View Full Version : EW's idea of a purist...
ToTheNines
08-11-2007, 10:45 AM
While reading through TMNT articles on ew.com (that's Entertainment Weekly) I was reading through this: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20015850,00.html
A short little article, not bad... until that last paragraph. Sounds like a decent plan. But will anyone care? So far, reviews have been mixed, and purists are irked by the Shredder's absence.
Now, I would ask "why is it that no one seems to have any idea what the TMNT fan-base is about". But I know the answer: the OT. Still ruffles my feathers tho.
EDIT: This little fan-boy some how got into entertainment weekly http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20015584,00.html
Not enough pizza... I've never seen a professional review seem so BAD.
Splinter's Iroonna
08-11-2007, 10:51 AM
Some people just do not get the fact that before there was OT, there was Comic.
I just read EW in the Doctor's office yesterday, about the release of the DVD. Some of her phrases were used I think (or paraphrased) in that little snippet-- at least, reading the link you gave sounded familiar to what I read yesterday.
Avatar Yuffie
08-11-2007, 11:39 AM
I wonder how viewers of the OT felt when they saw the Live Action movie in the for the first time... because that didn't follow the OT either...
Roseangelo
08-11-2007, 12:02 PM
I wonder how viewers of the OT felt when they saw the Live Action movie in the for the first time... because that didn't follow the OT either...
I can tell you that when I saw the first movie, on the very day it opened, all I knew before that was the cartoon. I don't think I even knew there was a comic book yet. And I LOVED the movie. I'd notice differences from the cartoon, but instead of thinking how wrong it was, I'd go to myself, "Ok, I can roll with that."
But it all depends on the person. The first movie got similarly panned for not being enough like the cartoon.
ToTheNines
08-11-2007, 12:21 PM
But it all depends on the person. The first movie got similarly panned for not being enough like the cartoon.
Yeah, but when you see all those faux-OT fanboys/girls in any other forum or message board they always say "omgz teh newww TNMt iz rilly gayyyy, teh rill cartoon iz betta an so was da moviez"
CyberCubed
08-11-2007, 05:10 PM
I knew there were differences between the movie Turtles and old toon Turtles yet I didn't care.
I noticed that Splinter was a rat instead of Hamato Yoshi, that there was no Krang, and that the Foot soldiers weren't robots. I must have been only 7 or 8 at the time, yet none of that bothered me.
I honestly can't imagine why people throw whiny and pissy fits just because the Turtles are different in various incarnations. I was only a kid at the time and NONE of that bothered me.
mattmanw54301
08-11-2007, 05:47 PM
For alot of people in the mainstream (i.e. people for whom TMNT was just a passing childhood thing), the OT was the beginning, middle, and end of the whole TMNT universe. It's what they remember, because it was BIGGER than anything else. They don't remember the comics, or the live action movies, or anything else.
Case in point: I used to work in a video store, and I would open every Sunday. Every other sunday was TMNT day!!! (the others being Superman day) And my coworker and I would play the live action TMNT movies all in order (yes, even 3) on the big screens that video stores have all around the store. And each and every time, someone would say 'TMNT!!! Awesome!!!!' And almost every time, the next question they had would be 'Where's Krang?'
See, to most people, TMNT is nothing but a fuzzy childhood memory. So they are looking at it after not having seen it since they were kids. Still though, it was a great movie IMO. And not having Shredder in it doesnt matter. The Foot and Karai were major players. Besides, they basically said that he will come back in the next one.
Avatar Yuffie
08-11-2007, 08:45 PM
Never saw the first movie in theaters T.T. Just in good old betamax.
I rectify that in the second movie.
But I really like the first one. Deep entrenched in the OT it didn't bother me that the turtles call each other in short names, or that the Foot are people, that Casey permanently joins the good guys or that Splinter's origin story is different from the one I saw in TV.
I do have issues with Don's character portrayal, and his lack of technical hoo haaas... but I'll live.
People should need to lighten up, sometimes...
Ninjinister
08-11-2007, 10:53 PM
Ohhh nooo.... Beta!
I find it utterly repulsive how people complain about no Krang, Rocksteady, or Bebop in this latest movie... because they never WERE in the other movies, either -_-
Andrew NDB
08-12-2007, 12:50 AM
While reading through TMNT articles on ew.com (that's Entertainment Weekly) I was reading through this: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20015850,00.html
A short little article, not bad... until that last paragraph. Sounds like a decent plan. But will anyone care? So far, reviews have been mixed, and purists are irked by the Shredder's absence.
I try to stay away from articles like that, due to my kneejerk looking-for-nearest-brick-wall-to-go-beat-my-head-against tendency at such media related to TMNT.
Coola Yagami
08-12-2007, 01:50 AM
eh, I noticed differences as a kid, but really, I was blinded by the fact that we got to see real-life Ninja Turtles kicking all sorts of ass, and that Shredder was a total kick-ass villian. I mean, that was awesome back then for any TMNT fan, and for the most part the turtles still acted silly, still had their trademark colors and weapons, we had lots of pizza and they still said Cowabunga, so it wasn't that big of a deal.
At the time I was also surprised they had no Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady, but it just didn't bother me. After I saw behind-the-scenes specials on TV showing how much work went into the Turtles and Splinter I just figured it was too expensive to make Bebop, Rocksteady and Krang too. Even back then, my friends and I had no idea how they'd make a talking brain work in real life. As for the sequel, I was confused like hell why they made up Tokka and Rahzar and not used Bebop and Rocksteady, but I just went with it.
Buslady
08-12-2007, 09:52 AM
maybe they should stick a PSA up before the movie:
"Dear Audience, please note this is not the old cartoon. There is no Krang, no Shredder, Bebop, Rocksteady, or any of the old cartoon elements. This is the real turtles, dark and serious. Splinter is a rat, not a person. The turtles KILL...If you dont like that idea, get the H*LL out of the theatre or open your mind and check it out; you might dig it. Just for 120 minutes, take them seriously and you might like the idea."
Jo Dawn
08-12-2007, 10:13 PM
I try to stay away from articles like that, due to my kneejerk looking-for-nearest-brick-wall-to-go-beat-my-head-against tendency at such media related to TMNT.
Haha. Hear, hear! My blood pressure went up reading that. I think a letter to EW is in store.
I now need to go scream into a pillow.
Kendamu
08-12-2007, 10:29 PM
This is just proof that if you want another $200 Million from the masses that you should throw Shredder into the next movie.
ToTheNines
08-12-2007, 10:40 PM
This is just proof that if you want another $200 Million from the masses that you should throw Shredder into the next movie.
200 mil? are you callin that?
While reading through TMNT articles on ew.com (that's Entertainment Weekly) I was reading through this: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20015850,00.html
A short little article, not bad... until that last paragraph. Sounds like a decent plan. But will anyone care? So far, reviews have been mixed, and purists are irked by the Shredder's absence.
Now, I would ask "why is it that no one seems to have any idea what the TMNT fan-base is about". But I know the answer: the OT. Still ruffles my feathers tho.
EDIT: This little fan-boy some how got into entertainment weekly http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20015584,00.html
Not enough pizza... I've never seen a professional review seem so BAD.
There's no such thing as a TMNT purist, since the franchise has been spawned into different variations. There's Mirage canon, which is basically gospel because it was the first form the turtles took; then there's OT, which was watered down (or should I say candied up) for kids and made the most money; then you've got Next Mutation, the unholy and blasphemous take on the group; after that there's 2K3, which revitalized the franchise with a mix of Mirage and OT and yet still holding true to form. Given that Shredder has gone through so many variations himself, not having him in the film in a physical sense shouldn't (and actually didn't) upset any fans at all. The article is one-sided and holds little water, if any, about the high hopes for the film's release.
As for the second article, it's even worse. At least the first one cited the 2K3 series, which is what the film was mostly based on (with the exception of Shredder's first-movie helmet, which in my opinion was more of a homage than a significant source of continuity; and the stacks of pizza boxes, which again I think is another homage, this time to the OT). This one had no research backing it up other than some jabroni's boo-hooing about how it's not like the OT. Horrible review; I give it a D-. It would've been an F but he had good grammar.
ew.com ... EW, indeed. Grotesque literature.
Jo Dawn
08-12-2007, 10:44 PM
To me, that just proves how immature people are. They need to get over Shredder and move on.
If they put Shredder in the next one, if there is one, I'll be disappointed. Not that I didn't like him, but he's D-E-A-D. And has been for a looooong time.
Well... the 'purists' know that. ;)
Kendamu
08-12-2007, 11:31 PM
200 mil? are you callin that?
I'm just estimating based off the idea that Transformers definitely didn't have that "ZOMG OLD TOON" feel to it... but it had Optimus Prime fighting Megatron so it ended up doing well. Besides, not having Shredder was the biggest complaint I heard from all the people who didn't go see it or didn't like it.
It might also have something to do with it being allowed to have real violence in it... but y'never know.
odupianist
08-13-2007, 08:49 AM
maybe they should stick a PSA up before the movie:
Hah the first thing I thought of was the disclaimer from Dogma.
Personally, I dont care if Shredhead's in it or not, at least the presence of the Foot was there. The Foot at least still bothered the TMNT in the comics, so that's still somewhat true having them in the movie.
Jester
08-13-2007, 09:26 AM
I would consider myself a TMNT purist, because I just plain like the Turtles. I don't care if the villain's a ninja master, an alien brain, or a mutant shark, give me TMNT and I'm happy. I think the only people who raise a big stink about it are people who aren't purists. People who's only experience with TMNT is the OT and maybe the first 3 films. A purist to me is a fan of the franchise in all it's incarnations (well...maybe not NT:TNM)
Man I wish the TMNT fan-dom was as respected as Trans-fans and the like. Heck we don't even have a sweet nick name....
The Shelf
08-13-2007, 10:08 AM
To me, that just proves how immature people are. They need to get over Shredder and move on.
If they put Shredder in the next one, if there is one, I'll be disappointed. Not that I didn't like him, but he's D-E-A-D. And has been for a looooong time.
Well... the 'purists' know that. ;)
I don't mind one way or another regarding Shredder, but I hope you won't be too disappointed if he shows up in a sequel. If we're going off the previous movie continuities he hasn't been dead that long, and he may not be dead at all. I mean, if he can survive getting crushed by a trash compactor as regular Shredder, I'm pretty sure he can survive a few wooden planks and beams falling on him as Super Shredder. But I wouldn't be surprised if they go the cloning route either, like the comics. Anyways, they've already hinted that Shredder might be back in a sequel, so just don't get too disappointed. What you should really be afraid of is if they decide to put Krang in it, but I think we're probably safe from that, as Kevin seems to be a bigger fan of the comics than the OT.
ToTheNines
08-13-2007, 10:35 AM
Man I wish the TMNT fan-dom was as respected as Trans-fans and the like. Heck we don't even have a sweet nick name....
'Dromers? mabey...
Andrew NDB
08-13-2007, 12:06 PM
"Dear Audience, please note this is not the old cartoon. This is the real turtles, dark and serious. Splinter is a rat, not a person. The turtles KILL...If you dont like that idea, get the H*LL out of the theatre or open your mind and check it out; you might dig it. Just for 120 minutes, take them seriously and you might like the idea."
If only someone would have explained this to the people behind the movie.
Ninjinister
08-13-2007, 02:40 PM
Hah the first thing I thought of was the disclaimer from Dogma.
So they should have had the guy running the diner reading that aloud to the audience as it was displayed onscreen ^^
Drtooth
08-14-2007, 09:14 AM
Seriously... was anyone actually dumb enough to think this was going to be the old series? I mean, considering it was based off the first 3 movies which didn't have anything to do with the cartoons, except for the colored bandanas, Reporter April, and the logo at the beginning.
Krang was NOT in TMNT 1-3, nor was Rocksteady, Bebop, Baxter Stockman as a fly (though a movie about the real Baxter Stockman is my impossible dream).
And going into the comics, there was never a Cowabunga uttered. No Pizzas eaten... and Casey Jones actually showed up and did things.
I can't stand these reviews. They're either reviewed by people too old to care or drunken 20 year olds who just don't get it was a serious comic to begin with that they had to lighten up to sell toys.
There's a fine line difference between someone that prefers the older cartoon and says, "I like the style of it better, and this dark turn doesn't work for me" and "Omg no kowagunba wat or you hjigh? gay fart poop..."
That said, if they don't like it watch one of the horrible Animal House knockoffs that drunken 20 year olds pretend to love so much. Yeah. Rise of Taj was a good movie..... this one wasn't. You can tell, because TMNT had quality in writing.
But I digress. Shredhead does NOT have to hold up the franchise. Much as the Joker doesn't have to hold up Batman. Sure, he's been in 4 movies, though (including the upcoming one, the animates one, and the 1960's) one.
mattmanw54301
08-14-2007, 11:26 AM
I agree with you Dr Tooth. But the problem is, alot of the critics/nostalgia audience that remembers TMNT from their childhood DID expect it to be like the old toon. And that is completely stupid of them.
Thankfully, in the months leading up to the release, when I explained to MY core group of friends (who are not hardcore fans) what the concept was, they all said 'You mean it's gonna be dark and more serious, like the original comics?'
So there is a large group of people out there who do appreciate and understand the diversity of stories and tones in TMNT storytelling. It's just that very few of them have access to web pages.
Andrew NDB
08-14-2007, 11:29 AM
Thankfully, in the months leading up to the release, when I explained to MY core group of friends (who are not hardcore fans) what the concept was, they all said 'You mean it's gonna be dark and more serious, like the original comics?'
Are they pissed because it turned out not to be?
ToTheNines
08-14-2007, 11:40 AM
And going into the comics, there was never a Cowabunga uttered.
Actually, Casey said it in "The Unmentionables"
But yeah, I agree with everything else you just said. It's rediculous that people are throwing such a fit because the villain hasn't been brought back. I know he was the main baddie in the OT, but the Turtles were the ones that were in every f**kin episode. I don't see why people can't be happy that the TMNT came back along with other supporting characters, that's all that matters (aside from the movie actually being good, but they all dismissed it before even seeing it.)
The Shelf
08-14-2007, 12:09 PM
Are they pissed because it turned out not to be?
Look, I'm not trying to be rude, but would you please get off it? Everyone's entitled to their opinion, but you've made yourself plenty clear, and you're beginning to sound like a broken record. :ohwell:
No, the new movie wasn't quite as dark and serious as the original comics, but it was far more serious than the OT could have ever hoped to be (except possibly the Red Sky series, but even that wasn't as serious as the new movie, imo).
And even if they didn't quite nail the seriousness of the old comics, they certainly nailed the dark style and atmosphere. I mean, you can't get much darker than having nearly the whole movie take place at night, in sewers, or in shadows.
It is precisely for these reasons that so many of the OT-only fans hated the new movie. You can't please everyone, but Kevin certainly tried. He did his best to please fans of the comics without completely alienating the much larger OT fanbase. I think he did about as well as he could have hoped to considering his goals.
xmen510
08-14-2007, 12:13 PM
The Shelf makes a great point there. Stop the bashing and just have a great discussion.
Ecto Jedi
08-14-2007, 12:50 PM
The guy's an attention-hog. He'll just keep posting these inane comments in every thread he can, at every opportunity he finds, just because that's the type of user he is. I've seen plenty of idiots like him before.
In fact, he's loving the fact that we're talking about him right now. Which is why we should just ignore the guy. Case closed.
Andrew NDB
08-14-2007, 02:12 PM
And even if they didn't quite nail the seriousness of the old comics, they certainly nailed the dark style and atmosphere. I mean, you can't get much darker than having nearly the whole movie take place at night, in sewers, or in shadows.
All right, I'll grant you that. And visually in general, the film is pretty much top notch. The only thing it loses marks from in my book is the manga/exaggerated-looking humans, but even that I can give a pass by chalking it off to artistic style.
Buslady
08-14-2007, 02:36 PM
If only someone would have explained this to the people behind the movie.
Andrew, knock it off. They did not do anything close to the OT...get over it. You can't expect a hard core TMNT. They have rules they gotta go by, they try to get away with what they can. You still haven't answered my questions Why did you buy it when you can't stand it?...what makes you so wonderful you know sooo much but you wooon't say...all you like to do is show off for attention. It's annoying.
Now if they were to do a high quality DTV TMNT movie aimed at the OLDER fans...then they can get away with ALOT more. But I would not want them to do so much that it removes them from their respectable personas.
I would like to see Bishop or a similar threat in a future movie. If they HAD to do Shreds, I wouldn't mind Karai taking on the Shredder outfit; but NO SAKI.
Andrew NDB
08-14-2007, 03:10 PM
You still haven't answered my questions Why did you buy it when you can't stand it?...
I'm a completist. What can I say?
what makes you so wonderful you know sooo much but you wooon't say...all you like to do is show off for attention. It's annoying.
I'd rather your annoyance than lawsuits. Sorry for that.
Now if they were to do a high quality DTV TMNT movie aimed at the OLDER fans...then they can get away with ALOT more. But I would not want them to do so much that it removes them from their respectable personas.
I don't see how "getting away with more" -- which I'm assuming you mean as it relates to a bit of violence, maybe a couple colorful words -- would take any of the Turtles away from their personas. How would you arrive at this conclusion?
I would like to see Bishop or a similar threat in a future movie.
They could do much worse than that, I suppose.
If they HAD to do Shreds, I wouldn't mind Karai taking on the Shredder outfit; but NO SAKI.
To be fair, I'm pretty sure that's what Munroe had been alluding to (i.e., Shredder coming back but it not being Saki, may or may not be Karai).
Ecto Jedi
08-14-2007, 03:21 PM
I would like to see Bishop or a similar threat in a future movie. If they HAD to do Shreds, I wouldn't mind Karai taking on the Shredder outfit; but NO SAKI.
Bishop in TMNT 2 or 3? Nah. A generic Agent Smith-look alike certainly won't win any fans.
Karai in the Shredder outfit? Could work, if done properly. What I'd like to see is Shredder return in plausible fashion, like in Volume 1 (worms, clones, whatever.) Shredder is just too bad-ass a villain to let fade away at the hands of, of all things, a creaky wooden dock.
ToTheNines
08-14-2007, 04:36 PM
I'd rather your annoyance than lawsuits. Sorry for that.
You crack me up.
mattmanw54301
08-14-2007, 04:58 PM
Maybe the next movie could go more in depth into TGRI, and the Utroms. Then they could have Shredder have the same 'secret identity' as in the cartoon (trying not to spoil, wink wink).
ToTheNines
08-14-2007, 05:38 PM
Maybe the next movie could go more in depth into TGRI, and the Utroms. Then they could have Shredder have the same 'secret identity' as in the cartoon (trying not to spoil, wink wink).
Ewww, no way man, that would be such a rip off. Besides, movie Saki is human (i.e. he turned into super shredder with the ooze).
Spike Spiegel
08-14-2007, 05:43 PM
Maybe the next movie could go more in depth into TGRI, and the Utroms. Then they could have Shredder have the same 'secret identity' as in the cartoon (trying not to spoil, wink wink).
Yeah, that would be pretty cool. I just hope that as the new CGI TMNT films go on, they forge their own mythology and create new stuff for us to talk about 16 years later. I honestly don't care that there may or may not be a Shredder.
Kendamu
08-15-2007, 02:56 AM
Bishop in TMNT 2 or 3? Nah. A generic Agent Smith-look alike certainly won't win any fans.
Karai in the Shredder outfit? Could work, if done properly. What I'd like to see is Shredder return in plausible fashion, like in Volume 1 (worms, clones, whatever.) Shredder is just too bad-ass a villain to let fade away at the hands of, of all things, a creaky wooden dock.
I agree. Plus, the logic behind the wood not killing him would make a great joke in the next movie.
Jester
08-15-2007, 02:20 PM
'Dromers? mabey...
I call fans who frequent here Dromers (or Dromies...not sure which is better), and I guess we could call all TMNT fans that but it's a bit to OT exclusive. Maybe, sadly like the company that spawned them, the TMNT fandom is little more than a Mirage.
Ecto Jedi
08-15-2007, 11:50 PM
Maybe, saddly like the company that spawned them, the TMNT fandom is little more than a Mirage.
Ooh, nice one Jester.
Drtooth
08-16-2007, 12:59 PM
I said it before and I'll say it again, I do NOT want Shredder in the next movie... only if it's a title. But then the whole movie would be "return of the Shredder" and not really anything they tried to accomplish here. Sure, they'd please these "Where is the Shredder" OT fans, but it would be a cheat.
I mean, looking back TMNT 2 was weak because it was return of the Shredder, and it became even more cartoony than the first one, especially the Super Shredder bit at the end.
Much like MIB 2 and Ghostbusters 2, the sequal turned into a movie version of the cartoon (more in MIB 2, when the Aliens even looked like they were taken from the cartoon) and it didn't work. I want to see a sequal that keeps the integrity of this film and expands on it. Not just a "Hey! Let's make a sequal" type deal.
ToTheNines
08-16-2007, 02:30 PM
Yeah, while I do want to see him in a way, it's been done already. It'll just be like a remake, nothing new. Who knows, mabey they could make an interesting story involving Saki, I just can't picture it happening. And if Karai is the Shredder, they had better not advertise that way. All those "shyyt, no shredder head in dis movie" people you see will turn into "OmGz, wtfZ teh Shrdar is a gurl" people.
ZariusTwo
08-16-2007, 04:22 PM
Actually, I want The Shredder back in the sequel, reviving mystically or otherwise. The new series did'nt did'nt get rid of Shredder ever (even with Fast Forward, which featured cameos from Ch'rell), it's utterly futile to assume he'll remain out of the next few sequels.
Drtooth
08-16-2007, 05:22 PM
Like I said. Theoretically a movie with Shredder coming back would have potential, but then it would get bogged down in "On No! Remember Shredder? He's Back" cliches.
I want to see something new, but mainly staying in the context of the comics, with a villain based on a comic character. Rick Viech's the River would make a good movie. I don't think it could be done. But I feel cheated they didn't make it a multiple episode arc.
Ecto Jedi
08-16-2007, 09:13 PM
Like I said. Theoretically a movie with Shredder coming back would have potential, but then it would get bogged down in "On No! Remember Shredder? He's Back" cliches.
I think having Karai don the Shredder armour could work, if done properly. What would you think of that?
johnnyblaze
08-16-2007, 11:57 PM
i think flashbacks to the turtle's final battle with the shredder could work but overall i think he should be there not so much physically but more like his influence is still being felt.
Andrew NDB
08-17-2007, 12:31 PM
I'd love to see the Shredder again... but it needs to be in a complete reboot, and one done properly.
Drtooth
08-17-2007, 01:25 PM
I think having Karai don the Shredder armour could work, if done properly. What would you think of that?
If done properly, it wouldn't quite be so much of "Dear God! Remember when we thought the Shredder was dead? Well..." It could be more like, "Karai is still bonded with her father. and now she feels she must ressurect his title to avenge his death." Which would be pretty amazing, actually.
I'd love to see some story from the comics done in movie form. maybe they could use the Karai bit and do sort of a "City at War" type twist on it. Only having Karai already introduced.
TheAnimatedSeries
08-17-2007, 07:02 PM
Are they pissed because it turned out not to be?
SERIOUSLY THOUGH, TMNT was only dark in that they literally hung out in darkness most of the movie. That was visually appealing though, and apparantly all you need to do to trick people, so I guess that was a good tactic for pleasing the "make it dark like the comics" crowd. Are they aware the comics werent "dark" just because they were in b&w? Beyond the visuals, its dumb 13 monsters prophecy stone warrior immortality portal plot is as bad as anything from the OT, only worse because it takes so much away from the rest of the story. It wouldnt have been any more silly or less dark if the plot involved Krang designing a LASER WEAPON that ressurects the Shredder and turns Mikey into a gerbil.. every.. thousand.. years.
ToTheNines
08-17-2007, 07:09 PM
its dumb 13 monsters prophecy stone warrior immortality portal plot is as bad as anything from the OT
Worse than Mr. Ogg, the Pee Wee Herman rip off from the oh-so-original Dimension Z? I think not.
Kendamu
08-18-2007, 03:13 AM
I can see the Shredder being done again simply for the fact that it's been 15 or 16 years since we last saw him on the big screen. Sure, in the timeline of the movies he hasn't been dead long. But in realtime he's not been kicking ass on the big screen for a long time.
I would very much enjoy seeing him again him his personality and such were a nice throwback to the first movie.
However, I would like to point out that the Shredder is far from being required to make a good TMNT movie. For all I care, they could make a movie version of the Vol. 1 Mirage comic where the TMNT are trying to save that Chinese food place from being taken down by the big business guy and his thugs (Issue 18, yo).
Avatar Yuffie
10-13-2007, 08:27 PM
The Shredder back? I dunno. I'd like to see him but...
since he was killed in the second live action movie, beheaded in the original comics, and NT had him expelled, I don't see how it would work out, really. Karai might wear it, but it seems she's happy with her threads (if the Mirage and the CGI movie was any indication), and I personally can't see her in armor (please don't show me the NT ones, because she looks freaky in said suit and I don't like it).
xmen510
10-13-2007, 10:13 PM
We never see the Shredder die. Just a hand fall. He may have fallen unconcious and been thrown in prison or taken to a private hospital and in a coma for all we know. It may have been implied that he died, but since it wasn't specifically stated as so, you can get either situation.
as long as it's been well rendered,why it's so neccessary to exactly comform to the original comics?
Avatar Yuffie
10-14-2007, 11:07 AM
We never see the Shredder die. Just a hand fall. He may have fallen unconcious and been thrown in prison or taken to a private hospital and in a coma for all we know.
But he's a gigantic lunk (he does have the 2nd lamest death in cinema history for me)... where would they hide him all these years?
Then again this IS a story about four mutant turtle New Yorkers. Suspension of disbelief should be patiently practiced.
Spitfire
10-14-2007, 03:34 PM
I guess we all forgot about the Worms. Even if he's dead the worms are always a possible way of bringing him back.
Dragon Turtle
10-14-2007, 06:52 PM
I guess we all forgot about the Worms. Even if he's dead the worms are always a possible way of bringing him back.
Worms, myticism, cloning, there are no shortages of ways of bringing back the Shredder, it's also not a given to assume the death mentioned at the begining of TMNT is refering to the death at the end of TMNT 2: TSOTO, since TMNT is only loosely based on the live action movies.
Slash
10-15-2007, 07:02 AM
Worms, myticism, cloning, there are no shortages of ways of bringing back the Shredder, it's also not a given to assume the death mentioned at the begining of TMNT is refering to the death at the end of TMNT 2: TSOTO, since TMNT is only loosely based on the live action movies.
The way that Shredder "died" in water makes me want to see him brought back via the shark from seen in Tales of the TMNT 2. :P
odupianist
10-15-2007, 09:14 AM
My thoughts are that it wasn't our Shredder that died at the docks. We only saw a Shredder clone that had been oozed so to speak. The transformation would not have been that quick IMO if he had drank the vial of ooze. Quick little switcheroo if you will. Just a thought though.
ToTheNines
10-15-2007, 03:36 PM
That's kinda silly dude.
MoreCowbell5263
10-15-2007, 03:50 PM
I remember a like a year or two ago, and the OT DVDs started coming out, and I was happy because I hadn't seen it in God knows how long. I remember watching the cartoons when I was younger, but didn't remember too much, and I had the live action movies. The only episodes I really remembered were some that I had on Burger King VHS's but I didn't remember little details and stuff. So when I watched the OT DVDs, I was like, "hey, Raph's not angry, he's the jokemaker? Thought Mike was supposed to be the jokemaker..." I like just turned 18 and I wasn't even born when the first movie went to theaters, I loved the OT growing up, I've been buying the OT DVDs even though I don't remember the episodes much, I've tried getting into the NT a little, and I still love the live action movies. I had more exposure to the movies than the OT, so I had to get used to what was different in the OT as opposed to the live-action movies.
I remember laughing when they made Casey Jones like this Clint Eastwood-wannabe vigilante nutjob in the OT when he was a pretty calm guy in the movies. Raph I think was the biggest thing that took me a while to get used to. The whole Splinter being Hamato Yoshi was weird because I was used to him being Yoshi's pet and never being human. Yeah, that was me though, I'm younger than you all and that was my perspective on it.
Jester
10-15-2007, 04:32 PM
My thoughts are that it wasn't our Shredder that died at the docks. We only saw a Shredder clone that had been oozed so to speak. The transformation would not have been that quick IMO if he had drank the vial of ooze. Quick little switcheroo if you will. Just a thought though.That's kinda silly dude.
I dunna, I've heard people say they assume that Super Shredder was just one of Shredder's minions, even some saying that it was Freddie, the Foot Soldier who was a spy at Channel 3, that was mutated by Shredder. They say this to explain away the fact that even Shredder's armor seems to mutate.
Dragon Turtle
10-15-2007, 06:59 PM
I remember a like a year or two ago, and the OT DVDs started coming out, and I was happy because I hadn't seen it in God knows how long. I remember watching the cartoons when I was younger, but didn't remember too much, and I had the live action movies. The only episodes I really remembered were some that I had on Burger King VHS's but I didn't remember little details and stuff. So when I watched the OT DVDs, I was like, "hey, Raph's not angry, he's the jokemaker? Thought Mike was supposed to be the jokemaker..." I like just turned 18 and I wasn't even born when the first movie went to theaters, I loved the OT growing up, I've been buying the OT DVDs even though I don't remember the episodes much, I've tried getting into the NT a little, and I still love the live action movies. I had more exposure to the movies than the OT, so I had to get used to what was different in the OT as opposed to the live-action movies.
.
OT Raph always reminded me of Peter Venkman from the Ghostbusters, particularly the cartoon version.
Mr._Mutant_Man
10-15-2007, 09:53 PM
Even if they aren't aware of the comics, he still died in Part 2. So I guess they don't even realize that this is supposed to sort of follow the movies.
Also, in the second article...he loved the first movie, which was quite different from the cartoon, but then this one not so much because it's different as well? When I was five I kind of just accepted the differences without knowing about the Mirage comics. The only thing that really confused me was why they were occasionally depicted with all red masks. I occasionally saw Mirage books and the cover of the NES game and didn't get that.
Dragon Turtle
10-16-2007, 08:03 AM
Even if they aren't aware of the comics, he still died in Part 2. So I guess they don't even realize that this is supposed to sort of follow the movies.
Also, in the second article...he loved the first movie, which was quite different from the cartoon, but then this one not so much because it's different as well? When I was five I kind of just accepted the differences without knowing about the Mirage comics. The only thing that really confused me was why they were occasionally depicted with all red masks. I occasionally saw Mirage books and the cover of the NES game and didn't get that.
Kinda funny how many mainstream critics critcize TMNT for being too dark and serious compared to the live action movies, yet there are people that also critcize TMNT for being too "light-hearted" and "kiddie" when compared to the old movies.:roll:
odupianist
10-16-2007, 12:32 PM
I dunna, I've heard people say they assume that Super Shredder was just one of Shredder's minions, even some saying that it was Freddie, the Foot Soldier who was a spy at Channel 3, that was mutated by Shredder. They say this to explain away the fact that even Shredder's armor seems to mutate.
Makes sense to me. I think it would be the easy way out and a way to bring back Shredder (although I'm not 100% for bringing Shredder back just to bring him back either)
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.