View Full Version : Oscar Noms. 1/22
Splinter's Iroonna
01-19-2008, 10:38 AM
I remember Mr. M's blog awhile back said that WB was going to push to get "TMNT" nominated for the animation category (which, I predict, will be won by Pixar). I don't read the entertainment trade papers-- anyone ever notice if they did those "For your consideration" thingies?
Anyway, it will be interesting to see if the movie actually gets on the list somewhere.
Of course, if the Writers Strike isn't settled, the Oscars may go the way of the Golden Globes.:sleep:
There's no joy for a TMNT Oscar nom in the news. No buzz at all. Even the nomination occurs, Animation is a tough category this year, like you said.
As much as I love Jon Stewart (he's supposed to host), I'd be happy to see the Academy Awards condensed to 30 minutes. I hope the writers stay on strike unless they get their 2.5 cents.
For this year's Oscars, there are 12 animated features that have been submitted for consideration:
"Alvin and the Chipmunks," "Aqua Teen Hunger Force Colon Movie Film for Theaters," "Bee Movie," "Beowulf," "Meet the Robinsons," "Persepolis," "Ratatouille," "Shrek the Third, " "The Simpsons Movie," "Surf's Up," "Tekkonkinkreet, " and "TMNT."
Mr._Mutant_Man
01-19-2008, 02:01 PM
I don't think I've really paid attention to the oscars in like three years. Nothing that is considered "Oscar caliber" by most has really appealed to me in recent years.
Splinter's Iroonna
01-19-2008, 03:56 PM
I read today (I am bad at remembering exactly which gossip blog it was) that there was a possibility that "Ratatouille" would be nominated for Best Picture period. But you know it's in the Oscar rules that Pixar/Disney= Best Animation Oscar.
As much as I love Jon Stewart (he's supposed to host), I'd be happy to see the Academy Awards condensed to 30 minutes. I hope the writers stay on strike unless they get their 2.5 cents.
:lol:
It would certainly be an earth-shattering event if it were-- I can just see Gov. Arnold and Mayor V. desperately trying to end the strike so no more money is lost here in L.A.
Quite frankly, I don't think it matters if TMNT gets a win, let alone a nomination. To me, winning an Oscar is just another way of labeling something. They're like trophies you get for some achievement in school: forgotten in a year. Sure, they're pretty to look at, but after a while people will hear about the win and say, "Well, what have you done, lately?" It's a pretentious award that only matters to the people giving it and the mindless drones who keep tabs on who wins. Hollywood is nothing but glitter and shamelessness.
Oscars do nothing to the quality of a film that its fans love.
Roseangelo
01-19-2008, 09:27 PM
I was flipping through Animation magazine recently and it's full of "For your consideration" ads for all of the animated movies. No TMNT ad, though. And the Ratatouille ad was pushing it for Best Picture, not Best Animated Picture.
But Ratatouille will win for best animated, and it should IMO.
TMNT won't get a nod.
Splinter's Iroonna
01-19-2008, 10:30 PM
I was flipping through Animation magazine recently and it's full of "For your consideration" ads for all of the animated movies. No TMNT ad, though. And the Ratatouille ad was pushing it for Best Picture, not Best Animated Picture.
But Ratatouille will win for best animated, and it should IMO.
TMNT won't get a nod.
Ah... so WB lied once again to Mirage.
And yeah, I'm certain Ratatouille may actually get the Best Picture (NOT animation) nod-- Beauty and the Beast certainly deserved its nomination-- and though I've not see R, if there is this much buzz, it must be worth the nod.
Meanwhile-- I will go watch "TMNT" again and yet again marvel at the "realism" of many scenes, and I do not just mean the big showdown between Leo and Raph.
Roseangelo
01-19-2008, 11:09 PM
Ratatouille won't be nominated for Best Picture. It's good, but it's not Pixar's best (don't know if it can get better than Toy Story 2). And the Animated category exists so that cartoons don't end up in the Big Category. Beauty and the Beast deserved it, but The Lion King deserved it even more and didn't get it. The voters don't want to get stuck having to nominate every movie released by any given production company. Imagine if Fellowship of the Ring had won Best Picture? You'd be stuck giving the prize to The Two Towers and The Return of the King as well.
tcclives23
01-21-2008, 09:11 PM
This is completely off topic but does anyone know where I can find the undoctored pic of Roseangelo's banner? The family portrait.
Roseangelo
01-21-2008, 09:14 PM
Sent you a PM.
tcclives23
01-21-2008, 09:25 PM
Sent you a PM.
Thank you! Very very much.
MoreCowbell5263
01-21-2008, 09:50 PM
I saw Ratatouille and I really wasn't impressed, or at least with what I saw. I nodded off like 4 or 5 times during it in the theater. The parts I saw, I didn't like, and it's certainly not Pixar's best, I don't think it's anywhere near Pixar's best, but that's just me. I gave it a chance and fell asleep, not much of a chance, but I know I really don't want to see it again. My brother told me at the end of the movie that he knew I was asleep and that I didn't miss much (meaning the movie wasn't good, I did sleep through a good portion of it). My brother and I are usually really open-minded about movies in regards to kids' movies, family movies, R-rated movies, you name it, and we both didn't like it.
If the category was like "Best Animation" then yeah, I'd give Ratatouille that award, but not "Best Animated Film", but again, that's just me. I didn't like Simpsons much either, and I didn't hear anything good about Bee Movie and I wasn't interested in seeing it anyway. I never saw the other ones. Meet the Robinsons looks watchable, but if I honestly had to pick out of the ones I've seen, I'd pick TMNT. It had some really great animation, especially during the Leo/Raph fight, some of the best CGI I've ever seen, but the story was too weak.
Dragon Turtle
01-22-2008, 08:18 AM
And your nominess are:
Best Animated Feature Film
'Persepolis'
'Ratatouille'
'Surf's Up'
Somewhat surprised Surf's Up got the nod over The Simpsons, but like TMNT, the opinions about the Simpsons movie were just as divisive.
"Surf's Up" is this years "Cars", tired live-action premise given a CGI makeover, although I did like Surf's Up more.
I'm rooting for "Persepolis" Which I'm glad got the nomination.
Drtooth
01-22-2008, 09:20 AM
Surf's Up... Surf's Up?!?! What the hell?!?! That may have well been a bargain DVD with low budget CGI stuff releasde DTV during Happy Feet.
I mean, I though Jimmy Neutron was an undeserved nomination and I enjoyed it. I wouldn't see Surf's up if you paid me. Well, it depends on how much. I'm pretty desperate now.
Anyway, I was about to say "TMNT" being a fan franchise, would never hold up. But since some moron from Sony musta paid their way into getting the film nominated, I'm insulted Warners didn't do the same.
I root for the other two. Rat was certainly more fun and more artistic than the other Restaraunt themes films of the year. Not too many Pop culture refferences, no poo or fart jokes (sorry Shrek. I liked your first 2 movies, but you've exhausted those jokes forever for me). I still think the riff on modern celebrity "Chefs" that sell themselves out to make horrible little food products is worth the award alone.
Splinter's Iroonna
01-22-2008, 10:15 AM
At least "Bee Movie" didn't get the nod.
But though I liked "Surf's Up", it still surprises me it made the cut. Doesn't matter, "Ratatouille" has it locked.
"Transformers" was nominated for sound stuff and visual effect (I think).
I knew TMNT wouldn't get the nomination, but I still hoped that WB had meant it when they said they would push for a nomination. Not that pushing would earn it, but still, they could have made a LITTLE noise.
"Persepolis"???
Mr._Mutant_Man
01-22-2008, 01:14 PM
Quite frankly, I don't think it matters if TMNT gets a win, let alone a nomination. To me, winning an Oscar is just another way of labeling something. They're like trophies you get for some achievement in school: forgotten in a year. Sure, they're pretty to look at, but after a while people will hear about the win and say, "Well, what have you done, lately?" It's a pretentious award that only matters to the people giving it and the mindless drones who keep tabs on who wins. Hollywood is nothing but glitter and shamelessness.
Oscars do nothing to the quality of a film that its fans love.
I'd agree with you about that being the way Oscars are today, where you can kind of pick out a movie that's going to be an Oscar contender a mile away. They always seem to share a lot of similarities, and the movies are eventually forgotten about for the most part.
There are certainly past Oscar winners which are kind of cemented as "must see" movies, such as The Godfather. There are movies like Star Wars, which didn't win but are still considered "must see". So I guess I agree that the Oscar is kind of pretentious, and it isn't a indicator that a movie will stand the test of time. Godfather would have stood the test the time regardless of whether or not it won, because it was such a fantastic drama and well done movie. Star Wars just has something special about it that makes you feel like a kid again, so it has stood the test of time as being kind of the king of space fantasies.
Dragon Turtle
01-22-2008, 02:10 PM
Surf's Up... Surf's Up?!?! What the hell?!?! That may have well been a bargain DVD with low budget CGI stuff releasde DTV during Happy Feet.
I mean, I though Jimmy Neutron was an undeserved nomination and I enjoyed it. I wouldn't see Surf's up if you paid me. Well, it depends on how much. I'm pretty desperate now.
Anyway, I was about to say "TMNT" being a fan franchise, would never hold up. But since some moron from Sony musta paid their way into getting the film nominated, I'm insulted Warners didn't do the same.
It makes a certain amount of sense that Surf's Up would get nominated, it was a summer release movie that was fairly well recieved by movie critics, mostly because it was such a harmless piece of fluff (not a great movie but not bad enough to hate, just meh), its dvd was also released later in the year so it was fresh in the minds of voters.
At least "Bee Movie" didn't get the nod.
I knew TMNT wouldn't get the nomination, but I still hoped that WB had meant it when they said they would push for a nomination. Not that pushing would earn it, but still, they could have made a LITTLE noise.
It's best not to put too much faith in Warner Bros, a studio that would be near the bottom of the barrel if they didn't stumble upon hits like Harry Potter.
"Persepolis"???
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persepolis_%28film%29
Drtooth
01-22-2008, 03:47 PM
It makes a certain amount of sense that Surf's Up would get nominated, it was a summer release movie that was fairly well recieved by movie critics, mostly because it was such a harmless piece of fluff (not a great movie but not bad enough to hate, just meh), its dvd was also released later in the year so it was fresh in the minds of voters.
..still.. it seemed that they only got a Sony film because they wanted to spite Dreamworks. much like how Shrek winning the Oscar was their attempt to spite Disney. Dispite the fact Disney didn't make that film. It just came off loud and annoying, and there was no way I'd pay to see it, or even rent it. Plus, Penguins have been done to death. Seems like Squirells will be the next animalsploitation we'll see. I mean, Skratt in Ice Age and that character that Steve Carell played in Over the Hedge seem to be hinting at that.
MoreCowbell5263
01-22-2008, 05:50 PM
Don't forget Alvin and the Chipmunks.
Splinter's Iroonna
01-22-2008, 06:06 PM
Don't forget Alvin and the Chipmunks.
Who?
Okay, jk, but seriously-- I had hoped that whole Garfield thing had ended with Garfield. Gollum worked. Roger Rabbit worked. I suppose even Transformers worked (as well as other movies I can't recall at the moment).
And I predict that, once Kung Fu Panda comes out, we'll be swamped with lots of animals doing martial arts... like Turtles, perhaps, who are Ninja... :roll:
Dragon Turtle
01-22-2008, 10:30 PM
..still.. it seemed that they only got a Sony film because they wanted to spite Dreamworks. much like how Shrek winning the Oscar was their attempt to spite Disney. Dispite the fact Disney didn't make that film. It just came off loud and annoying, and there was no way I'd pay to see it, or even rent it. Plus, Penguins have been done to death. Seems like Squirells will be the next animalsploitation we'll see. I mean, Skratt in Ice Age and that character that Steve Carell played in Over the Hedge seem to be hinting at that.
I believe squirrels are yesterdays news (wasn't there a wacky squirrel in "The Wild"?). Maybe "Horton Hears A Who" will start the elephant era.
Okay, jk, but seriously-- I had hoped that whole Garfield thing had ended with Garfield. Gollum worked. Roger Rabbit worked. I suppose even Transformers worked (as well as other movies I can't recall at the moment).
You mean animation mixed with live-action? As technology becomes more advanced and cheaper you can expect even more of these types of movies.
Drtooth
01-23-2008, 01:51 PM
And I predict that, once Kung Fu Panda comes out, we'll be swamped with lots of animals doing martial arts... like Turtles, perhaps, who are Ninja... :roll:
We already were. Care to take a guess what started it?
I believe squirrels are yesterdays news (wasn't there a wacky squirrel in "The Wild"?). Maybe "Horton Hears A Who" will start the elephant era.
Seems like they're just pulling up right now. Other than Rocky and Slappy, I could give a crud about Squirells. An Elephant thing may not be out of the question, however... considering we have an election coming up, and they may be trying to work out something subliminally... But when are gorillas gonna make a come back? And Alligators?
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.