PDA

View Full Version : Who else has kinda given up hope for a sequal at this point?


CyberCubed
02-24-2008, 01:54 PM
Has anyone else just lost a lot of interest? Even if they announced a movie sequel tomorrow the earliest it would be in theaters is 2010, and by that point will the franchise even still be going strong?

Has anyone else just stopped caring in general? My biggest hope when the new movie was first announced was a possible trilogy, so we would have 3 live action movies and 3 CG movies...but at this rate we'll be lucky if we get just 2.

What are your thoughts?

gobo
02-24-2008, 02:17 PM
I think it's a safe bet that it's not yet out-of-the-question. There will come a rainy day yet that will present an adequate opportunity.

Cure
02-24-2008, 02:37 PM
I stopped caring as soon as I saw the movie.

triplexxx
02-24-2008, 02:48 PM
Either they'll eventually give some type of confirmation it will happen or it won't happen, until then, I'll make no assumptions.

thebrownranger
02-24-2008, 02:59 PM
I stopped caring as soon as I saw the movie.

Yeah me too

ToTheNines
02-24-2008, 03:19 PM
Has anyone else just lost a lot of interest?

Yeah, I don't let it bother me anymore.

Spitfire
02-24-2008, 04:15 PM
If it happens it happens. '09 is the year to do it if their smart. Keep in mind it takes a movie 2 years to be made when there's lots of legal problems to deal with. For all we know the 2nd movie has a script and just needs funding. I'm sure they could crank out a sequel in a year. They do it with those horrid SAW movies every year. Plus animation goes by as fast as the team you have working on it. If they have enough animators they could pull it off. Their just dicking around with it.

I could careless if the make another film, the movie toyline ruined the toys in my opinion, and the movie wasn't amazing or anything. It's popular though, hell I just saw an Ad in the Target paper that feature TMNT along side Transformers, Spider-man 3, and that Rat Chef movie. If memory serves me well those movies were quite the box office juggernauts so to see turtles along side that means the DVD sales must be doing well.

I wish they would put the money into an animated film. Batman Mask Of The Phantasm was amazing and it was in theaters, but something like that will never happen again.

GreasyBoi
02-24-2008, 04:38 PM
Yeah we've been waiting quite a long time for more announcements. They probably might not even make another movie, but I doubt it.

Mr._Mutant_Man
02-24-2008, 05:14 PM
Has anyone else just lost a lot of interest? Even if they announced a movie sequel tomorrow the earliest it would be in theaters is 2010, and by that point will the franchise even still be going strong?


I think the Ninja Turtles have shown that they can stand the test of time. They really haven't been that strong a franchise since Power Rangers stole their thunder, but even so they've still been able to maintain a certain amount of popularity through hardcore fans, nostalgia, and a decent enough revival attempt. I think if a sequel were to happen they could possibly expect the same amount of attention paid to the movie, unless they go all out and make it about Shredder and possibly other elements from the old cartoon.

I haven't really thought of a sequel all that much. Really the first one was the near perfect Ninja Turtle film to me, and after that one I'm pretty satisfied.

Andrew NDB
02-24-2008, 06:04 PM
There was no hope to begin with, soon as weekend #2 rolled around for TMNT Part 4 and the box office flatlined.

Knowing the direction Imagi wants to go in any potential TMNT Part 5 (comedic), it's absolutely for the best. Let it die until there's parties involved with the clout, balls, and heart in the right place in making a true comic book adaptation. It may take 10 years (or more), but better that than more toy bonanzas targeted at toddlers.

Buslady
02-24-2008, 06:16 PM
I'm not holding my breath. And it's not consuming me either. I'd like to see more but if we get it cool, if not...life goes on.

Dragon Turtle
02-24-2008, 06:25 PM
Has anyone else just lost a lot of interest? Even if they announced a movie sequel tomorrow the earliest it would be in theaters is 2010, and by that point will the franchise even still be going strong?

Has anyone else just stopped caring in general? My biggest hope when the new movie was first announced was a possible trilogy, so we would have 3 live action movies and 3 CG movies...but at this rate we'll be lucky if we get just 2.

What are your thoughts?

Since Imagi was given a four month extension, you probably won't here anything till April, especially since a gag has been placed on Steve Murphy.

Since Warner Bros pretty much greenlighted the sequel last summer, TMNT's boxoffice performance is not an issue.

A sequel financially means alot to both Imagi and Mirage, the only parties holding up the production of the sequel, a sequel will be done.

As for how relevant TMNT will be as a kids property three years from now is anyones guess, but even before the movie, the TMNT brand was showing signs of fading with younger audiences, that is why a sequel needs to aim for the older nostalgic crowd, just like every other 80's kids property.

Scandia
02-24-2008, 07:20 PM
I am more concerned about getting more seasons of the current cartoon.

Coola Yagami
02-24-2008, 08:08 PM
Honestly when I saw the ad back then saying TMNT in 2007 in 2005, I was thinking 'oh yeah right, as if the TMNT cartoon will last THAt long for fans to care...' and lo and behold we got like 4 seasons and Fast Forward and word for yet another season... So who knows? 2010?

Mr._Mutant_Man
02-24-2008, 09:22 PM
I am more concerned about getting more seasons of the current cartoon.

I'm mostly concerned with the comic book continuing. I heard they thought of ending Tales of the TMNT, just when I started to read it.:(

As long as the comics and hopefully the trades keep coming, I think I'd be pretty much content.

Masked Ninja
02-24-2008, 09:46 PM
I'm sure they could crank out a sequel in a year. They do it with those horrid SAW movies every year.And that's the reason why they're horrid, probably. The better animated movies take roughly four years to go from concept to finished film. It's because they spend time getting the kinks out of the story and plussing the animation.

Not like I can hope for that with a Turtles movie, because nobody seems to take it seriously enough. The last one was a decent effort, but not quite there yet. Y'know?

Splinter's Iroonna
02-24-2008, 10:04 PM
This is a no-win thread. The ones who have an ax to grind regarding the recent film will triumphantly announce to one and all that there is no way in hell that a sequel will take place. The ones who actually believe that there IS a pony in this room full of manure will insist that YES, it's GONNA happen!


I guess I must be listed with those who are digging through the pile of sh*t...


Once there was a mother with identical twins-- only one was extremely pessimistic, while the other just as insanely optimistic. So a Child Psychologist said "Let's put the pessimist in a room with brand new toys, and he'll learn that not everything is bad, and at the same time, we'll put the optimist in a room with horse sh*T-- and he'll learn that life is NOT always so good"

After a day, they entered the first room where the pessimistic twin sat in the center of the room-- not ONE toy had been played with.

"Why didn't you play with the toys?"

"Because I thought they would break!"

In the next room, they found the optimistic twin DIGGING through the pile of horse manure cheerfully...

Psy: WHY are you digging through all this mess?

Twin: Are you KIDDING??? With all this sh*t, there has GOT to be a pony in here somewhere!!!!

Leogeddon
02-24-2008, 10:28 PM
Hmmm... The way they end the movie, doesn't seem like a way to end a series of movies, the way they ended it was to open more opportunities for a sequel, why do that and not have a sequel? If anything, my guess is there will be just ONE sequel, if they try to match the popularity of the old movies, they may go for a third new movie, but the chances of that is slim since this generation of kids are into Spongebob Squarepants and Harry Potter. I personally think they should make it PG - PG-13 for the next movie with the return of Shredder. Why end it with simple Shredder? Why not Super Shredder?

...awww, now you see what you made me do? Get my hopes up! :(

Andrew NDB
02-25-2008, 02:25 AM
They do it with those horrid SAW movies every year.

And that's the reason why they're horrid, probably.

Saw II was horrid, but Saws III and IV (in reverse order, I think) actually very much surprised me in how clever they were. They're a guilty pleasure, for those who appreciate a clever little modestly-budgeted horror movie.

But wait, we're comparing Saw to TMNT Part 4?

The better animated movies take roughly four years to go from concept to finished film. It's because they spend time getting the kinks out of the story and plussing the animation.

Hell, they could spend 20 years on it but if the fundamental principles from the financiers guiding its basis are of a comedic, toy and toddler-pandering/driven nature it's going to be akin to the franchise shooting itself in the foot, and then the skulll.

Not like I can hope for that with a Turtles movie, because nobody seems to take it seriously enough.

The real crime is that TMNT Part 4 not only did nothing to change the idea of TMNT being something that can't be taken seriously (after two children's cartoons, toylines, napkins, cowabungas and pizza throwers, etc., completely in spite of the mature comic book that spawned it all that is entirely ignored), but reinforced it.

Setting things back again...

The last one was a decent effort, but not quite there yet. Y'know?

Mm-hm.

Slash
02-25-2008, 07:26 AM
After watching the Lost Season, and then looking at the movie, I realized that "TMNT" is virtually TNM to me.

Dragon Turtle
02-25-2008, 07:52 AM
The real crime is that TMNT Part 4 not only did nothing to change the idea of TMNT being something that can't be taken seriously (after two children's cartoons, toylines, napkins, cowabungas and pizza throwers, etc., completely in spite of the mature comic book that spawned it all that is entirely ignored), but reinforced it.

Setting things back again...





I disagree, while TMNT was not on the same level of maturity as the old Mirage comics it was hardly a throwback to the old cartoons or movies, in terms of tone it was more serious then the previous movies (too serious according to some), only the lack of violence and action is what kept TMNT a kid friendly PG movie.

And for being PG, the movie was a step in the right direction, maybe not as big of a step as you may like, in getting the turtles to be taken more seriously, realistically, you're not going to go from one end of the spectrum to another overnight.

gobo
02-25-2008, 09:11 AM
Psy: WHY are you digging through all this mess?

Twin: Are you KIDDING??? With all this sh*t, there has GOT to be a pony in here somewhere!!!!
:lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol::lol: My sides hurt. *wipes away a tear*

Kendamu
02-25-2008, 09:46 AM
And that's the reason why they're horrid, probably. The better animated movies take roughly four years to go from concept to finished film. It's because they spend time getting the kinks out of the story and plussing the animation.

Not like I can hope for that with a Turtles movie, because nobody seems to take it seriously enough. The last one was a decent effort, but not quite there yet. Y'know?
Ending "Tales" is epic fail when it comes to my wallet's relationship with Mirage.

As for a movie sequel, as fun as it would be to see it happen, I'd rather have the most fun by seeing it done right. None of this "We have to limit it to PG" crap. If that means direct-to-DVD, fine. If that means I have to order it directly from Mirage to get it, fine. I'm just tired of hearing "4 t3h childrenz" as an excuse for PG when properties like Transformers, Batman, and Spider-Man can get PG-13 movies as still be enjoyed by the "they better fscking get this right" older crowd and the "BUY ME THAT USELESS PIECE OF PLASTIC!" younger crowd.

So, if they do it right, I'd like to see it. However, I can wait awhile and put it in the back of my mind if that's what it takes to get it right. I think the animators and such doing the dirty work last time had their hearts in the right place. They just didn't have the creative freedom to get it done right.

I had one other point, but I'm multitasking and forgot what I was gonna say.

Drtooth
02-25-2008, 10:51 AM
As for a movie sequel, as fun as it would be to see it happen, I'd rather have the most fun by seeing it done right. None of this "We have to limit it to PG" crap. If that means direct-to-DVD, fine. If that means I have to order it directly from Mirage to get it, fine. I'm just tired of hearing "4 t3h childrenz" as an excuse for PG when properties like Transformers, Batman, and Spider-Man can get PG-13 movies as still be enjoyed by the "they better fscking get this right" older crowd and the "BUY ME THAT USELESS PIECE OF PLASTIC!" younger crowd.

Been saying that since last year. If we can have Baby Spiderman products (he's on ^%$# diapers now!) while a PG13 movie is out, they can sure as shell make the next one PG 13. Or at least make a PG a PG, not a souped up G. No kid's gonna go on a shooting rampage if Raphael says "Damn" more than once.

And think this way. There are movies that do terribly and have sequals. Not even justi DTV sequals. Actual, theatrical sequals. Was their any call for Daddy Day Camp? Even if they decide on a DTV release there WILL be a second film made. It's not an issue of of the distribution company (which would be the biggest stumbling block). it's an issue of Imagi and Mirage working over the plot line.

So even if it's just DTV, we will get a sequal IF Mirage and Imagi work it out. While TMNT didn't perform amazingly at the BO (due in part it was released a week before a Disney film and a pointless Will Ferrel comedy), it did generate enough merchandising interrest.

Tinuvielsdreams
02-25-2008, 01:04 PM
I am going to say that I think there is still a shot. Remember if Imagi is the studio that will continue to do TMNT in the future there are busy right now. They have projects lined up...Gatchaman, and astroboy just for example

It can take 2-3 years usually to put together an animated film especially when you are talking about the caliber of CGI they are going for. 2009 and 2010 are very reasonable time periods. Look how long we had to wait for this one, if the franchise keeps going (which I know is a big debate) I know we will see another film

Jester
02-25-2008, 01:48 PM
I'm gonna remain optimistic and say 2009 to go with the 25th Anniversary and have it based on the City at War comic arc!

Kendamu
02-25-2008, 01:55 PM
I disagree, while TMNT was not on the same level of maturity as the old Mirage comics it was hardly a throwback to the old cartoons or movies, in terms of tone it was more serious then the previous movies (too serious according to some), only the lack of violence and action is what kept TMNT a kid friendly PG movie.

And for being PG, the movie was a step in the right direction, maybe not as big of a step as you may like, in getting the turtles to be taken more seriously, realistically, you're not going to go from one end of the spectrum to another overnight.
This I can agree with. Even a decade after The Dark Knight Returns, there were still people running around humming the old 1960s Batman theme song.

Of course, none of them read comic books and we were all twelve years old at the time, but you get my point.

Drtooth
02-25-2008, 03:18 PM
Even still, it's in everyone's best interrest to see a film made. Playmates wants to see another toy line made, Mirage needs the TMNT publicity and money, ditto 4Kids and Imagi. Even Warners stands to make a gain from this, even though they have almost 0 success with animated feature films. It's not like there's no finanical reason for this to be made. And now that 4kids is running the Kid's WB block, TMNT will no doubt be around for 2010. I mean, it's 2008 right now and the next season/series premires this fall. So, 2008-2009... and no doubt we'd have another series announced next year so, that covers 2009-2010. All it needs is 2 more seasons for it to be relevant to the show.

Dragon Turtle
02-25-2008, 03:31 PM
I'm gonna remain obtimistic and say 2009 to go with the 25th Aniversary and have it based on the City at War comic arc!

It's conceivable a TMNT sequel could make it out for 2009, the development time for TMNT was 18 months, but I would much rather have them take their time and release it later in 2010, TMNT's story definately would have benefited from more development time.


Considering the 25th Anniversary is something that will only appeal to older fans, I would like to see a direct-to-dvd animated (2-D) feature, maybe using CaW as a basis, or a directors cut of TMNT based on the original script.

OA
02-25-2008, 04:23 PM
If there is a sequel, I'm betting it will go straight to video...

Aztec General
02-25-2008, 04:44 PM
As for a movie sequel, as fun as it would be to see it happen, I'd rather have the most fun by seeing it done right. None of this "We have to limit it to PG" crap. If that means direct-to-DVD, fine. If that means I have to order it directly from Mirage to get it, fine. I'm just tired of hearing "4 t3h childrenz" as an excuse for PG when properties like Transformers, Batman, and Spider-Man can get PG-13 movies as still be enjoyed by the "they better fscking get this right" older crowd and the "BUY ME THAT USELESS PIECE OF PLASTIC!" younger crowd.

So, if they do it right, I'd like to see it.

I agree 10,000%!!!!!!!!!!!

As for TMNT 4, it was really such a dual movie. There were parts of it that reminded me of the Mirage comics and the first film. The parts where Leo & Raph fight, where Leo goes off on his own to train, where Raph becomes a vigilante, where Casey ponders growing up, where Splinter talks to his children, where Karai tries to lead the Foot after the death of the Shredder. These parts felt right. They felt like TMNT to me, they felt mature, and they felt like the direction where the TMNT should be heading.

Then there were just the absolutely childish, stupid, absurd, and downright useless parts. These parts like the whole retarded 13 Monsters storyline, Max "needlessly immortal and completely uninteresting" Winters, the stone generals, and some of the more childish jokes.

Why can't this franchise be taken more seriously in the year 2008? Especially, as the above poster points out, after other franchises such as Spiderman, Batman, and Transformers (of all the franchises) have. It's infuriating.

In short TMNT was a mixed bag. Half of it was a true sequel to the first, and only great, TMNT film and the other half was Saturday morning cheese. In short: wasted potential.

As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.

GreasyBoi
02-25-2008, 04:51 PM
As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.

How do you know there won't be one?

OA
02-25-2008, 05:06 PM
How do you know there won't be one?

I pretty sure he's making an "educational guess"...

Kendamu
02-25-2008, 05:12 PM
I agree 10,000%!!!!!!!!!!!

As for TMNT 4, it was really such a dual movie. There were parts of it that reminded me of the Mirage comics and the first film. The parts where Leo & Raph fight, where Leo goes off on his own to train, where Raph becomes a vigilante, where Casey ponders growing up, where Splinter talks to his children, where Karai tries to lead the Foot after the death of the Shredder. These parts felt right. They felt like TMNT to me, they felt mature, and they felt like the direction where the TMNT should be heading.

Then there were just the absolutely childish, stupid, absurd, and downright useless parts. These parts like the whole retarded 13 Monsters storyline, Max "needlessly immortal and completely uninteresting" Winters, the stone generals, and some of the more childish jokes.

Why can't this franchise be taken more seriously in the year 2008? Especially, as the above poster points out, after other franchises such as Spiderman, Batman, and Transformers (of all the franchises) have. It's infuriating.

In short TMNT was a mixed bag. Half of it was a true sequel to the first, and only great, TMNT film and the other half was Saturday morning cheese. In short: wasted potential.

As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.
Thanks for backing me up. Looking at your point of view about TMNT 4, I waswondering: did you read the novelization? I read it before I saw the movie and I think that the novelization, as it leaves a lot of the imagination, makes a great story that was kind of "true to Mirage tone" while having elements of "true to Archie tone" in there as well.

sdp
02-25-2008, 07:02 PM
I didn't think the first one was going to do that good, so I thought at best it was a miracle to have this one new movie. The fact that we are still getting new toys based off the movie and that the series was renewed mostly because of the movie I do think a sequel could happen. I always knew the movie wouldn't come out for quite a while anyway 2010 earliest. Imagi has a lot of projects right now. TMNT hasn't really gotten that big since its "come back" so I don't really see people losing interest in fact we now have many movies that come out every 3 years that are aimed at children like Spider Man, Harry Potter etc.

Andrew NDB
02-25-2008, 07:28 PM
I agree 10,000%!!!!!!!!!!!

As for TMNT 4, it was really such a dual movie. There were parts of it that reminded me of the Mirage comics and the first film. The parts where Leo & Raph fight, where Leo goes off on his own to train, where Raph becomes a vigilante, where Casey ponders growing up, where Splinter talks to his children, where Karai tries to lead the Foot after the death of the Shredder. These parts felt right. They felt like TMNT to me, they felt mature, and they felt like the direction where the TMNT should be heading.

Then there were just the absolutely childish, stupid, absurd, and downright useless parts. These parts like the whole retarded 13 Monsters storyline, Max "needlessly immortal and completely uninteresting" Winters, the stone generals, and some of the more childish jokes.

Why can't this franchise be taken more seriously in the year 2008? Especially, as the above poster points out, after other franchises such as Spiderman, Batman, and Transformers (of all the franchises) have. It's infuriating.

In short TMNT was a mixed bag. Half of it was a true sequel to the first, and only great, TMNT film and the other half was Saturday morning cheese. In short: wasted potential.

As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.

Correct. On every point.

xmen510
02-25-2008, 08:25 PM
The last movie has made a fair amount of money from Box Office and DVD. I would bet we will see one at some point.

Dragon Turtle
02-25-2008, 08:28 PM
Then there were just the absolutely childish, stupid, absurd, and downright useless parts. These parts like the whole retarded 13 Monsters storyline, Max "needlessly immortal and completely uninteresting" Winters, the stone generals, and some of the more childish jokes.


The only thing wrong with the monsters/Winters plot was that it was underdeveloped, and knowing how much was cut out of the movie, that may be more by design then poor writing.

Really, the plot of the movie was more representative of the types of plots you got in the original Mirage comics, If anything, the movie plot is far less silly and outlandish then many of the stories in the first two volumes of the Mirage comics.




Why can't this franchise be taken more seriously in the year 2008? Especially, as the above poster points out, after other franchises such as Spiderman, Batman, and Transformers (of all the franchises) have. It's infuriating.


There is no reason why TMNT can't be taken serious, but I wouldn't compare TMNT with Batman or Spider-Man, those franchises have far more mainstream credibility then TMNT. Transformers (a movie more immature then TMNT), was backed by Spielberg, and Dreamworks and Paramount were desperate for a hit franchise, and were willing to gamble on what many people viewed as just an 80's toy fad.


TMNT was greenlighted based on the popularity of the new cartoon and the toy sales based on the cartoon, hence a movie aimed more at little kids.

Considering other nostalgia properties (G.I. Joe, Robotech, He-Man, ect.) will likely head down the PG-13 road after the success of Transformers, Warner Bros would be fools not to jump on the bandwagon.



As to a sequel in theaters, I'll keep this simple. There won't be one so forget about it.

Unless you have any solid arguments to support this claim, I'll just take it as wishful thinking on your part.

Andrew NDB
02-26-2008, 02:02 AM
The only thing wrong with the monsters/Winters plot was that it was underdeveloped, and knowing how much was cut out of the movie, that may be more by design then poor writing.

I won't deny that another 20 minutes or so of material making us swallow the monster/wacky bonanza thrust upon us would have been beneficial to the film... but it's still back asswards.

It's like... let's make Batman Begins Part 7. But let's make it with Guidomaxius, who needs to trap 20 demon bats in order to stop a global apocalypse. Between Robin burping and Batman jumping in Robin's arms when a particularly scary bat demon surprises them, they save the day.

No, it was just a flat-out wrong approach to the source material. Is it better than TMNT 2 and 3? Yes. Is it kind of approaching TMNT 1, even in a sideways, diluted kind of way? Mm, I can see that to some degree in the side-stories of TMNT Part 4, sure (the family story bits).

But it's a far effing cry from anything resembling a proper comic book adaptation of the source material.

Really, the plot of the movie was more representative of the types of plots you got in the original Mirage comics, If anything, the movie plot is far less silly and outlandish then many of the stories in the first two volumes of the Mirage comics.

Oh? Which ones, pray tell?

Let's break it down.

The first issue, we learn the Turtles have been raised since birth to one day grow up and assassinate Oroku Saki. They do so, Leonardo impaling Saki through the chest with both katana, then Donatello throwing him over the side of a skyscraper, Saki's own grenade blowing up next to him turning him into giblets.

The second issue deals with mousers, mostly the Turtles' introduction to April. Not a story arc in itself.

We move on a bit, the Turtles investigate TCRI and end up -- long story short here -- on the Triceraton homeworlds. It's a bit of a brutal mortal combat here, the Turtles fending for their lives. The Turtles kill their adversaries and we even see Don jamming his broken staff into the neck of a Triceraton for the win. They escape; the Utroms teleport them back.

We arrive at the Leo special (following the Raph special, an excellent and gritty intro to Casey), where Leonardo is beaten to a bloody pulp by a resurrected Saki/Shredder after killing a number of Foot himself. Moving on, the Turtles escape after April's Second Time Around Store is torched.

They make it to Northampton, where we see a touching story with the Turtles coping and reaffirming themselves in the countryside. At one point saving April from dying/freezing in the ice.

Next issue some NRA crazies are big-game hunting. They're dealt with.

Some random one-shots follow, but the issue with April and the Turtles at the farm (#11) marks the last Eastman & Laird collaboration until #19-21... "Return to New York." Teaming with Zog for a while, they kill truckloads of Foot, take out Saki's other worm clones, and then Leo cuts off Saki's head and his brothers burn the pieces over the Hudson.

That's it from Eastman/Laird until #50 (the issues in between just a musical chairs with different teams, hit or miss), which begins with the Shredder Elite Foot asserting themselves, beheading the old Foot to usurp command themselves. After a very, very bloody ordeal (the brutal gunning down of Karai's daughter, countless Foot slain, and other deaths), finally the last Shredder Elite is killed.

Shall we go to Volume 2?

All right, cards on the table. I don't like it. It's boring. But to actually examine it?

First we get Baxter. He's back. He carves his own head open and inserts his brain into a cyborg and eventually has a rematch with the Turtles that ends in him getting exploded into giblets. Some Triceraton throwbacks attempt to launch a final attack on Earth to a nuclear end... and granted it gets a little fuzzy with Louis (did it happen? was it a dream? did he warp reality, and if so, how?), but pretty much all the Turtles and their enemies in DARPA get atomized -- and viscerally.

So yeah... about the "weirdest" storyline out of all of the Eastman & Laird TMNT comics was the TCRI storyline which segwayed into the Triceraton encounter/arena/escape. Which for how off-the-wall it may sound, was played pretty straight... a hybrid of a gritty ninja movie, a late night sci-fi movie, and Gladiator... it worked, it was cool and it had balls.

TMNT Part 4? 13 wacky monsters in a Pokemon-esque "Gotta Catch'em All" plot, Mikey doing a 5 second burp for toddler giggles, Turtles literally leaping into each other's arms screaming in terror like something out of Looney Tunes, bloodless, toothless combat, Mikey not even being able to use his weapons... yeah, not feeling so much Eastman & Laird in that.

There is no reason why TMNT can't be taken serious

There's every reason. It's not fair, it's not right, and it's a shame that the beancounters can't see the forest for the trees (meaning, can't see the Mirage source material in spite of the made-for-children rubbish it spawned).

but I wouldn't compare TMNT with Batman or Spider-Man, those franchises have far more mainstream credibility then TMNT.

They do now. But at some point they still had to go from Point A to Point B. At some point Spider-Man crossed over from old children's cartoons with a campy theme song to a relatively mature movie... what are the real differences here?

A guy of Sam Raimi's caliber. Marvel behind him. People with clout, people able to do exactly the movie they wanted to do, with a keen understanding and respect of the source material.

Transformers (a movie more immature then TMNT), was backed by Spielberg

Well there you have your answer. Spielburg is a skeleton key for any movie.

A proper TMNT movie doesn't need a Spielburg, per se... but it does need someone with a little more Hollywood clout than a former video game director.

It's unfair, I know. And again, I know that had Kevin Munroe been given carte blanche to do exactly the most badass TMNT movie he could imagine and conjure up, we would have gotten something very, very different than what we saw in TMNT Part 4... but we still have what we have, at the end of the day and have to judge it as such.

TMNT was greenlighted based on the popularity of the new cartoon and the toy sales based on the cartoon, hence a movie aimed more at little kids.

You're probably right... and that's unfortunate. Shooting oneself in the foot usually is.

Considering other nostalgia properties (G.I. Joe, Robotech, He-Man, ect.) will likely head down the PG-13 road after the success of Transformers, Warner Bros would be fools not to jump on the bandwagon.

See, this is where I can't agree. A proper TMNT movie should have little to do with nostalgia -- not apart from some kind of vague name-recognition of "TMNT" or "Ninja Turtles." It should sell itself.

Akin to movies like Hellboy and Spider-Man, with a minimal amount of concessions it should burden itself with nothing more or less than being a true and proper comic book adaptation (or amalgamation) of the comic books.

If watchers of the children's cartoons want to jump aboard, great. If not, it should totally be able to stay afloat on its own laurels... and if it doesn't, it'll have failed totally of its own right. I don't know about you, but I can live with that.

Drtooth
02-26-2008, 12:24 PM
I still think the option to have it theatrically released is 50/50 at this point. It could go either way. It's not like TMNT was a huge budget film anyway. And I've seen a lot more films that didn't do that well at the BO get theatrical releases. Hell, there's gonna be a "Hoodwinked 2" at some point, and I'll be damned that doesn't get a theatrical release.

Dragon Turtle
02-26-2008, 01:04 PM
I won't deny that another 20 minutes or so of material making us swallow the monster/wacky bonanza thrust upon us would have been beneficial to the film... but it's still back asswards.

It's like... let's make Batman Begins Part 7. But let's make it with Guidomaxius, who needs to trap 20 demon bats in order to stop a global apocalypse. Between Robin burping and Batman jumping in Robin's arms when a particularly scary bat demon surprises them, they save the day.

No, it was just a flat-out wrong approach to the source material. Is it better than TMNT 2 and 3? Yes. Is it kind of approaching TMNT 1, even in a sideways, diluted kind of way? Mm, I can see that to some degree in the side-stories of TMNT Part 4, sure (the family story bits).

But it's a far effing cry from anything resembling a proper comic book adaptation of the source material.



Why? If you are strictly basing your argument on story content, then the storyline for TMNT, which at its heart is nothing more then your standard villain-gathers-objects-to-obtain-power comic storyline, easily fits into the world created in the original Mirage comics.

Using the Mirage comics as source for what should be in the movies, is a very tricky and subjective approach, you start to get into what stories are more popular vs the type of stories established throughout the series.

There is no doubt when looking back at the Mirage comics that the most iconic and popular storylines involve the turtles fighting the against Foot Clan on rooftops or thugs in backalleys, but the reality is these types of stories aren't the only ones in the old comics, they are not even the most common either. You can ignore the stories that take place after issue one and before City at War, you can devalue them by saying they were written by fill in writers, but they are still canon, stories that include aliens, time travel, magic, mutants, and other oddities.


As for the "comedy" aspects, they're fairly subdued, mostly regulated to Mikey who doesn't have much screen time anyway, and even well respected serious movies like "Spider-man" aren't immune to "humor", just try bringing up the subject of evil dancing Peter Parker in a Spider-Man forum.:)





There's every reason. It's not fair, it's not right, and it's a shame that the beancounters can't see the forest for the trees (meaning, can't see the Mirage source material in spite of the made-for-children rubbish it spawned).


I understand where you're coming from, I can understand the frustration Mirage comicbook fans feel toward various interpretations of the ninja turtles, but the Mirage comic has long since been replaced in the minds of the mainstream public by the old cartoon, which leads us into the next point...




They do now. But at some point they still had to go from Point A to Point B. At some point Spider-Man crossed over from old children's cartoons with a campy theme song to a relatively mature movie... what are the real differences here?

A guy of Sam Raimi's caliber. Marvel behind him. People with clout, people able to do exactly the movie they wanted to do, with a keen understanding and respect of the source material.


Spider-Man, Batman, and other Marvel/DC properties have always enjoyed more mainstream credibility then TMNT, those are usually consider classic and iconic figures in American popculture, when people think about those characters they think about the comics, not about the cartoons they spawned. And as comicbooks moved from the golden age to the silver age and then to the 80's and onward, people got used to idea that you can have a serious tv or movie based on a comicbook.

This is not the case with TMNT, most people know only the old cartoon, few people in the mainstream public know TMNT was originally based on a comic, and even fewer people have read those comics. Comicbooks such as Spider-Man and Hellboy never produced cartoons that surpassed the popularity of the original comics.

Lets just imagine if TMNT 4 was made into a movie that greatly resembled the Mirage comics instead of the one we did get, the quality of the movie wouldn't even be an issue, it would still get hammered by the largest TMNT fanbase (fans of the old cartoon), it would be rejected by the mainstream(what twisted minds would turn a kid property into this?), it would be like releasing the last Harry Potter book right after the first one.

Don't believe me? Just look at the backlash the "kiddy" TMNT has recieved, enough to have Imagi attempting to turn the sequel into a comedy.


If anything, there should have been a few more nods to the old cartoon in the recent movie, afterwards, you can start moving the franchise back toward its roots with the sequels.

Kendamu
02-26-2008, 01:06 PM
The more I think about it, the less I have to give up on. We'd probably know more if Murph hadn't been silenced under threat of 'cement shoes' from 4Kids and Imagi.

Noah'Dib
02-26-2008, 02:14 PM
I'm mostly concerned with the comic book continuing. I heard they thought of ending Tales of the TMNT, just when I started to read it.:(

As long as the comics and hopefully the trades keep coming, I think I'd be pretty much content.

Agreed. I'm first and foremost for the comics. As for the movie and the dung I'm apparantly wading through, I have to say they WILL make one. It may not be anytime soon, but if hollywood could bring Rocky & Indiana Jones out of retirement, they could (and will) make another TMNT. It just might be some time. Hey, it only took 2 1/2 decades for Indy to come back.

Dr. Doom
02-26-2008, 05:40 PM
I really think everyone here overestimates just how many dedicated adult TMNT fans there are out there. Let's be honest, a large portion of our population here on the Technodrome has the maturity level, people skills, and grip on reality of a 5 year old as it is. TMNT thrives on the younder audience, and that's why we get what we do. I don't understand why people can't comprehend the fact that they need to market this stuff to kids in order to have any sort of success at all. There's no way TMNT could be at the same level as Spider-Man or Batman, because when it comes down to it, things like that are just frankly more grounded in reality and easier to take seriously than a property about 4 giant turtles who practice a somewhat bastardized form of martial arts.

Don't get me wrong, I love TMNT just as much as the next sane person here, and just like many others here, I'd love the makers of a film to take the source material just as seriosuly as I do and give me something that I can appreciate above anything else as an adult, but I know what TMNT is, and I know what we are. We're not the juggernaut of untapped financial output that people here seem to think we are. We're a cult following. You can throw Transformers at me if you want, and yes, that's coming from a similar place, but it's got a completely different angle, and one that's a lot easier for studios and producers to market towards people today in order to make it a bazillion dollar franchise, especially when you can get car companies involved. Audiences love cool cars and **** blowing up and giant robots who act like ****ing retards, so there you have it's success. TMNT is not the kind of property that can get the same reaction, and frankly I don't want TMNT to get taken in the direction that Transformers did, because that movie ****ing sucked. We'd end up with a movie about teenagers who discover the Turtles in a crashed meteorite and we'd then proceed to be regaled with humans talking to each other for 90 minutes while the 4 guys danced around in the background like assholes and advertised soft drinks while simultaneously offending any intelligent people who happened to be watching such a monstrosity.

I for one thought TMNT was a great film, despite its shortcomings, because it gave us a taste of the franchise on the big screen and in a large, epic scale once again. That really made me happy, I think Kevin did a great job. But it got there because the new cartoon was something that 4Kids and playmates realized they could direct at kids once again and make money that way. If the franchise didn't have that appeal, we would have never gotten the 2K3 cartoon in the first place and the last taste of TMNT media outside of volume 4 we would have had would be The Next Mutation, and everyone would still be stuck on how awful that was with the exception of a few lunatics who touch themselves to Venus' hawt plastron bumps.

In short, don't hold your breath for the franchise to be taken as seriously as we all want it to be, because while we're certainly a part of why any of this is possible, we're not the bulk of it. That's the parents who bring their kids to the movie and go buy them the action figures and happy meal toys and party favors and fruit snacks afterwards. They're the bread and butter. I'd love to see another movie in theaters, and I guess it's not impossible, but they don't stand to make like OMGWTF summer blockbuster money from it even as a kids' film, much less as a nod to the dedicated cult following who severely overestimate their significance to the people who see TMNT only as something to make money off of.

Kendamu
02-26-2008, 07:05 PM
I'm not exactly sure. When I saw TMNT there weren't any children in the theater. The theater consisted of adult fans, teenage fans, and young teens who are riding the "oldschool stuff is cool" fad that's still going on right now who wanted to see what exactly they were wearing on their t-shirts at school the other day.

I know plenty of children saw the movie. I'm glad they did! However, I think being limited to PG (rather than allowing themselves to slip into a low PG-13) and having runtime restraints that caused some neat things to be cut for time really killed some of the things that would've kept the older fans more interested so they would walk out of the theater saying "Okay, so it wasn't like the OT but it was still pretty cool" rather than going "gawd t3h sux no beebop nad roxteddy!!!11" and "ware iz buhnilla ice?!?!!!1"

Though a lot of people are looking for TMNT 1990 to happen all over again, I can't speak for all of them. I just think that a little more creative freedom would make it more interesting for older viewers while not having to abandon the kiddie aspect of the franchise. While I know Kevin and crew tried their hardest to give both crowds what they wanted, they didn't get enough creative freedom MPAA-wise and runtime-wise to allow that to happen and, in the end, a lot of the older viewers felt abandoned.

Personally speaking, though, I wouldn't mind seeing TMNT movies that had stylistic similarities to Issue 18 (http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/mirage/volume01/18/18.htm) or Issue 41 (http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/mirage/volume01/41/41.htm) (both Vol. 1) or Archie TMNT 42 (http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/archie/42/42.htm) through 44 (http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/archie/44/44.htm). Maybe a mixture of those writing styles, even! The Vol. 1 stuff could easily be tweaked in tiny places to fit PG by MPAA standards and TMNT Adventures was written toward children in the first place!

Don't get confused, though. I'm not asking for a direct rip of those stories. I'm just talking about the general writing style and how everything was depicted. I think those are good examples of stories that TMNT fans of different ages can more easily enjoy without having to give up any creative freedoms. Maybe if those and others like them were used as general examples, a movie that can be enjoyed equally by people of all ages can enjoy could more easily be created while keeping WB and the MPAA happy.

Andrew NDB
02-26-2008, 07:31 PM
Using the Mirage comics as source for what should be in the movies, is a very tricky and subjective approach, you start to get into what stories are more popular vs the type of stories established throughout the series.

There is no doubt when looking back at the Mirage comics that the most iconic and popular storylines involve the turtles fighting the against Foot Clan on rooftops or thugs in backalleys, but the reality is these types of stories aren't the only ones in the old comics, they are not even the most common either. You can ignore the stories that take place after issue one and before City at War, you can devalue them by saying they were written by fill in writers, but they are still canon, stories that include aliens, time travel, magic, mutants, and other oddities.

Actually no... Peter Laird has pretty much un-canonized every story that didn't involve... Peter Laird.

In any case I see the point you're trying to make (and there's been awesome stories with "oddities" like time travel and magic and such)... but the forest you're not seeing for the trees is that these stories were told straight out. No gimmicks, no Turtles jumping into each others' arms, no blatant kid/toy-pandering moments or cringe-worthy dialogue.

As for the "comedy" aspects, they're fairly subdued,

Yeah, you and I pretty much didn't watch the same movie. No offense.

mostly regulated to Mikey who doesn't have much screen time anyway, and even well respected serious movies like "Spider-man" aren't immune to "humor", just try bringing up the subject of evil dancing Peter Parker in a Spider-Man forum.:)

Meh, I had no problem with Dancing Evil Parker in the context of the films, but whatever. I'm not a Spider-Man fan so I don't judge.

I understand where you're coming from, I can understand the frustration Mirage comicbook fans feel toward various interpretations of the ninja turtles, but the Mirage comic has long since been replaced in the minds of the mainstream public by the old cartoon,

That's... crazy. First of all, the "mainstream public" has no idea the TMNT comics even exist for it to have somehow been imaginarily "replaced" by the cartoons. Second... why should they? Until there is a mainstream, proper comic book adaptation of the source material, the Mirage comics will never have any mainstream public appeal.

Spider-Man, Batman, and other Marvel/DC properties have always enjoyed more mainstream credibility then TMNT,

This is much ado about nothing. The credibility was earned.

those are usually consider classic and iconic figures in American popculture, when people think about those characters they think about the comics, not about the cartoons they spawned.

Do they? You go up to most kids and go "Superman!" and they're probably thinking about that boring movie with the guy doing the Hackman impression, or Smallville, not comic books.

But you're kind of going on a tangent here.

And as comicbooks moved from the golden age to the silver age and then to the 80's and onward, people got used to idea that you can have a serious tv or movie based on a comicbook.

This is not the case with TMNT, most people know only the old cartoon, few people in the mainstream public know TMNT was originally based on a comic, and even fewer people have read those comics.

Much ado about nothing. Just because the last and most prevalent thing in the media has been one thing (kid fluff) doesn't mean TMNT as a franchise needs to be a slave to it indefinitely. Did anyone know who the eff the Crow was before the Brandon Lee movie? Hellboy, before... Hellboy? Did it matter who or what they were before?

A proper TMNT movie shouldn't concern itself with any existing vestige of the fandom apart from the comic fans themselves , and even then they shouldn't go out of their way to give those comic fans a handjob... just concern themselves with doing a proper movie -- reboot, total clean page -- in the same spirit and grit of those original TMNT comics with whatever artistic flair (such as directors with a vision do when they're allowed to go balls-out) they want to add to the mix.

Better to do this than continue TPTB's never-ending perpetual cycle of putting TMNT crap on the screen that kids keep outgrowing. And it's not hard... they just need to look to the comics, or attempt something in that vein.

It might be one thing if it were the other way around... if the comics that spawned it all were kiddy, goofy, camp affairs and that later on the movies and cartoons went the opposite way (more serious)... but it's not. You look to the beginning, the TMNT are quintessentially the polar opposite of where they are in the "mass media"... I say let's give those original TMNT a crack in the mass media and give it at least the chance to fail -- it deserves it, and TMNT has never had one yet.

Comicbooks such as Spider-Man and Hellboy never produced cartoons that surpassed the popularity of the original comics.

Well that's a pretty broad statement... I'm pretty sure the millions and millions of readers of Spider-Man over the past some-odd decades would probably beg the differ. I'm certain the movie did kick Spider-Man "awareness" up to the Nth degree, sure. But Hellboy? It was a niche comic with a niche following that spawned a movie with a modest success... seemed about relative to me.

Lets just imagine if TMNT 4 was made into a movie that greatly resembled the Mirage comics instead of the one we did get, the quality of the movie wouldn't even be an issue, it would still get hammered by the largest TMNT fanbase (fans of the old cartoon),

F***'em. Let them sate their nostalgia for the children's cartoons on DVD.

it would be rejected by the mainstream(what twisted minds would turn a kid property into this?),

F***'em, too. It's not the TMNT's fault said people are uneducated about the Turtles' creation as a mature enough comic book.

it would be like releasing the last Harry Potter book right after the first one.

Eh, what? I don't think we're talking apples to apples anymore.

Don't believe me? Just look at the backlash the "kiddy" TMNT has recieved, enough to have Imagi attempting to turn the sequel into a comedy.

*cough**box office**cough*

If anything, there should have been a few more nods to the old cartoon in the recent movie, afterwards, you can start moving the franchise back toward its roots with the sequels.

Isn't that kind of like sitting someone in a chair, spinning them around until they're so dizzy they can't see, then expecting them to walk a straight line?

Andrew NDB
02-26-2008, 07:42 PM
I really think everyone here overestimates just how many dedicated adult TMNT fans there are out there.

A proper comic book TMNT adapation on the big screen would make adult TMNT fans.

But TMNT Part 4 set any hope of that motion back another 10 years, at least.

Let's be honest, a large portion of our population here on the Technodrome has the maturity level, people skills, and grip on reality of a 5 year old as it is.

How true. Which is why they really shouldn't bother themselves with any of the existing fandom -- 99% of TMNT fans will see any TMNT movie that they put out there anyway... so why not finally make one that's true to the source material?

Dr. Doom
02-26-2008, 08:06 PM
A proper comic book TMNT adapation on the big screen would make adult TMNT fans.

Who's to say they'd go see it in the first place if they weren't already fans? Marketing can only do so much, and I'm not confident that TMNT could be marketed well to adults who aren't already interested in it.

How true. Which is why they really shouldn't bother themselves with any of the existing fandom -- 99% of TMNT fans will see any TMNT movie that they put out there anyway... so why not finally make one that's true to the source material?

Why would they have to if the fans will just go see whatever anyways?

Andrew NDB
02-26-2008, 08:14 PM
Who's to say they'd go see it in the first place if they weren't already fans? Marketing can only do so much,

Marketing can do plenty. The campaigns for 300 and Cloverfield made people go crazy for those movies without knowing much about them at all.

A broad example, I know.

and I'm not confident that TMNT could be marketed well to adults who aren't already interested in it.

It's a bit of a challenge, granted, and it's moot anyway... if the first TMNT trilogy (moreso the latter two movies), NT:TNM, and the first cartoon and general "Turtlemania!" craze of the late 80s and early 90s kind of hammered into pop culture this nail of "TMNT is for Kids"... in the 10 years or so between then and TMNT Part 4, that nail got loosened a little bit. New generations of kids had come and gone, with only old-timers like you and I really having any memory of those days (and we're barely even in the target demographic of films at large anymore). So what do they do? Rather than seize the opportunity to let the nail finally fall out and start fresh or pull it out, they grab a hammer and nail it back down with TMNT Part 4... so we're back to the mass media idea of "TMNT is for Kids" for another decade or so.

And before anyone cites the 4Kids cartoon (which is good, and gets about as much mileage out of comic book stories as you can in, well, a children's cartoon... but let's not fool ourselves into thinking it's anything but)... look at the brand label itself. 4Kids. Need I say more?

Why would they have to if the fans will just go see whatever anyways?

Well, to touch on only one thing, because one would hope they'd learn from history. They've tried to dumb down the Turtles for toddlers and tweens, and offer it up as such... yet kids keep outgrowing it, forcing them to perpetuate this never-ending, self-destructive cycle of cashing in on one generation of kiddies and tykes, then putting it on ice after it fails, then going after another generation of kiddies and tykes... who all end up inevitably outgrowing it. Why do this over and over again, when they can attempt to do something that folks don't need to outgrow? Something that is... actually somewhat mature? I'd agree it's a stretch, except for the simple fact that the TMNT were created as a mature comic book, day one.

Dragon Turtle
02-26-2008, 09:28 PM
Don't get me wrong, I love TMNT just as much as the next sane person here, and just like many others here, I'd love the makers of a film to take the source material just as seriosuly as I do and give me something that I can appreciate above anything else as an adult, but I know what TMNT is, and I know what we are. We're not the juggernaut of untapped financial output that people here seem to think we are. We're a cult following. You can throw Transformers at me if you want, and yes, that's coming from a similar place, but it's got a completely different angle, and one that's a lot easier for studios and producers to market towards people today in order to make it a bazillion dollar franchise, especially when you can get car companies involved. Audiences love cool cars and **** blowing up and giant robots who act like ****ing retards, so there you have it's success. TMNT is not the kind of property that can get the same reaction, and frankly I don't want TMNT to get taken in the direction that Transformers did, because that movie ****ing sucked. We'd end up with a movie about teenagers who discover the Turtles in a crashed meteorite and be we'd then proceed to be regailed with humans talking to each other for 90 minutes while the 4 guys danced around in the background like assholes and advtertised soft drinks while simultaniously offending any intelligent people who happened to be watching such a monstrosity.


There is no shame in cashing in on nostalgia, all those kids that grew up on the old cartoon are anywhere between their late teens to early thirties, a prime target audience, it was those same nostalgic Transformer fans that went to go watch that movie 5-6 times, there are plenty of old ninja turtle fans to take advantage of (we are talking about 5-6 billion dollar franchise). As for the casual fan who could care less about the ninja turtles, you need hype and spectacle to get those people to even remotely care about a TMNT based movie, and the current movie had neither of these.





Yeah, you and I pretty much didn't watch the same movie. No offense.


I guess not, no offense taken.


Meh, I had no problem with Dancing Evil Parker in the context of the films, but whatever. I'm not a Spider-Man fan so I don't judge.


I guess it makes perfect sense that evil impulses would cause one to have the urge to boogie down.:roll:



That's... crazy. First of all, the "mainstream public" has no idea the TMNT comics even exist for it to have somehow been imaginarily "replaced" by the cartoons. Second... why should they? Until there is a mainstream, proper comic book adaptation of the source material, the Mirage comics will never have any mainstream public appeal.


You're right, the Mirage comics never had mainstream appeal, only the cartoon.





Do they? You go up to most kids and go "Superman!" and they're probably thinking about that boring movie with the guy doing the Hackman impression, or Smallville, not comic books.


So you are saying kids don't know that Superman is based on a comicbook character, un-huh, well try asking any adult on the street who characthers like Spider-Man, Batman, Superman are, I qurantee you they will tell you they are comicbook characters, ask the average adult on the street who the ninja turtles are they will tell you they are cartoon/videogame characters.





But you're kind of going on a tangent here.



You asked what the difference was between Spider-Man making the jump from campy cartoons to relatively mature movies, asked and answered.



Much ado about nothing. Just because the last and most prevalent thing in the media has been one thing (kid fluff) doesn't mean TMNT as a franchise needs to be a slave to it indefinitely. Did anyone know who the eff the Crow was before the Brandon Lee movie? Hellboy, before... Hellboy?


It's not about awareness, comics like the Crow and Hellboy have it easy, since they are not competing against more popular alternate versions of themselves, they just had the comics.





It might be one thing if it were the other way around... if the comics that spawned it all were kiddy, goofy, camp affairs and that later on the movies and cartoons went the opposite way (more serious)... but it's not. You look to the beginning, the TMNT are quintessentially the polar opposite of where they are in the "mass media"... I say let's give those original TMNT a crack in the mass media and give it at least the chance to fail -- it deserves it, and TMNT has never had one yet.


I have no problem with seeing a more faithful adaption of the old comics brought to big screen, and I would hope it would succeed, but just don't act surprise if gets ripped apart by the older cartoon fans and flops because it's not what most people are accustomed to when comes to the ninja turtles.




Well that's a pretty broad statement... I'm pretty sure the millions and millions of readers of Spider-Man over the past some-odd decades would probably beg the differ. I'm certain the movie did kick Spider-Man "awareness" up to the Nth degree, sure. But Hellboy? It was a niche comic with a niche following that spawned a movie with a modest success... seemed about relative to me.



umm, I believe you misread me, I said "never".



F***'em. Let them sate their nostalgia for the children's cartoons on DVD.


Heh, I'm pretty sure there are old cartoon fans saying the same thing about comic readers, "F***'em, let them reread their old comics, the 80's cartoon is the only version that matters".:)


Eh, what? I don't think we're talking apples to apples anymore.


Just using HP to illustrate the difference between the more kid friendly first book with the last one where everyone is getting killed off, as the books progressively got darker, imagine if they went from one extreme to another.



*cough**box office**cough*


Yes, there are those within Imagi/Warner Bros who believe TMNT was too dark and serious and it had a negative effect on the boxoffice, and that the sequel should be more lighter and silly, I'm glad we can agree on this.





Isn't that kind of like sitting someone in a chair, spinning them around until they're so dizzy they can't see, then expecting them to walk a straight line?

You would be surprise how little it would take to please fans of the old cartoon, I don't see the harm in acknowledging the fans who, like it or not, help to keep the ninja turtles alive today.




It's a bit of a challenge, granted, and it's moot anyway... if the first TMNT trilogy (moreso the latter two movies), NT:TNM, and the first cartoon and general "Turtlemania!" craze of the late 80s and early 90s kind of hammered into pop culture this nail of "TMNT is for Kids"... in the 10 years or so between then and TMNT Part 4, that nail got loosened a little bit.


Loosened? how, because they were off the radar? I can tell you alot of the buzz surrounding the movie was from fans expecting TMNT to be closer to old cartoon and they were happy because of it, "they have to have Krang!!", "No Bebop or Rocksteady, this movie sucks!!". And the 4Kids cartoon re-established TMNT as a kids property before the movie.

Coola Yagami
02-26-2008, 09:57 PM
Yo Andrew, you kinda forgot all the weird 'what were they smokin' stories Eastman and Laird did. I know that after Return to New York, the series went to 'guest-writers' hell before the comic got more serious with City at War, but you forgot the stories that took place in between the Turtles facing Shredder and Return to New York.

All the stories about Nobody, Leatherhead, Rennet, the Passing, the Kirby cyrstal Don Special, Justice Force and such were all extremely weird and wacky, especially yhe Rennet ones. And c'mon... in Return to New York did you ever expect the TMNT to side with a Triceraton to take down the Foot.. and to run into 3 weird-as-all-hell Shredder clones?

I agree that the 13 monsters story was out of left field, and in my opnion didn't really have any business in the movies, but yeah... the turtles in the comics was full of crazy stuff too. We've seen the TMNT in New York as is, maybe in a new movie we should see some Triceraton invasion stuff...

Jo Dawn
02-26-2008, 11:23 PM
It might be one thing if it were the other way around... if the comics that spawned it all were kiddy, goofy, camp affairs and that later on the movies and cartoons went the opposite way (more serious)... but it's not. You look to the beginning, the TMNT are quintessentially the polar opposite of where they are in the "mass media"... I say let's give those original TMNT a crack in the mass media and give it at least the chance to fail -- it deserves it, and TMNT has never had one yet.

Totally. Agreed.

Please!! It DOES deserve it. I wish the actual TMNT would have a chance to shine. In the right hands, and done in the right way, it would be HUGE. TMNT doesn't have to be silly. It can be a cool movie. TMNT isn't for kids. Heck, not all kids NOW like the old toon. A 6 year old told me last Sunday that he hates the old toon because it's too silly. He likes the new toon (not much better) or the comics or first movie.

And not all people in that age range for the old toon WANT to see it ever again.

My plea to those that are in charge... Just give the REAL TMNT a chance.

Jo Dawn
02-26-2008, 11:28 PM
Loosened? how, because they were off the radar? I can tell you alot of the buzz surrounding the movie was from fans expecting TMNT to be closer to old cartoon and they were happy because of it, "they have to have Krang!!", "No Bebop or Rocksteady, this movie sucks!!". And the 4Kids cartoon re-established TMNT as a kids property before the movie.

Uh, not really. Not around here, at least. People were kinda hoping for more. Like, going away from old toon tendencies.

...though I guess that explains why they can't sell an old toon DVD for anything here, either.




There is no reason why TMNT can't be taken serious, but I wouldn't compare TMNT with Batman or Spider-Man, those franchises have far more mainstream credibility then TMNT.

Well, we have the old toon to blame for that, don't we? It's kinda like they sold their soul for the one big hit and it's gonna haunt them forever by ruining any chance they had to BE credible. Why do we think TMNT isn't credible? I'd say if we got rid of the kiddie stigma, it'd be quite easy.

I disagree, while TMNT was not on the same level of maturity as the old Mirage comics it was hardly a throwback to the old cartoons or movies, in terms of tone it was more serious then the previous movies (too serious according to some), only the lack of violence and action is what kept TMNT a kid friendly PG movie.

It was in no way too serious. When I went to see it people were disappointed with how silly it was and wanted a more serious tone. No one laughed. They left and I heard whispers about how it had 'regressed'.

Dragon Turtle
02-26-2008, 11:44 PM
Uh, not really. Not around here, at least. People were kinda hoping for more. Like, going away from old toon tendencies.



Mostly on sites dedicated to following movies.


It was in no way too serious. When I went to see it people were disappointed with how silly it was and wanted a more serious tone. No one laughed. They left and I heard whispers about how it had 'regressed'.


And I've read and heard opinions to the contrary,"not enough pizza and cowabunga" and "it lacks the goofy charm of the originals", that pretty much balances it out.

Jo Dawn
02-26-2008, 11:52 PM
Mostly on sites dedicated to following movies.

Yeah, but what about real people that actually went to see the movie? All that I heard was that they wanted away from kiddie and more adult. And I heard that with my own ears. People can type what they want, but I'll let what I know for a fact by experiencing, and the obvious drop in the box office at week 2, after people actually saw it.

They really need to give the real TMNT a chance now. Though I think it's too late to salvage, they have nothing to lose. And it would be admirable if they made the movie that they really wanted to make. Make the movie for them, and if it bombs, then at least they had the balls to try it.

Andrew NDB
02-27-2008, 12:00 AM
There is no shame in cashing in on nostalgia, all those kids that grew up on the old cartoon are anywhere between their late teens to early thirties, a prime target audience, it was those same nostalgic Transformer fans that went to go watch that movie 5-6 times,

I'm not entirely convinced those people don't represent maybe, at best, 5-10% (and I think I'm being extremely optomistic, even assuming the active membership of this board only represents 5% of the fans out there) of the overall box office take. The other 90-95%? Young teens oblivious to Transformers that saw transforming robot action, the guy from Even Stevens, and slick trailers and went, "Whoa, awesome!" Hell, if I was like 15ish, I might just go see it because of Megan Fox's ass in the trailers.

But yeah, anytime you put the names "Spielburg" and "Bay" on the table at the same time, you're not exactly examining your garden variety movie.

there are plenty of old ninja turtle fans to take advantage of (we are talking about 5-6 billion dollar franchise).

OK, but can you quantify that dollar amount into how much longtime TMNT fans like you and I actually brought to the table in that? I suspect only a fraction. A small fraction.

As for the casual fan who could care less about the ninja turtles, you need hype and spectacle to get those people to even remotely care about a TMNT based movie, and the current movie had neither of these.

You're absolutely right, but in the case of this movie, you might have seen a significant boost in the opening weekend before word-of-mouth spread around about, "You guys fooled me! It was just a toddler affair!" (by this, I mean the regular movie-going public, not toddlers, tweens, or existing TMNT fans)... but that's about it.

I guess it makes perfect sense that evil impulses would cause one to have the urge to boogie down.:roll:

No strong feelings on the Spidey dance either way. It could go or it could stay, but it seemed somewhat in line with Spidey II's "Raindrops Keep Fallin' on My Head." But whatever.

You're right, the Mirage comics never had mainstream appeal, only the cartoon.

Won't argue that. But neither did material like the Sin City comics, the 300 comics, Hellboy comics, Crow comics, etc., etc..

So you are saying kids don't know that Superman is based on a comicbook character,

Kids about 10-15ish, sure.

un-huh, well try asking any adult on the street who characthers like Spider-Man, Batman, Superman are, I qurantee you they will tell you they are comicbook characters,

I wasn't talking about adults.

ask the average adult on the street who the ninja turtles are they will tell you they are cartoon/videogame characters.

Probably right. The name of the game is opening eyes... but again, TMNT Part 4 set the clock back on that one a good long while, so forget about it.

You asked what the difference was between Spider-Man making the jump from campy cartoons to relatively mature movies, asked and answered.

Oh, you're right. Sorry.

It's not about awareness, comics like the Crow and Hellboy have it easy, since they are not competing against more popular alternate versions of themselves, they just had the comics.

True.

I have no problem with seeing a more faithful adaption of the old comics brought to big screen, and I would hope it would succeed, but just don't act surprise if gets ripped apart by the older cartoon fans

All 30 of the fanatical ones that congregate here? I can live with that. I think you can, too.

and flops because it's not what most people are accustomed to when comes to the ninja turtles.

I think we're doing a bit of a dance here. When I'm envisioning a successful TMNT comic book adaptation of the comics on the big screen... I'm not factoring in any of the people that are "accustomed" to one mass media kid-fluff incarnation or another -- it will live or die by the hype it generates in being entirely its own beast.

And again (and again), this can only happen in a vacuum. TMNT -- at least in the mass media -- needs to go into a kind of ice age for a while, let memories of "Cowabungas" and camp and all that fade into a generation that isn't going to be filling the majority of seats anyway. TMNT Part 4 retarded that back a bit... but we can always hope for another 10, 12 years down the road again.

*sigh*

umm, I believe you misread me, I said "never".

Then I apologize again. Just running down the line here.

Heh, I'm pretty sure there are old cartoon fans saying the same thing about comic readers, "F***'em, let them reread their old comics, the 80's cartoon is the only version that matters".:)

Oh, those 30 again? They ought to sit down.

Just using HP to illustrate the difference between the more kid friendly first book with the last one where everyone is getting killed off, as the books progressively got darker, imagine if they went from one extreme to another.

Thus the need for an ice age. Well, a second ice age... the first one just ended up producing kiddy crap again.

Yes, there are those within Imagi/Warner Bros who believe TMNT was too dark and serious and it had a negative effect on the boxoffice, and that the sequel should be more lighter and silly, I'm glad we can agree on this.

When you phrase it like that, yes. The box office numbers came in weekend #2, I absolutely believe they played a bit of "OK, whodunnit?!?" before committees start piping, "It wasn't comedic enough. Look at Ratatouie and Over the Hedge... why can't TMNT be more like that?"

You would be surprise how little it would take to please fans of the old cartoon

I don't think I would be -- the ones I think we're talking about already are more than willing to settle for so little.

Though I lump myself in as a fan of the old cartoon. I'm just able to seperate my nostalgia from it enough to go, "That was fun when I was a kid, it's fun now in small doses as nostalgia and when I want to pop a DVD in and go, 'Haha, I remember that episode! That was the sh*t when I was 9 years old!'" but when it comes to actual material that does anything for me on an adult level... yeah, we're really just talking about the comics here.

A bit of a love-hate affair at the moment with the current state of Vol. 4 and Tales Vol. 2, but what can you do. Post-Eastman & Laird breakup things are a bit topsy-turvy.

I don't see the harm in acknowledging the fans who, like it or not, help to keep the ninja turtles alive today.

Can't agree with you there -- if something called "TMNT" with four brothers named Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Donatello on screen kicking butt isn't enough for fans of the old cartoon... that they just need another dose of cowabunga, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady like some kind of recovering alcoholic craving one more drink... I don't know, it just doesn't seem healthy, not when none of that had anything to do with Eastman & Laird's TMNT at its inception.

Loosened? how, because they were off the radar?

Exactly! That's what it takes, the extent of which the "TMNT is for Kids" motif has permeated things.

I can tell you alot of the buzz surrounding the movie was from fans expecting TMNT to be closer to old cartoon and they were happy because of it, "they have to have Krang!!", "No Bebop or Rocksteady, this movie sucks!!"

There's no accounting for the truly rabid fans of something. I don't think the answer is to cater to them.

And the 4Kids cartoon re-established TMNT as a kids property before the movie.

Yeah, pretty much. It did a little bit of damage control on the material vs. the Fred Wolf stuff... but essentially yeah, just, "Oh, look. A new TMNT children's cartoon."

Yo Andrew, you kinda forgot all the weird 'what were they smokin' stories Eastman and Laird did.

Like what?

All the stories about Nobody, Leatherhead, Rennet, the Passing, the Kirby cyrstal Don Special, Justice Force and such were all extremely weird and wacky, especially yhe Rennet ones. And c'mon... in Return to New York did you ever expect the TMNT to side with a Triceraton to take down the Foot.. and to run into 3 weird-as-all-hell Shredder clones?

Nevertheless, all of the stories you mention were handled in a straight enough manner with real, tangible consequences, TMNT that don't jump into each other's arms and scream in fright, spend and focus time on slapstick, goofball dialogue.

It's all in the "take." Right now, I can write a story about a clown on a space station with a talking cow... but I can write it to drum up the laughs, goof-factor, aim it to toddlers, or I can play it straight, keep it within a serious, Twilight Zone/Outer Limits feel.

I know you can appreciate the difference.

I agree that the 13 monsters story was out of left field, and in my opnion didn't really have any business in the movies, but yeah... the turtles in the comics was full of crazy stuff too. We've seen the TMNT in New York as is, maybe in a new movie we should see some Triceraton invasion stuff...

Crazy stuff in the comics isn't the issue. The goof, Looney Tunes crap... yeah, that's the stuff that wasn't there.

Unless you count those rubbish Hedden-McWeeny stuff... but even when it was published it bore no bones about it being Elseworlds.

I wish the actual TMNT would have a chance to shine. In the right hands, and done in the right way, it would be HUGE. TMNT doesn't have to be silly. It can be a cool movie.

That it can. Of its own right.

Kendamu
02-27-2008, 12:20 AM
I wish Bruce Timm would work on the Turtles for a direct-to-DVD animated movie, but everyone would probably be wondering where Batman was during "that new Justice League ripoff with the Ninja Turtles."

Coola Yagami
02-27-2008, 12:51 AM
The saddest part is.... if the movie sequel had Shredder return with Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady and the Technodrome... and the kiddy comedy aspect was played up further..... the movie would have been three times the hit a more dark and serious TMNT would have been....

Andrew NDB
02-27-2008, 12:56 AM
The saddest part is.... if the movie sequel had Shredder return with Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady and the Technodrome... and the kiddy comedy aspect was played up further..... the movie would have been three times the hit a more dark and serious TMNT would have been....

You can't know that for certain. A "dark and serious TMNT" movie has never been tried before (not that I'm saying there should ever be no humor in a TMNT movie)... and making "TMNT The Old Cartoon: The Motion Picture" is just preaching to a very small choir.

Krang
02-27-2008, 01:28 AM
TMNT thrives on the younder audience, and that's why we get what we do. I don't understand why people can't comprehend the fact that they need to market this stuff to kids in order to have any sort of success at all. There's no way TMNT could be at the same level as Spider-Man or Batman, because when it comes down to it, things like that are just frankly more grounded in reality and easier to take seriously than a property about 4 giant turtles who practice a somewhat bastardized form of martial arts.
Well said. What Mirage purists fail to realize is that the very concept of the Ninja Turtles is ridiculous. Eastman and Laird knew that, considering the concept of the TMNT was a joke, and the first issue of the comics was a parody. To quote the cartoon that throws Mirage purists into fits of rage, they're "big, green, talking turtles." One of the key reasons behind the original cartoon's success is that they took that concept and ran with it by making it into a comedy that didn't take itself seriously. Even if a serious, Mirage-based TMNT movie were made, the majority would most likely make a joke out of it rather than taking it seriously.

Can't agree with you there -- if something called "TMNT" with four brothers named Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Donatello on screen kicking butt isn't enough for fans of the old cartoon... that they just need another dose of cowabunga, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady like some kind of recovering alcoholic craving one more drink... I don't know, it just doesn't seem healthy, not when none of that had anything to do with Eastman & Laird's TMNT at its inception.
How is that any more "unhealthy" than Mirage purists who want to see the TMNT origin story over and over again? There is no "wrong" or "right" interpretation of the TMNT. People are entitled to their opinion as to which interpretation they like the best.

There's no accounting for the truly rabid fans of something. I don't think the answer is to cater to them.
So you're saying you don't want a Mirage-based movie after all? :P

You can't know that for certain. A "dark and serious TMNT" movie has never been tried before (not that I'm saying there should ever be no humor in a TMNT movie)... and making "TMNT The Old Cartoon: The Motion Picture" is just preaching to a very small choir.
And making "Mirage Volumes 1 and 2: The Motion Picture" is preaching to a far, far smaller one.

Andrew NDB
02-27-2008, 01:45 AM
Heya, Krang.

Even if a serious, Mirage-based TMNT movie were made, the majority would most likely make a joke out of it rather than taking it seriously.

Who, the critics? They've never made any difference on these kind of films... look at TMNT 1.

Anybody else? Well, again I agree it's a bit of a prickly pear. On the one hand, it's literally about four mutant Turtles to be sold in a serious manner... something that hasn't been done on the big screen since, well, Hellboy, and maybe the Toxic Avenger before him. It's a tough sell, I won't deny. We're talking about savvy, perhaps viral marketing, slick teaser trailers... this sort of thing. And we'd still need a good 10 years of sitting on our hands to wash the taste out of society's collective mouths of "TMNT is For Kids" after the TMNT Part 4 backwash.

How is that any more "unhealthy" than Mirage purists who want to see the TMNT origin story over and over again?

Who's talking about the TMNT origin over again? Well, now that you mention it I guess it'd be a necessity to some degree in any reboot en masse, but we're talking about potentially a -- at worst -- 3-5 minute flashback or such in the course of a 90+ minute feature. Would that be so terrible? And though it may not seem like it to you and I (and damned if those years aren't just a flyin' by lately) it has been 18 years since there was any TMNT origin on the big screen.

There is no "wrong" or "right" interpretation of the TMNT. People are entitled to their opinion as to which interpretation they like the best.

Of course they are... but we're talking about a TMNT comic book movie here -- we've never seen that before. TMNT is quintessentially a comic book property -- you follow the roots, you end up at a mature comic book. You follow your nostalgia... you end up in children's cartoon spinoffs, which, while have their own devout little followings (and that's cool), isn't indicative or the fault of the source material, which shouldn't perpetually be the whipping boy of Eastman and Laird sitting down sometime around 1986 saying, "OK, Fred Wolf Productions, you guys can do a cartoon loosely based on our comics."

And making "Mirage Volumes 1 and 2: The Motion Picture" is preaching to a far, far smaller one.

I'd like to see where you see anyone here advocating a literal "Mirage Vol. 1 & 2 Motion Picture" (I'd be far more interested in seeing someone in a Guilmero Del Toro vein taking the source material, piecing together what worked and what didn't, and bringing forth a creative/directive vision that will just blow comic fans and non-comic fans alike away) but you're not really seeing the bigger picture here. You can't count on the Mirage fans, same as you can't count on the Old Cartoon fans either... a proper TMNT movie absolutely needs to sell itself on itself and nothing else. A bit of name recognition from folks who read the comics, watched the cartoons, watched the old movies has to be the cherry on the top, not the cake itself.

But once more, it's just pie in the sky. There was a chance in the air but it's gone for a good while now. In ten years we can wet our finger and stick it up, see how the wind's blowing, but the pooch has already been effed for the here and now.

Dragon Turtle
02-27-2008, 02:27 AM
Yeah, but what about real people that actually went to see the movie? All that I heard was that they wanted away from kiddie and more adult. And I heard that with my own ears. People can type what they want, but I'll let what I know for a fact by experiencing, and the obvious drop in the box office at week 2, after people actually saw it.



Yes I heard people say it wasn't the fun loving turtles they remember, too "dour", too "dark", "a byproduct of a post 911 world", I heard all this nonsense at the movie theaters.

It dropped the second week like most front loaded movies, add to the fact it wasn't promoted very well and opened up in a crowed market.


I'm not entirely convinced those people don't represent maybe, at best, 5-10% (and I think I'm being extremely optomistic, even assuming the active membership of this board only represents 5% of the fans out there) of the overall box office take. The other 90-95%? Young teens oblivious to Transformers that saw transforming robot action, the guy from Even Stevens, and slick trailers and went, "Whoa, awesome!"

And yeah, anytime you put the names "Spielburg" and "Bay" on the table at the same time, you're not exactly examining your garden variety movie.


True, Transformers didn't make 300 million on the strength of G1 Transformer fans out of pocket money, but their constant and dogmatic
following certainly didn't hurt the hype machine for the movie.




OK, but can you quantify that dollar amount into how much longtime TMNT fans like you and I actually brought to the table in that? I suspect only a fraction. A small fraction.


The 5-6 billion figure covers the time it was introduced back in the 80's, a few years ago 4kids announced that the 2K3 turtles had collected over a billion dollars, I would say a good chunk of that money came from older fans, back when the turtles were a merchandising juggernaut in the 80's and 90's.


You're absolutely right, but in the case of this movie, you might have seen a significant boost in the opening weekend before word-of-mouth spread around about, "You guys fooled me! It was just a toddler affair!" (by this, I mean the regular movie-going public, not toddlers, tweens, or existing TMNT fans)... but that's about it.


Most front loaded fanboyish movies make most of their cash during opening weekend, and then drop like stones in week two, and if you were to add amazing PG-13 action it wouldn't be a "toddler affair" would it?:D



I wasn't talking about adults.


But they do make up the mainstream public, it's ok, kind of an old point, forget it.


Thus the need for an ice age. Well, a second ice age... the first one just ended up producing kiddy crap again.


How long would this ice age be? Looking at the reviews for TMNT, for good and for bad, 14 years was not enough too fade the memories of the "cowabunga" era, and putting it in a closet and hoping it will go away will never work, because there will always be a kids line. TMNT has proven itself a successful evergreen property, if you can dust off something every 10 years and make a billion dollars, Peter Laird or anyone else with an ounce of sense will never kill off the golden goose. And whenever dealing with movie execs who will be backing the movie financially, do you believe they will back the obscure black and white comic or the 800 pound gorilla that is a proven money maker.


If you really want to see the line mature then you deal with it in the here and now, TMNT may not be as serious as some people would have liked, but it is step in the right direction from the previous movies, and would be a nice building block for more mature stories, just like the Harry Potter books.

I also don't believe the existence of a kid friendly TMNT line spells the end for for a more adult version of TMNT or vise versus. The media world is big enough for both.



I don't think I would be -- the ones I think we're talking about already are more than willing to settle for so little.

Can't agree with you there -- if something called "TMNT" with four brothers named Leonardo, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Donatello on screen kicking butt isn't enough for fans of the old cartoon... that they just need another dose of cowabunga, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady like some kind of recovering alcoholic craving one more drink... I don't know, it just doesn't seem healthy, not when none of that had anything to do with Eastman & Laird's TMNT at its inception.


Seeing how Transformer fans flip over small things like hearing a specific sound effect, theme song, or VA, it wouldn't take much to satisfy those fans, and it would be a classy tip of the hat to the fans that made Laird and Eastman rich, and helped to keep the turtles alive after all these years. After that move on.

Krang
02-27-2008, 03:47 AM
Who, the critics? They've never made any difference on these kind of films... look at TMNT 1.

Anybody else? Well, again I agree it's a bit of a prickly pear. On the one hand, it's literally about four mutant Turtles to be sold in a serious manner... something that hasn't been done on the big screen since, well, Hellboy, and maybe the Toxic Avenger before him. It's a tough sell, I won't deny. We're talking about savvy, perhaps viral marketing, slick teaser trailers... this sort of thing. And we'd still need a good 10 years of sitting on our hands to wash the taste out of society's collective mouths of "TMNT is For Kids" after the TMNT Part 4 backwash.
Yeah, I meant the general public (I agree about the critics). Even if there never were any TMNT cartoons or TMNT 4 or anything else TMNT-related aimed at kids, I still doubt that even the most serious TMNT movie wouldn't end up being laughed at, considering the fact that most teens and young adults can't seem to take anything at all seriously. I'm not saying I'm against a mature TMNT movie, just that it is not likely to be successful. It would be interesting to see an attempt at one and the marketing behind it, though.

Who's talking about the TMNT origin over again? Well, now that you mention it I guess it'd be a necessity to some degree in any reboot en masse, but we're talking about potentially a -- at worst -- 3-5 minute flashback or such in the course of a 90+ minute feature. Would that be so terrible? And though it may not seem like it to you and I (and damned if those years aren't just a flyin' by lately) it has been 18 years since there was any TMNT origin on the big screen.
That was just an example to show that wanting to see a reboot with a Mirage-based story would involve retreading just like wanting to see a movie with concepts from the original cartoon in it would. Personally, I don't have a problem with either one.

Of course they are... but we're talking about a TMNT comic book movie here -- we've never seen that before. TMNT is quintessentially a comic book property -- you follow the roots, you end up at a mature comic book. You follow your nostalgia... you end up in children's cartoon spinoffs, which, while have their own devout little followings (and that's cool), isn't indicative or the fault of the source material, which shouldn't be perpetually be the whipping boy of Eastman and Laird sitting down sometime around 1986 saying, "OK, Fred Wolf, you guys can do a cartoon loosely based on our comics."
While TMNT did start out as a comic book, the success of the original cartoon is the reason why TMNT is still around today, so I don't think it's fair to try to sweep the OT under the carpet and forget it ever existed. It would be fine with me if there were a comic-based movie that made no reference to the OT whatsoever, but since the OT was an important part of TMNT's history, I don't think it should be considered out of the question to make references to it in the less serious interpretations of TMNT.

I'd like to see where you see anyone here advocating a literal "Mirage Vol. 1 & 2 Motion Picture" (I'd be far more interested in seeing someone in a Guilmero Del Toro vein taking the source material, piecing together what worked and what didn't, and bringing forth a creative/directive vision that will just blow comic fans and non-comic fans alike away) but you're not really seeing the bigger picture here.
It's true that nobody said anything about a movie that follows the comic page by page, but nobody said anything like that about the original cartoon either, which is what my comment was in response to. Incorporating characters or other elements from the original cartoon in a new TMNT movie wouldn't necessarily turn it into a revival of the OT.

You can't count on the Mirage fans, same as you can't count on the Old Cartoon fans either... a proper TMNT movie absolutely needs to sell itself on itself and nothing else. A bit of name recognition from folks who read the comics, watched the cartoons, watched the old movies has to be the cherry on the top, not the cake itself.
Good point, I agree.

raphdude
02-27-2008, 09:27 AM
Yeah, I meant the general public (I agree about the critics).

While TMNT did start out as a comic book, the success of the original cartoon is the reason why TMNT is still around today, so I don't think it's fair to try to sweep the OT under the carpet and forget it ever existed. It would be fine with me if there were a comic-based movie that made no reference to the OT whatsoever, but since the OT was an important part of TMNT's history, I don't think it should be considered out of the question to make references to it in the less serious interpretations of TMNT.


Krang,
I couldn 't agree with you more. The OT existed for almost 10 years. Honestly, I have grown to actually enjoy all of the interpretations of the turtles. They all have their place and time. Back in 1990, I went and saw the first live action film (it's still my favorite) repeatedly. I refused to watch the OT because at the time I thought it was stupid and silly. It wasn't until I started buying the Lionsgate dvd's that I got totally hooked on the OT. Back in 1990, I didn't appreciate the subtle adult humor in that show and how funny and almost lovable Shredder, Krang and his two buffoons were. Some of Krang's lines (i.e. "Cry me a river") and Raph's lines have had me laughing outloud! I have since bought all of the Lionsgate dvd's and have throughly enjoyed them.

In terms of another TMNT movie, I'm sure one will come down the road and
I'll go and see it. But I'm not really in a hurry. Until then, I have more than enough dvd's of the turtles to watch. :)

BTW Krang, Thanks for the warning on the Stephanie PM. 8) I thought that message was odd and my gut feelings told me not to open the link included with it. I'm glad I didn't!:o

Kendamu
02-27-2008, 09:40 AM
Well said. What Mirage purists fail to realize is that the very concept of the Ninja Turtles is ridiculous. Eastman and Laird knew that, considering the concept of the TMNT was a joke, and the first issue of the comics was a parody. To quote the cartoon that throws Mirage purists into fits of rage, they're "big, green, talking turtles." One of the key reasons behind the original cartoon's success is that they took that concept and ran with it by making it into a comedy that didn't take itself seriously. Even if a serious, Mirage-based TMNT movie were made, the majority would most likely make a joke out of it rather than taking it seriously.


How is that any more "unhealthy" than Mirage purists who want to see the TMNT origin story over and over again? There is no "wrong" or "right" interpretation of the TMNT. People are entitled to their opinion as to which interpretation they like the best.


So you're saying you don't want a Mirage-based movie after all? :P


And making "Mirage Volumes 1 and 2: The Motion Picture" is preaching to a far, far smaller one.
Hey, now! I'm (nearly) a Mirage Purist myself! Just wanting to throw out that: Krang, you're generalizing!

I know the Turtles are a parody! That's why, in most instances when talk of a movie comes up, I always speak of wanting to see more subtle humor. My favorite kind of Turtle humor is the subtle parody stuff that comes from the concept of turtles being ninjas set in a world full of 1980s martial arts movie drama and overused comic book cliches. My second favorite type would be subtle social commentary sprinkled throughout a TMNT story.

I don't think I'm the only one who understands this, either. I just feel like I'm being treated like an idiot when given cringe-worthy humor in lieu of something a little more... "No More Heroes" in terms of being funny.

Drtooth
02-27-2008, 11:42 AM
Well, I say this all the time, and I bang my head against the computer popping this respeonse out all the time. I agree...there is no wrong way to do the Turtle franchise (though adding a girl Turtle was pretty close).

When I expected to see TMNT, I expected something similar to the live action films, based only slightly off Mirage (the first one still had April as a news caster, and Don and Casey were friends instead of Raph and Casey, etc. Etc.).

Does this mean I want to see a real Mirage version of the film? Yes, eventually. Somehow. Does it mean I would like to see one based off the old series? Yes! Eventually. But I tended to think of TMNT as the same universe as the first 3 movies. Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady weren't there. Shredder was his own man, like in the comics. But then he had mutant henchmen in the second film. I find the films a good mix between the cartoons and Mirage, almost holding closer to Archie.

Before this gets into a critical about the movie thread (which it isn't), we need to get back on track. From what I've read, a lot of responses were "I didn't like the movie, and I don't want to see a sequal." not "does this film financially warrent a sequal" which is the real question here. A film need not be good or enjoyable in any aspect to get a sequal. Who clammored for Daddy Day Camp? In most cases, sequals are either franchise films (Saw, Shrek, etc) or contractual obligations (also like Saw from what I've heard).

As I said earlier, the merchandising alone warrents a sequal, be it DTV or theatrical. We know that all sides want to do one, but what we don't know is what they want to do for the next one.

silentrob
02-27-2008, 11:46 AM
I'm jumping in here late, but I just watched the movie again last night. It was the first time since I saw it opening weekend. I have to say, I really loved it.

I'm a Mirage fan from the very beginning, my favorite TMNT tales are the early stuff and my favorite movie was the first live-action one. With that being said I think the movie was the perfect mix for me. I love the heavy stuff between Leo and Raph, I love the brotherhood and team themes and I thought Don and Mike were handled well too.

I dont think us hardcore Mirage guys will ever get the original comic inspired turtle movie we've dreamt about. There just isnt the market for it and I've come to terms with that... so in my opinion the movie was great. As great as a modern CGI TMNT movie could be.

So I say bring on the sequel! And if/when they do I'll be first in line.

The Shelf
02-27-2008, 11:50 AM
Let me just say that I am very impressed with how well this thread has held up. It's refreshing to see a good internet debate with no flaming, so I commend all who have participated.

On topic, I have had the privilege to talk both online and off with many different types of Turtles fans, and I think it's safe to say that there are as many fans of one Turtles incarnation as there are of another (with a handful of exceptions). Personally, I have enjoyed nearly every incarnation, and I find myself torn because I am a big fan of both the campy turtles and the serious turtles.

TMNT (part 4) appealed to both sides which is why I loved that movie so much when it came out. I think that one of its greatest strengths was that it tried to appeal to both types of fans. Unfortunately, that is perhaps its greatest weakness as well. It tried to be something for everyone and ended up being everything for no one, which is just a clever way of saying that it flopped in the long run.

There are a lot of people who didn't go see the last movie because it wasn't like the old cartoon, and there are a lot of people who didn't go see the last movie because it wasn't serious enough like the old comics. I think if a TMNT movie is going to be successful it needs to cater to one or the other. Ideally, Mirage should make direct-to-dvd animated movies that resembles the old cartoon and live-action theatrical movies that resembles the comics. Sure, that would require making twice as many movies, but we'd be making twice as many movies that are both more successful than the last movie was.

Making a movie to please everyone at the same time is just too risky as we've seen. I am finally convinced that splitting the serious and goofy TMNT aspects once and for all is the only way to give everyone what they want, and I think it would be very well accepted.

Tinuvielsdreams
02-27-2008, 01:41 PM
Let me just say that I am very impressed with how well this thread has held up. It's refreshing to see a good internet debate with no flaming, so I commend all who have participated.

On topic, I have had the privilege to talk both online and off with many different types of Turtles fans, and I think it's safe to say that there are as many fans of one Turtles incarnation as there are of another (with a handful of exceptions). Personally, I have enjoyed nearly every incarnation, and I find myself torn because I am a big fan of both the campy turtles and the serious turtles.
TMNT (part 4) appealed to both sides which is why I loved that movie so much when it came out. I think that one of its greatest strengths was that it tried to appeal to both types of fans. Unfortunately, that is perhaps its greatest weakness as well. It tried to be something for everyone and ended up being everything for no one, which is just a clever way of saying that it flopped in the long run.

There are a lot of people who didn't go see the last movie because it wasn't like the old cartoon, and there are a lot of people who didn't go see the last movie because it wasn't serious enough like the old comics. I think if a TMNT movie is going to be successful it needs to cater to one or the other. Ideally, Mirage should make direct-to-dvd animated movies that resembles the old cartoon and live-action theatrical movies that resembles the comics. Sure, that would require making twice as many movies, but we'd be making twice as many movies that are both more successful than the last movie was.

Making a movie to please everyone at the same time is just too risky as we've seen. I am finally convinced that splitting the serious and goofy TMNT aspects once and for all is the only way to give everyone what they want, and I think it would be very well accepted.

I decided to pull the newest movie last night and watch it again. What is funny is after reading this I realized I had that exact same conversation with the person I was watching it with, but the outcome was opposite...
I think the happy medium is what will survive a theater debut, and I do agree with the idea that if little kids can be flocked to the theater to see Spiderman, and X-men PG-13 rated flicks then why not turtles?
I think for a turtles movie to be successful it needs to have a very balanced mix of what everyone wants to see...Light and dark. I think they went as far as they felt safe going with 4.

I do know our love of the franchise make us all very critical and that's okay conversation like this thread are great...

I would also say the more movies the merrier and I would really love to see darker straight to DVD turtles movies. I know a lot of people here would agree with me when I say I have a BFA in animation (or some other art and writing skill) I'd make them without needing to be paid a ridiculous amount of money if some studio decided to produce them but I just don't see it happening. This entertainment industry in to eager to dismiss and start over if they don't see a quick $$$ result.

I do however really think we haven't seen the last of turtles on the big screen...

Kendamu
02-27-2008, 02:13 PM
So, I just got done talking to Dan at Mirage about it all based off one of my later messages in this thread.

Seems to be that while the heart was there with Kevin Munroe and Peter Laird (Kevin and Peter? hah!) to make a TMNT movie that everyone could enjoy, it's the people who make the products based on the movie and such who had a lot of pull in why there's such a limitation put on it. Of course, this is due to TMNT's reputation as being purely Season 5 OT TMNT, but it was still marketing pull.

I mentioned earlier a DTV release based off the comic storylines. Seems Mirage has really considered it! However, how much it would cost to do such a thing is just way too much for them right now.

So, in the end, if they were to use some of the money they get from stuff produced for mainstram appeal into a project for Mirage purists and Mirage fans in general, I could handle them putting out something that's more comedic than serious... as long as they do it with dignity and it's used as a means to the end I want to see (more Mirage stuff).

The Shelf
02-27-2008, 02:38 PM
I think the happy medium is what will survive a theater debut, and I do agree with the idea that if little kids can be flocked to the theater to see Spiderman, and X-men PG-13 rated flicks then why not turtles?

But see that's exactly what I'm saying. TMNT needs a PG-13 movie for fans of the comics and a campier PG movie for the old 'toon fans. I don't think the Spiderman and X-men films are the happy medium you're talking about at all. If they were a happy medium, then they would be PG, not PG-13. Those films are geared toward teenagers and adults, not the kiddies. Sure, kids go to watch them, but they're not the target audience. There are animated cartoons and movies geared toward them. The theatrical movies are geared to a more mature audience. That's exactly what I want for the Turtles. Two separate lines for two separate audiences. TMNT (part 4) was a happy medium, and I just don't think it was as successful as it could have been if two separate movies lines were being made. The only thing is that one line needs to be theatrical while the other is direct to video. It doesn't matter to me which one goes where so long as it eventually happens, but I would prefer to see a PG-13 TMNT movie on the big screen just because it would be totally epic and the potential viral campaign could be amazing.

Kendamu
02-27-2008, 02:46 PM
But see that's exactly what I'm saying. TMNT needs a PG-13 movie for fans of the comics and a campier PG movie for the old 'toon fans. I don't think the Spiderman and X-men films are the happy medium you're talking about at all. If they were a happy medium, then they would be PG, not PG-13. Those films are geared toward teenagers and adults, not the kiddies. Sure, kids go to watch them, but they're not the target audience. There are animated cartoons and movies geared toward them. The theatrical movies are geared to a more mature audience. That's exactly what I want for the Turtles. Two separate lines for two separate audiences. TMNT (part 4) was a happy medium, and I just don't think it was as successful as it could have been if two separate movies lines were being made. The only thing is that one line needs to be theatrical while the other is direct to video. It doesn't matter to me which one goes where so long as it eventually happens, but I would prefer to see a PG-13 TMNT movie on the big screen just because it would be totally epic and the potential viral campaign could be amazing.
It could be done kinda Harry Potter style...

Y'know, start off aiming the movies as a specific target age group of kids and as they grow older make movies grow with that audience until they're adults. That's kinda how I felt going off the OT to the Image comics. They really tried playing off that whole "no moar kiddie turdlez thees r grownup turdlez rawr!!!111" thing.

Tinuvielsdreams
02-27-2008, 03:16 PM
But see that's exactly what I'm saying. TMNT needs a PG-13 movie for fans of the comics and a campier PG movie for the old 'toon fans. I don't think the Spiderman and X-men films are the happy medium you're talking about at all. If they were a happy medium, then they would be PG, not PG-13. Those films are geared toward teenagers and adults, not the kiddies. Sure, kids go to watch them, but they're not the target audience. There are animated cartoons and movies geared toward them. The theatrical movies are geared to a more mature audience. That's exactly what I want for the Turtles. Two separate lines for two separate audiences. TMNT (part 4) was a happy medium, and I just don't think it was as successful as it could have been if two separate movies lines were being made. The only thing is that one line needs to be theatrical while the other is direct to video. It doesn't matter to me which one goes where so long as it eventually happens, but I would prefer to see a PG-13 TMNT movie on the big screen just because it would be totally epic and the potential viral campaign could be amazing.

I get what you mean, I guess I just think of PG-13 more the norm lately for hero movies. PG is the new G because you barely ever see G rated movies anymore. I also know kids love to see PG-13 rated films..lol

I do love your idea, I have always wanted to see straight to DVDs happen. It's really nice to hear it has at least been considered from what Goongasnootch said earlier. I could see them putting the kiddier films in theater and doing the grittier version on DVD. We just may never get that.
I guess I thinkn back to Movie 1 and I just feel like they did something really right there with the balance of what fans were getting. Maybe I am just hoping too much for another TMNT 1

GreasyBoi
02-27-2008, 04:30 PM
I don't think there is any chance on having a rated R TMNT movie. If it is rated R, the kids will be dissapointed and not be able to watch. That means low budget on a rated R movie. Although, a PG-13 would still be great. But I'm hoping for a live action movie.

Masked Ninja
02-27-2008, 07:13 PM
Interesting, the too funny/not funny enough split reaction over TMNT.

My observation: There's quite a lot of attempted humor, but about 85% of it falls flat. So you really only laugh a few times, though they're constantly trying. It is surprisingly dark when compared to the OT, mainly because you have Raph and Leo seriously fight each other. And that family tension, while really the only "dark" thing happening, does pervade the whole tone even while Mike is ridiculous all over the place. That's where the OT fans get that "dour" complaint, I bet. The Turtles aren't mindless cartoons that are ready to group hug at any given moment - they have some problems they're working through and Leo returning isn't going to hunky-dorify everything.

Andrew's earlier assessment of TMNT is one I actually agree with on all points... I think the reason I'm still able to have fun watching it is I shrug off the bits I don't like and immerse myself in the parts I do. But the thing that still kills me every time I watch are those flopped one-liners. A few are chuckle-worthy, but most... blech.

That's what we need for any sequel... if there are gonna be jokes (and even in a Mirage-loyal film there should be a decent amount), they have to be good.

Dragon Turtle
02-27-2008, 08:49 PM
So, I just got done talking to Dan at Mirage about it all based off one of my later messages in this thread.

Seems to be that while the heart was there with Kevin Munroe and Peter Laird (Kevin and Peter? hah!) to make a TMNT movie that everyone could enjoy, it's the people who make the products based on the movie and such who had a lot of pull in why there's such a limitation put on it. Of course, this is due to TMNT's reputation as being purely Season 5 OT TMNT, but it was still marketing pull.


Got to get those Happy Meal toys out to the young'uns.



I mentioned earlier a DTV release based off the comic storylines. Seems Mirage has really considered it! However, how much it would cost to do such a thing is just way too much for them right now.


Since Warner bros. has been on a direct to video kick as of late, it would be nice if they could kick in a few mil for a direct-to-video TMNT flick, you know do something to promote the product for a change.


But see that's exactly what I'm saying. TMNT needs a PG-13 movie for fans of the comics and a campier PG movie for the old 'toon fans. I don't think the Spiderman and X-men films are the happy medium you're talking about at all. If they were a happy medium, then they would be PG, not PG-13.

I don't believe OT turtle fans would object to a PG-13 movie, especially considering many OT fans consider the first live action movie to be the gold standard of TMNT films, and that movie would definately be rated PG-13 today.


Interesting, the too funny/not funny enough split reaction over TMNT.

My observation: There's quite a lot of attempted humor, but about 85% of it falls flat. So you really only laugh a few times, though they're constantly trying.




I'll be honest, I just don't see where TMNT is constantly attempting to be funny, yes the Mikey parts more often then not fall flat, but most people would agree he and Don got the shaft when it came to screen time, so what else is there? Don's IT job, some one liners during the monster fight scene (most likely ablibbed by the voice actors), Raph's scuffle with the Jersy Devil? Meh. Maybe it's the shortness of the movie that gives the impression that TMNT was wall to wall gags.

Andrew NDB
02-28-2008, 02:35 AM
When I have 40 minutes to set aside to respond to a lot of the very articulately brought up points here, I'll do so. In the mean time, let me add...

Let me just say that I am very impressed with how well this thread has held up. It's refreshing to see a good internet debate with no flaming, so I commend all who have participated.

I couldn't agree more, and I was thinking the same thing. When I was voicing pretty much my same opinions a little under a year ago, maybe TMNT Part 4 was a little too fresh on the brain for the fans around these parts to properly digest it and set aside that kind of "zomg, new Turtlez movie, someone dares bash it?" blind sentiment (aside from one or two folks, posting my thoughts about the film was seemingly like throwing out a pinata for flamers), but it seems like -- maybe -- finally we can have an intelligent conversation about that in retrospect now, and for things moving forward.

This is a good thing, it's cool, and just about everyone here has brought up valid points. It's all remained respectful, no name-calling has been hurled even as personal convictions all seem to be laid plainly on the table.

Before I sign off, one post just begs a rebuttal...

I don't think there is any chance on having a rated R TMNT movie. If it is rated R, the kids will be dissapointed and not be able to watch. That means low budget on a rated R movie. Although, a PG-13 would still be great. But I'm hoping for a live action movie.

No one of sound mind is asking or expecting (or at least, asking that honestly expects) an R-rated TMNT movie... and you won't find any posts in this entire thread advocating an R-rated TMNT movie. It's quite possible to translate a proper Mirage-oriented comic book movie into PG-13... and quite impossible to do it as PG.

Is there any R-rated material in the comic books? Not a whole lot that it's just inherently a part of it, but sure. The way the R rating is, any kicks to the head is an automatic R (by this latest stigma, even the original TMNT movie would be rated R). Actual panels showing free-flowing blood and dismemberment would have to go, or be left tactfully implied (hopefully saved for a later unrated DVD director's cut, but whatever), and probably the TMNT doing any underage drinking of alcohol is probably a no-no... but I'm pretty sure even the most jaded Mirage fan can live with these concessions.

Krang
02-28-2008, 02:45 AM
Hey, now! I'm (nearly) a Mirage Purist myself! Just wanting to throw out that: Krang, you're generalizing!

I know the Turtles are a parody! That's why, in most instances when talk of a movie comes up, I always speak of wanting to see more subtle humor.
My mistake, I didn't mean to imply that all Mirage purists were like that. I was only referring to the really gung-ho ones that get furious at anything TMNT-related that isn't "dark and gritty" and are too closed-minded to acknowledge the humorous origins of the TMNT.

Ideally, Mirage should make direct-to-dvd animated movies that resembles the old cartoon and live-action theatrical movies that resembles the comics. Sure, that would require making twice as many movies, but we'd be making twice as many movies that are both more successful than the last movie was.

Making a movie to please everyone at the same time is just too risky as we've seen. I am finally convinced that splitting the serious and goofy TMNT aspects once and for all is the only way to give everyone what they want, and I think it would be very well accepted.
Good idea, I agree. If there were to be a new movie based on the original cartoon, though, I hope they would hire the original voice actors and one or more of the original writers. Without them, I doubt they would be able to capture the unique humor of the OT.

JetsAndHeels
02-28-2008, 09:11 AM
I'm jumping in here late, but I just watched the movie again last night. It was the first time since I saw it opening weekend. I have to say, I really loved it.


So I say bring on the sequel! And if/when they do I'll be first in line.


I agree with all of this. I thought the movie was great, and I look forward to hopefully seeing a sequel in the future.

It was a fun movie to watch...I enjoyed all the action and the plot. I thought the characters were well developed (although don and mike were not in it as much) and the animation was very well done. ONe of my favorite movies.

Drtooth
02-28-2008, 10:09 AM
Because it has no direct linking, and you'd have to go and look for it anyway:

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/

Scroll down to see the Wednsay, Febuary 27th post. It has a notice saying "Imagi is hiring" and it features an Uncle Sam-esque poster of one of the Turtles. Clearly they want one to happen.

And off topic, there' apparently an Astroboy version of this poster. I'm too lazy to look for it, though.

Andrew NDB
02-28-2008, 10:50 AM
Because it has no direct linking, and you'd have to go and look for it anyway:

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/

Scroll down to see the Wednsay, Febuary 27th post. It has a notice saying "Imagi is hiring" and it features an Uncle Sam-esque poster of one of the Turtles. Clearly they want one to happen.

Or it could be because TMNT is their first mass-media theatrical film and they want potential applicants to recognize something they'd done.

But in any case, Imagi does want one to happen. Imagi's wanting to do TMNT Part 5 is not in question... they just keep giving Peter Laird pitches to make it a comedy and he keeps (thankfully) rejecting them.

Revan
02-28-2008, 12:48 PM
But in any case, Imagi does want one to happen. Imagi's wanting to do TMNT Part 5 is not in question... they just keep giving Peter Laird pitches to make it a comedy and he keeps (thankfully) rejecting them.

I would rather the turtles stayed off the big screen altogether if it means keeping them out of a comedy. Cmon Imagi let's get dark and dirty!

http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/tmnt/imagi-recruiting-poster.jpg

Masked Ninja
02-28-2008, 03:43 PM
I'll be honest, I just don't see where TMNT is constantly attempting to be funny, yes the Mikey parts more often then not fall flat, but most people would agree he and Don got the shaft when it came to screen time, so what else is there? Don's IT job, some one liners during the monster fight scene (most likely ablibbed by the voice actors), Raph's scuffle with the Jersy Devil? Meh. Maybe it's the shortness of the movie that gives the impression that TMNT was wall to wall gags.Heh, it's probably why I can sit through the movie happily enough. When they're being serious and concentrating on their family tension story, they don't cheapen it with gags. But as soon as the fights start, they start chucking around these terrible one-liners and only a very few stick. That could be skewing my judgement because such a high percentage are cringe-worthy and therefore stand out, but there ya go.

And I still don't get why everyone calls this a "short" movie. It's a pretty standard length for an animated movie. Just because of the post-Lord-of-the-Rings 3-hour-movie trend, and because Pixar rolls out 2-hour monsters now doesn't mean the standard "feature length" 80-90 minute animation is now "short." :P Beauty and the Beast was 84 minutes (less than the IMDB-posted 87 minute length for TMNT), The Lion King was 89, 101 Dalamatians was only 79, etc. Most tend to fall around that length.

Though come to think of it, the barrage of bad one-liners combined with the fact that they have too much plot to fit into the length they ended up at probably has something to do with it.

Ehh, anyway. I still like enough of TMNT to be glad I own the movie, but it is interesting to see what everyone else thinks did and didn't work, and why. Yeah, I know we discussed it to death at the release, but a year helps people see ways to criticize, and accept the validity of criticisms that they didn't want to think about when the film was New.

I'll probably see the sequel if they make it simply because it's Turtles, but I'll obviously want it to be good as well. Not too likely, but I'm content to just quietly hope for now.

ToTheNines
02-28-2008, 05:04 PM
Man, F**K Imagi. F**k 'em for doing Ass-tro Boy and F**k 'em for trying to make a TMNT comedy. (I know it's kinda late, just wanted to get it off my chest).

Kendamu
02-28-2008, 05:21 PM
I wonder... If TMNT were to become a comedy, could it be done in a manner that would keep the "just for kids" label off of it?

I don't mind funny TMNT when it's actually funny.

Dragon Turtle
02-28-2008, 08:34 PM
And I still don't get why everyone calls this a "short" movie. It's a pretty standard length for an animated movie. Just because of the post-Lord-of-the-Rings 3-hour-movie trend, and because Pixar rolls out 2-hour monsters now doesn't mean the standard "feature length" 80-90 minute animation is now "short." :P Beauty and the Beast was 84 minutes (less than the IMDB-posted 87 minute length for TMNT), The Lion King was 89, 101 Dalamatians was only 79, etc. Most tend to fall around that length.



I feel TMNT is a short movie because it doesn't run long enough to develope its characters or story, not nesscarily because it's only 79 minutes long (the actual runtime not including credits). If it takes a movie 3 hours or 1, so be it, just as long as it has enough time to effectively tell its story. Most Disney movies are based on short stories and are often padded with little side adventures involving sidekicks or musical numbers.

TMNT was never intended to be an 80 minute movie, if it was, the story would have been more tighter and more developed (giving Kevin Monroe the benefit of a doubt). TMNT was originally a movie that was over two hours long, and while edited to a point where no one could actually tell there was ever a subplot involving April and Casey in the movie, the subplot had effectively taken away development time that could have been spent on other parts of the movie, since it was removed late in the movies development.