PDA

View Full Version : Tales of the TMNT--Continuing storylines?


quinnmjohnson
07-28-2007, 04:47 PM
So I was just emailing with Tristan Jones, author of the newest Issue #36, and he's got a big storyline planned that continues the story just released. We also haven't seen the wrap-up of the Three Foot Sorcerers vs. Splinter storyline, and Ross May's storyline involving the female ninja with a grudge against Hamato Yoshi has yet to be finished (sounds like he's got a lot of cool stuff planned too). So the question is: will they ever get the chance to wrap things up? I've personally pitched a new story (after my Issue #31 story came out) several times, but it seems like Mirage is clamping down on new submissions. Latest word was "no new submissions for 2008". Yikes!! Now the folks at Mirage are great guys, but I wonder what's in the future for the series. It's had some amazing stories as of late. (#36 was phenomenal.) Hope nothing drastic happens to curb all that!

Leogeddon
07-28-2007, 05:08 PM
very awesome, did you invite him here?? :O

Roseangelo
07-29-2007, 02:21 AM
Very awesome? Mirage is killing the comic book is the basic point of the post, which is not awesome. But it is consistent with Mirage "crashing the plane" as they have been. I honestly do not see any hope for the future of the TMNT comic book unless Peter is willing to allow for certain things to happen, which doesn't seem likely at this point. He can feel free to prove me wrong.

jenna
07-29-2007, 06:39 AM
Yeah... is this good news or bad news? Either it's really good and Mirage is full of new and exciting stuff for 2008 or it as Rose said: death of Mirage.

The turtles certainly seem to be on a higher point than 2 years ago: the new movie came out, the FF abomination is ending, a new revamped cartoon is due, it would be a shame for Mirage not to take advantage of this. Peter Laird once said that the comics are non-profit making. I think we need to come up with some fund-raising ideas to keep the comics alive. I've only just discovered them. I'm not ready for them to die.

VaughnMichael
07-29-2007, 08:41 AM
I don't see how tales of tmnt is not turning a proffit....it sells out in every shop I've ever been to.

Roseangelo
07-29-2007, 10:18 AM
I don't see how tales of tmnt is not turning a proffit....it sells out in every shop I've ever been to.

I really don't even think that's the point, although I do agree that Tales has to be doing as well as it can with whatever print run it is they're giving it (which is too low as it is). I think it's an issue of not enough manpower for the logistics of publishing, which we know is the case, and possibly an issue of Peter being intimidated by all these new people writing stories that get a better fan response than the stuff he was writing.

CyberCubed
07-29-2007, 11:44 AM
Or maybe Mirage already has comics for '08 set?

Remember, only 12 comics can come out in a year from Tales. Its very possible they already have 12 stories lined up and that's why they're not accepting new submissions.

DrSpengler
07-29-2007, 12:17 PM
Yeah, I'm also rather irked by the number of incomplete plotlines. Vol. 4 being on hold is one thing, but as the OP mentioned, there are a good three intriguing plot threads that have yet to be finished. Tales needs to focus!

I mean, it's nice that they're doing these solo Turtle miniseries and all, but I'd rather not have any threads still hanging....especially ones that have been hanging for several years without resolution. What's the excuse for that?

tablesalt
07-29-2007, 12:33 PM
I think we need to come up with some fund-raising ideas to keep the comics alive. I've only just discovered them. I'm not ready for them to die.

The only thing Mirage needs to do to increase sales is start selling their comics.

I just got volume 3 of tales becasue of the Allen/Clairain stories. AS it turned out, I liked some of the other stories as well so I started looking around to buy vol. 1 and 2, only to find that they weren't available. Why don't they keep these in print?

Mirage's low sale's are a self fullfilling prophesy. They could easily let people order online from their website (I think paypal has some system to let small businesses do this)
And there's quite a few independent comics that get sold on Amazon, like Gold Digger, or Strangers in Paradise.
I can't believe that TMNT, especially after the movie, and with a running tv series can't justify selling on amazon, while Gold Digger can. Hell, they could even set up an amazon z-shop, or have amazon list it as a special order, and only
send them copies when it's been ordered (which I've seen smaller publishers do).

But as it stands, the interest I had after reading vol. 3 pretty much died in the few hours I spent trying to find 1 and 2.

Scandia
07-29-2007, 12:44 PM
They sure need to put an online ordering system. Ordering by mail is what was done when catalogs first debuted and there were no telephones yet. And ordering by phone is very 20th century. Online ordering would be so much more efficient- not to mention there would be a lot less lost stuff.

And they sure need to finish unresolved storylines- including Volume 4.

DrSpengler
07-29-2007, 02:08 PM
I suppose the problem is Laird still thinks its 1992 and doesn't understand this new fangled interweb thingamajigger all the kids are talking about.

Laird seems determined to keep Mirage a small independant publisher at all costs, even if it means the end of Mirage itself, oddly. He can't sell TPBs through bookstores because he doesn't have enough manpower to handle bookstore return policies. But he can't hire more staff to deal with it because then Mirage would no longer be a smalltime independant publisher. It's like he'd rather run a small company that's constantly in the red than a large company that's constantly turning a profit.

A complicated one, this Laird.

CyberCubed
07-29-2007, 03:07 PM
Didn't they say they were losing money on every book they produce? Mirage is not Microsoft, they don't have an endless supply of money to blow.

Peter Laird already said that Volume 4 never made a profit, and I don't know if Tales is even breaking even. So essentially, each issue they print is basically throwing away money. I could be wrong about Tales, but I don't know how much money it could be making them.

jenna
07-29-2007, 03:33 PM
I don't see how tales of tmnt is not turning a proffit....it sells out in every shop I've ever been to.

Which really shows that the demand is much higher than Mirage cater for. My little comic man in town told me that the turtles comic fly off the shelves and he's sold out within days of them coming out, but once he's out, he's out. He can't order any more of them because they are simply no longer available. So, standing order for me it is.

There is potentially huge profit to be made, much more than now. All Mirage have to do is recognise their audience, and make their product more available.

PAAATE
07-29-2007, 04:00 PM
Or maybe Mirage already has comics for '08 set?

Remember, only 12 comics can come out in a year from Tales. Its very possible they already have 12 stories lined up and that's why they're not accepting new submissions.

This seems most plausible... Or at least I hope it is.

Andrew NDB
07-29-2007, 04:33 PM
I wouldn't be surprised if Tales isn't turning a profit, sadly. It has pretty tiny print run, and even as such I don't see any comic stores in Washington carrying it on their shelves except for two, and those only carry a couple of copies...

Can't vouch for other states, though.

Scandia
07-29-2007, 05:43 PM
The bookstore I go to does carry very few Turtles titles. The person who works there seems to like them a lot as well and be quite knowledgeable about them. I have been able to find a few titles a while after they have been published (Blind Sight 4, Mirage 28), but it's not like they are overflowing with Turtles titles.

I guess that Mirage is making the most money from the cartoons, movies, and other licensed products.

RossMay
07-29-2007, 07:37 PM
In planning for 2008 Mirage is presently not considering stories from freelancers. Though it frustrates me (my next two scripts were completed and bought by them in late 2005 and early 2006 respectively) I sympathise with the reason behind it; Mirage wants to make sure that its in-house guys have enough work for next year. Any new and continuing stories from freelancers may not see the light of day in 2008... and there's no guarantee that will change for 2009.

That's not to say there definitely won't by stories by freelancers. Even for 2008 they could decide to schedule in freelance content. If you want to read more stories by Quinn, myself, Tristan Jones, Will Tupper (don’t know who else I’m forgetting) then contact Mirage and let them know. It might affect decision making, it might not, but at least Peter and everyone will have heard what you want.

PS
Thanks for the compliment, Quinn.

VaughnMichael
07-29-2007, 09:59 PM
yeah ok I'm gonna get shot for this but ok I'm gonna say it Jim Lawson needs to step down so other people can come in why doesn't laird just give him a printing job or something and solve that issue.
While having new talent come in.
The new people coming in are sadly much better at doing mirage than mirage is and it makes me wonder if it really is getting to them to see so many of us wowing these wonderfull storys and art.
No dissrespect to anyone but some times "Things change" and I think it's time they started.

Ninjinister
07-30-2007, 09:09 AM
I wouldn't be surprised if Tales isn't turning a profit, sadly. It has pretty tiny print run, and even as such I don't see any comic stores in Washington carrying it on their shelves except for two, and those only carry a couple of copies...

Can't vouch for other states, though.

Amen to that. Here in Tacoma, I have to special order issues of Tales ahead of time.

jenna
07-30-2007, 11:33 AM
yeah ok I'm gonna get shot for this but ok I'm gonna say it Jim Lawson needs to step down so other people can come in why doesn't laird just give him a printing job or something and solve that issue.
While having new talent come in.
The new people coming in are sadly much better at doing mirage than mirage is and it makes me wonder if it really is getting to them to see so many of us wowing these wonderfull storys and art.
No dissrespect to anyone but some times "Things change" and I think it's time they started.

I think you're right. People who are new to the industry have to work very hard for their material to see the light of day, and as a consequence the quality is outstanding. An influx of new talent could work very well for Mirage and maybe boost the profit, leading to much more comics of a high standard and many happy fans. :D As I said in another thread as well, amazing artwork and narratives will attract new readers too.

Andrew NDB
07-30-2007, 04:50 PM
Amen to that. Here in Tacoma, I have to special order issues of Tales ahead of time.

Where do you go, btw? The only two stores I know that carry TMNT on their shelves outside of special order are Comics Dungeon and Zanadu Comics in the heart of downtown Seattle.

Since I don't want to drive there every month I've set up a special order for me at Action City at Federal Way. The guy that owns/runs the store is pretty cool, and the guy at Spy Comics is also a wealth of comic knowledge -- but he refuses to carry TMNT (except via special order) on his shelves, saying, "Hell, I couldn't even GIVE those away if I wanted to!"

Ninjinister
07-30-2007, 09:16 PM
Ever since O'Leary's in Lakewood closed down, I only go to Comic Book Ink - with an occasional jaunt to Atomic Comics if I'm in the area.

quinnmjohnson
07-31-2007, 07:36 PM
Wow, big response on this! My point in the thread is not to bash Mirage; I'm sure they know what they want and what they're doing. For the record, I think Peter Laird's been in the business long enough to know what he does and doesn't want, and where he wants the property to go. While some questions regarding the future of the comic are not clear yet, I do know that 2008 is planned with most of the issues by Jim Lawson and other in-house artists. And for the record, I'm a HUGE fan of Jim Lawson, both his art and his writing.

And you're welcome, Ross. You deserve the praise.

So while I'm disappointed that more freelance work isn't being accepted at this time, I am very interested to see what the in-house guys have in store. In a way, I respect Peter Laird for not letting the comic become a huge, impersonal corporate monster. So I'm cautiously optimistic.

VaughnMichael
07-31-2007, 09:54 PM
I do know that 2008 is planned with most of the issues by Jim Lawson.
HUGE HUGE HUGE MISTAKE TO BE MAKING...I swear if this comics keeps using him more than anyone else no matter how much one person likes the mans art it's going to be doomed.:dead:
I'm saying this not as some one who doesn't like Jim's art I'm saying this as some one who knows that his art is not for the most part as visually apealing as others. It used to be in the 80's but it's not now I've really not seen many artists get worse over time but I guess theres always an exception.
I don't mind Jim as person and I happen to like the way he writes allot it's just that his art is really making these comics suffer.
And if allot of 2008 tales comics are mostly him mark my words you will see it go belly up.
Btw Laird doesn't have to let the comic become a monster but for pete's sake get some more people working at mirage to at least print the comics and take care of business so he's not so swamped can get back to being a writter and Lawson can get back to drawing Vol. 4 and Tales can continue to fly off comic store shelves.
Bringing more people into mirage does not make it some huge company btw I really don't see why if Peter is so bogged down and can't get anything done why he doesnt just bring in some more new staff or ask for help.
I really think it all comes down to a case of being stuborn something I know about all to well myself.
Oh and to the "It's his company and comic he can do what he wants" people that excuse is getting a bit tired I'd rather voice my opinions on how I honestly think than to kiss some ones butt just because I respect them.
Peters never held his tongue on his fans so I really don't see the issue here it's not like anyones holding a gun to his head and saying hey you do as I say right now no allot of us are conerned I'm sorry I'm not just some fickle fan and I do care if they go away again I remember what a rut I was in when TMNT fell off the face of the earth the first time I'm not going to let that happen again. :)

RossMay
07-31-2007, 10:58 PM
Back at you, Quinn.

In response to your comments, Putrescent: Peter likes to OK every TMNT project, including every comic, cartoon episode, and I don't know what else. You're absolutely right; he could designate this sort of work to other people, even for just some of the projects. But this is the way he wants things to be, and this is the way they'll stay.

Spitfire
08-01-2007, 12:09 AM
Back at you, Quinn.

In response to your comments, Putrescent: Peter likes to OK every TMNT project, including every comic, cartoon episode, and I don't know what else. You're absolutely right; he could designate this sort of work to other people, even for just some of the projects. But this is the way he wants things to be, and this is the way they'll stay.

He showed some backbone by saying no the the new TMNT show pitch but we'll see if that holds. I agree with Putrescent here we don't need mostly Lawson art.

VaughnMichael
08-01-2007, 12:32 AM
Back at you, Quinn.

In response to your comments, Putrescent: Peter likes to OK every TMNT project, including every comic, cartoon episode, and I don't know what else. You're absolutely right; he could designate this sort of work to other people, even for just some of the projects. But this is the way he wants things to be, and this is the way they'll stay.
I'm not talking about projects I am talking about jobs.
There is no reason for them to complain about not having enough people to do things or saying they have 3 people doing everything when they won't move forward and progress.
It's not the numbers that really matter to me it's the quality.
I'm quite fine with Peter Laird obviously he and Kevin and countless others are the only reason I even started doing art besides Jim Henson.
I think things will change or they will perish there is no middle ground.

Andrew NDB
08-01-2007, 12:09 PM
http://a0.vox.com/6a00bf76d0a9b7438300c2252095a08e1d-500pi

Jim Lawson gotta eat, foo!

CyberCubed
08-01-2007, 01:30 PM
Jim Lawson is also going to be doing the Michelangelo mini-series in 2008, so it looks like a LOT of comics will be drawn by him next year.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-01-2007, 01:48 PM
Hey, if I were the sole owner of TMNT, I would definitely want to personally okay every comic, cartoon, and movie my ownself. You guys shouldn't knock him for that.

The rest of the stuff, though, I do tend to agree with.

As for Lawson, I like the art okay, but not on a regular diet of it. It's just too flat and 2D and black and white. Does he ever shade anything? The style I really like is Frank Fosco's, back in Volume 3.

Besides Lawson, who is considered an in-house artist?






Back at you, Quinn.

In response to your comments, Putrescent: Peter likes to OK every TMNT project, including every comic, cartoon episode, and I don't know what else. You're absolutely right; he could designate this sort of work to other people, even for just some of the projects. But this is the way he wants things to be, and this is the way they'll stay.

VaughnMichael
08-01-2007, 02:18 PM
Jim Lawson gotta eat, foo!
Then I say Let Him Eat Cake.
Hey, if I were the sole owner of TMNT, I would definitely want to personally okay every comic, cartoon, and movie my ownself. You guys shouldn't knock him for that.
In response to your comments, Putrescent: Peter likes to OK every TMNT project, including every comic, cartoon episode, and I don't know what else. You're absolutely right; he could designate this sort of work to other people, even for just some of the projects. But this is the way he wants things to be, and this is the way they'll stay.[/I]
It's really obvious you have no idea what I'm talking about at all.
I did not mention Peters wanting to go over projects at all. Period.
Ok now everyone read through this carefully.
I'm not talking about projects I am talking about jobs.
There is no reason for them to complain about not having enough people to do things or saying they have 3 people doing everything when they won't move forward and progress.
It's not the numbers that really matter to me it's the quality.
I'm quite fine with Peter Laird obviously he and Kevin and countless others are the only reason I even started doing art besides Jim Henson.
I think things will change or they will perish there is no middle ground.

odupianist
08-01-2007, 03:48 PM
Nothing wrong with having say of hwat goes and what doesn't if you're the sole owner, I agree, but you also have to be business saavy and open minded. If you want something to succeed, you have to be open to new ideas (and new artists). Some times you're going to have to do a thing or two that you don't like to help the franchise.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
08-01-2007, 04:46 PM
True dat! Besides, isn't Tales Volume 2 supposed to showcase non in-house artists and writers?

Kinda paradoxal here, doncha think?

Roseangelo
08-01-2007, 09:25 PM
I do have to say that I would have preference for the in-house guys over the freelancers, simply because I love all of those Mirage guys dearly and they all played a substantial part in shaping the characters and overall story, BUT they HAVE to deliver the goods!!! If they're not willing to, they need to step aside. Yes, this means Jim Lawson. And to some effect, it also means Peter Laird, who has proven that he just can't write stories for these characters anymore.

Venom
08-02-2007, 03:51 PM
Who all's in-house other than Lawson? Murphy, Talbot, and Dooney are considered in-house, and of course Kevin should he ever decide to tell one of his untold Turtles stories he mentioned in an interview a couple months back.

As far as writing goes, I liked the story Laird was crafting - especially there toward the halt! Pete was mostly the writer on the Volume 1 issues and collaborations. Lawson can weave quite a yarn, too.

In the best interest of Mirage, Peter and Jim should do writing duties and let Eric, Mike, and Steve draw when they can and when they can't let some of the Tales guys do art.

On another note - is there a place where you can see how many issues a comic sells? I found a place once but it's been a while back.

VaughnMichael
08-02-2007, 05:22 PM
In the best interest of Mirage, Peter and Jim should do writing duties and let Eric, Mike, and Steve draw when they can and when they can't let some of the Tales guys do art.
I couldn't agree more.

OldSchooler
08-02-2007, 05:37 PM
Although in the past, we've seen (and Pete's admitted to it too) that writing TMNT takes time, and that he likes taking his time. Would you rather have TMNT Vol 4 return or have Pete on Tales? Jim and Pete could alternate each month, but what about the follow ups to Ross May's story, or Tales #36? It'd be ace to have Pete come back, but I'd rather have him behind tmnt ongoing, and have other talent come in on Tales, be it Jim, Eric, Murph or any of the others (Jake, Ross, Quinn, Tristan, etc.).

Roseangelo
08-02-2007, 06:02 PM
Peter shouldn't write ever, ever again. And Murphy doesn't draw.

The Mirage crew would be:
Kevin Eastman
Peter Laird
Steve Lavigne
Ryan Brown
Jim Lawson
Dan Berger
Eric Talbot
Michael Dooney
A.C. Farley
Steve Murphy
I think that's everyone...

And I would consider Chris Allan and Dean Clarrain adopted into the Mirage crew.

PAAATE
08-02-2007, 06:15 PM
Peter shouldn't write ever, ever again.

I actually enjoy his writing a lot. And I know others do too. :o

Scandia
08-02-2007, 06:39 PM
I think they should return to Volume 4. And have people like Tristan and Diego do the Tales.

VaughnMichael
08-02-2007, 07:32 PM
I actually enjoy his writing a lot. And I know others do too. :o
I don't mind how he writes but to me Peters a great artist more than anything and that's what he should be doing.
I think they should return to Volume 4. And have people like Tristan and Diego do the Tales.
I agree and I think this will happen even though they're not talking about it I think that Peter will coming back to vol. 4 lawson will go with him and then everything will go back to the cool new artists that are doing tales again.:D

odupianist
08-02-2007, 07:36 PM
It was in one of those "Blast to the Past" things, but PL had mentioned a book with all of the Mirage artists covered in it. Unfortunately, it never happened.

Andrew NDB
08-02-2007, 08:04 PM
I don't want to tell Mirage how to run their business, but if I was asked, I'd suggest they ought to just concentrate their efforts on one, even bi-monthly book if need be -- perhaps officially cancel both Tales and V4 and just make this a nice Fresh Start that comic store owners will jump on to test the waters (the same owners that stopped carrying Tales V2 and V4 on their shelves long ago). Make it like 45 pages, with art and stories featured from up-and-coming folks as well as established talent so far from Tales V2, and every issue feature Peter's ongoing Vol. 4 storyline (continuing from where it was left in V4 #28 ) as a backup feature going forward.

I think this would make everyone happy, as well as being an equitable means to give TMNT a new chance on comic book shelves.

VaughnMichael
08-02-2007, 09:38 PM
I don't want to tell Mirage how to run their business, but if I was asked, I'd suggest they ought to just concentrate their efforts on one, even bi-monthly book if need be -- perhaps officially cancel both Tales and V4 and just make this a nice Fresh Start that comic store owners will jump on to test the waters (the same owners that stopped carrying Tales V2 and V4 on their shelves long ago). Make it like 45 pages, with art and stories featured from up-and-coming folks as well as established talent so far from Tales V2, and every issue feature Peter's ongoing Vol. 4 storyline (continuing from where it was left in V4 #28 ) as a backup feature going forward.

I think this would make everyone happy, as well as being an equitable means to give TMNT a new chance on comic book shelves.
this is exactly what tuns of us have been saying no one is telling mirage what to do see we're just voicing our opinions and concerns.
And what you just said is what Rose has been saying for some time now.

Roseangelo
08-02-2007, 09:46 PM
And what you just said is what Rose has been saying for some time now.

Thank you for pointing this out. 8)

Duke
08-03-2007, 04:12 PM
Once I got wind of this, I sent Dan an email about it. And even though I left the drome I figured everyone here had probably heard the same thing and sure enough there is a rather long topic about the subject, so I thought I post what I heard back.

Question 1: I recently read an interview where Kevin Eastman said he still had Turtle stories to tell. And then I heard that Mirage isn’t taking any new tales volume 2 story submissions for 2008. Is there any connection between the two?

Dan's Response: No

My opinion: When I first heard about the in-house only policy for 2008, I was hoping Kevin had asked Peter if he could do some Tales stories. Unfortunately Dan pretty much confirms that wasn't the case.

Question 2: If not what is the chance of getting some of the unfinished Tales storylines resolved? Like the three foot sorcerers Vs Splinter storyline, Female ninja with the Yoshi grudge or even the new Tales 36 Police perspective to the City at War storyline.

Dan's Response: At the moment it's unlikely that any of those story lines will be completed. Mirage management has decreed that all 2008 issues of Tales be done by in-house staff, so if the creators here can come up with 12 approved stories, there will be no work for outside talent. However, should Peter Laird decide that the stories submitted by the in-house staff aren't up to snuff, the doors will open to freelancers, and those creators whose work has already been published will have preferential treatment (to tie up their plot threads). So, time will tell.

My opinion: Honestly, I'm kind of hoping the in-house stuff isn't up to par and Peter is forced to finish some of the other stories.

quinnmjohnson
08-04-2007, 04:24 PM
Interesting.

And as far as Peter's writing goes, I personally love it. As the Eastman and Laird partnership was coming to an end, it was becoming plain to me that Eastman wanted to take the characters in a darker, goofier direction, not so serious about characters, more becoming "early 90's Image-like" if you get my drift. All I can say is thank goodness that Laird stayed on. I kind of look at him as the heart of the Turtles, and his understanding of their personalities and their human qualities stayed on. So I love what he's done with Volume 4. Don't misunderstand, I love Eastman's work, and his art was phenomenal and truly helped shape the Turtles. It's just that at the end, I'm glad Laird got the franchise. So here's hoping for his return to V.4 soon!

The Shelf
08-04-2007, 05:04 PM
Interesting.

And as far as Peter's writing goes, I personally love it. As the Eastman and Laird partnership was coming to an end, it was becoming plain to me that Eastman wanted to take the characters in a darker, goofier direction, not so serious about characters, more becoming "early 90's Image-like" if you get my drift. All I can say is thank goodness that Laird stayed on. I kind of look at him as the heart of the Turtles, and his understanding of their personalities and their human qualities stayed on. So I love what he's done with Volume 4. Don't misunderstand, I love Eastman's work, and his art was phenomenal and truly helped shape the Turtles. It's just that at the end, I'm glad Laird got the franchise. So here's hoping for his return to V.4 soon!

Dude, you are now my hero. To all you Vol. 4 haters, I say: :P :D

Roseangelo
08-04-2007, 05:19 PM
As the Eastman and Laird partnership was coming to an end, it was becoming plain to me that Eastman wanted to take the characters in a darker, goofier direction, not so serious about characters, more becoming "early 90's Image-like" if you get my drift.

What do you base this on? I hope it's not Bodycount, because that wasn't intended to be taken seriously or reflect any direction for the Turtles. That was the last TMNT story he did and everything before that was co-plotted with Peter, so I honestly don't know how you've arrived at this conclusion.

I also don't agree with your assessment of Peter's handling of the characters, but I can agree to disagree.

I do feel confident saying that you are in an extreme minority. At Comic-Con I spent various amounts of time with over 15 (possibly 20 or more) veryveryveryvery hardcore TMNT fans, and absolutely none of them like anything that Peter has been doing. Fifteen to twnety people may not be a lot in the grand scheme of things, but when no one has a remotely positive thing to say... there's something not right going on.

VaughnMichael
08-04-2007, 07:27 PM
What do you base this on? I hope it's not Bodycount, because that wasn't intended to be taken seriously or reflect any direction for the Turtles. That was the last TMNT story he did and everything before that was co-plotted with Peter, so I honestly don't know how you've arrived at this conclusion.

I also don't agree with your assessment of Peter's handling of the characters, but I can agree to disagree.

I do feel confident saying that you are in an extreme minority. At Comic-Con I spent various amounts of time with over 15 (possibly 20 or more) veryveryveryvery hardcore TMNT fans, and absolutely none of them like anything that Peter has been doing. Fifteen to twnety people may not be a lot in the grand scheme of things, but when no one has a remotely positive thing to say... there's something not right going on.
I may not have been there this year but you can add me to that number of people also.
And how can anyone say one persons version of tmnt is darker or more silly than the other to me each version of tmnt ever has had a bit of both and then some.

quinnmjohnson
08-04-2007, 11:51 PM
Oh well. I guess everybody's got an opinion. Just some examples of cool things Laird has done with the Turtles: he made a very bold move in the Utrom arrival, thus allowing the Turtles to walk around in broad daylight. This opened up a whole new world of storytelling that has been cool. It has allowed the Turtles' personalities to be explored in ways that couldn't have happened before. Also the addition of Shadow to the Turtles' world has been fantastic, as she's an awesome character and in a way represents the teens the Turtles are classically known as. Another bold move was the death of Splinter, a very risky maneuver sure to divide the fans, but the way it was handled was very bittersweet and lent a strong "real life" edge to the series--sometimes people just die, and we have to learn to live without them. (The funeral in the following issue, and the arrival of Eastman and Laird to said proceedings, was a powerful story and a touching tribute.) And a final example off the top of my head was the origin story of April. Again it may divide the fans, but it brought a real depth to April that just hadn't been there before.

So I guess there are opinions on both sides of the line, but I for one am on Vol. 4's side.

Roseangelo
08-05-2007, 12:45 AM
Yeah, everything you just mentioned I absolutely loathe.

The whole alien landing thing takes them out of the reality of our world, which was something I always appreciated. Superman, Batman, Spider-man, etc. - All of them exist in an obviously fictional world. But the TMNT had always existed in our world. Landing aliens on the planet in a story that is supposed to be set in present time makes it not our world; you might as well be in Metropolis.

While it is true that sometimes people just die, in this case there was absolutely no mourning beyond the funeral by anyone. I have a friend just a little older than me whose father died of heart trouble a year and a half ago; she has suffered from depression and insomnia ever since. I cannot believe that the Turtles (at least all of them) would go back to life as normal immediately following Splinter's death. Which is exactly what happened.

The April thing... ugh. It felt like nothing more than an excuse to reuse an object (the Kirby crystal/pencil) from a book that is probably one of his overall favorites (Donatello #1). I don't understand the purpose of taking away the normalcy from the first human friend the Turtles even had, who has always been their foundation of normalcy. Also, it really feels like a slap in the face to Kevin. As it is, Peter (for whatever reason) disputes the inspiration for April, who was a woman Kevin once knew who happened to be an African American woman. To give a character created by two people an origin that was not part of the original story without consulting the second creator strikes me as extremely insulting. The idea could have worked if it involved a brand new character.

Again, I'll agree to disagree.

VaughnMichael
08-05-2007, 12:50 AM
Oh well. I guess everybody's got an opinion. Just some examples of cool things Laird has done with the Turtles: he made a very bold move in the Utrom arrival, thus allowing the Turtles to walk around in broad daylight. This opened up a whole new world of storytelling that has been cool. It has allowed the Turtles' personalities to be explored in ways that couldn't have happened before. Also the addition of Shadow to the Turtles' world has been fantastic, as she's an awesome character and in a way represents the teens the Turtles are classically known as. Another bold move was the death of Splinter, a very risky maneuver sure to divide the fans, but the way it was handled was very bittersweet and lent a strong "real life" edge to the series--sometimes people just die, and we have to learn to live without them. (The funeral in the following issue, and the arrival of Eastman and Laird to said proceedings, was a powerful story and a touching tribute.) And a final example off the top of my head was the origin story of April. Again it may divide the fans, but it brought a real depth to April that just hadn't been there before.

So I guess there are opinions on both sides of the line, but I for one am on Vol. 4's side.
Oi! Lol Yeah we're gonna have allot of disagreements here I'm not gonna fight about it though.
I find it funny how tuns of people stick up for the idea of the turtles walking around in day light in the comic but when they do it in the show it's not ok.
It was one of the things Peter hated about the old toon so I find it funny he would let it happen in his story and in Fast Forward personally I don't have an issue with either just thought it to be a bit hypocritical of him to say things like that about one thing and do it himself.
And I don't mind either way myself but tuns of people really do hate all the things going on with the turtles in the comics that he's having done to them which sort of once again seems hypocritical of him considering he rags on ideas from the old toon and he's pretty much doing to Raphael in the comics what they did to all 4 turtles in the last seasons of the show with their hyper-mutations.
He also dislikes the Images series and also isn't to fond of Archies tmnt which both in my opinion are leaps and bounds better both in the art and story telling department than volume 4 could ever begin to be but that's besides the point I just find it funny and a bit hypocritical of him to be using ideas in his comic that he's so proud of and fans defend because he did it yet they diss those other things simply because Peter Laird does not like them I just find it to be very unfair and I'll be honest I think it's foolish to ignore his past as if it was an embarrassment if it wasn't for that past he'd not be in the place he is today love it or hate it.
I don't see how the Turtles personalities have changed at all though besides in the tales of TMNT series which is done by other writers.
And I've got to be honest I liked Shadow as a child better than a teenager the crap she gets Raphael in or the others I don't find cool at all frankly I think she's pretty much the epitome of the old Toon April O'Niel type not anything like the teenage heroes the turtles had been at all.
It's hardly a risky move to have Splinter die and it was hardly made a big issue of that's what divided the fans here not the fact that Peter had him die. His send off was less than spectacular in many peoples opinions.
The only thing honestly that makes that issue special to me is that for the first and only time one of my letters had been printed in the comic.
Aprils Story hardly brought Depth to her if you really think about it what it did was take away from her as a person now she's just some silly cartoon character. And once again it was handled better by Chris Allen in the Tales of April issue of tales of TMNT that issue was just done so well.
It's not that I'm not on the side of Peter, Mirage, or Volume 4 it's just that I think what the new artists and story tellers are doing are leaps and bounds better than what someone who is more than likely tired of the Turtles is doing.
The thing I will say is missing from Volume 4 that Tales has is a mixture of everything and this is why I think people loved the TMNT so much in past Volumes of the comics because they went on different adventures as Ninja, Spacemen, Explorers, Etc.
The idea could have worked if it involved a brand new character.
And the idea was it was going to be used for Kirby the 5th turtle.
Kind of makes one wonder...:|

Scandia
08-05-2007, 06:52 AM
Had I not been told that Eastman and Laird were at Splinter's funeral, I would not have even noticed or suspected. But I recognized them immediately upon looking at this comic again.

I still don't like the fact that Splinter died.

About the secondary mutations- just reverse them soon. I think I liked how it was handled in the NT better than in the OT- no time travel was necessary.

The Turtles being able to walk around in broad daylight I don't mind. But I wish they had kept April as a regular human being. I do not think her being a line drawing adds all that much to the plot.

Roseangelo
08-05-2007, 11:43 AM
And the idea was it was going to be used for Kirby the 5th turtle.
Kind of makes one wonder...:|

There seems to be a long list of things to wonder about. Adults have disagreements and friendships end. That's just a fact of life. But Peter's behavior with many things post-friendship with Kevin just comes off as extremely childish.

VaughnMichael
08-05-2007, 03:24 PM
About the secondary mutations- just reverse them soon. I think I liked how it was handled in the NT better than in the OT- no time travel was necessary.
The turtles didn't time travel to fix their mutations in the old toon Donatello used the Vortex Crystal to fix it from the episode Doomquest.
The only one that didn't get fixed was Leonardo because Mung sent his Micro Bots after the Crystal taking a peice out of it while Leonardo was being cured sending his mutation into a wild beast like state. Which eventually is resolved.

CyberCubed
08-05-2007, 03:43 PM
I just reviewed through all the Tales issues and there are technically only two storylines that need to be resolved, as said in the opening post:

- The three Mystic Foot Ninja's vs. Splinter, which started in Tales #2 and continued with Tales #11.

- Ross May's story about that female ninja in Tales #22, "Change of Power"

I'm sure there are other stories that plan to be expanded by their authors at some point, but at the moment those are the only two storylines that are currently written/produced without resolution. Everything else is either being resolved in specials (the Raph/Shadow werewolf story), or just stuff in Volume 4 which is up to Laird to do whenever he gets back to writing.

I'm not sure what else needs loose ends tying up at the moment besides what's above, and I don't see why two issues completing or expanding the stories above can't fill 2 out of the 12 issue slots in 2008.

discordiatookie
08-05-2007, 03:50 PM
Just reading through this and thought i'd chip in my two cents worth. I personally love volume 4, having came in half way through it, and it was my stepping on point for my rediscovery of all things TMNT. And i'm kinda excited about an in-house year of TMNT. I just hope its not forever, I really dig the two comics, Peter Laird writing vol 4 and others doing Tales. (Here's hoping he doesn't scrap vol 4 and do Tales from here on in... )

One thing i'm excited about (and I may just be reading between the lines) is Eric Talbot. On his blog he's been saying stuff like I've been busy working on stuff that I can't talk about or show so here is something from an old sketchbook. and Well I'm still busy working on things I can't show yet - so more old stuff. so i'm really hoping he's working on an issue of Tales. I love his art so much, if there was one turtles artist that I could meet and get a sketch from (that wasn't Kev or Pete), it would be him, hands down. And while i'm at it, Mike Dooney and AC Farley knocking out an issue each would be heavenly.

In saying all this, Murphy did say this in an interview with CJJ that's posted on his blog As of right now, the next mini-series is Tales of Michelangelo, written and illustrated by Jim Lawson (with inks possibly by Eric Talbot), with plot approved by Peter Laird. It’s currently slated for release in summer 2008, and is meant to give Jim work while he waits for Pete to return to writing TMNT V.4.

So I just hope that Laird doesn't give Jim Lawson ALL the Tales to draw. I really dig Lawson, but I dig the fact that Tales has a massive rota of different folks working on it even more... Also, does all this 'in-house' Tales stuff not coincide with the 25th anniversary, which makes me hope that its just temporary!

Andrew NDB
08-05-2007, 07:09 PM
Just reading through this and thought i'd chip in my two cents worth. I personally love volume 4, having came in half way through it, and it was my stepping on point for my rediscovery of all things TMNT. And i'm kinda excited about an in-house year of TMNT. I just hope its not forever, I really dig the two comics, Peter Laird writing vol 4 and others doing Tales. (Here's hoping he doesn't scrap vol 4 and do Tales from here on in... )

One thing i'm excited about (and I may just be reading between the lines) is Eric Talbot. On his blog he's been saying stuff like and so i'm really hoping he's working on an issue of Tales. I love his art so much, if there was one turtles artist that I could meet and get a sketch from (that wasn't Kev or Pete), it would be him, hands down. And while i'm at it, Mike Dooney and AC Farley knocking out an issue each would be heavenly.

In saying all this, Murphy did say this in an interview with CJJ that's posted on his blog

So I just hope that Laird doesn't give Jim Lawson ALL the Tales to draw. I really dig Lawson, but I dig the fact that Tales has a massive rota of different folks working on it even more... Also, does all this 'in-house' Tales stuff not coincide with the 25th anniversary, which makes me hope that its just temporary!

I'm sure whatever Talbot has up his sleeve that he "can't talk about" has nothing to do with TMNT or Tales.

VaughnMichael
08-05-2007, 07:56 PM
I'm sure whatever Talbot has up his sleeve that he "can't talk about" has nothing to do with TMNT or Tales.
I hope that's sarcasm because I'd like to know what would lead you to believe he isn't going to be doing anything for tmnt? I mean unless you're Eric or know something no one else does?

Andrew NDB
08-05-2007, 08:21 PM
I hope that's sarcasm because I'd like to know what would lead you to believe he isn't going to be doing anything for tmnt? I mean unless you're Eric or know something no one else does?

Oh, I'm certain he'll probably be working on TMNT into 2008 or so, particularly since the "in-house" stipulation is in effect. But who's-working-on-what-issue-of-Tales has never been a closely-guarded secret.

It's probably some design work for Hollywood, comic work for another publisher, or something else entirely.

VaughnMichael
08-05-2007, 08:28 PM
Oh, I'm certain he'll probably be working on TMNT into 2008 or so, particularly since the "in-house" stipulation is in effect. But who's-working-on-what-issue-of-Tales has never been a closely-guarded secret.

It's probably some design work for Hollywood, comic work for another publisher, or something else entirely.
Well they haven't even said what in-house artist are still around or are going to be a part of all of this yet so there's that.
And The only thing I've ever seen Eric do outside of tmnt is his Skull factory stuff. It would be nice to see him doing other things but I really doubt it will be anything but Ninja Turtle related.

Roseangelo
08-05-2007, 08:39 PM
I have to agree with Putrescent. As talented as Eric is, you have to be a REALLY big name in comic books to make the Hollywood connection. Names like Simon Bisley and Mark Bode get that kind of work.

Ninjinister
08-05-2007, 09:21 PM
Excuse me if it's already been said, but does this mean all art will be in-house as well? I was looking forward to more issues by Diego Jourdan, Paul Harmon, and Chris Allan in the near future. Plus, I spoke to Jesse Munoz at FCB the last two years, and he expressed a large interest in perhaps being a Tales artist (don't know how one would go about doing that though ^^; ).

What my question is, I guess, is with a ban on all outside story submissions, does that also keep out art submissions?

Roseangelo
08-05-2007, 09:32 PM
Excuse me if it's already been said, but does this mean all art will be in-house as well?

What my question is, I guess, is with a ban on all outside story submissions, does that also keep out art submissions?

In-house applies to everything - Art, stories, or anything else that comes out. However, Chris Allan may be considered in-house. I can't say for sure, though. (I know I would personally consider him in-house.)

Ninjinister
08-06-2007, 01:29 PM
Bugger on a stick -_-

Spitfire
08-06-2007, 06:16 PM
Interesting.

And as far as Peter's writing goes, I personally love it. As the Eastman and Laird partnership was coming to an end, it was becoming plain to me that Eastman wanted to take the characters in a darker, goofier direction, not so serious about characters, more becoming "early 90's Image-like" if you get my drift. All I can say is thank goodness that Laird stayed on. I kind of look at him as the heart of the Turtles, and his understanding of their personalities and their human qualities stayed on. So I love what he's done with Volume 4. Don't misunderstand, I love Eastman's work, and his art was phenomenal and truly helped shape the Turtles. It's just that at the end, I'm glad Laird got the franchise. So here's hoping for his return to V.4 soon!

Woah woah woah, back up for a second. Did you ever READ a volume 1 turtles comic? Their violent, and they don't take themselves seriously either.

The Image series was one of the best turtles series out there in my opinion. Volume 2 was garbage, volume 4 is garbage, and most of the tales volume 2 issues are garbage.

Honestly the core goodness of turtles is Volume 1, Volume 3*Image, and the Archie series. Funny enough Laird hates the last two of those. I wonder why that is? Because someone made a better comic book then he could.

The way I look at it Laird is ruining turtles. Volume 4 has terrible artwork and the stories in it are just lame. And Tales 2 has some good issues mixed in with some crap ones to. Why does everyone need an origin? Why does Rat King have one? He was cool because he was mysterious. I dread to see Casey's. And April's in volume 4 was so bad I don't even want to try and use words to express my hate for it.

I also love how Laird takes cartoon concepts and adds them to the comics. Like the Battle Nexus, the Ninja Tribunal, and The Ancient One. What is the point in that? It's bad enough his comic adapt episodes are terrible now he's mixing it with the core mythology.

You want goofy watch any episode based off a comic in the new series. Their horrible compared to the comic. And after reading all those issues again I began to dislike the new series a lot more. I like Fast Forward and many of the non-comic based episodes because their something new and their actually really good for the most part.

he made a very bold move in the Utrom arrival, thus allowing the Turtles to walk around in broad daylight.
This makes me laugh here. Laird hated the old toon because the turtles walk around in day light...funny.

I don't know who inflated your ego, seems all the new blood in Mirage is like you, but unlike most of the people on this forum I'm not going to kiss your ass just because you work on the turtles. And it looks like I'm not the only one here who thinks this way.

Roseangelo
08-06-2007, 06:25 PM
Spitfire gets a cookie.

TristanHuwJones
08-06-2007, 07:46 PM
Woah woah woah, back up for a second. Did you ever READ a volume 1 turtles comic? Their violent, and they don't take themselves seriously either.

The Image series was one of the best turtles series out there in my opinion. Volume 2 was garbage, volume 4 is garbage, and most of the tales volume 2 issues are garbage.

Honestly the core goodness of turtles is Volume 1, Volume 3*Image, and the Archie series. Funny enough Laird hates the last two of those. I wonder why that is? Because someone made a better comic book then he could.

The way I look at it Laird is ruining turtles. Volume 4 has terrible artwork and the stories in it are just lame. And Tales 2 has some good issues mixed in with some crap ones to. Why does everyone need an origin? Why does Rat King have one? He was cool because he was mysterious. I dread to see Casey's. And April's in volume 4 was so bad I don't even want to try and use words to express my hate for it.

I also love how Laird takes cartoon concepts and adds them to the comics. Like the Battle Nexus, the Ninja Tribunal, and The Ancient One. What is the point in that? It's bad enough his comic adapt episodes are terrible now he's mixing it with the core mythology.

You want goofy watch any episode based off a comic in the new series. Their horrible compared to the comic. And after reading all those issues again I began to dislike the new series a lot more. I like Fast Forward and many of the non-comic based episodes because their something new and their actually really good for the most part.


This makes me laugh here. Laird hated the old toon because the turtles walk around in day light...funny.

I don't know who inflated your ego, seems all the new blood in Mirage is like you, but unlike most of the people on this forum I'm not going to kiss your ass just because you work on the turtles. And it looks like I'm not the only one here who thinks this way.

A lot of what you're saying here is valid, it's an opinion I know is shared by others, but -- and I want to be clear that I'm not attacking you here -- I can't recall Peter ever saying explicitly that he HATED anything as you've said here. I know he said he didn't like a number of aspects, particularly the goofiness of the OT, and I've read and heard a number of times that he didn't like how cute and 'round' they were. He also said in the letters of Vol. 4 that he doesn't HATE the Image series, and says that there are a number of great ideas used in that series - along with the art - but that at the time, it wasn't the direction he wanted to take the Turtles in. The Image series is great in that you can read it and PERSONALLY keep it as part of TMNT continuity, because nothing before or after it has contradicted anything in the Image series. Sure, things have been ignored, but that doesn't mean the reader has to. I'd be more pissed off if I were a solid DC reader, with all the varying Earths and Crisis events and such, but you still get a lot of readers who like to keep stories not considered part of one continuity in-continuity because they just like the story so much.

Some other things you brought up are worth considering too. The Battlenexus was brought into Vol.4 at a point where the story was cut short, so really, we have no idea how that idea was to be incorporated into the story and in my mind (my mind here!) can't truly be judged without a little bit more.
The Ancient One and the Ninja Tribunal were only brought into the Leonardo one shot, which tied into the movie, which itself is a seperate universe to the Mirage U.
I know it's a completely seperate issue too, but it comes up time and time again: the cartoons are for kids. Not that we can't and shouldn't be able to enjoy them equally, but when they sit down to write the shows, be it a new episode or a comic adaptation, they're being written with a couple of very important things in mind: Audience and Censors. Part of the reason Australia got the Lost Season on DVD was because we have much looser censorship laws here. I know when I write my Fast Forward stories that they are being projected to a certain demographic, and the mentality I employ when writing them is vastly different to the one I was in when I wrote Tales #36. We've heard it a few times that the reason Fast Forward was pushed ahead was because interest in the show was waning; not necessarily from us, but from children - the target demographic. Anyway, my point is that the reason the cartoon adaptations of the comics won't be able to live up to the original stories is simply because they never truly can. If TMNT were a viable ADULT television property, then sure, adaptations would work awesomely, but edits have to be made so the show can continue running, otherwise parent groups get up in arms and the show gets the can. Who knows, maybe someday we'll get a straight to DVD turtles movie or mini series like what's currently in store for Batman and Spiderman where we won't have to worry about anything being kiddyfied (fingers crossed!).

Again, all this is simply a counter though to some of the issues you've raised, I'm not attacking you, or if I am it isn't intentional, because much of what you've raised here is valid opinion which everyone here should be entitled to do without worrying about being flamed horrifically, unless of course, they state that the want to be burned ;)

CyberCubed
08-06-2007, 08:07 PM
Random thoughts:

*doesn't think Laird is ruining TMNT writing-wise, although Mirage as a company really needs new blood and better structure*

*doesn't think Lawsons art is horrid, but it isn't that good either and Volume 4 would benefit from a face-lift*

*Volume 4's biggest problem is pacing, the bi-monthly releases, and the long hiatus (has it been over a year since he stopped yet?), otherwise I think the stories are ok. there's just too many of them going on at once*

*Most of Tales V.2 is well written and has good artwork, in all seriousness I think I liked Murphy's tales the LEAST, for some reason I didn't care for a good chunk of his stories but most of the freelancers have done a wonderful job on the Tales they've done*

* I enjoyed the Image and Archie series, both non-Mirage canon

* I want Kevin Eastman to do some more Turtle stories, hopefully in Tales or with his own bi-monthly comic*

VaughnMichael
08-06-2007, 09:21 PM
* I want Kevin Eastman to do some more Turtle stories, hopefully in Tales or with his own bi-monthly comic*
You aren't the only one buddy! WE WANT KEVIN BACK!!

RossMay
08-06-2007, 09:42 PM
Rather harsh there, Spitfire. If you don’t agree with Quinn (or anyone in particular) then fine, but how does him liking Peter’s work give him an “inflated ego”? I mean yeah, you’re right, I have a massive ego – COMPLETE prick in real life – but I can tell you all the other new guys are pretty swell people.

VaughnMichael
08-06-2007, 10:03 PM
Rather harsh there, Spitfire. If you don’t agree with Quinn (or anyone in particular) then fine, but how does him liking Peter’s work give him an “inflated ego”? I mean yeah, you’re right, I have a massive ego – COMPLETE prick in real life – but I can tell you all the other new guys are pretty swell people.
I think Spitfire like many of us are sick and tired of people Bashing Kevin Eastman and licking Peter Lairds butt all of the time.
You know I keep trying to gain my respect back for the guy really I do but every time I get some back for him he kills it with bad moves he keeps making conerning merch.:ohwell:
And unlike most of us Spitfire says the things we all wish we really could say to these people.
I try to be as polite as I can even when I don't like some thing but nope not spitfire his name works pretty well for him I'd say.:lol:

Spitfire
08-06-2007, 11:39 PM
Again, all this is simply a counter though to some of the issues you've raised, I'm not attacking you, or if I am it isn't intentional, because much of what you've raised here is valid opinion which everyone here should be entitled to do without worrying about being flamed horrifically, unless of course, they state that the want to be burned ;)

I'll be honest here, I wasn't expecting you to respond to me and I totally wasn't expecting you to be so civil about it, I've gotten some interesting responses to my words in the past from Mirage workers. So thank you for that.

I could be wrong but I seem to remember the Ancient One being mentioned in a Tales issue as well as the Leo movie issue. But what you said makes sense.

And I know the turtles can't be brutally violent or anything but what bothers me about the toon comic episodes is their really drug out. Like "Turtles In Space" for example. I think that could have been pulled off in 2 or 3 episodes. As where "City At War" wasn't long enough.

But hey thanks for that and keep up the good writing.

And unlike most of us Spitfire says the things we all wish we really could say to these people.
I try to be as polite as I can even when I don't like some thing but nope not spitfire his name works pretty well for him I'd say.
Biting my tongue doesn't suit me. In this world assume everyone will be rude and when they prove otherwise you see the kind of person they are.

I came at Tristan here like a complete asshole yet his response to me was very civil. For that I respect him greatly for I can see the kind of level headed person he is in that.

TristanHuwJones
08-06-2007, 11:54 PM
I'll be honest here, I wasn't expecting you to respond to me and I totally wasn't expecting you to be so civil about it, I've gotten some interesting responses to my words in the past from Mirage workers. So thank you for that.

I could be wrong but I seem to remember the Ancient One being mentioned in a Tales issue as well as the Leo movie issue. But what you said makes sense.

No worries mate, just trying to keep a balance here. :)

Hmmm. I'm in New York at the moment, which is a long, long way from home. If you remember which issue it is, be sure to let me know!

And I know the turtles can't be brutally violent or anything but what bothers me about the toon comic episodes is their really drug out. Like "Turtles In Space" for example. I think that could have been pulled off in 2 or 3 episodes. As where "City At War" wasn't long enough.

But hey thanks for that and keep up the good writing.

I do agree that some arcs could have been wound up a little quicker, but I think a lot of that is in retrospect. I know I enjoyed watching the whole thing play out as it was on television, and when the newer additions were introduced it was pretty neat. But this is just me.

Thanks for the kudos too, we'll see what happens next year...

Biting my tongue doesn't suit me. In this world assume everyone will be rude and when they prove otherwise you see the kind of person they are.

I came at Tristan here like a complete asshole yet his response to me was very civil. For that I respect him greatly for I can see the kind of level headed person he is in that.

Your philosophy on people is one I hear a lot these days! I like to think the otherway around, but that's just me again! :P

:lol: Don't worry too much dude, I didn't take any of it personally, though you might want to watch comments like the new blood one, it could be very easily misread. I'm just here to have some fun and talk with other fans of the TMNT, and while everyone here has a right to voice their opinion, we're all fans of the same thing here, so if one person likes something another doesn't it shouldn't be THAT big a problem (shouldn't be, of course, there are always exceptions... in EXTREME circumstances of course!).

Peace out!

Spitfire
08-07-2007, 12:05 AM
No worries mate, just trying to keep a balance here. :)

Hmmm. I'm in New York at the moment, which is a long, long way from home. If you remember which issue it is, be sure to let me know!
In the Rat King Origin issue they mentioned him, maybe it's someone else?

I do agree that some arcs could have been wound up a little quicker, but I think a lot of that is in retrospect. I know I enjoyed watching the whole thing play out as it was on television, and when the newer additions were introduced it was pretty neat. But this is just me.

Thanks for the kudos too, we'll see what happens next year...
No it was fun to watch it play out, I just got nit picky after repeat watchings over the years. Kind of like watching a movie so many times you start to notice errors or parts that drag. haha my fault for watching them to many times I guess.

And what ever it is I'll give it a shot. I know alot of people around here hate FF but I love it like I said before. And while I was one of the haters at first it really grew on me over time.


Your philosophy on people is one I hear a lot these days! I like to think the otherway around, but that's just me again! :P

:lol: Don't worry too much dude, I didn't take any of it personally, though you might want to watch comments like the new blood one, it could be very easily misread. I'm just here to have some fun and talk with other fans of the TMNT, and while everyone here has a right to voice their opinion, we're all fans of the same thing here, so if one person likes something another doesn't it shouldn't be THAT big a problem (shouldn't be, of course, there are always exceptions... in EXTREME circumstances of course!).

Peace out!

I know I can be really mean sometimes, but like I said I'm glad we got someone on here who just wants to have fun to. I know sometimes people in the minority get flamed here.

odupianist
08-07-2007, 09:50 AM
and this folks is how a debate/discussion on this stuff should go on these forums. I typically support Spitfire, he just says what we're all thinking without sugarcoating it lol.

TristanHuwJones
08-07-2007, 11:10 AM
No, I'm of the opinion that anyone should be able to voice their opinion, no matter what it may be, and you're right, there's no need to sugarcoat anything, but in the same instance -- and this applies to anyone (not targeting you here Spitfire, we're on the level ;) ) -- there's not really any need to be sandpaper anything either. Arguing in type format never really gets anywhere anyway in my mind. It's not as though one can correctly "read" how someone has written something every time. How many times do you see things on forums or on messenger or email where you read something totally off the way it was intended to be? Some of my best mates lost girlfriends that way:lol: !

ANYWAY... Let's get back on topic...

quinnmjohnson
08-08-2007, 03:05 PM
Wow, I don't think I've ever been accused of having an inflated ego or being a butt-kisser before. :) Like Tristan said, it's cool how people of greatly different opinions on the same subject but who share a common interest can have a place to share their thoughts with each other. I thought I was passionate about the Turtles, but it looks like many of you have got me beat! I doubt Eastman and Laird ever thought their idea would ever get big enough for stuff like this!

So follow your dreams, kids, and don't do drugs. :)