PDA

View Full Version : TMNT Not Nominated For Golden Globe


Roseangelo
12-13-2007, 09:58 AM
I didn't expect it to be nominated, but I thought this would go best in a TMNT discussion. If someone thinks otherwise, feel free to move.


7. BEST ANIMATED FEATURE FILM

1. BEE MOVIE
DreamWorks Animation; DreamWorks Animation
2. RATATOUILLE
Pixar; Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures Distribution
3. THE SIMPSONS MOVIE
Gracie Films; Twentieth Century Fox

Splinter's Iroonna
12-13-2007, 12:01 PM
This is no surprise-- the Golden Globes are a joke. Disney/Pixar, Dreamworks, and a TV classic-- go figure.

And I say they're a joke because of the hype "Bee Movie" is still getting-- I swear, I've never seen such a pimped-out film in my life.

Yorae
12-13-2007, 12:06 PM
While I did not expect TMNT to get a nomination, I still loath the fact that BEE Movie is nominated. I have a feeling its gonna win.

Maybe they should get Jerry Seinfield to voice someone in the next TMNT movie. Imagine all the pimpin its gonna get! :lol:

AquaParade
12-13-2007, 12:08 PM
Maybe they should get Jerry Seinfield to voice someone in the next TMNT movie. Imagine all the pimpin its gonna get! :lol:

Good idea. Imagine him as the Shredder :lol:

TMNT
12-13-2007, 12:52 PM
Seinfeld as Shredder...I can see it now.

"And what's the deal with those talking turtles?"

But yeah, sucks about TMNT not getting nominated. It's really just Ratatouille against The Simpsons because no matter what Jerry Seinfeld does, even he couldn't save Bee Movie from being just another run of the mill CG animal flick. But then again, watch it win.

The category is called "Best Animated" feature film. So, if we were going to be completely literal about it, TMNT would have a great chance. Okay, so that was me making myself feel better :lol:. Ratatouille should win (putting my love for The Simpsons aside) because it was just the better animated one.

Buslady
12-13-2007, 12:53 PM
Bee Movie?? You gotta be kiddin me. It bombed.

Jo Dawn
12-13-2007, 01:00 PM
I didn't expect it to get nominated to be honest. I don't think it deserved it.

I'll have to go with Ratatouille with this one, though I don't much care either way... though I prefer no Simpsons win. But no matter what, I couldn't much care less.

Cure
12-13-2007, 02:33 PM
Ratatouille should win for sure. Simpsons movie was funny, too, but Bee movie was only OK.

Buffy
12-13-2007, 03:01 PM
I liked Ratatouille, they really tried to tell a good story. It made me all warm and fuzzy inside :) Compared with Shrek 3 (contained too many crude jokes for my taste) or the other animation fliks that came out this year) this is a good movie.
I'm a huge Simpsons fan but my vote definitely goes to Remy the rat :)

Jester
12-13-2007, 03:45 PM
I agree with the concensus that I never expected TMNT to get a nod, bvut the nod for BEE Movie is a joke. I've heard it really stinks, but you couldn't pay me to watch it due to it's star. Never have liked Seinfield. Oh and TMNT, why is what you posted the first thing I said when I read the "Imagine Jerry as Saki."?

"What's the deal with those mutant turtles. I try to kill them and they don't die...have you seen this?!"

Sewer Bull
12-13-2007, 03:58 PM
I wonder why you all hate that "Bee Movie" so much, despite the fact half of you haven't even seen it.

Jester
12-13-2007, 04:18 PM
2 words: Jerry Seinfield. Never liked him, never will.

Cure
12-13-2007, 05:00 PM
I wonder why you all hate that "Bee Movie" so much, despite the fact half of you haven't even seen it.

Same thing here, homie. I saw it, and it's OK. I woulda nominated TMNT before it, but still give the win to Ratatooey. (Phonetics rule.)

MoreCowbell5263
12-13-2007, 05:10 PM
Although I wish TMNT were nominated for more awards, I wouldn't have been surprised if it were nominated and people on other boards said things similar to what we say about Simpsons Movie being nominated, seeing is how a lot of people associate Ninja Turtles with the OT mostly.

ZariusTwo
12-13-2007, 06:31 PM
Nominating TMNT would have just been silly. It's animation really isnt anything to orgasm about, despite the story being strong and having two solid set-peices.

The Simpsons Movie shouldnt get it because it's all style, no story (and scaresely any comedy), Ratatouille is going to win hands down, and only on default it's the only overrated film nominated that delivers long-term on gags and visuals.

VaughnMichael
12-13-2007, 06:46 PM
Ratatouille for the win!:D
I really enjoyed it myself...didn't see bee movie but I'm sick of cdgi movies about bugs.

Coola Yagami
12-13-2007, 08:00 PM
Well... what did you expect..? The movie was too short... had some of the best scenes cut out of it... Don and Mike were almost nonexistant and barely had a fight scene themselves... too little Karai... and most casual fans are wondering why Shredder wasn't in it.

Splinter's Iroonna
12-13-2007, 08:31 PM
It has nothing to do with TMNT or anything else-- it's a bogus awards ceremony. The "press" are barely that; there are very FEW international members despite the hype, and they like "big stars".

Despite how everyone seems to think that Golden Globes are the precursor to the Oscars, they really do NOT influence them one way or the other (although mainly the winners of Golden Globes RARELY go on to become Oscar nominees-- a sort of reverse influence if you will).

They chose "Bee Movie" because of Seinfield/Dreamworks/Spielberg (and GAD, do I remember seeing the preview for this when we went to see "TMNT"-- even then I knew I would not go see it). "Ratatouille" is prolly the only nomination worth anything. "The Simpsons Movie" is a cultural icon-- I imagine that the bulk of the "foreign press" grew up on the series.

The ONLY good idea Golden Globes has is to separate the comedies from the dramas. If only the Oscars would take a cue...

Juniorx
12-15-2007, 02:49 AM
dont let that crap awards get to you guys.the awards are always fix.i know its a bummer our turtles didnt get nominated.just like Raphael mentions is noting but ignorance interview with barber walters whatever her name is.

Andrew NDB
12-15-2007, 06:18 PM
I don't know, it deserves at least a nomination. A win, though, no way.

Warhorse
12-15-2007, 07:31 PM
Has Imagi ever had a project nominated for a major award?

Masked Ninja
12-15-2007, 10:31 PM
Ratatouille's a lock for sure. I'm kinda scratching my head over Bee Movie... I didn't see it but some of the other animation majors did. Nobody was blown away by it. I've actually heard a lot of good things about Surf's Up, even though it was more penguins. Once I get home for Christmas I'm heading to the library to watch that one, as I constantly get it recommended to me.

TMNT... I dunno. A nom might have been in the realm of possibility, but definitely not a win. Ratatouille told its story too well for that to happen. TMNT looked great and for the most part moved well, but those monsters combined with the first 4 minutes kill me every time.

One day I hope for a TMNT movie that doesn't have parts that make me cringe. Dunno if I'll ever get it, but it doesn't hurt to hope, right? :trazz:

Dragon Turtle
12-15-2007, 11:55 PM
Ratatouille's a lock for sure. I'm kinda scratching my head over Bee Movie... I didn't see it but some of the other animation majors did. Nobody was blown away by it. I've actually heard a lot of good things about Surf's Up, even though it was more penguins. Once I get home for Christmas I'm heading to the library to watch that one, as I constantly get it recommended to me.


Nominations are sometimes dictated by how much a studio promotes their movies to voters, no doubt Dreamworks, Pixar, and Fox went the distance
in campaiging for their respective films.

But realistically, for TMNT to overcome the stigma of being TMNT, it would have had to have been a great movie, and unfortunately it's just a good movie.

Quality wise, it is as good as any other animated movie released this year, and definately better then any movie released last year, and probably other then Ratatouille, it won't be forgotten like the rest of this years mediocre crop.

Splinter's Iroonna
12-16-2007, 12:15 AM
*shouts, though no one listens*

GOLDEN GLOBES ARE A FREAKING JOKE!!!!

If you have the (a)name and (b)money you get a nomination.


*sighs in frustration*


I KNOW that it won't win any awards-- but I think the ONLY thing it should be nominated for is Best Animation-- for the OSCAR! And I know, jaded as I am, that it won't win.

The Oscars are even worse than the Golden Globes for kissing the asses of best friends/people who can influence careers/etc.

Spielberg spent a LOT of blood, sweat and tears on films that should/could have won-- but it took a film about the Holocaust for Hollywood to finally quit ignoring him.


Anyway, Golden Globes are bogus. The End.

Cure
12-16-2007, 12:45 AM
*shouts, though no one listens*

GOLDEN GLOBES ARE A FREAKING JOKE!!!!

If you have the (a)name and (b)money you get a nomination.


*sighs in frustration*


I KNOW that it won't win any awards-- but I think the ONLY thing it should be nominated for is Best Animation-- for the OSCAR! And I know, jaded as I am, that it won't win.

The Oscars are even worse than the Golden Globes for kissing the asses of best friends/people who can influence careers/etc.

Spielberg spent a LOT of blood, sweat and tears on films that should/could have won-- but it took a film about the Holocaust for Hollywood to finally quit ignoring him.


Anyway, Golden Globes are bogus. The End.

No one's listening to you cuz you're full of crap. You're just one of those people that goes "awards shows suck cuz they don't give them to the crappy sh*t I like". You can't prove that awards are rigged. Have you seen most of the movies that are nominated? Like Atonement? Or, better yet, have you seen a big marketing campaign for those movies? Probably not. So if you really want people to listen, go back to Mikey's where they MIGHT. Didn't you say one time that you regretted coming here, anyway?

Drtooth
12-16-2007, 11:04 AM
GOLDEN GLOBES ARE A FREAKING JOKE!!!!

If you have the (a)name and (b)money you get a nomination.


I hate to agree with a conspiracy, but I'm agreeing with a conspiracy. It is a popularity contest, and WB didn't care to put enough cash to get a nod.

That said, I see it as thus:

Pixar film/ Dreamworks film/ Fox Film. In fact, if the Simpsons wasn't there, it would be Pixar/ Dreamworks/Dreamworks. They're the only 2 animation studios they care about. Maybe Surf's Up would get the third spot. But Rat's goona bag the award, hands down. Unless of course, Dreamworks or Fox put up more money.

Now that aside, I loved Ratatoullie. The most clever animated film I've seen since the Incredibles. No "this celebrity is an animal" type things where they just recite lines from other films a hundred times and pretend it's an original film.

That said, I saw Bee Movie yesterday, and I enjoyed it. More than I enjoyed Madagascar. Dreawork's films are enjoyable at Best. Good maybe, but not great. Though I will say, I'm happy they nominated Bee instead of Shrek 3. I like Shrek and all, but that one seemed like it should have been the last film they should make.

Of course, for Bee Movie to work, you have to be a fan of Seinfeld's stand up routine. Not the sitcom. It's pretty much an animated form of his standup routine. And the jokes are Very Jewish. So if you don't like jokes about nagging parents, then you may want to skip it. Though, Ray liotta's cameo was hillarious.

But other than that, I'm surprised that Beowulf wasn't nominated, since it seems like the most overhyped film of the year.

Masked Ninja
12-16-2007, 09:43 PM
It could be because it's motion capture... if there are any animation people in charge of the nominations, it's not as likely to get a nod. Motion capture =/= animation, especially the way Beowulf did it.

And yeah, it is a popularity contest... but I think the quality of the film does play at least a tiny little part. :P Lots of promoting and plugging and advertising going into it, but there's gotta be at least a little something to stand on.

Though I heard such bad things about Shrek 3, I'd take Bee Movie over it in spite of seeing neither. The sad thing is they have them planned all the way through Shrek 5. *facepalm*

Fledermaus
12-17-2007, 12:18 AM
Though I heard such bad things about Shrek 3, I'd take Bee Movie over it in spite of seeing neither. The sad thing is they have them planned all the way through Shrek 5. *facepalm*

Inconceivable. Now, where did you find this most deplorable news? :( :dead:

Jester
12-17-2007, 12:31 AM
By Shrek 5 will we have 3 teen ogres...:roll:

Masked Ninja
12-17-2007, 12:32 AM
Well, Shrek 4 is a definite (Shrek Goes Fourth), but I can't find anything definite on 5. It's a rumor at the very least*, mentioned on an animation discussion site I frequent, and I wouldn't be surprised. Puss in Boots is getting his own DTV too... and at this point I think I'd rather see a movie solely about him than another Shrek. :dead:

Katzenberg claims the story was "planned" this way for forever, but I highly doubt it.

*EDIT: Found something of a reference. Try this (http://uk.rottentomatoes.com/news/1648682/)...

Drtooth
12-17-2007, 03:12 PM
There is not too much you can do with the stroy line. When I walked out fo Shrek 3, I thought to myself, tyou know what would make a good movie? The Three Ogre babies are all grown up and on their own. Shrek and/or Fiona passed away. Having a very sheltered life, they know nothing about anti-ogre sentiment. And they all have to cope in a world that hates them. one would be furious at everything, and become a conspiracy theorist, one would be cautiously optimistic, and one would be completley oblivious to everything. And their friends are all off spring of various characters, like the Dronkeys.

But I think it'll be the same thing. Poor me Shrek acts like a jerk because he's secretly depressed about something, and then the others just play off of him until he gets annoyed with them. He then realises he's been a jerk, and everything works out in the end with a random pop tune. They even did that on the X-mas special. Now, I enjoy Shrek, but 3 films is enough. I want to see Puss get his own film, yes. But other than that, I could care less now.

Warhorse
12-17-2007, 04:08 PM
There has to be a conspiracy of some sorts going on. I raised my eyebrow when I learned that Sweeney Tod is being nominated for best picture of the year, and this movie is not being theatrically released till next week. And it's a Dreamworks production. So I am beginning to think it's who's in the know, and who's hand is in what pocket book.

Roseangelo
12-17-2007, 06:25 PM
There has to be a conspiracy of some sorts going on. I raised my eyebrow when I learned that Sweeney Tod is being nominated for best picture of the year, and this movie is not being theatrically released till next week. And it's a Dreamworks production. So I am beginning to think it's who's in the know, and who's hand is in what pocket book.

The people who do the nominating get screener copies of the movies; they're not nominating them sight unseen. It's nothing new - rather, it's quite usual - for movies released at the end of the year to get nominations.

Fugitoid Jones
12-17-2007, 09:24 PM
It's pretty sad when only one animated film is truly worthy of being nominated for an award for best animated feature (Ratatouille). I enjoyed the Simpsons movie, but I don't think it's "best animated feature" worthy (although, compared to the competition, maybe). And the previews for Bee Movie and other CG films from this year like Shrek 3 and Surf's Up really looked uninteresting. Remember when heart and soul were put into animated features? Yeah, dem were da days.

I only wish that TMNT would get recognized, if nothing else, then for the stellar CG animation that it had. Oh well. Such is the life of a TMNT fan.

ZariusTwo
12-18-2007, 01:41 PM
The animation wasnt steller.

Sewer Bull
12-18-2007, 01:52 PM
True to that. Just look at its human design.

The Shelf
12-18-2007, 02:15 PM
I don't think the designs have anything to do with how good the animation is. Things to watch out for in CGI films especially are lighting, shadows, and reflections along with the typical things one would look for in 2d animated films. But the title "Best animated film" leads me to believe that they won't be judging the movies based on quality of animation, but rather how good the animated movie was. I don't pay attention to awards shows much, so I don't really know what they're going to judge the movies on.

Has Imagi ever had a project nominated for a major award?
Wasn't TMNT Imagi's first project? I was under the impression they were a brand new company. I dunno, though.

ZariusTwo
12-18-2007, 03:59 PM
I don't think the designs have anything to do with how good the animation is. Things to watch out for in CGI films especially are lighting, shadows, and reflections along with the typical things one would look for in 2d animated films. But the title "Best animated film" leads me to believe that they won't be judging the movies based on quality of animation, but rather how good the animated movie was.

...You think an "best animated feature" award is given to the film because of the script? How dopey is that? You might as well get rid of the catergory right now.

Spitfire
12-18-2007, 04:01 PM
The movie isn't good so I'm not surprised. As a kids movie it might as well commit suicide cause it has even less of a chance winning any kid related awards.

Dragon Turtle
12-18-2007, 04:04 PM
I don't think the designs have anything to do with how good the animation is. Things to watch out for in CGI films especially are lighting, shadows, and reflections along with the typical things one would look for in 2d animated films. But the title "Best animated film" leads me to believe that they won't be judging the movies based on quality of animation, but rather how good the animated movie was. I don't pay attention to awards shows much, so I don't really know what they're going to judge the movies on.



Under the circumstances, the visuals for TMNT were pretty good (much better then I thought they would be), and the best animated picture doesn't always go to the film that features the best animation.



Wasn't TMNT Imagi's first project? I was under the impression they were a brand new company. I dunno, though.

TMNT was Imagi's first theatrical release, prior to that they did a few cgi tv shows, one of which (Zentrix) did win some type of award.

ZariusTwo
12-18-2007, 07:05 PM
Under the circumstances, the visuals for TMNT were pretty good (much better then I thought they would be), and the best animated picture doesn't always go to the film that features the best animation.

That makes no sense. Just because a MINORITY dont like the animation in the film that wins doesnt mean it's accomplished something to warrant the decision on ALL levels. Gross, story, animation.

Guess which didnt have gross, or animation?

Dragon Turtle
12-18-2007, 08:24 PM
That makes no sense. Just because a MINORITY dont like the animation in the film that wins doesnt mean it's accomplished something to warrant the decision on ALL levels. Gross, story, animation.


I'm not sure I follow, the judging for best animated movie isn't based on which movie is technically superior, it can be taken into account, but ultimately the overall movie needs to be the best all around, that includes story. They would not hand out the the Best Picture Award to a movie that simply had the best art direction or costume design.



Guess which didnt have gross, or animation?

huh?:-?

Masked Ninja
12-19-2007, 12:04 AM
I'd like to echo that yes, design =/= animation. TMNT had OK design, but not stellar. The human design in particular was pretty bad; they were so skinny that the animation was distracting as they bent in weird ways due to their skinny wrists/knees/waists/etc. (I thought Linguini's wrists sorta suffered this way in Ratatouille, as they're so thin that it's hard to make them look like they're bending naturally.)

Most of the kinetic animation (aka, running, jumping, fighting) was pretty good in TMNT. The lipsync got distracting in places because their mouths are so huge, and their acting animation definitely wasn't up to Pixar standard to begin with, though they do have their moments.

As for the technical stuff (lighting, textures, rigging, camera work) TMNT did do a really good job. Especially the texture work... wow.

And then there's the story, which was only good when it was focusing on the Turtles (unfortunately only half of the movie).

Thing is, the Best Animated Feature category is there so that animated films can get recognized, as American culture especially tends to push them aside as somehow being "less" than regular films. On one hand this is bad because it pigeonholes them into that category and makes it less likely for one to get a full-on Best Picture nomination if it deserves it. But at least they will show up every year at the Oscars, and exposure is always good.

Also the Best Animated Feature category is for overall goodness, story and look included... not just about animation, and if you take a peek in the Best Animated Shorts category it's definitely true there. The one that won last year was all story and not very impressive as far as animation was concerned (it looked like one of those wiggly old Sesame Street type shorts). The problem for TMNT is it isn't really consistent in either story or animation... some parts are really good, while others aren't impressive at all. Other films did those better and consistently this year, and a couple of 'em got a deserved nomination. Seems pretty simple to me.

Coola Yagami
12-19-2007, 09:40 PM
It's too late for the TMNT to break the kiddy-cartoon mold. If there was a movie about the TMNT hacking the Foot left and right and Leo decapitating Shredder, as well as Casey and Raph drinkin a beer or two, or even the slightest hint that Casey and April are sleeping together, everybody would throw a hissy fit about their beloved kiddy-cartoon heroes being ruind by being turned too dark and whatnot.

Hell, the first TMNT movie already had complaints for the violence and Raph saying 'Damn' more than once, and everybody sure made a big issue about Casey and April living together even if they're not married in this movie.

ZariusTwo
12-19-2007, 09:58 PM
Scadia is the only one here that made a habit out of that particular subject.

syd
12-20-2007, 08:42 AM
i will tell you why TMNT didn't win,coz it's not perfect.as long as there's still one part of the movie that is not perfect,it's not gonna win.surely you will say,there can not be zero bug in a movie,even if,let's face it,it's a pixar anime.but only if it got all the key points perfect,the entire is gonna shinning.and the keiest key point in a movie is the subject.it's the thing you want to tell your audiences that matters the most.that's what for a movie art,any art.

Drtooth
12-21-2007, 10:03 AM
But seriously. Considering the fact that 90% of everyone dimissed this film as a franchise cash grab, is anyone surprised?

That's probably why Bee got the nod, and Shrek 3 didn't.

Sewer Bull
12-23-2007, 05:59 AM
Hell, the first TMNT movie already had complaints for the violence and Raph saying 'Damn' more than once, and everybody sure made a big issue about Casey and April living together even if they're not married in this movie.

In the second movie, she lived together with four mutated turtles and one mutated rat - IN ONE FLAT!

Gross!