View Full Version : IGN picks TMNT in it's top 10 Computer-Animated Films!
Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
05-17-2007, 09:56 PM
I was pleasantely surprised to see it make the top 10!! http://movies.ign.com/articles/788/788890p1.html
10. TMNT
The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles returned to the big screen this past March with a vengeance in TMNT. The new flick ditched the hokey suits of the Turtles' previous big-screen outing (and the "Ninja Rap"), as well as the lightweight traditional animation of the cartoon series, in favor of some killer computer-animated style. The new-look Turtles are true to the Frank Miller-ish flavor of the original comic, and the film itself proved to be a fun, action-packed adventure. TMNT has some of the best action scenes of any computer-animated film we can remember.
:D Going to see it tomorrow at the cheap theater before it's time in the theaters is over. Can't wait!
MoreCowbell5263
05-17-2007, 10:03 PM
That's good news and all, but it being at 10 means it will be the first movie in that list to be replaced hopefully many years from now, but I do think the CGI in TMNT was very very impressive, so I don't think it'll be replaced for a while.
bullet
05-17-2007, 10:29 PM
that's some pretty big names up on that list. it's awesome to see tmnt making it onto the list, at least. tho i believe it deserved more...it's just my fandom clouding my judgment i guess.
FearlessLeader
05-17-2007, 10:32 PM
That's good news and all, but it being at 10 means it will be the first movie in that list to be replaced hopefully many years from now, but I do think the CGI in TMNT was very very impressive, so I don't think it'll be replaced for a while.
Prehaps it will be replaced by the next TMNT movie ;)
Personal bias... I honestly don't like Finding Nemo or any of the Shrek films...
The Toy Stories and Cars on the other hand totally deserve there spots!
Cascadia
05-17-2007, 10:33 PM
This is excellent news...there is some very big movies that are among the list.
MoreCowbell5263
05-17-2007, 10:36 PM
I wish they would just condense the Shrek 1 and 2 and Toy Story 1 and 2 into just one slot for the series. That way, TMNT could be further up on the list, and the same movie companies with the same graphics wouldn't get two spots on the list.
Meaning instead of having a slot for Shrek, Shrek 2, Toy Story, and Toy Story 2, just have a slot for Shrek 1 and 2, and Toy Story 1 and 2, and then TMNT sequels could be included as well as this recent movie.
Cascadia
05-17-2007, 10:38 PM
I know what they mean but Shrek and Shrek 2 are entirely different movies. The same goes with Toy Story 1 & 2.
Time Mistress
05-17-2007, 10:55 PM
Yea TMNT! But it deserves #1 as far as I'm concerned.:D
Roseangelo
05-17-2007, 10:58 PM
TMNT is by far better than Ice Age or Shrek 2. I can understand throwing all the Pixar stuff in there and the original Shrek, although I would put TMNT above most of those, too. I do agree that Toy Story 2 should be #1, though.
ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
05-18-2007, 01:05 AM
TMNT is by far better than Ice Age or Shrek 2. I can understand throwing all the Pixar stuff in there and the original Shrek, although I would put TMNT above most of those, too. I do agree that Toy Story 2 should be #1, though.
Meh, all these Pixar and Dreamworks movies suck IMHO. TMNT deserves number 1. And even though it's not here yet, Gatchaman at number 2, just becuase you know it's gonna be something different from the stuff were getting forced fed now.
ZariusTwo
05-18-2007, 01:12 AM
PIXTARD get the bacon again for the most part.
Spitfire
05-18-2007, 01:21 AM
Out of all the animated films out there TMNT just being on there is amazing enough.
Fledermaus
05-18-2007, 01:43 AM
How the hell did Cars make that list??
"A Bugs Life" was better...
Risawn
05-18-2007, 02:01 AM
As far as animation is concerned, this list is very well put together.
1. Toy Story 2
2. The Incredibles
3. Toy Story
4. Shrek
5. Finding Nemo
6. Monster's Inc
7. Cars
8. Shrek 2
9. Ice Age
10. TMNT
I would agree for the most part, in a combination of story plus animation (whether breakthrough animation techniques or just the overall look of the film) I would keep this list, the I would be inclined to place TMNT above Ice Age.
To put it in perspective, here is a list of major animated features that TMNT beat out!
Ant Bully
Antz
Barnyard
Bug's Life
Hoodwinked
Chicken Little
Dinosaur
Everyone's Hero
Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children
Final Fantasy: The Spirits within
Flushed Away
Happily N'ever After
Happy Feet
Ice Age 2
Jimmy Neutron: Boy Genius
Jonah: A Veggie Tales Movie
Madagascar
Meet the Robinsons
Monster House
Open Season
Over the Hedge
Polar Express
Robots
Shark Tale
Valiant
The Wild
I have to say that I can see why TMNT beat out a number of these movies (poor animation ((Hoodwinked)) or simply a horrible story((The Wild)) ), but I was surprised (and pleased) to see that Happy Feet wasn't on the list. As animation goes, its very well done, but story wise, after the first half, I hated it.
Not that bad a list... it is kind of impressive that TMNT is in there with the heavy-hitters. The detail of TMNT is superior to most CGI flicks out there.
I would never have put Shrek II on that list. Yeah, it was pretty, but the story really sucked and the original was prettier.
I haven't seen Cars... any good?
The Shelf
05-18-2007, 07:55 AM
Meh, the only movies that deserve to be on that list are TMNT, both Toy Stories, The Incredibles, and A Bug's Life. Most other CGI movies (the rest of the movies on the list and the ones that didn't make the list) are crap.
odupianist
05-18-2007, 08:28 AM
You all have to realize they're not just looking at the animation for all of them. The story and the other aspects of the film are taken into account. If you look at how Shrek mocked pop culture and pulled from the fairy tales we know as kids and twisted them a bit, it's really a good movie I think. I agree that they should have lumped TS and Shrek together, but at the same time I see why they separated them. Think about it this way, if the Shreks and the TS's had been lumped together, TMNT would be higher, so if you look at it that way, being 10 ain't so bad. In regards to Happy Feet, I finally saw it last night. Story was okay, but the visuals were amazing. I don't know if they CGI'ed the humans or did a Roger Rabbit kind of thing and mixed them, but the animation was really good. Okay, I'm done.
The Shelf
05-18-2007, 08:54 AM
Actually, I was referring mostly to story, not the animation. If I was going for animation, I wouldn't have listed the ones I did. Story-wise, most CGI movies are crap. That's why I dig TMNT so much. The monsters/generals story may not have been very good, but the turtles' story was rock solid.
If we want to talk animation, then Shrek, Toy Story, Monsters Inc., and Cars all pushed the envelope in CGI animation. Toy Story and Shrek were simply well done for the time periods they were each released in, but Monsters Inc. was known for the fur engine they made for Shelly (name?) and Cars, I think, was known for its reflections and such. TMNT's animation stands out to me because it did a lot with shadows, lighting, and the rain in the renowned Leo/Raph fight.
Tinuvielsdreams
05-18-2007, 08:55 AM
I agree with ALMOST all of those spots, and I am extremely happy to see TMNT on there. It is tough competition and they are up against very well known monopoly studios. Good job! TMNT and Imagi deserve it :)
Cascadia
05-18-2007, 11:57 AM
To put it in perspective, here is a list of major animated features that TMNT beat out!
Ant Bully
Antz
Barnyard
Bug's Life
Hoodwinked
Chicken Little
Everyone's Hero
Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children
Final Fantasy: The Spirits within
Flushed Away
Happily N'ever After
Happy Feet
Ice Age 2
Jimmy Neutron: Boy Genius
Jonah: A Veggie Tales Movie
Madagascar
Meet the Robinsons
Monster House
Open Season
Over the Hedge
Polar Express
Robots
Shark Tale
Valiant
The Wild
You forgot one more that just came out on video...Arthur and the Invisibles. Also it beat out Spirit.
odupianist
05-18-2007, 12:22 PM
It is tough competition and they are up against very well known monopoly studios.
I think that's the biggest feat right there. I didn't know anything that I can think of about Imagi until the TMNT movie. Once Toy Story came out, we all heard of Pixar (of course being attached to Disney didn't hurt I'm sure). I can't think of how I heard about Dreamworks, hell, probably Shrek.
jenna
05-18-2007, 12:42 PM
This is just brilliant news. It shows that TMNT is being taken seriously out there. Horrary for Kevin - the film may not have been to everyone's taste but he certainly pulled it off.:)
Jester
05-18-2007, 01:25 PM
I'm suprised they didn't combine the Toy Stories and Shrek films. I mean, how much did they improve on each other, really?
Risawn
05-18-2007, 03:06 PM
You forgot one more that just came out on video...Arthur and the Invisibles. Also it beat out Spirit.
Arthur and the invisibles is kind of a mix of live action and animation, so its not a true animated movie, but I digress, I haven't seen it myself.
Spirit? I never heard of that one, unless your talking about the Buckskin Stallion, which was Traditional Animation.
I'm suprised they didn't combine the Toy Stories and Shrek films. I mean, how much did they improve on each other, really?
I can understand keeping Toy Story seperate, as the first was the breakthrough in the genre as it is the first CGI full length film, whereas the second had a superior story.
I always thought Shrek was a bit overhyped. Cameron Diaz is a horrible voice actress, I never thought she did that great of a job. The first one had a good story, but the human characters felt a bit stiff and not very well animated. The second one showed an improvement.
At first TMNT bugged me in regards with the human characters and how they were animated, and then as I watched it, I'm glad they gave them a more cartoonish appearance and less realistic. When CGI tries to go too realistic, it can make watching it worse.
Jester
05-18-2007, 03:10 PM
Arthur and the invisibles is kind of a mix of live action and animation, so its not a true animated movie, but I digress, I haven't seen it myself.
Spirit? I never heard of that one, unless your talking about the Buckskin Stallion, which was Traditional Animation.
Wasn't Happy Feet a mix also, at some point.
Risawn
05-18-2007, 03:17 PM
Wasn't Happy Feet a mix also, at some point.
I have no real clue, I thought it was beautifully animated at first but when they got to the human characters I went 'What the Hell? Are those real or animated?'
I couldn't stand Happy Feet for a variety of reasons. I liked it at the beginning, but I couldn't understand why they couldn't make the penguins sing original songs. How can some Famous Pop Ballad by Elvis be a Penguin Heart song? Grr, that bugged me.
Furthermore, if I was watching a bunch of penguin's dancing, I wouldn't think 'Wow, I think they are trying to tell us something. Like maybe we are destroying their food supply. Let's do something about that.' I would think 'Holy crap look at all the dancing penguins!' By the sheer masses of them I wouldn't think they were starving.
And Mumble being the only penguin that looks like an adolescent penguin, even after being in a human zoo for MONTHS, was equally retarded. It would have made more sense to make a couple other penguins be late bloomers, not JUST him. Its a scream of 'Look at ME! I'm Different! In more ways then being unable to sing!'
Ok, end Happy Feet rant.
Aztec General
05-18-2007, 03:23 PM
That's cool. I do agree about Toy Story 2 being #1 though. That was such a brilliant film.
Courk
05-18-2007, 06:43 PM
I think I liked Toy Story 1 more than #2, but it's been a while.
I liked A Bug's Life more than The Incredibles and Cars. It's my favorite Pixar movie.
Overall, Happy Feet isn't my favorite movie, but I loved Lovelace and the Adélie penguins.
I didn't care much for Shrek 2 -- they seemed to reuse a lot of jokes.
Whoever posted the CGI list: Thanks! I was wondering how many CGI movies there had even been for there to be a Top 10.
Buslady
05-18-2007, 06:48 PM
im sick of seeing "hokey suits" to describe the original movies...yeah 3 were crap, 2 was eh...1 were real.
stupid ign
but yay cos TMNT is a bitchin movie
ToTheNines
05-18-2007, 06:53 PM
TMNT smashed all of those movies, and where was Bug's Life? I loved that flick.
Raph's Girl
05-18-2007, 06:57 PM
As far as animation is concerned, this list is very well put together.
1. Toy Story 2
2. The Incredibles
3. Toy Story
4. Shrek
5. Finding Nemo
6. Monster's Inc
7. Cars
8. Shrek 2
9. Ice Age
10. TMNT
Barnyard
Happy Feet
Ice Age 2
Why is "Ice Age 2: The Letdown" on the list??? That's a horrible movie!
Oh and Happy Feet IS on the list. I agree with the top 10 list a bit...but Barnyard needs to be on it. Altho it's kinda funny that TMNT beat out Barnyard since Barnyard stars Rob Paulsen and Cam Clarke. :lol:
IMO the top 10 should be:
1: Toy Story
2: Finding Nemo
3: Shrek
4: Cars
5: TMNT
6: Barnyard
7: Happy Feet
8: Monster's Inc
9: Incredibles
10: A Bugs Life
Risawn
05-18-2007, 07:42 PM
Why is "Ice Age 2: The Letdown" on the list??? That's a horrible movie!
Oh and Happy Feet IS on the list. I agree with the top 10 list a bit...but Barnyard needs to be on it. Altho it's kinda funny that TMNT beat out Barnyard since Barnyard stars Rob Paulsen and Cam Clarke. :lol:
Happy Feet wasn't on the original IGN Top 10 list. And Ice Age 2 wasn't either.
Barnyard is not on the list on account of poor animation and reallypoor character design. Who the hell thought it would be a great idea to put udders on a bull? Did they think that we wouldn't understand that they were cows so they needed something traditionally associated with cows to help us realize that the bulls were cows?
Egads, adrogynous cows. Shoot me now. . .
Tinuvielsdreams
05-18-2007, 07:53 PM
I was surprised about Polar express. I mean they even did a theatrical holiday re release, and then I thought about Advent children and how amazing that was and it didn't make the list either.
Could it be the motion capture aspect...?
I just really wanted to come back to this thread because I am so excited to see this:D
ToTheNines
05-18-2007, 07:56 PM
Polar Express, that movie was a God-awful bore-fest with SINGING. If there is one thing I hate in movies, its musical scenes. I'm sure if I saw it when I was like 3-8 it would have been amazing, but I hated it.
Tinuvielsdreams
05-18-2007, 07:58 PM
I thought visually it was well done though, if you can past the fact it is a children's book it is impressive. Plus we have a big name actor Tom Hanks playing all through it.
cowabunga14
05-18-2007, 08:38 PM
I'm glad that TMNT is on the list, but if I had it my way, I'd replace it so it wouldn't be at the tenth spot.
Risawn
05-19-2007, 01:41 AM
I thought visually it was well done though, if you can past the fact it is a children's book it is impressive. Plus we have a big name actor Tom Hanks playing all through it.
I like Tom Hanks and all, but he doesn't have a lot of range as a voice actor. Throughout this movie when you are listening to all the voices of the adults, you go 'yeah, there's Tom Hanks, there's Tom Hanks again, oh, there he is again.'
I think a good voice actor is one that can render their voice unrecognizeable so you can't tell who they are right away. It seems these days most animated features are done with big name actors who really are just a name because they look pretty and they must bring a draw to the movie but in fact, don't have a lot of range with their voice. Cameron Diaz anybody? Holy hell is she overhyped.
Of course, there are some big name celebrities that do a fantastic job with voice acting, Mike Meyers comes to mind.
ajistheman
05-19-2007, 12:42 PM
i must be the only person to enjoy the incredibles:ohwell: I didn't hate it, but didn't think it was special. I hated Ice Age 1 + 2 (those are 2 of my least liked movies ever, i just think they used the cuteness of the animals instead of pushing a decent story, ex. that little sucker randomly looking for his acorn was randomly thrown in for "oh cute" moments, and was irrelevant to the movie/story)
tmnt is my favorite cgi movie, but looking at it unbiased it would be
1 toy story 2
2 toy story
3 shrek
4....
i havent seen cars, i guess i should go see it
MoreCowbell5263
05-19-2007, 02:24 PM
I didn't like Cars, I didn't like Ice Age 2, but the first was ok. My top 10 list would be...
10. Happy Feet
9. Ice Age (1 & 2 I guess)
8. Cars
7. Monster's Inc
6. A Bug's Life
5. Finding Nemo
4. The Incredibles
3. Shrek (1 & 2)
2. TMNT
1. Toy Story (1 & 2)
odupianist
05-19-2007, 02:26 PM
I thought the Incredibles was great. I really enjoyed it. That little sucker in Ice Age is Scrat. I don't think he was thrown in there for "cute" moments. It was for the audience to laugh at the torture he kept going through. Ice Age 1 was better than 2 I think.
Tinuvielsdreams
05-19-2007, 03:30 PM
Me too! I loved the Incredibles so i was glad to see it on the list
I do wish if they said a movie they counted the sequels all together instead of giving two spots like Toy Story one and two
I do agree with most of it but I loved a few films like Dreamworks Madagascar so if I had to make a list I would be very stuck.
if we do get a sequel I could see it making the top 5
JusticeForce
05-19-2007, 06:00 PM
Go, TMNT, go! :D It deserves to be on that list for that rooftop battle in the rain alone - never mind everything else that's great about it! A word that describes the movie's visuals around here is "gorgeous!" :)
The Incredibles is our favorite movie of all time, animated or not, since we're fans of classic super-heroes and animation. We also love both Toy Story movies, so we're glad they ended up being the top 3 on that list.
We're not fans of any of the other movies IGN picked, but we're not really surprised that they made it onto their list since they're so popular. However, for that same reason, it's surprising that TMNT DID make it onto their list, since it wasn't popular with critics nor the general populace (ie. didn't make tons of money in the theatre like Shrek 2 or Finding Nemo).
- T & J
shuriken
05-19-2007, 08:06 PM
TMNT[/I] DID make it onto their list, since it wasn't popular with critics nor the general populace (ie. didn't make tons of money in the theatre like Shrek 2 or Finding Nemo).
- T & J
That's not exactly true considering that it was the #1 movie in the US for like two weeks.Anyways here's my list (trying not to be bias here.)
10-Cars
9-Antz
8-Ice Age
7-TMNT
6-Shrek(1&2)
5-Monster's Inc.
4-Toy Story
3-The Incredibles
2-Finding Nemo
1-Toy Story 2
Antz was an underated movie. Shrek one and two were both good but relatively similar. TMNT's story was kind of bleh so that's why it's not my # one. The Incredibles and the Toy Story movie did a good job with both parody and story.
ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
05-19-2007, 09:32 PM
We're not fans of any of the other movies IGN picked, but we're not really surprised that they made it onto their list since they're so popular. However, for that same reason, it's surprising that TMNT DID make it onto their list, since it wasn't popular with critics nor the general populace (ie. didn't make tons of money in the theatre like Shrek 2 or Finding Nemo).
- T & J
No no, it wasn't popular with those old fart 50-something critics. The dudes at IGN liked the movie.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.