View Full Version : Shredder Sequel
odupianist
06-04-2007, 01:57 PM
Here's some food for thought. After reading the toy thread about why the Shredder toy isn't the super Shredder, it got me thinking. IF Shredder was in the sequel, would he be the buffed out super Shredder or just the normal Shredder? I can't think of any stories where humans come in contact with ooze (other than the old toon). Think about it. If it were the old toon ooze, Shredder would have been mutated in to some turtle/wolf/snapping turtle beast, not just super Shredder. So it obviously wasn't old toon ooze. We have no stories with humans and ooze in the comics or 2k3 series (as far as I know), so we'll go with this kind of ooze. It mutated him in to a really strong superhuman. Maybe the effects will wear off after awhile, maybe they won't, who knows. So what does everyone think? Super Shredder or regular Shredder? (if he appears in the TMNT sequel)
NOTE: I have NO clue whether or not Shredder will be in the sequel. This is pure speculation. I have no inside contacts, nor have I spoken with anyone to know if there will even be a sequel. I got this idea cause I was bored at work and someone else kinda hinted at it. So I developed on the idea.
Coola Yagami
06-04-2007, 02:18 PM
I can tell they'd go with regular shredder and try to either give some kind of explanation or none at all. I just can't see them using super shredder as many fans would boo this like hell. Even in the movie itself, Shredder's lil artwork looks more like a normal shredder than the kevin nash shredder. As does shredder's cameo in the movie games and that 'what if shredder was in the movie' action figure they got comin out.
SassyGal
06-04-2007, 02:38 PM
I voted for regular Shredder, because I agree with Coola Yagami. The brief glimpses of Shredder from the new movie & video game, seem to lean more towards regular Shredder. However, I wouldn't be ticked off if they used the Super Shredder design. Either way is cool with me :)
TMNT isn't in continuity with the previous films.
jenna
06-04-2007, 02:56 PM
I voted for regular Shredder, because I agree with Coola Yagami. The brief glimpses of Shredder from the new movie & video game, seem to lean more towards regular Shredder. However, I wouldn't be ticked off if they used the Super Shredder design. Either way is cool with me :)
:lol: I thought you might like the Shredder idea, Sassy.
SassyGal
06-04-2007, 02:59 PM
:lol: I thought you might like the Shredder idea, Sassy.
:lol: :lol:
You know it! :evilgrin: I loves me the Shredder!!!
I'm not adding to the poll as I'd be forced to use your reasoning that the effects of the ooze wore off. In case you didn't know, humans are just animals with extra abilities. Therefore, the effects of the ooze would be indefinite as they are for all other organic creatures. But, as this is a legal issue of character likeness and keeping the Super Shredder history would mean that they have to claim the Ice-man stuff as well, it just doesn't seem likely. These movies are an hommage, not a sequel to the live-action trilogy.
MoreCowbell5263
06-04-2007, 03:14 PM
I'd be happy with either, but I think no matter what you do, there will always be people complaining, no matter how accurate to any medium it is or how "Hollywoodified" it is. I wouldn't mind seeing either Super Shredder or regular Shredder, they were both big foes.
triplexxx
06-04-2007, 04:22 PM
TMNT isn't in continuity with the previous films.
Actually it is; it's just that the events that took place in the previous films may not have happened exactly the way they were depicted in those films; that plus a couple of years has apparently gone by since the third film and more events have occured.
ToTheNines
06-04-2007, 04:53 PM
The great thing about this movie is that if your a turtle fan, you can make it a continuity of of alot different universes (movie, comics, even current cartoon).
Actually it is; it's just that the events that took place in the previous films may not have happened exactly the way they were depicted in those films; that plus a couple of years has apparently gone by since the third film and more events have occured.
no, there are homages to the old film but its obviously on a different continuity. I mean all universes have defeated shredder, and the time scepter could have happened on this continuity as well since many continuities share characters, they mention the silver sentry who was a 2k3 character. Its a sequel as much as Superman Returns is to the reeves movies.
There is no reason to acknowledge Super Shredder in fact doing it can only come out badly...I wanted this movie to be in continuity for the longest time but after watching it I don't. It just makes no sense to put extra baggage on it just because its a movie and it should be in the old movies continuity.
Andrew NDB
06-04-2007, 07:53 PM
The great thing about this movie is that if your a turtle fan, you can make it a continuity of of alot different universes (movie, comics, even current cartoon).
Apart from the preceding three films, the new movie can only be in continuity of the other universes in a fanfiction.
Avatar Yuffie
06-04-2007, 07:56 PM
Super Shredder.
They didn't even fight the guy. Shame, I remember I felt it was hanging with no resolution, well other than that wooden beam, but...
Seems I'm the only one who voted for him, LOL.
Roseangelo
06-04-2007, 07:59 PM
Neither. Oroku Saki is dead; the Shredder should only return as a symbol.
Spitfire
06-04-2007, 08:23 PM
Where's the option for no Shredder cause he's over used and I'm sick of seeing him and sick of people thinking TMNT can't exist without him when it did for almost the entire comic run?
Scandia
06-04-2007, 08:30 PM
I do not want to see Shredder in a sequel because Oroku Saki is DEAD.
In pretty much all universes- movie, Mirage, NT. OT and Archie are closed anyway.
It would be more interesting to see more of Karai anyway.
triplexxx
06-04-2007, 08:44 PM
In my overall opinion, yeah, it'd probably be best if he not come back. I for one liked the ending he came to in the second film, going insane and killing himself for the sake of revenge like a typical ruthless TV villain. And both Shredders in the new toon were given nice fitting endings as well. Karai should take the mantle, though I was so sure 'til the very end she was gonna be on the turtle's side.
Andrew NDB
06-04-2007, 09:04 PM
Neither. Oroku Saki is dead; the Shredder should only return as a symbol.
Where's the option for no Shredder cause he's over used and I'm sick of seeing him and sick of people thinking TMNT can't exist without him when it did for almost the entire comic run?
Agreed on both counts -- if TMNT must have a constant injection of the Shredder to survive, it really doesn't deserve to.
The source material/comics, it's really kind of funny. Shredder/Oroku Saki is killed in the very first issue (repeatedly slashed, impaled cleanly through his gut, and then for the icing on the cake is thrown off a building and blown up by a grenade mid-fall). The worm clone that is regrown from his disembodied remains that appears in Leonardo, #10, #21 has pretty much been retconned with the new Tales stuff to really have never been Saki at all... so we only have one Saki appearance in the entire run of the source material.
Still, we're talking about the TMNT movies in which any kind of good sense or attention to the source material is... anyway, suffice to say, they might as well just do whatever they bloody want in the sequel. Bring back Saki, Tokka, Rahzar, maybe some more monsters and why not even some space aliens.
odupianist
06-04-2007, 10:28 PM
Neither. Oroku Saki is dead; the Shredder should only return as a symbol.
I'd typically agree, but thinking about it more. I really don't think if he was "Super" Shredder that some timber would have brought him down. I mean really, the dude is super supposedly. How would some wood falling on him kill him?
Where's the option for no Shredder cause he's over used and I'm sick of seeing him and sick of people thinking TMNT can't exist without him when it did for almost the entire comic run?
Sorry. I'm not saying the TMNT can't exist without Shredder. I'm not saying that he should be in the sequel. I'm just saying for argument's sake, if he were in the sequel. Just bare with me and don't be so cranky.
Coola Yagami
06-04-2007, 10:38 PM
I'd typically agree, but thinking about it more. I really don't think if he was "Super" Shredder that some timber would have brought him down. I mean really, the dude is super supposedly. How would some wood falling on him kill him?
It was Super Wood!!!
SassyGal
06-04-2007, 10:39 PM
I'd typically agree, but thinking about it more. I really don't think if he was "Super" Shredder that some timber would have brought him down. I mean really, the dude is super supposedly. How would some wood falling on him kill him?
That's what I felt as well. He survives being crushed by a garbage truck, but a pier killed him? That's lame.
I love Shredder & if he comes back, cool. If not, I can deal. I enjoyed TMNT without him, much to my surprise...if he doesn't come back, I still have my OT, 2k3, & TMNT 1 & 2 DVDs to make me happy :)
Revan
06-04-2007, 11:17 PM
I don't want to see any more shredder. That conflict has been done and resolved too many times.
That being said, if they did bring him back it would probably be in his original form. Super shredder was a bad idea to begin with. Bringing him back as a huge hulking vengeful idiot wouldn't accomplish much. If they somehow obtained his dna and cloned him as his regular saki version it might work. I think they should just let him stay dead.
Andrew NDB
06-04-2007, 11:17 PM
For sheer nostalgia and childhood "Ooohs!" I wouldn't mind seeing SuperShredder again. As a 10 year old it was pretty much the pinnacle of the film to me, where my friends and I were like, "ooooh, rad! SuperShredder, hell yeah!" but we saw so precious little of him.
Revan
06-04-2007, 11:32 PM
I suppose children enjoyed super shredder but everything about him was so wrong. Now we know that inanimate objects are effected by ooze. (shredders spikes miraculously enlarged as well as his other armour). And it seemed like the ooze decreased his mental capacity rather than enhancing it like it did to the turtles (he basically killed himself. What a bonehead)
It was Super Wood!!!
Close... It was Vanilla Wood! :o No one can withstand that wood, man. Wood, wood, baby! :D
odupianist
06-05-2007, 07:47 AM
That's what I felt as well. He survives being crushed by a garbage truck, but a pier killed him? That's lame.
He survived a garbage truck as regular Shredder, and got killed by a pier as Super Shredder. I'm starting to wonder how much the ooze really helped him lol
If and only if Shredder comes back I'd like to see him as Super Shredder but done correctly. First, there is no way he should have died the way he did. He survives a Garbage truck crushing him as a normal human but gets owned by a small pier. That still makes absolutely zero sense to me. And what also doesn't make sense is the turtles reaction when his hand moves. "No way!" Yes way should have been their reaction. He drank an entire canister of Ooze and already survived a much more severe death. Also, he should be smarter and stronger than his previous non-oozed version, but instead he was just huge and dumber. Also I don't think his spikes should have grown but I guess it is too late to change that.
However, a sequel that doesn't include him would also be more than appropriate. Although, I think if they make a sequel, he will probably be in it.
Kendamu
06-06-2007, 03:29 PM
I think it would be cool if Shredder returned in a sequel and was able to willingly change between regular Shredder and Super Shredder. That would give fans a fight scene with him in both forms to give both sides of fandom what they want. That, and with CGI, a Super Shredder would be a lot easier to pull off.
odupianist
06-06-2007, 03:37 PM
I think he'll have some sort of small role in the second one. Maybe not the main villian, but some small role, dont you think?
I think it would be cool if Shredder returned in a sequel and was able to willingly change between regular Shredder and Super Shredder.
Like a Hulk sorta' thing? "You're making me Super. You wouldn't like me when I'm Super." :P ;) That sounds kinda cool to me, but I doubt Laird would go for it.
Andrew NDB
06-06-2007, 07:27 PM
All SuperShredder had to do after he frees himself from the rubble is just walk over like 50 meters to where the Turtles "Traditional Pre-Fight Donuts" are located with the retromutagen inside.
Revan
06-06-2007, 07:34 PM
^ Yeah Super Shredder is dumb. I would much rather see original shredder
CJStyles
06-06-2007, 09:25 PM
Well if they do use "Shredder" it would be cool to fool us into thinking it's Saki but turns out to be someone else. I think it would be appropriate for the sequel(Kevin if you're reading the boards and come across this take this into consideration lmao).
However, if we do see Shredder why not use regular Shredder. Let's just say Baxter discovered him after the incident ran some test and reversed the mutagion, but allowing him to trigger the ooze making him the Super Shredder when he sees fit
Spitfire
06-06-2007, 09:31 PM
For sheer nostalgia and childhood "Ooohs!" I wouldn't mind seeing SuperShredder again. As a 10 year old it was pretty much the pinnacle of the film to me, where my friends and I were like, "ooooh, rad! SuperShredder, hell yeah!" but we saw so precious little of him.
Yeah as a kid I watched that movie a million times, when I got older I watched it again and the magic of him went away when I could see his ABs were drawn on him like a cheap halloween costume.
tOkKa
06-06-2007, 09:38 PM
-->> ..maybe he'll come back as a ghost..
http://webpages.marshall.edu/~yeager10/pictures/ghostbusters.jpg
Andrew NDB
06-06-2007, 10:00 PM
Yeah as a kid I watched that movie a million times, when I got older I watched it again and the magic of him went away when I could see his ABs were drawn on him like a cheap halloween costume.
Yes, there is that, isn't there? :)
But I was strictly speaking from my POV in 1991. If you're asking me in the here and now, honestly, the only time I'm interested in seeing the Oroku Saki Shredder again is in a complete movie reboot that is balls-out gritty that goes even further with things than TMNT 1.
Kendamu
06-08-2007, 03:14 AM
All SuperShredder had to do after he frees himself from the rubble is just walk over like 50 meters to where the Turtles "Traditional Pre-Fight Donuts" are located with the retromutagen inside.
Simple! I like it!
Revan
06-19-2007, 01:54 PM
Well if they do use "Shredder" it would be cool to fool us into thinking it's Saki but turns out to be someone else. I think it would be appropriate for the sequel(Kevin if you're reading the boards and come across this take this into consideration lmao).
However, if we do see Shredder why not use regular Shredder. Let's just say Baxter discovered him after the incident ran some test and reversed the mutagion, but allowing him to trigger the ooze making him the Super Shredder when he sees fit
Haha the Incredible Hulking shredder!
I suppose if they absolutely have to throw shred back in the mix, I wouldn't mind seeing shredder as long as it's Karai and not Saki.
ToTheNines
06-19-2007, 01:59 PM
It could possibly be Karai, I think it would be cool for her to pretend to be Saki and make a false alligance with the turtles as Karai then double cross them. While that would be interesting I definantly wan't Saki to come back for revenge:shredder:
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-19-2007, 02:10 PM
You know, if you take only the first live action movie as canon for the movie universe (which seems to me to be the way Laird and the other producers want it), there's no guarantee that Shredder is really dead. He could be, but maybe not.
After all, Splinter only kicked him off the roof into a garbage truck. In TMNT II, he had survived. Well, if he could have survived then, he could have survived now.
So, my question to everyone is: Why has Saki taken so long in coming back, hmm?
ToTheNines
06-19-2007, 02:13 PM
Because he's building a new TECHNODROME.
SassyGal
06-19-2007, 02:50 PM
Because he's building a new TECHNODROME.
That would be so cool :D
Revan
06-19-2007, 03:49 PM
Because he's building a new TECHNODROME.
:lol: All by himself:lol:
Poor shredder has no friends
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
06-21-2007, 03:45 PM
RETURN OF THE TECHNODROME!!!
Yeah, I hope they bring Tatsu back in the sequel. I loved that bald dude. Not much of a conversationalist, though.
Avatar Yuffie
06-21-2007, 06:00 PM
Ah, the Technodrome.
Is there no other way for it to appear in any incarnation? Even if it's just a password for a Doomsday Device (tm) would make me happy.
Andrew NDB
06-21-2007, 07:35 PM
RETURN OF THE TECHNODROME!!!
Yeah, I hope they bring Tatsu back in the sequel. I loved that bald dude. Not much of a conversationalist, though.
Would've made more sense to have Tatsu in the current film instead of Karai -- and we could even swallow April O'Neil knocking him down (Casey, with no martial arts training that we know of, managed to knock him out in TMNT 1).
xmen510
07-02-2007, 09:39 PM
I believe it would be the regular Shredder. It would be much easier for people to understand if they haven't followed the live action movies.
ToTheNines
07-02-2007, 09:42 PM
Right, and he would just be some un-inspired villain if it was some random Foot Clan member, it would just feel all wrong.
EDIT: By regular shredder did you mean not-super shredder or did you mean Saki and not some other dude in shredders suit?
Mr. Stay Puft
07-02-2007, 10:15 PM
I can't think of any stories where humans come in contact with ooze (other than the old toon).
If I'm not mistaken, don't the turtles share their origin with Daredevil? If that's the case, then the result of a human coming into contact with ooze would be enhanced senses, or something to that effect.
odupianist
07-03-2007, 07:56 AM
EDIT: By regular shredder did you mean not-super shredder or did you mean Saki and not some other dude in shredders suit?
Regular Shredder = Shredder from TMNT1 or pre ooze Shredder
If I'm not mistaken, don't the turtles share their origin with Daredevil? If that's the case, then the result of a human coming into contact with ooze would be enhanced senses, or something to that effect.
I had heard that too. Any truth to that? I know it was a similar accident.
CJStyles
07-03-2007, 08:45 AM
(Casey, with no martial arts training that we know of, managed to knock him out in TMNT 1).
He had a golf club so of course he knocked him out lol
johnnyblaze
07-03-2007, 10:17 AM
I think i'd like to see the Shredder in flashback only. Have it a bit like City At War where he is more of a dark shadow over the turtles past who's legacy keeps showing back up. Infact, didn't Kevin say that he though City at War would be a great direction to take the boys...
ToTheNines
07-03-2007, 11:44 AM
We need City at War featuring Oroku Saki in the flesh, I know more people would see it if Shredder was in it and I know for damn sure that I wanna see Shredder.
But, the lack of Saki is the catalyst for the city to be warring. How would you change that?
ToTheNines
07-03-2007, 12:57 PM
I dunno, they could work around it i guess:D
Revan
07-03-2007, 01:51 PM
But, the lack of Saki is the catalyst for the city to be warring. How would you change that?
Haha yeah exactly. There is no war if Saki remains in the picture which is why CaW seems to be the most popular on the drome boards and IMO the most logical way to go.
xmen510
07-03-2007, 02:57 PM
When I mention "Regular Shredder" I ment pre-ooze Saki. I suppose I wouldn't mind if it was flashbacks with a new head of the Foot Clan, but I would much prefer, if they use him at all, to see the real Shredder.
Zog the Equalizer
07-03-2007, 03:51 PM
(Im sorry if someone already said this, I didnt have time to read the whole thread) i think it would be cool if they kept shredder dead but used the worm clone( or regular clone) idea to bring him back.
ToTheNines
07-03-2007, 05:56 PM
Yea, as long as he's Saki one way or another.
Spawn Guy
07-03-2007, 06:16 PM
But, the lack of Saki is the catalyst for the city to be warring. How would you change that?
The three Shredder clone prototypes from Return to New York. Each is on the loose and Kari and the Elite are tripping over each other to be the first to nab them so one side won't use them against the other.
ToTheNines
07-03-2007, 06:18 PM
Sounds possibly interesting, but I think we've had our fill of chasing monsters
Spawn Guy
07-03-2007, 06:20 PM
As oposed to having our fill of The Shredder?
Revan
07-03-2007, 06:24 PM
The three Shredder clone prototypes from Return to New York. Each is on the loose and Kari and the Elite are tripping over each other to be the first to nab them so one side won't use them against the other.
It seems you are thinking too much along the lines of the comic/2k3 series and not enough of the movie universe.
I think it would be unwise for the sequel to venture even further from movie universe canon than did TMNT. Fans seemed divided on the new movie because of it's loose sequel status. They strayed from the previous movies' canon. If we see Karai and her foot as rivals in the sequel... what? That would be even more loose than was the new movie. And Return to New York has not yet been shown in a movie so it could be argued that that entire arch is not canon either and thus has never happened.
ToTheNines
07-03-2007, 06:33 PM
Return to New York happened in the first film, it wasn't a direct addaption by any means, but the turtles came back to kick Shredders ass after Raph (instead of Leo) recovers.
Revan
07-03-2007, 06:38 PM
Return to New York happened in the first film, it wasn't a direct addaption by any means, but the turtles came back to kick Shredders ass after Raph (instead of Leo) recovers.
And there were no clones. See what I'm getting at. The foot's technology was not capable of it.
Spawn Guy
07-03-2007, 06:40 PM
It seems you are thinking too much along the lines of the comic/2k3 series and not enough of the movie universe.
No, I'm think along the lines of "Shredder in the film both physically and symbolically". Also, all those who actually bothered to look beyond the cartoon will get what they are while those who didn't get a decent explanation that covers what they are and who the Elite are as well. Also, I'm not suggesting things happened panel to panel from the book, I'm talking the TMNT not knowing these things existed until they started bashing the hell out of every thing. And ultimately all this was a passing thought on how to get the Shredder in as a legacy to haunt the TMNT (which we can do through the Foot anyway) and a physical nemesis (so Kevin can shut up all those who never grew up and try to stop that happening to a franchise they barely remember).
Return to New York happened in the first film, it wasn't a direct addaption by any means, but the turtles came back to kick Shredders ass after Raph (instead of Leo) recovers.
If you want to keep up the trend of lumping every film together, yeah, but I'd rather use my imagination on the line "They battled many creatures and foes before defeating their arch nemesis..."
Revan
07-03-2007, 06:45 PM
^ Makes some sense. Movie one was geared toward the OT fans and those are the fans it reached. Many of the people who saw TMNT4 were fans of the previous three movies, thus the gripes about no shredder.
Basically I'm just saying I don't ever need to see shredder in another tmnt film. But I still realize that the closer they stick to the movies' canon, the more successful the film will be. I know it's a slippery slope but that is what the turtles have become.
ToTheNines
07-03-2007, 06:55 PM
The first movie wasn't really for the OT fans, I mean the fans at the time loved it because it was ninja turtles, but it left out alot of things from the animated series and incorperated the comics story lines into its plot.
Revan
07-03-2007, 06:58 PM
^ I don't agree but I won't tell you what to think. Just keep in mind how huge ninja turtles were back when movie one came out. How did it get so big? The 87 series. Even the opening sequence gave the movie title in the OT logo just before Leo jumps into frame.
ToTheNines
07-03-2007, 07:00 PM
Well it was adverstised towards fans of the OT, and it was influenced by the OT but even more influenced by the comics.
Revan
07-03-2007, 07:05 PM
Well it was adverstised towards fans of the OT, and it was influenced by the OT but even more influenced by the comics.
I agree with you 100%
^ Makes some sense. Movie one was geared toward the OT fans
...See
I didn't mean to deny that movie one was influenced more by the comics, just that it was geared (advertised) toward OT fans.
I can't help but wonder what the box office numbers would have been had TMNT4 stayed closer to movies 1,2, and 3. Not that I personally judge success in terms of $$$$ but some people do. In fact I was very pleased with what we got in TMNT. Just something to think about.
ToTheNines
07-03-2007, 10:53 PM
If they put out the same effort for advertising it wouldn't have made a difference. But alot of people who say they like TMNT, but really just have some vague memories of the OT, didnt like this recent movie. If all the commercials said "DUUUUH we gotz Rock Warriors, Foot-bots, Bepop, Rogsteddy, and the brain guy and Shredder" while the OT theme song was playing, alot more of the mindless masses would have came out and saw it.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.