View Full Version : Turtles in space PLEASE
BigApple3AM
06-28-2007, 11:36 PM
Normally I like the turtles to be in NY fighting ninjas or crime, but if they're to do a sequel I'd really like them to reimagine issues 4-6 from the original comic. Utroms, Triceratons, Federation, Fugitoid... it could be the kickstart this franchise needs.
I just think Turtles in Space would cover all the bases. About 1/3 of the movie would take place in NY, so those who like that setting won't miss out. The rest would be sort of like Star Wars. This would reach those original comic fans, the new movie fans, and even the old cartoon fans. They can work Krang to be one of the utroms (possibly Krang in name only). Bebop and Rocksteady can be bit part or cameo bounty hunters in outer space so they don't look too out of place.
The only thing the movie would lack would be Shredder, which many fans wouldn't mind in the least, but I know even more fans and general movie goers want to see him. The third movie can come back to earth and do City at War so at least fans would get their foot clan ninjas back.
Just an idea. What do you guys think. Turtles in space yay or nay?
Roseangelo
06-28-2007, 11:42 PM
I say no. If you had asked me seven years ago I'd have gone, "YES!" but Peter's overuse of everything you mention has me so tired and sick of all of it. I'd really like to see the sequel just be down and dirty, Turtles vs. Foot.
CyberCubed
06-28-2007, 11:45 PM
I don't think we'd ever see something that sci-fi in the movies.
Even though we had monsters, time travel, and mutants in the previous movies...the Turtles going into outer space is too much for the casual audience. Its for the same reason I don't think we'll ever see any Triceratons or Utroms in the movies.
MoreCowbell5263
06-29-2007, 12:11 AM
I agree with Rose, good old fashioned Turtles vs. Foot in New York would be great and good for a grittier movie and stuff. City At War would be good, but if the mafia is gonna be done accurately, may have to be PG-13, which would be cool, seeing is how other superhero movies are PG-13. I'd go Turtles Vs. Foot, City At War, or maybe a Battle Nexus kinda deal, but Battle Nexus probably wouldn't please the older fans.
ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
06-29-2007, 12:27 AM
As much as I want to see a CaW adaption, I'd be happy to see a Turtles in Space adaption. Pete knows how to do Sci-Fi and Paranormal, Plus CGI Triceratons sound so good.
Revan
06-29-2007, 01:08 AM
We still haven't seen an utrom or a triceraton. I think it's because they wanted the first movie to be as realistic as possible. I loved movie one as a child because I picked up on the realism aspect of it.
The movies have used more and more science fiction with each new film. I would just like to see a return to the real life aspect of the first film. I think the TMNT sequel should be set in NY all the way through. Perhaps a short time elsewhere but mostly in NY.
Andrew NDB
06-29-2007, 02:00 AM
God no. We haven't seen a down-to-earth movie since the original, the last thing we need is a movie that literally goes to outer space.
bullet
06-29-2007, 02:06 AM
eh, dunno, just seems like a strange idea to me. i'd rather have them stay earthbound. :P
ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
06-29-2007, 02:42 AM
You guys just have no imagination
Scandia
06-29-2007, 05:52 AM
I honestly don't mind either way.
I do wonder why, if Triceratons have such a big role in the TMNT Mirage Comics, why were they not shown AT ALL in the OT or the movies. I had no idea they existed till I joined this website and started checking out the Mirage comics. I understand there were not so many Mirage comics published when the OT came out- but the Triceratons had already shown up.
Buslady
06-29-2007, 07:20 AM
No OT elements ever.
I can go with the space thing since they really did encounter Triceratons and all that but as long as there's nothing from OT....
CAW on screen would be the best thing ever. MORE Raph & Leo arguments! WOO!!
Raph's Girl
06-29-2007, 07:34 AM
Yea.. um cut scene from the current movie mentions Triceratons and Utroms (read the novelization) and according to the comic book adaptions of the movie the turtles faught Triceratons shortly before Leonardo left for his world stint (he was gone for nearly 2 years).
Altho Triceratons would be nice in the movie we'll have the DVD with the cute out scenes that mention em in August.
Scandia
06-29-2007, 07:48 AM
I do remember now the Raphael comic. Although someone who has not read it and has only watched the movies has no way to know to be honest.
The battle in the Raphael prequel comic happened 18 months before Leo returns. His training period was supposed to last a year- and he was gone a bit longer than that. Plus there were some preparations. Nearly 2 years is way longer than what he was gone.
I'll have to re-read the comic. It has been a while. I do deal with a lot of data at work and keep up with a lot of nerdy geeky fandoms- so it is likely that I forgot about it.
Masked Ninja
06-29-2007, 10:04 AM
I wouldn't mind it, though I would much prefer a City at War adaptation. It'd be better than the "13 monsters" thing of this past movie, though as a followup it might feel like more of the same, as far as the "monsters Joe Public may not be familiar with" (Triceratons and Utroms, that is) is concerned.
Maybe if there were a 3rd movie. :trazz: But yeah, while I'd welcome Turtles in Space, I'd rather see the Turtles go darker, grittier, and more "crime noir" than "sci-fi" should there be a sequel.
ToTheNines
06-29-2007, 10:33 AM
Turtles in Space can wait till the 3rd movie, and even then I would prefer for them to stay in NY.
I tend to agree with the majority. Although the Triceraton story would be a good one, to have it as the basis for a possible sequel would be too soon. I think the turtles should stay in NYC and solidify their presence there in the minds of the viewers before venturing off into the unknown.
Besides, we have Karai's words from the film to think about.
I think it would be better if we had a CaW-type story and maybe have a Triceraton ship (or even an Utrom one) crashland in Central Park at the end. That'll get things rolling for a turtles in space movie.
johnnyblaze
06-29-2007, 10:51 AM
I remember reading, it may have actually been in his thread, that a space adventure and a time travel adventure were some of the ideas that Kevin Munroe talked to Laird about that Laird wasn't fond of
ToTheNines
06-29-2007, 10:59 AM
He wasn't fond of it for the first movie of this re-boot, he wanted to ground the central characters in the proper environment, get off on the right foot.
Spike Spiegel
06-29-2007, 11:45 AM
I would say that a Turtles in Space film would be cool, but I want the locales and elements to be fully established like in the first movie (and the first season of 2k3). What made the storyarc so great in the comics and on the show was that they actually had an established "home" to get back to. I want to see more New York/Foot/crime-fighting storyline, then maybe it would be a reasonably good idea.
If there is a Turtles in Space themed movie, you don't want it to be too soon, right? The last thing you want is to have another "Next Mutation," right? (Some people here have also compared TNM to TMNT III, but I still greatly enjoyed the movie:P )
odupianist
06-29-2007, 12:28 PM
It's a good idea but tagging along with the bandwagon, they've over done the big sci-fi stuff already. The cartoon was a good medium for it. Third movie would definitely be a possibility, but we haven't seen the Foot in some time, since season 4 of the new toon. We've had a whole season and a movie with minimal Foot presence.
jenna
06-29-2007, 12:29 PM
I voted no, for a number of reasons:
1. commercially the turtles will be harder to relate to for a wider audience of those less familiar with the comics / 2k3 arm of the franchise, which could harm profits and success of the film, and subsequently the longevity of the turtles in pop culture;
2. although I love it, it is one of my less favoured story arcs;
3. I love (and that is LOVE) the more gritty stuff set in NYC. My ideals turtles film would reflect the atmospher of the teaser trailer - where NYC itself is practically a character.
In conclusion, have the turtles fighting human enemies (Foot) in a city on earth (NYC) with as little sci-fi elements as possible (with the obvious exception of the mutated turtles and rat) and you have a box office winner which will also please the fans and Joe-Bloggs general public alike.
MoreCowbell5263
06-29-2007, 12:55 PM
I'm gonna say nay, as much as I like the OT and the NT, what bothered me about the OT were all the episodes with weird aliens. Most of them weren't needed. The only sci-fi, other than the idea of mutant turtles and rats, that I wanna see is Don's technology.
Scandia
06-29-2007, 01:19 PM
Yeppers, for a while it seemed that the OT was simply episodes featuring alien after alien and mad scientist after mad scientist. That there was no coherence whatsoever. Some villains were seen once and never again.
Normally I like the turtles to be in NY fighting ninjas or crime, but if they're to do a sequel I'd really like them to reimagine issues 4-6 from the original comic. Utroms, Triceratons, Federation, Fugitoid... it could be the kickstart this franchise needs.
I just think Turtles in Space would cover all the bases. About 1/3 of the movie would take place in NY, so those who like that setting won't miss out. The rest would be sort of like Star Wars. This would reach those original comic fans, the new movie fans, and even the old cartoon fans. They can work Krang to be one of the utroms (possibly Krang in name only). Bebop and Rocksteady can be bit part or cameo bounty hunters in outer space so they don't look too out of place.
The only thing the movie would lack would be Shredder, which many fans wouldn't mind in the least, but I know even more fans and general movie goers want to see him. The third movie can come back to earth and do City at War so at least fans would get their foot clan ninjas back.
Just an idea. What do you guys think. Turtles in space yay or nay?
Not a bad idea for a movie adventure, but 'TiS' really does seem to be too much too soon. However, it would be a convenient setup for my idea of the Turtles being away from New York when Shredder is revived, and he starts tearing up the city trying to find them while the Turtles are too preoccupied to notice. Just a trip to April and/or Casey's farmhouse to seclude them from the news seems like a rather boring way to accomplish this. But, my hopes for a sequel are that Shredder is revived and causing strife, but he's a secondary plot and not seen interacting with the Turtles at all. It would be a lead-in to a third TMNT CG that the classic-'toon-only fans would love, and only a handful of Mirage-faithful would be too elitist to enjoy.
We still haven't seen an utrom or a triceraton. I think it's because they wanted the first movie to be as realistic as possible.
Then, what possessed them to go with '13 monsters'? :lol: I'd like to see them do something more believable than that too before jumping into sci-fi territory, Neutrino. :)
I do wonder why, if Triceratons have such a big role in the TMNT Mirage Comics, why were they not shown AT ALL in the OT or the movies.
In the classic 'toon, the Triceratons planned to invade but changed their minds before even letting their presence be known in the Season 7 ep, "NIGHT OF THE DARK TURTLE". It really was a lack-luster way to incorporate them into the show.
MORE Raph & Leo arguments! WOO!!
Wasn't it unanimously decided that there was too much of that in the movies? O_o
Altho Triceratons would be nice in the movie we'll have the DVD with the cut out scenes that mention em in August.
They'll probably include that on the Australian Deluxe Edition, but latest official word suggests that the rest of the world is still only getting the three: alternate intro, alternate ending, and Mikey getting some cake for his dad. :ohwell:
Scandia
06-29-2007, 05:54 PM
I have not watched season 7 of the OT. I only watched the first 4 seasons before it changed stations for some reason. Plus I was totally booked with activities back then.
I do not want to see any more Raph vs. Leo arguments in future movies. They have given us enough. Plus Splinter told Raph that he is just as loved as the rest of his brothers. So that should reassure him enough.
Avatar Yuffie
06-29-2007, 07:00 PM
I just don't like the idea that ninjakens, sais, bos and chucks are at par with hi-tech plasma blasters.
But if Leo gets a beam saber out of this, I'll watch it. :D
Swany
06-29-2007, 07:24 PM
Nay, its all been done anyhoo. I prefer seeing them in NY. Its where their home is and I like seeing the guys at home 'casue its their only real chance to relax and let their guards down.
Plus other reasons I cant think of now 'cause Its late and I'm tired. To quote John Proctor "I'll think on it"
Revan
06-29-2007, 08:33 PM
You guys just have no imagination
That's not it at all. It's just that I want to see what's best for the franchise. Everyone thinks they've got the answer and many people's opinions differ. I just feel that a return to realism would be better for tmnt than would having a space adventure.
SimplerSimon
06-29-2007, 10:09 PM
I know space/time travel is an established part of the TMNT mythos, but it's something really hard for the casual fan to accept without a lot of preparation and development. The 2K3 series tried its best with the gradual introduction of the Utroms leading up to Turtles in Space, and even that only semi-worked for me when it premired.
I feel the new TMNT already used up its chance at a sci-fi related adventure, and did so rather sloppily. The next one should be gritty, but it doesn't mean it has to be the famed CaW storyline. There's other options of course.
ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
06-30-2007, 03:43 AM
That's not it at all. It's just that I want to see what's best for the franchise. Everyone thinks they've got the answer and many people's opinions differ. I just feel that a return to realism would be better for tmnt than would having a space adventure.
The thing about TMNT is, to accept the fact that it's about mutant talking ninja turtles, you're already throwing realism out the window. I just really see no point in constantly keeping them "grounded in reality" by having them fight human enemies. I'm not saying theres anything wrong with it, either way, the Turtles are kicking ass. But with "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" as the title, you can't fully keep it in reality.
The world is a ****ed up place. Sometimes we need an escape. That's why I love the franchise, you don't know what to expect they could be fighting aliens, robots, demons, or just common muggers. All the while I'm just thinking, this is what reality should be.
MoreCowbell5263
06-30-2007, 04:30 PM
Because the world is so ****ed up is another reason the Turtles fighting criminals in New York City, a.k.a. the people you think of when someone mentions the kind of people who make the world a ****ed up place, is a good idea. It's good to watch a movie where the world is being made a slightly better place because the people who make it as bad a place as you say it is are getting the butts kicked by turtles who mutated and were trained as ninjas. I know what people are saying, because the idea of mutant ninja turtles are hard enough to grasp in real life as it is, but I don't think making something that's somewhat sci-fi and then just totally overhauling the entire movie with sci-fi stuff like aliens and other galaxies and other interdimensional ideas like that would just be too much. The turtles are very relatable as characters and that has played a big part in their success as a franchise. If you put them on an intergalactic quest to save the entire universe, that might be a bit much, because even little kids these days don't dream of saving entire galaxies. Saving the city is good because ordinary people can do that if they work hard and all that sappy speech stuff, but it is possible. Anyway, before I ramble more, I'll just wrap up by saying Turtles in Space is just a bit too much sci-fi, it makes the story and characters less relatable as people (or mutant turtles). This is why Superman was never a fan-favorite superhero as opposed to like Batman or Spider-Man, Superman just isn't relatable, he's too powerful he's literally perfect as a person, people find it hard to relate to him especially since a lot of his biggest foes are either aliens or Lex Luthor with Kryptonite. Sorry for making this so long, and I'm not trying to offend ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael, I just think aliens and space travel for the Turtles is a bit too much science-fiction.
ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
06-30-2007, 04:53 PM
Because the world is so ****ed up is another reason the Turtles fighting criminals in New York City, a.k.a. the people you think of when someone mentions the kind of people who make the world a ****ed up place, is a good idea. It's good to watch a movie where the world is being made a slightly better place because the people who make it as bad a place as you say it is are getting the butts kicked by turtles who mutated and were trained as ninjas. I know what people are saying, because the idea of mutant ninja turtles are hard enough to grasp in real life as it is, but I don't think making something that's somewhat sci-fi and then just totally overhauling the entire movie with sci-fi stuff like aliens and other galaxies and other interdimensional ideas like that would just be too much. The turtles are very relatable as characters and that has played a big part in their success as a franchise. If you put them on an intergalactic quest to save the entire universe, that might be a bit much, because even little kids these days don't dream of saving entire galaxies. Saving the city is good because ordinary people can do that if they work hard and all that sappy speech stuff, but it is possible. Anyway, before I ramble more, I'll just wrap up by saying Turtles in Space is just a bit too much sci-fi, it makes the story and characters less relatable as people (or mutant turtles). This is why Superman was never a fan-favorite superhero as opposed to like Batman or Spider-Man, Superman just isn't relatable, he's too powerful he's literally perfect as a person, people find it hard to relate to him especially since a lot of his biggest foes are either aliens or Lex Luthor with Kryptonite. Sorry for making this so long, and I'm not trying to offend ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael, I just think aliens and space travel for the Turtles is a bit too much science-fiction.
First off, Superman is not perfect. This has already been brought up so many times in the comics. Supes was never meant to be the "hero with issues" that Spider-Man is. He's supposed to be that archtype hero that people rally around for hope and support. Thats what gives Superman his appeal. And I stand by my belief that you have to relate to a character to like them, none of us can relate to Batman, or Spider-Man(anymore), yet we still love the characters.
But back to the Turtles. No matter if you take out the aliens and the monsters, which have been part of Turtles lore since the begining, It's still a scifi property. You're main characters are mutated Turtles and a mutated rat. What keeps theTurtles grounded is they're personalities. They don't have delusions of grandure. They know they're limitations, they're not the Justice League and they know it. **** happes, whether it be down-to-Earth, or Otherworldly. If it comes to them, they deal with it, and go on trying to live a semi-normal life.
Making them fight humans all the time isn't gonna turn it into a crime drama or something like that. You cna still relate to the characters, having aliens isn't gonna change that. Leo's still gonna be Leo, Don's still gonna be Don, Mikey's still gonna be Mikey, and Raph's still gonna be Raph.
Spitfire
06-30-2007, 05:09 PM
The cartoon version of this arc was horrid and I can't watch it anymore.
The comic version is okay but I got bored reading it after watching the cartoon version. It was still cool though. I don't know if it would work for a movie.
See the Fuigitoid back story is very important and I believe if a movie version was made they'd need to touch on that in the very first scene. And TMNT fans would be pissed if they came to watch a TMNT movie and they had to wait like 15 minutes to see the turtles.
Plus they'd have to do the whole, Splinter Utrom thing and that would be impossible to fit all in like 90 minutes.
I'm sick of these comic adapts that don't live up to the issue, they need to focus on new stories because that's what good in the new toon.
Avatar Yuffie
07-01-2007, 12:41 AM
I simply just don't like aliens attacking the earth stories. Even in Justice League.
I'm still hoping for Rat King, Leatherhead and Usagi to make their movie debuts.
Andrew NDB
07-01-2007, 04:52 PM
I simply just don't like aliens attacking the earth stories. Even in Justice League.
Well, it makes sense with the Justice League -- the very idea of the League is that they band together to deal with the uber threats that they can't handle alone. In many cases this involves otherworldly menaces.
Avatar Yuffie
07-01-2007, 05:26 PM
Well, yeah, alien invasions in Justice League makes more sense. As three of their members are aliens, and Green Lantern works with an intergalactic group.
But I still don't like it. As they're sort of repetetive and tiresome... I mean, the series starts with an alien invasion, the series ends with an alien invasion. It's a little too much.
BigApple3AM
07-01-2007, 06:40 PM
I didn't like the TMNT cgi movie all that much. My reasoning for taking them into space was even for a first movie they didn't want to just have the turtles fighting foot soldiers or crime in NY. They had to have a sci-fi/fantasy situation with 13 monsters. I just don't think they're going to become more grounded for a sequel. Almost every blockbuster/comic book movie that has a sequel tries to take the original and make it even bigger and flashier. It usually isn't a good thing, but that's not the point. The point is the studio making TMNT 2 is going to want the same thing, and rather than have them time travel or whatever, I think recreating turtles in space would be the best option.
But I'm with everyone who wants a down to earth gritty turtles movie like the 90's film. Except... they're using CGI. The whole point of using CGI with turtles was to make it more over the top and appeal to kids/families. If we're going to just have turtles fight ninjas for an hour, might as well make it live action.
Avatar Yuffie
07-10-2007, 04:46 AM
First off, Superman is not perfect. This has already been brought up so many times in the comics. Supes was never meant to be the "hero with issues" that Spider-Man is.
I actually like Bill's take on Superman in the "Kill Bill" movie actually: Clark Kent is how Superman sees the human race.
A pessimistic view, really, but I quite agree.
Coola Yagami
07-11-2007, 11:00 PM
I still think the 'prequel' comics should be taken with a grain of salt.... Triceraton helmet or no Triceraton helmet, the Triceratons are too bad-ass for the movie to just like 'oh, we fought them before, whatever'. If they are to appear in a movie sequel they need to be properly introduced and everything.
It's like making Superman Returns, another loose sequel, and have Lois Lane casually mention how Superman already defeated Braniac and Doomsday 'way back then' or something.
Spawn Guy
07-12-2007, 08:20 AM
I actually like Bill's take on Superman in the "Kill Bill" movie actually: Clark Kent is how Superman sees the human race.
Not anymore.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.