point, Donatello is the default back-up leader. This is why Splinter admonishes Donatello in the movie, telling Don to be strong when his brothers are weak.
If Raphael could get himself under control, he would make a better leader in the field. Don has the capacity to lead, but he is very uncomfortable making snap decisions. Don would prefer to let others lead unless he feels like he could do the job better in a specific case. I think that's why, technical expertise aside, Leo sometimes defers to Don.
MoreCowbell5263
04-22-2007, 12:52 PM
The movie seems to make it look like Raph might not necessarily want to lead, but just not take orders from someone. It's been a while since I've seen Tales Of Leo, but Raph never struck me as a leader, he struck me as a perfect solo man. His personality isn't perfect for leading, and he seems more interested in running things his way or the highway. And frankly, Don, being Raph's complete opposite, would disagree with Raph a lot. Sounds weird, but Don is to Raph as Raph is to Leo at times (using analogies there, haha). Mike seems to be the only one who doesn't question anything, but I've been proven wrong before, I don't know if Mike has, but he might have.
Although I see Raph as more of a solo vigilante, I can also at the same time imagine him not enjoying the idea of sharing power with Don of all Turtles in leading.
They're just too different. It's like having two presidents rule the U.S., one Democratic, the other Republican. But for some reason, I can see it working with Raph and Don, which is what makes this franchise so interesting and intriguing as opposed to most things.
Shark_Blade
04-22-2007, 01:02 PM
Raph as leader = chaos
Everything is just do or die without thinking. For example in the movie, when they confronted Big Foot, he's the one suggesting "I say we stop talking!" and charge at the beast.
I think if Shredder has a laser gun machine ready, raph will still charge through and got himself and everybody killed in an instant. To me as a leader it's all not about rage. That doesn't show might or smart at all. A leader is someone who makes good decision(watched the apprentice and that's very true) and weight every alternatives heavily and not blinded by their own emotions and passion.:)
So Don is the perfect choice. Sorry raph. Mikey...not yet I guess, but I bet it'll be hillarious if he's being a leader.:p
It's like having two presidents rule the U.S., one Democratic, the other Republican
You know, it was originally set up so that the person with the most votes became President, and the runner up became Vice President.
That didn't work out terribly well. ;)
Raph could go solo, but honestly I think he's too much of a people person to really want that for himself. He'll only go solo because he's brash and doesn't know how to win people to his point of view when he's passionate about something. He'll make a very good leader when he starts listening, and stops trying to intimidate people into agreement.
Warhorse
04-22-2007, 01:07 PM
At this point, Donatello is the default back-up leader. This is why Splinter admonishes Donatello in the movie, telling Don to be strong when his brothers are weak.
If Raphael could get himself under control, he would make a better leader in the field. Don has the capacity to lead, but he is very uncomfortable making snap decisions. Don would prefer to let others lead unless he feels like he could do the job better in a specific case. I think that's why, technical expertise aside, Leo sometimes defers to Don.
I don't think so. Splinter may like it if Donny led, but Raph would steam roll over him in a heart beat.
Look at some of the things that happened in the movie. When the Turtles were lounging around on the roof top, and then they heard the monster from the nearby building, Raph immiediately jumped to check it out, and Donny was quick to follow instead of standing on his own, and then Mikey, and then Leo followed.
Then while watching the fight with the monsters and the foot soldier, look who was the first to say "Let's stop talking and start fighting!" and was the first Turtle to jump into the caos, followed by his brothers.
And then, who was the one who took control of the situation to get back Leo and get control of the monsters!;)
In an ideal world, Donny would be the second back up. But in this world, Raph's aggressive personality I think would be way too much for Donny to try and reel in.
But that aside, I do see Donny coming up with the plan and Raph leading it on the battlefront like someone has posted before. That would be the best outcome.
Revan
04-22-2007, 01:07 PM
I think if Shredder has a laser gun machine ready, raph will still charge through and got himself and everybody killed in an instant.
Ironically, the thing I most love about Raph can easily be his downfall. I admire Raph's fearless side. I love it because I am not the bravest of sorts by any means and it's great to have someone to look up to (even if he is younger than I am :) ). I wish I was more like Raph.
Revan
04-22-2007, 01:10 PM
In an ideal world, Donny would be the second back up. But in this world, Raph's aggressive personality I think would be way too much for Donny to try and reel in.
Exactly. Don is not as headstrong as Leo. Don would crack under Raph's rebellion.
Edit: Crud, my apologies for the DP.
MoreCowbell5263
04-22-2007, 01:14 PM
This is always interesting to me, I've actually spent days pondering over this. It's interesting because they're personalities are like opposites.
Leo is opposite of Mike and vice-versa
Don is opposite of Raph and vice-versa
They'd all make very different leaders. This is why Mike is completely out of the running for leadership. Leo is a great leader, Mikey...not so good. Raph and Don being in the middle make them better choices for leader.
All of them have their strengths and weaknesses. I think it's genius how they attributed their personality traits. They're such polar opposites of each other, it's uncanny.
Cascadia
04-22-2007, 01:19 PM
I know that this is off-topic, but interesting choice of words in your signature...we are not female dogs.
Revan
04-22-2007, 01:19 PM
All of them have their strengths and weaknesses. I think it's genius how they attributed their personality traits. They're such polar opposites of each other, it's uncanny.
That is the genius of Pete and Kevin. It's actually a basic concept. Have characters with different personalities. Most great works utilize this formula.
I always favor the angry rebel.
Raph
Wolverine
Achilles
Cera (Land Before Time) :lol:
Cascadia
04-22-2007, 01:21 PM
They are siblings whom are never exactly the same in terms of personality/attitudes. My personality is not like my brother's or my step-siblings.
I don't think so. Splinter may like it if Donny led, but Raph would steam roll over him in a heart beat.
Look at some of the things that happened in the movie. When the Turtles were lounging around on the roof top, and then they heard the monster from the nearby building, Raph immiediately jumped to check it out, and Donny was quick to follow instead of standing on his own, and then Mikey, and then Leo followed.
Then while watching the fight with the monsters and the foot soldier, look who was the first to say "Let's stop talking and start fighting!" and was the first Turtle to jump into the caos, followed by his brothers.
And then, who was the one who took control of the situation to get back Leo and get control of the monsters!;)
In an ideal world, Donny would be the second back up. But in this world, Raph's aggressive personality I think would be way too much for Donny to try and reel in.
But that aside, I do see Donny coming up with the plan and Raph leading it on the battlefront like someone has posted before. That would be the best outcome.
Pretty much agreed on that, and that's a good point about who took the reins after Leo was captured. First Splinter, then Raph. Not Don. However, I'm not certain things would have gone that way if Raph hadn't felt personally responsible for Leo.
But if the question was, "who's 2IC on the team," that's definitely Donnie, effective or not. Raph's not ready yet.
triplexxx
04-22-2007, 01:53 PM
Pretty much agreed on that, and that's a good point about who took the reins after Leo was captured. First Splinter, then Raph. Not Don.
Just curious, what do you mean "First Splinter, then Raph"? Splinter's head of the family, he chooses the leader, he doesn't take reins after anyone, he holds reins before anyone else always.
Warhorse
04-22-2007, 01:55 PM
But if the question was, "who's 2IC on the team," that's definitely Donnie, effective or not. Raph's not ready yet.
Can you show me examples on how Raph is not ready to lead compared to Donny?
I always saw it that it was Leo, then Raph, in all the incarnations I have seen.
Usually, Splinter lets one of the guys lead. But in this case that wasn't happening and he was clearly the one gathering the forces and telling them what to do, up until Raph said, "I'll tell you what we're gonna do...."
Can you show me examples on how Raph is not ready to lead compared to Donny?
I always saw it that it was Leo, then Raph, in all the incarnations I have seen.
I was sticking to this movie for the topic. Both Leo and Splinter seem to agree that Raph isn't ready. Don didn't lead well, but he also wasn't about to lead the team into trouble. Do you think Raph would have had enough restraint for that?
From basic recollection it generally seems like when Leo's not calling the shots, it's Don (with Leo's blessing), for whatever reason. They're usually fighting aliens or something. :)
I could be wrong about any of this, of course. (Hey, I'm not the Donatello expert on this board. lol )
triplexxx
04-22-2007, 02:01 PM
That's my point, Splinter lets one of them lead. Splinter's official leader & head of the family, and any of his sons are only allowed to call shots when they got his permission.
Sage Ninja
04-24-2007, 03:07 AM
wow, interesting turn of topic for this thread. Here is my two cents. I think that in a domestic setting Donatello is pretty much in charge and "leader" and is defered to as the eldest and is expected to be listened too. Like go to bed when I say so kind of way. In a battle situation I think Raphael would take up the reigns of Leadership simply because he is the most aggressive of the two. Although I do see them sharing leadership status when a sitaution arises that one has more knowledge in a certain situation than the other.
But, ugh...poor Michelangelo :( . It seems like he is lacking in every area that might make an important contribution to the team. He really seems like the odd turtle out. I sort of agree that Leonardo seems to be the perfect balance of both Donatello and Raphael's character traits with out all the weaknesses (while still possesing his own unique traits that make up who he is). Its like all three turtles personalities seem to compliment each other in the both their similarites and diffrences except Michelangelo.
triplexxx
04-24-2007, 03:17 AM
But, ugh...poor Michelangelo :( . It seems like he is lacking in every area that might make an important contribution to the team. He really seems like the odd turtle out. I sort of agree that Leonardo seems to be the perfect balance of both Donatello and Raphael's character traits with out all the weaknesses (while still possesing his own unique traits that make up who he is). Its like all three turtles personalities seem to compliment each other in the both their similarites and diffrences except Michelangelo.
Well, they did need him around to handle the Generals at the end. April and Casey couldn't fight them. A short final battle, but enough to give Michaelangelo saving grace. And he did show a strong concern for family in the Raphael/Splinter scene, a concerned look and no words. And at times, "no words" speaks volumes. If you look in another thread, you'll see someone said Michaelangelo is kind of a mixture between Raphael and Donatello. And in the movie, he showed an eagerness to get back to his crime-fighting days like Raphael, and was laid-back like Donatello sort of is. I'd say that's evidence of complimentary personalities. Not to mention, what I said about his show of concern for family may play off Leonardo's personality, although they all care about family, so that's nothing unique between them.
Seiza
04-24-2007, 04:20 AM
Its like all three turtles personalities seem to compliment each other in the both their similarites and diffrences except Michelangelo.
I think Mikey pretty much embodies the heart of the group (am so resisting bringing in Captain Planet here...). That's not to say Leo, Raph and Don lack that compassionate aspect... but throw a kitten into a freezing pond and it feels like the first turtle to jump in without thinking about his own safety would be Mike.
The rest embody very "cold" traits: skilled training, intelligence, physical strength. Mikey's emotions are warm, hopeful, and it seems like without his presence, the turtles could lose their "good guy" alignment pretty quickly. There was a fanfic in which Don realised that if he could only save one brother from certain death, it would be Mike: I think that holds true for Raph and Leo too. Not because he's the "baby brother" or in any way weaker and thus needs protection, but because Mikey is the warm hearth they return to after a cold day in New York's streets.
But of course, it's easier to show off Leo, Raph and Don's traits than it is Mike's in most mediums. That's why he gets short-changed in his portrayals.
jenna
04-24-2007, 12:30 PM
But, ugh...poor Michelangelo :( . It seems like he is lacking in every area that might make an important contribution to the team. He really seems like the odd turtle out. I sort of agree that Leonardo seems to be the perfect balance of both Donatello and Raphael's character traits with out all the weaknesses (while still possesing his own unique traits that make up who he is). Its like all three turtles personalities seem to compliment each other in the both their similarites and diffrences except Michelangelo.
I know it's not Canon, but I think it's ironic that in the Series 3 episode of the OT, "Take me to your leader", where Leo left and the other three all attempted to be leader, Michelangelo was the most successful. Donatello next and then Raphael buckled at the earliest sign of struggle. I know it's not really comparable, but still.... a moment in the history of TMNT worth noting.
MoreCowbell5263
04-24-2007, 02:48 PM
Yeah, that's my favorite episode of the OT. I loved it, Leo leaves because he doubts his leadership instincts, Raph led them out of the sewer into the Central Park Zoo and quickly relinquished control, Don took FOREVER to make a decision, and then his energy tracker led into a trap that Shredder and Krang had set knowing they'd use Don's energy tracker, and Mike was clueless to begin with and eventually got lucky in finding the source of why the Sun was losing it's energy.
But, ugh...poor Michelangelo :( . It seems like he is lacking in every area that might make an important contribution to the team. He really seems like the odd turtle out. I sort of agree that Leonardo seems to be the perfect balance of both Donatello and Raphael's character traits with out all the weaknesses (while still possesing his own unique traits that make up who he is). Its like all three turtles personalities seem to compliment each other in the both their similarites and diffrences except Michelangelo.
I think you make good points, Sage, but I'd be careful about calling certain character traits weaknesses. A weakness in one situation can be a strength in another.
I think that Michelangelo has very important characteristics for the team. If you've ever led a team, you know how important it is to keep people interested, and to have people get along. Mike facilitates that. And even more importantly, Mike's a very good follower. I know being "a leader" has positive connotations in Western society, but if everyone were a leader nothing would ever be accomplished. You'd have "too many cooks in the kitchen," as they say. You really need good followers who are intelligent enough to be competent and self-reliant, and who will put their full faith and effort into the predefined goal. Mike's all that (and a bag o' chips :twink: ). He may play around, but he certainly doesn't need a babysitter when you need to rely on him.
On the other hand, there are situations in which Mike can take the lead because he is the expert in those areas. (As someone pointed out about Donatello.) Everyone has their strengths.
This is just barely on topic now. But thinking about Mike's strengths, I don't think that any of the other guys could have had what looked like a really successful party planning/entertainment business. Having your own business is no joke, and it looked like Mike (maybe with some organizing influence from Don) had thought of everything. I loved when Don answered the phone with the overly-rehearsed, almost maybe somewhat enthusiastic Cowabunga Carl message. :lol:
MoreCowbell5263
04-27-2007, 05:18 PM
I definitely think Don had something to do with Mikey getting a job, Mikey not necessarily set up the Cowabunga Carl thing, but I suppose it does sound like an idea he'd come up with, and having a job interview when you look like a turtle would be difficult to actually get the job (or not, seeing is what the costume looks like, haha). Don did sound like he had experience in answering the phone with that Cowabunga Carl message. When I read reviews about the movie and found out the headset thing in the poster of Don was for his job, I thought he and Mike worked together for the CC thing, perhaps Don did some technical stuff to help out with the parties while Mike entertained. I always loved the pairing of Mike and Don in the movies, I know a lot of people like the Leo/Raph conflict, but I like how well they get along better than how much Leo and Raph argue, but people like it, so it'll continue. I think Mike and Don are just as interesting as Leo and Raph, and I always enjoyed the jokes they made in the movies and cartoons.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.