View Full Version : alright
fastforwarddregg
09-21-2007, 04:55 PM
alright, Splinter knew there was an Utrom shredder all along, why did he asume Shredder dead those times and never tell the Turtles?
like Shredder surviving the watertower and the beheading, he never let them know!
OH when Shredder was beheaded I Suspected he might be an utrom, and when they showed the evil Utrom (nameD chrell in eXodus part 2) I had a feeling that was Shredder's true form. it was kind of obvious. But I was thrown off a little for a few minutes when the Turtles thought it was Shredder's anscestor. I mean, when it said The shredder's secret is revealed when it said next week in TUrtles in SEcret ORigins part 2, that is when I had afeeling The evil UTrom was shredder's true form. funny how he was still dangerous without the Shredder armor.
Scandia
09-21-2007, 04:57 PM
I hoonestly do not think that Splinter knew that Shredder was an Utrom any more than the Turtles did.
fastforwarddregg
09-21-2007, 05:03 PM
I hoonestly do not think that Splinter knew that Shredder was an Utrom any more than the Turtles did.
watch fathers and sons and Splinter tells The Ancient one that Yoshi was slain by the UTrom Shredder and Ancient one tells the Ninja Tribunal of it and he says the utrom bearing the Shredder name.
VaughnMichael
09-21-2007, 05:13 PM
Hence one of the many reasons I hate that disgusting episode.:dead:
You know Splinter's the true villain of the show, right? He is a rat, after all. :evilgrin:
Seriously, Splinter just did it to make you ask silly questions. (Shredder being an Utrom wasn't set in stone or even decided until Season 2, so Splinter couldn't possibly know what the writers didn't even know yet.
ToTheNines
09-21-2007, 05:29 PM
watch fathers and sons and Splinter tells The Ancient one that Yoshi was slain by the UTrom Shredder and Ancient one tells the Ninja Tribunal of it and he says the utrom bearing the Shredder name.
Yea, and in "The Ultimate Ninja" the Daimyo says his people came to Earth and tought what has become ninjitsu. Then some time in the lost season (I think it was "Legend of the 5 Dragons) the Ninja Tribunal say that they were the pioneers of ninjitsu. It's just writers not really thinking through dialouge, and since it's a cartoon you can believe what you want to believe.
Scandia
09-21-2007, 06:49 PM
I am interpreting this as:
- first, the Daimyo's people taught martial arts to people on Earth.
- then the Ninja Tribunal was taught by the masters and shaped what would become Ninjitsu.
What Splinter said in Fathers and Sons:
- why it could technically be interpreted as "the new Shredder", I think it is just a consistency error. Like the kind Mirage is full of anyway.
Mr. Stay Puft
09-21-2007, 07:55 PM
I am interpreting this as:
- first, the Daimyo's people taught martial arts to people on Earth.
- then the Ninja Tribunal was taught by the masters and shaped what would become Ninjitsu.
What Splinter said in Fathers and Sons:
- why it could technically be interpreted as "the new Shredder", I think it is just a consistency error. Like the kind Mirage is full of anyway.
Or perhaps the Daimyo's people actually taught the Ninja Tribunal.
ToTheNines
09-21-2007, 08:31 PM
Or perhaps the Daimyo's people actually taught the Ninja Tribunal.
From what I remember, nothing of the sort was implied.
Scandia
09-21-2007, 08:43 PM
It could have still happened. It's perfectly plausible and credible.
ToTheNines
09-21-2007, 08:52 PM
No it's not. I mean, I don't have a problem with you thinking that, it's just not for me. Since it's such a minor little detail in the series I'm just gonna except the fact that it's a cross-up the writers made while trying to make the lame Tribunal members seem a bit cooler.
Janus Prospero
09-21-2007, 09:20 PM
Well is it at all possible that Splinter knew him as the "Utrom Shredder" but didn't necessarily know what being an "Utrom" entailed?
Scandia
09-22-2007, 05:30 AM
That's quite possible.
Either that, or since "Fathers and Sons" is a story being told, Splinter may have inserted that in the story without remembering that he was unaware back then of this Shredder's true identity.
Janus Prospero
09-22-2007, 06:13 PM
Either that, or since "Fathers and Sons" is a story being told, Splinter may have inserted that in the story without remembering that he was unaware back then of this Shredder's true identity.
Oh that's a very cool kinda unreliable narrator (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unreliable_narrator) take on it. I like it.
alright, Splinter knew there was an Utrom shredder all along, why did he asume Shredder dead those times and never tell the Turtles?
like Shredder surviving the watertower and the beheading, he never let them know!
Because he is the teacher and this was the way he wanted his students to learn and grow.
ToTheNines
09-23-2007, 04:43 PM
Because he is the teacher and this was the way he wanted his students to learn and grow.
I honestly don't think he knew. I was under the impression that Splinter was looking to kill Shredder. So if he had known, I think he would have went back for more.
BubblyShell22
09-24-2007, 09:28 AM
Yeah, but maybe Splinter did know. After all, he knew about the Shredder and never told the Turtles, and he also knew about the Battle Nexus and never told his sons. So, I think maybe Splinter did know and didn't tell his sons because he didn't think they were ready to know about it.
Coola Yagami
09-24-2007, 11:36 AM
Well since there are now 3 Shredders running around, maybe Splinter said Utrom Shredder so they wouldn't confuse him with either Karai or the original Oroku Saki.
Or he just added that in since now he knew the Shredder they faced all that time was an Utrom. I mean, if you thought all your life that some girl you dated was named Mary, and found out years later her real name was Sue, when you start telling people about your story, you'd call her Sue from then on. It didn't mean that at the time the events happened you already knew her name was Sue.
ToTheNines
09-24-2007, 02:36 PM
Yeah, but maybe Splinter did know. After all, he knew about the Shredder and never told the Turtles, and he also knew about the Battle Nexus and never told his sons. So, I think maybe Splinter did know and didn't tell his sons because he didn't think they were ready to know about it.
I'm pretty sure Splinters face was like :o when the little utrom climbed out...
BubblyShell22
09-24-2007, 05:16 PM
Yeah, but maybe he sorta heard about Utrom Shredder but didn't want to believe it until he had proof. Hence, the surprise.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-25-2007, 08:33 AM
alright, Splinter knew there was an Utrom shredder all along, why did he asume Shredder dead those times and never tell the Turtles?
like Shredder surviving the watertower and the beheading, he never let them know!
OH when Shredder was beheaded I Suspected he might be an utrom, and when they showed the evil Utrom (nameD chrell in eXodus part 2) I had a feeling that was Shredder's true form. it was kind of obvious. But I was thrown off a little for a few minutes when the Turtles thought it was Shredder's anscestor. I mean, when it said The shredder's secret is revealed when it said next week in TUrtles in SEcret ORigins part 2, that is when I had afeeling The evil UTrom was shredder's true form. funny how he was still dangerous without the Shredder armor.
Why would an Utrom survive the watertower if it can't get out of the suit? Why behead Shredder if he knew it was a human when it's a cartoon? Yes, they kill in the new cartoon, but only when they are in danger, they don't kill just for fun.
odupianist
09-26-2007, 10:26 AM
The Damiyo's people could have easily taught ninjitsu first. Remember, the Tribunal was human before they learned more of the ways and the mystic arts (which could have been placed by the Damiyo and his people).
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.