PDA

View Full Version : What if a different Turtle had been chosen?


Scandia
05-23-2007, 08:29 PM
Chosen to do the training pilgrimage, that is. How would they have reacted? What would have been the results?

Here are my guesses:

RAPHAEL chosen

Raph- "Yes! Finally! It was about time! Take that!"
Mikey- "Congrats bro!"
Donnie- "There HAS to be a rational explanation for this. Perhaps sending away will calm him down. Calm down, calm down..."
Leo- "But, but, then what was all my training for?"

MICHELANGELO chosen:

Mikey- "Mondo tubuloso!"
Raph- "NOT cool! While it's good someone else got chosen for a change, that someone else should have been ME! Not this goofball!"
Donnie- "Again, there has to be an explanation"
Leo- "Why"

DONATELLO chosen:

Donnie- "Who, ME? What the?"
Raph- "What did he do that's so great? NERD!"
Mikey- "Cool, dude!"
Leo- "He may be smartest, but I work hardest. Why?"

What else would they say?

triplexxx
05-23-2007, 08:52 PM
What would have been the results?
No matter who it was, I'm positive the family would've fallen apart anyway and a lot of stuff that happened between them in the movie would happen. As Raphael clearly stated at the end, they're supposed to "train together".

Warhorse
05-23-2007, 08:54 PM
And they should have been sent away on this training mission together as well.

Scandia
05-23-2007, 08:58 PM
So it was Splinter's fault then. His plan backfired to say.

If Leo had stayed behind, I do not know if he would have gotten his other two homebound brothers to keep on training. But he would either have- or gotten totally discouraged.

triplexxx
05-23-2007, 09:02 PM
So it was Splinter's fault then. His plan backfired to say.

If Leo had stayed behind, I do not know if he would have gotten his other two homebound brothers to keep on training. But he would either have- or gotten totally discouraged.
Exactly (top part). And whoever said they weren't still training? Based on how well and easily they fought against the Generals and how quick they got past the Foot, they must've still been doing some training at the very least.

Warhorse
05-23-2007, 10:01 PM
Exactly (top part). And whoever said they weren't still training? Based on how well and easily they fought against the Generals and how quick they got past the Foot, they must've still been doing some training at the very least.

You totally got my phrase out of context. In order to advance the training of the team Splinter should have sent them all out on this training mission. If they are supposed to be a team, it makes no sense to send one of them away while the others sit on their laurels. You want them to be a team, you have them train together like a team.

triplexxx
05-23-2007, 10:06 PM
I know that, that's why I said "Exactly" to if it was Splinter's fault, because he made the mistake of not sending them all away.

Warhorse
05-23-2007, 10:10 PM
I know that, that's why I said "Exactly" to if it was Splinter's fault, because he made the mistake of not sending them all away.

Oh, when you said top part, I thought you meant the first half of Scani's post. Sorry. My bad.

Jo Dawn
05-23-2007, 11:11 PM
I think Don might have gone mad, with no technology. But, after that, I kinda imagine him as the 'Professor', not unlike the Prof from Gilligan's Island, making all sorts of things. Or MacGuyver. Either or.

triplexxx
05-23-2007, 11:13 PM
Well, any of them would've been able to take care of themselves, they're all self-sufficient.

Buslady
05-23-2007, 11:21 PM
they should have been sent off as a TEAM. SO i agrree wwithth thatt one..

like raph said, "this team you speak of doesnt exist" well no kidding...

Roseangelo
05-23-2007, 11:28 PM
I don't think Mike could have handled going off on his own. Not because he can't take care of himself (he most definitely can), but because he'd have trouble being alone for all that time.

Scandia
05-24-2007, 05:18 AM
Yup, Mikey is the least independent of the 4. He's best buds with everyone.

Splinter said that only one Turtle was ready to take things to the next level. He did not pick Leo arbitrarily. There was a reason- and Leo did tell Raph that if he had spent more time training, it may have been him. OK, so there are probably other factors. But Leo had the highest skills for a reason.

odupianist
05-24-2007, 07:54 AM
Let's not get into the Splinter's fault thing again lol.

The question is, if any ofthe other three had gone off to training, would they have done their year and come back or would they have stayed longer like Leo did?

iris
05-24-2007, 12:18 PM
I think Don might have gone mad, with no technology. But, after that, I kinda imagine him as the 'Professor', not unlike the Prof from Gilligan's Island, making all sorts of things. Or MacGuyver. Either or. Don would be set up like the Swiss Family Robinson inside a month.

Tinuvielsdreams
05-24-2007, 06:49 PM
yeah I think if anything they should have all been sent together.
I understood why Leo was sent away in the new series but in the movie it doesn't make as much sense. To be a better leader sure, but why AFTER Shredder has died. Splinter must know something, the guys don't?

Spawn Guy
05-24-2007, 07:47 PM
God forbid any of them actually try and take advantage of a chance for some self improvement now that life dosen't consist of fighting the tin can that walks like a man.

Buslady
05-24-2007, 07:52 PM
if splinter picked raph to go all over the place, they wouldn't have recognised him. he may have come back quite humbled and mellow :lol::lol:

Spawn Guy
05-24-2007, 08:07 PM
"The only reason we die...is because we accept it as an inevitability. *Deep Exhale*"

"Dude...could you slap me or something just to show your still you?"

Don probably would be gone longer than Leo. Not because he couldn't figure out what was mising, but because he just forgot.

"Good God, the fungi in this swamp is simply fascinating. Hmm...mental note; do I find it as such becasue I am developing a fondness for my surroundings, or because my food supply ran out last week and I've been forced to eat ten of these things to survive?"

Roseangelo
05-24-2007, 08:34 PM
The only thing about sending all four Turtles out together would be that Splinter would get lonely. :(

Spawn Guy
05-24-2007, 08:41 PM
No he wouldn't. The Rat King would be there.

While he has a heart attack.

Warhorse
05-24-2007, 09:05 PM
The only thing about sending all four Turtles out together would be that Splinter would get lonely. :(


That's what his soaps, April and Casey are for:D

Jo Dawn
05-25-2007, 12:43 AM
Don would be set up like the Swiss Family Robinson inside a month.

Yeah, them too!! Haha.

Sage Ninja
05-25-2007, 12:53 AM
Yup, Mikey is the least independent of the 4. He's best buds with everyone.

I don't think Mike could have handled going off on his own. Not because he can't take care of himself (he most definitely can), but because he'd have trouble being alone for all that time

I disagree with this. I don't think Mikey is the least independent of his brothers, and could handle a training trip by him self away from home. Yeah since he is such a social butterfly he might feel the sting of loneliness for a little while longer than maybe the rest of them, but i think he would quickly get over that and enjoy the chance to be on his own and call his shots. I think he would actually benefit from having to train all by himself and really grow as a warrior and as an indivdual if he had a training session like Leonardo had. He would finnaly be able to act in a role that isn't the little brother or the member of a team with more important members than him self, and I think that would cause Mikey to grow and mature. I also think that his open mindedness and social skills would make it easier to adapt to his surroundings than any of the other turtles would, since Michaelangelo has a flexiabilty to his character that the others do not. :P

odupianist
05-25-2007, 07:50 AM
I think he would actually benefit from having to train all by himself and really grow as a warrior and as an indivdual if he had a training session like Leonardo had.

He'd have to train because there'd be no Justice Force on TV (or TV at all for that matter) and I doubt Splinter would let him bring his comics AND the terrain woudl be too rough for Mikey to skateboard. I could be wrong on the skateboarding part though.

but in the movie it doesn't make as much sense. To be a better leader sure, but why AFTER Shredder has died. Splinter must know something, the guys don't?

Maybe he knew that the team would fall apart since they had no main purpose anymore. He sent Leo off to become a better leader so he could rally the family together even though they had no common purpose. Kind of touches on the beginning of City at War mentality, I think.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
05-25-2007, 02:08 PM
No matter who it was, I'm positive the family would've fallen apart anyway and a lot of stuff that happened between them in the movie would happen. As Raphael clearly stated at the end, they're supposed to "train together".

He didn't say they were supposed to train together, he was just stating that they do train together.

There's nothing wrong with wanting to train sepertley, just as long as they don't forget the family.

Zeno
05-25-2007, 03:54 PM
Yup, even members of a team have to train on there own sometimes.
Not to mention maybe he wanted to see how being alone would affect them in case one did get felled in battle at some point.

triplexxx
05-25-2007, 03:58 PM
He didn't say they were supposed to train together, he was just stating that they do train together.

There's nothing wrong with wanting to train sepertley, just as long as they don't forget the family.
When he said they "do train together", that implied that's the wisest course of action and what they'll do from now on. And nobody actually said anything about "wanting" to train alone, Splinter ordered it. And obviously it does cause them to forget family and their screw-up in that first battle with the monsters was a result of them training apart for 2 years, so now Splinter probably knows it was a mistake and won't do it again. This whole movie was about emphasizing their need to be together and train together.

Scandia
05-25-2007, 04:19 PM
Your timeline's a bit off. According to the prequel comic, Splinter had made the special training announcement 18 months before Leo returned. And there was some trip preparation. It was supposed to last a year- but Leo stayed a couple months longer due to his fear of returning home a failure.

triplexxx
05-25-2007, 04:31 PM
I was convinced when I saw the movie that the amount of time the family had been something from 1 to 1.5 years, but I kept hearing different things on this and other forums, then I didn't know what to believe. So I'll go with what the movie told me. Still, the point is: they train apart, they fall apart; they train together, they prosper. Simple as that.

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
05-25-2007, 05:11 PM
I was convinced when I saw the movie that the amount of time the family had been something from 1 to 1.5 years, but I kept hearing different things on this and other forums, then I didn't know what to believe. So I'll go with what the movie told me. Still, the point is: they train apart, they fall apart; they train together, they prosper. Simple as that.

Yes you're right, when they do work together, they prosper. And maybe if they all went off to train together, the break up may not have come to pass(or at least, delayed). But, theres still nothing wrong with them learnign new things by themeselves, and then bringing that new knowledge to the team.

Besides, the whole animosity between Leo and Raph was what was causing the rift. It wasn't the fact that one went off to train alone, it was the fact that Raph felt neglected becasue he felt Leo being favored as a STUDENT meant that he was favored as a son. Also, Leo's long absence and the fact that he never tried to make amends for it was also a factor.

Spawn Guy
05-25-2007, 05:27 PM
That and if we didn't have that gap we wouldn't have the side story of the broken family that we all love to analyse to death so much, so let's not go over this all again.

NightwatchersOnlygirl
06-05-2007, 06:54 AM
If Raphael went there be no Nightwatcher

Sunshine
06-10-2007, 01:02 PM
Personally I think Splinter sent Leo off to help him learn more then just how to be a better leader. It seemed like he learned some humility as well, though I think the fight with Raph ended up showing he still needed more work in that area. Overall I just think Splinter knew Leo would think he "failed" and ultimately was trying to teach him more through that as well. Also it made the others have to learn to adapt to life without their "leader" and to me it seemed like Raph was the only one who actually tried in that department. He was at least trying to keep doing what he felt was right rather then just sitting around waiting for Leo to come back and tell them what to do. *shrug* But that's just my opinion...

MoreCowbell5263
06-10-2007, 04:37 PM
I was never a big Raph fan, he was always my least favorite, but I like Ninja Turtles more when Raph is the angry one who questions Leo all the time and argues a lot, even though he gets on my nerves sometimes. But in the OT, he was too similar to the other turtles, so I like him being different even if he annoys me sometimes. But I do have to agree with Sunshine, because it did seem like Raph was the only one trying to do what the Turtles used to do before Leo was gone, and he was the only one trying to adapt healthily. But he went overboard with it, and that's where the conflict came into play.

Sunshine
06-11-2007, 02:07 PM
I was never a big Raph fan, he was always my least favorite, but I like Ninja Turtles more when Raph is the angry one who questions Leo all the time and argues a lot, even though he gets on my nerves sometimes. But in the OT, he was too similar to the other turtles, so I like him being different even if he annoys me sometimes. But I do have to agree with Sunshine, because it did seem like Raph was the only one trying to do what the Turtles used to do before Leo was gone, and he was the only one trying to adapt healthily. But he went overboard with it, and that's where the conflict came into play.

To be honest that was what surprised me most about the movie I really was surprised the Mikey at least wasn't doing any of the hero type stuff in Leo's absence. And Donnie I could of understood taking the time Leo was gone to work on inventions and things like that but they didn't even show him doing any of that. :ohwell:

Swany
06-11-2007, 02:20 PM
To be honest that was what surprised me most about the movie I really was surprised the Mikey at least wasn't doing any of the hero type stuff in Leo's absence. And Donnie I could of understood taking the time Leo was gone to work on inventions and things like that but they didn't even show him doing any of that. :ohwell:

Yeah, but they'd all lost their "mojo" I think Donnie probably did all that stuff for a little while, but being the acting older bro while Leo was away he probably felt he was neglecting those duties and had to do more for the family.

So he got a job. 'Cause money solves all problems. (yay!)

Although in the Donnie prequel

He is still inventing and sometimes helps Mike with the Cowabunga Carl thing when he needs more cash for inventing.

Sunshine
06-11-2007, 04:27 PM
Still overall I am glad Raph at least didn't just give up on helping people just because Leo wasn't around.