View Full Version : Ch"rell the utrom Shredder/the fake Oroku Saki
godzod
06-25-2008, 09:35 PM
Does anyone think it will be a great idea if they introduce Ch"rell as the new Shredder in the next film.
Hell no. They already mix&match the TMNT universes too much. I say have some originality or just make it one big mashup universe and be done with it. >_<
Andrew NDB
06-25-2008, 10:28 PM
Apart from liking it being a means of allowing Leonardo to graphically decapitate Oroku Saki on-screen, even in PG-13, I have no interest in the idea.
Revan
06-25-2008, 10:33 PM
Does anyone think it will be a great idea if they introduce Ch"rell as the new Shredder in the next film.
No. The shredder we saw in movie one was hardly someone I would expect a powerful alien to want to impersonate. It felt to me that movie 1 Saki was little more than a jealous assasin. I mean, how hard would it be to find confused youth in NYC to join a "family."
My point, if ch'rell wanted to take up a mantle, there are more respected people than a shredder. Shredder from movie one was basically a crime lord. Why would an alien be interested in that?
VaughnMichael
06-25-2008, 10:35 PM
http://rosswhite.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/05/mr_horse_as_a_gi.png
“No sir, I don’t like it.”
godzod
06-25-2008, 11:26 PM
I just think is better idea to bring Ch"rell as the next Shredder than bringing saki back from the dead.
VaughnMichael
06-25-2008, 11:50 PM
I'd rather see the Worm clone idea from the mirage comics implimented.
And have them show how they try to clone shredder and how they ended up with those 3 crazy clones.
NameGoesHere1066
06-26-2008, 01:00 AM
are you talking about Worms of Madness?
VaughnMichael
06-26-2008, 01:02 AM
are you talking about Worms of Madness?
I'm talking about the mirage comics in the return to new york part where the turtles take on 3 messed up clones of shredder and then leo takes on the worm clone shredder.
godzod
06-28-2008, 01:25 AM
Beside is the perfect way to have a city at war type film,having two factions
of the foot go against each others.One led by Shredder(Ch"rell) and the other by karai.
Na, I think Karai would rather work under Shredder, if they are going to keep to the comics (which I am sure they will). Karai = Adopted daughter of Shredder/Saki, remember? This isn't the cartoon or the comics. This is the movie universe, with it's own set of rules. I wouldn't be surprised if they tried to leave the Utrom idea out all together, since things could get complicated for kids (i.e. the target audience).
And introducing the whole "SHREDDER IS UTROM!!1" idea is just plain silly. I'd rather see how long TMNT can last without introducing the alien idea. We've already seen mutants, super-mutants, time travelling, and alternative dimensions of doom, but I think the movie line can do much more before playing the Utrom card.
godzod
06-28-2008, 02:53 AM
You guys would rather bring back Saki back the dead than have Ch"rell as the Shredder come on. Ch"rell pose a bigger threat to the turtles than Oroku Saki.
ToTheNines
06-28-2008, 07:46 AM
You guys would rather bring back Saki back the dead than have Ch"rell as the Shredder come on. Ch"rell pose a bigger threat to the turtles than Oroku Saki.
How about this, you go write a fanfic about it and pretend it's being made into a movie.
Seriously tho, if you knew anything about the comics you'd know that there are other ways to bring back Shredder. The utrom thing was nice for the 2k3 toon, but they need to (and will, trust me) leave it at that.
Revan
06-28-2008, 11:52 AM
I wouldn't mind them doing one of two things. 1. Either have Karai take up the mantle of shredder or 2. Having no shredder altogether. Shredder is a cool villian but a City at War story would be original and a bit less repetitive.
"Oh shredder is back from the dead... again."
However if they reboot, I would rather see a human being as saki.
Spike Spiegel
06-28-2008, 04:07 PM
I"Oh shredder is back from the dead... again."
However if they reboot, I would rather see a human being as saki.
I feel the same way, it'd be a bit like the Lex Luthor thing in the 70s and 80s Superman movies.
EDIT: I think I posted twice!!
Magneto
06-29-2008, 01:09 AM
If the Shredder is to return, then I would personally prefer it to be via the worm clone scenario that was seen in the Mirage comics. Though I wouldnt be surprised if Laird dictates the Utrom version to be the one for a sequel.
godzod
06-29-2008, 02:25 AM
Part of the problem for me is the turtles have a very weak rogues gallery,Most of them are b level villains at best.The only other villain i want to see more than Shredder(Ch"rell) is Agent Bishop.
Spitfire
06-29-2008, 02:46 AM
You obviously haven't been following turtles for very long then.
godzod
06-29-2008, 03:30 AM
I been a turtles fan for 20 years.In my opinion i can't see villains like Complete Carnage and Savanti Romero, Baxter Stockman and the Triceraton carry the films as the main antagonist.I just think they should add villains from the new toon like Hun,Bishop,Ch"rell in the movie universe.
VaughnMichael
06-29-2008, 03:53 AM
I been a turtles fan for 20 years.In my opinion i can't see villains like Complete Carnage and Savanti Romero, Baxter Stockman and the Triceraton carry the films as the main antagonist.I just think they should add villains from the new toon like Hun,Bishop,Ch"rell in the movie universe.
Hun, Bishop and Utrom Shredder are all 2k3 things the movie is it's own universe taking losely from the mirage comics with a hint of the old toon.
I don't know if you think things like this will go well in the new movie world because Karai was in the new movie but she first and foremost a Mirage character before a 2k3 character.
I seriously think that if they did a movie with both the rat king and baxter in it that it could do very well.
While the entire time in the background the foot is trying to clone the shredder just like they did in the mirage comics.
I think to say the turtles rogues gallery is week is a bit silly, but hey why should anyone else really take them or the turtles all that seriously when Peter himself doesn't really think that much of them.
Drtooth
06-29-2008, 09:35 AM
http://rosswhite.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/05/mr_horse_as_a_gi.png
“No sir, I don’t like it.”
A quintillion internets to you!
I think, as long as another film gets made, Karai should be the Shredder. Though it would be great to see a plot revolving around Baxter Stockman or the Rat King or something like that.
tOkKa
06-29-2008, 05:53 PM
-->> ..grown a bit fond of Ch'rell tho' .. no movie me liken ..
but i don't mind looking forward to him back in the toon.
He's a nasty little f7cker and formidable..
>v<
shuriken
06-29-2008, 07:27 PM
Yeah...I really wouldn't like to get an Utrom Shredder in the next movie. A worm shredder/clone shredder or Baxter and or Rat King would be awesome.
godzod
06-30-2008, 02:12 AM
I think villains like Baxter Stockman and the Rat king work better as side villain than being the main antagonists in the film.
Dude, have you even seen "I, Monster"? Or read at least the issue when Rat King was introduced? Introducing characters like the Rat King is just what we need - new blood for villains. And Baxter can be an equally dangerous threat to the TMNT as Shredder will ever be able to, alien or not. Heck, I think a Baxter and Rat King team up (maybe Baxter creating the Rat King under the orders of the Foot?) would be better than having Shredder come back fully.
ToTheNines
06-30-2008, 03:45 PM
Heck, I think a Baxter and Rat King team up (maybe Baxter creating the Rat King under the orders of the Foot?) would be better than having Shredder come back fully.
Well, Baxter's mousers kill rats. So I was thinking more of a Stockman v. Ratking v. TMNT, that could get interesting.
VaughnMichael
06-30-2008, 05:07 PM
Well, Baxter's mousers kill rats. So I was thinking more of a Stockman v. Ratking v. TMNT, that could get interesting.
That's exactly the plot I've got together and it has leo and mike teaming up and raph and don.
If I was to make a tmnt movie it'd be differnt for sure and having things we hardly ever see happen.
That's one of my major gripes with the turtles franchise everything is so redundant.
shuriken
07-01-2008, 12:36 AM
Out of those a City at War movie would be bithchin. But as stated before a new idea with a fresh slate (by that I mean a non adaptation that includes Villians from the comics but doesn't rely solely on a particular set of comics and or a comic). For example, use a Baxter Karai Team up against a rebel Foot Group which also includes the Purple Dragons with the Turtles getting into the mix, which also incorperates City At War elements.
Or April getting a Job with Baxter and the creation of the mousers. Baxter sells thousands of Mouser units to eliminate the huge mouse/rat problem in NY. But he also controls the mousers to steal millions of dollars and hold the city ransom. Thus attracts the attention of Both the Turtles and a new villain, the Rat King!(these are just an idea so don't hurt me). Or they could use more aliens and aztec gods or whatever...
Yeah. I think you (ToTheNines) and I are on the same( if not very similar) page.
godzod
07-01-2008, 01:53 AM
While i don't mind seeing Baxter Skockman and the Rat King i not sure they can work as the main villains.The Rat king is more of a neutral character and Baxter Stockman is more of a henchman type villain.
VaughnMichael
07-01-2008, 03:08 AM
While i don't mind seeing Baxter Skockman and the Rat King i not sure they can work as the main villains.The Rat king is more of a neutral character and Baxter Stockman is more of a henchman type villain.
Um Baxter Stockman was always his own man in the Mirage comics, and the Rat King was a mysterious character until recently in the Mirage comics as well so I'd hardly call some one who tormented Splinter neutral.
godzod
07-01-2008, 04:21 AM
I know Baxter Stockman has been independent villain in mirage comic, But for the most part he been a henchman both in the old and new cartoon to Shredder and now working for Bishop.I not sure people want to see a mad scientist as the main antagonist.The Rat King's spirit did help Splinter in caw,I always thought he was too ambiguous to be consider a villain.
odupianist
07-01-2008, 08:08 AM
dude, you're not going to change people's minds. Unless they create a new villian, Baxter and the Rat King would probably be their best or maybe their most ideal choice as a villian in the next movie.
godzod
07-01-2008, 09:43 AM
My point is the turtles have a weak rogues gallery in the mirage universe,that why the new cartoon had to create hun, Bishop,Ch"rell and other character.
the old toon had to create Bebop,Rocksteady,Krang and other villains.Hell even the archie comic did the same thing.
Spitfire
07-02-2008, 04:36 PM
I've heard that tossed around quite a bit recently. The turtles has plenty of villains. Sure they don't appear very often but turtles was never big on encounters with the same villains a million times. Even Shredder was dusted in a few issues and he's supposedly the main villain. There's plenty of guys they could use for the film.
I agree the toon makes them stronger but as far as the comic goes they are still some strong powerful villains.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
08-27-2008, 09:57 AM
If you want evil brain-like aliens, you always have Krang.
ZariusTwo
08-29-2008, 09:37 AM
I been a turtles fan for 20 years.In my opinion i can't see villains like Complete Carnage and Savanti Romero, Baxter Stockman and the Triceraton carry the films as the main antagonist
...That's quite an idiotic mentality to have, considering The Triceratons were the focus of two very major arcs that are arguably feature-length when put together
thebrownranger
08-29-2008, 10:40 AM
Hell no.
Agreed. It's too much of a stupid concept if they want to come out with a PG-13-ish live action/cgi tone (which I highly doubt will happen).
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
08-29-2008, 10:53 AM
I been a turtles fan for 20 years.In my opinion i can't see villains like Complete Carnage and Savanti Romero, Baxter Stockman and the Triceraton carry the films as the main antagonist.I just think they should add villains from the new toon like Hun,Bishop,Ch"rell in the movie universe.
Baxter Stockman is one of the most well-known TMNT characters ever, so even those who didn't read the Mirage comics but only watched the 1987 cartoon will know who it is (even if his appearance not will be the same).
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.