PDA

View Full Version : Reflection: Through Rose Colored Glasses?


Ramboraph4life aka Matt
07-18-2007, 02:02 PM
Since the DVD is coming out soon...I've been thinking more and more about the film. And I have questioned myself about a few things. Now I like this movie. I like it. But do I like it because it's a ninja turtles movie, and a movie is better than nothing? Or do I like it because it's an actual awesome movie? Unfortunately....disappointment was the word that came to mind. So I'd have to choose the former.

Now I know I'll get hate mail. Bad comments. That's cool, I know this and I will deserve it. No problem. My main problem, for me, was too huge high hopes. I can't blame the filmmakers for that, and I won't. That part is my fault and no one elses. And there are good things.

Beautiful CGI....seeing the characters once again on the big screen....the Leo/Raph subplot.....the rooftop sequence.

But then I started thinking of things I wasn't too fond off. I know I'm alone on these faults...but hell I might as well admit it. The plot....plainly it sucked. I'm sorry...to me it did remind me of Ghostbusters and "The 13 Ghosts of Scooby Doo." That was a cartoon that had Scooby, Shaggy, Scrappy, and Daphne team up with a man voiced by Vincent Price to get 13 ghosts back into a treasure chest. Only in this case it's turtles getting monsters into the portal. It's just....there were many better stories, at least to me. City at War. Baxter Stockman/mouser storyline. Many people on the board have said other, better examples of storylines than the one used in this movie. And with it's short running time, it took up quiet a bit of room for something I didn't care about. I wanted to see more of the TMNT....not Winters.

The voices of the turtles.....wonderful! Everyone elses....kind of distracting. Maybe it's just me...it most likely is....but it took me out of the film to hear Buffy from April's mouth, and other celebrities. That's what it felt like...celebrities. They could/should have just went with unknowns...or just get Elias Koteas as Casey or Paige Turco as April. I don't think they are that busy...and my guess would be they weren't asked. Maybe I'm wrong about that...but that would be my guess.

But...I think Casey and April should have been put into the sequel...let this first one concentrate even more on the turtles. If there's a sequel, then you could expand with Casey and April. But their screen time in this unbelievably short film (what like 80 minutes?) could have been used for Mikey and Donny. Extra scenes to bump up their characters. Have more different interactions (Mike/Raph.....Don/Leo, etc.) with the family. The story was too much for a short time.

And this next one is a fanboy (and I am one in the horrible, nerdy sense) nitpick. I really, really would have loved Mikey/Raph interaction. Either I have a crappy memory, which I may, or did Raph and Mikey not have ONE conversation between the two of them. Just Raph and Mikey bantering with each other. I love Raph and Mikey banter...it's like the 'buddy-cop' thing. They annoy each other but they're the best of friends, that sort of thing. And that scene where Mikey is watching Raph and Splinter from afar could have been wonderful...they just didn't take the extra step. They build up the Mikey liking Nightwatcher stuff...but a cool scene (Mikey finding out his brother IS the same guy he's been idolizing) that could have been, became a missed opportunity. At least to me. Again a fanboy nitpick.

Another thing....that Leo/Raph resolution to their story....when Raph gets Leo out at the end. Is it just me, or did there need to be just one more scene between the two of them at the end. After all is done, the both of them having one final heart to heart scene....even if it was brief.

And yeah the CGI is beautiful....but I am in the catergory of "wishing it was live action." I know that makes me single-minded....and the animation is top notch. It's more about....well I guess just the fact I know that it seems likely there won't be anymore live action TMNT movies. When a sequel comes around...it'll be CGI no question about it. If they did make another live action film it would be a very LONG time. It became almost 20 years (17 to be exact) for another movie to hit the screen. I guess I just would have liked one more live action on that big screen. I can't blame the animators though, they did a bang up job. Sorry if that sounded stupid and confusing...it's hard to put into words.

I know reading all this would make you think I hate the movie. I like it...I'll buy it on DVD. I remember posting a review many months ago saying how much I LOVED it. Then I realized....I was looking through rose colored glasses. I didn't want to just like the movie....I wanted to LOVE this movie. But I can't say that with an honest face. I like it, but I don't love it. Sorry if that doesn't make sense. I realize the blame lies on me....I put too high expectation on it (although I REALLY wanted Raph/Mikey scenes lol :) )

Anyway I apologize if any of this offended anybody in any way. I don't want that to happen. This was more of a "get it off my chest" kind of way. If you agree, cool. If you don't agree, cool. Thanks for the time.

The Shelf
07-18-2007, 02:16 PM
You make a lot of valid points, and I think I agree a lot of them.

On the other hand, TMNT is the only movie I've ever watched where I literally smiled throughout the entire movie. I just couldn't help myself.

jenna
07-18-2007, 02:21 PM
I also agree with most of what you said, but I think there is a lot to be said for loving the film just because it is a tmnt film. Like The Shelf, I grinned throughout the whole thing and loved every second, even though some of it wasn't particularly sophisticated in content and that it didn't even come close to being my perfect tmnt film, but I still loved it and still saw it 9 times (God I'm a LOSER!!) because it was tmnt and it passed the test for me that films 2 and 3 failed. The character design and VAs were enough to keep me hooked in a way and although there is so much more that I would have liked to have seen, and a bit of the silliness I would have liked not to have seen (monsters etc), I love it.

Anyway I apologize if any of this offended anybody in any way. I don't want that to happen. This was more of a "get it off my chest" kind of way. If you agree, cool. If you don't agree, cool. Thanks for the time.

None of that now. You are allowed to not like the film or be disappointed by it. There are plenty of people who were disappointed and you shouldn't feel that you're not entitled to your views or to express them. :)

CyberCubed
07-18-2007, 03:04 PM
I didn't mind the monster plot at all, since it didn't even comprise as much of the movie as I thought it would.

A big complaint I think everyone has is the misuse of Mikey and Don. (especially Don).

For a movie that's based on the TMNT, it sure felt like the "Leo and Raph movie!" with Mike and Don as the supporting cast. Now, even Movie 1 focused on Leo/Raph more than the others, but Mike and Don still had a LOT of good scenes in the original film. You can't say the same here.

Basically, the movie should have given more screentime to Mike and Don. Flesh them out a bit more, and some more action scenes. Otherwise I was content, I didn't mind the monster plot and everything else was fine.

Dr. Doom
07-18-2007, 03:06 PM
In my opinion, it's easily the best movie as far as overall quality goes. And I really don't regret for one second the decision to have it be fully animated. It's far eaiser to immerse yourself in the setting and the story when everything is animated, as opposed to having live actors interact poorly with 3D models or rubbers suits with animatronics. Don't get me wrong, the Henson stuff was great at the time, but I think fully animated was definitely the right decision. And it was done gorgeously.

iris
07-18-2007, 04:25 PM
O 'TMNT', do I love you because you're wonderful, or are you wonderful because I love you? Are you the sweet invention of a TMNT-lover's dream, or are you just as wonderful as--

Wait a sec, you are the sweet invention of a TMNT-lover's dream.

Nevermind then.

Carry on.


So, the movie wasn't perfect. I found SMG distracting, and the overall story pacing was a bit off (seemingly due to editorial scene-slashing). But it was still a damn good movie that I was thrilled to see in the theatres.

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
07-18-2007, 04:52 PM
The Shelf: Yeah I smiled at parts too, so that should count for something.

jenna: Thank you for the smiley face :)

Cybercubed: I agree about Mike and Don (good intros though, I gotta admit)

Dr. Doom: I understand what you're saying about animation. I wonder if it's more "nostalgia" factor to me, about why I like the suits more I mean. I guess if they looked pretty good in 1990...how good could they look 17 years later (better technology, etc.). Still, I can understand what you mean about the animation. I guess it's more personal liking than anything else.

iris: lol yeah you're right, I did get a little too 'artsy-fartsy' with that opening in my post. sorry bout that :P

Janus Prospero
07-18-2007, 04:54 PM
I think you have very valid opinions here. I certainly don't agree with a lot of what you're saying. I for one, welcome our CGI overlords with open arms. Additionally I didn't find SMG or Stewart distracting (which, just AMAZES me because Stewart's voice is very distinct.)

However, I'm totally feeling you on the "fleshing out the brother's relationships" sort of thing. I would have loved to have seen some Raph/Mike interaction. Although I can sorta understand them wanting Raph and Leo to interact most with each other in order to draw attention to that conflict. But still, we should have had some Don and Mike interaction, perhaps with each other showing some scene where they're dealing with the Raph/Leo thing. In my head I kind of imagine Raph arguing that they need to back him up when he rushes to fight and Leo on the other side arguing that they need to follow his orders, and they're both stuck in the middle.

I really wanted to comment on this though:
The plot....plainly it sucked. I'm sorry...to me it did remind me of Ghostbusters and "The 13 Ghosts of Scooby Doo." That was a cartoon that had Scooby, Shaggy, Scrappy, and Daphne team up with a man voiced by Vincent Price to get 13 ghosts back into a treasure chest. Only in this case it's turtles getting monsters into the portal. It's just....there were many better stories, at least to me. City at War. Baxter Stockman/mouser storyline. Many people on the board have said other, better examples of storylines than the one used in this movie. And with it's short running time, it took up quiet a bit of room for something I didn't care about. I wanted to see more of the TMNT....not Winters.
I will admit that of the two main conflicts of the movie, the monster part is certainly the less interesting one. I love Raphael and Leonardo and their whole dynamic, so I was eating that stuff up!

I wouldn't say that the monster plot sucked. It carried a theme of brotherhood, that connected it to the turtles plot (although I feel they could have done more with this if the movie was a bit longer.) And mostly, I feel like the plot followed in the spirit of the comics. The turtles have always endured insane sci-fi/fantasy stories. There is no reason to deny that in the movies. That's sort of the reason why I don't mind the time travel aspect of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III [that movie bothers me for many other reasons].

I can see the City of War suggestion because that story rocked the house. What's more, I feel it would have made perfect sense to use the City of War idea in the new movie. With Leo away training and the turtles forbade from fighting, of course crime was going to get out of control. This would have been an even greater motivation for Raph to go all vigilante, and for April to urge Leo to come back. ::closes eyes:: That would have been freakin' sweet.

But I am really perplexed at your suggestion to use the Baxter/Mouser sub plot. Aren't you just removing your rose colored glasses only to find that you're wearing an extra pair, blinded by your attachment to the story? I mean, as it's from the original comics, I'm attached to that story too, but I don't think it is any better or worse than the monster plot.

triplexxx
07-18-2007, 05:54 PM
I didn't mind the monster plot at all, since it didn't even comprise as much of the movie as I thought it would.

A big complaint I think everyone has is the misuse of Mikey and Don. (especially Don).

For a movie that's based on the TMNT, it sure felt like the "Leo and Raph movie!" with Mike and Don as the supporting cast. Now, even Movie 1 focused on Leo/Raph more than the others, but Mike and Don still had a LOT of good scenes in the original film. You can't say the same here.

Basically, the movie should have given more screentime to Mike and Don. Flesh them out a bit more, and some more action scenes. Otherwise I was content, I didn't mind the monster plot and everything else was fine.
Well, I don't know why people keep complaining about that. I think they got a fair share of dialog and a good deal of time, and they got to kick ass as much as Leonardo and Raphael. The only scene I felt belonged to L and R was their rooftop fight, and that went by pretty quickly. Every turtle got a fair share in the movie.

Ramboraph4life aka Matt
07-18-2007, 06:32 PM
Janus: Hmm...the more I think about it I must say I stand corrected on what you said about the "Baxter storyline" part I posted. I must admit I personally like that story better than the monster one...but I agree, that one would be more of a personal opinion of mine than anything else. And you are correct...there were a lot of sci-fi type stories that the turtles endured through (the Fugitoid arc being a prime example of that). I guess for me personally I was always more interested in the...well realistic sounds stupid when talking about a comic with 4 walking, talking, ninja turtles (and even more so when I suggested the "Baxter storyline" lol :P )...but movies like X-Men, Batman Begins, etc. went through my mind. It's stories that are unrealistic (mutants, etc.)...and yet in a way trying to be a little more serious/realistic (the Leo/Raph storyline though I thought worked very well). If that makes sense....probably not since I already confused myself on the whole matter lol. But that is more my own fault than the filmmakers. I understand, but just happen to disagree.


triplexxx: My thoughts on that....lol I just wanted to see Raph/Mikey interaction...but I also have the comics, fanfiction, cartoons, etc. for that so I should stop bitching and getting on everyone's nerves with that whole thing lol :P. Anyway, I think what people mean about the lack of Mikey and Donny is...well the story, when not with the monsters, dealt a lot with Leo returning home and Raph as the Nightwatcher. They both had a dramatic arc in a way....although it was pretty much the same as in the 1990 film (but I still enjoyed it). Maybe some wanted Mikey and Donny to have a sort of arc as well....to see growth and change from who they were at the beginning to who they were at the end. Or on the other end, hardcore Mikey and Donny fans wanted to see those two sort of headline there own story in a kind of dramatic manner. Like in a way, Leo and Raph did in this one and in the 1990 version. In that matter I absolutely agree, I mean we all want to see our favorite characters get a cool dramatic storyline for themselves. Hopefully in the sequel that can happen for Don and Mikey. So i can understand that argument...but I do agree with you triplexxx they did have good moments (like i said their intros were perfect for those characters).

And if all of this seems like I should just shut up and take a hike...please feel free to say so, so I don't make myself unwelcome lol :P .

Dr. Doom
07-18-2007, 08:15 PM
Well, I don't know why people keep complaining about that. I think they got a fair share of dialog and a good deal of time, and they got to kick ass as much as Leonardo and Raphael. The only scene I felt belonged to L and R was their rooftop fight, and that went by pretty quickly. Every turtle got a fair share in the movie.

What movie were you watching?

johnnyblaze
07-19-2007, 07:14 AM
it may not have been a great film in the classic sense but it was a great Ninja Turtles film. For me it captured what makes the turtles so fun and interesting to follow and overall it gave great justice to the boys and their universe. I want more damn it!

Masked Ninja
07-19-2007, 09:42 AM
I agree that the monster plot sucked, and we needed some more Mikey and Donny... but for me, the animation (mostly), "brother"-themed subplot and rooftop fight made up for it. I think the perfect TMNT movie is still out there, waiting to be made, but this was a decent shot at it. :tpizza:

johnnyblaze
07-19-2007, 11:55 AM
I thought the family aspect was nailed (although like everyone else I would have loved more Don and Mike)

Janus Prospero
07-19-2007, 12:01 PM
I guess for me personally I was always more interested in the...well realistic sounds stupid when talking about a comic with 4 walking, talking, ninja turtles (and even more so when I suggested the "Baxter storyline" lol :P )...but movies like X-Men, Batman Begins, etc. went through my mind. It's stories that are unrealistic (mutants, etc.)...and yet in a way trying to be a little more serious/realistic (the Leo/Raph storyline though I thought worked very well). If that makes sense....probably not since I already confused myself on the whole matter lol.
Nah, I totally grok what you're saying. ;)

jenna
07-19-2007, 01:51 PM
I agree that the monster plot sucked, and we needed some more Mikey and Donny... but for me, the animation (mostly), "brother"-themed subplot and rooftop fight made up for it. I think the perfect TMNT movie is still out there, waiting to be made, but this was a decent shot at it. :tpizza:

I totally agree with you. Word for word.

And I meant to say earlier, I think the CG option was brilliant for the tmnt. The life action was great but for the design of the turtles themselves was so awesome. For me, they were perfect.

odupianist
07-19-2007, 02:07 PM
I think the Foot rooftop fight could have been longer and more detailed. I had already seen the clip on IGN before the movie, so I figured the scene might be longer. I was disappointed when it wasn't :(

Rooish
07-19-2007, 04:46 PM
I agree with jenna and Masked Ninja in general, but I sort of thought the family subplot wasn't done too great either. I didn't really feel the closeness so much as hear it repeated over and over. I think the first movie did better with the family aspect.

triplexxx
07-19-2007, 04:47 PM
What movie were you watching?
If you don't agree with me, that's fine. But I still think what I think for a reason. Maybe Donatello and Michaelangelo didn't have much of a part in the Leonardo/Raphael conflict, but they were still part of the plot, which was about the whole turtle family reuniting, not just two of them. And if you think about it, they each had their significance too. I mean, Michaelangelo expressed his own individual internal conflict about his desire to go back to his crime-fighting days when watching the news about the Nightwatcher and talking about his "guns", and he gets his wish in the end. Donatello, while he might not have had a personal conflict, he was the one who figured out Winter's plot (the planetary alignment, the portal, and the monsters) and where and when, and that the Legend of Yaotl was true. And their fight with the generals at the end was the reflection of the 4 of them fighting together again, and they all participated in that. To answer your question: I watched more than just the "major" scenes, I watched the WHOLE movie.

Scandia
07-19-2007, 04:59 PM
I liked the movie when I watched it so much that I wanted to see it again.

In retrospect, there are several things that I would have changed. I only have one major objection and one thing I would have altered so that it would make more sense. But it still was fine for a TMNT movie. They did a great job considering there had not been a TMNT movie done in 14 years.

Now I am getting images of Irma chasing Max Winters!!!

ToTheNines
07-19-2007, 07:12 PM
If you don't agree with me, that's fine. But I still think what I think for a reason. Maybe Donatello and Michaelangelo didn't have much of a part in the Leonardo/Raphael conflict, but they were still part of the plot, which was about the whole turtle family reuniting, not just two of them. And if you think about it, they each had their significance too. I mean, Michaelangelo expressed his own individual internal conflict about his desire to go back to his crime-fighting days when watching the news about the Nightwatcher and talking about his "guns", and he gets his wish in the end. Donatello, while he might not have had a personal conflict, he was the one who figured out Winter's plot (the planetary alignment, the portal, and the monsters) and where and when, and that the Legend of Yaotl was true. And their fight with the generals at the end was the reflection of the 4 of them fighting together again, and they all participated in that. To answer your question: I watched more than just the "major" scenes, I watched the WHOLE movie.


You could interpret it that way, but it was really more of a joke than anything. And Donatello's intellegence may have been essential to the plot, but that still dosen't mean that he got a fair share of screen time.

Garou
07-20-2007, 04:03 PM
Hmm, a little late, I see....
But seriously raphroehler, after watching the movie and concluding that it was awesome, I started getting the same thoughts as you did. After debating with myself, I know that I at first judged the movie better than it honestly was.

I didn't think so much about the lack of Don and Mikey in the beginning and the monster plot didn't bother me. And frankly, I still love the movie, but I know that I as a Turtles fan was also seeing the movie through "rose colored glasses".

You put up a lot of valid points. People can agree or disagree, and I doubt that anyone went through the movie and afterwards didn't have one thing they wanted different.

I was glad that they used CGI and not real people. Not that it wouldn't work, but the animation was gorgeous and I wouldn't miss it now that I have seen it. And I fear that people could have disliked it for a "weak attempt at recreating the old movies", if they made it with real people. Just my two cents.

MoreCowbell5263
07-20-2007, 09:48 PM
I agree with the idea that if the movie is gonna be a little more than 80 minutes long, then they shouldn't worry about April and Casey and they should spend more time on Don and Mike. But ideally for me, I just wish the movie was longer, like a 2-2 and a half hour movie with a fair share of screentime and a big enough role for everyone in the movie.

Spitfire
07-20-2007, 10:16 PM
I agree with the idea that if the movie is gonna be a little more than 80 minutes long, then they shouldn't worry about April and Casey and they should spend more time on Don and Mike. But ideally for me, I just wish the movie was longer, like a 2-2 and a half hour movie with a fair share of screentime and a big enough role for everyone in the movie.

A kids movie that long would have bombed. You can't keep kids still for more then an hour and a half for the most part.

Rooish
07-20-2007, 10:21 PM
Which is why the ****ing thing shouldn't have been a kid's movie ... but oh well, they tried.

Spitfire
07-20-2007, 10:26 PM
Which is why the ****ing thing shouldn't have been a kid's movie ... but oh well, they tried.

Honestly explain me how it couldn't have been a kids movie. Tell me how in the world Laird could have adapted his turtles which are known to most of the world as a children's property into a PG-13 movie? Especially with a movie studio that probably doesn't have to much faith in it after how bad the previous movie failed.

Transformers is PG-13 because of who worked on it and because it's being re-birthed. TMNT came back as a kids show and then did a movie. Transformers has been off most peoples radar for awhile now so they could bring it back as anything they wanted to.

And they did, as a horrid summer movie. Everyone saw it because there was nothing else worth seeing being released that week, older fans wanted to feel like they were 6 again, and Hot Topic kids think their cool to like stuff that was made before their time.

If TMNT turned out like that I'd be pissed.