PDA

View Full Version : Harry Potter Compared to TMNT (?!!)


Roseangelo
07-22-2007, 10:00 PM
This one shocked me...

Harry Potter's no more magical than the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.

Like the crime-fighting reptiles, the young wizard's run atop the weekend box office was brief, ousted after one weekend by Adam Sandler and Kevin James' I Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry.

I don't get the point of the comparison, especially when all the Harry Potter fans were busy reading the new book this weekend and had already seen the movie.

Here (http://www.eonline.com/news/article/index.jsp?uuid=f9391384-4264-4ed9-b70d-c7b9fe10f0a4&entry=index&sid=rss_topstories&utm_source=eonline&utm_medium=rssfeeds&utm_campaign=rss_topstories) is the full text.

ToTheNines
07-22-2007, 10:04 PM
Never thought of the ninja turtles as magical, but I like it :P

It's cool to see TMNT being recognised (even if in a slightly negative way) by critics (even though its a little late).

Spitfire
07-22-2007, 10:07 PM
Wow, well not to surprising everyone hated turtles but the fans for the most part, and even some of them hated it.

No one but Disney and Pixar are allowed to make kids movies I guess.

Anyways I don't see how they can even say that since Chuck And Larry made a weak 2 mil more then Harry potter. Hardly a triumph.

No movie all year has logged more than three consecutive weekends as number one. (And no, the turtle-populated TMNT wasn't one of them.)
Wow turtle populated now their just fishing for insults and failing horribly. To bad it made more money then most of those movies though. If you take what they spent on it and what is grossed alot of those flicks didn't do to well. Yeah they MADE more then TMNT all together but not what the studio expected and with that said TMNT wins over those movies.

The Shelf
07-22-2007, 10:56 PM
I'm a bit surprised that Harry Potter isn't doing a bit better, but as far as the article goes, I think they're just trying to push the Sandler movie. I mean, it's E! for goodness sake. I don't know why, but they must have an agenda to make the latest gay movie sound better than it really is. Probably just to get more attention. I wouldn't take the article too seriously. I'm not a fan of E! anyway.

Scandia
07-23-2007, 07:06 AM
I have NOT been obsessed with Harry Potter, preferring other fantasy books for similar audiences instead. I still like Harry Potter enough to spend 45 bucks yesterday on the audiobook for Deathly Hallows. I have read or listened to all the books and watched all the movies.

I still prefer TMNT for some bizarre reason.

And the Harry Potter movie was pretty full this past Saturday when I went to watch it. Even though they had to stop it due to the thunderstorm and then start it again, people still stayed and enjoyed it.

I did not want to go see it a second time, unlike TMNT.

xmen510
07-23-2007, 07:27 AM
I saw Potter once. It was very good, but not great. I think that Potter Fatigue is starting to set in with the movie going crowd.

Avatar Yuffie
07-23-2007, 10:05 AM
I'm too busy reading the last book. Heh.

I'll watch the movie this weekend.

tilallr1
07-23-2007, 10:33 AM
Yeh I kinda felt disappointed too with Potter 5. I mean the series has been building itself up. Each film getting better then the last with 4 being the best one, no one can argue. But 5 kinda fell flat. Heard the book was ALOT better.

Shark_Blade
07-23-2007, 02:24 PM
Of course the book was better but it's impossible to cram everything into a 2 hour movie, so a lot of it got cut off. Although I was expecting it, I do feel it's a litttle too rushed in and too complicated

Wherever I go people said "Where's the Phoenix? I don't see it? Why is it called Order of phoenix?"

I just roll my eyes and calmly explain to them, half heartedly wish to say to them: read the book dammit!

ToTheNines
07-23-2007, 02:25 PM
I mean the series has been building itself up. Each film getting better then the last with 4 being the best one, no one can argue.

I have not seen 4 or 5 but I think they have gotten worse with each one.

shuriken
07-23-2007, 04:10 PM
I haven't seen the last Harry Pottewr movie but I've read the first four books and seen the first four movies. I have to say that the books are (surely enough) a lot better than the movies. This by no means states that the movies are bad, it's just a lot of stuff is left out for time's sake. I personally liked the books ( all of which were bought in garage sales and at discounted prices;)) but the movies were decent, and I really enjoyed Goblet of Fire.I have no idea why the hell they are comparing Harry to TMNT but I guess he just really hates them to poke fun at them with every chance he gets.

dripgutz24
07-23-2007, 04:39 PM
How can they compare harry potter to TMNT, thats just weird, last time I checked I didn't see a turtle pull out a magic stick and ride a broom.

ToTheNines
07-23-2007, 05:22 PM
How can they compare harry potter to TMNT, thats just weird, last time I checked I didn't see a turtle pull out a magic stick and ride a broom.

Dude where have you been? Michelangelo mastered "Flipendo" in the last issue of tales!

Roseangelo
07-23-2007, 06:25 PM
Dude where have you been? Michelangelo mastered "Flipendo" in the last issue of tales!

Random question: Was Flipendo ever even used in the books? I just read all seven and I don't recall seeing it. Was it just a video game thing? Because I'm very familiar with it from those...

ToTheNines
07-23-2007, 08:48 PM
Lol, I don't think so, I just recalled the day I was obsessed with beating the first game (which was the day I got it). I can't give you an honest answer for the first book, I was sorta young when I first read it and don't remember that clearly.

Cure
07-24-2007, 09:32 AM
They're not comparing the actual movies, they're comparing the fact that both movies which are about pretty popular characters were at #1 at the box office for their first weeks only. I thought that was pretty clear.

Tinuvielsdreams
07-24-2007, 08:32 PM
From what I have been hearing because the Harry Potter movies was so big the first week only the really hardcore fans were willing to fight the crowds and then after the parents started hearing how "Dark" it was they wouldn't take their kids. This is what I heard being around the summer school age program I work for it's just stipulation.

That didn't happen with TMNT they just had some pretty heavy competition in the box office

It's pretty cool the TMNT were the example used though, people still have it on their minds :)

Ninjinister
07-25-2007, 09:36 AM
TMNT in comparison with Potter? I am filled with shame.

Andrew NDB
07-25-2007, 12:08 PM
How can they compare harry potter to TMNT, thats just weird, last time I checked I didn't see a turtle pull out a magic stick and ride a broom.

No, but you might as well have. I saw plenty of magic, talking statues, and weirdness in the latest TMNT movie.

I don't get the point of the comparison, especially when all the Harry Potter fans were busy reading the new book this weekend and had already seen the movie.

And all the TMNT fans were too busy reading their Mirage TMNT movie prequel comics to go see the movie, right? :)

It's a valid comparison, if only in sheer box office terms. TMNT came out in a weekend where it was pretty much unchallenged, then jaw-droppingly dropped more than 50% its second weekend and continued to freefall from there (yet a lot of fans of the movie seem to just have heard, "It came out at #1! Yay!" and blank out the rest, plugging their ears and chanting, "It was #1, it was #1, it was #1"). More or less same as the latest Potter movie.

The Shelf
07-25-2007, 12:21 PM
And all the TMNT fans were too busy reading their Mirage TMNT movie prequel comics to go see the movie, right? :)

Um.... It takes significantly longer to finish a 700+ page book than it does a couple comics. Not to mention most of the prequel comics weren't even out until a few weeks after the movie was released. Most of the people I know who got the Harry Potter book spent their entire weekend reading it, so no, they wouldn't have had time to go see the movie.

Andrew NDB
07-25-2007, 12:27 PM
Most of the people I know who got the Harry Potter book spent their entire weekend reading it

How weird.

Barkworm
07-25-2007, 12:54 PM
The comparison kind of makes sense but we're talking about completely different boxoffice dimensions here.

The Shelf
07-25-2007, 02:09 PM
How weird.

It's not all that weird. People really are that obsessive about it. I'm not one of those people, but I know at least 4 or 5 people who started reading it Saturday and were finished by the end of Monday, some even by Sunday. And a lot of people spent Friday night camping out for it.

Shark_Blade
07-25-2007, 02:42 PM
I haven't even finish Deathly Hallow :( :p I got it on launch date of course.

Jo Dawn
07-25-2007, 09:37 PM
Midnight bay-bee.

Dragon Turtle
07-26-2007, 01:56 AM
No, but you might as well have. I saw plenty of magic, talking statues, and weirdness in the latest TMNT movie.



You're right, it needed more.:)



And all the TMNT fans were too busy reading their Mirage TMNT movie prequel comics to go see the movie, right? :)

It's a valid comparison, if only in sheer box office terms. TMNT came out in a weekend where it was pretty much unchallenged, then jaw-droppingly dropped more than 50% its second weekend and continued to freefall from there



"unchallenged"? If I recall correctly, TMNT opened up the same weekend as five other movies, three of which opened at or above 10 million that same weekend, Hills Have Eyes 2, Shooter, and The Last Mimzy, all of which would have had some effect on TMNT's demographics, a week later you had Blades of Glory and Meet the Robinsons, and of course you still had 300 going strong.

As for Potter, the second week drop is pretty much in line with most Potter films, Order of the Phoenix's drop is actually less then the second week drop
for Prisoner of Azkaban(the last Potter film released in the summer), and this year Potter has alot more competition then he did in 04, where he was going up against the likes of Soul Plane and The Chronicles of Riddick.





(yet a lot of fans of the movie seem to just have heard, "It came out at #1! Yay!" and blank out the rest, plugging their ears and chanting, "It was #1, it was #1, it was #1"). More or less same as the latest Potter movie.


Still, being #1 is not bad for a under marketed movie in a crowded field .

Andrew NDB
07-26-2007, 10:57 AM
"unchallenged"? If I recall correctly, TMNT opened up the same weekend as five other movies, three of which opened at or above 10 million that same weekend, Hills Have Eyes 2, Shooter, and The Last Mimzy,

One of those is hard R horror film, one is a hard R actioner/suspense film, and the other movie I've never even heard of (but at a quick glance seems to be some kind of little girl's drama film)... none of these would cut into the TMNT's target demographic of toddlers and tweens.

WB didn't just put a blindfold on and walk up to a calendar with their finger out to pick the release weekend... it was strategically positioned to meet the least/Zero competition in its demographic. That it was #1 isn't a testament to "The TMNT are back!" or "Wow, it's a blockbuster!", but rather just a testament to WB being at least a little bit savvy in its opening weekend positioning.

Spike Spiegel
07-26-2007, 01:59 PM
Maybe the guy who wrote this article just did that to come up with a decent hook so people will read it...:roll:

Seems a little obnoxious to me.

Dragon Turtle
07-26-2007, 07:20 PM
One of those is hard R horror film, one is a hard R actioner/suspense film, and the other movie I've never even heard of (but at a quick glance seems to be some kind of little girl's drama film)... none of these would cut into the TMNT's target demographic of toddlers and tweens.


HHE2, Shooter, Blades of Glory, and 300 all cater to the teen and twenty-something crowd. Warner Bros own opening weekend exit polls showed that
22% of the audience were between the ages of 12-17, while another 22% were over the age 18, only 28 % of the audience were under the age of 12.
Toddlers and tweens may have been the target audience, but the reality is that the movie attracted an larger older audience that WB had not anticipated,
Warners Bros even contributed TMNT's opening weekend success to older fans of franchise, base strictly as a kids movie, WB probably were expecting TMNT to pull in a 9-12 million its opening weekend(which it did).

Movies such as 300 and Blades of Glory had just as much of an negative impact on TMNT's bottomline as did the kid movies.

As for the kids demographic, The Last Mimzy was targeted at both boys and girls("This Generations E.T." :lol: ), so it was in direct competition with TMNT for the kid market, as well as Disney's Meet the Robinsons, and both were better promoted then TMNT, I might add.




WB didn't just put a blindfold on and walk up to a calendar with their finger out to pick the release weekend... it was strategically positioned to meet the least/Zero competition in its demographic. That it was #1 isn't a testament to "The TMNT are back!" or "Wow, it's a blockbuster!", but rather just a testament to WB being at least a little bit savvy in its opening weekend positioning.

Warner Bros did move TMNT away from Meet the Robinsons, but placed it closer to 300, since they never thought a movie based on the ninja turtles could appeal to an older audience, a move that actually hurt both movies, 300 would have easily remained the #1 movie in America for a third straight week.


If they knew then, what they know now, WB wouldn't have made the move,
the best thing they could have done was to have TMNT switch places with The Reaping.

METALHEAD
07-26-2007, 07:35 PM
how dare they, harry potter is evil witchcraft.

Barkworm
07-27-2007, 12:47 AM
Sad thing is that some retards actually believe that kind of bullsh*t.

Andrew NDB
07-27-2007, 12:59 AM
Warners Bros even contributed TMNT's opening weekend success to older fans of franchise, base strictly as a kids movie, WB probably were expecting TMNT to pull in a 9-12 million its opening weekend

The first part of this I believe -- and the crime of it is that they made the TMNT film as a toddler/tween affair tweaked to cater to a bit of the existing now-adult fandom rather than the other way around -- but the second part is... and forgive me if I sound insulting (is not my intent), insane.

Everything rides on a strong opening weekend, because statistically speaking, the average movie is going to drop 40-50% off the bat the very next (the 2nd) weekend. If you honestly believe they only expected TMNT to earn 9-12 million its first weekend, you're then also believing they anticipated the movie only earning about 4-6 million its second weekend, and then down from there... that wouldn't even cover the production budget itself, let alone marketing or distribution.

Dragon Turtle
07-27-2007, 03:15 AM
Everything rides on a strong opening weekend, because statistically speaking, the average movie is going to drop 40-50% off the bat the very next (the 2nd) weekend. If you honestly believe they only expected TMNT to earn 9-12 million its first weekend, you're then also believing they anticipated the movie only earning about 4-6 million its second weekend, and then down from there... that wouldn't even cover the production budget itself, let alone marketing or distribution.


Ahh yes, that is exactly the point I have been trying to get across about Warner Bros' attitude toward the TMNT movie, they didn't believe this movie was going to be a success, and probably saw this movie and thought it was going to be another dissapointment like last years "Ant Bully", which opened up at 8 million and limped its way to a final 28 million domestic boxoffice gross.
And since there were no penguins in TMNT, you could forget about another Happy Feet miracle. This ties directly into me belief why Warner Bros did not
go out of their way to promote this movie. Why spend marketing budget money on a movie that was going to flop?


According to Dan Fellman, Warner Bros.' president of distribution, "I was hoping we could get TMNT to the high teen millions", that is "hoping" not "expecting", if the high teens were a best case scenario, realistically within WB, the suits were probably expecting an opening weekend somewhere in the low teens, which if you subtract the 44% from the 12 and older crowd, is what they got.

And what exactly does a "high teens" opening get you for a CGI movie "Flushed Away" opened up 18 million and "Surf's Up" opened at 17 million, both movies ended with domestic boxoffice totals of 64 mil and 57 mil respectively, break even money as far as TMNT is concerned.


Somewhere along the line between greenlighting the movie and its final release, Warner Bros' lost faith in TMNT and were just hoping the movie could recoup some of its 34 million dollar budget.

Andrew NDB
07-27-2007, 12:39 PM
Somewhere along the line between greenlighting the movie and its final release, Warner Bros' lost faith in TMNT and were just hoping the movie could recoup some of its 34 million dollar budget.

I don't think that at all. From the relatively small budget they allotted the film upon greenlighting to their criticized marketing efforts in post production (which I actually thought was respectable, but who knows outside my neck of the woods), all of it seemed pretty consistent to me. TMNT just wasn't ever really a big deal to them, just a quick, low-risk experiment catered to the lowest common denominator that might guarantee the most profit.

TMNT
07-27-2007, 01:57 PM
I didn't know where to put this. It's another addition of "turtle citing in an article not at all related to the turtles in any way other than to make reference to them". Okay, so I'm still working on a title. This is Roger Ebert's review of The Simpsons Movie, in which he makes reference to the turtles. Here's the direct quote:

I'm not generally a fan of movies spun off from TV animation. "The Flintstones" and "Ninja Turtles" moved me only marginally.

http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070725/REVIEWS/707250301

The most obvious gripe is the fact that we all know the turtles didn't originate on television.

Andrew NDB
07-27-2007, 02:26 PM
The most obvious gripe is the fact that we all know the turtles didn't originate on television.

Oh, there's still plenty of fans out there that would like to believe it did. Which is crazy.

Juniorx
07-27-2007, 06:48 PM
has anyboddy wrote to these foes that the ninja turtles came from a comic book not from the tv.

Dragon Turtle
07-27-2007, 07:30 PM
I don't think that at all. From the relatively small budget they allotted the film upon greenlighting to their criticized marketing efforts in post production (which I actually thought was respectable, but who knows outside my neck of the woods), all of it seemed pretty consistent to me. TMNT just wasn't ever really a big deal to them, just a quick, low-risk experiment catered to the lowest common denominator that might guarantee the most profit.


You are correct in saying TMNT was never really a big picture for WB in terms of how its success would impact Warner Bros' bottomline line, WB probably cared more for such movies as "License to Wed" or "Nancy Drew".


But at one point Warner Bros had told the producers that TMNT needed to gross 100 million in order to obtain a sequel, which is actually a very large chunk of change for a March released movie. They probably would have been happy with anything north of 75 million, if they thought TMNT would have made less then that, they would not have bothered to greenlight it in the first place, a project they weren't overly enthusiastic about, given the relatively low production budget and the need for the producers to convince the studio that the turtles were still relevant based on the success of the 2k3 cartoon and toyline(something that may have actually backfired against them).

has anyboddy wrote to these foes that the ninja turtles came from a comic book not from the tv.

Probably, but most likely they don't care, as far as the mainstream public and media are concerned, the turtles are 80s/90s popculture fad based on a cartoon.:(