View Full Version : Highly Irritating Review
a_big_apple
07-12-2007, 02:11 PM
I was puttering around the internet this morning, and found this really, REALLY frustrating review of the new movie (http://www.tvguide.com/movies/teenage-mutant-ninja/review/286990) on tvguide.com. It drove me absolutely crazy. Naturally, I decided I should share the pain.
ToTheNines
07-12-2007, 02:19 PM
The Foot Patrol.... WHAT THE ****? Angel Cohn needs to stop writing reviews about some **** he/she dosen't even know **** about and go to hell.... forever. They bitch about the dumbest stuff, no more "cool lingo" or pizza gobbling, and the turtles call each other by shortend names OMGZZZ. I'm done.
Raziel
07-12-2007, 02:20 PM
Haah, I don't think he even knows what a longtime fan means. Longtime fan at least knows the '87 ain't the only cartoon out there.
a_big_apple
07-12-2007, 02:26 PM
Haah, I don't think he even knows what a longtime fan means. Longtime fan at least knows the '87 ain't the only cartoon out there.
Not to mention the fact that the '87 cartoon came from a comic book. In which they often call each other by their nicknames. I think what frustrated me most about this article was that the writer doesn't seem to have any concept of TMNT canon or history, and judging a new movie based on the old toon and old movies isn't exactly a valid way to review it.
ToTheNines
07-12-2007, 02:42 PM
By "long-time fan" he means long time ago.
It's amazing how stupid people can be.
"Foot Patrol." Holy Hell, that's laughable. It's been "Foot Clan" for over 25 years yet this jamoke prints it otherwise. Oh, and "TMNT" is "edgy." Really? Gee, I always thought something edgy was something that was taboo. An acronym is hardly taboo unless it spells out a body part that dwells below the belt line. "TMNT" has always been used by fans and the short-lived, ill-fated Image series used it as its title. It's hardly edgy.
Then there's the mention of their names shortened for "hipiness" (now THAT'S edgy! :roll: ). They've done that for more than 25 years, too. How can anything be hip if it's been done decades ago? Wouldn't it be considered retro in that case? This person is a writer and has this many definitive errors? Shameful.
And now the greatest of them all, saying that the hand-to-hand combat made the TMNT unique. Wow! I thought it was turtles mutated into bipedal creatures who learned ninjitsu that made it unique! Holy sh*t, was I wrong!
Moron.
Swany
07-12-2007, 03:29 PM
Oh my giddy aunt.
Though I pretty much agree with everything KROW has said. What an idiot.
CyberCubed
07-12-2007, 03:49 PM
Its pretty sad this moron thinks the turtles names were shortened to "Leo" and "Raph" to modernize them. Does this fool remember they used their nicknames in the original movies as well?
And how stupid do you have to be to think the name was shortened to "TMNT" to be edgy, when that was always used as an abbreviation for the title?
It just shows how disconnected people are from TMNT, and it isn't their fault per se, but the least the guy could do is not act like a dumbass and bash Munroe for "shortening" the turtles names.
PipingPringle
07-12-2007, 03:59 PM
Wow, you'd think someone would put a little research in before writing something like that. boo!
SassyGal
07-12-2007, 04:03 PM
OMG the ignorant reviews continue...there is just so many wrong things in this that my brain may actually implode. I agree with everything Krow said...it's so depressing when stupid people review somthing they no nothing about.
Seriously, what a knob.
MoreCowbell5263
07-12-2007, 04:04 PM
Bashing the Turtles for shortening the names is definitely kinda stupid, I mean if I had friends or brothers whose names had 3 or more syllables, I wouldn't waste my energy pronouncing all 5 in Michelangelo all the time or 4 on Donatello when I could just say Mike or Don or Donnie or something. Apparently, Raphael is shortened to Raf, not Raph, so correct me if I'm wrong there, but I always thought it was spelt Raphael not Rafael.
In the article he says the Turtles "definitely needed re-vamping" or something to that degree, and then he bashes the movie for trying to "modernize" them. I know his complaints on modernizing them were stupid, but in the article, even said they needed to modernize them, or re-vamp them in other words. Strikes me as hypocritical.
I'm gobsmacked. All these years, I thought it was the 'family of mutant ninja turtles' part of TMNT that made them unique. Now, I learn the truth-- it was the hand to hand combat! Oh TMNT, I never understood thee. :cry:
Seriously, tho. Don't sweat this review. Even casual turtle fans will laugh at this review for complaining about high-octane action, shortened names, and generally being less 'kiddie.'
Ava Collier
07-12-2007, 06:16 PM
I wanted to say something...
but...but...
KROW already said it.
Naturally, I decided I should share the pain.
Bless your heart. May it never be said that you aren't generous. ^_^
a_big_apple
07-13-2007, 03:00 AM
Bless your heart. May it never be said that you aren't generous. ^_^
Maybe there should be a Dromie award for that next time around! "Most Generous With Pain."
Spitfire
07-13-2007, 03:26 AM
I find it funny how they give him crap for not making it exactly like the old cartoon. Way to go!
Proves my point that movie go'ers are idiots.
At least this person isn't any worse this this one critic on RT who always says movies are bad because of homosexual references that don't exist. Like Spider-man 3 for example she said was bad because Harry and Peter had a homo erotic relationship. That's not why it sucked but oh boy was she convinced.
Anarky
07-13-2007, 04:10 AM
Oh, hell, there's a couple bad mistakes in there. I wonder if his factchecking department is already going nuts, since his article has about the same factual accuracy as someone's inane copypaste-journalism.
But you can't call a man an idiot or worse just because he wants his 87-toon back. Sure, those times have passed, but some still would want to see more goofy, lighthearted nonsense. And for a bunch who is constantly misunderstood by the mainstream ("Heh, you like kiddie-stuff!") while yearning for tolerance, you sure are an intolerant bunch yourselves. How do you expect things to ever get better with double standards like that?
a_big_apple
07-13-2007, 08:07 AM
It's not the desire to have the OT back that frustrates me, though, it's the lack of fact-checking, and the lack of openmindedness. I know reviews are all opinion, anyway, but they should at least be based on an openminded viewing of the movie. This particular review is mostly criticizing TMNT for not meeting the reviewer's expectation, rather than for any actual problems with the plot, or characterization, or animation.
NightwatchersOnlygirl
07-13-2007, 09:26 AM
I conld done better So rude about Nightwatcher and Raphael
Oh, hell, there's a couple bad mistakes in there. I wonder if his factchecking department is already going nuts, since his article has about the same factual accuracy as someone's inane copypaste-journalism.
But you can't call a man an idiot or worse just because he wants his 87-toon back. Sure, those times have passed, but some still would want to see more goofy, lighthearted nonsense. And for a bunch who is constantly misunderstood by the mainstream ("Heh, you like kiddie-stuff!") while yearning for tolerance, you sure are an intolerant bunch yourselves. How do you expect things to ever get better with double standards like that?
True enough. Though I tagged him a moron because of his inaccuracy. If you're gonna badmouth something, at least get it right, ya' know? Heh. And I never expect things to get better with movie critics. There will always be a handful who are going to crank out stupidity. Like Ron White said, "You can't fix stupid."
I conld done better
I believe it!
Courk
07-13-2007, 10:59 AM
I barely remember the old toon, but for as long as I've known TMNT, I've known their nicknames. Did they really not use the nicknames in the old toon? I feel sorry for every voice actor who had to say "Michelangelo" -- what a mouthful!
I only skimmed the review, but I agree with wanting more ninja hand-to-hand combat, though I doubt I can ever really get my fill of that. :-)
johnnyblaze
07-13-2007, 12:22 PM
yeah thinking back I think the only medium they didnt use nicknames was the OT
How do you expect things to ever get better with double standards like that?
Kinda surprised you were the one to say it, but 'yay for wisdom!' ^_^
It's not the desire to have the OT back that frustrates me, though, it's the lack of fact-checking, and the lack of openmindedness.
Hear (sp?), hear (sp?)! How many times did they say in the movie that Leo was in 'South America', and the dufus went and put 'Mexico' anyway? Mexico is part of the continent of North America. So, this is like calling Africa a country. :roll:
But you can't call a man an idiot or worse just because he wants his 87-toon back. Sure, those times have passed, but some still would want to see more goofy, lighthearted nonsense. And for a bunch who is constantly misunderstood by the mainstream ("Heh, you like kiddie-stuff!") while yearning for tolerance, you sure are an intolerant bunch yourselves. How do you expect things to ever get better with double standards like that?
"Kiddie" was his word. I really like the OT, but it's OK not to be exactly like the OT. TMNT has a lot of interpretations within the franchise, and I think that's awesome.
He's being willfully hateful about the film because it's not what he expected, in order to take a popular stance and at the same time try to look like he knows knows the franchise. The fact that he knows so little about the subject (new movie or OT) makes it seem that he probably would have taken the hateful stance even if it did meet his expectations. That's pretty closed-minded.
kerfootw
07-13-2007, 04:03 PM
This is why I laugh at the ditech.com commercial that says that people are smart. That review is but one small piece of proof out of numerous that contradicts that notion. Not saying you guys are of course, you've already proven that but to me, stupidity is like a plague that's grasping others bit by bit.
Buslady
07-13-2007, 06:40 PM
typical reviewer who knows nothing of the whole TMNT mythos. Screw them, we'll get our DVD and enjoy every second of it.
Foot Patrol?!??!!
:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
Jester
07-13-2007, 06:55 PM
I think it's a bit much to expect a movie reviewer to delve into the mythos of TMNT for a simple review...it's tantamount to reviewing the Spider-man, Superman, Batman, or X-men mythos to write a review on those movies. What I would like is a movie reviewer to put away all preconceived notions about a film and just watch it and review it. Then you don't have to worry about "It's not the 80's show" crap or the mean-spiritedness of Richard Roeper's E&R review of the film.
I think it's a bit much to expect a movie reviewer to delve into the mythos of TMNT for a simple review...
Very true, but the reviewer's evident unwillingness to make sure any of their facts are accurate (movie-related or not) saps their credibility. This is really nothing of concern, and I couldn't even force myself to waste the time to finish reading this review. With the plethora of more reliable reviews available, a person would have to be daft to forget their grain of salt when taking the word of a TV Guide review.
Jester
07-13-2007, 07:28 PM
True...it does smack of bad journalism...
xmen510
07-13-2007, 08:03 PM
Agree with many of the posts here. Ignorant and bad review.
Buslady
07-13-2007, 08:48 PM
Kinda surprised you were the one to say it, but 'yay for wisdom!' ^_^
Hear (sp?), hear (sp?)! How many times did they say in the movie that Leo was in 'South America', and the dufus went and put 'Mexico' anyway? Mexico is part of the continent of North America. So, this is like calling Africa a country. :roll:
Um none cos he was in Central America.
'Central'? :sweatdro: I thought he was in 'South'. :embarass: I wonder how I got that confused... But, contrary to popular belief, Mexico isn't the only country comprising Central America. In the April prequel book, Winters points at El Salvador on the map, saying the statue he's sending her after is somewhere around there. So, yeah... I goofed. *fires his fact-checking dept.* ^_^
Zog the Equalizer
07-14-2007, 11:23 AM
I honestly couldnt force myself to read the entire review. It was simply to idiotic and enrageing. May God have mercy on the soul of whoever wrote that.
jenna
07-14-2007, 04:43 PM
I haven't read it because I know I'll get mad and I don['t have the energy to be angry right now, but I will say this: I'm sick of people thinking that all there is is the OT. I love the OT, but very much see it as a branch-off rather than having the same validity as the original concept. We all know it was radically adapted to be suitable for kids and suffered further censorship - pretty heavily by season 3. If someone doesn't know that it was an adaption of a fairly adult comic they shouldn't be writing about it - and certainly not with any authority.
xmen510
07-14-2007, 05:05 PM
I agree with you jenna. The review just seemed to be a bash on something that people loved from the past and not an actual "review". They really did not seem to know anything about the product history despite what they claimed.
Coola Yagami
07-14-2007, 10:31 PM
true, but for most people outside of this forum, only having watched the old cartoon, the past 3 movies and buying some of the toys back then qualifies as knowing alot about the product history.
Small example... fans of the original Transformers. They ever saw or heard of Beast Wars. Suddenly, new live-action Transformers movie coming out...... but it's Beast Wars. All the old school fans that missed out on Beast Wars woulda been pissed that Prime was replaced by Primal and that Megatron is now a dinosaur.
ToTheNines
07-14-2007, 10:45 PM
Small example... fans of the original Transformers. They ever saw or heard of Beast Wars. Suddenly, new live-action Transformers movie coming out...... but it's Beast Wars. All the old school fans that missed out on Beast Wars woulda been pissed that Prime was replaced by Primal and that Megatron is now a dinosaur.
Say what, dude?
Coola Yagami
07-14-2007, 10:48 PM
I'm just saying some ppl only saw the old TMNT cartoon back in the day, never ever heard of the original comics or the 2K3/Fast Forward cartoon and were disappointed that the new movie wasn't about the TMNT facing Shredder and munching pizza and all the surfer speak, cause they didn't know better.
Just like how someone who only saw the original TF cartoon and never ever heard of Beast Wars would have been disappointed to hear there is a new TF movie comin out, only to find out that it was about Beast Wars.
ToTheNines
07-14-2007, 10:57 PM
But the new Transformers movie ain't about Beast Wars.
It's a hypothetical situation. Not the best (cuz I never enjoyed Transformers aside from the toys, yet I knew of Beast Wars), but that's what he was getting at. A hypothetical example. :)
I'm just saying some ppl only saw the old TMNT cartoon back in the day, never ever heard of the original comics or the 2K3/Fast Forward cartoon and were disappointed that the new movie wasn't about the TMNT facing Shredder and munching pizza and all the surfer speak, cause they didn't know better.
Exactly. He didn't know better. Bearing that in mind, his review shouldn't have had the missteps that it had due to his vast amount of misinformation. Regardless that the guy only heard or knew of the OT, it's not dubbed the friggin' Foot Patrol. My 10-year-old knows the difference and the TMNT doesn't hold the same influence on him as it did me at that age.
jenna
07-15-2007, 04:36 AM
I'm just saying some ppl only saw the old TMNT cartoon back in the day, never ever heard of the original comics or the 2K3/Fast Forward cartoon and were disappointed that the new movie wasn't about the TMNT facing Shredder and munching pizza and all the surfer speak, cause they didn't know better.
Just like how someone who only saw the original TF cartoon and never ever heard of Beast Wars would have been disappointed to hear there is a new TF movie comin out, only to find out that it was about Beast Wars.
I know what you are saying, but I don't see why anything shouldn't be allowed to evolve. We are talking about a phenomenon that happened 20 years ago - it's only natural that it would develop organically. Even Peter Laird accepts this - Fast Forward is an example.
For example, I was pretty annoyed when people said they were disappointed that the new TMNT film wasn't set in the 80s. Setting it in the 80s would be restricting it to a certain era, not allowing any growth and denying the on-going possibilities. TMNT has now become timeless and I love that. But like you say, there are the people who want Mike to be obsessed with pizza to the point where he can't talk about much else; Shredder to be an incompetent villain who never gets the job done; who think that Krang was the original utrom and who wonder what happened to the initials on the turtles' belts.
Even if there were no comics, if we hadn't had 2k3, I would still expect a TMNT film released now to have more levels than it had in the OT.
ToTheNines
07-15-2007, 11:21 AM
It's a hypothetical situation. Not the best (cuz I never enjoyed Transformers aside from the toys, yet I knew of Beast Wars), but that's what he was getting at. A hypothetical example. :)
Ok, I get it now.
Even if there were no comics, if we hadn't had 2k3, I would still expect a TMNT film released now to have more levels than it had in the OT.
Yep. I love to the OT, but I have to admit: It has really come back to haunt us.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.