View Full Version : The Adventures of Milo & Otis vs. TMNT (Part 4)
Andrew NDB
02-06-2008, 11:34 PM
Let's take it to the polls!
Revan
02-07-2008, 09:58 AM
Ha:lol: So TMNT was so kiddy that it compares to milo and otis!?
Drtooth
02-07-2008, 10:12 AM
Blame our moronic ratings system. I loved the movie and found it quite powerful, but it seemed they were so dead set to make it PG, it came out looking like G.
I remember hearing BS that the ratings system was slipping, so PG films were more like PG 13, and PG 13 was more like R. I call poppycock. But that was Warner's call. Somehow they didn't get the memo that Batman and Spiderman are both kid friendly (and preschooly merchandise of both existed prior to, during, and after the movies) but were both rated PG 13.
Revan
02-07-2008, 02:59 PM
^ I've actually noticed that in some movies in terms of sexual content and violence. PG13 can get a lot of that put into movie nowadays IMO. Am I wrong?
Dragon Turtle
02-07-2008, 03:20 PM
Ha:lol: So TMNT was so kiddy that it compares to milo and otis!?
Only in Andrew's fevered mind.:)
Blame our moronic ratings system. I loved the movie and found it quite powerful, but it seemed they were so dead set to make it PG, it came out looking like G.
I remember hearing BS that the ratings system was slipping, so PG films were more like PG 13, and PG 13 was more like R. I call poppycock. But that was Warner's call. Somehow they didn't get the memo that Batman and Spiderman are both kid friendly (and preschooly merchandise of both existed prior to, during, and after the movies) but were both rated PG 13.
In many cases, particularly when it comes to PG-13, I believe that it is true that you can get away with more stuff then you used to, but in certain cases the MPAA will go after certain movies with more zeal then others, namely a movie like TMNT, which has a strong reputation as being a kids property, the MPAA is quicker to slap a stronger rating on such a movie in order to protect the parents who are either too stupid or lazy to notice the ratings, and will take their children to see the movie and later complain to MPAA how inappropriate the movie was for their children. Even the fact the movie was scaled back in terms of violence, didn't stop one major newspaper from lambasting the MPAA for not giving TMNT a PG-13 rating.
One other thing about TMNT's rating was that, it had to be PG rated in order to secure a McDonalds Happy Meal deal, sad but true.:ohwell:
^ I've actually noticed that in some movies in terms of sexual content and violence. PG13 can get a lot of that put into movie nowadays IMO. Am I wrong?
No, you're right, PG-13 is a vast grey area, particularly when it comes to sex and violence, you can show a man get ground up into hamburger meat but as long as you don't say the F-word, your ok.:ohwell:
Kendamu
02-07-2008, 05:11 PM
One other thing about TMNT's rating was that, it had to be PG rated in order to secure a McDonalds Happy Meal deal, sad but true.:ohwell:
Which is total crap considering that Batman Returns was PG-13 and I remember getting McDonald's toys of that as a kid.
Mr._Mutant_Man
02-07-2008, 06:03 PM
I really don't get the complaints about a lack of mature content. I would have liked to have seen more violence, because I thought there was a lack of action in the beginning (the first movie had the fight scenes pretty well spread out). But I don't see the need for the violence to reach a level that wouldn't be appropriate for kids. I've read a good deal of volume 1 of Ninja Turtles and I don't see anything that's really ultra-violent. Maybe compared to the cartoon, but it isn't like you saw decapitations left and right and foot soldier's intestines spilling out as the blood splatters all over the Ninja Turtle's faces. In issue one there is some blood splattering here and there, but nothing I would really consider innapropriate for kids. I used to see worse in horror movies. I don't think gore is the key to good Ninja Turtles storytelling. The first movie was able to tell a good story just fine without showing Leonardo slicing people apart with his swords.
I'm pretty sure an R-rated Ninja Turtles would be a tough sell. PG-13 might even be pushing it, because the general audience sees the turtles as kid friendly. The first Ninja Turtles movie managed to find that balance.
Dragon Turtle
02-07-2008, 08:20 PM
Which is total crap considering that Batman Returns was PG-13 and I remember getting McDonald's toys of that as a kid.
Yeah, McDonalds and Warner Bros took alot of flak over the Batman Returns promotion, I wonder how much this past experience effected the decision to make TMNT PG, here is an old article about the Batman Returns promotion, notice the mention of the old TMNT movie (probably part 2) not being suitable for young children:lol::
http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,311012,00.html
I really don't get the complaints about a lack of mature content. I would have liked to have seen more violence, because I thought there was a lack of action in the beginning (the first movie had the fight scenes pretty well spread out).
Other then the lack of action and fighting, and a few eye-rolling "comedy" moments, TMNT is fine when it comes to how mature the content is.
I'm pretty sure an R-rated Ninja Turtles would be a tough sell. PG-13 might even be pushing it, because the general audience sees the turtles as kid friendly. The first Ninja Turtles movie managed to find that balance.
R-rated turtles would be financial suicide, but a PG-13 would be fine, there is a wide gap between lighter PG-13 movies and darker PG-13 movies, the first movie would definately be rated PG-13 if it was released today.
Mr. Stay Puft
02-07-2008, 08:27 PM
No, you're right, PG-13 is a vast grey area, particularly when it comes to sex and violence, you can show a man get ground up into hamburger meat but as long as you don't say the F-word, your ok.:ohwell:
Yet I recall Beetlejuice, which was rated PG, contained the f-word. To me, it seems like the rating system has been getting more strict over the years.
Kendamu
02-07-2008, 08:30 PM
The MPAA is part of the reason I'd like to see something TMNT made independently and set straight to DVD. TMNT'07 out-did the old TMNT 2 and TMNT 3 by a lot, but I'd still like to see more.
thebrownranger
02-07-2008, 08:46 PM
The MPAA is part of the reason I'd like to see something TMNT made independently and set straight to DVD. TMNT'07 out-did the old TMNT 2 and TMNT 3 by a lot, but I'd still like to see more.
Same here.:sleep:
Andrew NDB
02-07-2008, 09:27 PM
Ha:lol: So TMNT was so kiddy that it compares to milo and otis!?
Not exactly. But I honestly really, really do love Milo & Otis -- it's the flagship "talking animals" movie, and what people often don't realize about it is that it's actually a Japanese movie repackaged for American audiences... but still with all of its grit intact.
Look at the sequence with the bear and the cat. And the sequence with the dozens of seagulls pecking at Milo. And Milo jumping/being thrown several hundred feet down into the ocean -- no tricks, no CGI. It also, very dubiously, doesn't contain the usual "No animals were harmed in the making of this movie" that movies like this have.
And it actually had the balls to show unmarried talking animals of opposite sexes co-inhabiting. TMNT couldn't even show that with humans... even though it was in the story.
thebrownranger
02-07-2008, 09:45 PM
TMNT couldn't even show that with humans... even though it was in the story.
I know right.:lol: They were probably afraid that it would be pushing PG.
Dragon Turtle
02-07-2008, 10:41 PM
Not exactly. But I honestly really, really do love Milo & Otis -- it's the flagship "talking animals" movie, and what people often don't realize about it is that it's actually a Japanese movie repackaged for American audiences... but still with all of its grit intact.
Look at the sequence with the bear and the cat. And the sequence with the dozens of seagulls pecking at Milo. And Milo jumping/being thrown several hundred feet down into the ocean -- no tricks, no CGI. It also, very dubiously, doesn't contain the usual "No animals were harmed in the making of this movie" that movies like this have.
Even though nothing has ever been proven (one Japanese animal-rights group claimed 30 "Milos" had died), I wouldn't be shocked to learn that more then a few "Milos" and "Otises" met their demise during the filming of that movie.
And it actually had the balls to show unmarried talking animals of opposite sexes co-inhabiting. TMNT couldn't even show that with humans... even though it was in the story.
Casey and April were shown living together, anything beyond that and you're running the risk of getting an R rating.;)
Andrew NDB
02-07-2008, 11:18 PM
Casey and April were shown living together,
In Munroe's script they were. In the final movie, you have to read between the lines... only implied, not shown.
anything beyond that and you're running the risk of getting an R rating.;)
I know you're joking around, but ratings were never the consideration here -- there's no MPAA guideline in place where co-inhabitation increases a rating. Literally, it was probably just WB and their focus groups/committees (toys factoring in here somewhere) getting jittery about TMNT Part Four potentially offending someone. Anyone. Somewhere. Out there. You know.
Even though nothing has ever been proven (one Japanese animal-rights group claimed 30 "Milos" had died), I wouldn't be shocked to learn that more then a few "Milos" and "Otises" met their demise during the filming of that movie.
I wouldn't be surprised either... particularly the "Throw Milo 9000 feet into the ocean" bit where the cat is clearly afraid for his life. Milo at least does change in appearance pretty drastically over the course of the movie. Though, they really did shoot it over the course of several years... so naturally they'd have to use different cats.
Damn it. Forget about TMNT Part 5 (no, really... forget about it)... where is Milo & Otis II? I would pay good money to see that.
Drtooth
02-08-2008, 09:25 AM
One other thing about TMNT's rating was that, it had to be PG rated in order to secure a McDonalds Happy Meal deal, sad but true.:ohwell:
Pirates? of the Carribean? I bet 4Kids had their hand in it, being the licencee. Even still, I would have given the movie a G rating. There wasn't nearly enough violence or content to warrent a PG at all. And if it's the Casey and April living together stuff, I call BS on that one too:
Because the original idea was to have Casey propose to April at the end of the film.
I also blame those idiotic parental groups. No guns in cartoons, but you can sell toy guns at a toy store. That's a double standard if ever I saw one.
Dragon Turtle
02-08-2008, 02:25 PM
Pirates? of the Carribean? I bet 4Kids had their hand in it, being the licencee. Even still, I would have given the movie a G rating. There wasn't nearly enough violence or content to warrent a PG at all. And if it's the Casey and April living together stuff, I call BS on that one too:
Because the original idea was to have Casey propose to April at the end of the film.
The Pirates of the Carribean: Dead Man's Chest promotion was the last PG-13 movie based Happy Meal, McDonalds still had an exclusive deal with Disney back then, obviously Disney is more scary then any advocate group.
As for the Casey and April subplot, it may very well have just been removed by Monroe himself, considering how far along it got into development before being pulled.
I also blame those idiotic parental groups. No guns in cartoons, but you can sell toy guns at a toy store. That's a double standard if ever I saw one.
You can have guns in cartoons, they only need to be painted funny colors and make Star Wars sound fx when fired.:)
odupianist
02-08-2008, 02:28 PM
Classic example of movie ratings I like to use... Blues Brothers-1980-R, Blues Brothers 2000-1998-PG13
Revan
02-08-2008, 02:36 PM
Classic example of movie ratings I like to use... Blues Brothers-1980-R, Blues Brothers 2000-1998-PG13
What does that prove? the 1980's had the f word alot. the 1998 had nothing questionable in it
Andrew NDB
02-08-2008, 02:53 PM
Classic example of movie ratings I like to use... Blues Brothers-1980-R, Blues Brothers 2000-1998-PG13
Blues Brothers ( 1980 ): $57,229,890
Blues Brothers 2000 ( 1998 ): $14,089,198
In any case, you did notice that the content in the Blues Brothers 2000 was noticeably watered down from the original, right?
Janus Prospero
02-08-2008, 03:11 PM
You can have guns in cartoons, they only need to painted funny colors and make Star Wars sound fx when fired.:)
*pew pew*
He he...It's so true though. For the most part, firearms in cartoons are laser based ones. This is something that occured to me when I was watching GI Joe as a kid. And notice how the lasers only stun or knock down the person rather than slice right through them.
I do recall some slug throwers in a few cartoons like Gargoyles and Batman:TAS. But even those had their fair share of *pew pew*
Gargoyles in particular comes to mind as the main human character, Elisa Maza, is a cop and carries a handgun. And in the "gun safety" episode of the show she actually gets shot.
Revan
02-10-2008, 06:44 PM
I remember the spider-man cartoon had the guns shoot lasers instead of bullets. Even as a child I thought that was strange.
Spitfire
02-11-2008, 12:43 AM
How stoned were you when you came up with this comparison? Clearly TMNT needs to be compared to MVP 2: Most Vertical Primate.
http://www.totalobscurity.com/mind/outbursts/gfx/mvp2.jpg
I do recall some slug throwers in a few cartoons like Gargoyles and Batman:TAS. But even those had their fair share of *pew pew*
They always had real guns in Batman, and they never made off noises. Even in Batman Beyond they had guns with bullets sometimes, though they used laser as well but it made sense because it was the future.
Anyways yeah Batman TAS always had guns, no whacky lasers. Handguns, machine guns, umbrella guns, flame throwers, grenades, tranquilizer guns, acid shooting flowers, punching glove guns.
Man Batman kicked so much ass.
Lady Venus
02-12-2008, 05:03 PM
TMNTs would mopped the floor with Milo and Otis.
Andrew NDB
02-12-2008, 09:45 PM
TMNTs would mopped the floor with Milo and Otis.
Otis, you want to field this one?
http://www.iwannapet.com/pug.jpg
Sure, Andrew. I'll smack the sh*t out of those four green clowns. At least I got laid in my movie.
(chorus): We're gonna take a walk outside today, gonna see what we can find today. We're gonna take a walk outside today, gonna see what we can find today... On a pretty little farm, the sun comes up on a curious cat and a pug-nosed pup, a brand new life outside the door, follow your nose and go explore. Cuz (chorus). Such a great big world, it's all set up for a curious cat and a pug-nosed pup. Friends to meet, places to be, it's all so new and fun to see! And (chorus)!
Dragon Turtle
02-12-2008, 11:06 PM
Otis, you want to field this one?
http://www.iwannapet.com/pug.jpg
Sure, Andrew. I'll smack the sh*t out of those four green clowns. At least I got laid in my movie.
Shortly after these comments, Otis dissappeared from his Brentwood home, and has not been heard from since.
Despite this setback executive producer Masanori Hata has stated this recent development will not affect the production of "Milo and Otis 2: The Wondeful Journey."
"While we are all concerned for the well-being of No. 42...erm I mean Otis, we are confident he will miraculously return to the set tomorrow morning, happier and younger...erm I mean healthier, then before."
"Milo and Otis 2: The Wondeful Journey" reunites the beloved pair, Milo(a kitten) and Otis (a puppy), as they set fourth on new adventures, which include spirited hijinks at construction sites, industrial waste treatment plants, and a military weapons testing range.
CJStyles
02-13-2008, 05:57 PM
Ummm..... That's interesting
Warhorse
02-13-2008, 08:56 PM
Even the fact the movie was scaled back in terms of violence, didn't stop one major newspaper from lambasting the MPAA for not giving TMNT a PG-13 rating.
What newspaper was this complaining that TMNT should have been PG-13 because of it's violent content?
Dragon Turtle
02-13-2008, 09:29 PM
What newspaper was this complaining that TMNT should have been PG-13 because of it's violent content?
The Chicago Tribune, the reviewer was Michael Phillips who pops up frequently
on Ebert and Roeper, filling in for Ebert.
http://chicago.metromix.com/movies/review/movie-review-tmnt/168007/content
Revan
02-13-2008, 10:29 PM
The Chicago Tribune, the reviewer was Michael Phillips who pops up frequently
on Ebert and Roeper, filling in for Ebert.
http://chicago.metromix.com/movies/review/movie-review-tmnt/168007/content
Jeez Michael. Step into 2008 with us. This isn't 1960
Andrew NDB
02-13-2008, 11:03 PM
Sheesh, what do they want? Nobody was even hurt in TMNT Part 4. And beancounter spinelessness prevailing, Michelangelo didn't even use his weapons, for chrissakes (ironically, you have to buy the TMNT Part 4 video game to be able to see/use Mike's chucks).
Spitfire
02-14-2008, 04:46 AM
Actually in 1960 there wasn't PG-13 so it would have still been PG. Censors are worse now really I can see why he's whining.
Revan
02-14-2008, 08:40 AM
^ that wasn't really the point. I was simply making a joke about conservatives. I'm sure we can all agree that our culture has evolved since then. Just look at what women wear nowadays compared to back then
Dragon Turtle
02-14-2008, 03:31 PM
^ that wasn't really the point. I was simply making a joke about conservatives. I'm sure we can all agree that our culture has evolved since then. Just look at what women wear nowadays compared to back then
I'm not sure Micheal Phillips is a conservative, being uptight over movie violence seems to be bipartisan. Children entertainment prior to 1960 was far more violent then it is now(Looney Tunes, Tom and Jerry, ect...).
Unfortunately, critics like Micheal Phillips are more representative of current times, its no wonder Imagi is trying to steer the franchise into more comedic territory, given so many reviews either thought the movie was too violent for kids or was too serious for ninja turtles.
Check out the L.A. Times review:
http://www.calendarlive.com/movies/reviews/cl-et-tmnt23mar23,0,6697355.story
Kendamu
02-14-2008, 03:41 PM
If the TMNT movies do move into the comedic territory and had even less Ninja action than now and such, I would like it to at least be GOOD comedy and storytelling.
Revan
02-14-2008, 07:20 PM
Ok so just to clarify, Andrew. You are saying you thought Milo and Otis was a better all around movie than TMNT?
Slash
02-14-2008, 09:15 PM
This thread makes me miss that movie... compared to my copy of TMNT that will end up as a coaster in time. :)
Andrew NDB
02-14-2008, 10:03 PM
If the TMNT movies do move into the comedic territory and had even less Ninja action than now
Let's just stop right there. Just... stop.
Ok so just to clarify, Andrew. You are saying you thought Milo and Otis was a better all around movie than TMNT?
Absolutely.
This thread makes me miss that movie... compared to my copy of TMNT that will end up as a coaster in time. :)
Buy it again, man. You'll thank yourself (http://youtube.com/watch?v=YmuDLpzTdBY) for it.
Sage Ninja
02-14-2008, 11:05 PM
If the TMNT movies do move into the comedic territory and had even less Ninja action than now and such, I would like it to at least be GOOD comedy and storytelling.
are you feeling ok? I think you need to sit down and have a drink. :-?
Andrew NDB
02-14-2008, 11:14 PM
are you feeling ok? I think you need to sit down and have a drink. :-?
I think Goonga has had enough to drink. :) He's cut off.
Lady Venus
02-19-2008, 04:28 PM
Otis, you want to field this one?
http://www.iwannapet.com/pug.jpg
Sure, Andrew. I'll smack the sh*t out of those four green clowns. At least I got laid in my movie.
(chorus): We're gonna take a walk outside today, gonna see what we can find today. We're gonna take a walk outside today, gonna see what we can find today... On a pretty little farm, the sun comes up on a curious cat and a pug-nosed pup, a brand new life outside the door, follow your nose and go explore. Cuz (chorus). Such a great big world, it's all set up for a curious cat and a pug-nosed pup. Friends to meet, places to be, it's all so new and fun to see! And (chorus)!
As if, dude!
Revan
03-14-2008, 08:34 PM
It also, very dubiously, doesn't contain the usual "No animals were harmed in the making of this movie" that movies like this have.
looks like they tried to cover their rear with a half-@$$ed short message. Notice how they don't claim that no animals weren't harmed.:lol:
http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/000017.jpg
Look at the sequence with the bear and the cat. And the sequence with the dozens of seagulls pecking at Milo. And Milo jumping/being thrown several hundred feet down into the ocean -- no tricks, no CGI.
http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/milo-new.gif
It is cool though that a turtle:tthumbsu: ends up saving Otis. :lol::lol::lol:
http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/000014.jpghttp://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/000015.jpg
Andrew NDB
03-18-2008, 07:38 PM
On a sidenote, I just received the Japanese "The Adventures of Chatran" version of Milo & Otis and have now seen all the stuff cut from the American film.
Wow, there's some hardcore **** there I'll upload to Youtube later.
For one, where Otis fights the bear by the water, the bear is like whacking him around visibly, then throwing/pinning Otis by the neck against a log and the dog is screaming for help.
Another part, remember where Milo kept poking out of the dresser drawers at the other bear, playing peek-a-boo until the bear got fed up and left? Yeah, in the full version, the bear does get Milo finally, visibly biting his paw with the cat crying for help/in pain.
Also, a puzzling cut... after Milo does his 1000 foot drop to the ocean, the Japanese version actually shows him swimming out of the water just fine in the same shot. What was maybe a bit cruel that they cut, was Milo frantically trying to climp up the completely vertical rockface three times, continually falling back down into the ocean.
Other odds and ends here and there.
Revan
03-18-2008, 08:10 PM
I don't know if I even want to see that! That sounds terrible. How many animals died in the making?:lol:
Andrew NDB
03-18-2008, 10:29 PM
Also Milo's mom getting bit repeatedly by a snake and Milo puking after eating a poisonous mushroom.
Andrew NDB
03-19-2008, 12:04 AM
Also Milo hitching a ride on a horse with bags attached to it.
Milo & Otis drinking from big man-made cannisters of milk by another farm.
Otis finding Milo much earlier in the movie... up a tree rather than in a ditch.
Milo and Otis watching a baby cow get killed by crows.
Andrew NDB
03-22-2008, 04:23 PM
Some of the deleted scenes from the Japanese version:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=goix8a6xMok
http://youtube.com/watch?v=z2W_UbTAaw8
Revan
03-23-2008, 12:03 AM
dude, sad. sons of *****es being mean to Milo
SWAT_KAT_RAZOR
03-23-2008, 03:43 AM
Never liked Milo nor Otis. It seems the US gets watered down version of movies. I mean The Japanese have the best movies! Fist Of The North Star being one of them. You wouldn't see **** like that in the U.S. Yeah, they made an american version of the movie. Wasn't as good as the jap version thou. Japanese have more freedom when they're making movies. Hell the japs have like 3 death note movies. You won't see anything like that in the us because it'd be 'sending a bad message to the kids' Well.. Kids, if you can't distinguish what's real or what's not. Than **** you. Don't spoil it for the rest of us. You ignorant slapstick bastards.
Oh yeah.. 4Kids Dubbing Sucks. :P
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.