PDA

View Full Version : Volume 4 News!!


Mutated Leo
09-11-2007, 03:15 PM
Thought you all might like to read this. It's from the TMNT mailing list newsletter. Could be intresting...

====
Howdy folks,

Some news regarding the TMNT Volume Four comic book series directly from Peter Laird:

Welcome back to TMNT Volume 4!

Well, not quite yet... but soon. Volume 4 is going to return this year, but in a slightly different form -- or forms, to be more precise. There will be an inexpensive -- or possibly free -- online form, as well as a more expensive limited edition collectible printed version.
There are a few reasons for this new approach, mostly related to my work habits. For quite some time, before I took most of the last year off from doing the Vol. 4 comics, I had been getting more and more frustrated by what was required of me, with every issue, to meet the requirements of Diamond Comics, the major comics distributor. This included preparing solicitation material three months in advance for the "Diamond Previews" catalog, along with ads and such. For whatever reason, preparing these materials on this schedule, along with actually getting the book ready to go to the printer by a set deadline, was just really starting to get to me. (Don't get me wrong -- Diamond's system is a fine, reasonable, businesslike approach to distributing comics, and works very well. I just can't deal with it anymore.)
I was also getting frustrated with the time lag between finishing the book and actually seeing it appear before the eyes of the fans, on comic store shelves. It would very often be up to four or five weeks from the time we sent the materials to our printer. Again, not uncommon and completely reasonable -- it takes time to print, bind, trim and ship a comic book.
So, while I was on hiatus, I started thinking about it, and came up with a new scheme. It may turn out to be harebrained, or it might be really good... or maybe just okay. We'll see.
Here's the plan:

1.) Digital Distribution: Each issue will be posted online at the ninjaturtles.com official TMNT website, within a few days (or maybe even hours) of being completed. Access to each issue will very likely be free to anyone with an internet connection and a decent browser, though I am looking into possibly charging a small fee... haven't figured that one out quite yet.
In addition, if feasible technically, I may try something new for TMNT -- a somewhat interactive online letters page. I'm not completely sure how or even if this will work, but I'm mulling it over.

2.) Limited-Edition Printed Distribution: Each issue will also be printed in a "collectible" limited edition, very likely somewhere between 1000 and 3000 copies. These will be available via mail order from Mirage, and will probably cost $10.00 each, shipping included. The first hundred books ordered per issue will have an original black and white TMNT head sketch drawn and signed by me on the inside front or back cover.
These print versions will almost certainly not appear at the same time that the online version is posted, but probably several weeks later.

I'm hoping that these changes will work, and will allow me to continue doing Volume 4 with the same sense of fun which has sustained the book from its inception in 2001 up until the beginning of my hiatus in June of 2006. I think it's worth a shot... and I hope you do too!

-- Peter Laird

turkishproverb
09-11-2007, 03:46 PM
Ten dollars an issue? (**()&.

HOpefully he'll also put them into collected editions, so I can get them for an affordable price. I'd prefer not to do the read online thing, honestly.

Mutated Leo
09-11-2007, 04:09 PM
$10 seems steep. If its a CBR File that would be cool... But any #4 news is good in my book!

CyberCubed
09-11-2007, 04:20 PM
I find reading comics online to be incredibly annoying. And like most people, I prefer owning comics in a tangible form that I can "keep" and store.

I'm not sure how I feel about this, as I hope they just release Volume 4 collected books then instead of individual issues.

OA
09-11-2007, 05:05 PM
sheesh $10 a pop is going to start hurting...but I'd rather have it like this than not at all...

I wonder how long till this actually comes to fruitition...?

Chris
09-11-2007, 05:10 PM
I'm happy at the news.

Free (or very low cost) online volume 4 is far better than no volume 4 at all.

As for $10 I think it's a fair price. The book was making a loss every issue and Peter was doing it just for the fans. With such a limited print run that $10 is probably just covering costs, and those that don't want to pay it can read the free online version.

I know it's not ideal as I (like most) would prefer to have the whole set in print (and at this time I'm planning to get them, though it will be the most expensive on-going comic I've ever bought and living in the UK I'll probably have to pay extra postage on top). But if it's this or nothing I'd say it's a very good deal, especially since he will likely make little (if any) profit from this and it is just for the fans.

junkboy
09-11-2007, 05:17 PM
Apart from returning of Vol4 being awesome... It is said that each book is $10 shipping included. I hope it is that way for Europe, too, or at least just some low shipping price.

Also it would be great if the comics were sold from PaneltoPanel, too. Getting from Mirage as someone living out of US. That's really difficult cause of their hate and grim looks upon online orders or online paying methods.

Andrew NDB
09-11-2007, 05:22 PM
It really changes nothing -- virtually no comic stores were carrying any TMNT comics toward the end of Vol. 4 anyway.

The way I see it, this is nothing but positive news for Volume 4 (though $10.00 seems a little high, but the niche market the TMNT comics seem to be catering to are probably willing to shell out a little more cash for the comics... no pun intended).

TristanHuwJones
09-11-2007, 05:49 PM
I think what Pete's proposing is interesting in that I've been hearing a lot of rumblings about comic companies looking for new means of distribution, and it looks as though Mirage may start leading the way.

Digital comics, as everyone knows, is one of those hotly debated subjects at the moment, so I think if Mirage get this to work, then it's likely to become the model for other companies to base their own online distribution on.

Rose, I noticed you made the comment about it not really doing anything to expand the general readership - I think I may have to disagree to an extent. So many more people seem to be downloading comics illegally than actually going to a store and getting them (we even had people here on the boards admit to it), and I think if Pete ends up distributing them for free online, then it's going to do huge things for the readership. If Tales continues to run the way it always has, then the downloaders will likely take more notice of Tales and hopefully go in search of it physically. Ultimately too, though the pricing on the limited prints may seem steep, it would help cover whatever costs went into the production of it and go straight to the fans. In the end, there's really very little cost going into an online comic, outside of the actual physical work that's gone into it on the artist's behalf.

I'm pretty sure that, if promoted properly, this could be a big thing.

Either way, I'm just glad to see that Volume 4 is back up and running!

Vegita-San
09-11-2007, 06:01 PM
Agreed. If properly promoted and or reasonably priced, this could only be GOOD for the comic. That, and I don't have that much time too go too my supported comic book stores these days anyway, since TMNT is now the only title I pick up...

Never heard of illegal comic downloads though...

Revan
09-11-2007, 06:01 PM
I think if Pete ends up distributing them for free online, then it's going to do huge things for the readership.
That's an excellent point. Many fans don't read the comics simply because they are hard to come by. It would be great if the following picked up due to this new availability.

junkboy
09-11-2007, 06:11 PM
This method might be easier than actually printing lots of comic books. But if the comic will be online and if there will be just a small fee, then ppl will again download it from some p2p sharing programs. Thinking that if my comic will be a digital one, why should i pay for it. At the end i will read it thru screen.
Tho ofc real tmnt fans will pay cause,, you now they will feel much better that way.
Downloading comics is another thing.. but tbh i really do not like digital comics and i can never get used to them. I would be much more happy if vol.4 was to go on the regular old school way.

As i said if PaneltoPanel sells those limited edition issues too then i will get every one of them eagerly, but if only Mirage sells as told in the interview, not very good news...

whatever...
conclusion...welcome back Vol.4... I have missed you very much

Ratchet
09-11-2007, 06:25 PM
Does this mean that we'll be getting more freelancers working on Tales? Wasn't there some sort of discussion that mentioned that because Volume 4 was indefinite, the Mirage crew would have first dibs on the Tales stories? I really want to see some of the freelancer stories tied up or continued!

Still, I'm very happy that Pete's back on things!

Roseangelo
09-11-2007, 06:26 PM
Rose, I noticed you made the comment about it not really doing anything to expand the general readership - I think I may have to disagree to an extent.

My point concerning readership is that distributing online isn't going to bring in a new reader who might otherwise not look twice at a TMNT comic book. You're only going to reach already existing fans who are looking for TMNT. This proposed method doesn't allow for browsing on a shelf of diverse titles. I'm not concerned about any of us reading this message board getting any of the comics, I'm concerned about those who are just discovering comics in general never discovering TMNT.

That said, I do think this method works fine for what Peter wants to do, as he can publish irregularly and it really won't be that big of a deal.

I think the TMNT as a whole would be better served if there was a monthly title with a continuing storyline that was on the shelf to be found by anyone.

All of which I said in my comment that you are referring to.

TristanHuwJones
09-11-2007, 06:33 PM
Sorry Rose, I realise that, but what I meant was that with a lot of comic readers being the online "pirates", I think that IF promoted properly, it will probably have a better chance of luring in new readers than actually putting it on shelves. There are already a huge number of instances where comic shops don't carry TMNT because they either don't know about it, or they don't think it sells.

All that really needs to be done is a bit of well placed word spreading, and some promo stuff over at Newsarama, CBR and the other major news feeds.

And what was mentioned about the downloading fee, I think ultimately the fee thing might not work out, as was mentioned, because someone will pay the fee, download it, then put it illegally up on a p2p network. Still, it's early days, and there's only one way you can find these things out.

Roseangelo
09-11-2007, 06:42 PM
I was trying to refrain from snide comments, but the problem with sales and lack of stores carrying the book could easily be fixed if the quality increased 10-fold. I'm going to give Peter the benefit of the doubt until I see one of these new books, but as it was that majority of TMNT fans I know stopped buying the comic long ago or were only buying it to keep their collections complete. When you've lost your already existing fans, you're not going to have a successful book. If a quality product is delivered, there's no reason a TMNT book can't be successful.

TristanHuwJones
09-11-2007, 07:01 PM
Either way, I think Tales will still be hitting the shelves like clockwork, so that will still be there, and hopefully people keep picking it up. It was cool seeing the sales figures on my own issue, so hopefully things pick up a bit more with the seemingly renewed interest in TMNT, and with the anniversary approaching.

I'm not sure the quality of the comics is that big a factor in the stores not carrying TMNT. The thing that was surprising to me most was how few BIG newsfeeds were even aware that there was a Turtles comic running! Tales or otherwise! When I was doing the solicitations and promo's just before the editorial change-over (something I've gotta get back onto now actually) it was astonishing how many of the writers at Newsarama, the EIC at CBR, Comicnewsinternation, comic-con.com, comicbookresources.com, none of them even realised! Heck, even IGN's comics section and Crave online's comic section didn't know! Most people, even in the industry, have the original toon still heavy in their memory, and when you say 'comics' a lot immediately think "Archie".

All that needs to happen is a little more aggressive PR and I genuinely think Mirage's comics would find the sales they deserve. I also think NECA's new Mirage line of figures is going to help bolster the profile of the original TMNT comics.

Raph's Girl
09-11-2007, 07:10 PM
I like this idea. There's no comic book store in my area (the closest one is like an hour away) and the only way for me to get comics is online. The only book store in town (Barnes & Noble) does carry TPB's but Mirage doesn't distribute their TPB's to B&N for some reason (thank the gods for Panel to Panel).

It almost sounds like the $10 cost is for a TPB.

Roseangelo
09-11-2007, 07:17 PM
Thing is, when Vol. 4 originally launched there WAS hype and excitement. So much so that the first two issues completely sold out and Mirage actually reprinted them. But as the book progressed, sales declined and suddenly we were reading in the letters page about how the book wasn't making any profit. That didn't happen by accident. This relaunch will no doubt drum up some hype, but long-term success isn't going to happen unless there's a quality product being delivered.

Tales is a good book, but when the creative team changes on each issue and subsequently the quality waxes and wanes (although the quality outlook is very positive ATM), it's hard for any but the largest comic shops to commit to the title. I know fans with limited budgets who find it hard to commit to the title, but they can only commit to all or none of it. They get stuck buying an issue even if it doesn't interest them at all.

I agree that Mirage needs to put more effort into publicity, but publicity can only do so much.

TristanHuwJones
09-11-2007, 07:32 PM
I still think the coolest thing I heard was something fan wrote in, telling me that their store actually started carrying TMNT because of Tales #36. That blew me away. Probably had more to do with Paul's art though :lol:

Though I still can't get over the retailer outlook on the TMNT comics :ohwell:

Roseangelo
09-11-2007, 07:48 PM
I still think the coolest thing I heard was something fan wrote in, telling me that their store actually started carrying TMNT because of Tales #36. That blew me away. Probably had more to do with Paul's art though :lol:

I think that actually proves my point about what can happen when a quality product is delivered. :)

Raph'N'Roll
09-11-2007, 08:08 PM
Yeah exactly, good quality equals good sales more often than not, that issue was fantastic, and it was both the story and art that did it.
I wouldn't mind paying $10 for an issue if it was of substantial quality, but I'm at a stage now where I'm only buying TMNT if both art and story are good.
I bought the first issue of Raphael BMR, but the story and art just don't appeal to me, it should be renamed Bad Art Rising.

I don't know if I speak for many fans, but I'm a bit tired of 1 dimensional monsters and weird creatures in TMNT stories, for example Raphael BMR, I'd love to see some more gritty tales featuring cops, gangsters and Ninja's.

Andrew NDB
09-11-2007, 08:10 PM
their store actually started carrying TMNT because of Tales #36. That blew me away. Probably had more to do with Paul's art though :lol:

You're too modest.

I'll say that this direction for Vol. 4 is probably the most equitable for all parties involved (Mirage as a publisher, Laird as an author, the niche market that has supported it, and the almost unanimous number of comic stores that had long since dropped it from their shelves). As it was, and I don't mean to be disrespectful in any way, shape or form, it was really only ever going to appeal to old school Turtle fans that were/are willing to go on whatever ride Mr. Laird decides to take us on, no matter the quality of art and how many tangling plot threads are left tangling... you won't find anyone going, "I was introduced to TMNT by Volume 4 and here I am." And this is OK, I think -- Laird has never maintained he expected Vol. 4 to set the Diamond Distribution charts on fire.

Barring a fresh start, though, "Tales of the TMNT" as it is right now should really be the introductory sort of "Gateway Drug" into the comic book world of TMNT -- for better or worse, it needs to be on comic stands each month (more or less) next to the likes of Batman, X-Men, Spider-Man, Justice League of America with consistently solid art and captivating stories if there's to be any hope of a TMNT comic ever regaining its former heights.

I guess I'm saying, if Tales follows Vol. 4 into "online only" territory and there's nothing to take its place... the towel might as well be thrown in on the whole thing. Though I could be very wrong.

Scandia
09-11-2007, 08:50 PM
On one hand, I can read them online during downtime at work.

On the other hand, comics are better to read when I'm having lunch/dinner out.

VaughnMichael
09-11-2007, 09:01 PM
Most people, even in the industry, have the original toon still heavy in their memory, and when you say 'comics' a lot immediately think "Archie".
Yeah well that should tell you something right there.
If people remember those things so much they should push them into the dark of past forgotten TMNT things like it's some unwanted child.
I know Peter hates the fact that people remember those things more so than his own work but he has to remember that these other things are what kept Mirage going and is the same things that keep the checks rolling in.
You shouldn't be ashamed of your past at all I hope at some point he will be able to get over this and realize that was it did wasn't something bad but brought him tuns of fans and new readers to his comics as they grew older they went out and searched comic shops and found the Mirage comics either by their own, an uncle or heck even the comic shop owner themselves.
I also really don't think people downloading comics online is a huge deal as you'e making it Tristian I've only ever seen it brought up twice.
And no one's downloading comic books of the turtles for free at this point it's sad to say this and I don't want to sound like an ass but it's like the bands that complained when people where downloading music for free without them making a cent and no one was even downloading those bands music.
And I really do think we need a new comic along the lines of the Archie comics but I say we already have it with the new Tales of TMNT series.
To me Tales is the book that needs the pushing and promoting because it sells out allot of the time.
Also Many people don't really think it's a factor but ART is a huge factor in comic books and I'm sorry to say but tuns of people think Jim Lawsons recent art just doesnt cut it with todays comic world.
I honestly don't care at this point I got over Lawsons art and was getting into Peters story at this point I'd just like him to finish it.

Andrew NDB
09-11-2007, 09:10 PM
Yeah well that should tell you something right there.
If people remember those things so much they should push them into the dark of past forgotten TMNT things like it's some unwanted child.
I know Peter hates the fact that people remember those things more so than his own work but he has to remember that these other things are what kept Mirage going and is the same things that keep the checks rolling in.
You shouldn't be ashamed of your past at all I hope at some point he will be able to get over this and realize that was it did wasn't something bad but brought him tuns of fans and new readers to his comics as they grew older they went out and searched comic shops and found the Mirage comics either by their own, an uncle or heck even the comic shop owner themselves.

I could see him being not too fond of the Fred Wolf cartoon and such. The whole thing was kind of a double-edged sword, wasn't it (I'd stop just short of calling it a deal with the Devil, but that's just me)? On the one hand TMNT became a super-franchise and loaded their pockets with cash, on the other... it drifted pretty effing far away from the world/vision of Eastman & Laird's comics and took the general public perception of it along for the ride. Some of the editorial-type pages of Mirage's Vol. 1 from Eastman/Laird kind of illuminated their perspective on this as the TMNT cartoon/action figures/TMNT underwear stuff began to flourish while they continued to do their thing in the B&W comics.

That in the 2000s Laird was able to make a new cartoon that is kind of an reasonable enough compromise between the jovial/light-heartedness/off-the-walledness of the original cartoon and the early Mirage comics I'm sure he's very happy about accomplishing, but I think if he had to choose, he ain't gonna do no favors to the Fred Wolf cartoon and I don't know that I blame him (creatively, that is... monetarily, there'll always be money to be made off of original cartoon cult fans, be it in T-shirts or new figures or what-have-you).

VaughnMichael
09-11-2007, 09:30 PM
I could see him being not too fond of the Fred Wolf cartoon and such. The whole thing was kind of a double-edged sword, wasn't it (I'd stop just short of calling it a deal with the Devil, but that's just me)? On the one hand TMNT became a super-franchise and loaded their pockets with cash, on the other... it drifted pretty effing far away from the world/vision of Eastman & Laird's comics and took the general public perception of it along for the ride. Some of the editorial-type pages of Mirage's Vol. 1 from Eastman/Laird kind of illuminated their perspective on this as the TMNT cartoon/action figures/TMNT underwear stuff began to flourish while they continued to do their thing in the B&W comics.

That in the 2000s Laird was able to make a new cartoon that is kind of an reasonable enough compromise between the jovial/light-heartedness/off-the-walledness of the original cartoon and the early Mirage comics I'm sure he's very happy about accomplishing, but I think if he had to choose, he ain't gonna do no favors to the Fred Wolf cartoon and I don't know that I blame him (creatively, that is... monetarily, there'll always be money to be made off of original cartoon cult fans, be it in T-shirts or new figures or what-have-you).
I know Murphy said there will be t-shirts of Krang and the gang soon....but I think theres allot more to be said about a moderized line of highly detailed figures based on the old toon I mean sure I'm excited as hell about the Mirage figures finally being made and will buy all of them but I have to say more people would buy figures of the cartoon characters if they looked exactly like they did on the show say around 1992ish.
I'm not blaming him for having issues with it I just think it's unhealthy to have such issues about your past when it brings and brought so many people joy over the years and introduced tuns of people to the turtles no matter what version they like it really doesn't matter to me the TMNT are the TMNT no matter what version shape or form they come in as long as they've got the same names and story.

TristanHuwJones
09-11-2007, 09:33 PM
Yeah well that should tell you something right there.
If people remember those things so much they should push them into the dark of past forgotten TMNT things like it's some unwanted child.
I know Peter hates the fact that people remember those things more so than his own work but he has to remember that these other things are what kept Mirage going and is the same things that keep the checks rolling in.
You shouldn't be ashamed of your past at all I hope at some point he will be able to get over this and realize that was it did wasn't something bad but brought him tuns of fans and new readers to his comics as they grew older they went out and searched comic shops and found the Mirage comics either by their own, an uncle or heck even the comic shop owner themselves.
I also really don't think people downloading comics online is a huge deal as you'e making it Tristian I've only ever seen it brought up twice.
And no one's downloading comic books of the turtles for free at this point it's sad to say this and I don't want to sound like an ass but it's like the bands that complained when people where downloading music for free without them making a cent and no one was even downloading those bands music.
And I really do think we need a new comic along the lines of the Archie comics but I say we already have it with the new Tales of TMNT series.
To me Tales is the book that needs the pushing and promoting because it sells out allot of the time.
Also Many people don't really think it's a factor but ART is a huge factor in comic books and I'm sorry to say but tuns of people think Jim Lawsons recent art just doesnt cut it with todays comic world.
I honestly don't care at this point I got over Lawsons art and was getting into Peters story at this point I'd just like him to finish it.

You'd be surprised Putre. After checking out the sales figures, and then checking out the number of completed downloads of a torrent of just tales #36, if the number of people who downloaded the issue went out and bought the issue as well (I'm not saying they all didn't), I would've had a sell out issue, which would've been awesome. And the difference between the downloading of comics illegally over music is that the comic industry as a whole has been dying slowly. Fewer and fewer people are buying comics these days, and compared to the music industry, the comic book industry is like a flea. Sure you have Marvel and DC, but when you compare sales over the years, you see the decline. Downloading comics doesn't hurt the artists so much, it hurts the industry as a whole more than anything else. I personally have no problem with online comics, personally I rather have the actual book, but if people are reading my work, who am I to complain? But when you get scanners distributing it, you get people with the mentality of "well, I've read it and it's on my computer, why spend the money on it?". I've seen it come up on other boards moreso than this one -and you're right, it's only come up here a couple of times- but it does come up. I think downloadable comics is definitely the way of the future, but there needs to be a way for it to be done that won't hurt those putting their comics out there, and I think what Pete is proposing is something of a big deal, simply because it could very well pave the path for others looking to do the same.

The main thing here is, Pete's got his comic game back on, and he's got some pretty interesting ideas about how he's going to do it. He's also taking care of his fans by releasing the limited standard format books. I think the whole thing will be very interesting to watch from an industry point of view, but as a fan of volume 4, I'm just stoked to see it return!

VaughnMichael
09-11-2007, 09:43 PM
You'd be surprised Putre. After checking out the sales figures, and then checking out the number of completed downloads of a torrent of just tales #36, if the number of people who downloaded the issue went out and bought the issue as well (I'm not saying they all didn't), I would've had a sell out issue, which would've been awesome. And the difference between the downloading of comics illegally over music is that the comic industry as a whole has been dying slowly. Fewer and fewer people are buying comics these days, and compared to the music industry, the comic book industry is like a flea. Sure you have Marvel and DC, but when you compare sales over the years, you see the decline. Downloading comics doesn't hurt the artists so much, it hurts the industry as a whole more than anything else. I personally have no problem with online comics, personally I rather have the actual book, but if people are reading my work, who am I to complain? But when you get scanners distributing it, you get people with the mentality of "well, I've read it and it's on my computer, why spend the money on it?". I've seen it come up on other boards moreso than this one -and you're right, it's only come up here a couple of times- but it does come up. I think downloadable comics is definitely the way of the future, but there needs to be a way for it to be done that won't hurt those putting their comics out there, and I think what Pete is proposing is something of a big deal, simply because it could very well pave the path for others looking to do the same.

The main thing here is, Pete's got his comic game back on, and he's got some pretty interesting ideas about how he's going to do it. He's also taking care of his fans by releasing the limited standard format books. I think the whole thing will be very interesting to watch from an industry point of view, but as a fan of volume 4, I'm just stoked to see it return!
Well I'm not a fan of the art like I said but I started to enjoy Peters story so I'm happy he will be moving forward with it.
But just like the whole Mirage old toon thing I really think this internet comic book thing is a double edged sword.
You're saying now people are downloading comics so whats stoping them if peter puts them online and one of us downloads it and then sends it to all the other turtle fans.
Also on the subject of comic stores not doing well...don't you think this isn't going to help much either if some one can just simply download something.
I mean hell I'm not going to be I'll wait till it's printed I own every other comic of the turtles in paper format even small spots they had in other comics and I'd not like to stop now so I'm happy he will be printing them.
But I have to agree $10.00 is a bit much for one issue unless they are going to be large or collected. Even Murphy thinks it's a bit much.
I've gotta agree with Rose though I don't think this is going to draw in any new fans at all.
I see tuns of stores from here in PA all the way to LA who still have copies of Vol.4 yet Tales usually more often than not sells out the day it comes in.
It should really tell you something about the standerd of comics, art and the people who read them these days.
Honeslty I know you're tooting your own horn allot about your issue but yeah I want more of that I wouldn't mind all the scifi every issue if the art and story telling was that good seriously. Tales for me is where it's at.
Oh and one last thing Tristsywisty could you please call me Cent or by the full user name I've asked everyone to please stop calling an abrivation that sounds close to a female sexual part lol k thanks.

TristanHuwJones
09-11-2007, 09:57 PM
There's nothing stopping it from happening at all. But if they're put online for free, and Pete sells the printed versions to those who are pretty much guaranteed to buy them (fans like you and me, and the other turtle fans around the world who buy the comics), then the printed versions will probably sell quite well indeed, even at that proposed price.
Mirage isn't going to lose money (or as much money) by putting it online and releasing it in quantities they're pretty sure will sell. It'd be better than releasing a set number and then having it warm shelves. At least then, if people reading it online decide they want the physical format, and the demand for product increases, they can raise the print runs and perhaps lower the price.
If the comics are available to download for free, then I'm sure you'll find that people are more likely to check them out because it's a simple matter of clicking a few buttons. The POTENTIAL readership is a hell of a lot bigger than hoping people will pick it up in a comic shop. As I've been saying, this will depend hugely on how well promoted it is. It could die in the arse and we'd essentially be no better off (outside of having volume 4 to read), but if promoted well enough, then the readership for BOTH books can only expand. I'm sure those people who dropped the book, or were planning on doing so are more likely to give it a second chance if they don't have to pay for it and can read it without even leaving work or their home.

The only reason I'm using my own comic as an example is because I have the numbers on hand, so it's an easy example for me ;) Tales of Raph would actually have done the same thing after checking that too though.

StealthNinjaScyther
09-11-2007, 10:34 PM
Well, this is certainly interesting. It very well might get more people to look at the TMNT comics. However, the physical distribution is still problematic. I don't see putting out physical copies significantly later and at 10$ a pop could possibly work out.

Now, if the online thing works out and generates new interest I think that people would definitely want to buy the real thing. But they're not going to buy it if it's a hassle to do so. Put them into collected books and get them properly distributed and they'll sell. And proper distribution would mean major bookstores as well. If they could manage to make that happen, this plan might just work.

But the major hurdle, I fear, is whether or not enough people will like volume 4 enough to buy it. I'm not sure it provides enough for those who aren't already hardcore turtles fans.

Andrew NDB
09-11-2007, 10:57 PM
Well, this is certainly interesting. It very well might get more people to look at the TMNT comics. However, the physical distribution is still problematic. I don't see putting out physical copies significantly later and at 10$ a pop could possibly work out.

Now, if the online thing works out and generates new interest I think that people would definitely want to buy the real thing. But they're not going to buy it if it's a hassle to do so. Put them into collected books and get them properly distributed and they'll sell. And proper distribution would mean major bookstores as well. If they could manage to make that happen, this plan might just work.

But the major hurdle, I fear, is whether or not enough people will like volume 4 enough to buy it. I'm not sure it provides enough for those who aren't already hardcore turtles fans.


I guess how it comes down is... regardless of whether or not Mirage stands to sell an equal or greater number of "copies" (whether virtual or the later physical "collector's" copies), Mirage stands to lose practically no money on Vol. 4 anymore.

Roseangelo
09-11-2007, 11:11 PM
I guess how it comes down is... regardless of whether or not Mirage stands to sell an equal or greater number of "copies" (whether virtual or the later physical "collector's" copies), Mirage stands to lose practically no money on Vol. 4 anymore.

Well if they're going to print 1000-3000 copies of the physical book anyways, you bet they're going to lose money. Murphy says the book was selling 3,500 copies before the hiatus (although that actual seems high... because my understanding is that you break even at 3,000 copies). If that's how many they sell at $3.25, there's no way they'll sell anything close to that at $10/each. IMO they'll be lucky to sell 500 copies of each.

Ratchet
09-12-2007, 01:20 AM
I guess that's why the download or online viewing will be beneficial. If the fans that lost faith in the book back in the day like what they see they can order it. As Tristan said, if there's a guaranteed fanbase buying it, even in small numbers from all over the world, it's not going to lose anywhere near the amount of money it may have when it was running at a set print number. And this way it will be there at Mirage and not sitting on comic shop shelves putting retailers off. I like what's happening, although I think based on the response I often see online with TMNT, it might be better going straight into Trade Paperback form and distributing it that way with colelcted versions of Vol.1, 2 and especially 4.

Andrew NDB
09-12-2007, 01:23 AM
Well if they're going to print 1000-3000 copies of the physical book anyways, you bet they're going to lose money. Murphy says the book was selling 3,500 copies before the hiatus (although that actual seems high... because my understanding is that you break even at 3,000 copies). If that's how many they sell at $3.25, there's no way they'll sell anything close to that at $10/each. IMO they'll be lucky to sell 500 copies of each.

You might be right on that estimate. But if they decide to bank on the online pay-per-views, the "collector's copies" could be printed on demand... say, a run of 250 per printing to suit demand. I actually have no idea what would be most feasible.

I'd be curious to know exactly how many copies of Vol. 4 (or Tales now, for that matter) were actually printed per issue to get a better idea/scale of the sales vs. cost associated.

But from scanning over the actual sales of the issues, I've compiled some hard numbers here (only spent about 15 minutes on this to grab these to give a rough idea) :

Tales 1 - 1600
Tales 2 - 5800
Tales 3 - 5100
Tales 4 - 4400
Tales 5 - 4200
Tales 6 - 3900
Tales 7 - 1000

Tales 13 - 3200

Tales 18 - 2900
Tales 19 - 2900

Tales 30 - 2600
Tales 31 - 2600
Tales 32 - 2553
Tales 33 - 2835
Tales 34 - 3116
Tales 35 - 3050
Tales 36 - 3,375 (Tristan kicking ass and taking names)

TMNT 14 - 5500
TMNT 15 - 5900
TMNT 16 - 5300
TMNT 25 - 3400

For anyone willing to take the time to grab the other sales figures, go here:

http://www.cbgxtra.com/Default.aspx?tabid=695

Pretty easy to navigate.

Roseangelo
09-12-2007, 01:36 AM
Putting in a new post...

Coola Yagami
09-12-2007, 01:42 AM
I still don't like this... stuff like this is what keeps the TMNT down, into obscurity. Like how would the casual turtle fan even know the comic has gone online now? Unless they treat TMNT like any other big-name comic, the turtles will always remain obscure.

Roseangelo
09-12-2007, 01:46 AM
I still don't like this... stuff like this is what keeps the TMNT down, into obscurity. Like how would the casual turtle fan even know the comic has gone online now? Unless they treat TMNT like any other big-name comic, the turtles will always remain obscure.

Exactly. This is the heart of the point I've been trying to make.

Andrew NDB
09-12-2007, 02:01 AM
I still don't like this... stuff like this is what keeps the TMNT down, into obscurity. Like how would the casual turtle fan even know the comic has gone online now? Unless they treat TMNT like any other big-name comic, the turtles will always remain obscure.

Exactly. This is the heart of the point I've been trying to make.

Pretty true, but hopefully we're just talking about Volume 4 here (which even you yourself have said, Rose, isn't going to convert any TMNT non-believers either way).

The problem is really fundamental, and only worsened by the latest movie that reinforces the idea of TMNT as toddler fare in the public eye. Joe Q comic X-Men/Civil War/Infinite Crisis/World War Hulk buyer (which by most current 2007 demographics is about 20-35) that only knows about TMNT from previews and word of mouth or even some vague remembrance of Turtle Vans and Blimps isn't very likely to pick up a copy of the current TMNT comics unless an actual Mirage TMNT fan gives them a heart-to-heart about, "Hey, it's really not like that in the comics."

Roseangelo
09-12-2007, 02:05 AM
Pretty true, but hopefully we're just talking about Volume 4 here (which even you yourself have said, Rose, isn't going to convert any TMNT non-believers either way).

This is true. Unless Peter decides to completely revamp the Vol. 4 we currently know, nothing is going to change. And there's no hope to bring in new readers when they're going to be lost and confused from the start.

The problem is really fundamental, and only worsened by the latest movie that reinforces TMNT as toddler fare in the public eye.

The problem is fundamental, but it has nothing to do with the movie and/or your personal opinion of it.

Ratchet
09-12-2007, 02:11 AM
I think Pete knows what the sales figures were like on Vol.4, which could be the reason for the print count. Even if he only prints one thou, I'm pretty sure most of them would sell upon sale. Even at the price tag estimated, there'd be a fair number of people willing to shell that out (pun not intended). I mean, in the end, we're TMNT fans. I'm a Silent Hill fan, and I was paying fairly high costs for those comics, and TMNT often went from being 30 or so pages to reach nearly sixty odd at times. And given Pete has had stories probably partially ready to go because of the previews listings, chances are that those first few stories would be fairly hefty issues. Of course, I could be wrong...

Andrew NDB
09-12-2007, 02:12 AM
The problem is fundamental, but it has nothing to do with the movie and/or your personal opinion of it.

Here's the part where we go in our corners and put on boxing gloves, as usual, with "Eye of the Tiger" playing in the background.

Roseangelo
09-12-2007, 02:14 AM
(moved this from a now older post)

Ok, looking up Vol. 4:

#09 - 7,000
#10 - 7,100
#11 - 6,800
#12 - 6,600
#13 - 5,800
#14 - 5,500
#15 - 5,900
#16 - 5,300
#17 - 4,900
#18 - 4,600
#19 - 4,500
#20 - 3,600
#21 - 4,000
#22 - 3,900
#23 - 3,700
#24 - 3,500
#25 - 3,400
#26 - 3,400
#27 - 3,300
#28 - 2,700

So am I off the mark on thinking that you break even with 3,000 copies? With the exception of #28, which slid off a bit, it looks like it had to be at least close to breaking even.

Edit: Now that I've looked up more, there's a definite pattern of a downward slope.

Edit: For comparison, Dreamwave's TMNT:

#1 - 32,300
#2 - 22,300
#3 - 21,600
#4 - 19,700

THIS is what a TMNT book is capable of!

Andrew NDB
09-12-2007, 02:20 AM
Edit: For comparison, Dreamwave's TMNT:

#1 - 32,300
#2 - 22,300
#3 - 21,600
#4 - 19,700

THIS is what a TMNT book is capable of!

Wow, that's actually fascinating. I had no idea Dreamwave's comics were turning that kind of numbers. Of course, by any comparison of other titles, losing over 10,000 readers in just 4 months is no laughing matter... more than likely what we're looking at here is stores getting behind an up and coming, somewhat proven studio... then more than likely ending up with a ton of unsold copies on their shelves (which was pretty much what led to Dreamwave's rapid implosion). Still, Dreamwave knew how to market themselves.

VaughnMichael
09-12-2007, 02:56 AM
wow that's shocking Rose and I'm sorry to say I likie vol. 4 much more than the crap that dream wave was...it was going places though but it ended before it got a chance so still ended crappy.
Those numbers are crazy though for sure!

Roseangelo
09-12-2007, 03:12 AM
Oh I pretty much agree. Dreamwave didn't last long enough for me to really form any sort of opinion on it. But it sure looked pretty.

VaughnMichael
09-12-2007, 03:14 AM
Oh I pretty much agree. Dreamwave didn't last long enough for me to really form any sort of opinion on it. But it sure looked pretty.
I don't want to say my true opinion on it I'd be called a racist.:ohwell:
I was looking forward to the turtlebot story though I think that one would have really helped the series allot.

Ratchet
09-12-2007, 03:15 AM
I think the Casey and the April issues are both really solid reads though. Kinda funny how it was Peter David that jerked Pete and Kevin around back in the day with Marvel, and here he is writing the Turtles.

discordiatookie
09-12-2007, 03:16 AM
Here's hoping that Mirage get in Paypal or something to pay for this issue online (heh and all their back issues!) because being outside the US, its pretty crap for us to be sending money orders every time we want something. That's what I dig about PaneltoPanel, everytime I want something I just drop them an email and within a day or so they've got back to me with a paypal invoice that I can pay straight away.

I know that i'll be getting the issues everytime they are printed (I hate online comics, yeesh!) Just hoping that they're not printed to irregularly and are pretty big books (hell, i'd be happy with a nice sized quarterly book!)

Roseangelo
09-12-2007, 03:19 AM
I don't want to say my true opinion on it I'd be called a racist.:ohwell:
I was looking forward to the turtlebot story though I think that one would have really helped the series allot.

Knowing what you think, I'd say it is probably on the mark.

Anywho... this reminds me that I recently found on an old computer the text for the solicitation for Dreamwave #9 (yes, #9, not #8 ). I'll see if I can find it again...

I know that i'll be getting the issues everytime they are printed (I hate online comics, yeesh!) Just hoping that they're not printed to irregularly and are pretty big books (hell, i'd be happy with a nice sized quarterly book!)

I think a $10 quarterly book would be quite reasonable.

junkboy
09-12-2007, 04:06 AM
I think the best solution in my mind is :
Free online comics + actual printed TPBs after some time as it is done for Collected Books now.

Its just my idea but i do not think that Limited Edition comic thing will work. If by each month less and less ppl start to buy those printed comics they will start to come in lesser frequency, or really in a bad reputation from the standpoint of regularity.

We hardcore fans might try to grab the actual printed ones, yeah. but most ppl will read the online one and then will pass without buying the "real" comics.. where they are meant to be.. on paper...

Raph's Girl
09-12-2007, 04:32 AM
I think the best solution in my mind is :
Free online comics + actual printed TPBs after some time as it is done for Collected Books now.

That's what NBC is doing with their Heroes comic. It's free to download (in PDF format) or view from their website (heroes.nbc.com) but DC Comics is making the TPB of the first 42 issues (each one is between 5 and 7 pages long).

Time Mistress
09-12-2007, 04:27 PM
I see this as either an example of Mirage being on the cutting edge of comics like they were in 1984, or a failed expeiment waiting to happen. I don't see much middle ground here. But then it was taking a big risk that gave us TMNT in the first place so why not go for it?

Revan
09-12-2007, 04:30 PM
That's what NBC is doing with their Heroes comic. It's free to download (in PDF format) or view from their website (heroes.nbc.com) but DC Comics is making the TPB of the first 42 issues (each one is between 5 and 7 pages long).
apples and oranges

nbc can afford it because they advertise on their site and have lots of money

CyberCubed
09-12-2007, 05:19 PM
Uh, Murphy just confirmed on his blog that neither Volume 4 nor Tales have turned a profit at all:

All good points, Summer. The thing with Mirage comics, though, is that outside of the TPBs, none of the comics have made a profit in years... and exist soley out of the good will of the non-profit motivated PL.

I guess that proves a lot of points here.

junkboy
09-12-2007, 05:36 PM
I buy a huge variety of comics. Sometimes i think that Tales should not be my number 1 comic. Aspen Comics and IDW is kicking ass. I read their titles in a drooling state. But nope... TMNT is still best. Not cause that in a way they bring me to peace, they are indeed perfect...
We have been speaking that profit thing with my vendor. We,too thought that the comic was being published just for fans and not for profit... and now this is officially confirmed. I hope an accident does not occur to come for Tales too...
Sigh. please no online comics... (tho better than none ofc)

DK2
09-12-2007, 11:24 PM
This is my 1rst post here and I have to voice my two cents. I'm happy about the return of TMNT Vol.4 series, but the future for it isn't good to me. I mean if we get the series off the TMNT site for free, then thats barely ok. Not fond of this idea though. If they charge for it, then I'm not OK. I have enough problems just trying to get paypal to work. And the price for the physical comic is very steep. I think something like this should at least be a double sized story or triple sized for this price. Laird has always stated he may publish the comic in other sizes, release shedules, or methods. I remember some odd issues of this series were extra sized with no added cost to us. I'm thinking at least the content should be more fulfilling. The price is just way too high. As far as I can tell, TMNT Vol.4 is still in limbo for me. I like someone elses thoughts on an earlier post. That they'll just wait for the Vol.4 trade books. I agree with this thought. But when they bring out those Vol. 4 books is a question? And when those collected books will catch up on the stuff we want from after TMNT V.4 #28 is another question. To me its not very optimistic about my being able to continue to get this series. Comics are expensive enough as it is. What is Laird thinking? His reasons to not go through Diamond is 1.) To give story outlines and ads 3 months ahead,
2.) The physical comic getting printed from after sent to the printer is 4-5 weeks.
These 2 things bugs him? It just seems a more lazy Peter Laird to me. How can these two things bug him that much? I think we should email them folks at Mirage with our thoughts, and perhaps if enough people voice concern, they may reconsider these ideas. I mean how can this be such a problem when they have Tales of TMNT at Diamond? This isn't causing them to change that book. Your dealing with Diamond anyway. I just don't get it. Why bother to post the comics online if your still willing to print them to some extent? I just don't get it.

TristanHuwJones
09-13-2007, 12:11 AM
The extra printed copies are for the core fanbase who want to actually have the comics there in their hands. The digital versions are a cheaper, much more immediate option, a way which allows fans to get the comic pretty much as soon as it's finished, instead of the delay between the comic being finished physically, sent to the printers, shipping and then hitting shelves for readers to see. A comic can be totally finished and ready to read well and truly before it hits the shelves.

VaughnMichael
09-13-2007, 12:31 AM
all in all it's just another brick out of the comic stores walls.:lol:

Andrew NDB
09-13-2007, 01:52 PM
The extra printed copies are for the core fanbase who want to actually have the comics there in their hands.

I don't know very many comic collectors that don't want to have a comic book in their hands.

odupianist
09-13-2007, 01:56 PM
Okay I've skimmed over this and here's my two cents for what it's not worth...

First, get this out of the way, Dreamwave could have been written better, but art wise, freaking amazing. The turtlebot idea probably would have helped because it would have taken a previous idea and expanded on it intelligently. I'm surprised to see how amazingly different the numbers are between Vol 4 and Dreamwave. Any idea how Image did or past volumes of TMNT?

Personally, I don't like the online comic idea. I think the old Volume 1 stuff online is great, but (as someone mentioned before) the site's server would have to have a complete upgrade and boost. They have crashes now with simple stuff, imagine having comics uploaded on there and all of us trying to read them? Yeah, not good technically as of right now. They would have to invest the money that they are getting off of the "small fee" just to buy a server or a couple of them. As I said, I like reading the old comics online, in my down time like Scandia said, but the new stuff, I'd prefer a solid comic in my hand.

As for finding the comics in general, I think if they are definitely doing the online thing, they need to keep Tales Vol 2 in the stores. I agree with Rose that people who want to read comics and find new ones will have an easier time finding the TMNT on the shelfs rather than online. Hell, I only found this site a few months ago by searching turtle stuff online, and I only found the main site a few years ago by doing the same. I didn't instinctively type in ninjaturtles.com and hope something worked. I'm not even a big comic person. Yeah I had the occassional Archie comic as a kid and one of the collected books of Vol 1, but I didn't get my first comic until I saw a huge collection on eBay. I have alot more fun reading the hard copy than getting online and reading it, unless I'm bored at work like now lol.

Bottom line: I don't like the idea, but it's not my comic line to deal with so I'll just figure out how I'm going to deal with it when the time comes. I hope the best for the green guys no matter what, I just hope they survive for a long while, however it is. Best of luck PL and crew.

Andrew NDB
09-13-2007, 01:59 PM
Hell, I only found this site a few months ago by searching turtle stuff online, and I only found the main site a few years ago by doing the same.

Except doesn't that kind of undermine your point against the comics going online pay-per-view?

tilallr1
09-14-2007, 01:13 PM
I am really excited to hear that Volume 4 is returning. Alot of loose ends that need a tie up. But I personally hope that for now that is the only purpose of its return. The story has to end sometime, I just don't want it left wide open. I need closure.

Might I suggest you simply post like 1/3 of each book online to generate hype to purchase the issue. At $10 + shipping your going to need it and don't want people to say, well I read it / downloaded online so don't need to purchase it.

If you do decide to post the issues online, then I think the smartest thing to do is NOT release each and every issue. Bulk them up for like 10 issues in a Trade and sell em that way through Diamond. Volume 1, 2 ,3 , 4 etc ... This way you reach everyone and you'll make alot more money doing it this way. Plus don't have to pay for shipping. Everyone is happy. You have the online individual issues for the crazed fans who can't wait. Then the TPB for everyone else who would rather read the issues on paper but don't want to pay $10 an issue.

turkishproverb
09-14-2007, 01:55 PM
Now you see, this I like

SIngles-collectors item $10 a piece

ONline distribution (which megatokyo's profitibility will tell you don't have to cost money for you to make it on the paper versions) is free and quicker

trades are for people who want physical copies at a better value.

AquaParade
09-14-2007, 07:45 PM
:ohwell: More chaos from volume 4...sorry, but like it's been said, pretty much all comic fans want the comic in their hands. If I were Peter, I would just start releasing trade paperbacks.

Andrew NDB
09-14-2007, 10:46 PM
Whatever they do, they should probably release #29 of Vol. 4 normal to stands, with a big full-page deal in the back explaining what's happening to the book from there.

jerome
09-15-2007, 12:11 AM
I want a volume 4 that i can take to class and read on my lunch break at work. I want to be able to read it when i'm on the can. I want to bag and board it and put in in the box with all my other tmnt comics and i don't want to spend 10 freaking dollars an issue to do it. :x I think if you are going to do a comic book then do a real comic BOOK. The thing that really bothers me is that i really really liked volume 4. I've defended it to my other comic nerd friends and bought every issue the wednesday it came out. Its just disappointing that peter can't quite brainstorm a way to make the book sell. Giving it away online (which is really not a great medium for reading comics) is not the answer. Peter has a pretty bad case of George Lucas Disease. Its ironic to because of the way he bashed episode III and lucas in the letters column of volume 4. Take a look in the mirror dude.

Its peter's ship. If he wants to blast holes in it and watch it sink we can't stop him.

Roseangelo
09-15-2007, 12:22 AM
Its peter's ship. If he wants to blast holes in it and watch it sink we can't stop him.

Doesn't mean we can't try. IMO the ship belongs to all of us.

VaughnMichael
09-15-2007, 01:50 AM
Peter has a pretty bad case of George Lucas Disease. Its ironic to because of the way he bashed episode III and lucas in the letters column of volume 4. Take a look in the mirror dude.

Its peter's ship. If he wants to blast holes in it and watch it sink we can't stop him.
I've been looking at him that way for some time.
And It may be his ship but his Crew can save it.

Andrew NDB
09-15-2007, 03:24 AM
Doesn't mean we can't try. IMO the ship belongs to all of us.

I'll never subscribe to that mentality, as much as I'd like to. We're just along for the ride, for better or worse.

Spitfire
09-15-2007, 03:44 AM
You can never do anything if you never try to do anything.

We have plenty of power, no matter how blind someone is if enough people speak up for anything it will change. Fans are the power.

Laird may be a boat but we're the water it sails on and without us his boat isn't going anywhere.

ZariusTwo
09-15-2007, 09:02 AM
Peter has a pretty bad case of George Lucas Disease. Its ironic to because of the way he bashed episode III and lucas in the letters column of volume 4. Take a look in the mirror dude.

Nah, Pete is Darth Vader. He chokes the s*it out of the rear admirals when they act like they know better but can't aqquire crap.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-15-2007, 09:36 AM
I just think that the whole boat metaphor is pretty funny.

Peter Laird must have a really small dingy...

johnnyblaze
09-15-2007, 11:39 AM
man am i the only one who thinks laird bashing is so damn lame and unfunny

Buslady
09-15-2007, 11:49 AM
For me, having it online gives me what I look for in the shops, and what I can't find in those stupid shops. The one by here would not carry TMNT because he said it didn't sell. Yeah I was getting them in other ways, I'll admit it, but I do have the actual books now. I'd get them online and once I find them in stores I'd grab em. It's nice to hold a book though, kick back with a soda and read and relax...it's different than reading it online. So I'm for it both ways. I would hope the $10 would be a few issues in one shot, not EACH single issue cos no way I can afford that.
I do appreciate Pete doing what he can for the fans, I like that he seems to really care of US, the big fans as well as the causal fans.

Venom
09-15-2007, 12:17 PM
While Vol. 4 was mostly out of fan serivce and Pete having a story to tell, it was also a way to get the Turtles back out into the public eye. It led to negotiations between several studios which eventually gave us 2k3, new toys followed suit, and a new movie was spawned along with finally getting collectible figures from NECA. For that I say thanks to Pete.

But I don't like this possible new format he wants to take.

Why not have a better online store, take orders and print the comics on demand. It would be a very interactive way to include fans. Have a monthly newsletter announcing when the book is ready and tell the fans however many orders for the books are needed to break even (or a 10% profit).

For example: "Hey guys, Pete here to let you all know #33 is ready to go! We need to reach 1000 orders on the books before they can be printed so head on over to our new store right away. We accept PayPal, too! [then insert filler/news here]"

Since most of us would probably get the newsletter we would possible meet the order demands the very first day along with any shops that order the books.

Mandi-chan
09-16-2007, 06:10 PM
I like the idea.

Now, I haven't read any of Volume 4 (I haven't made it past Volume 1 to be honest) because I've heard a lot of mixed comments here regarding it and I wasn't sure if I wanted to get myself invested in it and ending up disliking it...

Putting it online (even with a small fee) would give me the oppertunity to check it out.

If I end up enjoying what I read, then I could continue to read the new issues online (there's no way I'm paying $10.00 per issue, even if I end up loving it) while catching up with the back issues.

It's an interesting idea to me, and I think it's worth trying out.

Any news on when this will start happening?

CJStyles
09-16-2007, 07:59 PM
All in all it sounds good. Let's hope this works out for the company and the series

R-iZZy
09-16-2007, 11:22 PM
For $10 a pop? Eh, I'd rather wait for scans to come through than pay that much an issue.

Raph's Girl
09-17-2007, 12:04 AM
Peter Laird must have a really small dingy...

*sings* Leonardo had a rowboat....

http://www.mikeystmnt.com/media/sounds/songs/tunes/leoboat.mp3

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-17-2007, 09:05 AM
Do we have to go down with the ship?

And why can't Mirage have a mega yacht instead of a little flatbottom with no motor, just two oars?

Sigh.

And I really don't like online comics too much, but--we get Vol. 4 back! Finally!

odupianist
09-17-2007, 11:02 AM
Except doesn't that kind of undermine your point against the comics going online pay-per-view?

Not necessarily, because I was just looking for TMNT stuff in general. Not the comics. I was happy with reading the synopsi of the comics. The reason I got in to the comics is because I saved myself some time (and maybe money) buying a bulk load of comics already prebagged and ordered and most of the volumes.

peter_schaaff
09-17-2007, 04:58 PM
Since the legend was born fans made them relaunch StarTrek centuries ago them nerds think them is power ...

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

The biggest fan of TMNT is Mr. Laird himself.
All this years I asked myself why this comic series is still ongoing. Watching the art and the way of storytelling I couldn´t believe it would make reasonable sales in the USA any time compared to the Spawns, Witchblades or all the standard guys in payamas you have over there.

And I asked myself why I still ordered the comics here in germany. Longtime TMNTartist Mr. Lawson is a great dinosaurs & reptiles artist but cant manage the human form. Some stories written by Mr. Laird really made me fall asleep.

I found out I was a fan of the idea behind that TMNT thing: selfpublishing, giving young guns a chance to work on comics (remember some of the great stuff published in vol.1?), doin something you really like ...*

So must be Mr. Laird.
Since years he is burning his money with publishing TMNT comics. If he would make it for profit Mirage would have stopped manymany years ago.
He does it cause he loves it. And he does it his way. So we have to love it or leave it. Right?

Maybe some day there will be again these dark, action packed, funny, heartbreaking, black humored, undergroundy ninja tales with breathtaking artwork. Till then I take everything Mirage throws at me. It is always better than nuthin´.


* and being a fan of green teenaged mutant martial art reptiles kicking bad ass of course!

Mutated Leo
09-17-2007, 11:56 PM
Well put...

I for one am glad to get to read more of #4. Short of driving to Pete's house to ask him to finish the story, I thought it would never happen.

I still think the art while not the most polished, reminds me a bit of #1's art.

DK2
09-18-2007, 12:13 AM
Someone came up with the idea of of why not taking down an online orders type thing from the TMNT website for Vol 4 series. This gave me the idea of why not Mirage make the series subscribable through the mail? Wouldn't this entail Mirage guarantees covering back most of their or a chunk of the publishing costs instead of giving it all away through heavy discounts from Diamond? Surely this method would also give him control over the numbers he needs to make the comic. Surely this can be a feasible idea. But if they did this, it'd still have to be less then $10/issue idea of right now though. Maybe some sort of subscription thats 6 issues/year at least. Assuming Vol.4 's return is even gonna stay at a bi-monthly schedule.
I don't understand why everyone compares Dreamwaves TMNT comic to the Vol. 4 TMNT print numbers. This is an albatross to compare these two series.
Because:
1) Mirage is a dinky publisher and not every comic store orders TMNT because its a slow seller. Only the hardcore fans were reading this. The high numbers of the early issues of Vol.4 were that high because, stores thought this was the return of the TMNT comics and with one of its co-creators doing it. Then it all slowly withered away. Based on mixed results, the art is bad, and the stories are more slow paced, and serioulsy lack action. Hardly "ninja" stuff. I remember when this book started, my comic store said I with 5 others were getting this book. By the time last year, he told me I was the only one getting it now. I was pumped when Vol.4 was coming back then. Now for me I just want to see where the TMNT were going. I seriously miss the old "classic" toning look which braced the art of the first 8 issues. It really helped the art too.
2) Dreamwave had high numbers cause, it was the 2003 cartoon based version of the TMNT, around the reluanch of the TMNT licensed property, toys, etc. It had good art, Peter David was writing it. This comic died because, the first 4 or 5 issues adapted cartoon episodes and had the stipulation from Mirage that it had to have the origins and basic premise/character intros of the TMNT history to start off this book. This in the short run killed this book, which upset Peter David as he thought it restricted him from getting to really write his own TMNT, with original stories from the get go. Personally I think it was a dumb idea from Mirage. And probably Dreamwaves financial problems came into this too.

You can't compare these two book print runs at all. They were somewhat intended for a different TMNT crowd. But theres such a huge diiffeence in their situations of execution.

Everything of Vol.4 is that Peter Laird is lazy. He gets rid of the old toning cause its too time consuming. Now Vol.4 can't go through Diamond cause he's too lazy to bother with solicit summaries, and can't wait for a once completed comic to come to print. I mean geez your a comic publisher get with it already and live with it. Be a little more responsible.

Roseangelo
09-18-2007, 12:39 AM
The only reason I brought up the Dreamwave numbers was to show the kind of numbers a TMNT book can sell when you put all of the right factors together: writing and art (and being in color probably didn't hurt).

But you nailed why Vol. 4 continuously dwindled in sales (as most people in this thread have). My point was that if Vol. 4 was a quality product that could appeal to the mass market (or at least actually had the support of the majority of the fanbase), it wouldn't be losing money. So IMO, I really don't care if the book was losing money, 'cause it's only the fault of the people making it.

I think the only thing holding Mirage back from taking subscriptions is a complete lack of manpower. Otherwise it would be a very good idea, especially since we're not going to be able to subscribe to the book through our comic retailers.

I just hope the new "issues" try to fix what went so wrong with the first 28.

junkboy
09-18-2007, 05:43 AM
Just allow online orders Mirage.
that's what i wanna say aside from sale numbers, tones, coloring, etc etc...

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-18-2007, 08:08 AM
Of course Laird is the TMNT's number-one fan. But I'm number-two! :tgrin:

As long as the author is the number-one fan, the writing continues. Once the author thinks "ya know, this sucks and I'm tired of writing it", the story is over.

tilallr1
09-18-2007, 12:51 PM
Let me all ask you a question. If instead of dragging out the series in the online format he instead made a mega TPB (20 regular comic issues) concluding the series and charged a premium for it like $100 would you be upset or happy about that?

I can't see them not being able to make a large profit with this considering they could market this as the end of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. It would be HUGE.

peter_schaaff
09-18-2007, 01:57 PM
there is so many people here knowing so much about comics publishing, sales figures and how to make bestsellers etc. I am wondering why there is less and less comics to buy and fewer small press publishers every year trying to make it out there.

get real. with 3000 copies per issue sold you cant keep a kitten alive. the reason we were able to buy TMNTs the last years is Mr. Laird wanted to do a comic book about four turtles on regular schedule no matter the costs.

what I ask myself is why nobody can do a comic about something popular like the TMNT that makes a profit. permanently for years they are on tv, in the toy shops and now even on big screen. jesus, what more backup is needed? but the comic books dont sell (like Image´s or Dreamwave´s). this is a bad dream ... or the work of the Shredder. I smell the Foot. this is evil ...

turkishproverb
09-18-2007, 04:44 PM
Actually, I think the reason they don't sell is that Mirage realy has no marketing machine of its own.

Really, I didn't even know there WAS a volume 4 until I found out at a con, and I read Previews regulalry.

I think one of the big problems is the lack of press. Hence why the Dreamwave version sold so well. For all the cheating creators that Pat Lee did, he could get press.


Besides that, though, I do know how hard it is to get an indy book published, mostly from failing repeatedly.

I've gotta try to remember how much a print run of three thousand costs though. I remember a print run of like a thousand is pretty expensive though, as that's usually what I try to get the money up for. I think breaking even for me would've required selling every copy at like 3.50 or so an issue. Gotta check my numbers.

Mutated Leo
09-18-2007, 05:27 PM
Let me all ask you a question. If instead of dragging out the series in the online format he instead made a mega TPB (20 regular comic issues) concluding the series and charged a premium for it like $100 would you be upset or happy about that?

I can't see them not being able to make a large profit with this considering they could market this as the end of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. It would be HUGE.

I dunno if I want it to end. I have enjoyed reading Volume 4. Death of Superman anyone? Yeah... I would not like this Sam I am.

Sabacooza
09-19-2007, 09:41 AM
Just e-mailed Berger and he said Laird is considering print on demand but has no plans for subscriptions. Just thought I'd pass that on.

Scandia
09-19-2007, 10:48 AM
Just because the Mirage comic of TMNT would come to a conclusion, does NOT mean that it would be the "end" of the Ninja Turtles.

For example, the Sailor Moon and Rose of Versailles manga both ended years ago. But the Takarazuka of RoV and Sera Myu ran for a loooong time. And both have gotten movie and TV remakes recently.

Meaning that the 2k3 series could go on even after the Mirage comic were to conclude.

PAAATE
09-19-2007, 12:00 PM
I want the Mirage comic to have a proper conclusion sometime, but not yet.

Since the comic tries to show the "real" life of the turtles, not having a proper conclusion would suck..

And by proper conclusion I mean that I want a lot of death. Oo Kinda like City At War. But for some reason I want the Turtles to die at the end. ._.

I hope I won't get totally bashed for saying that...

Mutated Leo
09-19-2007, 03:27 PM
I want the Mirage comic to have a proper conclusion sometime, but not yet.

Since the comic tries to show the "real" life of the turtles, not having a proper conclusion would suck..

And by proper conclusion I mean that I want a lot of death. Oo Kinda like City At War. But for some reason I want the Turtles to die at the end. ._.

I hope I won't get totally bashed for saying that...

LOL! Nice... But you know it will become a media circus like Death of Supes! Variant covers and foiling galor... Oops should give them any ideas. :P

The Big Bad
09-20-2007, 06:14 AM
TMNT: The Webcomic? Excellent Idea. TMNT: Collectors Editions? Not a very good one at first glance.

Seriously, look at Girl Genius (http://www.girlgeniusonline.com) a published comic book that made the leap to webcomic (with periodically-released TPB's) about three years ago: since doing so, its readership and profitability have increased considerably, as detailed here (http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?threadid=36605).

People complain that the book is unadvertised and unfindable as obstacles in finding new readers. Going online solves both these problems by introducing word of mouth into the mix; advertising becomes an issue of simply making a link, and reading the comic becomes an issue of clicking it: no muss, no monetary cost. Say, for (a quite optimistic) example, that you post on a message board frequented by 10,000 people; you add a link to the webcomic to your signature, where every one of those 10,000 can see it. Say a fraction of that board's audience--say, 700--ever click on the link, and only 150 of those decide to stick with the comic--that's still 150 new readers at basically no cost--nothing to sneeze at, considering the numbers we're talking about here.

On another note, an online comic book means that the book can be in color without the exhorbitant costs usually associated with it. Color, you guys.

Of course, this mostly applies if the webcomic actually ends up being free. Charging any amount for it would be nothing short of a disaster--the New York Times tried it for the longest time, and it's just recently recanted.

I am considerably less enthusiastic about the idea of collectors editions--at ten bucks a pop, I just don't see how I'd be getting my money's worth by going that route, unless the books turn out to be considerably larger than the news item leads me to believe it will. Yearly TPB's sound like a much more sensible option.

Mr._Mutant_Man
09-20-2007, 11:52 AM
Hmm, I haven't been following along with volume 4, but if it were put in trade format, I'd probably consider getting a printed copy. $10 is a bit much though per issue.

There have been times where I kind of wished that another comics company would get the rights to reprint the old comics in trades. I finally caved and looked for used copies online. I got the colorized versions, which are actually pretty neat. A little bent and worn, but all things considered (the books are nearly 20 years old) in good condition.

Mutated Leo
09-20-2007, 03:00 PM
On another note, an online comic book means that the book can be in color without the exhorbitant costs usually associated with it. Color, you guys.


Thats a great idea, had not thought of it!

DrSpengler
09-20-2007, 03:28 PM
I wouldn't get my hopes up for color, guys.

Every time anyone has ever asked Laird why the book is still in black and white his typical answer is "because I said so" in so many words. Even online I doubt he'll go the extra mile and add color.

Mutated Leo
09-20-2007, 04:22 PM
I wouldn't get my hopes up for color, guys.

Every time anyone has ever asked Laird why the book is still in black and white his typical answer is "because I said so" in so many words. Even online I doubt he'll go the extra mile and add color.

True but it would be a nice... I do like the B&W, but it would be nice!

cormano
09-20-2007, 05:11 PM
Saying that TMNT being on comic book shelves will expand the audience more than having it online is ridiculous. Only fans go to comic book stores, everyone gets online. Yeah, you probably won't accidentally trip over an online Ninja Turtles comic, but you'll have a better chance of seeing it than if it was in a comic shop and you're not someone who goes into comic shops.

I know of at least two people (my niece and nephew) who will start reading this online despite not owning any printed comics (other than the few that I've given them ;) ). Reading comics online isn't great yet, but all it needs is a good UI to come around and make it a great experience. Also, a new device to read digital comics on would be a huge help, something like the iPod did for music. There are devices out there, but they're still too expensive and there is not enough content to really go mainstream yet, TMNT getting on board early can only be seen as a good thing for them.

As for the quality… :roll: it's all opinion, because as far as I'm concerned, Vol 4 is the best TMNT comic ever. There has never been a Ninja Turtles comic that has sustained an ongoing story with a consistent creative team for as long other than maybe Adventures, which isn't really my thing but I understand why some love it. The only problem with Vol 4, in my mind has been the release schedule. I really hope that this shake up helps to get it back on track and I would encourage anyone who read it issue to issue and thought it was slow to go back and read the whole series now that you have a big chunk. This is a series that I believe reads much better this way and I really hope it is collected soon. Big, fat twelve issue trades would be incredible and would be one of the few books that I would buy in collections despite owning the original issues.

Raph's Girl
09-20-2007, 07:37 PM
Looks like they're testing the waters. They've set up a pay pal account where we can buy backorders of Vol 4 (issues 1 - 28 )Each issue is $3. Only people in the U.S can use this feature ATM tho.

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/html/vol4cart.html

cormano
09-20-2007, 08:13 PM
(moved this from a now older post)

Edit: For comparison, Dreamwave's TMNT:

#1 - 32,300
#2 - 22,300
#3 - 21,600
#4 - 19,700

THIS is what a TMNT book is capable of!
Those number are extremely deceiving, though. Those are the numbers ordered by stores, not actually sold. Those high numbers are the reason that I've seen the Dreamwave TMNT comics in $.50/$1.00 bins in two different stores. They were based on the cartoon and the stores hoped to capitalize off of that by selling to kids who rarely come in so they ordered high and kept them on the shelf for a long time, but eventually if they're not gone, the price plummets.

turkishproverb
09-20-2007, 09:01 PM
Those number are extremely deceiving, though. Those are the numbers ordered by stores, not actually sold. Those high numbers are the reason that I've seen the Dreamwave TMNT comics in $.50/$1.00 bins in two different stores. They were based on the cartoon and the stores hoped to capitalize off of that by selling to kids who rarely come in so they ordered high and kept them on the shelf for a long time, but eventually if they're not gone, the price plummets.
Actually, part of the reason dreamwave comics are in bins is 'cause some people refuse to buy the Back issues on principle (weird, but true) due to the fact Pat Lee cheated some people.

DK2
09-20-2007, 11:02 PM
Honestly I've lost all hope on Vol. 4 now. They're not even gonna try a subsciption service for us readers. Honestly how many of us are gonna buy these $10 issues? Anyone?
You wish that Eastman & Laird would come back together and give one final harrah on the TMNT. I have an interview of them from a defunct comic mag from '92, talking about "City at War" at that time Vol. 1's #50 that they did. They mentioned they had a story and plans for a TMNT graphic novel that would be a future TMNT-middle aged story. Laird didn't know if they'd ever do it, Eastman said they will and that he had all the notes somewhere. Aw mann you just wish they'd come back and do this instead. Heck do it for the 25th anniversary! But who am I kidding? I think I emailed Laird a few years ago, and asked of this graphic novel. He said he has no problems with doing this he just didn't know if i'd ever happen. He sort of doubted it, I guess cause he and Kevins situations. But he also told me that he'd used some of the ideas already in Vol. 4. I'm guessing one them was Splinters death no doubt.
And you wonder what Mirages plans are for the 25th anniversary? Knowing Mirage being so small it maybe pretty much not much. Maybe we'll finally see the collected books of Vol. 1 series (unfortunately redone by Laird)?
To me what else can they do for this event? The Archie series' "Forever War" will finally will be concluded. But that to me means nothing, I wasn't into this comic. I'm an original TMNT fan of the B&W comics. What does anyone else think of this 25th anniversary?

Roseangelo
09-20-2007, 11:08 PM
What does anyone else think of this 25th anniversary?

While I am certainly excited to see The Forever War, I do remain somewhat skeptical on what else they have planned. However, I have heard from a good source that there is at least one particularly exciting thing planned, although I was given no hints as to what this might be.

cormano
09-21-2007, 06:00 AM
They need to get the rest of Vol 4 online quick if they are going to get any new fans through, though. The whole series really depends on you knowing what has happened before to fully enjoy it, so if anyone comes in on #29, they're going to be immediately turned off, if they're able to read the whole series, though I really think this can get them a lot of new (to the comic) fans.

ZariusTwo
09-24-2007, 10:17 AM
They need to get the rest of Vol 4 online quick if they are going to get any new fans through, though. The whole series really depends on you knowing what has happened before to fully enjoy it, so if anyone comes in on #29, they're going to be immediately turned off, if they're able to read the whole series, though I really think this can get them a lot of new (to the comic) fans.

There should be at best a four page recap of events in the issues before each comic begins with illustrations

GordonUniverse
09-24-2007, 03:13 PM
4 pages? before each comic? you dont need THAT much.

Personally, I'd be fine with the one page "story so far" thing that was done in the Leonardo: Blind Sight story and is now being done with Raphael.

There should definitely be SOMETHING though for the people who are just starting.

cormano
09-24-2007, 06:10 PM
They already have four page previews, I'm talking about putting the full comics online like they're going to do with new issues, though. I think this is a great opportunity to pick up new fans, but dropping them into an ongoing story 30 issues in is not gonna keep them for long.

ZariusTwo
09-24-2007, 09:36 PM
4 pages? before each comic? you dont need THAT much.

Considering the individual tales being told, I think you do...

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
09-26-2007, 09:01 AM
Posting the first 28 Vol. 4 comics online would definitely help new readers understand everything going on. Even I don't know all of the Vol. 4 stuff.

Scandia
09-27-2007, 06:07 PM
I'd like to see more of Volume 4. And for it to pick up the pace.

But most important, they need to remember the series is called

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

They are not Teenagers anymore. That's fine.

The mutants walk around like everyone else. That's fine.

WHERE is the ninjutsu? I do not see much of it in Volume 4. It was so crucial in Volume 1. But now I see so little of it. Possibly cause Splinter is gone. At least we have the Tales. But in 4 there is little of it from what I gather- other than the Battle Nexus and Leo helping the Foot and Splinter having trained Shadow.

ZariusTwo
09-28-2007, 12:28 AM
The Ninjitsu not playing a factor in the storylines has more to do with Peter's preference for fantasy and science-fiction first, and action later. Action tells the story only when it should, kind of like how a Ninja shouldnt escalate a battle unless forced to.

Roseangelo
09-28-2007, 12:39 AM
I believe it was Goongasnooch who amused me so much a few months ago when he told me how disappointed he was that Volume 4 had stopped.... because someone was almost going to fight.

Really, it still makes me laugh. :lol:

junkboy
09-28-2007, 07:54 AM
I think everybody agrees that TMNT has some magic in it , that it is suitable for every genre. Ninja, Sci Fi, goose bumps, light hearted space adventure, dystopia style , cheap horror and sometimes even pulp fantasy.
Tbh, less ninja action is .. yeah.. a bit weird for a group of ninjas. But that does not bother me so much. Cause i really like the other types, too. and they are making the TMNT universe much more funny and rich.

Raph's Girl
09-28-2007, 03:14 PM
WHERE is the ninjutsu?

The Ninjutsu? Why it's clearly there when Michelangelo was starting to train those midget Triceratons...who appearantly all worship the TMNT to the point that on the Triceraton homeworlds they have their OWN TMNT animated series... :lol:

Mutated Leo
09-28-2007, 03:32 PM
The Ninjutsu? Why it's clearly there when Michelangelo was starting to train those midget Triceratons...who appearantly all worship the TMNT to the point that on the Triceraton homeworlds they have their OWN TMNT animated series... :lol:

Good point... Dang this comic needs to contiue and soon... :D

R-iZZy
09-30-2007, 01:59 PM
To be honest, I'm not all that crazy about volume four re-launching. I always look back and see how terrible it is compared to the other volumes (I want to say excluding three, but I don't even know anymore). I mean, it's cool as far as storylines go, but it seems like we could replace the Ninja Turtles with any random four people and the storyline wouldn't even be that messed up.

I hope Laird can tweak his vision just a little bit to reflect more on the TMNT I grew to love. Now, it's all one big soap opera and mishap after another. Rarely have I seen a battle where their skills in ninjutsu was needed. It's sorta boring. But who knows, last I remembered, something was about to go down.

Andrew NDB
09-30-2007, 02:45 PM
I hope Laird can tweak his vision just a little bit to reflect more on the TMNT I grew to love.

I think it would be a pretty colossal mistake for any comic creator to alter their own vision of their creation to that of some fans.

That said, more ninja action, please. :)

ZariusTwo
09-30-2007, 11:07 PM
I think it would be a pretty colossal mistake for any comic creator to alter their own vision of their creation to that of some fans.

That said, more ninja action, please. :)

Especially since has a billion versions of the interpretation to enjoy whilst the official canon moves on

Slash
10-01-2007, 07:00 AM
I used to know Volume Four pretty well and could predict what was going on. Now I don't remember a good chunk of it. :(

NinjaFootClan75
10-19-2007, 12:58 AM
comic on-line? aw man, i want a BOOK to told and read and admire the ART! not sit at screen and scrolling down & up (do that enough already!)

i miss my Mirage TMNT and want it back... i hope this series continues.

i like Lairds writing, and i like Lawsons art, and Dooneys covers!
is Laird burned out? (i know he took a break) or is it sales? or a combo of both?

were are the fans?

hoping/waiting for the Forever War...maybe we'll get a good conclusion to the Archie series:)
yeah, i love both universes:P

dan1
10-19-2007, 08:03 AM
It will be online and in print form.

Raph's Girl
10-20-2007, 08:27 AM
comic on-line? aw man, i want a BOOK to told and read and admire the ART! not sit at screen and scrolling down & up (do that enough already!)


It'll be online yes but you also have the option to buy for around $10 (not sure if that's per issue or a TPB...better be a TPB )

As for Forever War...expect that along with some Archie series TPB's around May 2009.

tilallr1
10-22-2007, 12:07 PM
Any new updates on this?

Magneto
10-22-2007, 12:24 PM
It'll be online yes but you also have the option to buy for around $10 (not sure if that's per issue or a TPB...better be a TPB )

As for Forever War...expect that along with some Archie series TPB's around May 2009.
I'll take the option to buy.

Just never can get into online comics.

Mr._Mutant_Man
12-08-2007, 01:26 AM
I think the best way to do it would be like the Heroes graphic novels: have the comics online for free, then the people who are really enthusiastic about it can buy the comics in a TPB/hardcover later. I'm sure enough hardcore TMNT fans would end up buying the TPB later.

AquaParade
12-08-2007, 12:26 PM
I think the best way to do it would be like the Heroes graphic novels: have the comics online for free, then the people who are really enthusiastic about it can buy the comics in a TPB/hardcover later. I'm sure enough hardcore TMNT fans would end up buying the TPB later.

I know I would want to buy the tpb's...I'm still waiting on them to release all the other non-tales ones, so I can read the official tmnt story in continuity, but I think it'd be a little too risky for Peter.

Lord Nightwalker
12-08-2007, 05:38 PM
I want the Hold it in my hands, read it over and over Comic book myself.

Mr._Mutant_Man
12-08-2007, 08:24 PM
I know I would want to buy the tpb's...I'm still waiting on them to release all the other non-tales ones, so I can read the official tmnt story in continuity, but I think it'd be a little too risky for Peter.

If Mirage themselves can't do it, it would be cool if they got some other comic studio to do it for them. Back when TMNT came out it would have been cool to start releasing Vol. 1 trades as a sort of tie-in.

Roseangelo
12-08-2007, 10:23 PM
Back when TMNT came out it would have been cool to start releasing Vol. 1 trades as a sort of tie-in.

Oh, don't even get me started on that...

Mr._Mutant_Man
12-09-2007, 12:28 PM
Oh, don't even get me started on that...

Yeah I know, Laird wants to go George Lucas on it. When will artists realize that the fans loved their stuff just fine the first time around? :)

Roseangelo
12-09-2007, 12:44 PM
Yeah I know, Laird wants to go George Lucas on it. When will artists realize that the fans loved their stuff just fine the first time around? :)

And don't even get me started on that. George Lucas is a thousand times better than Laird.

Mr._Mutant_Man
12-09-2007, 12:50 PM
And don't even get me started on that. George Lucas is a thousand times better than Laird.

Just as long as Han's blaster or Michelangelo's nunchakus aren't replaced with walkie talkies, I guess I won't freak out over it.

Ninjinister
12-10-2007, 10:56 PM
Just as long as Han's blaster or Michelangelo's nunchakus aren't replaced with walkie talkies, I guess I won't freak out over it.

Why? They'd need them to phone home!

DK2
12-16-2007, 03:09 PM
Yeah the ninja aspects have been really non existant in this vol. 4 run. As someone stated it is Laird himself thats not really into this. He is more into the scifi-fantasy stuff. He even said in the letters page of the vol. 4 comics that the ninja stuff and violence and choreography of the panels was Kevin Eastman's thing. Which I think is pretty weird considering the title of the comic for one of its creators to almost ignore the ninja stuff.

Scandia
12-16-2007, 04:28 PM
Tell me about it! With Splinter gone, there goes a big chunk of the ninjitsu. And Leonardo is the most ninja of the bunch. Bring in more ninja stuff. Ninjas rule and pirates drool!

Ninjinister
12-16-2007, 05:24 PM
Tell me about it! With Splinter gone, there goes a big chunk of the ninjitsu. And Leonardo is the most ninja of the bunch. Bring in more ninja stuff. Ninjas rule and pirates drool!

(Smacks you in the back of the head) Never disrespect pirates in my presence! My lovely lady is one!

CyberCubed
12-18-2007, 01:05 PM
On the official site Dan just said Laird is putting together the next issue of Volume 4 and if you want to get into the letters section now is the time to write/e-mail a letter.

At least now we have a rough idea when to expect the next issue...online that is.

Raph's Girl
12-18-2007, 03:57 PM
On the official site Dan just said Laird is putting together the next issue of Volume 4 and if you want to get into the letters section now is the time to write/e-mail a letter.

At least now we have a rough idea when to expect the next issue...online that is.

Indeed. So the next issue probably in January...hopefully....or February....

OA
12-18-2007, 08:56 PM
Well, at least there actually is some progress...I am NOT excited about it being online (and will definately try to get the hardcopies when available), but something is better than nothing...

TristanHuwJones
12-18-2007, 09:26 PM
I know a lot of people don't like the online idea, but in all honesty I think it's the best thing for everyone. A lot of people aren't happy with the way volume 4 was going, that's been made clear enough, at least with it being online, those people can check it out (assuming it's free) without cost and if they don't like it then it's not as though they've put any money into it. If it's not free then we know it would cost less because there would be no printing costs involved.

The other good thing about this is accessibility. I remember reading threads where people said their LCS had stopped stocking Turtles because of it's selling numbers, or stores that wouldn't stock them period. Those people won't really have to worry about that with it being online. The other thing I just realised is that say Pete got an issue out sooner than expected, we wouldn't be waiting for it to get printed, it'd be up online straight away, meaning we might get stories sooner than expected.

Roseangelo
12-18-2007, 09:39 PM
Yeah, as stupid as I think the online thing is, I really don't care that they're doing it. Volume 4 in comic shops embarrasses me as a fan, so no new Volume 4 in stores = fine with me.

Fugitoid Jones
12-18-2007, 11:54 PM
Yeah, me two.

I hope it is free, cause mostly I've been buying the new series just to work on my Mirage collection. This way I won't have to spend money on something that I haven't been liking very much.

I'm actually just starting to catch up on vol. 4. What the hell was the deal with issue #22? F'n cockroaches???? "We lived as cockroaches, we even mated with some of the others". What. The. Hell. Probably the worst issue of TMNT I've EVER read. (in all fareness, I haven't read the Image series, I'm sure that would be equally as bad)

Roseangelo
12-19-2007, 12:04 AM
I'm actually just starting to catch up on vol. 4. What the hell was the deal with issue #22? F'n cockroaches???? "We lived as cockroaches, we even mated with some of the others". What. The. Hell. Probably the worst issue of TMNT I've EVER read. (in all fareness, I haven't read the Image series, I'm sure that would be equally as bad)

Nope, Image is far superior to Volume 4.

Agreed on issue #22... I have no nice words for it.

Fugitoid Jones
12-19-2007, 12:30 AM
The following might be considered spoilerish for those who haven't read this series yet, but because of my disdain for vol. 4, I don't care if I'm spoiling anything for you. Your not missing much anyway.





What the hell was Peter thinking when he decided to reveal that April was the product of that magical pencil thing? That was worse than having Mikey do the nasty with the dinosaur princess. Dare I say, even worse than having the earth being populated by aliens. What next, we learn that the turtles weren't really turtles, they were banished pixies from a pocket dimension that took the form of turtles to escape from, you guessed it, dinosaur aliens, but after being in turtle form for so long, fogot that they were pixies.(If Peter's reading this, he's going "Damn, how'd he know?")

Roseangelo
12-19-2007, 12:39 AM
What the hell was Peter thinking when he decided to reveal that April was the product of that magical pencil thing? That was worse than having Mikey do the nasty with the dinosaur princess. Dare I say, even worse than having the earth being populated by aliens. What next, we learn that the turtles weren't really turtles, they were banished pixies from a pocket dimension that took the form of turtles to escape from, you guessed it, dinosaur aliens, but after being in turtle form for so long, fogot that they were pixies.(If Peter's reading this, he's going "Damn, how'd he know?")

:tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol:

ZariusTwo
12-19-2007, 01:19 AM
Nope, Image is far superior to Volume 4.

:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

What the hell was Peter thinking when he decided to reveal that April was the product of that magical pencil thing

It made her ten times more interesting?

Even the ARCHIE April was superior to MIRAGE's version. I cant think of a single thing her bland ass really contributed to when Eastman and Laird were handling the ship together. She was lost in the shuffle. Making her an enigma rather part of the crowd elevated her importance to the story. Now she isnt just the Turtles first human freind that did JACK-SQUAT, she's part of their larger destiny.

Dont get me wrong, human characters are great, when handled properly, and such an April exists in the animated series and ARCHIE, but MIRAGE APRIL? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. Oohhh nooo, THAT is where the anti-Laird fans love to overrate.

So leave Volume Four to the real fans*, and we will continue to enjoy and appreciate it. I might be labled an "apologist", but hell, when half the detractors act like babies, you're damn right, because I'm constantly having to apologise to Laird for THEIR behaviour.


*By "real fans", I mean the ones that enjoy it, not in a "if you dont like this, you're not a real fan" way

Fugitoid Jones
12-19-2007, 02:07 AM
It made her ten times more interesting?

Even the ARCHIE April was superior to MIRAGE's version. I cant think of a single thing her bland ass really contributed to when Eastman and Laird were handling the ship together. She was lost in the shuffle. Making her an enigma rather part of the crowd elevated her importance to the story. Now she isnt just the Turtles first human freind that did JACK-SQUAT, she's part of their larger destiny.

Dont get me wrong, human characters are great, when handled properly, and such an April exists in the animated series and ARCHIE, but MIRAGE APRIL? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. Oohhh nooo, THAT is where the anti-Laird fans love to overrate.

So leave Volume Four to the real fans*, and we will continue to enjoy and appreciate it. I might be labled an "apologist", but hell, when half the detractors act like babies, you're damn right, because I'm constantly having to apologise to Laird for THEIR behaviour.


*By "real fans", I mean the ones that enjoy it, not in a "if you dont like this, you're not a real fan" way

I totally agree with you in that Mirage April was really uninteresting and unimportant. I just thought that the direction Peter went in to make her interesting was silly. I would've preferred anything else, she was adopted, her parents were Nazi spies, hell, even if she was revealed to be a clone, I wouldn't have minded so much. But the fact that she's a f'n "doodle", really just made me shake my head.
I can't wait to find out that Casey's a cyborg from the future sent to kill Sarah Conner.

The Shelf
12-19-2007, 08:40 AM
Issue #22 was very poetic, but if you don't get it now, then you never will so I won't bother trying to explain it to you. I've explained some of it before anyway. April would have been better off as a clone?! Please! Clones are so cliche in sci-fi these days. You at least have to give #22 credit for being more original than that.

Anyway, I loved it. Especially considering that it was the first issue without the turtles, I'd have to say it was a darn good issue.

But what are we talking about? This is a thread about volume 4 coming back! Why the heck are people complaining about it here? Go find your own thread or something you wicked, wicked, naysaying Shredder Jr.'s!

EDIT: You know, I recently watched Tin Man on Sci-fi, and it got me thinking... They could do a Tales story or even a non-canon story of a TMNT version of Wizard of Oz that takes place in Kirby's land. Kirby could be the wizard, the two April's could each be the wicked witch and Glinda (sp?), our April could be Dorothy, and the four turtles could be the lion, scarecrow, tin man, and Todo (not sure how they'd pull off Todo). Anyway, I thought it was funny. I'd get a real kick out of it if they told a story like that, just for fun.

Lord Nightwalker
12-19-2007, 10:21 AM
I've been waiting forever for more TMNT in comic form. Tales is good, it's been sweetening the ride, but I'm glad Volume three is back in gear. Yeah, I call vol 4 Vol three. Deal with it. It is the third series from Mirage. the Archie and Image runs where seperate individuals.Therefore, Image comics to me, are Image vol one. Nuff said on that.
I will be trying to get the actual paper in my hands version as soon as I can. The on line comics will be ok. But I can see rabid fans buying and changing them, at least coloring them, on a regular basis.
I have no major issues with any of them. They are telling stories. Let those stories continue. Could they be better? Could they do something different? Yes. But are they horribly horrible? Utterly detestible? No. Not by far. if done correctly, anything TMNT could and would be excellent to read. I will not judge this until it's finished and I can read it from book to book, begining to end and see how it flows. Or dosen't.
Let's just see how it all comes together.
I will not give up on my TMNT.
I'll be there for the ride right up until Ultima Thule.

Spitfire
12-19-2007, 04:30 PM
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:

Please do explain, I agree with Rose.

Buslady
12-19-2007, 08:17 PM
I'm not a big fan of V4 but I had been reading it and buying it when i can find it, but all I want to see is Raph be his normal self. Along with the April being a artificial person, Raph's issue is not really that great. Hasn't Raph had enough torture? Let him live in peace, have cool adventures and kick butt like he likes to.
I am dying to see if I'm right about Mikey being framed though!!!!

the whole April thing...that's just too weird. After ALL THESE YEARS????? She's suddenly a fake person!?!?!?

Having it online for me is great, I want to see what happens next...we lost the best comic shop over in Orange County, Mile High bailed...they had everything...

Ninjinister
12-19-2007, 08:30 PM
The internet is for fancomics, short panel things (like Penny Arcade, Megatokyo, et cetera), and crappy Paint-drawn monstrosities. Continuations of professional comics, even indie ones, belong in paper form and sat on bookshelves for purchase.

Rooish
12-23-2007, 04:46 PM
Not if the story/art is effing retarded. It embarassed me when I bought Volume 4 from stores ... any casual fan who picked it up would think something was terribly wrong. I much prefer the new Tales of the TMNT, which are usually better, being in the comic book stores. What's the big problem with Volume 4 being online? Won't Mirage lose less money that way?

R-iZZy
12-24-2007, 05:34 PM
:lol: @ trying to defend April's new origin. In no way, shape or form could I call that idea refreshing, impactful or interesting. It was just some random idea that had no reasoning behind it. This was Laird just doing dumb sci-fi moves without Eastman telling him how stupid of an idea it would be.

"True fans" don't have to appreciate every idea Laird puts out. "True fans" always have the time to check a TMNT issue, no matter how horrible it is, yet still maintain the dignity to keep whatever opinion they have for it. Most opinions were the "Secret Origin" idea was plain stupid and a waste of time, and just further contributed to the ridiculousness of Volume 4.

I still think this volume is a huge clusterf***, but as a TMNT fan, all I can do is hope things will get better.

Raph's Girl
12-24-2007, 09:01 PM
April's origin is lame yes but having her be a drawing come to life is really no different than Wonder Woman's origin (a statue come to life). Do people think Wonder Woman's origin is lame? Nope...well..maybe in the beginning but we're all used to it now.

Comic book logic is never logical. Neither is comic book magic. All April's origin did really was give a background for Kirby's pencil. Altho we don't know where the stone originated from (just that April's dad got it at some auction). I'd like to know the origin of the crystal! Maybe there's something neat to that that brings more things together....like it belonged to an Utrom named Krang or something.

VaughnMichael
12-24-2007, 09:14 PM
April's origin is lame yes but having her be a drawing come to life is really no different than Wonder Woman's origin (a statue come to life). Do people think Wonder Woman's origin is lame? Nope...well..maybe in the beginning but we're all used to it now.

Comic book logic is never logical. Neither is comic book magic. All April's origin did really was give a background for Kirby's pencil. Altho we don't know where the stone originated from (just that April's dad got it at some auction). I'd like to know the origin of the crystal! Maybe there's something neat to that that brings more things together....like it belonged to an Utrom named Krang or something.
haha I didn't even know that about wonder woman but hey yes now that you've told me that, yes I do that that's lame as hell.

Bircher
12-24-2007, 10:17 PM
I think it is so funny that fans always hate what is current and long for the past. In a year or so, most of the complainers will probably be longeing for the first 30 issues of TMNT v4

The cartoon series was this way, fast forward was this way (now that they are changing it again, a bunch want it to continue), I see it in other genres as well.

V4 is actually pretty good. Much better than vol 1 after Peter and Kevin left and before City at War. This volume is what I was able to hook my wife on, and she loved the stories with April being the result of a drawing (she's an artist).

I am looking forward to it being back again, and will be buying hard copies to support the work.

Raph's Girl
12-25-2007, 11:00 AM
haha I didn't even know that about wonder woman but hey yes now that you've told me that, yes I do that that's lame as hell.

Well the whole statue come to life thing is far more complicated then that. Queen Hypolita (who is kinda sorta the ORIGINAL wonder woman due to some weird time traveling) wanted a baby. Many of the Amazons who wanted kids carved them from wood and pretended they were real (which was recently revealed in the current Wonder Woman comics). Hypolita went even further. She made a clay statue of a baby and asked the gods to bring it to life. Which they did by infusing the statue with the soul of an unborn child from thousands of years ago (Hyppolyta had been a cavewoman in a past life who was killed by her husband. :lol: )

Funny thing tho is that Diana's birth wasn't revealed till like the 100th issue of the original WW book.

And reading Wikipedia I see that all the Amazons were statues braught to life by the gods (aren't reboots fun? ).... *blinks*

R-iZZy
12-26-2007, 04:58 AM
April's origin is lame yes but having her be a drawing come to life is really no different than Wonder Woman's origin (a statue come to life). Do people think Wonder Woman's origin is lame? Nope...well..maybe in the beginning but we're all used to it now.

Comic book logic is never logical. Neither is comic book magic. All April's origin did really was give a background for Kirby's pencil. Altho we don't know where the stone originated from (just that April's dad got it at some auction). I'd like to know the origin of the crystal! Maybe there's something neat to that that brings more things together....like it belonged to an Utrom named Krang or something.

Just because it's no different, doesn't make it good. I wasn't even aware of Wonder Woman's origin. But thanks to that tidbit, I'd have to say that's pretty lame too. But then again, that's just the Amazonian culture (or so it sounds like), so I can see why that would be accepted eventually. April's origin was just some random dumb arc because Laird wanted to make the franchise more sci-fi rather than what it used to be.

It's almost like Laird is saying, "Hey, let's take something my original fans loved and do something completely different with it, not taking into account of how poorly this might be received." I bought the first volume because point-blank, we got the brothers doing their thing in ninja action. That was what we loved. Now we're getting some Sci-Fi channel movie script with the Turtles being planted in.

As for the crystal ordeal, I don't think it needed that great of a role to begin with. That crystal was simply to tie in a tribute to Jack Kirby, which I thought was brilliant. It never played a major role in the TMNT universe before, so I don't see why it had to now [and especially in the way that it did].

You have to excuse me, I just have to keep venting, because my thorough disappoint for volume four still never died down. I know a few vets on this board saw exactly what I see, and they quit the series altogether. I'm still too much of a hopeful for the Turtles to quit. But perhaps even I'll reach that point and just stick to the new Tales of the TMNT series. That title is the closest thing we have to volume 1, and I think it's doing a fantastic job!

Roseangelo
12-26-2007, 10:14 AM
Building on what R-iZZy said, I see April's pencil origin as being just another kick in the face to what Eastman contributed to the series/characters. Peter has a narcissistic need to put his own personal stamp on everything and this was him doing it to April. Since the Kirby pencil was Peter's concept/idea, that's what he used.

Issue 22 isn't even written well if you aren't completely repulsed by the content. It's long-winded and is obviously trying to be deep and thought-invoking... but it just fails. I figured out where it was going within the first few pages and there was just way too much text left in the comic before it actually got to that conclusion.

I also know handfuls of HUGE TMNT fans who gave up on the comic because of Vol. 4 and especially #22. But it's painfully obvious that what the fans think doesn't matter one bit at all. Not even just as far as the comic is concerned, but with all things TMNT. TMNT would be so much more successful in general if someone were asking us what we wanted and actually listened. Then we might actually get stories about ninjas instead of all the sci-fi & dinosaur alien crap.

CyberCubed
12-26-2007, 08:26 PM
The thing is, if Pete wraps up Volume 4 and assumingly all the plotlines he's been doing...then how likely are we in getting another comic after that?

Even if a new creative team pitches a "Volume 5," Pete is still going to review and/or reject their ideas, so whatever the case the comics will still follow his guidelines.

And either way, Volume 4 is never going to be "retconned" like Image was, so aliens would still reside on the Earth even if a Volume 5 takes place afterward with a new creative team. So whether Volume 4 ends or not, everything that happened is forever going to be canon.

Andrew NDB
12-26-2007, 08:55 PM
Just speculation, but in everything talking about Laird wrapping up Volume 4 implies some kind of "ending," likely for the whole Mirage TMNT. Whether or not he'll allow things like Tales of the TMNT to continue, though, is another matter.

Andrew NDB
12-26-2007, 09:04 PM
TMNT would be so much more successful in general if someone were asking us what we wanted and actually listened.

See, this is something I'm never going to be able to agree on. Turning to the fans and basically asking them what they want to see written is just never the way to go, really in any fandom. Often times the best thing in good comic book writing is not giving the fans exactly what they want (and if you think about it, how fun would that be, really?)... but rather giving them what they didn't even know they wanted, and it working.

Of course, that's really not the case here, to be fair. The situation here is... Laird is giving fans what they didn't know they wanted... but what they didn't know they wanted is so out there and unlike what's come before that they just don't care/have little interest in it. And it's not even laid out in concise story arcs or anything... it's just one ongoing story arc of story arcs that never seem to wrap up anything satisfactorily.

But I'm not even sure I'd want Laird to look to the fans. If he grabs a handful of your average, active TMNT fans right now here on the forum, half of them would probably say, "I want you to bring in Bebop, Rocksteady, and Krang! Why can't you do that??", a quarter of them might like the sci-fi oddity stuff just fine, leaving only a quarter of so of fans that may actually be interested in what you or I would want to see in Volume 4. I bet you 99% of the fans that were very much into the Mirage Ninja Turtles gave up on the whole thing a long time ago and never looked back (or have no idea there's even still a comic going on).

It's a can of worms you just don't want to open up. Better or worse, I'd just like to see Laird wrap up TMNT the way he sees fit... and let history judge whether it sucks or has any merit. Hopefully down the line this can be learned from.

Then we might actually get stories about ninjas instead of all the sci-fi & dinosaur alien crap.

Or we might get Bebop, Rocksteady, Krang, and Pizza Monsters.

Roseangelo
12-26-2007, 09:17 PM
No, fans should not have any real control.. that's dangerous territory.

But fans gave high praise to Tristan's Tale of the TMNT and what happened? The follow-up to that got shot down with no explanation.

Look at what people have had to say about the Archie series/Forever War on Murphy's blog in the last week, yet even though TFW will be seeing print, Archie TMNT is still seen as a lower form of life in the eyes of Laird.

He approved the Overload idea, yet look at the virtually universal outcry of anger that erupted when we found out what almost became of next season.

That's what I mean when I say we deserve to be listened to, and that's not happening. But no, fans shouldn't actually be involved in the creative process.

tOkKa
12-27-2007, 12:35 AM
-->> i don't want TMNT to go away as a comic..

.. V.4 is crazy ..

but i don't want it to disappear..

.. my heart is sinking..

Mr._Mutant_Man
12-27-2007, 07:54 AM
Nope, Image is far superior to Volume 4.

Volume 4 must really suck then, because I have the Image trade and have never been able to get more than an issue and a half into it. It just completely reeks of 90's comic trends/cliches.

Seeing as it was an Image comic, I probably shouldn't have been surprised by that. It was their characters that sort of inspired the DC comic Kingdom Come.

xZAOx
01-03-2008, 03:14 PM
On the official site, Dan said that Peter was putting together the next issue of Volume 4, and is accepting letters emailed to [email protected]. So have fun :)

Lord Nightwalker
01-03-2008, 04:44 PM
I have no desire to see the TMNT comics fade away into the night, and forgoton. There's so much untapped potential, and They realy could work in any genre, It's all in how you go about it. Look at AVP, Or Star Wars, They both share warrior aspects similar to TMNT, and are incredibly different animals. Animals that have transcended Genere and done fairly decent.
I gotta have my TMNT. Gotta. Or I'll end up making my own to fill the gap. That's how my fan fic, I still haven't finished, got started.