View Full Version : SM "FOREVER WAR INTERVIEW" ON Peters "REMASTERED" volume 1: Has he given up?
turkishproverb
06-09-2008, 07:17 PM
I was reading the Murphy interview and I noticed this comment
SM: In terms of publishing, Mirage plans to also put out a sourcebook of characters that have appeared in the official Mirage continuity comics, as well as a TPB reprint of the first TMNT TPB. Our French publisher, Wetta, has also indicated wanting to do something special for the 25th anniversary and we've begun tossing preliminary ideas back and forth.
Now, given that, in regard to the remastered comics, Peter laird has stated in the letercol for TMNT vol. 4 issue number 29 that To date I have only completed one issue --TMNT Vol.1 #1 -- and even that one still needs a few tweaks I didn't have time to do before getting it to the printer so it could see print as the "Special PBBZ Edition a couple of years ago.
Given this, and how Slow Pete's work seems to come in the last decade, I was wondering if there was a possibility that the book would not be a "complete" remaster.
Even so, I still hold out no hope for issue 8 being right, despite the fact peter is has been proven to be telling anything but the truth anytime he says he can't use it because of legal issues.
Roseangelo
06-09-2008, 07:24 PM
Murphy announced the plan to republish the first Collected Book awhile ago. Peter is continuing work at "remastering," and only recently has considered the idea of publishing both versions. I don't think he's given up on the whole project, though.
turkishproverb
06-09-2008, 07:29 PM
Murphy announced the plan to republish the first Collected Book awhile ago. Peter is continuing work at "remastering," and only recently has considered the idea of publishing both versions. I don't think he's given up on the whole project, though.
Both versions, eh? Where was that posted, and where did murphy first post the plan? I must've missed it.
Roseangelo
06-09-2008, 07:32 PM
Both versions, eh? Where was that posted
I think Peter said so in the first "Ask Peter Laird" post to his blog.
and where did murphy first post the plan? I must've missed it.
Awhile back on The 5th Turtle. Maybe January? He announced pretty much all of the publishing plans for next year.
turkishproverb
06-09-2008, 07:38 PM
I think Peter said so in the first "Ask Peter Laird" post to his blog.
Awhile back on The 5th Turtle. Maybe January? He announced pretty much all of the publishing plans for next year.
Thanks, it was in ask peter laird 2. Interestingly, he also hinted at possible reprints of City at war and return to new york in 2009. Nice to know he hasn't forgotten completely.
Roseangelo
06-09-2008, 07:41 PM
Thanks, it was in ask peter laird 2. Interestingly, he also hinted at possible reprints of City at war and return to new york in 2009. Nice to know he hasn't forgotten completely.
Well, as someone pointed out in the comments, the old RTNY collected book is still available for cover price direct from Mirage (at $6, that's probably less than what a new collected book would be priced at today).
turkishproverb
06-09-2008, 07:49 PM
Well, as someone pointed out in the comments, the old RTNY collected book is still available for cover price direct from Mirage (at $6, that's probably less than what a new collected book would be priced at today).
I was really more excited about city at war.
Edit: And Murphy's blog says it will be a remastered TPB. BLECH if it even comes out the right year (which i'm not confidant in) but yay for the "origional style" very special reprint of TMNT 1.
Andrew NDB
06-12-2008, 03:22 PM
Thanks, it was in ask peter laird 2. Interestingly, he also hinted at possible reprints of City at war and return to new york in 2009. Nice to know he hasn't forgotten completely.
Man, the prospect of a toneless/PS-quick-E-toned "Return to New York" redux truly, truly horrifies me.
Roseangelo
06-12-2008, 06:52 PM
Man, the prospect of a toneless/PS-quick-E-toned "Return to New York" redux truly, truly horrifies me.
I'm curious about how far he can go with that whole nonsense. Since Jim penciled RTNY, would he have the right to alter the artwork? Or does Mirage hold the right to do with it as they please?
But you're right. Butchering RTNY could give results far worse than the sample #1 we've already seen.
I do have to wonder if Peter's always been quietly anti-toning all these years. If you look at the issues he worked on alone, or #19, which he toned on his own, they're all very tone-lite.
Mr._Mutant_Man
06-12-2008, 11:37 PM
I was really more excited about city at war.
Edit: And Murphy's blog says it will be a remastered TPB. BLECH if it even comes out the right year (which i'm not confidant in) but yay for the "origional style" very special reprint of TMNT 1.
I kind of wish it were the other way around: release the redone versions as single issues, possibly as a way of seeing if you can get more of the comic audience into the TMNT via a re-release. Then, reprint the original versions in the trade for the hardcore fans.
turkishproverb
06-14-2008, 04:37 AM
I kind of wish it were the other way around: release the redone versions as single issues, possibly as a way of seeing if you can get more of the comic audience into the TMNT via a re-release. Then, reprint the original versions in the trade for the hardcore fans.
Only problem is, comic shops aside single issues are dying.
Mr._Mutant_Man
06-14-2008, 07:51 AM
Only problem is, comic shops aside single issues are dying.
It's been that way for a while. I can't remember the last time I saw a newsstand full of comic books.
I just figure if you can get more of the typical comic book audience into the books, that would already be an improvement. There's probably a lot of comic books fans who know that the TMNT was originally a comic book, but they probably still don't know much about it and might be curious.
I think they should have tried re-releasing the first issues a long time ago. When volume 4 started, I'm sure it didn't help sales when a majority of the people who walk into a comic shop would have picked up the issues and thought, "I know what the Ninja Turtles are, but what the heck is going on?". Re-releasing the comics may be a way of gaining a bit more of an audience.
tOkKa
06-14-2008, 04:12 PM
Only problem is, comic shops aside single issues are dying.
-->> ..evolving may be accurate.. too.
>v<
turkishproverb
06-15-2008, 12:43 AM
Might be. I'd personally like to see anthologies like Shonen Jump exist for regular comics.
Mr._Mutant_Man
06-15-2008, 08:38 AM
Might be. I'd personally like to see anthologies like Shonen Jump exist for regular comics.
That would certainly be more convenient than picking up a million titles each month to catch up with what is going on with Marvel or DC. Maybe they could keep their really popular titles separate (like Amazing Spider-Man and X-Men), but then include everything else in one book every month. I don't know if that would help them get more readers if they made things easier with an anthology type book.
TristanHuwJones
06-15-2008, 04:17 PM
I think anthologizing books the way you're suggesting probably wouldn't go down very well. If Marvel were too keep Spidey running as is but collect say Iron Fist, Daredevil, Moon Knight and Iron Man you'd have outrage all over the place. People who just want to read Moon Knight don't want to be paying a higher price point for the book they love (as it is, comics are pretty expensive -- comparatively anyway) and forcing the to have two or three other titles they may not want or even like would probably put them off completely.
Mr._Mutant_Man
06-15-2008, 04:52 PM
I think anthologizing books the way you're suggesting probably wouldn't go down very well. If Marvel were too keep Spidey running as is but collect say Iron Fist, Daredevil, Moon Knight and Iron Man you'd have outrage all over the place. People who just want to read Moon Knight don't want to be paying a higher price point for the book they love (as it is, comics are pretty expensive -- comparatively anyway) and forcing the to have two or three other titles they may not want or even like would probably put them off completely.
You have a point there, maybe the titles would need a certain degree of popularity to be bundled together successfully. I was thinking along the lines of books that probably don't sell too well could be put together instead of published separately, that way someone is easily able to read about other characters they wouldn't have been able to before because they wouldn't have bothered to buy the single comic. The only way that might work though is by making everything black and white to keep the cost down, but a lot of people seem closed minded on the black and white thing.
I think maybe it could work if you bundled together all the X-Men stuff (too many single titles to keep up with) and the mini-series type stuff. I think all the stuff DC puts out there would have been easier to follow in an anthology type book.
turkishproverb
06-16-2008, 12:43 AM
I think anthologizing books the way you're suggesting probably wouldn't go down very well. If Marvel were too keep Spidey running as is but collect say Iron Fist, Daredevil, Moon Knight and Iron Man you'd have outrage all over the place. People who just want to read Moon Knight don't want to be paying a higher price point for the book they love (as it is, comics are pretty expensive -- comparatively anyway) and forcing the to have two or three other titles they may not want or even like would probably put them off completely.
Look, All I'm saying is that it'd lower publishing costs and is a business model that has worked internationally (States (in form of manga reprint anthologies) UK, EUROPE, Japan, Korea, China, etc.). As to what to bundle, I doubt you'd get half as much outrage as you think, especially past the first year or so. YOu'd have to do subject-related (relativelly) books, with a few main features being virtual constants (spidey) and other works skipping around (Iron fist and moon knight coming and going, etc.)
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.