View Full Version : Dream TMNT movie
Slap-Happy
12-23-2007, 12:14 AM
The Second Of My Dream TMNT Series
What would be Your Dream TMNT Movie?
Mine would be based on Vol. 1 #1 Almost ecxactly but with more personality added to the turtles and splinter. Target rating PG-13. Aimed more at adults than kids. NECA would handle the toyline. In the parts of the orgin story that is set in Japan would be japanese with english subtitles. Tons of character development. The turtles and splinter would be motion capture. and everybody else would be real actors. And the turtles would be waaay more agile. Tell your ideas, You're all welcome!
Buslady
12-23-2007, 12:22 AM
im gonna sound like a broken record but an all raph solo story. :P
Slap-Happy
12-23-2007, 12:23 AM
im gonna sound like a broken record but an all raph solo story. :P
OMG I'm SO SURPRISED!!!!
NightwatchersOnlygirl
12-23-2007, 02:50 AM
An all solo Nightwatcher story
PAAATE
12-23-2007, 03:09 AM
Well, I think they should try to look like the movie V For Vendetta. Love everything about that movie, and I think the tone of it should fit TMNT. Not the story or anything (obviously).. Just.. Y'know.. The look of it..
Mr._Mutant_Man
12-23-2007, 07:57 PM
As someone who grew up on the cartoon, I kinda want to see something involving Krang and Bebop and Rocksteady.
But as someone now reading the comics, I'd kind of like to see something with Triceratrons and utroms.
Wildcat
12-23-2007, 09:51 PM
The original 80's cartoon is what got me into TMNT...so this would be my "Dream TMNT Movie"
A storyline in the style of the 2K3 series...ya know kinda dark and serious.
Krang,Bebop,Rocksteady,Fly Baxterstockman,April in a yellow news outfit(not 80's style of course :P )Purple colored Footclan with the Foot print on thier heads,Mousers,The Technodrome,the original turtle van,the turtle blimp,the letter of each Turtles name on thier belt...ect..ect...
Live Action...everything LIVE ACTION...the turtles could be the super realistic CGI used for Transformers so they dont come off as too clunky and can preform big ninja attacks not possible in those old costumes.
Lets see am I missing anything?......nope guess not...thats it for now,I'll post more if I remember something.
Ramboraph4life aka Matt
12-23-2007, 11:32 PM
For me, a Raph solo story too, with good back-up from Mikey.
Splinter's death would start the story, and I would have it be that Raphael was with him when he died. (Maybe have it be that Raph went up top to cool down, and Splinter went up to talk to him. There are Foot members, a fight breaks out, and Raph does his hothead thing. He breaks away to fight other members, leaving Splinter behind since Raph believes that he can handle himself. He comes back to find Splinter stabbed by someone...who we'll find out later who it was.)
Raph blames himself, so he spends countless nights patrolling, suicidal thoughts, looking for the Foot, etc. Leo maybe/kinda blames him but not really, Donny keeps to himself, and Mikey tries to help him each step of the way.
I'd want the evil turtle plot device introduced, but done in a non-cheesy way. I'd like Slash, but a more evil and sadistic/good humored character. We find out he was the one who killed Splinter, plays head games with Raphael (maybe he wants a brother, so the whole 'turn to the dark side' type of arc), and ultimately captures him (maybe with Raph saving Mikey in someway but getting caught in the process).
Raph is tortured, pieces of shell (or maybe the whole shell) carved up until Raph escapes. Broken and bruised, his family finds him and takes him back to the farmhouse. Brothers talk, bonds are renunited, but at this point I'd like Mikey to REALLY come into play. Fighting with leo and donny with their "ignoring Raph" behavior, and taking control in helping Raph (both physically and mentally).
Raph gets stronger with the help of Mikey, and ultimately with the whole family. He decides to go back to finish it with Slash once and for all, but Mikey finds him before he leaves. He says "I'm coming or I'm telling" or something like that...knowing Raph's reason at this point of the story is not 100% revenge, but because he doesn't want the others hurt.
Throughout the movie I'd like to see a subtle change for Raphael, from angst-ridden, to being able to trust. And subtle for Mikey as well, for wanting someone to trust him as an adult, that "I can handle myself".
I'd have moments going back to childhood throughout the film, like Raph being small and calling Splinter "Say-say"....and that would be one of the last lines of the movie "I love you....say-say". As well as Mikey and Raph being buddies as kids....and have the relationship between the two play out like a lot of buddy-cop movies. But more low-key, to still have jokes between each other and to know that love each other very much as well.
The end would be Raph and Mikey taking the compound. Slash would have an arc too...climbing up the Foot clan 'chain of command' type of thing. So Raph and Mikey take them on, and of course somehow/someway there'd be a fire and the walls/ceilings are in flames. Raph vs. Slash. Raph wins, Mikey helps Raph out of the fire/building, and they both go home. The last image/scene would be Mikey talking to Leo and Donny (camera is far away, no sound, instead it's on Raph as he looks down at Splinter's grave near the farmhouse). Mikey comes out to say they're 'for lack of a better word pissed...but they'll get over it." Mikey puts a hand on Raph's shoulder and asks if he's okay, and Raph goes "yeah....I am". Mikey walks a couple steps away and then stops, waiting for Raph. That's when Raph whispers " I love you, Say-say" and then walks side by side with Mikey into the farmhouse. Camera pans back to show the 4 turtles in the house (through the windows) and we see Splinter's grave in view with the turtles. Fade to black.
So yeah....that's how my dream flick would be lol.
Buslady
12-24-2007, 01:07 AM
OMG I'm SO SURPRISED!!!!
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:
well hey, at least i can make fun of myself and say I'm a broken record :D:D:D:D
CJStyles
12-24-2007, 11:56 AM
a more darker and sinister plot. Shredder's dead. A brand new villain. Karai is given a proper introduction to the TMNT movie series. Just something really dark and it's given a pg 13 feel.
Buslady
12-25-2007, 12:46 AM
but no further than PG13. I dont want a R rated TMNT...I dont mind them using mild words like 'damn' or 'hell'...nothing like $#!+ or the f-word. a little red on leo's blades and correct usage of their weapons as we saw in 2K7.
Andrew NDB
12-25-2007, 12:56 AM
The Second Of My Dream TMNT Series
What would be Your Dream TMNT Movie?
Mine would be based on Vol. 1 #1 Almost ecxactly but with more personality added to the turtles and splinter. Target rating PG-13. Aimed more at adults than kids. NECA would handle the toyline. In the parts of the orgin story that is set in Japan would be japanese with english subtitles. Tons of character development. The turtles and splinter would be motion capture. and everybody else would be real actors. And the turtles would be waaay more agile.
I could live with that. But even if they adapted TMNT Vol. 1 #1 completely faithfully, you'd only end up with about a 30-40 minute movie. They'd need to fluff it up a bit.
Maybe spend the first half of the movie showing us further the Turtles' journey to finally assassinate Shredder... more of their training, maybe some earlier adventures while Splinter waits for the right time to finally give the order while intercutting with Saki growing up also and raising his New York Foot Clan, creating a sort of dichotomy with both the Turtles' and Saki's rise to power, their destinies intertwined until they finally meet in that fateful rooftop duel.
but no further than PG13. I dont want a R rated TMNT...I dont mind them using mild words like 'damn' or 'hell'...nothing like $#!+
Sh*t? But they've said that in the comics before. And you can say sh*t as many times as you like in a PG-13 movie.
But yeah, hard R is going to a place even the original comics never went, except for in a few places.
Buslady
12-25-2007, 09:44 AM
Sh*t? But they've said that in the comics before. And you can say sh*t as many times as you like in a PG-13 movie.
But yeah, hard R is going to a place even the original comics never went, except for in a few places.
I'm well aware of it being used in the comics, but like it or not, kids will want to see a PG13 TMNT but parents wont wanna hear the S word out of the turtle's mouths. I'd probably laugh if I heard Raph bellow out SHhhhh****TTTTT!!! If they did use the word, not excessively or just keep it in the comics. But the F word NO WAY.
Sage Ninja
12-25-2007, 09:36 PM
did the turtles ever use the F word in the comics?
Andrew NDB
12-26-2007, 01:33 AM
did the turtles ever use the F word in the comics?
Never that. But there is certainly a moderate amount of R-rated content to be found in Volume 1... though I could see them getting away satisfactorily with things just fine in a PG-13 film.
Mr._Mutant_Man
12-26-2007, 05:47 PM
I'd like to see the turtles both in far out situations involving robots and magic powers, and at the same time dealing with real life problems, like the type we face everyday.
Andrew NDB
12-26-2007, 08:01 PM
Urban, gritty material are really what interest me most with the Turtles; the dichotomy of them living in a world that will never truly embrace them, yet getting drawn into its affairs nonetheless (but not as crimefighters or vigilantes... the idea of them protecting mankind/fighting crime for humans is silly and bizarre). I like to see them pitted against other ninja or warriors of equal standing, and the action to be exactly what you'd expect to see if real ninja were involved in such combat (not Turtles jumping into each others arms, screaming with their eyes bugging out as they fight boogeymen like something out of Looney Tunes).
Which isn't to say Turtles can't work against the "odder" backdrops like outer space adventures or running into other mutants -- they have and they can... I just prefer those stories to more interspersed throughout the above, and not the other way around.
Slap-Happy
12-27-2007, 01:10 AM
Urban, gritty material are really what interest me most with the Turtles; the dichotomy of them living in a world that will never truly embrace them, yet getting drawn into its affairs nonetheless (but not as crimefighters or vigilantes... the idea of them protecting mankind/fighting crime for humans is silly and bizarre). I like to see them pitted against other ninja or warriors of equal standing, and the action to be exactly what you'd expect to see if real ninja were involved in such combat (not Turtles jumping into each others arms, screaming with their eyes bugging out as they fight boogeymen like something out of Looney Tunes).
Which isn't to say Turtles can't work against the "odder" backdrops like outer space adventures or running into other mutants -- they have and they can... I just prefer those stories to more interspersed throughout the above, and not the other way around.
Maybe a trilogy by peter jackson
1: The turtles face one of the mobs of New York in a drug smuggling case that the police don't have enough evidence to back up.
2: The turtles are framed for the murder of a cop and must clear their name.
3: The turtles meet the cult of assasins wearing the ancient japanese symbol of the foot.
And maybe to be even more gritty, it would be set in Harlem. And by cult I mean small group restricted to about 200 members led by Karai instead instead of a human can opener. The turtles will have to clear their name through mail and recorded messages rather than meeting the PoPo in person.
I'd love to see a film based around the "City at War" story arc.
Splinter's Iroonna
12-27-2007, 06:24 PM
im gonna sound like a broken record but an all raph solo story. :P
Nope-- he has to have Splinter around to be his "control" or whatever.... Raph as Night Watcher, while Splinter runs the computer stuff from home, offering wisdom via the comlink while Raph is kickin' butt...
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:
Buslady
12-27-2007, 07:12 PM
Nope-- he has to have Splinter around to be his "control" or whatever.... Raph as Night Watcher, while Splinter runs the computer stuff from home, offering wisdom via the comlink while Raph is kickin' butt...
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol:
*High Five..errr Three!!!!!!!!!!!*
Spitfire
12-27-2007, 07:55 PM
One that is made by a real director who has experience. One that Laird is not allowed to touch. Needs to be a totally new story not some watered down piece of crap comic adaptation like the 2K3 series is full of. If it's PG it needs to stick with being PG. I'm tired of turtles trying to be a rated R kids movie. Either use a dark tone and make it for older people or use a light tone and keep it for kids.
I can handle CGI so they can stick with that cause I'd hate to see CGI turtles with live action characters. I'd prefer a re-vamp on their look though.
Andrew NDB
12-27-2007, 08:06 PM
One that is made by a real director who has experience. One that Laird is not allowed to touch. Needs to be a totally new story not some watered down piece of crap comic adaptation like the 2K3 series is full of. If it's PG it needs to stick with being PG. I'm tired of turtles trying to be a rated R kids movie. Either use a dark tone and make it for older people or use a light tone and keep it for kids.
I'm not sure what you mean here. Are you saying it needs to be either PG or R?
And you're tired of Turtles trying to be an R-rated kids movie? What does that even mean, and what TMNT films attempted to do this? If what you're trying to say is, "If you're going to make a proper TMNT movie with the same type of adult material found in the Mirage comics, you need to go all the way or don't even bother," then I'm in agreement with you. Unless they're willing to make a proper comic book adaption of the source material -- and so far, the only film that's bothered to try to any noticeable extent is the original movie -- they might as well just make "TMNT (the 4Kids series): The Movie" or "TMNT (the original cartoon): The Movie" and just continue those universes on the big screen. Not that I'd be overly enthused about seeing either.
Spitfire
12-27-2007, 08:14 PM
That's what I'm trying to say yes. Do one or the other. This mix isn't working, the first film was the closest because it was made before PG-13 had settled in so you could get away with more in a PG movie.
Dragon Turtle
12-28-2007, 01:13 AM
One that is made by a real director who has experience.
Someone like Uwe Boll perhaps?
If it's PG it needs to stick with being PG. I'm tired of turtles trying to be a rated R kids movie. Either use a dark tone and make it for older people or use a light tone and keep it for kids.
Rated R kids movie, I'm assuming you're refering to TMNT(2007). So why can't a PG rated movie possess a dark tone, must all entertainment aimed at kids be brightly colored, slap-schtick laden, fart-filled, wacky squirrel infested, jaunts of merriment?
A PG-13 rating is great, but lets not assume a PG-13 rating is an automatic ticket too more "adult" or "mature" storytelling.
Spitfire
12-28-2007, 02:14 AM
Someone like Uwe Boll perhaps?
I know your being a smart ass but seriously here. Kevin directed one video game before this movie. Seriously now.
Rated R kids movie, I'm assuming you're refering to TMNT(2007). So why can't a PG rated movie possess a dark tone, must all entertainment aimed at kids be brightly colored, slap-schtick laden, fart-filled, wacky squirrel infested, jaunts of merriment?
It must if it wants to be successful, or not frowned upon. A movie with kids humor and dark adult tones doesn't work. A movie with adult humor and a bright kids tone could work but turtles doesn't work in a bright kids tone. Turtles 2 was perfect in my opinion, it had a kids tone, light humor, stayed goofy like the old toon. It worked. The first movie was dark, had some kids humor but it wasn't as predominate as the other films. This is why most fans like it the best but it still had a road block. It just needed to have bigger wings and allowed to fly a little more. Perfection was close.
TMNT had dark tones and way to light kiddy humor, also tons of other issues but we won't get into those.
A PG-13 rating is great, but lets not assume a PG-13 rating is an automatic ticket too more "adult" or "mature" storytelling.
No it isn't turtles could work as a PG movie too but letting it be a little more violent would help to. Also it needs better writers.
Hm, a dream movie? I'm not that fussy about staff. As long as the director has a clear and unique image to follow, I'm happy.
For the story...I agree with Spitfire. Instead of recycling old ideas and adapting comics to the movies...why not try something new? No utroms, no dinosaurs from outer space, no regrouping of the clan like the last film, but something for the movie to call it's own. I wouldn't mind a "City at War" type of plot, as would most of you, but let's face it...it's not original. It's taking the comic version and putting it on screen. Having something new would be nice for the fans to talk about, me thinks. Splinter's death...could happen. As long as it fits and ties in with the next movie. If he dies, I would probably have it at the end of the movie, as an aftermath kind of a thing. Leo leaning over his tomb or something and having a brief discussion with Mike or Don would be a nice touch... "looking towards a brighter future" and such if it's PG. Personally, I would like it M (Australian standard speaking), since I think you can get away with a bit of blood and swearing then, but that's just me.
As for the overall look/feel of the movie...I don't know. take a bit of the "City at War" story, throw in a dash of "Doctor Who"-ish technobabble for scientific explanation for anything outlandish, and I guess put in some of that feeling you got when you saw "Spiderman 2" or the first "Pirates of the Caribbean"...the kind that makes your heart warm and soar with delight. Add in some gritty "Batman" looks, and the original heart of the Ninja Turtles (family and fighting, my friends), and mix it all up with a nice budget, live action with a bit of CGI to help things along, and our original idea for the movie. Let everything go into post-production for a few months and vola! we have ourselves what would more than likely be my dream TMNT movie.
...great, I'm babbling again...
NightwatchersOnlygirl
12-28-2007, 04:59 AM
Oh Baby Nightwatcher that will make me very happy
Oh Nightwatcher
Dragon Turtle
12-28-2007, 08:49 PM
I know your being a smart ass but seriously here. Kevin directed one video game before this movie. Seriously now.
The Uwe Boll reference is to illustrate the point that just because you can get a director with "experience", doesn't mean you're going get a better movie, is this director someone experienced with animation, with action, is this director used to Imagi's drive-thru animation philosophy, is this director used to handling intellectual properties where everyone has a say in the production, and does this director care about the property itself? How many big movies did Steve Barron direct before he directed the first live-action TMNT movie? I will take Kevin Monroe's directing on TMNT over the more experienced directing of Micheal Bay on Transformers anyday.
It must if it wants to be successful, or not frowned upon. A movie with kids humor and dark adult tones doesn't work.
It worked for the first live-action movie.
A movie with adult humor and a bright kids tone could work but turtles doesn't work in a bright kids tone. Turtles 2 was perfect in my opinion, it had a kids tone, light humor, stayed goofy like the old toon. It worked. The first movie was dark, had some kids humor but it wasn't as predominate as the other films. This is why most fans like it the best but it still had a road block. It just needed to have bigger wings and allowed to fly a little more. Perfection was close.
The sillier moments in the first live-action movie are as silly(if not more silly) then the silly moments from TMNT, while conversly the darker moments from TMNT '90 are much darker (since much of the story is taken from the Mirage comics) then similar moments from TMNT '07.
The first movie went to extremes with its tone, while the current movie was more consistent with its tone, it was neither as goofy nor as dark as the first movie, a reason why you get so many varying opinions as to whether TMNT '07 is either too dark or lacks the goofy charm of the first movie.
Spitfire
12-29-2007, 03:17 PM
The Uwe Boll reference is to illustrate the point that just because you can get a director with "experience", doesn't mean you're going get a better movie, is this director someone experienced with animation, with action, is this director used to Imagi's drive-thru animation philosophy, is this director used to handling intellectual properties where everyone has a say in the production, and does this director care about the property itself? How many big movies did Steve Barron direct before he directed the first live-action TMNT movie? I will take Kevin Monroe's directing on TMNT over the more experienced directing of Micheal Bay on Transformers anyday.
When I say "real director" I mean people who make "real movies". "Transformers" is not a real movie, yes it's a movie but it was made simply to haul in cash. Someone like "Del Toro" would be perfect for a turtles movie since he knows how to make comics movies and makes them well. "Christopher Nolan" is also a good comic movie director. "Paul Verhoeven", "David Cronenberg", "The Coen Brothers" all these guys make movies and don't care how much cash they haul in they make whatever they want and don't back down when it comes to removing content.
That's what I mean by "real director"
It worked for the first live-action movie.
The kids humor wasn't half as heavy as it is in the other films.
The sillier moments in the first live-action movie are as silly(if not more silly) then the silly moments from TMNT, while conversly the darker moments from TMNT '90 are much darker (since much of the story is taken from the Mirage comics) then similar moments from TMNT '07.
The first movie went to extremes with its tone, while the current movie was more consistent with its tone, it was neither as goofy nor as dark as the first movie, a reason why you get so many varying opinions as to whether TMNT '07 is either too dark or lacks the goofy charm of the first movie.
I can agree with that you make a good point, I never viewed it that way.
Splinter's Iroonna
12-29-2007, 03:47 PM
Honor dictates that I say that EVERY Director started out with simple stuff-- whether video games, student projects, Pepsi commericals, or music videos.
Kevin Munroe is a real director.
Spitfire
12-29-2007, 04:00 PM
Honor dictates that I say that EVERY Director started out with simple stuff-- whether video games, student projects, Pepsi commericals, or music videos.
Kevin Munroe is a real director.
Yes, as a starting project. But they didn't tackle stuff like this as their first movie. Kevin never did anything but a video game before this movie. Directing a video game is way different from a movie. As is directing a TV series or advertisement. You can't go from doing Ads to film easily, or TV to film that usually turns out bad to. The worst are the people who go from music videos to film.
They may be directors but they fall far from the description I wrote.
Roseangelo
12-29-2007, 04:06 PM
The worst are the people who go from music videos to film.
Wouldn't Steve Barron fall into that category?
Slap-Happy
12-29-2007, 06:29 PM
Wouldn't Steve Barron fall into that category?
Rose has a point there Spitfire. Did you think the movie was good? If not it applies to you but I think you should put "I think that..." or " My opinon is that...". If you don't like the director fine we'll leave it alone
Dragon Turtle
12-29-2007, 10:31 PM
Yes, as a starting project. But they didn't tackle stuff like this as their first movie. Kevin never did anything but a video game before this movie. Directing a video game is way different from a movie. As is directing a TV series or advertisement. You can't go from doing Ads to film easily, or TV to film that usually turns out bad to. The worst are the people who go from music videos to film.
They may be directors but they fall far from the description I wrote.
One thing to take into consideration is that TMNT is an animated movie, a medium that directors like Del Toro and Nolan have no experience with in terms of directing, it would be another story if TMNT was a live-action movie.
Another thing is that Imagi isn't run the same way as Pixar or Dreamworks, where most of the production work is done in house with a production staff that speak the same language. You would have to wonder how comfortable these directors would be working under these conditions and how steep their learning curve would be.
As far as Kevin Monroe's experience is concerned, he is a veteran in the animation field, spending the last 10 years working on various tv projects, his career path is similar to most other animation directors, including such directors as John Lasseter and Brad Bird, neither of which had any major directing credits before doing their first major theatrical releases.
For a first effort and given the conditions in which he had to work with, I feel he did a pretty good job, if I do have one major criticism about his work on the movie, it would have to be the removal of the April and Casey subplot very late into production, he probably should have just left them in or at the very least he should have removed those parts earlier in the process and focused on developing the other parts of the story.
Spitfire
12-30-2007, 03:39 AM
Rose has a point there Spitfire. Did you think the movie was good? If not it applies to you but I think you should put "I think that..." or " My opinon is that...". If you don't like the director fine we'll leave it alone
As a movie itself all the turtles movies are pretty bad the only reason I enjoy any of them is simply because they bring me warm childhood memories. I don't feel I need to put "I think that..." or " My opinion is that..." because everything I post is my opinion. Things like movies being good can't be facts only opinions.
One thing to take into consideration is that TMNT is an animated movie, a medium that directors like Del Toro and Nolan have no experience with in terms of directing, it would be another story if TMNT was a live-action movie.
Yes and if those guys made it they would use costumes, look at Hellboy worked out great as a live action movie and some of those creatures are way more outlandish looking then the turtles.
Another thing is that Imagi isn't run the same way as Pixar or Dreamworks, where most of the production work is done in house with a production staff that speak the same language. You would have to wonder how comfortable these directors would be working under these conditions and how steep their learning curve would be.
They wouldn't be working for those people they would be working for WB itself or a major film studio.
As far as Kevin Monroe's experience is concerned, he is a veteran in the animation field, spending the last 10 years working on various tv projects, his career path is similar to most other animation directors, including such directors as John Lasseter and Brad Bird, neither of which had any major directing credits before doing their first major theatrical releases.
According to this site http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1083489/ He's worked on one thing for TV called Donner and he didn't direct it. This 10 years of experience you speak of is no where listed on here as "Donner" was made in 2002. If anything that's 5 years.
For a first effort and given the conditions in which he had to work with, I feel he did a pretty good job, if I do have one major criticism about his work on the movie, it would have to be the removal of the April and Casey subplot very late into production, he probably should have just left them in or at the very least he should have removed those parts earlier in the process and focused on developing the other parts of the story.
I'm not talking about giving him the benefit of the doubt. He made a good movie for what he had to work with. By those standards allot of movies would be considered good. I've seen more amazing stuff pulled off in that aspect. You want to see some good looking low budget films watch some foreign stuff. It's so cheap to make movies in other countries their CGI in some cases looks just as good as ours and they did it on half the budget.
A movie is only as good as the people working on it and the effort of the studio to get good people working on it. TMNT movies remain bad because film studios leave the work to nobodies with either zero experience or piss poor resumes. Steve Barron at least made "Merlin" after turtles which was a pretty decent made for TV special. All the guys who worked on the first 3 were from TV or made some movies that fell off the radar. I can't speak if any of them are good because I haven't seen them but judging from their work on this I can't say I have much hope for how their earlier films were.
You all obviously enjoy these movies allot for the most part and I don't want to offend anyone with what I'm saying. I also don't want to toss this topic into an endless void of bickering about why turtles movies are good or bad as that's not the purpose of it. Though if you'd like to talk about it more your welcome to PM me I'm always up for a good debate.
Andrew NDB
12-30-2007, 06:24 AM
One thing to take into consideration is that TMNT is an animated movie, a medium that directors like Del Toro and Nolan have no experience with in terms of directing,
A film is a film is a film. Directors get a script and figure out and know the angles they want, they get it done... whether it's CGI, live-action, or whatever else. If anything, a CGI film allots a seasoned live-action director an advantage, because they can get precisely the shot they want, angled just the way they want, and they don't need to compromise to get it. And they don't need to deal with actors asking "What's my motivation?" ... they can literally tell animators precisely what to do.
Another thing is that Imagi isn't run the same way as Pixar or Dreamworks, where most of the production work is done in house with a production staff that speak the same language. You would have to wonder how comfortable these directors would be working under these conditions and how steep their learning curve would be.
I'm not sure what this means, or if you do. I'm sure in a multi-million dollar production there is at least one guy standing there translating directives pretty much verbatim from Point A to Point B.
if I do have one major criticism about his work on the movie, it would have to be the removal of the April and Casey subplot very late into production, he probably should have just left them in or at the very least he should have removed those parts earlier in the process and focused on developing the other parts of the story.
*erm* I think people are getting too much of a hard-on about what exactly was removed to that extent... it's presence was pretty much negligible.
But in any case, Munroe had no say in it's removal. In fact, he wanted it left in there. Which really speaks volumes about his "pull"... the director of the film, and he didn't even have enough to leave something as minor as that in the movie.
As a movie itself all the turtles movies are pretty bad the only reason I enjoy any of them is simply because they bring me warm childhood memories.
Here's one of those times when I pretty much entirely agree with you. Although TMNT 1 is one of those really good bad movies (and I mean that in the kindest sense, and I do love the movie), a guilty pleasure I can watch freely, whereas TMNTs 2-4 are ones you watch when no one is around over the age of 10.
Yes and if those guys made it they would use costumes, look at Hellboy worked out great as a live action movie and some of those creatures are way more outlandish looking then the turtles.
Of course Del Toro would have. But that's not the same situation. The decision to go all CGI was made even before WB/Imagi went looking for a director... and they weren't looking to spend a lot on a director.
That said, I think Del Toro would be absolutely perfect helming a live- or semi-live action TMNT movie. And he would absolutely have the pull to cockblock the toy-mongers and kid-panderers at WB.
A movie is only as good as the people working on it and the effort of the studio to get good people working on it. TMNT movies remain bad because film studios leave the work to nobodies with either zero experience or piss poor resumes. Steve Barron at least made "Merlin" after turtles which was a pretty decent made for TV special.
I just now realized he made that now that you mentioned it. That was a pretty cool movie with Sam Neill, actually.
Slap-Happy
12-30-2007, 03:56 PM
Here's one of those times when I pretty much entirely agree with you. Although TMNT 1 is one of those really good bad movies (and I mean that in the kindest sense, and I do love the movie), a guilty pleasure I can watch freely, whereas TMNTs 2-4 are ones you watch when no one is around over the age of 10.
When I saw TMNT, there were only teenagers in the theater. No Kids, No Adults.
Dragon Turtle
12-30-2007, 06:34 PM
A film is a film is a film. Directors get a script and figure out and know the angles they want, they get it done... whether it's CGI, live-action, or whatever else. If anything, a CGI film allots a seasoned live-action director an advantage, because they can get precisely the shot they want, angled just the way they want, and they don't need to compromise to get it. And they don't need to deal with actors asking "What's my motivation?" ... they can literally tell animators precisely what to do.
With all due respect, directing a live-action movie is not the same as directing an animated movie. While it is true cgi gives the director the freedom to get virtually any shot they can imagine, it doesn't mean they will get what they want, the director needs to have some knowledge of the animated process, that is where the compromise comes in, if the director just wanted everything they could imagine, without any consideration for the limitations of the animators, then he will definately not get what he wants. Even Monroe wasn't immune to this, what happened to all the wild camera angles of the turtles leaping and swinging around buildings? Even mundane shots like a turn around shot of Rapheal or a panning shot of baby turtles in a bowl were axed due to time and money restraints. An animation director has to have a more hands on approach when it comes to directing a cgi movie, some of the most difficult and annoying shots to make in cgi would be considered easy throw away scenes if shot in live action, unlike live-action where you can go to a location/stage get your shot and move on, every scene in a cgi movie needs to be created and when you switch off to another character, you're not just switching to another camera, you actually have to make those scenes with different perspectives from scratch. There are lot advantages to shooting a movie in CGI, but there are also alot of other headaches I'm not sure a live-action director would want to put up with, and if they are not willing to put up with it, they probably won't get the movie they wanted.
I'm not sure what this means, or if you do. I'm sure in a multi-million dollar production there is at least one guy standing there translating directives pretty much verbatim from Point A to Point B.
Of course there are people on hand to translate(virtually all the managers and supervisiors at Imagi speak fluent english), but when you see how a director like Brad Bird is there in person going over tiny details, talking to the animators in person, being able to convey exactly what he wanted right there and then, as opposed to sending stuff overseas and relying on other people to convey your ideas. Even with translators there were times when the language barrier was a problem, although I feel Monroe is probably much better in dealing with this now then before he started TMNT.
The way Imagi produces movies reminds me of upscaled version on how tv animation is done, where the producers send their work overseas and are basically at the mercy of the overseas production company to interpret their storyboards, with strong storyboards this isn't much of a problem for a 22-25 minute 2d animated show, but for a 2 hour cgi movie, you can definately see alot hurdles popping up in production.
*erm* I think people are getting too much of a hard-on about what exactly was removed to that extent... it's presence was pretty much negligible.
But in any case, Munroe had no say in it's removal. In fact, he wanted it left in there. Which really speaks volumes about his "pull"... the director of the film, and he didn't even have enough to leave something as minor as that in the movie.
I can't speak about the quality of the scenes involving April or Casey, since I've never seen them (for all we know they could have sucked and deservered to have been cut). But I don't believe their removal is negligible, perhaps to what effect they would have had on the Leo/Raph subplot and the Winters/Monster plot, but not to the overall movie. Not only were those scenes plotted and scripted, but they were also animated, since we saw the "still wanna fight" deleted scene was colorized (remember this movie was originally animated in black and white), and if those scenes pushed the runtime over two hours, then that is alot of wasted time and effort for something that ultimately ended up on the cutting room floor, time and effort that could have been better spent on the other parts of the movie, like the Raph/Leo scenes which feels like a B-subplot or the Winters plot that feels tacked on. I wouldn't be surprised to find out the real reason why Monroe wasn't considered for the sequel was his decision to cut out nearly 40 minutes of nearly completed animation.
As for who decided to remove the scenes in the first place, all I can go by is Monroe's dvd commentary, where he says it was his decision to remove
the scenes, since he felt this plot took up too much time, and this wasn't an April/Casey movie, I've read interviews where he regreted their removal, but none saying he was forced to remove them.
According to this site http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1083489/ He's worked on one thing for TV called Donner and he didn't direct it. This 10 years of experience you speak of is no where listed on here as "Donner" was made in 2002. If anything that's 5 years.
There are several interviews that talk about Monroe's past experience including this one:
http://animated-views.com/2007/director-kevin-munroe-on-tmnt/
Design work, writing, directing a few tv episodes, that basically is the standard resume for an animation director, they toil away in the animation industry doing production work earning their stripes, before getting a shot at sitting in the big chair.
You all obviously enjoy these movies allot for the most part and I don't want to offend anyone with what I'm saying. I also don't want to toss this topic into an endless void of bickering about why turtles movies are good or bad as that's not the purpose of it. Though if you'd like to talk about it more your welcome to PM me I'm always up for a good debate.
No offense taken, there is no way any interpretation of the turtles is going to be universally enjoyed by everyone, given all the different interpretations that currently exist, and my apologies for derailing this thread, just for the record my dream TMNT movie would be one with an intelligently written plot and script with excellent characterization, it would be CGI to take advantage of the medium for the action scenes, which will need a real action/fight choreographer, like Yuen Woo-Ping or Donnie Yen, although I do not want to see too much wire work style action, it should be more grounded in reality.
As for subject matter, as long as I get the above, I'm not too particular as to what the direction of the movie is, but I wouldn't mind seeing a more indepth look at the Foot clan, who I feel are a great untapped source for story material.
TheAnimatedSeries
01-02-2008, 12:09 PM
One that is made by a real director who has experience. One that Laird is not allowed to touch. Needs to be a totally new story not some watered down piece of crap comic adaptation like the 2K3 series is full of. If it's PG it needs to stick with being PG. I'm tired of turtles trying to be a rated R kids movie. Either use a dark tone and make it for older people or use a light tone and keep it for kids.
Exactly on everything. These are stand-alone movies that are totally free to tell good stories, free of continuity restraints and should be free of Laird and, ideally, 13 or any other numerical value of monsters.
Drtooth
01-02-2008, 01:24 PM
Dream movie? An ACTUAL origin story, exactly like the comic book. A little darker in tone than the 2k3 adaption. And a little more condensed. It would work better as a CGI animated film, in the vein of TMNT than a live action. I mean, all those Triceritons. No wonder why they had to be TGRI.
My other dream movie is a DTV old toon type film, everyone from the old series as possible comed back and works on it. Something that would explain how Shredder and Krang came together a little deeper.
CJStyles
01-02-2008, 02:26 PM
Dream movie would be a darker tone, a more serious plot, individual characters, lots of action, serious dialog. AND BLOOD SHED
Slap-Happy
01-05-2008, 09:09 PM
Dream movie would be a darker tone, a more serious plot, individual characters, lots of action, serious dialog. AND BLOOD SHED
maybe a few jokes here and there
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.