View Full Version : Pros and Cons of the new and old models
Slap-Happy
12-22-2007, 11:20 AM
pros and cons of the models they used in the movie. Pros and cons of the models we saw in the teaser poster
The Shelf
12-22-2007, 11:47 AM
I see, excellent point. Wait, what?
AquaParade
12-23-2007, 09:03 PM
I love how the design's look in The Shelf's avi...probably some of my favorite tmnt designs ever right there.
Donatello
01-27-2008, 02:33 PM
pros and cons of the models they used in the movie. Pros and cons of the models we saw in the teaser poster
can u link a pic to the earlier designs?
I thought they were the same
Revan
01-27-2008, 06:04 PM
I think he means this poster. This was the first one I saw and really I don't know many pros about it besides the fact that I was glad to see a new turtle movie in the works. Leo's head looked smashed and too wide.
http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/leo2.jpg
Then later, this poster was released. The animation was a bit better. Smoother skin and muscle tone. It looks almost as if the head sculpts had not be completed yet though because they didn't show Leo's face.
http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/leo3.jpg
And when I finally saw the movie the designs were great. The animation looked amazing and the final designs blew the first "teaser" poster out of the water.
http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/turtles.jpg
Donatello
01-27-2008, 07:26 PM
thanks Neutrino.
I think you can see the gradual evolution of the artwork. to call a change in design is probably wrong, you can see how it logically got better.
As for the TMNT designs. I loved em. i don't think the Heroes in a Halfshell have ever looked better. it took inspiration for Eastman and Laird's original design, stylized it a bit more, and came out with a beautiful set of character designs.
I also loved that each turtle was unique, i always wanted that from every version of the turtles, but never really got it.
Raphael was bigger, and buffer, like he lifted alot
Leo was just cut, with a very sharp design, clearly showing that he trains hard, but differently than raphael, more about balance than power.
Mike looked a little smaller, shorter, a bit cuter, giving him that likability.
And Don was a bit slimmer, less muscle mass (which would be accurate for my favorite turtle) and was a bit rounder, showing that he's a bit softer in some ways.
Splinter was great, it was a cool, unique design.
The only downside (design wise) of the film was the humans, they were a bit too stylized for my taste.
Herr_Shredder
01-28-2008, 04:55 PM
thanks Neutrino.
I think you can see the gradual evolution of the artwork. to call a change in design is probably wrong, you can see how it logically got better.
As for the TMNT designs. I loved em. i don't think the Heroes in a Halfshell have ever looked better. it took inspiration for Eastman and Laird's original design, stylized it a bit more, and came out with a beautiful set of character designs.
I also loved that each turtle was unique, i always wanted that from every version of the turtles, but never really got it.
Raphael was bigger, and buffer, like he lifted alot
Leo was just cut, with a very sharp design, clearly showing that he trains hard, but differently than raphael, more about balance than power.
Mike looked a little smaller, shorter, a bit cuter, giving him that likability.
And Don was a bit slimmer, less muscle mass (which would be accurate for my favorite turtle) and was a bit rounder, showing that he's a bit softer in some ways.
Splinter was great, it was a cool, unique design.
The only downside (design wise) of the film was the humans, they were a bit too stylized for my taste.
yup and April seemed unhealthyly skinny to me.... and everyone kinda looked like they've been in The incredibles
thebrownranger
01-28-2008, 09:42 PM
If you haven't noticed, but the first poster w/ Leo, Raph and Don is the scene from the teaser trailer where Mikey falls into the garbage dump.
Donatello
01-30-2008, 10:09 AM
yup and April seemed unhealthyly skinny to me.... and everyone kinda looked like they've been in The incredibles
yeah. except i liked the stylization of The Incredibles. I think it's just that it didn't fir with the TMNT. I think because the Turtles seemed to have a closer to human form than the humans did.
JusticeForce
01-30-2008, 10:40 AM
Do you think that making the humans look a lot more cartoon-y/stylized was perhaps a deliberate move by the production company to make the Turtles look more realistic?
Don't get me wrong, I LOVE the final character designs of the Turtles, but if we'd had a movie with live action actors interacting with the same CGI Turtles, we'd probably all be complaining about how the Turtles didn't seem real enough. However, putting the same Turtles next to cartoon-y humans really keeps the focus on the Turtles as the main characters of the movie because they seemed the most detailed.
Make any sense?
Drtooth
01-30-2008, 11:56 AM
Don't get me wrong, I LOVE the final character designs of the Turtles, but if we'd had a movie with live action actors interacting with the same CGI Turtles, we'd probably all be complaining about how the Turtles didn't seem real enough. However, putting the same Turtles next to cartoon-y humans really keeps the focus on the Turtles as the main characters of the movie because they seemed the most detailed.
I seriously would have hated to see that. They would probably seem more pasted in than intergrated into the action, like even some of the better CGI/live film hybrids out there. I'm really glad they went all CGI. And I admit, I like how the characters were stylized (especially Karai). I cannot stand how more accurate humans look in CGI, even in the Shrek films.
And I really was on the fence about how the characters looked when we first saw them. Looks like we got a nice blend of lizard looking characters and more stylized interpretations. While a bit angular, I still really like the finished looks of the characters. And I also like how they didn't feel obligated to make CGI versions of the Creature shop costumes from the first 2 films.
Dragon Turtle
01-30-2008, 03:23 PM
Do you think that making the humans look a lot more cartoon-y/stylized was perhaps a deliberate move by the production company to make the Turtles look more realistic?
In one interview Monroe does say that realistic humans would have been too distracting, when compared to the turtles.
In the past Monroe has expressed a dislike for ultra-realistic human designs, usually because they appear to be too stiff and lifeless. Like many animators, he believes that animated characters should have a bit of caricature in their designs.
I believe using Jeff Matsuda as the lead character designer was more out of convenience then out of personal choice, in a few interviews even the directors weren't overly happy with the human designs.
Monroe and Tanaka sound more enthusiastic about Gatchamans human characters though:
"Tanaka added that they are going for something more realistic this time around than the Turtles’ human characters were.
Munroe says, “I try to describe it to people, it’s not cartoon-ey and it’s not photo-real. It’s really pushing the western style of animation, something very cool and different.”
However, putting the same Turtles next to cartoon-y humans really keeps the focus on the Turtles as the main characters of the movie because they seemed the most detailed.
Make any sense?
It make sense, but the humans were too cartoony, the human designs actually had the opposite effect on me. I found the humans, Casey and April in particular, to be distracting whenever they were on screen with the turtles. Karai fares a bit better, perhaps because she was designed by someone other than Matsuda.
Masked Ninja
01-30-2008, 09:10 PM
OK, first: design =/= animation. Animation describes the way something moves. Design describes the way something looks.
The very first version (both of those teaser posters are the same model I think, it's just the foreshortening that makes it so you can't see the muscle tone on the arms very well). I thought it was fine except for the heads were too flat and the eyes too far apart. This was significantly improved on the final designs, though I still think the eyes could have been pushed a little closer together - Mike's eyes were big and round enough for it to look OK, Raph was all right, but Don and Leo's eyes look especially far apart. If they choose to do a sequel, I hope this is altered a little bit.
Other than my issues with the head designs, I love the 2007 Turtles. I like that they're more slender and fast-looking, instead of being built like wrestlers or boxers. They're acrobats and should look like they're able to move like ninjas. I also like their thick ankles and wrists and the big feet and hands to match. It helps underscore that they're not green humans with weird heads and shells - they're mutants.
The humans being skinny kinda works because the Turtles are, but then again it kinda makes their slender builds a moot point because they still look like musclebound beasts compared to everyone else. The facial designs for the people were kinda predictable, too... what made the Incredibles people work is the bold caricatures and strong use of shapes. The TMNT people were kinda generic. The one human design I really liked was actually one of the random thugs Nightwatcher beats up - the big burly black guy. I like his face for some reason. :)
Mr._Mutant_Man
03-02-2008, 12:05 PM
I think I actually like the older design a bit more. In comparison the final design almost looks like the skin is too smooth.
I think my only problem with the designs is April. She was just too darn skinny, almost distractingly skinny at times. In the new movie April's design made it seem like the turtles should be trying to fatten her up with their pizza.
Raph The Angry
03-04-2008, 07:28 PM
I was pleasantly surprised with the animation for the movie, it looked great and a lot better than the 1st poster revealed. My only gripe was with the grayer color of their skin instead of a green or brown tone we were used to, which I think is more "turtlesque".
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.