View Full Version : All-red masks in a new movie?
turtle142
06-01-2008, 12:15 PM
Hey everybody,
I'll never forget as a kid learning the turtles all wore red masks in the comics, that really said something to me, and just made it very cool (especially since Raphael has always been my favorite) Now I can't help but wonder, wouldn't it be cool if they ditched the multi colored masks that were created for the 80's show? I think it would be a great step toward the pg-13 comics reflective film many of us are pushing for.
Not only that, but I think the red masks would be great in a cartoon or videogame as well. I know there are some who would say well that won't work because they can't tell them apart, etc. I've did sketches to prove otherwise. By accentuating little differences in facial structure (ala first movie) and varying the colors (ala fast forward) while also varying the level of red in each mask while kinda differentiating the ties in the back, it could be very evident who is who. Raphael (dark red) Leonardo (red) Michelangelo (faded red) and Donatello (burgandy)
So what do you all think? I'd love to hear your thoughts!
Andrew NDB
06-01-2008, 12:22 PM
They're a ninja clan. Of course they'd wear all red.
Despite what children's cartoons and toy lines would have you believe, they really aren't out there to make fashion statements or be Metrosexual with lettered belts or color coded bandannas or anything.
They're just chilling in sewers, raised from birth to assassinate a guy.
Revan
06-01-2008, 12:54 PM
why do they even wear masks at all? multicolor or red?
AquaParade
06-01-2008, 01:00 PM
^ Now you're just taking it too far:lol:. Seriously though, I think of it as just part of their culture. They wear masks as a symbol.
As far as all red bandana's in a movie?...Dream on.:|
Jester
06-01-2008, 01:26 PM
They're a ninja clan. Of course they'd wear all red.
Despite what children's cartoons and toy lines would have you believe, they really aren't out there to make fashion statements or be Metrosexual with lettered belts or color coded bandannas or anything.
They're just chilling in sewers, raised from birth to assassinate a guy.
We get it the Turtles are supposed to be TOTALLY HARD CORE NINJAS. But if it weren't for the TMNT cartoons and toylines, how many of us would know about the TMNT all red bandanas or not?
Andrew NDB
06-01-2008, 02:35 PM
We get it the Turtles are supposed to be TOTALLY HARD CORE NINJAS. But if it weren't for the TMNT cartoons and toylines, how many of us would know about the TMNT all red bandanas or not?
I didn't realize I was walking into a debate about popular culture, childhood nostalgia, and TMNT. Seemed like an honest question from Turtle142 about the TMNT using their red bandannas in media other than the source material to me, divorced from what you or I or the pocket of fandom left that even cares.
And I'm not sure that you really get that the "Turtles are supposed to be TOTALLY HARD CORE NINJAS."
Revan
06-01-2008, 02:36 PM
^ Now you're just taking it too far:lol:. Seriously though, I think of it as just part of their culture. They wear masks as a symbol.
As far as all red bandana's in a movie?...Dream on.:|
Oh I definately love the masks. I'm just wondering how practical they are. Sure, the elbow and knee pads make sense but a mask? :ohwell: I just never understood it, even though it makes them look BA
I will say this. The all red masks are the original and they are cool but without the OT toy line, I probably would have never got into the comics in the first place. It's a tricky situation and I think Jester nailed it. If there were to be a rebot, unlikely, it would be worth looking into the all red mask style. To reach new fans and start a "new" movie canon, they might have to deviate as far from the cute cuddly turtles we all know and love
Andrew NDB
06-01-2008, 02:46 PM
Like most ninja clans, I always figured the red denoted their common clan -- Splinter's clan. You throw different colors in there, you're getting into metrosexual/"I wanna be different"/let's-make-sure-kids-can-tell-them-apart territory and any kind of purpose to it is lost.
Revan
06-01-2008, 02:53 PM
Like most ninja clans, I always figured the red denoted their common clan -- Splinter's clan. You throw different colors in there, you're getting into metrosexual/"I wanna be different"/let's-make-sure-kids-can-tell-them-apart territory and any kind of purpose to it is lost.
So it makes sense for the OT but now that that is over, a reboot should warrant the red bandanas
Jester
06-01-2008, 03:40 PM
I didn't realize I was walking into a debate about popular culture, childhood nostalgia, and TMNT. Seemed like an honest question from Turtle142 about the TMNT using their red bandannas in media other than the source material to me, divorced from what you or I or the pocket of fandom left that even cares.
And I'm not sure that you really get that the "Turtles are supposed to be TOTALLY HARD CORE NINJAS."
If you've read some of my recent post, you'll see that I'd love to see a comic accurate City at War, with red bandannas. It seems all you want to do is piss all over the classic toon, for being "kiddy." That was it's point. Deal with it, or ask Eastman and Laird why they "sold out" the Turtles hard core, all red, trained-by-Splinter-simply-as-an-act-of-avenging-Yoshi's-murder roots.
ToTheNines
06-01-2008, 04:10 PM
It depends on what kind of movie it is. If it's a comic adaption, yeah do it. Anything else... no.
But, I think it might hurt it at the box office, plus all these ass holes on the internet will be like "THE PPL WHO MADE THIS MOVIE KNOW NOTHING ABOUT THE REAL TMNT!!!"
Monte Williams
06-02-2008, 12:36 AM
I didn't realize I was walking into a debate about popular culture, childhood nostalgia, and TMNT... And I'm not sure that you really get that the "Turtles are supposed to be TOTALLY HARD CORE NINJAS."
Jester may have been a bit knee-jerk defensive with his comment, but it's not like there's no precedent; there's an absurdly dismissive tone some fans take towards the multi-colored-bandanas branch of the Turtleverse, and while that may not have been where turtle142 was coming from, I don't blame Jester for seeing it that way.
I can see why some people prefer the comic book Turtleverse, but honestly, it would be marketing suicide to produce a movie featuring all four turtles in matching bandanas at this point. And yes, making money is ultimately what Ninja Turtles movies are all about.
I for one wish for nothing more than a direct sequel to the CGI movie; it took the property in a much more daring, dark, exciting place than most obsessively nostalgic fans give it credit for.
Kendamu
06-02-2008, 01:38 AM
why do they even wear masks at all? multicolor or red?
I actually sent in a letter to Dan a couple weeks ago on that. He told me that they wear masks to have some semblance of a uniform for themselves.
On this subject and based on the above comment, most martial arts schools have everyone wear the same color of uniform. Having the Turtles wear the same color only makes sense.
Jelly Bean
06-02-2008, 02:46 AM
I'm open for change I don't think I'd mind all red masks. ANd the argument that you won't be able to tell them apart is weak. All you have to do is make them look slightly diffrent and maybe diffrent shades of color and they'll be fine.
Jester
06-02-2008, 09:59 AM
To be fair, my comments weren't ment for turtle142. He wasn't totally dismissing the color coded system, he was just saying, "Wouldn't it be cool if for a PG-13 TMNT movie, they went back to their roots." I don't fault him for that. When I read the second post, however, I felt the need to respond how I did. Maybe I should have quoted Andrew, but since turtle124 never said anything anti-kiddy-colored-bandannas, I didn't.
turtle142
06-02-2008, 10:43 AM
To be fair, my comments weren't ment for turtle142. He wasn't totally dismissing the color coded system, he was just saying, "Wouldn't it be cool if for a PG-13 TMNT movie, they went back to their roots." I don't fault him for that. When I read the second post, however, I felt the need to respond how I did. Maybe I should have quoted Andrew, but since turtle124 never said anything anti-kiddy-colored-bandannas, I didn't.
Thanks for helping me clear that up, Jester. I just wanna stress something very important to anyone reading my thread, I ABSOLUTELY cherish the original series, and the multicolored bandannas and everything they mean to me. That cartoon is the very reason I'm here today. I just can't believe this has turned into a debate kinda thing lol, it's just me saying, wouldn't it be great for comic book afficianados and the big kids for all the companies involved in a film to be confident enough in the turtles and their unique attributes to make an incredible statement like going back to the red masks? Continue the discussion, just wanted to make sure everybody knew that I am a HUGE fan of the original stuff.
I for one wish for nothing more than a direct sequel to the CGI movie; it took the property in a much more daring, dark, exciting place than most obsessively nostalgic fans give it credit for.
Dude...no. You must have seen a different movie cuz it was anything BUT dark or daring. Exciting, sure, but not dark or daring.
Sage Ninja
06-02-2008, 12:26 PM
maybe it was the first turtle movie he's seen. Any way call me close minded but I really like the colors the turtles have.
Raphael_
06-02-2008, 01:56 PM
Ehh, I grew up on the toon, so I like the colors. The images presented in the Mirage comics were pretty generic IMHO.
Andrew NDB
06-02-2008, 02:32 PM
Ehh, I grew up on the toon, so I like the colors. The images presented in the Mirage comics were pretty generic IMHO.
They're not interested in making fashion statements. They're interested in training for the day they are to assassinate Oroku Saki.
I think the new Sex and the City movie is in theatres, though. Probably there's lots of different bright colors and fashions there for a quick metrosexual fix.
Raphael_
06-02-2008, 03:11 PM
They're not interested in making fashion statements. They're interested in training for the day they are to assassinate Oroku Saki.
I think the new Sex and the City movie is in theatres, though. Probably there's lots of different bright colors and fashions there for a quick metrosexual fix.
Did I miss somewhere in Mirage's disclaimers that TMNT is SERIOUS BUSINESS?
Kendamu
06-02-2008, 03:18 PM
It is to a lot of Mirage fans. I was once the same way and can still totally see it that way if I choose to. However, I've gotten into a more absurd view of things over the years and see TMNT more for the joke than the seriousness in the Mirage world.
Andrew NDB
06-02-2008, 03:21 PM
Did I miss somewhere in Mirage's disclaimers that TMNT is SERIOUS BUSINESS?
It's there in the script to Vol. 1, #1 in 1984.
Raphael_
06-02-2008, 03:52 PM
It's there in the script to Vol. 1, #1 in 1984.
Pics or it didn't happen.
Aelia
06-02-2008, 04:15 PM
I have nothing against the multicolored masks or the red masks. I think the multicolored masks are great for the really young children who would probably have great difficulty identifying each turtle if they all wore red.
While red masks would be a nice present for older fans, it really would be financial suicide as most audiences remember only the OT and then they also have to cater to the aforementioned young children as well.
Monte Williams
06-02-2008, 05:26 PM
I think the new Sex and the City movie is in theatres, though. Probably there's lots of different bright colors and fashions there for a quick metrosexual fix.
Dude, give it a rest; that's the third or fourth time you've used the term "metrosexual" in this thread. Get a thesaurus or something.
EDIT:
Dude...no. You must have seen a different movie cuz it was anything BUT dark or daring.
maybe it was the first turtle movie he's seen.
It's precisely because I saw the original movies (well, the first two anyway) that I found the new movie so refreshing and exciting and, yes, dark and daring.
The first movie had some dark aspects, but it's as overrated as Empire Strikes Back, and it boasts the same fault: a cheesy script ("Laser brain" in Empire, Don and Casey's alphabetical insult competition in the first Turtle movie)... the second movie had Vanilla Ice; enough said there.
The new movie was hardy a relentlessly dark tour de force, true, but that rooftop battle between Leo and Raph, taken by itself, is darker than anything the first two movies presented. Plus the fight scenes were much more fluid and engaging in the new movie; I am no champion of CGI, but in this case it totally liberated the writers and made for a much more compelling story.
Revan
06-02-2008, 05:42 PM
I actually sent in a letter to Dan a couple weeks ago on that. He told me that they wear masks to have some semblance of a uniform for themselves.
On this subject and based on the above comment, most martial arts schools have everyone wear the same color of uniform. Having the Turtles wear the same color only makes sense.
I love how their masks were intended to be something of a uniform. Uniform meaning uniformity. And then they were all changed to a different color thus defeating the entire purpose of the bandana.:ohwell: Things change.
I can see why some people prefer the comic book Turtleverse, but honestly, it would be marketing suicide to produce a movie featuring all four turtles in matching bandanas at this point. And yes, making money is ultimately what Ninja Turtles movies are all about.
But think of this. With the turtle fans aging out of the fandom it would be a good time for a revamp. Really the only fans now are the longtime turtle fans familiar with the comics and the little kids watching 4kids. The kids who liked the old toon years ago but don't anymore aren't going to like a new gritty turtle movie regardless on the color of the bandana so why not make a change?
Arcade Joe
06-02-2008, 08:11 PM
I believe they use different weapons..Another way of telling them apart..
Andrew NDB
06-02-2008, 08:29 PM
In all honesty, though, I could live with the different colored masks just for the sake of... whatever. There's far, far bigger things the matter with the take on the TMNT and their direction for the big screen than that and bigger bones to pick.
Krang
06-03-2008, 03:32 AM
They're a ninja clan. Of course they'd wear all red.
Technically, the main goal of a ninja clan's uniform should be to blend in, either with the environment or with other people. I don't see how red eye masks would accomplish that goal in any way (and judging by most of the Mirage covers, it's not even a dark red, either, so that's not exactly the best color choice if your main goal is stealth...).
Like most ninja clans, I always figured the red denoted their common clan -- Splinter's clan.
Why would they need to wear a different color from any other clan? You'd think their uniforms would be geared toward avoiding being seen, not setting themselves apart from other clans. Oh, of course, that must mean they're "metrosexual"... :roll:
My point here is that TMNT is not the pinnacle of realism to begin with, so there's no point in trying to cut down any of the TMNT universes using that as an argument. And on that note, I don't see why anyone feels the need to bash any of the TMNT universes in the first place. At times, it even seems that some Mirage elitists are more preoccupied with how much they hate other universes than with how much they like their own comics. In my opinion, everyone should just like what they want to like and pay no attention to what they don't.
Kendamu
06-03-2008, 07:37 AM
The first movie had some dark aspects, but it's as overrated as Empire Strikes Back, and it boasts the same fault: a cheesy script ("Laser brain" in Empire, Don and Casey's alphabetical insult competition in the first Turtle movie)...
The insult game is based off of something that actually happened in Vol. 1. Just like...
Both of Splinter's origin stories
Raph's rooftop fight
The rooftop fight at the end
Nearly the entire farm scene including the insult game
The TMNT's reaction when coming home to find Splinter missing
The final street, rooftop, and Shredder battle
Splinter being really, really old
There's more, but to call the original TMNT movie overrated is pretty much slapping any really decent comic book adaption that's respectful to the source material in the face with a Stop sign.
They even managed to fit a few more OT-like things into that movie rather seamlessly... a feat that seemed impossible to Mirage TMNT fans back in the day who were appalled by the very presence of a "watered down" version of TMNT making it's way into mainstream culture.
The only way it could be seen as overrated is if it were actually used as a secondary source as to things related to historical Ninja or Japanese terms in general. Well, 'cept for Tatsu throwing out that "kuso" under his breath...
Monte Williams
06-03-2008, 08:14 AM
Aren't there more important things to worry about than what the general public thinks about Ninja Turtles?
Name one! ;)
At times, it even seems that some Mirage elitists are more preoccupied with how much they hate other universes than with how much they like their own comics.
Yeah, hardcore G.I. Joe fans were the same way about Sigma 6, and Transformers fans are the same way about the live action movie. It's ridiculous, and tiresome.
The insult game is based off of something that actually happened in Vol. 1.
But that doesn't mean it's good. I mean, seriously, could someone with a better memory post that section of the script for me? The insults were, like, "hose brain" and crap. :roll:
Splinter's origin
Which the cartoon improved on, frankly; a rat performing ninja moves is just stupid.
to call the original TMNT movie overrated is pretty much slapping any really decent comic book adaption that's respectful to the source material in the face...
So just because it had aspects that were loyal to the comic books, we have to turn a blind eye to its flaws and pretend it's better than it is?
By your logic, a kindergarten portrait of the Turtles would be better than the last movie, as long as their bandanas are all colored in red crayon.
The only way it could be seen as overrated is if it were actually used as a secondary source as to things related to historical Ninja or Japanese terms in general.
Really? That's the only way it can be overrated? So crappy dialogue is totally irrelevant?
Buffy
06-03-2008, 08:18 AM
Technically, the main goal of a ninja clan's uniform should be to blend in, either with the environment or with other people. I don't see how red eye masks would accomplish that goal in any way (and judging by most of the Mirage covers, it's not even a dark red, either, so that's not exactly the best color choice if your main goal is stealth...).
Kinda. I've been thinking about that lately too: they should be wearing more black. (Raph did that for a while in a few Archie comics)
Kendamu
06-03-2008, 11:41 AM
Really? That's the only way it can be overrated? So crappy dialogue is totally irrelevant?
Yes, it is irrelevant. People love the first TMNT movie because it's a damn good adaption of the source material. To call the adaption crap is kinda like calling the source material crap.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
06-03-2008, 11:45 AM
Don't bring it back. The different colors was one of the best changes in TMNT ever. It was created for the 1987 TMNT cartoon, and has always been used since then. It's much easier to see who's who.
Monte Williams
06-03-2008, 11:45 AM
So crappy dialogue is totally irrelevant?
Yes, it is irrelevant.
Um. Wow.
Seriously, just....
Wow.
Jester
06-03-2008, 01:18 PM
But that doesn't mean it's good. I mean, seriously, could someone with a better memory post that section of the script for me? The insults were, like, "hose brain" and crap. :roll:
Casey Jones: Not even close, Zip Neck. Professor and Mary Anne. Happily ever after.
Donatello: No way, Atomic Mouth, Gilligan was her main man. They'd be married and have six kids by now.
Casey Jones: Gilligan was a geek, Barfaroni!
Donatello: You're the geek, Camel Breath!
Casey Jones: Dome head.
Donatello: (Rubs his head over his very round head)Elf lips!
[Casey finishes fixing the engine.]
Casey Jones: Okay let's give this a try, fungoid!
Donatello: Here it goes. What are we on?
Casey Jones: G.
Donatello: Here it goes, gak face!
Casey Jones: I'm ready, hose brain!!
It's alphabetical. I kinda liked it cause it showed them bonding in a weird way. :P
Monte Williams
06-03-2008, 02:37 PM
Thanks, Jester, for typing that up, or pasting it or whatever.
I get that they're bonding, and I'm not even saying that it's a terrible movie, but people put it up on a pedestal because they're so blinded by nostalgia that they've lost all ability to think objectively. I mean, really:
Zip Neck
Atomic Mouth
Barfaroni
Camel Breath
Dome head
Elf lips
Fungoid
Gak Face
Hose Brain
Give me one dialogue excerpt from the latest movie that's even half that cheesy...
ToTheNines
06-03-2008, 02:49 PM
Give me one dialogue excerpt from the latest movie that's even half that cheesy...
"Good night dark prince."
"It looked like your mom DUUUUUDE"
"Because, it was Winter's name all over it"
"I thought this place needed a skylight"
There's one from each turtle, easy.
Monte Williams
06-03-2008, 03:05 PM
"Good night dark prince."
I don't remember this line or its context, but while it's a bit over the top, it's sure as hell better than "Hose brain."
"It looked like your mom DUUUUUDE"
While mom jokes are played out, his delivery made that line mildly funny, and the response line made it hilarious.
"Because, it was Winter's name all over it"
Again I don't specifically remember this, but I'll concede that it's either A) a tiresome cliche or, in the event that the speaker was referring to something which literally had Winters' name all over it, a pretty goofy gag. But again, this is nowhere near the cheese level of "Fungoid."
"I thought this place needed a skylight"
Really. You'd put that alongside "Zip Neck" and "Camel Breath"?
Kendamu
06-03-2008, 03:11 PM
Um. Wow.
Seriously, just....
Wow.
Have you ever even read the original TMNT books? If you have, have you seen other books from that era? Specifically, have you read The New Mutants, Daredevil, or any X-Men story involving Wolverine fighting the Hand? Because, it really seems that you're not seeing the first TMNT movie in the same light that I am.
The original TMNT comics were meant as a parody to the mainstream Marvel stuff such as the titles and storylines I listed above. Those comics were "so serious that it's funny" in that light that it's trying to poke fun at how campy comics were even in the 1980s when everything had just started switching to dark storylines and anti-heroes.
The movie adaption of the storylines from those original TMNT issues basically did the same thing, except that since it was made by an independent studio known for making martial arts flicks it went about doing things that made subtle fun of martial arts flicks while retaining a great adaption of the comic storylines that can only be outdone in terms of accuracy by more modern films such as 300 or Sin City.
While the first TMNT movie was "darker" and "more violent" than all the rest, that sort of adds to why the movie is fun. It was never supposed to be Shindler's List with Ninja battles. It was supposed to be fun. However, every TMNT movie ever since seemed to lose the subtle humor in the atmosphere of the comics that was beautifully translated into the movie and instead the studio went about focusing on the more overt OT-style of humor.
The latest movie tried to go back to something more Vol. 1 comic-esque, but it didn't really succeed. Instead, it got bogged down by the stigma of the majority of English-speaking people only seeming to remember TMNT as consisting of Bebop, Rocksteady, Krang, and Vanilla Ice. It also didn't hit the mark because I'm vastly out-numbered when it comes to interpreting what exactly the TMNT comics are accomplishing. It's gotten to the point that the "serious stories" of the comics are actually being taken so seriously that now they're actually written in a serious light. So, the latest TMNT movie followed in that light and reflected Vol. 1 and Tales Vol. 2 rather well.
So, when you're like "the original TMNT was poopy and overrated because it wasn't serious business, you Goongafsck" I'm generally rolling my eyes. For me, taking something that comes out of Vol. 1 (especially the really early stuff) as "serious business GWAR!!!1" is the same as treating No More Heroes (the game, not the song) as "srlyius bizniss GNAR!!!11".
So, the original TMNT movie can't be overrated when looking at it from the aspect of things it pulled from Vol. 1 or things that are just goofy about it. If you say something like "the Casey/Don insult thing was really dumb" you're also saying that the comic version of the same thing, which was almost identical, was dumb and that the source material, what a lot of hardcore fans (though not all of them) seem to find as the Holy Friggin' Grail of TMNT material and wish to see emulated in other media once again. To down on the source material just generally send the message that "a good TMNT movie based off the comics can never be made because the comic sucks, thus, an adaption of said comics will suck."
So, really, if you really don't find the original movie to be all that great, I can't see how you could ever possibly like the original comics unless you're just not getting the joke.
Anyone else who thinks that Vol. 1 is just a bunch of "SERIOUS BUSINESS" meant to rock out the martial arts drama and be hardcore can also feel free to diagree with me. Just note that while you vent your Nerd Rage on me my absurd view of things and geek humor (it's like a mix of No More Heroes, Venture Brothers, Metalocalypse, and the Internet with a scoop of schizophrenia on top) will not allow me to see it your way no matter how unique, dramatic, hardcore, and awesome it sounds.
Yes, I have that much of a problem taking things seriously.
ToTheNines
06-03-2008, 03:15 PM
I don't remember this line or its context, but while it's a bit over the top, it's sure as hell better than "Hose brain."
When Leo dropped The Nightwatcher. It really makes me cringe like you wouldn't believe, I hate it.
While mom jokes are played out, his delivery made that line mildly funny, and the response line made it hilarious.
Yes, the reaction was decent, but his delivery was not ever close to humorous.
Again I don't specifically remember this, but I'll concede that it's either A) a tiresome cliche or, in the event that the speaker was referring to something which literally had Winters' name all over it, a pretty goofy gag. But again, this is nowhere near the cheese level of "Fungoid."
When Don examines the dart. The worst part about it is his smile afterwards. It's fugly.
Really. You'd put that alongside "Zip Neck" and "Camel Breath"?
No, but I needed one for Raphie.
Monte Williams
06-03-2008, 03:39 PM
First off, Goongasnootch, thanks for clarifying your stance. I now have a much better sense of where you're coming from.
Secondly, I think we can both agree on two points:
1. Venture Brothers kicks unholy levels of ass.
2. Shindler's List with Ninja battles would be the greatest thing ever.
Moving on...
Have you ever even read the original TMNT books?
Indeed I have not. I have long wanted to, but I've yet to do so. I am aware of its roots as a parody of the comics of its time, however, and while what you said about its silly dialogue being a reflection/parody of the crappy dialogue of the comic books it was playfully mocking makes perfect sense, I dare say that as an excuse, that only goes so far.
I mean, would the first movie (for which I still feel some lingering affection, for the record) have been any less a fitting adaptation of the comic had they eliminated such nonsense as "booger face" or whatever?
The movie adaption of the storylines from those original TMNT issues basically did the same thing, except that since it was made by an independent studio known for making martial arts flicks it went about doing things that made subtle fun of martial arts flicks...
Now that I did not know. That's interesting.
...and instead the studio went about focusing on the more overt OT-style of humor.
I've seen "OT" mentioned a few times here; what does it stand for, exactly?
Yeah, I was surprised that the new movie didn't focus more on comedy (though I did think the "It looked like your mom" exchange was cute); corny as the '80s cartoon could be, it had some great humor. I'll never forget when the Turtles ran into a room hoping to rescue Zack from Shredder, only to find Zack chilling in the room alone, and Raph (I believe) said, "Shredder, this time you're Zack... Zack?!?"
Goofy, but fun.
The latest movie tried to go back to something more Vol. 1 comic-esque, but it didn't really succeed. Instead, it got bogged down by the stigma of the majority of English-speaking people only seeming to remember TMNT as consisting of Bebop, Rocksteady, Krang, and Vanilla Ice.
Do you really think so? I mean, really, the Foot Clan was just about the only lingering bit of continuity, I'd say. If anything, the new movie went in its own new direction: new villains, etc.
How do you feel it was hampered by the mainstream's association of the property with Bebop and Vanilla Ice and the like?
So, when you're like "the original TMNT was poopy and overrated because it wasn't serious business, you Goongafsck" I'm generally rolling my eyes.
To clarify, I don't want to insist that the first movie sucks or anything, and I don't require that it be super serious ('cause really, how seriously should one take a story about anthropomorphic turtles?), but when people dismiss the new movie in favor of blindly celebrating the first movie, I can't help but look at lines like "Elf lips" and wonder what the hell's the matter with people.
If you say something like "the Casey/Don insult thing was really dumb" you're also saying that the comic version of the same thing, which was almost identical, was dumb...
If that exchange was taken verbatim from the comic, then yes, the comic suffers from some damn silly dialogue. But that doesn't mean that the comic as a whole sucks; The Matrix offered us the line "Hold on, Dorothy, 'cause Kansas is going bye-bye" or whatever, but it was still generally a good movie.
Again, it's less about proving that the first movie sucks then it is simply about making people realize that nostalgia has blinded them:
http://www.popmatters.com/pm/columns/article/43366/transformers-autobotic-asphyxiation
Monte Williams
06-03-2008, 03:42 PM
Geez, really? That "sweet prince" line was directed at The Nightwatcher? That is lame... and weird.
Really. You'd put that alongside "Zip Neck" and "Camel Breath"?
No, but I needed one for Raphie.
:lol:
Revan
06-03-2008, 05:05 PM
I've seen "OT" mentioned a few times here; what does it stand for, exactly?
OT refers the the 1987 cartoon series. It stands for Old toon.
(2k3 refers to the 4kids cartoon)
To clarify, I don't want to insist that the first movie sucks or anything, and I don't require that it be super serious ('cause really, how seriously should one take a story about anthropomorphic turtles?), but when people dismiss the new movie in favor of blindly celebrating the first movie, I can't help but look at lines like "Elf lips" and wonder what the hell's the matter with people.
I've read through the thread and seen some of your opinions. I have to ask what your stance is on the first movie. You think it's overrated because of bad dialogue?
Monte Williams
06-03-2008, 05:29 PM
Ah, "Old Toon." Gotcha. Thanks for clarifying.
I've read through the thread and seen some of your opinions. I have to ask what your stance is on the first movie. You think it's overrated because of bad dialogue?
I didn't make that clear, huh? ;)
I absolutely LOVED it when it came out, of course (I was thirteen, if that matters.) I dorked out big time for the OT and I loved the movie even more (but even then I thought a rat performing ninja was lame.)
The sequel was a major disappointment (as a heavy metal fan, I REALLY hated Vanilla Ice), and I never watched the third movie.
I haven't seen the first one now in years, but the last time I watched it there were just certain aspects that did little for me. Dialogue was a problem (though there were good bits: "Ninja kick the damn rabbit!" is a highlight.) Some things just fell flat or felt awkward in terms of jokes, and Danny was tiresome... I did like Casey, and I liked their treatment of Raph... for what it was, it holds up pretty well, but it's not the end-all, be-all that some nostalgic types insist it is.
For my money, this is the movie series:
First movie: Pretty damn good.
...
...
New Movie: Quite a bit better.
(I prefer to avoid the two live action sequels.)
Jester
06-03-2008, 07:56 PM
I would recomend my 2 youtube videos on the emotion of the original live action TMNT to you monte, but I dunna if you'd be interested....:P
Andrew NDB
06-03-2008, 08:28 PM
The "TMNT was created as a parody" thing is grossly overstated here, and applies only to its inception, not the story material of the Mirage comics itself. And even if there were subtle jabs at Daredevil, or Ronin, or what-have-you (yes, yes, Hand = Foot, Stick = Splinter, etc.... but you could grandfather on this "parody" factor just as easily to the cartoons and crap, couldn't you?), this was pretty much relegated only to the first issue and nothing else.
"TMNT is serious business" is absolutely hammered out in the Mirage material (from #1 into the Leo, #10, #11 issues, into #19-21, and all of City at War #48-62), though no bones were ever made about the comic taking an occasionally frequent to the left or right along the way (the odyssey across Triceraton space, Savanti stuff, things of this nature).
Revan
06-03-2008, 09:43 PM
"TMNT is serious business" is absolutely hammered out in the Mirage material (from #1 into the Leo, #10, #11 issues, into #19-21, and all of City at War #48-62), though no bones were ever made about the comic taking an occasionally frequent to the left or right along the way (the odyssey across Triceraton space, Savanti stuff, things of this nature).
Those giddy stories aren't really even that bad when compared to Mark Martin's stories. :lol:
Andrew NDB
06-03-2008, 10:21 PM
Those giddy stories aren't really even that bad when compared to Mark Martin's stories. :lol:
None of which were ever considered in canon, even when released (and I don't know anyone carrying around the illusion that they were). And even the "giddy" stories I mention had a good deal of gritty realism in them, where appropriate.
On a sidenote, did you see Mark Martin's pin-up page in the new Tales of the TMNT #46? I wonder if this is even the same Mark Martin... a very macabre side to him, if it is.
Kendamu
06-03-2008, 11:58 PM
The "TMNT was created as a parody" thing is grossly overstated here, and applies only to its inception, not the story material of the Mirage comics itself. And even if there were subtle jabs at Daredevil, or Ronin, or what-have-you (yes, yes, Hand = Foot, Stick = Splinter, etc.... but you could grandfather on this "parody" factor just as easily to the cartoons and crap, couldn't you?), this was pretty much relegated only to the first issue and nothing else.
"TMNT is serious business" is absolutely hammered out in the Mirage material (from #1 into the Leo, #10, #11 issues, into #19-21, and all of City at War #48-62), though no bones were ever made about the comic taking an occasionally frequent to the left or right along the way (the odyssey across Triceraton space, Savanti stuff, things of this nature).
Maybe you see it that way, but what I see are a bunch of turtles (generally slow and "heavy" creatures) being Ninjas (generally light, flexible, and acrobatic) that were raised to fight a security salesman who lives a double life as a Ninja who dresses in bright red and shiny armor.
What's not funny about that?
Oh, and there's the whole comic parody thing, too.
Andrew NDB
06-04-2008, 12:22 AM
Maybe you see it that way, but what I see are a bunch of turtles (generally slow and "heavy" creatures) being Ninjas (generally light, flexible, and acrobatic) that were raised to fight a security salesman who lives a double life as a Ninja who dresses in bright red and shiny armor.
What's not funny about that?
Oh, and there's the whole comic parody thing, too.
Security salesman? You made that up. Protection rackets are a well-documented part of racketeering/the mobs of the past and present. And it was well-established in the same issue that Saki's NY Foot was involved in other avenues including assassination and arms trading.
I didn't find much funny about that at all.
VaughnMichael
06-04-2008, 12:31 AM
On a sidenote, did you see Mark Martin's pin-up page in the new Tales of the TMNT #46? I wonder if this is even the same Mark Martin... a very macabre side to him, if it is.
Yes it's him, as a huge fan of his I visit his blog allot, and he was showing parts of this art pin-up.
I frankly hope they have him come back and do an issue or two as the comics could stand to have a good artist drawing for them, doesn't mean he has to write the story though.
shuriken
06-04-2008, 12:49 AM
Wow... all of this stemming from a simple question asking if an all red Bandana cast of turtles would be cool :lol:. I love forums and their awesome deviations into origin stories and discussions about which movie is better. Oh yeah, I think an all red bandana wearing cast of Turtles would be pretty cool, but very, very, very, very unlikely.
Andrew NDB
06-04-2008, 01:02 AM
I vote for all-black bandannas! :)
VaughnMichael
06-04-2008, 01:12 AM
I vote for all-black bandannas! :)
I secon that vote but then everyone would be all oh they all look like slash!:roll:
Aelia
06-04-2008, 01:13 AM
I vote for all-black bandannas! :)
Bah! Tie-dye is where it's at! :P
Sage Ninja
06-04-2008, 02:00 AM
how about pink?
Aelia
06-04-2008, 02:13 AM
No pink unless it is a slight mauve color.
Sage Ninja
06-04-2008, 02:20 AM
pink is a macho color damn it!! Mauve is for pansy ass sissies!
odupianist
06-04-2008, 08:06 AM
if we're going with pink bandanas, why not give them different colored polos and have them pop their collars while we're at it?
off topic, wasn't the "zip neck" "atomic mouth" dialogue taken directly from the comics but with Raph and Casey?
JusticeForce
06-04-2008, 03:15 PM
Just to jump in regarding the insult-exchange in the first movie/comic being "bad dialogue"...
If those insults were being spouted by the Turtles while they were fighting the Foot, then I would totally agree that would be bad dialogue. But the lines are delivered in a scene that is meant to be a little character vignette. It's a snapshot of dialogue between two teenaged friends (well, one teenager and one man who does not always "act his age") trading insults as a background game to the non-life-threatening but important task at hand. In that regard it succeeds as being well-written dialogue.
Where it fails is the fact that it was originally dialogue between Casey and Raph, in the comics (as odupianist pointed out), and doesn't really suit Don's character at all.
Monte Williams
06-04-2008, 03:19 PM
Even as a teenager, I would never have engaged in such a dialogue with a friend.
In first grade, perhaps...
ToTheNines
06-04-2008, 03:20 PM
Where it fails is the fact that it was originally dialogue between Casey and Raph, in the comics (as odupianist pointed out), and doesn't really suit Don's character at all.
Hardly anything in that movie fit Don's character at all, starting with the asshole who voiced him.
Aelia
06-04-2008, 03:44 PM
Coincidentally, I remember an improv game that my Theatre Arts teacher made us play once. Two students would get up on stage trade insults in alphabetical order but without actually saying any bad words or stuff like that, and then near the end of the game we would have to remember all the words we said and say them in backwards order only at a speed that would make NASCAR drivers blush.
Revan
06-04-2008, 05:51 PM
I vote for all-black bandannas! :)
That could be cool and would make more sense than multicolor bandanas when you think about it.
Even as a teenager, I would never have engaged in such a dialogue with a friend.
In first grade, perhaps...
Every movie has a few lines than don't work for every person watching it. Especially a turtle movie trying to appeal to people of all ages.
JusticeForce
06-04-2008, 06:02 PM
Even as a teenager, I would never have engaged in such a dialogue with a friend.
In first grade, perhaps...Me neither, but the dialogue wasn't meant to establish your personality or my personality, was it? We don't have to be mutants, teenagers, ninjas, or turtles to watch and enjoy a movie about them, so why should all of the dialogue have to be something we would say?
It's not my favorite scene, by any means, I just think it works well at what it is supposed to do, which is to establish the characters and relationship of Casey and Raph... uhm, Don. :ohwell:
Hardly anything in that movie fit Don's character at all, starting with the asshole who voiced him.Which is something that I think the new movie did better than the first - get Don's character right (for the few and far between moments he got screen time).
For the record, I like all of the movies (yes, ALL of them) because they all offer something the others lack. I personally think the first movie is the best overall, espcially in terms of writing and plot, but there are certainly visual and other elements which I enjoy far more in TMNT.
ToTheNines
06-04-2008, 07:15 PM
Which is something that I think the new movie did better than the first - get Don's character right (for the few and far between moments he got screen time).
Meh, that movie really dosen't deserve praise for that. I mean, he fits the "intellegent" achetype.... it isn't that hard to follow. The main reason why it pisses me off is that the first movie was such a good (PG) adaption of the comics, and Don just sticks out like a sore thumb.
Monte Williams
06-04-2008, 08:44 PM
All black bandanas would be much better than all red, in my opinion.
Every movie has a few lines than don't work for every person watching it. Especially a turtle movie trying to appeal to people of all ages.
Heh. Fair enough. I think it's a dumb scene with crappy writing, but I guess it doesn't ruin the whole movie or anything.
Vincent
06-15-2008, 11:53 AM
I don't have a problem with the multicolored masks per se, but I would like to pitch an animated series that's not for kids, which would not air in the morning. I'd call it something like "Red Mask Turtles" and basically have it be an alternative series, much more dramatic, psychological and "dark" than the 4kids show (while retaining that sense of not taking itself all too seriously that makes the TMNT work), perhaps having the characters be slightly older (like Next Mutation, except not being crap) and perhaps Splinter dying in the first or second episode (and only being seen in flashbacks and dreams after that), and with a bunch of intelligent writers who actually know how to get into the psychology of the characters and depth of stories and still be exciting and funny (I'd suggest Peter David for one). That way, kids kan watch 4kids Four Color Teen Turtle Titan Adventure Fluff in the morning and then the nostalgic people who grew up on the TMNT and want a more intelligent take on the premise can watch Red Mask Turtles in the evening or on DVD or the web or whatever. I think it could be a great success (and a much smaller risk than a movie would be), but it seems an unlikely thing to happen unless someone with some power understands that there's an audience, gets their thumb out of their ass and does something.
While I do enjoy both the original comics and first movie and chunks of the 4kids show and the Imagi movie and a bunch of other takes on the material (even finding some cheesy fun in the old toon), I for one would really like to see what would happen if the TMNT were taken beyond anything they've ever been before. The TMNT is an exciting premise with great potential that's only been tapped slightly.
If it can work for Batman ("The Batman" & "Batman: Gotham Knight", et.c.), it should work for TMNT to have several animated incarnations for different audiences at the same time without creating any confusion.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.