PDA

View Full Version : A Leo rant: "Maybe you should talk to Raphael"


Raphamel
04-18-2007, 12:34 PM
Splinter of all people would know (more than Leo) how Raph felt. Splinter demanded they stay in hiding until Leo returned, and Raph resented Leo for coming back and going straight into order mode, basically pretending like the whole last year never happened. Leaving to train was one thing, but then to STAY there after the training was over and to not even acknowledge life back home is totally another.

Leo even admits to Splinter: "I was caught up in my own world, I forgot about everyone else." So how is his "Ghost of the Jungle" any different from Raph's "Nightwatcher"? They're ONE AND THE SAME. Which makes one wonder why Leo hated the Nightwatcher so much... I sure as heck don't understand it. Leo just didn't want to admit to Raph that he was WRONG. If Raph wanted an apology then jeez, step up to the task and be a leader, Leo. You're just as guilty of making a bad situation worse.

Whoops, back to the subject of the post: Splinter knew if Leo talked to Raph it would have smoothed things over a lot more quickly. I mean, he raised them--and though he knows Don and Mikey would accept Leo back without question and while Splinter himself may understand why Leo stayed away so long, he knows Raph does not. Raph is the one brother who sees Leo's decision to stay and find himself as the other extreme--desertion. A leader doesn't forget about his troops. And Raph wouldn't admit that he wanted Leo there not only because he's his brother but because he knows that as a team they are all needed. Read: a leader is needed. If Leo refuses to come back and need them then Raph's going to be his OWN leader. And that's exactly what he did. Too bad so sad, Leo.

True, Raph didn't necessarily want anything to do with Leo right away: "Leo's back, better go say hello before he leaves again"... but Leo didn't exactly start things out with a bam by dissing Nightwatcher almost immediately. I can't help but feel that if Leo had actually talked to Raph instead of being so stand-offish and I-don't-need-to-explain-myself-since-you're-the-only-one-who-has-a-problem-with-me, then things might have been different. Leo was TOLD that his brothers needed him by April and TOLD by Splinter his absence affected Raph the most. I'd stop and think "Wow... it does probably seem like I deserted them. Raph's obviously still mad at me, maybe I should tell him why I stayed down there--that I'm not perfect. That becoming a better leader was taking longer than I thought. That I just didn't feel like the leader I needed to be."

Raph thinks Leo has this smug confidence like he's now perfect in every way... and when he was battling the Nightwatcher you could see that confidence. It was when he saw Raph his whole demeanor changed--like it's Raph who phases his confidence daily. Oh the irony. I love it. I do think Leo's "I'm BETTER than you" was completely uncalled for. Though I agree Leo should be the leader, he's not "better" than any of his brothers. Throughout the whole movie Leo disses Raph along with the Nightwatcher and thus OF COURSE that's why he's so willing to fight with him at every turn. I kind of resent the fact that Leo didn't even take into account his brother's feelings. Their fight needed to happen for several reasons--Leo needed to be humbled just as much as Raph's anger needed to be dealt with. After the fight you can clearly see that BOTH of these goals were accomplished. Which is why they forgave each other. Each brother saw his own faults, no words need be spoken.

In a way Leo's lucky Raph isn't as proud as he is... or he would be dead right now. At least Raph admitted something very hard for himself to hear, and right in front of Leo *and* Splinter no less.

Go Raph. I'm proud of ya.

Comments? Thoughts?

johnnyblaze
04-18-2007, 12:40 PM
you might want to check some of the other threads--we've had huge debates about this in a bunch of them

jenna
04-18-2007, 02:56 PM
you might want to check some of the other threads--we've had huge debates about this in a bunch of them

Yeah, there's some really interesting stuff in the Leo vs Raph thread and also the Splinter, Casey portrayal thread which looks a lot into the realtionship between Splinter/Leo/Raph.

Raph'N'Roll
04-18-2007, 03:41 PM
It's a case of the movie's script just not being good enough.

It was full of plot holes so obvious, that I just can't understand how they didn't correct or re-write parts of the story.

Rooish
04-18-2007, 05:04 PM
I agree with you (although Leo was dissing up the Nightwatcher right away without knowing the Nightwatcher was Raph), but I think some parts of Raph being bitchy were cut out of the movie. In the novelization, when the Turtles first go up on the roof together, they play a game of Ninja Tag (Don and Mike pair up, and Leo and Raph pair up, and they try to race each other to a billboard).

I'm gonna quote it now (cutting out some rambly parts).

The sixth rooftop posed a bit of a challenge as it sloped east at a thirty-degree angle. Flat out running wouldn't work here. Teamwork would.

Leonardo and Raphael slammed onto this rooftop and began sliding down its slope.

"Quick! Grab my hand!" Leonardo called out.

"No. You grab mine," replied Raphael.

Leonardo expected his brother to grab his hand, and when he didn't, Leonardo was forced to duck and roll--right into Raphael.

Raphael crashed face-first into a duct. Leonardo bounded over the duct and onto a pipe.

"You did that on purpose!" Raphael said accusingly.

"It was an accident," said Leonardo. "Wouldn't have happened if you grabbed my hand."

Raphael climbed on top of the duct and looked over at the next rooftop. "The only way we're going to get over there is if I cannonball you over and then allow the momentum of my throw to bounce off that flagpole and up onto the rooftop behind you."

Leonardo considered this. "Sounds good except--"

Before Leonardo could finish his thought, Raphael grabbed his arm, then spun him around before launching him into the air.

"Whoaaaaaaa!" Leonardo shouted, as his shell skidded over the lip of the next rooftop, barely clearing it.

"You did that on purpose," said Leonardo. They began to job toward the last rooftop.

Raphael grinned. "No I didn't," he said.

Leonardo looked intently at his brother. "What's up with you, Raph? Have you been avoiding me? I've barely seen you since I got home."

"I've been busy."

"I see," said Leonardo. "You're definitely not upset at me or anything, right?"

"Why do you think that?"

"Because when your brother gets to go on a worldwide training mission, and you have to stay home ... might upset me, too."

Raphael glowered. "You trying to make me mad?"

"I'm just saying, I'd understand if you were upset."

"You wouldn't understand the first thing about me, daddy's boy!"

See how petty Raph was being there? Leonardo was trying to get Raph to talk. Perhaps a little unsensitively, but still. Granted, this was cut out of the movie so it doesn't really matter, but I think that Leo's jerk-ness in the later scenes was written to follow this exchange. And right after this, Raph launches right in to fight the monster, even though both Splinter and Leo thought this would be a bad idea.

Courk
04-18-2007, 05:15 PM
While there were plot holes, I don't think Leo not talking to Raph is one of them. Yes, it would have been better if Leo had done that, but Leo isn't perfect, and I think this movie did a good job of showing that. Not having characters making ideal choices isn't a plot hole, it shows aspects of who they are. It would have been better if Han Solo had originally decided to stay for the Death Star fight, but he didn't.

Edit: Even though Leo attempting to talk to Raph is cut out from the movie (or something -- are novelizations based on the script?), just because it wasn't included doesn't create a hole.

triplexxx
04-18-2007, 06:18 PM
So how is his "Ghost of the Jungle" any different from Raph's "Nightwatcher"? They're ONE AND THE SAME. Which makes one wonder why Leo hated the Nightwatcher so much... I sure as heck don't understand it.
That's an excellent point. I've thought about that since I saw the movie. How come nobody else touched on it yet. Leonardo said he wanted to know why Raphael hated him for leaving and training to be a better leader, but why did Leonardo hate Raphael for making good use of his year away by protecting NYC? And how exactly was Raphael risking the safety of his fmily any more than Leonardo was? They both had been working out in the open all year, and in a different thread, a couple people told me that if Raphael had been killed on the job, there'd be no way for anyone to conclude there were others of his kind.

Mandi-chan
04-18-2007, 06:44 PM
Yeah, I didn't get it either.

Why was Leo so hellbent against the Nighwatcher?

Because he was a vigilante?

Well, that doesn't make sense....Casey's one, the TMNT as a team are, and Leo himself was one on his little trip to South America.

Because of his methods?

Again, that doesn't make sense since the Nighwatcher's methods were no different than Leo's. In fact, from what we saw in the movie, he didn't kill his enemy like Leo did...

Because the guy was getting a lot of attention on the news?

Maybe, but if we really do consider this movie a loose sequel to the original films then that doesn't add up either since the boys landed on the cover of a newspaper in the second movie...

Besides, why should Leo care about how much media attention a complete stranger's getting? He didn't know who he was!

The only reason I can come up with is that Leo was jealous of the attention the Nighwatcher got from his family. Mike respected the guy, and Raph (who was the person in question) defended him.

But, that's a really stupid reason for Leo to be against the Nighwatcher.

What really kills me is that Leo goes after the Nighwatcher and preaches to him about the error of his ways being a vigilante (totally glossing over the fact that he, his family, and a friend of his are ALL vigilante's themselves).

His actions were completely hypocritical and senseless to me.

I do get why he was so pissed when he discovered it was Raph though.

Leo did act alone in South America, but it wasn't anywhere near as populated there...so the risk of being caught was low, especially since the people there were grateful for his actions.

In NYC, the population is high, and vigilante's are more shunned than praised. The authorities want them arrested.

While the TMNT do act as vigilante's, they're actions are done as a team. They can watch each other's backs, to prevent from getting caught. And Casey's a human, so it's no big deal if the cops catch him.

I can see why Raph playing vigilante solo would bother Leo (especially with how heavily active he was and how much attention he was getting).

However, before he learned who the Nightwatcher really was, I don't understand Leo's anti-Nightwatcher attitude. Besides maybe jealousy against him, why should he care?

FearlessLeader
04-18-2007, 07:40 PM
“Oh so this is my fault now Raph? I’m the only one that has to be responsible?”


I will admit I have not read every thread on this subject so if I repeat things that have already been said I apologize in advance.

I have to preface what I am about to say by stating I don’t honestly find neither Leonardo nor Raphael at fault solely for there issues. I see them both as two very strong willed personalities that clash. It just tries me because I feel like since before this film was released Leo is getting the brunt of the blame. They are brothers, they are a family, and they fight. If the two of them can forgive each other and move on, I honestly wish the fandom could too. I am a diehard Leonardo fan and I have never once called Raphael out for the way he acted towards him, even if I didn’t agree with it. I understand Raphael had his own issues, he and Leo resolved there issues with each other I have absolutely no reason to tear apart and over analyze everything Raphael did. I will be frank, it is beginning to annoy me a little that EVERYTHING Leonardo did in this film is being put under a microscope it seems like.

Raphamel no offence but your really looking at everything in a very one sided fashion. I am very happy that you are obvious such a strong supporting Raphael fan, I am the same way with Leonardo, but I feel with a lot of your arguments you are ignoring the fact that Leonardo is only a singular being himself, he can make mistakes. He is still young and yes he is the leader, but as the Ancient One himself says in the Leo prequel comic he is still a “baby ninja”.

You go on and on about how Leo was so insulting to the Nightwatcher how he shouldn’t have said nasty things about him, how if he hadn’t he and Raphael wouldn’t have gotten off on the wrong foot. How was Leo supposed to know Raph was the Nightwatcher? Leonardo up until the point that he knocked the helmet off Raphael’s head though he was dealing with him vigilante lunatic. I am sorry Leonardo cannot read minds. Had it come right out to Leo in an unheated situation that Raphael was the Nightwatcher I think there could have been a much more understanding exchange between the Brothers’s. Yes what Leonardo does in the Jungle is very similar, he even says to the Nightwatcher before they fight that he has been down the same path as him and that it won’t help. Leonardo does not know if the Nightwatcher is actually doing what he does for good reasons or if he is just some nutcase who enjoys beating the living crap out of people. Had him and Raphael been able to sit down and have a conversation, had Raphael explained to Leonardo why he was making the choices he was I am certain Leonardo would have been more supportive. I still don’t imagine him being happy about it. Leo is very much one of those types of guys that has no issue with putting himself in danger but HATES to think of anyone in his family in danger. So who’s fault do I feel it is for this… both characters. Raphael is a big boy too and could have tried to talk to Leo just as much as Leo could have tired to talk to him. They both made bad choices that put them at odds with each other. They both learned and grew form them. That’s what’s important.

Also I feel Leonardo was fearful of Raphael being caught either dead or alive in his Nightwatcher gear and it giving away his family’s secret. In Tales of Leonardo: Blindsight the Mirage Mini-series in the first issues it shows the grim imaginings of Leonardo. Of himself slipping and falling to his death, from finger prints on his shell from his brothers and the techs analyzing the type of soil clinging to his feet Police are able to find the lair and his family. I can see fears like this being very real for Leonardo everyday. Leo tends to see the big picture much more then Raph does and I think it was something like this that caused him to be angry at Raphael for putting the family in danger. And considering the “magic” men and women work in modern labs today I don’t see it being that far off form being possible.

I have to admit I almost have to laugh at the fact you say Leo has a “smug confidence”. He spends almost the entire movie doubting himself. Not believing he is a good leader, believing he has failed his Master and his Brothers. The scene of his return of him begging Sensei for forgiveness for his failure breaks my heart. If this is a “smug” man maybe I need to look up what the word means again. Yes Leonardo is smug during the Nightwatcher battle, but that’s just his style when he fights. It’s a great way for him to unnerve his advisory and a great way for him to read just how controlled the man he is fighting is. Plus Leo was still furious from his fight with Raphael and he viewed his little bout with the Nightwatcher as a way to blow off some steam. I love his little smirk before he begins the chase. This is what Leo loves. Being out there, battling. How can you fault him for taking the same pleasure during battle that Raphael himself does? It reminds me of the opening scene with Raph “Looks like it’s just you and me shaky… don’t worry I won’t hurt ya….. much.”

And you say Leo’s “I’m better than you” line was uncalled for… well so was Raphael’s tirade about how no one in the family needs Leo and how they were better off without him. Raph hit Leo’s most sensitive spot (his family is the most important thing to Leo) so Leonardo in his frustration hit right back in Raphael’s. They are two very close brother’s fighting of course they are going to say things that they KNOW will hurt one another.

I think maybe you need to stop looking at Leo as being this all knowing being and realize his is just as capable as making mistakes as his brother is. You have so readily forgiven every mistake Raphael made in the film; it’s unfair to chastise Leonardo for every one of his. Is Leonardo prefect…. NO. Is Raphael prefect… NO. That’s what makes them the interesting characters that they are and that’s what makes there dynamic together so effective.

Oh and Raphael as JUST as proud as Leo… don’t kid yourself and Leonardo is just as willing to admit when he is wrong as his brother is. (As long as neither is completely pissed off at which point neither will make the correct choice.)

All I ask is for people to realize that both characters are at fault for there transgressions and for people to stop berating Leonardo for what happened.

The Brother’s made up… I think its time for all of us to move on about it too.

triplexxx
04-18-2007, 08:19 PM
I agree, they were both at fault, neither are perfect, and yet the two of them are still dedicated warriors with noble intentions, as their brothers are. And in the end, everything was forgiven and forgotten and the family's issues were resolved, as it should have been.
Besides, I still blame Splinter for this whole thing anyway: it was his decison to separate them that further fueled the fire which was already between them, and led them to clash their personalities in an almost lethal battle.
I know Splinter's not perfect either, but I still think he should've at least been given an ounce of blame for what happened.

Revan
04-18-2007, 08:19 PM
Yes Leo and Raph both acted strange. They acted like... teenagers. Wow what a concept. No one is perfect, especially young teenage "boys" who must live in a sewer and avoid human contact. Not to mention there are no female mutant turtles to... well you get the point.

Leo acts the way most teenagers act when everyone around him is telling him who great he is.

"Your brothers need you."

"You are the leader Leonardo."

So on and so on. It's quite difficult for a young male to keep a small head when he constantly put under pressure and told his is the leader. After all that, it's only natural for a teenage boy to think "Maybe I am better than my brothers. Everyone else seems to think so."

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
04-18-2007, 08:39 PM
Yeah, I didn't get it either.

Why was Leo so hellbent against the Nighwatcher?

Because he was a vigilante?

Well, that doesn't make sense....Casey's one, the TMNT as a team are, and Leo himself was one on his little trip to South America.

Because of his methods?

Again, that doesn't make sense since the Nighwatcher's methods were no different than Leo's. In fact, from what we saw in the movie, he didn't kill his enemy like Leo did...

Because the guy was getting a lot of attention on the news?

Maybe, but if we really do consider this movie a loose sequel to the original films then that doesn't add up either since the boys landed on the cover of a newspaper in the second movie...

Besides, why should Leo care about how much media attention a complete stranger's getting? He didn't know who he was!

The only reason I can come up with is that Leo was jealous of the attention the Nighwatcher got from his family. Mike respected the guy, and Raph (who was the person in question) defended him.

But, that's a really stupid reason for Leo to be against the Nighwatcher.

What really kills me is that Leo goes after the Nighwatcher and preaches to him about the error of his ways being a vigilante (totally glossing over the fact that he, his family, and a friend of his are ALL vigilante's themselves).

His actions were completely hypocritical and senseless to me.

I do get why he was so pissed when he discovered it was Raph though.

Leo did act alone in South America, but it wasn't anywhere near as populated there...so the risk of being caught was low, especially since the people there were grateful for his actions.

In NYC, the population is high, and vigilante's are more shunned than praised. The authorities want them arrested.

While the TMNT do act as vigilante's, they're actions are done as a team. They can watch each other's backs, to prevent from getting caught. And Casey's a human, so it's no big deal if the cops catch him.

I can see why Raph playing vigilante solo would bother Leo (especially with how heavily active he was and how much attention he was getting).

However, before he learned who the Nightwatcher really was, I don't understand Leo's anti-Nightwatcher attitude. Besides maybe jealousy against him, why should he care?

While you do bring up good points, I'd have to say with leo's situation, it was slightly different.

In the Raph prequel comic, he says to Raph to leave man's problems(with things like muggings and theft) to the cops, while things like Utroms and Triceratons were they're business. But with the stuff in South America, I don't know if there was anyone else that could help these people, plus, he had misinterperted the last part of the 5-Fold Path, and thought helping the people in the village was a part of his journey.

But with the stuff with the Nightwatcher, I guess he felt that he needs to leave all the stuff like theft and murder to the cops and stop before he goes to far. With Casey, they mellowed him, and since they're close friends, he doesn't look at Casey that way.

But yeah, Leo was being a hypocrite, but the film does a good job at acknowledging that. I think Leo himself kinda realizes that at the end.

Mindy
04-18-2007, 08:54 PM
I like how some folks are so quick to root for Raphael when he "one ups" somebody but should another character "one up" him, AW HELL NAW CAN'T HAVE THAT NOW RAPHAEL IS REBEL RAWWWWWWWWWWWWWR. HE SO MISUNDERSTOOD, NOBODY LIKE HIMMM.


...Seriously, folks... they're FAMILY. How many times has a family member made you so mad, you wouldn't even pee on them if they were on fire? Brothers argue, fight, call each other names, and all kinds of "serious business". In the end, they hug, punch each other on the arm, and the book is closed.. until next time when somebody's feathers or shells or whatever gets ruffled. If we're going to continue this "RAPHAEL SHOULD'VE SMACKED LEO TEN WAYS INTO SUNDAY", then we're totally missing the entire point of the series.

Still, a nice conversation piece - if a bit being one-sided a lot. Then again, there are so many dimensions to the characters.. that's why we're all here discussing them.

johnnyblaze
04-18-2007, 10:42 PM
In the book Leo tells Nightwatcher during the scene where he is 'lecturing' him that he tried the vigilante path and that it doesn't work, acknowledging that they both did the same thing. In the film there is a brief amount of dialogue that is muffled while Leo 'lectures' Nightwatcher, the scene where Raph comments that he is being lectured too. I would not be surprised if the muffled dialogue is the i've tried this path part of his speech found in the book.

FearlessLeader
04-18-2007, 10:45 PM
In the book Leo tells Nightwatcher during the scene where he is 'lecturing' him that he tried the vigilante path and that it doesn't work, acknowledging that they both did the same thing. In the film there is a brief amount of dialogue that is muffled while Leo 'lectures' Nightwatcher, the scene where Raph comments that he is being lectured too. I would not be surprised if the muffled dialogue is the i've tried this path part of his speech found in the book.

It is, if you listen really closely you can hear it.

Mindy
04-18-2007, 10:53 PM
In the book Leo tells Nightwatcher during the scene where he is 'lecturing' him that he tried the vigilante path and that it doesn't work, acknowledging that they both did the same thing. In the film there is a brief amount of dialogue that is muffled while Leo 'lectures' Nightwatcher, the scene where Raph comments that he is being lectured too. I would not be surprised if the muffled dialogue is the i've tried this path part of his speech found in the book.


While it was a poignant scene, it was so amusing when Raph muttered if Leo was lecturing him XD; I'm sure he's thinking, "Geez, he lectures to ANYBODY!"

I've got to buy those prequel comics.

Courk
04-19-2007, 12:58 AM
My first impression at the time was that Leo knew it was Raph. Once you realize Leo has no clue who Nightwatcher is, that scene is even better. That kind of double-take makes me forgive the ambiguity it starts out with.

Warhorse
04-19-2007, 05:10 AM
Also in the novel, the fight between Nightwatcher and Leo was alot more extended. And that for a while, Nightwatcher was getting the upper hand. Mainly because everytime Leo would try a move, the Nightwatcher would easily block it, and Leo was starting to figure out how come the Nightwatcher was so good at counterattacking his blows. Then Leo decided to change his strategy completely to something he doesn't normally do, the uppercut.

In the book, I'm sure a red alarm was going off, but it does seem that Leo was rather distracted and not as observing as he should have been.

johnnyblaze
04-19-2007, 10:42 AM
plus going from his reaction the entire dressing up thing seemed like something he truly didn't think Raph would do. it didn't click because it didn't seem like his brother to him.

jenna
04-19-2007, 01:47 PM
There are two sides to this coin. Leo should have talked to Raph. If he knew his brother at all he would know that Raphael's frosty reception of him and later antagonism was a clear indicator that he was hurt by him, but at the same time, Leo has been going through his own process - undergoing some spiritual growth and dealing with his fear of failure. Maybe he just came back and thought, I can't deal with Raphael right now. Maybe Raph's rejection of him on his return was just as hurtful to Leo as Leo's absence was for Raph. Leo was returning in a somewhat vulnerable state, feeling like he had failed.

Also, I don't think that Leo has ever considered the deepest cause to Raph's resentment of him (the whole Raph thinking Splinter loves Leo more thing) and still thinks that Raph's just got a big chip on his shoulder about the fact that Leo was appointed the leader. Leo is probably thinking: "Raph, get over it, it's been 4 years...(or however long)." Leo has been on the receiving end of Raphael's unrelenting antagnism for years and he may just have had enough. Of course, his not realising that Raphael's pain is so much deeper than that continues to damage Raph.

I don't really have a point... I'm tired and rambling... either way, I agree with both Raphamel and Reira - you both raise some really good points.

Seiza
04-19-2007, 02:15 PM
"Wow... it does probably seem like I deserted them. Raph's obviously still mad at me, maybe I should tell him why I stayed down there--that I'm not perfect. That becoming a better leader was taking longer than I thought. That I just didn't feel like the leader I needed to be."
Leo being able to think it through in such a logical manner would have made him too perfect.

His inability to understand Raph's frustration or identify the correct method of reaching out to his brother are themselves imperfections. Neither brother could get into the other's head (Raph didn't seem all that keen to calm himself and ask Leo why he'd stayed away), but that's not surprising. They're teenagers, but more importantly, they're directly involved in this mess. It is only we, as third-parties, who can easily see what should've been done.

Raph thinks Leo has this smug confidence like he's now perfect in every way... and when he was battling the Nightwatcher you could see that confidence.
Just because Raph says it's so, doesn't make it true. Leo puts on a show for his brothers (that whole tough-talking "vigilante showboat" rooftop scene), and Raph could not see through that show. But we know better because we're privy to more scenes than Raph is--we've seen Leo express self-doubt. Leo didn't waltz back into Splinter's room like he owned the place--he was short of walking in with his tail between his legs.

Also, the minute he knows it's Raph, Leo stops all talk. It's possible he only used the tactic to get under the Nightwatcher's skin-- perhaps he realised the Nightwatcher reacted badly to taunts and decided to press his advantage. Or maybe he just really needed to let off some steam.

(The turtles taunt their opponents all the time, anyway.)

In a way Leo's lucky Raph isn't as proud as he is... or he would be dead right now. At least Raph admitted something very hard for himself to hear, and right in front of Leo *and* Splinter no less.
Raph is very proud, as is Leo. That's pretty much why they butt heads so often--both have egos that refuse to back down without a fight.

And while I certainly applaud Raph for owning up to his insecurities, it took almost killing his brother and losing him to stone generals to finally get him to 'fess up to Splinter... But, you know, that's exactly how siblings work. Apologising to family is a heckuva lot harder than apologising to friends or perfect strangers.

However, before he learned who the Nightwatcher really was, I don't understand Leo's anti-Nightwatcher attitude. Besides maybe jealousy against him, why should he care?
I doubt it was jealousy. It's clear that Don (and probably Splinter) didn't approve. I think Leo was annoyed by the amount of attention the Nightwatcher's activities were bringing to vigilantes in general. The turtles get in and get out; I presume Casey's antics didn't make headlines either. The Nightwatcher was appearing in the news and on talkshows. You just know there'll be some crazies out there who'd try to trap him/follow him around.

When more attention is given to the Nightwatcher, who was operating on the turtles' timetable--at night, in New York--there're higher chances of people running into the turtles themselves.

Maybe Raph's rejection of him on his return was just as hurtful to Leo as Leo's absence was for Raph.
"Why do you HATE me for that?!"

Yeah, the hurt was going both ways. As was the snark. Both turtles were at fault, and that's why their fight ended so bitterly-- there could never be a clear winner, a clear right and wrong.

johnnyblaze
04-19-2007, 02:32 PM
I doubt it was jealousy. It's clear that Don (and probably Splinter) didn't approve.
very true, people are forgetting that Don didn't like what the Nightwatcher was doing either. Granted Don didn't get into a fight with the Nightwatcher, but he and Leo had similar thoughts on the subject

Warhorse
04-19-2007, 06:06 PM
very true, people are forgetting that Don didn't like what the Nightwatcher was doing either. Granted Don didn't get into a fight with the Nightwatcher, but he and Leo had similar thoughts on the subject

This reasoning doesn't go well with me. They are all best friends with Casey Jones, whome they met because of him being a vigilante, so why are they so against the Nightwatcher? I think Leo felt like his territory was being infringed on, Donny felt that biting sting of what it was like to be a crimefighter in disguise, so was just convincing himself that it was wrong, and Splinter might have not liked seeing his three sons watching the vigilante on screen, knowing it might spark some sort of uncontrolled interest to get back in the game. Remember when mikey started to make that comment "I remember those days!" when he was watching the news on the Nightwatcher. He very well could have been speaking for all of them.

I just don't understand it. Why is it ok for Casey Jones, but it's a no no for Raph/Nightwatcher. At the time, the Nightwatcher wasn't doing anything to hurt the TMNT, why was Leo so hell bent on going after him? I still think he just wanted to pick a fight.

The Shelf
04-19-2007, 06:16 PM
At the time, the Nightwatcher wasn't doing anything to hurt the TMNT, why was Leo so hell bent on going after him?

Try this, and maybe you'll understand...

At the time, Casey wasn't doing anything to hurt the TMNT, why was Raph so hell bent on going after him?

Raph stopped Casey because he was afraid Casey would end up killing someone. Why couldn't Leo stop Nightwatcher for the same reason? Leo trusted himself, his brothers, and Casey to take care of things without going too far, but Nightwatcher was an unknown to him, unpredictable, a risk. Pay attention to Leo's lecture again. He was telling Nightwatcher that he had been down that road, that it wasn't a good idea (fighting alone with no one to help you and keep you in check). Who's to say that he wouldn't have taken Nightwatcher in as one of the team like they did to Casey? Instead Nightwatcher provoked Leo into a fight.

Of course, Raph was Nightwatcher so the possibility that Leo would have taken Nightwatcher in is a moot topic, but the way he handled Nightwatcher wasn't any different than how Raph handled Casey.

Courk
04-19-2007, 06:22 PM
Who's to say that he wouldn't have taken Nightwatcher in as one of the team like they did to Casey? Instead Nightwatcher provoked Leo into a fight.
You say "instead" as if Nightwatcher provoking Leo into a fight is different from Casey/Raph, when in fact, as you've been saying, it is exactly the same. Good post.

As others have pointed out, it probably didn't help matters that Nightwatcher could have appeared to be robbing the diner.

Warhorse
04-19-2007, 06:33 PM
Try this, and maybe you'll understand...

At the time, Casey wasn't doing anything to hurt the TMNT, why was Raph so hell bent on going after him?

Raph stopped Casey because he was afraid Casey would end up killing someone. Why couldn't Leo stop Nightwatcher for the same reason? Leo trusted himself, his brothers, and Casey to take care of things without going too far, but Nightwatcher was an unknown to him, unpredictable, a risk. Pay attention to Leo's lecture again. He was telling Nightwatcher that he had been down that road, that it wasn't a good idea (fighting alone with no one to help you and keep you in check). Who's to say that he wouldn't have taken Nightwatcher in as one of the team like they did to Casey? Instead Nightwatcher provoked Leo into a fight.

Of course, Raph was Nightwatcher so the possibility that Leo would have taken Nightwatcher in is a moot topic, but the way he handled Nightwatcher wasn't any different than how Raph handled Casey.


Raph with Casey was different. Raph was catching Casey in torturing the thieves, which is why Raph came and stopped him. Remember, the banter, "You beat it, these low lifes need to be taught a lesson!" "Not like that they don't, not from you!"

Raph just caught the guys and had them wrapped up for the police, jsut like the Turtles did to the first gang of thugs when they first saved April. But the Nightwatcher didn't torture anyone, nor did Leo catch him hurting anyone. Sure, he could have thought that the Nightwatcher was going to steal the cash register from the cafe owner, but Leo seemed to forget about that and more into "lecturing" him. Really, what was Leo expecting the Nightwatcher to do? What if the Nightwatcher had been someone completely different and was armed with a gun?

No matter what way I look at it, seems Leo and Splinter came off as hypocrits! And I'm not the only one either.

(But to get back on subject, if things were different, Leo would have been more wiser to go seek Casey for some advice, as it seems he and Raph are alot more closer than Raph is with his brothers at times. Sometimes you can't be the lone hero on a quest, no matter how small it is! Like trying to reach out to your sibling?)

MoreCowbell5263
04-19-2007, 06:39 PM
So you guys are saying that Leo was feeling regret about killing that fat Hispanic guy in the beginning of the movie and that's why he was trying to tell Nightwatcher to stop? Leo was trying to prevent Nightwatcher from going possibly too far with protecting people as he did with the Central Americans, that would make sense, but if that is the case, I wish they would have given Leo something else to say that could get muffled while Raph is saying "he's lecturing me?" so that way it clears things up a bit.

FearlessLeader
04-19-2007, 07:52 PM
Raph with Casey was different. Raph was catching Casey in torturing the thieves, which is why Raph came and stopped him. Remember, the banter, "You beat it, these low lifes need to be taught a lesson!" "Not like that they don't, not from you!"

Raph just caught the guys and had them wrapped up for the police, jsut like the Turtles did to the first gang of thugs when they first saved April. But the Nightwatcher didn't torture anyone, nor did Leo catch him hurting anyone. Sure, he could have thought that the Nightwatcher was going to steal the cash register from the cafe owner, but Leo seemed to forget about that and more into "lecturing" him. Really, what was Leo expecting the Nightwatcher to do? What if the Nightwatcher had been someone completely different and was armed with a gun?

No matter what way I look at it, seems Leo and Splinter came off as hypocrits! And I'm not the only one either.

(But to get back on subject, if things were different, Leo would have been more wiser to go seek Casey for some advice, as it seems he and Raph are alot more closer than Raph is with his brothers at times. Sometimes you can't be the lone hero on a quest, no matter how small it is! Like trying to reach out to your sibling?)

How was Raph with Casey different? Leo though he was catching the Nightwatcher stealing from a cowering man. The news had been playing up what a brutal, crazy character the Nightwatcher was... As for your quote.... What do you think Leo is lecturing the Nightwatcher about? Much like Raph does with Casey Leo is trying to tell the Nightwatcher that he is not choosing the correct path, even if he has good intentions.

Also I think Leonardo has enough faith in his ability as a warrior to feel he could handle himself against one man. Even if he did end up armed. In the prequel comic for Leo they show him taking out a small army in the jungle all armed with guns all by himself. Leonardo in his mind was trying to help the Nightwatcher and also I admit blowing off a little of his own steam.

How are they hypocrits? This statement baffles me??

Once again I like how Leo is expected to do EVERYTHING and coddle to Raphael's personality. You know Raphael could have just talked to Leonardo too. He could have been straight forward with him. Also did you notice that the Turtles didn't seem to be to close to April or Casey in this film until the end. In fact when they go to get Raph from there apartment it was the first time Casey had seen Leo in over a year. How was he to know if Raph and Casey were even close anymore?

Leo had a lot of his own pain and issues to deal with. Just as much as Raphael did. They couldn't meet each other half way until they butted heads. Neither is right or wrong.

It also baffles me why people can't seem to see this?

Revan
04-19-2007, 08:04 PM
It also baffles me why people can't seem to see this?

You make good points but I can answer this question above. Because most people won't change their opinions even if you explain why you feel how you feel. You should know because you disagreed with warhorse even though horse gave reasons.

Example: I think Leo was wrong to tell Raph he was better and that will be my opinion no matter how anyone explains it to me.

FearlessLeader
04-19-2007, 08:07 PM
You make good points but I can answer this question above. Because most people won't change their opinions even if you explain why you feel how you feel. You should know because you disagreed with warhorse even though horse gave reasons.

Example: I think Leo was wrong to tell Raph he was better and that will be my opinion no matter how anyone explains it to me.

Fair enough *laughs*

Though I will continue to be baffled mostly because I don't understand, but there are a lot of things I don't understand so that is cool with me ;)

Revan
04-19-2007, 08:15 PM
I think it's great for the movie to have apparent "holes" like Leo' supposed hypocritism. It allows different people to develope their own meaning. In a way, holes allow people to use their own imagination to fill the holes. This way, the movie becomes personalized for each different person.

Courk
04-19-2007, 08:29 PM
I think Leo was wrong to tell Raph he was better and that will be my opinion no matter how anyone explains it to me.
Of course he was wrong to say that to Raph -- but that's what's great about it. It shows Leo's character. He wouldn't be interesting if he were perfect all the time.

If Leo could talk to Raph in an ideal manner for Raph, Raph wouldn't be as upset with Leo, but that would be boring:

Leo: Hi, back from South America.
Raph: Oh yeah? *anger*
Leo: I understand you're angry, but *explains in perfect way for Raph*
Raph: Oh, OK, cool. Welcome back.

But Leo can't explain it to Raph because:
1. He doesn't know how to (that'd be tough for anyone)
2. Leo isn't perfect -- instead of continuing to try to say the right thing, he said the wrong thing. Could have been 100% intentional, could have been due to his anger getting the best of him. Either of those reasons indicates flaws on Leo's part, which makes him an interesting character.

Warhorse
04-19-2007, 09:03 PM
How was Raph with Casey different? Leo though he was catching the Nightwatcher stealing from a cowering man. The news had been playing up what a brutal, crazy character the Nightwatcher was... As for your quote.... What do you think Leo is lecturing the Nightwatcher about? Much like Raph does with Casey Leo is trying to tell the Nightwatcher that he is not choosing the correct path, even if he has good intentions.

Raph was lecturing Casey because Casey was going to seriously hurt those thugs! Not to mention that those particular thugs were kids who did a stupid thing. Nightwatcher went after thugs that did armed robbery! But back to the pursesnatchers, it was the way Casey was going to deal with things that got Raph to step up, not the fact that he was going vigilante. Whereas, Leo was lecturing the Nightwatcher (for his good intentions) when he himself does the same damned thing (for good intentions) Like catch the bad guys and wrap them up for the police (like they have been shown to do in the first movie, the comics, the 2k3...............

Also I think Leonardo has enough faith in his ability as a warrior to feel he could handle himself against one man. Even if he did end up armed. In the prequel comic for Leo they show him taking out a small army in the jungle all armed with guns all by himself. Leonardo in his mind was trying to help the Nightwatcher and also I admit blowing off a little of his own steam.

But there is a difference between being concealed by foilage of the jungle to being out in the open, where there really isn't much hiding spots to jump to. ALso, did it ever cross Leo's mind that there might have been police in helicopters looking for the Nightwatcher, and Leo would have been stuck with him, and in his birthday suit?

How are they hypocrits? This statement baffles me??.

Easy! Definition of a vigilante! From Webster's dictionary! Vigilante: (1)A watchman or member of a vigilante community. (2)Any individual who acts outside of legal authority, often violently, to punish or avenge a crime
The TMNT as a group, whenever they go after criminals, are doing vigilante work. But it's not ok for the Nightwatcher to engage in the same practice.:ohwell: Again, Raph didn't go about beating the thugs for the hell of it like Casey was going to do. He did just enough to immobolize them so he can tie them up for the police.

Once again I like how Leo is expected to do EVERYTHING and coddle to Raphael's personality. You know Raphael could have just talked to Leonardo too. He could have been straight forward with him. Also did you notice that the Turtles didn't seem to be to close to April or Casey in this film until the end. In fact when they go to get Raph from there apartment it was the first time Casey had seen Leo in over a year. How was he to know if Raph and Casey were even close anymore?

Raphael wasn't sure what he was angry about, other than that Splinter seems to favor Leo over him, so why would Raph go to Leo to whine about that? Also, I would think, reguardless how long you have been away from your home, it would be common sense to go talk to friends to see how things have been in your absence. But that's just me. Like you said, Leo is flawed, and made for and interesting piece. But I still put the big burden on Splinter, in why he kept on forcing Leo to talk to Raph. This is something Splinter should have set them both down and had a heart to heart talk. And Splinter's slamming Leo on "There are no excuses when you are the leader!" Left me baffled.

Leo had a lot of his own pain and issues to deal with. Just as much as Raphael did. They couldn't meet each other half way until they butted heads. Neither is right or wrong.?

I agree with your statement here. But then, if they were to talk to eachother right from the start, wouldn't make much of a conversation piece on this forum, would it.

johnnyblaze
04-19-2007, 10:08 PM
This reasoning doesn't go well with me. They are all best friends with Casey Jones, whome they met because of him being a vigilante, so why are they so against the Nightwatcher? I think Leo felt like his territory was being infringed on, Donny felt that biting sting of what it was like to be a crimefighter in disguise, so was just convincing himself that it was wrong, and Splinter might have not liked seeing his three sons watching the vigilante on screen, knowing it might spark some sort of uncontrolled interest to get back in the game. Remember when mikey started to make that comment "I remember those days!" when he was watching the news on the Nightwatcher. He very well could have been speaking for all of them.

I just don't understand it. Why is it ok for Casey Jones, but it's a no no for Raph/Nightwatcher. At the time, the Nightwatcher wasn't doing anything to hurt the TMNT, why was Leo so hell bent on going after him? I still think he just wanted to pick a fight.except Casey Jones style is now supposed to be alot different than what was estabished as being Nightwatchers style (and Raph's style as Don points out). They don't agree with the use of fear, intimidation and showboating. And hell didn't Raph even get at Casey Jones when they first met because he thought he was going overboard? So its not like you can say that they were always 100% ok with how Casey did things--atleast on the Raph front which should say something considering how wild Raphael can be

plus Mikeys "I remember those days" speech was simply about him remembering his gory days of fighting bad guys.

Plus yeah Leo wanted to shut the Nightwtacher down but he was hardly obsessed with it. His incounter with him was strictly a coincidence while he was out looking for Raphael. As others have pointed out there are plenty of reasons why he and Don didn't want the Nightwatcher around the chief reason seeming to be that he isn't doing anything nor helping anything as Leo said to him when tehy met up. Not to mention the heat he can bring down on all of them with the fact that people know he is out there and that the people of the city don't like him nor want him around (remember the newspaper article and news reports where people said just that. I wouldn't be surprised if those aided Leo's decision that Nightwacher has to knock the vigilante stuff out as well).

Raphamel
04-20-2007, 02:36 AM
Actually, Reira, I wrote this rant because I believe my views are in the minority. And please don't assume I think Raph is perfect. I'm the first person to point out Raph's flaws, believe me, but I don't feel badly pointing out Raph's flaws because I know at base he's a tough guy with anger issues but also a noble and loving individual with a soft center. It's the same with Leo--pointing out bad choices in the rant doesn't mean I stopped respecting him. I admire Leo in many ways, he is my 2nd favorite turtle. My problem isn't with people who think from both sides like you do. I'm at odds with people who are quick to point out Raph's flaws but totally overlook Leo's--all the while adding their cute little quips "Well, Leo IS better than Raph!" I tend to roll my eyes because they're good at stating the obvious but they refuse to acknowledge Leo's role in the disaster. Would you sit by and let a hundred Leo rants go by without trying to convice people otherwise? If I offended you I do apologize, but it was not my intention.

I'm sure if you read through my rant again in a more neutral stance you'd see that I did not diss the Turtle that Leo is, rather I only dissed the particular choices he made in this film that contributed to Raph's acting out. To ignore Splinter's direct advice... to me that seems kind of cold: "Well it's Raph, he's always mad, he's always going to be mad, it's not important enough to me to explain it to him." Leo didn't soothe the hurt until it was almost too late, and even then it was mostly well-timed luck that brought them together.

I am a diehard Leonardo fan and I have never once called Raphael out for the way he acted towards him, even if I didn’t agree with it... I have absolutely no reason to tear apart and over analyze everything Raphael did.

I'm a Leo fan too, hon. Raph has made many a mistake in the past, and before you jump to any conclusions maybe you should read my little pro-Leo story (http://www.geocities.com/ken_chan_fan/dear_raph.html) and tell me how "perfect" I think Raph is. And I'm not overanalyzing, I'm just wondering why Leo didn't take Splinter's advice.

Raphamel no offence but your really looking at everything in a very one sided fashion. He is still young and yes he is the leader, but as the Ancient One himself says in the Leo prequel comic he is still a “baby ninja”.

I don't think that I'm being one-sided at all. I'm not anti-Leo whereas the people I'm trying to reach are very much anti-Raph. I wanted to point out some things that prove Raph isn't solely at fault... is that so wrong of me?

You go on and on about how Leo was so insulting to the Nightwatcher how he shouldn’t have said nasty things about him, how if he hadn’t he and Raphael wouldn’t have gotten off on the wrong foot. How was Leo supposed to know Raph was the Nightwatcher?

Leo knowing or not knowing who Nightwatcher wasn't important in the context of my question. I asked WHY Leo hated the Nightwatcher because The Nightwatcher and The Ghost of The Jungle are basically the same thing. In that way Leo was sort of being a hypocrite and I didn't understand what his problem with Nightwatcher was (before he knew it was Raph). I have since read replies that might explain Leo's disapproval him.

Had him and Raphael been able to sit down and have a conversation, had Raphael explained to Leonardo why he was making the choices he was I am certain Leonardo would have been more supportive.

As far as Raph knew, Leo wasn't *ever* going to apologize and would continue treating him like he's a "hothead" and little else. If I were Leo I'd get my brothers together and explain why I did what I did: "I was wrong to stay away as long as I did when my family needed me back home. I felt lost. I'm sorry. I care about each of you and want to be a good leader for you, I hope you can forgive me." But that's just me, I guess I'm a silly girl.

Raphael is a big boy too and could have tried to talk to Leo just as much as Leo could have tired to talk to him. They both made bad choices that put them at odds with each other. They both learned and grew form them. That’s what’s important.

I sided with them both throughout the movie, with Leo a lot at first because I felt sorry for him and thought Raph was going overboard as usual. So did a lot of people. But after their storyline sank in more after my 2nd viewing I started noticing more things... things that Leo said and didn't say/did and didn't do that could have eased Raph back into his grasp. Which makes everything after the fight that much more poignant because Leo saw that his presence *is* needed and that his absence *was* hard on Raph like Splinter said it was. If Leo could have seen Raph's anguish over his capture he wouldn't ever doubt that Raph had always wanted him back in NYC. Given the choice of A) Leo choosing to stay away or B) Leo being taken from them, Raph obviously doesn't like either. But at least he can rescue Leo from capture... he can't rescue a Leo who doesn't want to leave his jungle. There's a BIG difference.

I have to admit I almost have to laugh at the fact you say Leo has a “smug confidence”. He spends almost the entire movie doubting himself.

I NEVER said Leo has a smug confidence, Oh my GOD. I said "Raph thinks Leo has this smug confidence" as in "Raph THINKS Leo has this smug confidence but really isn't that confident at all because Raph himself phases his confidence." And I found that both sad and ironic.

Not believing he is a good leader, believing he has failed his Master and his Brothers. The scene of his return of him begging Sensei for forgiveness for his failure breaks my heart.

Mine too. And it made me equally sad that he doesn't seem to care at all about getting Raph's forgiveness. Because I know Leo is genuine, brave, caring, strong, wise... in Splinter's and in my *own* forgiveness of Leo I also want Raph to forgive him.

And you say Leo’s “I’m better than you” line was uncalled for… well so was Raphael’s tirade about how no one in the family needs Leo and how they were better off without him.

This is Leo we're talking about... he should know by now Raph tends to act out and says what he doesn't mean when he's upset. And that line was uncalled for when Leo was the one who wouldn't apologize to Raph when it would have helped things a WHOLE LOT. Raph had only himself to count on ever since Leo left and Leo conveniently forgets this. He is in a sense making himself feel better by chastising Raph's faults--comparing his strengths to Raph's weaknesses, which is hardly fair.

I think maybe you need to stop looking at Leo as being this all knowing being and realize his is just as capable as making mistakes as his brother is. You have so readily forgiven every mistake Raphael made in the film; it’s unfair to chastise Leonardo for every one of his.

I never said Leo was all-knowing or not allowed to make mistakes. I'd forgiven Leo the minute he stepped into the lair. He came back home and I had confidence he could set things right... I just think he (along with Raph) prolonged his and Raph's misery for no reason. An apology was the first thing I would have said to Raph if he were my brother. I forgave Raph only after he came to his senses at the end of the fight. Hmmm, who did I forgive first?

Oh and Raphael as JUST as proud as Leo… don’t kid yourself and Leonardo is just as willing to admit when he is wrong as his brother is. (As long as neither is completely pissed off at which point neither will make the correct choice.)

In this particular film Leo is much more proud. I was also referring to the fact that 1) I think it's safe to say Leo didn't think Raph could/would ever beat him in their fight 2) Leo never did admit his mistake (or apologize) to his brothers for his long absence. If two little brothers aren't as bothered by it, that's fine, but to overlook your emotional third little brother is just asking for tension.

All I ask is for people to realize that both characters are at fault for there transgressions and for people to stop berating Leonardo for what happened.

That's... all I was asking as well. Except I was focusing more on opening the eyes of all the people who blame Raph for everything but... ya know...

The Brother’s made up… I think its time for all of us to move on about it too.

Hopefully I was able to make at least one Raph hater stop and think: "Oh, well, maybe Raph does have a point." I see you're totally aghast at my having a point of view I didn't think many people shared... you've obviously read all the Leo rants while I was stuck hearing/reading about Raph's mideeds for the past four weeks. I didn't think Leo's faults were above dissection, nor did I think Raph was above needing some understanding and defense... :ohwell:

*crawls back into cave*

Raphamel
04-20-2007, 03:40 AM
Also, I just realized something: I've been at my current job for as long as Leo was gone from NYC.

It feels like a VERY long time... and I'm not even a teenager, a year and a half for me is different than a year and a half for a teenager as far as maturity/personality growth/trust issues/etc are concerned. No wonder Raph felt deserted. If he wouldn't have become Nightwatcher I'm sure he'd have a lot more resentment and anger for Leo to deal with.

Masked Ninja
04-20-2007, 04:00 AM
I think Leo was a little overwhelmed, personally. Not that excuses him (and for the record: I loved that he got to be a little bit of a jerk, as much as I like him as a character), but it can explain a lot.

While I can no longer pick a favorite out of the Turtles, I tend to identify most closely with Leonardo, as an eldest sibling who also happens to be a perfectionist. And part of my perfectionist personality makes me very uncomfortable when I don't have control over a situation, or sometimes even change in general.

So what if Leo also has this problem? He comes back from the jungles, and everything's different. His brothers seem generally unhappy with life, Raph seems even more bitter towards him than before, and Splinter charges him with a vague "fix it" order. So that's what he plans on doing, though he's not really sure where to start. He starts out with rooftop training, but that goes awry - Raph is very hostile and totally disregards Leo's reminder of Splinter's "do not fight" orders, and in effect any "authority" he was supposed to have. And the result? Not only has he failed at leadership again, but he gets lectured by Splinter for being unable to control his brothers. This only adds to the frustration and confusion... he's only been back for a couple days and he's supposed to fix everything?

Meanwhile, there's this Nightwatcher character. I honestly can't find a good excuse for Leo's annoyance by him initially... perhaps he has something of a distaste for vigilantes in general (a reason he's not terribly close with Casey, perhaps? At least in the 2k3 'toon there's a hint of this - check out how surprised Casey is when Leo pays him a visit in "Dragons Rising"... he even says "to what do I owe the honor?"). At any rate, I don't suspect he was seriously meaning to go after the Nightwatcher at any point... but he sure didn't like what he was doing.

So, fast forward to where he spots the Nightwatcher, holding the tray of a cash register in front of a cowering diner chef. Instantly we have two things - first, the Nightwatcher (who Leo already showed some annoyance for) apparently gone bad and now a complete danger to society. Second... there's a part of me that wonders if Leo saw some parallel to what he'd been doing in South America for so long, with cowering victims at the feet of brutal thieves. And we know by his treatment of those South American thieves what his feelings are on that subject.

So he goes after the Nightwatcher... at this point, Leo has tons of things on his mind - his failure as a leader, the fact that he still needs to go find Raph after dealing with this lowlife, his general frustration that things are not the way they were... Perhaps (either consciously or subconsciously) he just wanted to get into a good fight (verbal or physical) with this Nightwatcher guy and hopefully clear his head.

Which leaves the lecture in an awkward place... I dunno, maybe Leo just can't work without those. :P Or it was meant to inflame; he couldn't have been expecting a dangerous vigilante to just say "Oh, all right... I suppose I'll just clean my act right up, thanks!"

At any rate, the fight begins and Leo is finally doing something more familiar, hence his apparent excitement to get things going. But once he lands that punch and Raph's helmet comes off, he realizes he mired back in his family troubles. But there's already been a fight, so it's not like he can totally back off. So he vents at Raph, who has no problem doing the same. Amid his frustration, Leo lets loose the "I'm better than you" bomb.

For someone who's supposed to be leading his brothers, this is inexcusable. Such a thing can only cause bad feelings and disunity. But by this point, Leo is frustrated with everything - his own shortcomings, Splinter's expectations, Raph's defiance... and lets it slip... especially since nothing he's tried on Raph so far has seemed to work. Immediately he tries to back off because this pretty much solidifies some kind of serious consequence, but Raph has had enough and wants to settle it physically. And finally, Leo sees that what he's done can't be fixed easily, so he accepts the challenge. I can see his "Don't do this" line as being a last, rather half-hearted attempt to remind Raph that what he's about to do is wrong... almost a disclaimer because fighting is wrong... but by this time Leo is just as ready to fight it out as Raph.

So I think the deal with Leo is a bunch of good intentions gone wrong, for understandable reasons. His worst point is that "better than you" line, which has no excuse but (I think) an explanation.

And while Raph is a bit of a surly bonehead up until the fight, he really takes it like a man after he loses Leo to the Generals - confessing to Splinter and arranging to go get his brother back. Leo had the luxury of being unconscious until his family shows up (instead of having to sit in a little cage and dwell on what he'd done), so a good portion of the "reaching out" credit goes to Raph. Leo was no doubt prepared to offer his apologies and did so readily, but Raph really humbled himself and admitted he was wrong to the two members of his family he felt most smothered by. And it was this that enabled Leo to run the team smoothly for their final fight.

And really, why call it a "team" if it can function without the help of one of its members? I think that's an important point made here. When Leo was gone, things went downhill and the brothers became dissatisfied with life, perhaps because Splinter seems to have aged and withdrawn some influence... so there was nobody to keep them in shape. Therefore, Raph got used to being a loner and the other two seemed pretty bored.

But when Leo returned and Raph was not cooperating, things still didn't work... especially since the two are so strong-willed that when they don't cooperate, things only get worse. But once Raph was willing to work with his brothers and swallow a little pride, things ran smoothly again. Too bad the specific values of the other two Turtles couldn't be shown, but the movie was only about 90 minutes. Maybe next time? *hopeful*

So in conclusion to my long and rather all-over-the-place ramble... I think both Raph and Leo were at fault for parts of the family issues, and Leo, while trying to get everyone back together, just couldn't succeed. But Raph did some very commendable stuff to repair the damage... which allowed Leo to complete it and finally lead the team as he'd been charged. One could argue that he finally realized what Leo had been trying to do and found the motivation to do his part to make it happen.

I just love how the movie handled this dynamic, can't you tell? :trazz: Both Turtles were jerks at times, and both tried really hard to get their family back together. And in the end it worked, though I seriously doubt there will never be Leo/Raph clashes again afterward - their personalities will still clash and they will keep each other on their toes. It's a useful dynamic to ensure that neither goes too far, with Raph constantly challenging Leo's authority and Leo constantly challenging Raph's stubbornness.

triplexxx
04-20-2007, 04:23 AM
What exactly did Splinter expect was gonna happen?
His sons retain an actual purpose in their life by going topside to fight crime. And he deprived them of this for a year. He gave one son a task, and neglected the rest, who had to do with making some use of their lives. The one son who got the task became overwhelmed with responsibilities upon returning home. Splinter should know it's every turtle's job to hold the team together, not just one, so he shouldn't be holding only one son responsible for a team that's deunified only because their father made them that way in the first place. Like I said, the others felt neglected, Raphael especially, and Splinter knew that, and yet still went ahead with his decision to fuel Raphael's fire by sending Leonardo away, which in essence treats Raphael as if he has no responsibilities in the family. The year apart only succeeded in making Raphael and Leonardo more hot-headed/egotistical. It's only because of a lucky turn of fate where a family member got captured (Leonardo) which brought the team & family back together and made them all strong again. Raphael's defiance and Leonardo's frustrations all go back to a decision which Splinter made a year ago, I can't see how that's so hard to realize.

So in conclusion: Splinter's the one who triggered the whole family crisis in the first place with his faulty judgment and overexpectations. And why wasn't he given blame for it? Because he's a self-righteous rat fink who doesn't know as well as he think he does what's best for his sons. He's the one who should've been given the RANT.

Not that he's the only one to blame, but he is the one who started it. so he deserves most blame. If he'd just kept his sons home and let them continue training together and getting on with their lives in the first place, none of this mess would've happened.

Masked Ninja
04-20-2007, 04:30 AM
What exactly did Splinter expect was gonna happen?
His sons retain an actual purpose in their life by going topside to fight crime. And he deprived them of this for a year. He gave one son a task, and neglected the rest, who had to do with making some use of their lives. The one son who got the task became overwhelmed with responsibilities upon returning home. Splinter should know it's every turtle's job to hold the team together, not just one, so he shouldn't be holding only one son responsible for a team that's deunified only because their father made them that way in the first place. Like I said, the others felt neglected, Raphael especially, and Splinter knew that, and yet still went ahead with his decision to fuel Raphael's fire by sending Leonardo away, which in essence treats Raphael as if he has no responsibilities in the family. The year apart only succeeded in making Raphael and Leonardo more hot-headed/egotistical. It's only because of a lucky turn of fate where a family member got captured (Leonardo) which brought the team & family back together and made them all strong again. Raphael's defiance and Leonardo's frustrations all go back to a decision which Splinter made a year ago, I can't see how that's so hard to realize.

So in conclusion: Splinter's the one who triggered the whole family crisis in the first place with his faulty judgment and overexpectations. He's the one who should've been given the RANT.I do like Splinter in general, but I think I have to agree... in this movie he's not really shown as helpful at all. Leo still takes Splinter's advice very seriously, but he doesn't to a lot to help his son with his tasks... and I wonder if he really knows how to relate to the others very much at all.

I attribute this to his getting old, and being past his prime - he can no longer help his sons with training much more than giving them sage advice, but in Leo's absence he seems to have turned away from his other sons a bit (though he still loves them, he just doesn't really know how to keep them occupied).

I think the 2k3 Splinter is a lot more understanding, though he too seems to have been getting a little older and less involved by the end of the 4th season. And movie 1 Splinter (while immobile) is still awesome. His talk with Raph is precious. :)

FearlessLeader
04-20-2007, 09:07 AM
Also, I just realized something: I've been at my current job for as long as Leo was gone from NYC.

It feels like a VERY long time... and I'm not even a teenager, a year and a half for me is different than a year and a half for a teenager as far as maturity/personality growth/trust issues/etc are concerned. No wonder Raph felt deserted. If he wouldn't have become Nightwatcher I'm sure he'd have a lot more resentment and anger for Leo to deal with.


Raphamel-

First off I just want to say, you never made me angry, no worries ;) a but annoyed maybe *laughs* Defensive, yeah, but I will willingly admit I get a little defensive over Leo, mostly because I relate to him so much.

That said, if you would have prefaced your orginal rant with everything you said in your last post, I honestly don't think you would have gotten a reply from me at all. Your original rant ws a little one sided ;) Not that, that is wrong, but you were very pro-Raphael and while I never claimed you were personally dissing Leonardo, you did completely call to question every single choice he made in the film and made a lot of what happened look like it was his fault alone.

Now I understand where you are coming from. And while I will still admit I do not agree with many of your points I find them to be valid.

Just next time if you want to argue that something is the fault of both characters you may wanna stress that a little bit more instead of just dumping everything on one of them like the people that are ticking you off are doing. And I honestly mean this in the kindest way... it will keep crazy people like me at bay from ranting to you about an idea you already agree with and keep me from writing long winded replies *laughs*

:D

jenna
04-20-2007, 01:53 PM
And while Raph is a bit of a surly bonehead up until the fight, he really takes it like a man after he loses Leo to the Generals - confessing to Splinter and arranging to go get his brother back. Leo had the luxury of being unconscious until his family shows up (instead of having to sit in a little cage and dwell on what he'd done), so a good portion of the "reaching out" credit goes to Raph. Leo was no doubt prepared to offer his apologies and did so readily, but Raph really humbled himself and admitted he was wrong to the two members of his family he felt most smothered by. And it was this that enabled Leo to run the team smoothly for their final fight.



So true, so true. Masked Ninja, you are very wise ;)

Seiza
04-21-2007, 03:29 AM
Raph just caught the guys and had them wrapped up for the police, jsut like the Turtles did to the first gang of thugs when they first saved April. But the Nightwatcher didn't torture anyone, nor did Leo catch him hurting anyone.
I think the Nightwatcher's... er, for lack of a better word at the moment, "brutality"... was kept off-screen for the movie. Doesn't the novelisation mention that he got pretty brutal with his targets, to the point that even Donny was concerned? Whether it's true or not (there's always the chance that the media was exaggerating), that's the image Leo and Don have of the Nightwatcher.

But that's just to compare the Casey/Raph and Nightwatcher/Leo thing: both felt the vigilantes were going overboard.

I think that, ultimately, the Nightwatcher was very low on Leo's Annoyance List. Other than expressing his disdain and some showy words to his brothers, Leo didn't bother hunting him down. He did as much about the Nightwatcher as Donny did: disapprove.

Which leaves the lecture in an awkward place... I dunno, maybe Leo just can't work without those. Or it was meant to inflame; he couldn't have been expecting a dangerous vigilante to just say "Oh, all right... I suppose I'll just clean my act right up, thanks!"
Yeah, I think the lecture was... well, a Leo thing. :lol: But not expected to do any good. His "you don't wanna do this" to the Nightwatcher was much more insincere than the same line on Raph.

I do like Splinter in general, but I think I have to agree... in this movie he's not really shown as helpful at all. Leo still takes Splinter's advice very seriously, but he doesn't to a lot to help his son with his tasks... and I wonder if he really knows how to relate to the others very much at all.
One could say that it's not only the turtles who grew apart, but Splinter too, by becoming less involved with his sons than he could have been. Leo's kidnapping was the force that propelled all of them to pull together, including Splinter.

But I still put the big burden on Splinter, in why he kept on forcing Leo to talk to Raph. This is something Splinter should have set them both down and had a heart to heart talk.
Probably for the same reason my dad expects the same of me and my younger bro-- he probably thinks that, as siblings, we'll connect more and I'll make a stronger impact than when a parent tells my bro something.

Suffice to say, Splinter and my dad underestimate the intricacies (and mutual pig-headedness) of sibling relationships. :lol:

This is Leo we're talking about... he should know by now Raph tends to act out and says what he doesn't mean when he's upset. And that line was uncalled for when Leo was the one who wouldn't apologize to Raph when it would have helped things a WHOLE LOT.

I never said Leo was all-knowing or not allowed to make mistakes. I'd forgiven Leo the minute he stepped into the lair. He came back home and I had confidence he could set things right... I just think he (along with Raph) prolonged his and Raph's misery for no reason. An apology was the first thing I would have said to Raph if he were my brother. I forgave Raph only after he came to his senses at the end of the fight. Hmmm, who did I forgive first?
On the first point, it's not easy to brush off something said, even with what is known of Raph. Especially with Leo, whom seems to be overly sensitive to how his family views him--he thought in the beginning that his family didn't need him, and now Raph's words were hitting unnervingly close to home.

Anyway, it's funny--Leo's your 2nd fave and Raph's my 2nd fave but I went about it the other way: I forgave Raph first, and Leo second. :lol: While they've always had friction, most of Raph's extra edginess and his moonlighting occured because Leo stayed away and cut off communication. So if it's a matter of "who started it?", I'd put it on Leo.

But of course, dividing it so strictly simplifies their relationship. They both fed the fire through their imperfections, and comments like "Leo/Raph PWNED the !@$# outta Raph/Leo" also grates my cookies.

Warhorse
04-21-2007, 08:35 AM
Hey, I have another point of view I can throw into this mix. My cousin pointed this out to me.

At the end, we see Splinter placing the Nightwatcher helmet on the memory shrine. It seems to me that the memory shrine is something that Splinter has used as a way to reflect on defining moments in their lives.

Now with the Nightwatcher helmet, why was it really placed there? my cousin pointed out that after the realization that the Nightwatcher had been Raph the whole time, that SPlinter changed his mind a bit on the subject and became rather proud that Raph would use his skills and ingenuity to help the city, despite disobeying Splinter's orders. It's not that Splinter condoned the action, but respects that Raph is his own person, and no one can't change the protector in him, not even someone as important in Raph's life as Splinter.

FearlessLeader
04-21-2007, 08:49 AM
Hey, I have another point of view I can throw into this mix. My cousin pointed this out to me.

At the end, we see Splinter placing the Nightwatcher helmet on the memory shrine. It seems to me that the memory shrine is something that Splinter has used as a way to reflect on defining moments in their lives.

Now with the Nightwatcher helmet, why was it really placed there? my cousin pointed out that after the realization that the Nightwatcher had been Raph the whole time, that SPlinter changed his mind a bit on the subject and became rather proud that Raph would use his skills and ingenuity to help the city, despite disobeying Splinter's orders. It's not that Splinter condoned the action, but respects that Raph is his own person, and no one can't change the protector in him, not even someone as important in Raph's life as Splinter.

Well Splinter allowed Raphael to place the Nightwatcher helmet in the memory shrine... Splinter was placing Max Winter's helmet when Raph walked up and asked if he could.

It could be as simply as Splinter is honoring Raph's desire to remember his time as the Nightwatcher and what is accomplished and taught him.

My question is did he actually allow Mike to place his Cowabunga Carl head in the shrine?? :D

Avatar Yuffie
04-21-2007, 05:32 PM
Now with the Nightwatcher helmet, why was it really placed there? my cousin pointed out that after the realization that the Nightwatcher had been Raph the whole time, that SPlinter changed his mind a bit on the subject and became rather proud that Raph would use his skills and ingenuity to help the city,

I dunno... the Shredder's helmet is there. Does that mean Splinter is respecting him?

I think he allowed the Nighwatcher helmet as a trophy. For Raph's achievements.

Warhorse
04-21-2007, 07:44 PM
I'd like to know Splinter's feelings on the whole Nightwatcher thing once he found out it was Raph the whole time. Something like realizing a hidden person is someone you knew all along, could change your perceptions about the whole subject. I mean, this was never touched upon in neither the movie or the book.

Would you not be proud to find out this vigilante had been your son the whole time, just trying to make things a little better. No, you can't change the way things are like Leo pointed, but it is better to have tried and failed, then never tried to begin with and live with that regret.

Leonardo Mystic
04-22-2007, 12:28 AM
Leo even admits to Splinter: "I was caught up in my own world, I forgot about everyone else." So how is his "Ghost of the Jungle" any different from Raph's "Nightwatcher"? They're ONE AND THE SAME. Which makes one wonder why Leo hated the Nightwatcher so much... I sure as heck don't understand it. Leo just didn't want to admit to Raph that he was WRONG. If Raph wanted an apology then jeez, step up to the task and be a leader, Leo. You're just as guilty of making a bad situation worse.

Why? Because Leo did see the similarities between himself as the former jungle ghost and the Nightwatcher. He was actually mad at himself as much as he was at Nightwatcher. Which is the reason why he went after him, and tried to talk him out of it. I think in a way too he was repaying the favor of April talking to him in Central America; by helping (in his eyes) someone else from straying down that same self-destructive path.

Leo had known what he'd become in that role, and he was trying to keep from the Nightwatcher becoming that too.

Or maybe I'm reading too much into this at a pyschological viewpoint.

Buslady
04-22-2007, 01:52 AM
I'd like to know Splinter's feelings on the whole Nightwatcher thing once he found out it was Raph the whole time. Something like realizing a hidden person is someone you knew all along, could change your perceptions about the whole subject. I mean, this was never touched upon in neither the movie or the book.



its only fan work, but im gonna touch that topic in my Nightwatcher story. it'll be interesting to write.

Shark_Blade
04-22-2007, 05:55 AM
I dunno... the Shredder's helmet is there. Does that mean Splinter is respecting him?

Funny thing....I seem to remember Splinter's quote:

"Something much worse comes for you. For when you die, it will be.....(*Shredder throw knife but then Splinter let go of the nunchaku. Shredder fall into the garbage truck*)................without honor"

Why respect him now?

Raphamel
04-22-2007, 07:40 AM
Funny thing....I seem to remember Splinter's quote:

"Something much worse comes for you. For when you die, it will be.....(*Shredder throw knife but then Splinter let go of the nunchaku. Shredder fall into the garbage truck*)................without honor"

Why respect him now?

I thought for sure Splinter's collection defines the enemies they've defeated. So I don't think he's paying homage to The Shredder at all. Nightwatcher's helmet is there because he was loner Raph in disguise and therefore an "enemy" to the team--like an "if you're not with us then you're against us" type deal. And technically Nightwatcher *was* defeated by Leo, right? ;)

Seiza
04-22-2007, 08:58 AM
Funny thing....I seem to remember Splinter's quote:

"Something much worse comes for you. For when you die, it will be.....(*Shredder throw knife but then Splinter let go of the nunchaku. Shredder fall into the garbage truck*)................without honor"

Why respect him now?
I don't think the collection in that room is meant to honour everyone (although I'd guess they are honouring Master Yoshi and Winters with the helmet and what looks like a robe to the side). It feels more like a place to keep physical memories of defining moments in their lives, good or bad.

I figure Shredder's helmet is in the centre because of his importance to the audience, but if I were Splinter, I'd have put the TCRI canister in the centre. :D

I love Mikey's line there, though: "Can I get rid of this too?"

Dude, that's NOT a dumping room! XD

Raphamel
04-22-2007, 09:10 AM
I think the Nightwatcher's... er, for lack of a better word at the moment, "brutality"... was kept off-screen for the movie. Doesn't the novelisation mention that he got pretty brutal with his targets, to the point that even Donny was concerned? Whether it's true or not (there's always the chance that the media was exaggerating), that's the image Leo and Don have of the Nightwatcher.

I'm sure Raph went overboard sometimes. As angry as he was, Nightwatcher was the perfect displacement for his moodiness & aggression. It seemed like he always left the wrongdoers for the cops though and never killed anyone... but he did "toy" with them and probably enjoyed that sadism quite a bit, bwaha.

One could say that it's not only the turtles who grew apart, but Splinter too, by becoming less involved with his sons than he could have been. Leo's kidnapping was the force that propelled all of them to pull together, including Splinter.

Definitely. Good point! And the way they show Splinter staying calm, he doesn't blame Raph or even get angry with him... I love it. Splinter Jr will eventually reach this point... I'm sure of it ;)

Anyway, it's funny--Leo's your 2nd fave and Raph's my 2nd fave but I went about it the other way: I forgave Raph first, and Leo second. :lol: While they've always had friction, most of Raph's extra edginess and his moonlighting occured because Leo stayed away and cut off communication. So if it's a matter of "who started it?", I'd put it on Leo.

I guess it was because Leo explained to April and thus, we as the audience understood for the most part why he stayed away so long... and so I could identify with Leo's insecurities and forgave him first because he did come back and wanted his brothers at his side, even though his dealing with Raph wasn't the best. Plus, Raph executed the major "baddies" in behavior all throughout the film. I won't sugarcoat it. But that's why the several post-fight scenes of him being vulnerable and running away and then chasing after Leo and confessing to Splinter moved a lot of people, which shows Raph is usually always dealing with more emotions more frequently and more intensely than anyone else in the TMNT universe. Kind of a lot of baggage for such a young person. It's cool to me how Splinter seems to understand that about his angry child.

But of course, dividing it so strictly simplifies their relationship. They both fed the fire through their imperfections, and comments like "Leo/Raph PWNED the !@$# outta Raph/Leo" also grates my cookies.

YES!!! People who can't see that real life is gray and not black and white... scary folks. I also think there's something majorly wrong with people who don't like Leonardo :P I'm not sure which Turtle has the most fans... probably Mikey? Maybe Don? I do have a special place in my heart for Don because I'm like him in just about every way, but as far as Raph goes, I would rather have people not like him at all than to like him for over-simplified or superficial reasons. He's the most delicate (oh the irony) therefore I'm all for Raph having a protective & understanding fandom, lol. He and Leo are the main reasons I like Splinter too...

Note to self: Gosh I'm lame! I need to get a life...life...cereal. That's good stuff! Quaker Oat-y!

Warhorse
04-22-2007, 10:25 AM
YES!!! People who can't see that real life is gray and not black and white... scary folks. I also think there's something majorly wrong with people who don't like Leonardo :P I'm not sure which Turtle has the most fans... probably Mikey? Maybe Don? I do have a special place in my heart for Don because I'm like him in just about every way, but as far as Raph goes, I would rather have people not like him at all than to like him for over-simplified or superficial reasons. He's the most delicate (oh the irony) therefore I'm all for Raph having a protective & understanding fandom, lol. He and Leo are the main reasons I like Splinter too...


Hmmm. I don't think it's people not like Leo. It's more like the, I don't like Leo less, but like Raph more.

As for the fan favorite. In the past, it was usually Mikey as the fan favorite. Now it seems Raph is the heavy weight favorite, with Mikey and Leo neck and neck. Judging by the polls that are on this forum, the superhero hype boards and the IMDb boards.

Personally, I jsut think there are more people who see the world like Raph and Mikey than Leo, so thye will favor those that they identify the most with.

I like Raph because I do have a temper that is not so easily controlled. Things will piss me off for no reason, and I don't know why. I also don't like being told what to do, I find that as an insult that I can't take of myself when people try to lead you. But I dont want to lead people either. I want to be my own person and be accepted for who I am. If people don't like it, well, tough sh!t.

NightwatchersOnlygirl
07-02-2007, 07:55 AM
Leo knew that the Nightwatcher was bad news so did Donnie the one didn't
was Mikey see that the Nightwatcher was bad news as a big fan of the Nightwatcher Leo was in the wrong not the Nightwatcher

Buslady
07-02-2007, 10:44 AM
Leo knew that the Nightwatcher was bad news so did Donnie the one didn't
was Mikey see that the Nightwatcher was bad news as a big fan of the Nightwatcher Leo was in the wrong not the Nightwatcher



well that's a pointless post....:roll:


All the nightwatcher was is Raph's anger wrapped up in a neat little package.
I would agree that Leo defeated NW...btu RAPH himself, beat Leo.

Magdolin
07-17-2007, 12:14 AM
Oh my god! Raphamel, I agree. And when I saw the fight, I was almost ready to burst into tears! I could feel my eyes start to tear up!:cry:


I may be a Mikey fan, but that doesn't stop me from thinking about how sad the fight between Leo and Raph was.

Rooish
07-17-2007, 06:57 PM
well that's a pointless post....:roll:


All the nightwatcher was is Raph's anger wrapped up in a neat little package.
I would agree that Leo defeated NW...btu RAPH himself, beat Leo.

Do you need to bully her? She's trying to put in her opinion.