View Full Version : Episode/story arc content. What is your prefrence?
Sage Ninja
01-23-2008, 03:56 PM
When you are watching the New toon of the ninja turtles do you prefere seeing content from orginal Mirage comics to be incorporated into the storylines or do you prefere seeing orginal ideas that give fresh or diffrent twists to the story telling of the ninja turtles?
My favorites are Big Brawl and Notes from the Underground, so I guess original stuff.
Kunoichi_Haruko
01-23-2008, 04:00 PM
I wouldn't mind a little from Column A and a little from Column B, but primarily I'd hope for mostly original content. For example, we need not rehash their origin story yet again...
Scandia
01-23-2008, 04:01 PM
Both please.
Anything done well that works well and flows well makes me quite a happy Turtle fan.
triplexxx
01-23-2008, 06:36 PM
Anything's fine, just not another SAINW-level extreme.
Kunoichi_Haruko
01-23-2008, 08:46 PM
Anything's fine, just not another SAINW-level extreme.
Aww, I kinda liked SAINW. Could've been fleshed out a bit more, but it was decent for what it was...:shrug:
Whitewolf89
01-23-2008, 09:30 PM
Both please.
Anything done well that works well and flows well makes me quite a happy Turtle fan.
Ditto this for me.;)
Sage Ninja
01-27-2008, 12:09 AM
Even though I enjoy the more "true-to-its-comics-roots" feel that the New toon has, I think I actually like having orginal ideas used in the shows storylines over comic adaptions. Mainly because, for one, I never read the comics but also because I think not following the comics adpations it gives the storylines more flexabilty and range to bring the characters and plot than to follow guideline as it where, and it has the potinetcial to suprices viewes with something new or diffrent that have already read the comics.
However that is not to say that I don't like comics adaptions, (I do) but I just don't care for sticking to a formula of events, I think that it limits the story, but I do like comics adpations that are tweaked a bit sometimes (so long as it keeps the spirit and intensity its supposed to have) just to have something new and fresh.
Time Mistress
01-27-2008, 09:53 PM
I like the mix of both though I honestly prefer the Mirage adapted episodes. Seeing those come to life on the small screen was really of what made this show so awesome for me in the beginning and why most of my favorite eps come from the first two seasons.
That said, I think the flexibility with the comics stoylines was a great thing that the show had too, and thought the show did a great job building it's own mythos that really came to fruition in the LS and was almost as good as the earlier stuff. I've really enjoyed original eps like Big Brawl, Grudge Match, and SAINW. Hun, Bishop, and the Ultimate Ninja are great new villains created by the 2k3 show and I liked seeing different takes on Karai and Zandramon as well as alien Shredder and "real" Shredder from the LS.
Sage Ninja
01-29-2008, 02:23 AM
that makes me wonder for those of you that have read the mirage comics, which episodes (story arcs) in the 2k3 series had the best transistions from comic to cartoon?
which stories had the best adaptions?
which had the worst?
Which had the best comic adaptions that had good original tweaking in in it?
cowabunga14
01-29-2008, 07:14 PM
When you are watching the New toon of the ninja turtles do you prefere seeing content from orginal Mirage comics to be incorporated into the storylines or do you prefere seeing orginal ideas that give fresh or diffrent twists to the story telling of the ninja turtles?
For me, it would have to be a bit of both. I don't see why I should have to prefer one over the other.
thebrownranger
01-29-2008, 07:20 PM
Half and half works for me as long as the story doesn't get too redundant.
Spitfire
01-29-2008, 07:58 PM
The original stuff because the comic episodes come out horrible most of the time. Mixing comic characters into new stories is great but using comic ones has proved bad in almost every case.
Sage Ninja
05-12-2008, 02:14 AM
does any one think that in season seven their will be some story lines and comic adaptions in some episodes or do you think like the lost season and fast foward it will be all orginal story lines. Does any one want to see a few comic adaptions in the up coming seasons or no?
odupianist
05-12-2008, 07:49 AM
I like a bit of both, as most have said. A good example, "I, Monster", good episode, not a perfect adaptation BUT still managed to have original elements in it like Bishop's Slayer as the Rat King.
Revan
05-12-2008, 11:04 AM
that makes me wonder for those of you that have read the mirage comics, which episodes (story arcs) in the 2k3 series had the best transistions from comic to cartoon?
which stories had the best adaptions?
which had the worst?
Which had the best comic adaptions that had good original tweaking in in it?
This will sound extremely cynical but few if any mirage books have turned out as good on the television screen. To answer the topic question frankly, I prefer the original episodes more than the mirage book episodes. Mostly because it's fun to see a new episode and not know what is supposed to happen next. Also, 2k3 doesn't measure up to the mirage stories imo
VaughnMichael
05-12-2008, 11:14 AM
I totally agree Neutrino and know I am not alone in saying this.
They sure did try but they sure did water almost everything down when it came time to animate the show, and they took chunks of things and slopped it all over the place as they saw fit.
Tinuvielsdreams
05-12-2008, 03:30 PM
Like Nuetrino said I can't think of many at all that I though justice was done to the comic but All Hallows thieves was done okay, I mean they lengthened the fight between the turtles and the idol and they took out the poisoning part but like Putrescent said they do water things down.
I do like the concept, for example, when I watch eppys like the "shredder strikes" and I think of Tales of Leo and silent partner I am glad they decided to try it, some episodes work better then others even though none of them are 100% accurate
It was a really great idea comics to cartoons but its the same thing with many books to film, its hard to do them justice and translate them for timing and rating constrictions
Warhorse
05-12-2008, 09:27 PM
I like the original stories. They have more ground they could cover and I asw a viewer, will have more surprises with I don't know what will happen next.
Like, isn't Bishop an original character?
Jelly Bean
05-13-2008, 03:09 AM
I've never read the comics so I can't tell if something was dipicted wrong from it's adpations from comic to cartoon. But if the serious and deep content comes from the storylines in the comics, than I would say that I would rather have comic adaptions rather than orginal "lets make this into a kiddy show" storylines. :roll:
VaughnMichael
05-13-2008, 03:15 AM
I've never read the comics so I can't tell if something was dipicted wrong from it's adpations from comic to cartoon. But if the serious and deep content comes from the storylines in the comics, than I would say that I would rather have comic adaptions rather than orginal "lets make this into a kiddy show" storylines. :roll:
It is a kids show, something fans here tend to forget.
Hence why the episodes of the cartoon can't even come close to being as good as the comics they're based off of.
I'd go with one of each. Original stories and adaption, just like the good ol' days of Season 1. Something for adults and kids, and fans overall. Nothing too dark (as much as I hate to say it), but nothing too happy and bright like Fast Forward proved to be (correct me if I'm wrong, since I really couldn't handle any more than 3 episodes, all of which were unnervingly bright and "kiddy").
Besides, if you just keep the language and story that little bit higher than most cartoons today, kids will love it. They don't like being talked down to at all from what I've seen and heard.
VaughnMichael
05-13-2008, 11:29 AM
Nothing too dark (as much as I hate to say it), but nothing too happy and bright like Fast Forward proved to be (correct me if I'm wrong, since I really couldn't handle any more than 3 episodes, all of which were unnervingly bright and "kiddy").
KILBfQBPIK8
Oh and also remember there's no continuing storyline, yeah maybe to people who don't pay attention.
ToTheNines
05-13-2008, 01:11 PM
KILBfQBPIK8
Oh and also remember there's no continuing storyline, yeah maybe to people who don't pay attention.
I just watched that one this morning! Another thing about fast forward that went over looked was the fact that the fights were really cool (espicially in the later half of the show).
The Big Bad
05-14-2008, 04:45 AM
This will sound extremely cynical but few if any mirage books have turned out as good on the television screen.Really; I'd have to disagree. Some of the one-shot adaptations--notably, Nobody's Fool and Return of the Justice Force--I find to be definite improvements over the originals' plots (and only their plots--I'll admit I haven't actually read these comics and cannot judge execution), while others, such as the Mouser two-parter, the Search for Splinter/Turtles in Space/TCRI arc, and several one-shots are at least comparable in quality, if not better. Only two stories--City at War and Sons of the Silent Age--stand out as being unquestionally worse than the stories they're based on. It seems to me that, somewhat legitimate complaints about atmosphere aside, the main objection against adaptations of actual storylines seems to be that...well, they changed things (http://http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheyChangedItNowItSucks).
Still, at this point in the series, I'd rather see original stories than adaptations (asuming we're limited to the Mirage stuff); not only have most of the worthwhile/memorable/adaptable stories already been adapted, we have enough characters and recurring plotlines that we can probably spend a couple of seasons focusing on them without having to dip into the comic book pool.
Jelly Bean
05-15-2008, 01:24 AM
It is a kids show, something fans here tend to forget.
Hence why the episodes of the cartoon can't even come close to being as good as the comics they're based off of.
It was a kids show before it went FF don't foget and it was just fine in the first three seasons, while having good depth and charactersation. They should have just stuck to the tone in season one, it was good enough to warrant three other seasons before it went into R-rated movie material in a saturday morning cartoon mode. As much as I loved season four and all the cool gritty stuff that came with it, season four killed the turtles cartoon and made the higher ups think it should be gimicky shallow kiddy fodder (fast forward) or flashy magical transformations anime rip off (lost season), so now we're screwed.
VaughnMichael
05-15-2008, 01:33 AM
It was a kids show before it went FF don't foget and it was just fine in the first three seasons, while having good depth and charactersation. They should have just stuck to the tone in season one, it was good enough to warrant three other seasons before it went into R-rated movie material in a saturday morning cartoon mode. As much as I loved season four and all the cool gritty stuff that came with it, season four killed the turtles cartoon and made the higher ups think it should be gimicky shallow kiddy fodder (fast forward) or flashy magical transformations anime rip off (lost season), so now we're screwed.
Oh give me a flippin break you take this stuff way to seriously.
Jelly Bean
05-15-2008, 01:35 AM
your come back for every thing :roll:
VaughnMichael
05-15-2008, 01:44 AM
your come back for every thing :roll:
Um no seriously your spazzing out over a cartoon series.
The change in format that's not even that drastic and kept storylines from the past isn't the end of the world.
I'm going to be laughing my ass of when next season comes and it's still not dark enough for all you dark obsessed people.
Seriously it's a program on tv, tv shows have differnt story arcs, art styles, and change formats all the time it's not the end of your life.
This one isn't even that bad and so many of you act as if it's the end of the world to the point that it's annoying to even discuss something quite a few of us enjoy.
That's the way it became with the Next Mutation around here and Fast Forward isn't even close to being that bad.
2K3 is cool and all of that but I just cant watch it over and over again like I can with the FF episodes, the only 2K3 episodes I can even watch over and over are the later ones that you feel ruined the show, so go figure.
I like what I like and I say screw the whiney fans who bitch about everything and are never happy with what they're given.
You don't like it don't watch it and stop bringing up how much you hate it because quite frankly no one gives a Splinters ass, you should be thanking your lucky stars there's a TMNT show on tv at all.
But perhaps I should just sit back and let the kids say what they want I mean the show is made for you kids anyway what do I know I'm not a kid.
Jelly Bean
05-15-2008, 02:00 AM
dude calm down and accept that not every one liked the change or will like the changes. You get way to worked up when some one doesn't agree with you about how FF was good, and don't say that you don't because you always do. And you accuse me about taking it seriously. Drop it.
VaughnMichael
05-15-2008, 02:17 AM
dude calm down and accept that not every one liked the change or will like the changes. You get way to worked up when some one doesn't agree with you about how FF was good, and don't say that you don't because you always do. And you accuse me about taking it seriously. Drop it.
Jelly Bean is not my lover she's just a girl who thinks that I am the one but FF is not my son...anyway
No I get mad when you guys keep beating a dead friggin horse then complain about everything under the sun never being good enough, like every day it's really gotten old.
I don't even care about change that's what I'm saying, you guys make such a huge deal about it to the point that it's like wtf is wrong with these people get a life.
I thought I'd be happy that FF was over because finally people would stop whining about it but they don't they just keep beeting a dead horse over and over and over.
Everyones gotta have their swing at it and it just wouldn't be a party without that would it.:lol:
Seriously you guys are the ones that need to calm down about it, and you're new here like you even know half of what I've said about things. I mean unless you study Putrescent 101?
I haven't even said anything about FF in months the only people who do are you negative nancies who just wont drop it, spitfire & tothenines are the only ones who sticks up for the damn show because I got sick of repeating myself.
But It's funny how more and more people now are taking the time to see what people like spitfire have been saying the entire time about this, that it's not that differnt from 2k3 at all.
No one would even need to say anything about how much they liked it if people would stop ripping on it every chance they get.
Sorry but I've got better things to do then to argue about a series I've completly enjoyed all the way through and plan to continue enjoying.
I mean seriously what do you people want out of this series?
I'd love for it to be all bloody and dark as the next Mirage lovin' fan but that's not going to happen on 4kids so you guys need to just get that idea out of your head for the moment.
Seriously this entire thing is just so:
http://i94.photobucket.com/albums/l108/billelzebub/724you_win_the_prize.jpg
Spitfire
05-15-2008, 03:58 AM
It was a kids show before it went FF don't foget and it was just fine in the first three seasons, while having good depth and charactersation. They should have just stuck to the tone in season one, it was good enough to warrant three other seasons before it went into R-rated movie material in a saturday morning cartoon mode. As much as I loved season four and all the cool gritty stuff that came with it, season four killed the turtles cartoon and made the higher ups think it should be gimicky shallow kiddy fodder (fast forward) or flashy magical transformations anime rip off (lost season), so now we're screwed.
The thing about you that gets me is you have basically no prior turtles knowledge and came into this thing completely blind. You have a character in your sig from a TV show you've never even watched.
From what you've said you never watched the old series so you have no clue what that was like nor do you have any childhood attachments like most of us do. I've never seen you mention reading the comics so all these stories are new to you.
I hardly see FF as "gimicky*gimmicky* shallow kiddy fodder".
Maybe you don't know what those words mean
Gimmicky - to equip or embellish with unnecessary features, esp. in order to increase saleability, acceptance, etc.
I guess you could see it like that but if that's the case you must really hate Season 5 then because it's dressed up even worse, and yes I'm aware you mentioned you hate Season 5. On that note you can completely blame 4Kids for why it's like that because it was planned on staying the same style as 2K3 was.
Shallow - lacking depth; superficial
I really fail to see how it's at all shallow. Teletubbies is shallow this has clear plot lines and character development.
Kiddy isn't even a word but I know what it means nonetheless, God help us. I don't think knocking a grenade into someone's mouth to kill them is "kiddy", a man trying to kill his own nephew, or a guy who wants to enslave the entire planet and turn it into a graveyard. Hmmm maybe FF should be a line of childrens books.
Fodder - coarse food for livestock, composed of entire plants, including leaves, stalks, and grain, of such forages as corn and sorghum.
Hmm didn't know the turtles fed livestock I guess I never saw that episode.
So to you the turtles are embellished with unnecessary features, lack depth, kiddy, and coarse food for livestock.
That's the most interesting definition of them I've ever heard personally. I'd almost say I'm impressed you somehow managed to come to that conclusion. Ah to be young...
KILBfQBPIK8
Oh and also remember there's no continuing storyline, yeah maybe to people who don't pay attention.
Yes!! Now that's what I'm talking about (sans Cody :P). If the new season were like that, I think it would reach a very wide audience. Wait and see, I guess.
Jelly Bean
05-15-2008, 02:32 PM
Spit, Put, get over your selves. Just because I didn't watch the turtles back when it came on in the 80's/90's doesn't mean I don't have back ground with the new series. It seems unless you're a veteran turtle fan around here who saw the show when it debuted in 1987 up until it's end, or read the very first comic when it came out, your opinions don't mean squat. It's the fact that some one can't have an opinion about not liking something with out the FF shippers getting their panties in a knot. I don't care if you're tired of it I'm saying what I honestly feel about the situation. If it bothers you so much why bother even aknowldeging my or any ones else posts about FF?
Spitfire
05-15-2008, 02:50 PM
It all stems from a rising issue around here. You unfortunately happen to be the one we're making an example out of. Maybe some of you noticed a lot of pushy new members who lack serious knowledge yet try to act like they know everything.
Opinions are opinions but if you expect an entire message board of long term turtles fans to think on the same level or hold the opinions of someone whose new to the fandom as highly as their peers your setting yourself up to fail. That's like a teenager trying to talk politics with an adult whose voted in a few elections.
On top of that your bringing up subjects we are over already. We're over the "FF sucks/no it rules" debate. We are over the "Oh noes format change" and lastly I'd like to think we're over "Lost Season rules!/Lost Season is an Anime rip off" debate. You have come at an unfortunate time to discuss something that's long since past and us seasoned fans are sick of hearing about it. It's like bringing up Mike Tyson biting the ear, it's been talked about to death. It happened, it's over now, let it stay dead. You might be behind on the news and I could understand you bringing it up a few times but when it's constant and you don't get the clue it appears to me someone needed to point it out to you.
I can't speak for Putrescent but I'm sure like myself we're not trying to be assholes but our patience for this is exhausted and unfortunately for you that causes conflict.
VaughnMichael
05-15-2008, 03:00 PM
Yes!! Now that's what I'm talking about (sans Cody :P). If the new season were like that, I think it would reach a very wide audience. Wait and see, I guess.
Yeah, I don't know I'm thinking it's his voice that has allot to do with it, I haven't watched FF in awhile and now looking back at Cody It's like nails on a chalkboard with his voice.
His voice really isn't that differnt from chaplin's though, which who at first I thought had a gay crush on Baxter then we see he's really in love with Karai. lol:lol:
But anyway Cody pretty much kills the moment when he busts through the roof and says what he does.
But I would expect a kid to act that way, especially one in his position.
It all stems from a rising issue around here. You unfortunately happen to be the one we're making an example out of. Maybe some of you noticed a lot of pushy new members who lack serious knowledge yet try to act like they know everything.
Opinions are opinions but if you expect an entire message board of long term turtles fans to think on the same level or hold the opinions of someone whose new to the fandom as highly as their peers your setting yourself up to fail. That's like a teenager trying to talk politics with an adult whose voted in a few elections.
On top of that your bringing up subjects we are over already. We're over the "FF sucks/no it rules" debate. We are over the "Oh noes format change" and lastly I'd like to think we're over "Lost Season rules!/Lost Season is an Anime rip off" debate. You have come at an unfortunate time to discuss something that's long since past and us seasoned fans are sick of hearing about it. It's like bringing up Mike Tyson biting the ear, it's been talked about to death. It happened, it's over now, let it stay dead. You might be behind on the news and I could understand you bringing it up a few times but when it's constant and you don't get the clue it appears to me someone needed to point it out to you.
I can't speak for Putrescent but I'm sure like myself we're not trying to be assholes but our patience for this is exhausted and unfortunately for you that causes conflict.
Yeah that pretty much sums up what I'd have said besides that I won't get over myself because without me who else have I got.:lol:
Revan
05-15-2008, 05:03 PM
Really; I'd have to disagree. Some of the one-shot adaptations--notably, Nobody's Fool and Return of the Justice Force.
To each his own I suppose. I will admit that Mirage's Return of the Justice force was a dissapointment, not too difficult to top that in a kids show. Then again, I am not nor was I ever a fan of the existance of superheroes in turtle continuity:roll:. That issue was goofy. If I recall correctly several fans had their letters published in that issue about how the comics had taken a turn for the worse. (Anyone know what I'm talking about? I remember reading angry letters about how the first issues were good but had begun to get stupid.)
...But I digress. Sometimes the fact that the mirage books were written so long ago is enough to make 4kids episodes better but when you keep in mind what was going on at the time, the books are still better than the cartoon IMO and understandably so.
[enter beating dead horse mode] Ratings and content must be regulated on a saturday morning children's cartoon but not in a comic book [exit beating dead horse mode/]
Sage Ninja
05-16-2008, 02:32 AM
um, yeah getting back on topic :lol:
I like orginal stories and adapted ones because it's nice to see something you enjoy reading brought to life on your television screen. But I can see where the people who don't like adapted stories are coming from because nothing is worse than seeing a watered down version of what you like on screen. Why bother too tackle the cool stuff if you can't give the content justice?
But with that said even when something has been "watered down" or given a new spin to it sometimes there are still merits to that make it good in it's own right. I loved Return to New York arc in the 2k3 even though it is a far cry to the awsomeness that was depicted in the comics. Like the ninja mystics and Baxter finnally betraying Shredder and getting all cocky and smug with him. There was some good gem in it despite the deviation and watering down of the orginal plot from the comics.
And any way I know that the majority doesn't want any more comic adaptions but I think I would really like to see the Savanti Bride issue adapted and see Renent become compentent and help the turtles. Also I would also like to see some of the dynamic between the Rat king and his terrorising Splinter come into play in the next season. Pretty unlikely since he will be spread across the world or what ever but a gal can dream. ;)
After 26 episodes of stand alones, I would like to see more depth in the new season. Seasons 1-4 had a lot of depth, and the episodes felt longer. FF felt like it blew by fast, however I do like FF.
I would like to see multiparters again as well.
-X-
Revan
06-01-2008, 03:21 PM
But with that said even when something has been "watered down" or given a new spin to it sometimes there are still merits to that make it good in it's own right. I loved Return to New York arc in the 2k3 even though it is a far cry to the awsomeness that was depicted in the comics. Like the ninja mystics and Baxter finnally betraying Shredder and getting all cocky and smug with him. There was some good gem in it despite the deviation and watering down of the orginal plot from the comics.)
Oddly enough, I prefered the 2k3 version of return to new york over mirage's original version. It seemed much more difficult for the turtles to infiltrate saki's fortress without Zog. They seemed to struggle through in the cartoon whereas it seemed to me in the book, they didn't as much. Just my opinion though
maryshine
06-02-2008, 06:58 PM
When you are watching the New toon of the ninja turtles do you prefere seeing content from orginal Mirage comics to be incorporated into the storylines or do you prefere seeing orginal ideas that give fresh or diffrent twists to the story telling of the ninja turtles?
Both as long it is filled with drama!
Bizzaro
06-05-2008, 09:01 PM
Both please.
Anything done well that works well and flows well makes me quite a happy Turtle fan.
Yep, I'd have to say both too. I can't go out and pick up a comic so I love getting to experience the whole City at War arc as well as the other stuff they threw in from the comics. But I also love their original ideas. Just give me plenty of season spanning story arcs and alot of action and I'll be happy. I think the 2k3 series is fantastic from beginning to end, so I guess it doesn't take much to please me.
clockstomper
06-05-2008, 09:23 PM
I think the first 4 seasons of 2K3 did it well, good individual episodes with a strong underlying continuity. I liked the episodes dealing with Master Yoshi's past adventures, especially. Ninja tribunal overdid it, too much time out of New York and the familiar cast, though I applaud it for correcting itself mid-way. It managed to bring the series to a good close, and tie off loose ends like Nano and the explanation for how Splinter and the Ancient One met (after Splinter's mutation and Yoshi's murder). Only Leatherhead and April's adventure with Renet were unaccounted for.
The Lost Season at least had the art style we were accustomed too and Michelangelo was written in-character. Fast Forward got rid of the Ninja elements and substituted in new supporting characters. I understand Playmates was behind this, in the interest of making new toys. It was a cruel gesture to the people who actually liked Fast Forward that they the went and canceled the toyline. A big "eff you" to anyone who liked the new spinoff continuity and it made pointless the abandonment of the old.
Eh, but that's the past. can't change it. They have to work on returning the emphasis on action and character and they'll be fine. It would be nice for them to touch on past characters like the Utroms, Leatherhead, Bishop and so forth.
thunderdragonwk
06-07-2008, 10:21 PM
They should have the Mona Lisa character in the new cartoon. If She was in there that would have been Sweet Cause She's Smokin Hot & she would Definately kick Shredder's Ass. Too bad she's not though But I bet that would be sweet...If you catch my drift.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.