View Full Version : Eastman confirms meeting with Steve Barron for new film?!!
Krutch
09-01-2008, 04:32 AM
Skimming over Heavymetal.com, I'm noticing that a few hours ago he replied to a thread asking him about the status of the sequel. He replied:
"Yes, it is true. Although the CGI film did well enough to warrent a sequel, there has been much talk between Imagi and Warners to do a better "re-invention" (newest Hollywood buzzword) of the TMNT's, in a live action film--like what was done with Batman. Back to basics, back to the origin and the intro of the Shredder, etc...there have been talks, trips to Northampton to talk to Mr Laird, and discussions with the original "first" TMNT film director Steve Barron to come back and do it right--but no official word yet...will keep you posted. Best, Kevin"
Wow. I dont know what to say. I mean, I know theres a long way to go and this is far from any guarantee, but what do u guys think? Steve Barron once again at the helm? I'm kind of excited, but the way he put it, it kinda seems like he'd be making the same movie...
Andrew NDB
09-01-2008, 05:06 AM
Interesting. But why is the word "Imagi" still in there?
junkboy
09-01-2008, 05:20 AM
I am happy with a live action movie. I did love the animated one but i think we all need another live action movie.
If it is indeed resurrected as it is done for Batman... in a good way, i will be more than happy.
If something like that happens, i hope Raph does not speak with a voice alike Batman of Dark Knight tho. :)
I hate Bale's Batman voice. :evil: It's just plain silly and out of character. So, yeah, that would suck if they tried giving that voice to one of the Turtles.
Drtooth
09-01-2008, 10:20 AM
I'd love for them to try one as Dark as the Batman film.. even if they could get one as "not quite dark, but the characters still have a serious threat" as Iron Man and Spider-Man.
Not "as dark as we can get so parental groups don't get up our butts, so we have to make it a G film, but lable it PG" like the last one was.
junkboy
09-01-2008, 10:20 AM
In the first movie, it was not bad, but he second one was pure overkill about that voice thing.
If it is an origin story and it will be about Shredder, i believe it will be more serious. I would not believe it to be
dark ( tho i would like it to be a bit )
Dragon Turtle
09-01-2008, 10:42 AM
Interesting. But why is the word "Imagi" still in there?
Maybe these are just talks between Imagi and Warner Bros who are still interested in doing a sequel, both were connected to the sequel deal that expired, and Felix Ip did mention that Imagi had done work on new CGI turtle models for a CGI/live action movie.
Warhorse
09-01-2008, 11:05 AM
I am happy with a live action movie. I did love the animated one but i think we all need another live action movie.
If it is indeed resurrected as it is done for Batman... in a good way, i will be more than happy.
If something like that happens, i hope Raph does not speak with a voice alike Batman of Dark Knight tho. :)
I sure hope not. I really would like to see them keep the same voice actors that they used for the prior movie. They pretty much nailed the ideal voices for me. Only change I might make, would perhaps bring in Robbie Rist to reprise Mikey, but it wont break or make the movie either way without him.
AquaParade
09-01-2008, 11:23 AM
The first ninja turtles movie is my favorite piece of tmnt ever...Count me in. Really hope we can get some more info on the new movie soon...all these rumors are killin me.
CyberCubed
09-01-2008, 11:24 AM
Ugh, I hope this doesn't mean they're going to restart continuity again.
I have absolutely no desire to see the Turtles origin story, their first meeting with April, and there first interactions with Shredder rehashed for the billionth time.
The first movie did this perfectly, I have no desire to see a "copy."
One reason I liked the 4th movie is we didn't have to sit through a repeat of what we saw before, it was a NEW story and had Karai as the leader of the Foot. I would have much rathered the 5th movie continue to show Karai as the leader and go from there.
Here's hoping Pete debates about the story or whatever because I don't want to see a rehash.
Evilsherbear
09-01-2008, 11:39 AM
I'm not that into a redo of the origins either. I'd rather see a new story (like the 4th movie) rather than the same one with a "twist" or "darker" or whatever they're labeling it.
I'd love to see it live action, but I hope they put the time and effort into it to make the turtles look good.
AquaParade
09-01-2008, 11:51 AM
Ugh, I hope this doesn't mean they're going to restart continuity again.
I have absolutely no desire to see the Turtles origin story, their first meeting with April, and there first interactions with Shredder rehashed for the billionth time.
The first movie did this perfectly, I have no desire to see a "copy."
One reason I liked the 4th movie is we didn't have to sit through a repeat of what we saw before, it was a NEW story and had Karai as the leader of the Foot. I would have much rathered the 5th movie continue to show Karai as the leader and go from there.
Here's hoping Pete debates about the story or whatever because I don't want to see a rehash.
Totally understandable, but hopefully we will get it in a way a lot more rooted to the original comic and it's themes. If done just right, which would make it a pretty different monster then most tmnt rehashes we've seen, you may just end up not minding the fact that it's another origin story.
Jester
09-01-2008, 12:18 PM
I hate Bale's Batman voice. :evil: It's just plain silly and out of character. So, yeah, that would suck if they tried giving that voice to one of the Turtles.
w2yv8aT0UFc
Tehe...love this bit.
If they bring Barron back, maybe they could just do a Barron's TMNT 2, like WB did with the Donnor cut of Superman 2. That'd I'd go for, but I'm not sure how many other fans would be ok with that route, one that threw out TMNT 2 and 3, and started fresh with a direct sequel to what everyone would agree is the best movie adaptation the Turtles have received.
junkboy
09-01-2008, 12:32 PM
I do not see an origin story as a waste of time or something like that.
As for Batman, the new movies really resurrected the character on big screen. There are ppl around thinking that the new Joker is much better than Jack Nicholson. (duh?!) ( i do not think that way, but even such a comparison is a very very huge success imo )
whatever...
If they will make a new story , i think it might be in the animated way.
Karai at the reins...
But for the live action one, i prefer an origins story. And really connected to the Mirage origin. Telling more about the alien stuff. Also if they wanna make a live action one, and they want it to be something big, making it an origin one might increase its success.
Ppl reading comics is minority and we guys, followers of Mirage comics are even less in the big ocean... Lots of ppl thought, there was nothing done for TMNT other than the old cartoon and movies till the new animated movie, unaware of comics.
There are tons of ppl around still asking why all their bandanas are red? ( nearly all my friends asked me about it when i bought my NECA boxed set and i was bored answering that - thanks god that i am kind of a lonely guy and do not have too many friends. hah
SO.. the new live action movie can be an origin movie good enough to satisfy a hardcore fan, and at the same time someone who is unaware that TMNT has been going on since years. If they can manage that, kudos to them.
P.S. - making the movie darker is not the only way to do that, but i think it is simple and needs less effort.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-01-2008, 12:44 PM
Don't bring back all having red bandanas. It's just confusing after all those years of bandanas in different colors. People will just wonder if Donatello cloned Raphael.
junkboy
09-01-2008, 12:52 PM
Don't bring back all having red bandanas. It's just confusing after all those years of bandanas in different colors. People will just wonder if Donatello cloned Raphael.
Oh you may be right... Ppl around me will start to ask each why they all wear red as the movie starts in theater. Geez, what a nightmare for me.
NameGoesHere1066
09-01-2008, 12:55 PM
post a link to the forum of Kevin saying this. Other wise I'm not believing or speculating on nothing. I've been burned by false news about a possiable live action sequal and I'm not even going to even consider it as valid till I see physical proof. If you can't, then this is my last post in this thread.
junkboy
09-01-2008, 12:57 PM
http://metaltv.rightangleinc.com/mboard/read.php?4,14844
SHREDDER-X
09-01-2008, 12:57 PM
Don't bring back all having red bandanas. It's just confusing after all those years of bandanas in different colors. People will just wonder if Donatello cloned Raphael.
Why not have them all start off wearing the same color masks until they meet April, who convinces them to wear different colors so that it will be easier to tell them apart ( In which Rapheal, being the rebel that he is, refuses and keeps his original color.)
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-01-2008, 01:01 PM
Oh you may be right... Ppl around me will start to ask each why they all wear red as the movie starts in theater. Geez, what a nightmare for me.
If they feel they "have" to bring it back, they can have a text appearing in the cinema before the film begins: "Attention everybody! All the TMNT wear red bandanas in the 1984 Mirage comics, that's because they do so in this film. So don't ask why they are the "Teenage Clone Ninja Raphaels". :)
Ugh, I hope this doesn't mean they're going to restart continuity again.
I have absolutely no desire to see the Turtles origin story, their first meeting with April, and there first interactions with Shredder rehashed for the billionth time.
The first movie did this perfectly, I have no desire to see a "copy."
One reason I liked the 4th movie is we didn't have to sit through a repeat of what we saw before, it was a NEW story and had Karai as the leader of the Foot. I would have much rathered the 5th movie continue to show Karai as the leader and go from there.
Here's hoping Pete debates about the story or whatever because I don't want to see a rehash.
Agreed. I'd rather see a continuance than a restart. Their origin has been done enough times. This franchise doesn't have the same immense fanbase (or financial backing) as Batman so tossing remakes left and right is quite a risk.
NameGoesHere1066
09-01-2008, 01:34 PM
http://metaltv.rightangleinc.com/mboard/read.php?4,14844
thankyou. This is interesting.
AquaParade
09-01-2008, 01:57 PM
Agreed. I'd rather see a continuance than a restart. Their origin has been done enough times. This franchise doesn't have the same immense fanbase (or financial backing) as Batman so tossing remakes left and right is quite a risk.
It would be a risk if that was the case, but do you really see the tmnt as having a lot of origin stories compared to other properties?
The TMNT need a fresh start in the eyes of the public, imho, a movie that finally captures the magic of the comics. The point is, the tmnt can not re-establish themselves in a way more close to the source material without a new beginning...you can't change public icons so drastically, without starting the story over.
However, you could always do the origin story in a more free form creative way, and have bits and pieces of the past throughout a trilogy, leaving room for a sequel involving the utroms and the turtles origins and whatnot...you could really go places with something like that.
It would be a risk if that was the case, but do you really see the tmnt as having a lot of origin stories compared to other properties?
No, and that's a good thing. We saw an origin in the Mirage book (of course), the OT, and the first film. I think it's already been established how it all happened, so why spend an already questionable budget on another one? It's folly. It'd be better cost-effective to just begin with a new adventure that continues where we left off. I don't see how we need a reminder.
Slap-Happy
09-01-2008, 02:04 PM
Why not have them all start off wearing the same color masks until they meet April, who convinces them to wear different colors so that it will be easier to tell them apart ( In which Rapheal, being the rebel that he is, refuses and keeps his original color.)
I've been thinking about that, what if there where colored and red masks in the same continuity?
CJStyles
09-01-2008, 02:28 PM
I'm on the fence about a retelling of an origin story. It'd be nice to see it done in a more mature fashion, but the first movie was done perfectly in my opinion. I just want to see a more mature TMNT movie. Which of course has been said a billion times over with the response "TMNT is a children's property!"... so I'm kind of wasting my time saying this.
However, I can see both sides of the coin. I just hope Warner Brothers will let them go for a PG-13 rating in this "re-invention" and bring on people who will do the franchise justice like Barron did. If we can get an edgy and darker film like the original and it be a good story, whether origin or a continuation, I'd be very happy with it
Slap-Happy
09-01-2008, 02:39 PM
A dark movie could end up like TDK or something horrible
Jester
09-01-2008, 02:47 PM
I've been thinking about that, what if there where colored and red masks in the same continuity?
Archie did it....:P
Slap-Happy
09-01-2008, 02:50 PM
Archie did it....:P
OH yeah!, I forgot about that.
AquaParade
09-01-2008, 02:54 PM
No, and that's a good thing. We saw an origin in the Mirage book (of course), the OT, and the first film. I think it's already been established how it all happened, so why spend an already questionable budget on another one? It's folly. It'd be better cost-effective to just begin with a new adventure that continues where we left off. I don't see how we need a reminder.
I see what you're saying, so I guess to see what I am saying you must share this point of view: The tmnt need a fresh start in the media, that is more representative of the early comics and all the potential in them. I think mirage may see it this way as well, otherwise they would just continue in the form of TMNT 2007. If we were going with tmnt 07, an origin story would be useless. If were trying to show the world who the tmnt really are...we need a reboot.
ToTheNines
09-01-2008, 02:59 PM
If were trying to show the world who the tmnt really are...we need a reboot.
Exactly, leave it to the sequel for something new.
I see what you're saying, so I guess to see what I am saying you must share this point of view: The tmnt need a fresh start in the media, that is more representative of the early comics and all the potential in them. I think mirage may see it this way as well, otherwise they would just continue in the form of TMNT 2007. If we were going with tmnt 07, an origin story would be useless. If were trying to show the world who the tmnt really are...we need a reboot.
So, in other words, we need another 1990 film, but without colored bandanas, pizza, and April as a reporter.
ToTheNines
09-01-2008, 03:16 PM
So, in other words, we need another 1990 film, but without colored bandanas, pizza, and April as a reporter.
Get some good writers on the scene and alot can be changed for the better while still taking the overall plot from the same comic books.
Get some good writers on the scene and alot can be changed for the better while still taking the overall plot from the same comic books.
Isn't that what the 1990 film was?
Jester
09-01-2008, 03:27 PM
I take it I'm alone in the Steve Barron's TMNT 2 department...:P
ToTheNines
09-01-2008, 03:42 PM
Isn't that what the 1990 film was?
Meh, yeah. But there's more than one way to peel a banana, and they all consist of good writing and creativity.
Cipher
09-01-2008, 05:24 PM
Isn't that what the 1990 film was?Why does "TMNT origin in tone with the comics" have to mean "carbon copy of the first movie"? There are multiple ways to arrange the elements of origin story, Shredder, and dark tone without repeats.
For example, there have been two dark Batman movies about the Joker in the last two decades. They're nothing alike, and I wouldn't call either bad.
cup-mikey-gertha
09-01-2008, 05:47 PM
I am happy with a live action movie. I did love the animated one but i think we all need another live action movie.
If it is indeed resurrected as it is done for Batman... in a good way, i will be more than happy.
If something like that happens, i hope Raph does not speak with a voice alike Batman of Dark Knight tho. :)
You had me laugh out loud. :lol: But, don't get me wrong. I'm OK with Bale's voice as Batman. Just imagine if Batman's voice is same as Bruce Wayne's, it's like sooner or later, "Hey, Bats! You sound just like Wayne. Are you that millioner guy?" So much for secret identities. It's just that your comment is funny. Now, imagine Raph's voice as the original and when he turns Nightwatcher it becomes Bale Batman's. Ha-ha-ha-ha! :lol:
Why does "TMNT origin in tone with the comics" have to mean "carbon copy of the first movie"? There are multiple ways to arrange the elements of origin story, Shredder, and dark tone without repeats.
Well, let's see... The origin in the movie was pretty much a carbon copy of the comics. You really can't get any closer than that without making it a panel-by-panel scene as used in the 2003 Hulk film. But I like your multiple ways theory. Can you offer some examples?
Cipher
09-01-2008, 08:02 PM
Well, let's see... The origin in the movie was pretty much a carbon copy of the comics. You really can't get any closer than that without making it a panel-by-panel scene as used in the 2003 Hulk film. But I like your multiple ways theory. Can you offer some examples?It doesn't have to follow the comics either, though. For example, I think it might actually be smarter to bring the Shredder in starting with the second movie. You could spend the first movie on April, Casey, the origin, and Baxter. Hell, you could even have Baxter become a mutant fly to throw nostalgics a bone as long as you keep it dark.
A reboot in tone with the comics doesn't have to mean it has to take its plot directly from the comics. It just has to reintroduce the Turtles to people.
Drtooth
09-01-2008, 09:01 PM
Ugh, I hope this doesn't mean they're going to restart continuity again.
I have absolutely no desire to see the Turtles origin story, their first meeting with April, and there first interactions with Shredder rehashed for the billionth time.
The first movie did this perfectly, I have no desire to see a "copy."
One reason I liked the 4th movie is we didn't have to sit through a repeat of what we saw before, it was a NEW story and had Karai as the leader of the Foot. I would have much rathered the 5th movie continue to show Karai as the leader and go from there.
Here's hoping Pete debates about the story or whatever because I don't want to see a rehash.
Couldn't agree more. You CAN make a darker film reimagined withOUT having to keep remaking the origin a milliondy times. I want to see the tention between the turtles and Karai. I wanna see Stockman and Bishop and Rat King somehow worked in. I don't want to see April re-re-re-re-re-remeating the Turtles (unless they have the original Baxter line... and even then, I just ddon;t want another origin film).
I wanna see something that could work as TMNT5 that has a dark turn. look at harry potter.... Half Blood Prince is gonna be PG-13. They didn't have to go back and remake the first 4 movies to reimagine it for a more adult audience.
Jester
09-01-2008, 09:07 PM
I'm sure that the big thing is the origin for the TMNT is done in every incarnation so far....except maybe NM...to re do it a 6th (MIrage, Old Toon, Archie, 1st movie, new toon) is a bit much.
It doesn't have to follow the comics either, though. For example, I think it might actually be smarter to bring the Shredder in starting with the second movie. You could spend the first movie on April, Casey, the origin, and Baxter. Hell, you could even have Baxter become a mutant fly to throw nostalgics a bone as long as you keep it dark.
A reboot in tone with the comics doesn't have to mean it has to take its plot directly from the comics. It just has to reintroduce the Turtles to people.
I could see that. Though the Baxter-into-fly thing would be a bad turn. I think the Mousers would be enough.
AquaParade
09-01-2008, 10:58 PM
Back to the darker yet still comedic and spirited roots, Start with a baxter story...save the origin, we can keep it a mystery for now. Save room for a sequel with an origin story involving tcri, or utroms, or the Shredder. Third Movie...City at War...I can only hope.
Andrew NDB
09-02-2008, 02:13 AM
Don't bring back all having red bandanas. It's just confusing after all those years of bandanas in different colors. People will just wonder if Donatello cloned Raphael.
People that wonder that deserve it. Give them all red.
Spitfire
09-02-2008, 03:37 AM
Eh Barron isn't really the best choice. The only thing he ever did I thought was impressive was "Merlin" and that was by TV standards. As a movie director he's done mostly crap and I'll be honest the sole appeal of the first turtles movie for me are my childhood ties to turtles and the costume work, which was and still is pretty good. As a film it's pretty "meh" and really doesn't do anything else well.
As for the red bandannas they'd be stone cold retarded to switch the colors. I've had numerous people ask me why the turtles in all my posters or on the covers of my comics have red masks. People, and kids especially, identify with the colors. "I liked the purple one what was his name again?" If they want this to work and have appeal to both old and new fans they can't switch the colors. Honestly the only fans who want or even know about the red masks are the comic fans, which turtles has zero new comic fans I'm sure.
It's not a bad idea but horrible business. Movies is about making money. Unless you're doing an independent film on a shoe string budget off the good graces of others giving you grants you don't really get to do whatever you want. This is turtles here so they don't get that luxury. It's funny to because people ask why they were all the same color and if it gets confusing. My answer is always, "Well the comics in black and white..." Honestly in medium where their speaking red masks is the best way for that to work too. But the first cartoon changed that all and the public will never shake that. Unless a later reboot happens but it'd have to be after turtles dies out.
tOkKa
09-02-2008, 05:08 AM
http://www.terrible2z.com/coleco-wh0rehouse/sewer/jerseydevil-smack1.jpg
-->> ..claw m'eyes out..
.. just good to see Kevin's name there on this ..>v<
Andrew NDB
09-02-2008, 05:14 AM
I think a ninja clan color-coding themselves just so toddlers don't get them mixed up on the toy shelf when they go to buy their toys is asinine... but if I've got to pick my battles on a proper TMNT comic book-deriven movie, I'll admit it's fairly low on the list.
And yes, Steve Barron isn't really that exciting of a choice. He's a competant director... but as has been pointed out, all he's really done in the 18 years since TMNT in 1990 was Merlin and the Coneheads bomb. His directorial prime has pretty much passed, and even now is in what is considered "Directorial Prison"... which seldom offers a way out.
I'm not even sure at this point he'd even have much more pull in Hollywood than Kevin Munroe did on the last movie... and I have no interest in seeing another movie made by committee.
Drtooth
09-02-2008, 09:53 AM
I think a ninja clan color-coding themselves just so toddlers don't get them mixed up on the toy shelf when they go to buy their toys is asinine... but if I've got to pick my battles on a proper TMNT comic book-deriven movie, I'll admit it's fairly low on the list.
Personally, I thought it was always "color co-ordinate them" so we could use the same sculpt and just paint it different colors so it would be a "Unique figure."
For a totally comic based live action movie origin story, I'd wait 5 years. That's just me. I want something that's a floating sequal, but with more pull behind it.
AquaParade
09-02-2008, 11:22 AM
And yes, Steve Barron isn't really that exciting of a choice. He's a competant director... but as has been pointed out, all he's really done in the 18 years since TMNT in 1990 was Merlin and the Coneheads bomb. His directorial prime has pretty much passed, and even now is in what is considered "Directorial Prison"... which seldom offers a way out.
I'm not even sure at this point he'd even have much more pull in Hollywood than Kevin Munroe did on the last movie... and I have no interest in seeing another movie made by committee.
You're right in saying he is not the most exciting choice, but I think the fact that they wanna take it back to the roots is exciting in itself. If this is the case, I'm sure Peter Laird and maybe Kevin would have some important involvement.
staypuftweepel
09-02-2008, 11:58 AM
So is anyone else really confused on what Kevin Eastman actually sold out of? I was looking at the buyout in the March 2008 posts on ninjaturtles.com and I'm really confused on why Kevin Eastman is still working on these projects. I'm really glad that he is continuing to work on some of the Turtles projects, but just confused on what exactly he isn't involved with.
That being said I'm pretty glad that they're intested in making a new movie that's dark like the original comics. I wouldn't leave the bandanas all red because personally I like the multi color look. I do wonder if kids and most people would be a little confused if it's a reboot. That last one just came out only like a year ago. I would think most people would assume that it's a continuation.
I think what would be cool is if they did a story similar to Return to New York and City at War. Where you have Karai as the new foot leader, but the foot elite have decided to clone who they think is the real Shredder. And then you have the Turtles get in the middle of this fight between Karai trying to hold on to her leadership and a Shredder who's trying to take his empire back. You could even work in the three worm clones. Too bad they haven't had Triceraton's in the movies yet. It'd be neat to have Zog in there too.
I think it would be nice if they did do an origin story, but twisted it around a little bit and maybe added Baxter Stockman. I dont' know if mousers are such a good idea though for a Turtle movie. I think most people owuldn't find them to be very exciting. It just may seem that if the Turtles are running after these little robots people wouldn't take it so serious. I would like to see either animatronic, puppet, or 3D triceratons though.
-Gary
Hmm... You know, having them all wearing red bandanas will just leave us with the chore of distinguishing them by their weapons. But with a movie, their voices and attitudes would help immensely. Also, their body structure could be altered to fit their personality. Raph could appear more bulky since he likes to work out and is the powerhouse of the group, Mikey could have a wiry look since he's the comedian and a bit more agile, Don would have the normal build, being the level-headed one, and Leo's physique would be in the middle of Don and Raph -- a bit more muscular than Don, but thinner than Raphael.
I think if it was done that way, a bit akin to how their facial structure was in the live action films, the all red bandana thing wouldn't be too much of a problem. And how about film it in Sin City style?
the fixer
09-02-2008, 01:07 PM
All this is great news...
Wow... I sure hope they bring back Barron. That guy did an amazing job back in 1990.
Anyway... Revamp of the origin or not, I'd really love to see some Mousers in this one. They haven't appeared on the silver screen and they more than deserve it :)
MOUSERS = COOL
Hmm... You know, having them all wearing red bandanas will just leave us with the chore of distinguishing them by their weapons. But with a movie, their voices and attitudes would help immensely. Also, their body structure could be altered to fit their personality. Raph could appear more bulky since he likes to work out and is the powerhouse of the group, Mikey could have a wiry look since he's the comedian and a bit more agile, Don would have the normal build, being the level-headed one, and Leo's physique would be in the middle of Don and Raph -- a bit more muscular than Don, but thinner than Raphael.
I think if it was done that way, a bit akin to how their facial structure was in the live action films, the all red bandana thing wouldn't be too much of a problem.
You do have a point, but I sadly think they will never put all red bandanas in a Turtles film. They'll "think of the kids".
And how about film it in Sin City style?
Actually, that wouldn't be a bad idea... I take it you mean with black & white turtles with all red bandanas...
Yeah... I could see that working. It would definately be cool...
Still... I reckon they won't go for that idea...
They'll "think of the kids".
ToTheNines
09-02-2008, 02:38 PM
I'm sure that the big thing is the origin for the TMNT is done in every incarnation so far....except maybe NM...to re do it a 6th (MIrage, Old Toon, Archie, 1st movie, new toon) is a bit much.
Well, we've seen/read it 6 different times, but it isn't really about us. Most people have sat through the origin 2 times (even 3 is pushing it), so it's not a bad idea if the plan is to "re-introduce" the characters.
It's like Batman Begins, they showed the origin because they were re-inventing the character and his universe. Everyone knows Bruce's parents were killed when he was a kid and then he dissapeared to become this legendary crime-fighter and came back to Gotham. Begins just wanted to add some cool stuff to that and make some "realistic" sense.
Sage Ninja
09-02-2008, 03:40 PM
Hmm... You know, having them all wearing red bandanas will just leave us with the chore of distinguishing them by their weapons. But with a movie, their voices and attitudes would help immensely. Also, their body structure could be altered to fit their personality. Raph could appear more bulky since he likes to work out and is the powerhouse of the group, Mikey could have a wiry look since he's the comedian and a bit more agile, Don would have the normal build, being the level-headed one, and Leo's physique would be in the middle of Don and Raph -- a bit more muscular than Don, but thinner than Raphael.
I think if it was done that way, a bit akin to how their facial structure was in the live action films, the all red bandana thing wouldn't be too much of a problem. And how about film it in Sin City style?
I say hell no to that, because they will stero-type their body types to much. I know they will make Raphael a juggernut, and Donatello a male Balerinna, and Michaelangelo will look like an awkward, gangly limbed, pimple faced twelve year old who hasn't reached puberty yet, that'll probably only be waist high to all his other brothers in hight. :dead: As far apperances go, they really need to stop giving the boys these cookie cutter physical attributes.
Andrew NDB
09-02-2008, 04:02 PM
Hmm... You know, having them all wearing red bandanas will just leave us with the chore of distinguishing them by their weapons.
Boo hoo. We've had little/no problem distinguishing them for the most part in comics for the past 25 years... and those are in black and white.
And mark me down for the "Reboot without an origin retelling" if I had a choice. Some comment can be made by one of the Turtles about being exposed to ooze as petshop Turtles or something over the course of the film and that should be sufficient, if anything.
But still... people seem to forget that by the time if/when a new movie comes out it will have been 20 or more years since the last TMNT origin was seen on screen. It's not entirely bad taste to take another crack at it by this point.
So is anyone else really confused on what Kevin Eastman actually sold out of? I was looking at the buyout in the March 2008 posts on ninjaturtles.com and I'm really confused on why Kevin Eastman is still working on these projects.
I'm not confused at all. Nothing is preventing whatever studio or company is putting together the film from hiring Eastman as a producer or executive producer, or even a creative consultant. What rights he has (which is basically none now) is irrelevant.
Of course... that doesn't mean Peter Laird has to sign off on such a thing. A studio could approach Peter Laird and say, "Yo, Pete, wuz good, man? We took it upon ourselves to bring Kevin Eastman aboard and we're working on an idea to bring to you about --" and Pete can just tell them to go bugger off and that'll be end of the movie.
Spitfire
09-02-2008, 04:17 PM
You know they say the best way to expose exposition is gracefully and unknowingly to the audience. Every turtles story has failed at this horribly especially the origin based things because it right up tells you everything that happened in one long boring narration.
TerranigmaFreak
09-02-2008, 04:51 PM
They can easily rebuild and reintroduce the story by following the CGI movie. I've seen the introduction of the TMNT 5 times already. 1. Original comics 2. Archie Comics 3. Archie Cartoon 4. First movie 5. TMNT2k3 I don't want to watch it a 6th time.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-02-2008, 05:02 PM
I agree. You can also borrow the background story from another TMNT universe with some references, and create another to directly start with another, like the Archie comics did with the 1987 cartoon (even if they adapted the first episodes).
SHREDDER-X
09-02-2008, 06:29 PM
Hmm... You know, having them all wearing red bandanas will just leave us with the chore of distinguishing them by their weapons. But with a movie, their voices and attitudes would help immensely. Also, their body structure could be altered to fit their personality. Raph could appear more bulky since he likes to work out and is the powerhouse of the group, Mikey could have a wiry look since he's the comedian and a bit more agile, Don would have the normal build, being the level-headed one, and Leo's physique would be in the middle of Don and Raph -- a bit more muscular than Don, but thinner than Raphael.
I think if it was done that way, a bit akin to how their facial structure was in the live action films, the all red bandana thing wouldn't be too much of a problem. And how about film it in Sin City style?
I agree 100% Krow. And as for a turtle movie did in Sin City style ? I say HELL YEAH !!!! Since the turtles started off as a B&W comic, what better way to take it back to it's dark roots than to do a B&W movie ( with limited color). Sin City was beautiful, and I think the turtles would be too. Just imagining a B&W Rapheal looking down from atop of a building, wearing a red mask with no pupils, and a rolling cloudy B&W night sky would be AWESOME !!!
Dr. Doom
09-02-2008, 07:03 PM
We do not need another origin story.
Also, I was a big fan of the CG format if only because it made it so much easier to become immersed in the world and not get hung up on how animatronics or animated characters blend with live actors. 100% Animation is really the best setting for TMNT in my opinion.
Andrew NDB
09-02-2008, 08:17 PM
Also, I was a big fan of the CG format if only because it made it so much easier to become immersed in the world and not get hung up on how animatronics or animated characters blend with live actors.
If it was an honest attempt at making realistic CGI in a realistic world I wouldn't be against that, really. But everything else bad about it put aside, the Looney Tunes-like humans in the last movie completely yanked me out of anything resembling "Okay, this is New York City and these are real, albeit CGI people."
I'd be much quicker to risk that the blend between CGI and live-action be a little bit skewed than suffer more Yosemite Sam humans and April the Beanstalk.
AquaParade
09-02-2008, 08:59 PM
I know most of you prefer to see a brand new adventure with no rehash at all, but the fact of the matter is, we can either get a "TMNT 2" or a new direction and a new beginning. I really don't see a direct continuation and a new adventure but with a totally different tone. It wouldn't work with a general audience.
Krutch
09-03-2008, 01:46 AM
I'm not sure if Barron is the right choice IF this movie is a remake of the 1st(which is what it sounds like). He did a phenomenal job with the first one, why try to do the same thing twice?
If its a sequel to the first ala Donner's Superman 2 Cut, then I'm all for it. Hell, re-use the costumes to save on budget, i'm all for it.
Seriously though, I see Barron being a great safety net. Meaning, interview some other directors, get their input, and if none of them share the same vision and passion as Barron did in the 90s, then put Barron back on the helm.
My two cents anyways.
Peanut
09-03-2008, 09:24 AM
The CG movie was f*cking terrible, so I'm all for a new live-action movie. I don't even care if they go back to the origin. As far as I'm concerned, unlike most comics, the origin of the TMNT is actually better than the ridiculous sh*t they get up to later down the line.
It's not like they have a ton of back story, anyways. Batman, Spider-Man, those types of characters have such a huge amount of back story that covering it in a movie usually means a good 45 minutes or more of boredom. The TMNT are really straight forward, as we don't have to go through them BECOMING Ninja Turtles, they already ARE Ninja Turtles.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-03-2008, 09:56 AM
The CG movie was f*cking terrible, so I'm all for a new live-action movie. I don't even care if they go back to the origin. As far as I'm concerned, unlike most comics, the origin of the TMNT is actually better than the ridiculous sh*t they get up to later down the line.
It's not like they have a ton of back story, anyways. Batman, Spider-Man, those types of characters have such a huge amount of back story that covering it in a movie usually means a good 45 minutes or more of boredom. The TMNT are really straight forward, as we don't have to go through them BECOMING Ninja Turtles, they already ARE Ninja Turtles.
With origins, many don't mean their entire background story, they just mean the stuff where the TMNT fight the Purple Dragons and save April from bad guys (Baxter Stockman, Purple Dragon-like gang with Bebop and Rocksteady, or Foot Clan), introduce themselves, defeat the mouser robots, fight the Shredder and then meet pink aliens (Utroms or Krang) again.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-03-2008, 10:31 AM
I agree 100% Krow. And as for a turtle movie did in Sin City style ? I say HELL YEAH !!!! Since the turtles started off as a B&W comic, what better way to take it back to it's dark roots than to do a B&W movie ( with limited color). Sin City was beautiful, and I think the turtles would be too. Just imagining a B&W Rapheal looking down from atop of a building, wearing a red mask with no pupils, and a rolling cloudy B&W night sky would be AWESOME !!!
And who, except for some fans, want to watch a black and white films nowadays? It's so 1950's and 1960's.
SHREDDER-X
09-03-2008, 11:21 AM
And who, except for some fans, want to watch a black and white films nowadays? It's so 1950's and 1960's.
Ummm, try the ones who made Sin City a hit when it first dropped back in 05, thats who, and Sin City didn't even have the large fanbase that the TMNT has. BTW the movie tech for Sin City is way more advance than the tech from the 1950's and 60's.
Andrew NDB
09-03-2008, 12:23 PM
The CG movie was f*cking terrible, so I'm all for a new live-action movie. I don't even care if they go back to the origin.
Same.
Whatever they do -- whether it's B&W Sin City-esque with red bandannas or whatever -- there needs to be a very striking visual difference in a reboot movie with everything that's been seen on screen so far. A very clear message needs to be sent to audiences new and old: this is not the same TMNT you've seen on the screen. You know that toddlerfest in 2007? Yeah, this is pretty effing far from that.
If that can't achieve that it'll all be for naught.
The Stryker
09-03-2008, 12:39 PM
As long as Shredder is involved in some way. As overused as he is, I'm not interested in seeing the Turtles fighting anyone but him.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-03-2008, 01:40 PM
As long as Shredder is involved in some way. As overused as he is, I'm not interested in seeing the Turtles fighting anyone but him.
At least, use some major bad guys from some TMNT universe, like Baxter Stockman, Karai, Krang or the Rat King.
Dragon Turtle
09-03-2008, 02:16 PM
As to the Kevin Eastman's recent post, Steve Murphy says:
"This is complete nonsense and entirely untrue."
http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/2008/09/rumor-fatigue.html
ToTheNines
09-03-2008, 02:41 PM
As to the Kevin Eastman's recent post, Steve Murphy says:
"This is complete nonsense and entirely untrue."
http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/2008/09/rumor-fatigue.html
Well it's on IGN and a bunch of other junk now.
The Stryker
09-03-2008, 02:59 PM
At least, use some major bad guys from some TMNT universe, like Baxter Stockman, Karai, Krang or the Rat King.
Sure they could be supporting villians but none of those names can carry a movie. Especially Karai.
Canadian Turtle
09-03-2008, 04:23 PM
I love the fact that no matter what happens they will never make all of us TMNT heads happy. There are so many conflicting views, but I love it because the TMNT world is so diverse in mediums to enjoy this story.
I have to say I was not a huge fan of the CG, I have never really been a CG fan, to easy, to smooth, to boring. But there were some cool things they could do with it, other than the story sucked.
I would LOVE to see a dark real life movie, even if it were a shot for shot re-make of the first one (that didn't work in the past when they did psycho like that). But what ever they through at me I am going to love it as long as it's TMNT.
PS, if they had krang as an real puppet in a dark live action that would be SOOOOO cool! he would be the most evil bad ass ever!!
R-iZZy
09-03-2008, 04:33 PM
Welp, that sucks. To be honest, I wouldn't mind a revamp on the origin, but it would have to be done right. It's gotta be the definitive origin that can carry the Turtles' cinematic run for the next ten years at the least. I had a vision for a relaunch that basically just takes right from the comics, and I've already figured a way to spread it out into a trilogy.
I'm not gonna get too deep into it, because I know it would sound silly for me to go into detail how I'd envision my movie going. But it would definitely be the TMNT movie to put asses in seats as well as satisfy the core TMNT fans.
Jester
09-03-2008, 05:07 PM
I'm confused:
Murph said this:
http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/
About this:
http://perezhilton.com/2008-09-03-coming-soon-live-action-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles
Which is also quoted in the first post of this...thread. :P
Dragon Turtle
09-03-2008, 09:11 PM
I'm confused:
Murph said this:
http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/
About this:
http://perezhilton.com/2008-09-03-coming-soon-live-action-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles
Which is also quoted in the first post of this...thread. :P
It may be that Kevin Eastman is getting his info from Imagi and Warner Bros, not from Mirage. Eastman has close ties with Imagi, working with them on several projects.
If it was an honest attempt at making realistic CGI in a realistic world I wouldn't be against that, really. But everything else bad about it put aside, the Looney Tunes-like humans in the last movie completely yanked me out of anything resembling "Okay, this is New York City and these are real, albeit CGI people."
It would have been better if they had used Kevin Monroe's "Gatchaman" human CG models:
http://www.butterboom.com/wp-content/uploads/mar07/gatchman2008.jpg
Andrew NDB
09-03-2008, 11:56 PM
It would have been better if they had used Kevin Monroe's "Gatchaman" human CG models:
http://www.butterboom.com/wp-content/uploads/mar07/gatchman2008.jpg
Agreed. I could then take no issue with the "look" of the film at all, really.
I mean, as an all-CGI movie it was already fighting an uphill battle to, y'know, make people showing up to it not believe they're walking into a children's cartoon that's just theatrical length. They didn't make anything easier on themselves by literally making the humans look like hyper-exaggerated characters that wouldn't look too out of place on cheap Cartoon Network shows.
Ninjinister
09-04-2008, 12:11 AM
God... there's some idiots on IGN arguing that what Eastman said was the gospel and Murphy doesn't know his $#!+... it's as much of a cesspool as GameFAQs these days....
Andrew NDB
09-04-2008, 12:13 AM
God... there's some idiots on IGN arguing that what Eastman said was the gospel and Murphy doesn't know his $#!+... it's as much of a cesspool as GameFAQs these days....
Ugh.
Countdown to Eastman coming out and setting the record straight in 5, 4, 3, 2...
ThirdMarioBro
09-04-2008, 04:14 AM
What the......fu*k?
I love the TMNT. At one point they were like a second religion for me (or first, depending on the time of my life we're talking about). But a live action movie? It's been done, and it was done to perfection. The 1990 movie reflected the era perfectly. It was a perfect moment in time. Yeah, "Secret of the Ooze" and the third one I won't mention by name sucked balls, but the first one is cinematic perfection. It had soft core swearing, kid gangs doing pot, ninjas, burning buildings, MC Hammer, and a cheesy/serious atmosphere. Sure, they screwed up on Raph being leader of the group transformed from the norm by the nuclear goop, but it's not that big of a deal.
The turtles only work in the 80's/early 90's. I don't like the comics. I never have because they take it too seriously. Just how seriously can you take four anthropomorphic green shellbacks with a rat as a mentor who want to get revenge on a bad clone of Darth Vader with a can opener on his head?
If they think they are going to get a Batman Begins out of this, they're in for a rude surprise. There is a market for a movie like this (us), but it's only a fraction of the audience who liked the turtles as kids, and today's kids who grew up with the 2003 iteration aren't yet old enough to appreciate something like this. I also just don't think the Turtles work that well in today's clean-cut New York City in comparison to the relative mess it was in the 80's.
Now, I'm overreacting--I know. A movie like this could be freaking awesome, but the odds of it blowing up in their faces are astronomically high. I also understand the desire for yet another reboot. The turtles always start out strong, but there's a reason the cartoon lasted ten years, and nothing else has...the story never progressed. The turtles kinda' suck when you get Shredder out of the picture. After that, they go off into outer space and the quirkiness and NYC grittiness gets lost.
Steve Barron's (director of the original film) involvement makes the potential development of this project interesting to say the least, but I still don't think they will be able to wipe the nostalgic love of the original movie. It was just way too damn good.
Now, with all that being said, it would still be worth it just to watch the early 90's replay itself with all the so-called conservative "family values" activists coming out of the woodwork to once again proclaim the TMNT as the downfall of modern American youth. I would laugh myself sh*tless.
xmen510
09-04-2008, 07:44 AM
Apparently the original thread over at the Heavy Metal site which quoted Mr. Eastman is now gone. That is the source for all the, it's only rumor talk.
Drtooth
09-04-2008, 09:16 AM
At the risk of sounding confused, how much of this is rumor? All of it, certain parts... did he REALLY meet with a director? Murph doesn't go into much detail....
NameGoesHere1066
09-04-2008, 10:27 AM
I'm completely confused to. I knew this sounded too good to be true. Shame on me. :roll:
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-04-2008, 10:38 AM
What the......fu*k?
Now, with all that being said, it would still be worth it just to watch the early 90's replay itself with all the so-called conservative "family values" activists coming out of the woodwork to once again proclaim the TMNT as the downfall of modern American youth. I would laugh myself sh*tless.
I agree. Drugs, pollution, hatred, poverty, war, weapons and violence (in reality, not in fictional stories) are a much bigger threat to the future of planet Earth than TMNT. Something for those conservative politicians to think of.
Drtooth
09-04-2008, 11:00 AM
I agree. Drugs, pollution, hatred, poverty, war, weapons and violence (in reality, not in fictional stories) are a much bigger threat to the future of planet Earth than TMNT. Something for those conservative politicians to think of.
Conservatives and liberals... both are behind these hateful, mislead, moronic groups.
This ISN'T new. Nor is it news. Parental groups have ALWAYS managed to ruin things because they can't control anything else.
It's like I said in the Princess and the Frog movie thread... you can't get social change unless you work hard, but a Hollywood entertainment company will back down and cower at the fear of a bad PR story.
Kids who become criminals would have became criminals anyway. You can at least make a PG film a PG film....
Jester
09-04-2008, 11:29 AM
Agreed, hey does anyone know where I can find the book from the 90's that openly trashed the OT, I need a good laugh.
This ain't it, but it is one:
http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/ciu/71/36/4987b2c008a0dc2a09a84010._AA240_.L.jpg
NameGoesHere1066
09-04-2008, 11:38 AM
some one took to the time to write a book trashing the orginal cartoon? :o Ooh boy, that had to have been a some bitter, sex depraved, over weight, stay at home, soccer mom, that found the need to point out all the moral pitfalls of four wise cracking talking turtles, in a a book. I want to see this book too now out of morbid curosity.
Jester
09-04-2008, 11:47 AM
The original toon, but also the 1990 movie.
NameGoesHere1066
09-04-2008, 11:58 AM
oh noez, Raphael said DAMN! And April got slapped in the face by a male ninja :o Get the FCC!!
seriously that's all pretty tame from what I heard rumoured was supposed to happen in the movie. Wasn't April supposed to raped in the first concept of 1990 movie? And the turtles where supposed to swear more.
Drtooth
09-04-2008, 12:42 PM
some one took to the time to write a book trashing the orginal cartoon? :o Ooh boy, that had to have been a some bitter, sex depraved, over weight, stay at home, soccer mom, that found the need to point out all the moral pitfalls of four wise cracking talking turtles, in a a book.
Or a hack child "psychologist" trying to say outrageous things so they can sell a bunch of whiney, discreditable books. And this was the 80's, when The Get a Long Gang ruled the airwaves... yeah..
No offense, but a violent cartoon doesn't make kids violent, nor does an educational show make kids smart. it all comes from Mommy and Daddy.
NameGoesHere1066
09-04-2008, 12:48 PM
the eightes and ninties was such a double edged sword in cartoons. In some areas they waaaay more freedom and hard hitting content in them than taday and at the same time they where much more restrictive. It boggles the mind. :o
Dragon Turtle
09-04-2008, 02:07 PM
At the risk of sounding confused, how much of this is rumor? All of it, certain parts... did he REALLY meet with a director? Murph doesn't go into much detail....
At the time Murphy posted his response to the rumors, I don't believe he knew the source of the Kevin Eastman quotes, today he only had this to add:
"Thank you. My understanding is that the whole thing started at the Heavy Metal website and viralled out from there.
Draw your own conclusions as to why it was originally posted..."
Any "official" information about a movie sequel has come from Peter Laird's blog:
"Yes, we had a movie meeting yesterday (one of several we've had over the last few months). As Mirage policy is to not discuss details until an actual deal is in place, I must be circumspect. However, I can say this -- the people we met with are enthusiastic and energetic and very much want to do a TMNT movie, and I believe they have the wherewithal to accomplish that goal. And it is almost entirely certain that if we do the movie with these folks, it will be a live action/CGI hybrid. -- PL"
and
"Of course we will make our best efforts to surpass what has come before, but as yet we have only had the most cursory of discussions about what the plot/direction of a new movie could be. Hopefully that process will start in earnest soon."
Hannah
09-04-2008, 02:53 PM
80's kids rejoice.
The co-creator of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles has confirmed (http://www.comingsoon.net/news/movienews.php?id=48436)that a new live-action TMNT is in the works.
Looks like he's hoping for Batman-like money blessings!
Here's the latest statement released by the TMNT co-mastermind:
Yes, it is true. Although the CGI film did well enough to warrent a sequel, there has been much talk between Imagi and Warners to do a better "re-invention" (newest Hollywood buzzword) of the TMNT's, in a live action film–like what was done with Batman. Back to basics, back to the origin and the intro of the Shredder, etc…there have been talks, trips to Northampton to talk to Mr Laird, and discussions with the original "first" TMNT film director Steve Barron to come back and do it right–but no official word yet…will keep you posted. Best, Kevin
Are you excited about this?!
http://perezhilton.com/2008-09-03-coming-soon-live-action-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles
wat
Jester
09-04-2008, 03:00 PM
Hannah, there's a thread about this already, Murph has said the Perez Hilton story is a crock...where have you been?
Hannah
09-04-2008, 03:01 PM
I dunno, not reading about TMNT?
Peanut
09-04-2008, 04:22 PM
Dude, shut up. Not everyone here is ass deep in Ninja Turtles news at all times. I could see if she posted this in the TMNT section, but it's in the TV and Movies section, so it's not like she had any idea it was already being talked about.
Mecha Cow
09-04-2008, 04:51 PM
I'm surprised to hear it's bogus since I've seen the same article on more credible sites than Perez Hilton and actually believed it was true. That f*cking sucks though, I would have loved a new proper movie. Nobody wants that CGI stuff, damn it.
Aelia
09-04-2008, 05:45 PM
I'm surprised to hear it's bogus since I've seen the same article on more credible sites than Perez Hilton and actually believed it was true. That f*cking sucks though, I would have loved a new proper movie. Nobody wants that CGI stuff, damn it.
Really? Damnit. Part of me wanted it to be true.
Arcade Joe
09-04-2008, 06:00 PM
Here's a link I ran into. I don't know if anybody read this one....
http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/movies/a129035/eastman-in-talks-for-new-ninja-turtles.html?imdb
some one took to the time to write a book trashing the orginal cartoon? :o Ooh boy, that had to have been a some bitter, sex depraved, over weight, stay at home, soccer mom, that found the need to point out all the moral pitfalls of four wise cracking talking turtles, in a a book. I want to see this book too now out of morbid curosity.
Didn't you say in another thread how you hate how "your people" are quick to stereotype? I'm glad you know so much about the author to say all that, even when the picture CLEARLY shows the author is male.
Mecha Cow
09-04-2008, 06:54 PM
That's what Murphy's blog says anyway, and I reckon he's a bit more credible than... whoever the hell this news came from. F*ck man, I really thought it was for real.
Dr. Doom
09-04-2008, 07:11 PM
Nobody wants that CGI stuff, damn it.
I do. I was very happy with the CGI and am not interested in seeing live action at this point. 100% animation is the way to go to create a more immersive experience in my opinion, and that's one of the reasons I enjoyed the recent film so much.
I am a little confused, however. The Perez Hilton thing was debunked, but his source claims it got the info straight from the Heavy Metal website (the link is broken at this point, though). I saw the very same thing on SHH a few days ago.
Darth Shredder
09-04-2008, 07:14 PM
Didn't you say in another thread how you hate how "you're people" are quick to stereotype? I'm glad you know so much about the author to say all that, even when the picture CLEARLY shows the author is male.
Ah, cut some slack here. The psychologist and theoretical soccer mom both apparently had the same misguided hate toward the turtles.
Mecha Cow
09-04-2008, 07:25 PM
I was very happy with the CGI and am not interested in seeing live action at this point. 100% animation is the way to go to create a more immersive experience in my opinion, and that's one of the reasons I enjoyed the recent film so much.
I completely disagree, but to be fair most of the problems I had with the latest movie had little to do with it being CGI.
Hannah
09-04-2008, 07:47 PM
The CGI movie was so ugly. I would have preferred TMNT 3-esque costumes to the CGI animation, and I'm not even kidding.
Dr. Doom
09-04-2008, 08:01 PM
I dunno what movie you were watching.
The CGI movie was so ugly. I would have preferred TMNT 3-esque costumes to the CGI animation, and I'm not even kidding.
I agree the movie had a lot of problems, but the CGI was not one of them. Some of the scenes were awesome looking.
Dr. Doom
09-04-2008, 08:04 PM
The fight on the roof, for example, was some of the best looking CGI I've ever seen.
Mecha Cow
09-04-2008, 08:04 PM
The turtles only work in the 80's/early 90's. I don't like the comics. I never have because they take it too seriously. Just how seriously can you take four anthropomorphic green shellbacks with a rat as a mentor who want to get revenge on a bad clone of Darth Vader with a can opener on his head?
Why does everything have to be about your childhood? Is it so hard to accept that there's a whole TMNT universe beyond what you grew up with, and that -gasp- it actually has a dedicated fanbase of its own?
The OT kids have had their cartoons, toys and movies for over two decades now; I don't think just one proper, straight-up comic book adaption is too much to ask for.
Hannah
09-04-2008, 08:09 PM
You're all crazy! It was hideous.
Peanut
09-04-2008, 08:12 PM
The CGI itself was impressive, but the designs were much less so. On top of that, the story was just f*cking terrible. Aside from the roof top fight, the entire movie was a complete waste of potential.
Dr. Doom
09-04-2008, 08:15 PM
Well the design aspect is a very subjective matter. There are some people out there who like Jim Lawson's style, for example, and that's great. I can't stand it for one. But I did like how this movie looked. The plot left something to be desired, but as for the overall tone of the film and how they all acted, I think this is the closest they've gotten so far to how the Turtles are supposed to be presented, setting aside the storyline (which I think would have benefited very much from being fleshed out significantly and therefore more inclusive to characters like Don, Mikey, Casey, April and Karai/The Foot). The dynamic, how the characters interacted, it felt very genuine to me. That obviously isn't something that everyone can be bothered to look for or appreciate, I suppose, but this is what I loved about the movie so much, even if my favorite character had a severely diminished role. I'm obviously in sort of an uncomfortable position in that way though because I'm a Ninja Turtles fan whose opinions tend to differ greatly from other people who concern themselves with Ninja Turtles. Not that I really miss the association, but it leads to me having to defend and explain myself pretty regularly.
Mecha Cow
09-04-2008, 08:18 PM
Even the rooftop fight was kind of a mess from a story perspective IMO; the overdone Raph-Leo relationship was about as subtle as an elephant in a trenchcoat and them actually engaging each other with lethal weapons was terribly out-of-character any way you slice it.
... I just nerded this thread to death, didn't I?
Dr. Doom
09-04-2008, 08:22 PM
Well I'm very glad I'm not trying to deal with the thread for this going on in the TMNT forums, let me tell you that. It's a good thing, although redundant, that one was made here.
ToTheNines
09-04-2008, 08:26 PM
Why does everything have to be about your childhood? Is it so hard to accept that there's a whole TMNT universe beyond what you grew up with, and that -gasp- it actually has a dedicated fanbase of its own?
The OT kids have had their cartoons, toys and movies for over two decades now; I don't think just one proper, straight-up comic book adaption is too much to ask for.
Exactly. I've said it before, the OT is on DVD... go ****ing crazy. But other than the first movie (and not all the comic fans like it), we haven't had a serious film. So stop raining on our parade.
Andrew NDB
09-04-2008, 08:27 PM
Why does everything have to be about your childhood? Is it so hard to accept that there's a whole TMNT universe beyond what you grew up with, and that -gasp- it actually has a dedicated fanbase of its own?
The OT kids have had their cartoons, toys and movies for over two decades now; I don't think just one proper, straight-up comic book adaption is too much to ask for.
Thank you. Brilliantly put.
ToTheNines
09-04-2008, 08:31 PM
Dude, shut up. Not everyone here is ass deep in Ninja Turtles news at all times. I could see if she posted this in the TMNT section, but it's in the TV and Movies section, so it's not like she had any idea it was already being talked about.
It's not a big deal, but in his defense this is a TMNT forum. You'd think she woulda checked the TMNT movie section first, but then again you guys down here would never have seen it, so yeah... no reason for him to bitch.
Jester
09-04-2008, 09:12 PM
I have a question, and don't bite my head off, but how many "fans" of the TMNT are truly fans of the Mirage universe? Most of us, yes I'll count myself among them, didn't know about the Mirage universe for years. Most people who will see a TMNT movie will expect some of the OT's goofiness. Now please don't take this to mean I am one of them, I'm not, I think that it'd be great to see a TMNT film geared for adult fans, but you've gotta admit that most people know the Ninja Turtles through the cartoons and not the comic books.
Here's a link I ran into. I don't know if anybody read this one....
http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/movies/a129035/eastman-in-talks-for-new-ninja-turtles.html?imdb
Just a stab in the dark here (and the link definitely does not show any evidence of this), but perhaps Eastman is plotting to get Bodycount as a film somehow.
Jester
09-04-2008, 09:29 PM
One wonders if he has the rights....he did re-publish, maybe he can, on his own do a Bodycount film.
NameGoesHere1066
09-04-2008, 09:30 PM
I don't think Raph and Leo going at each other with weapons is out of character. They've gone at each other with leathal intent in the comics. Heck in Return to new York, when Raph was being a impulsive, two-year-old, butt head, intent on confronting Shredder, Leo tried to stop him and it escalated to Leo trying to stab him. And on it went until Raph threw Leo into a wall.
Point is, it's in canon that both have gotten riled enough with each other to go for the throat so to speak. I didn't find the fight with full on weapons out of character in the movie. And it was a pretty sweet fight to! 8)
One wonders if he has the rights....he did re-publish, maybe he can, on his own do a Bodycount film.
Well, he is working on a Heavy Metal 3 film. Maybe he's trying to get the green light for a Bodycount piece in it or something. Again, though, this is just a thought. I'm not attempting to assume anything or start any rumors.
Mecha Cow
09-04-2008, 09:42 PM
but you've gotta admit that most people know the Ninja Turtles through the cartoons and not the comic books.
No doubt about it, but I fail to see how that's relevant to anything. Should Batman Begins have been based on the Adam West show because that's what most people were familiar with? Just because one incarnation happens to be more well-known doesn't mean every other one should be ignored.
And for the record, I am a Mirage fan.
The Shelf
09-04-2008, 09:49 PM
Thank you. My understanding is that the whole thing started at the Heavy Metal website and viralled out from there.
Draw your own conclusions as to why it was originally posted...
Why was it originally posted?! Isn't it obvious? The internet is now raving for a more mature turtles movie than what we've seen before. If nothing else, this should show the powers that be that there is, indeed, a significant audience for such a movie.
Kevin, you clever, clever man. :)
Take away the 13 Monsters bit and the movie was good. But, seeing as how the film was mainly for kids (who have been watching the current cartoon, obviously), it's understandable that an original antagonist was created.
NameGoesHere1066
09-04-2008, 10:15 PM
Didn't you say in another thread how you hate how "your people" are quick to stereotype? I'm glad you know so much about the author to say all that, even when the picture CLEARLY shows the author is male.
boy, STFU and sit down before you start running your mouth about what I said about "my people". And for your FYI, when I posted that, Jester or whoever, hadn't put up the picture of the book cover with the authors name on it so I didn't know who wrote it or what their gender was until after I had posted my responce; also I was being sarcastic. Why don't you mind your own bussiness and stop jumping on every one and what they post. I notoice you do that alot and you started a fight between two memebers in the New Toon section when it wasn't even your bussiness. Piss off and stop acting like the police around here montering what every one says.
Jester
09-04-2008, 10:24 PM
No doubt about it, but I fail to see how that's relevant to anything. Should Batman Begins have been based on the Adam West show because that's what most people were familiar with? Just because one incarnation happens to be more well-known doesn't mean every other one should be ignored.
And for the record, I am a Mirage fan.
Yes, but how many people don't know that Batman is also a balls to the wall comic book hero? Heck, Mark Hammill has said in interviews that as a kid he both read the comics and watch the Adam West series. Batman's fan base is much larger, and older. TMNT is a much smaller fan base, and fewer people probably even knew it was based on a comic book.
And I'm not saying it should be ignored, but you can't ignore that the OT is what made the TMNT a house hold name. Batman was already that when Adam West camped it up.
Dragon Turtle
09-04-2008, 10:30 PM
I have a question, and don't bite my head off, but how many "fans" of the TMNT are truly fans of the Mirage universe? Most of us, yes I'll count myself among them, didn't know about the Mirage universe for years. Most people who will see a TMNT movie will expect some of the OT's goofiness. Now please don't take this to me I am one of them, I'm not, I think that it'd be great to see a TMNT film geared for adult fans, but you've gotta admit that most people know the Ninja Turtles through the cartoons and not the comic books.
I believe the number of fans of the OT easily outnumber the fans of the Mirage Comic, but the real question is how will the general audience (who don't really care about either and who will ultimately determine how successful the movie will be) will react to a straight forward adaptation? Personally, I can't say how well it would be received, nobody can, looking at the reaction to Kevin Eastman's comments, about taking the turtles back to their darker roots, they have been met with nearly equal amounts of praise and disapproval.
But I feel that an attempt to bring the original vision of the turtles to the mainstream should at least be tried once, and be given the opportunity to see whether or not the public will embrace it.
Jester
09-04-2008, 10:33 PM
I believe the number of fans of the OT easily outnumber the fans of the Mirage Comic, but the real question is how will the general audience (who don't really care about either and who will ultimately determine how successful the movie will be) will react to a straight forward adaptation? Personally, I can't say how well it would be received, nobody can, looking at the reaction to the Kevin Eastman comments about taking the turtles back to their darker roots has been met with nearly equal amounts of praise and disapproval.
But I feel that an attempt to bring the original vision of the turtles to the mainstream should at least be tried once, and be given the opportunity to see whether or not the public will embrace it.
I can understand that, and I'd agree, but how much of a straight adaptation are we talking? All red bandannas adaptation?
Brodie
09-04-2008, 11:04 PM
boy, STFU and sit down before you start running your mouth about what I said about "my people". And for your FYI, when I posted that, Jester or whoever, hadn't put up the picture of the book cover with the authors name on it so I didn't know who wrote it or what their gender was until after I had posted my responce; also I was being sarcastic. Why don't you mind your own bussiness and stop jumping on every one and what they post. I notoice you do that alot and you started a fight between two memebers in the New Toon section when it wasn't even your bussiness. Piss off and stop acting like the police around here montering what every one says.
Your sig is too large. As is that wall of text that no one probably cares about.
Dragon Turtle
09-04-2008, 11:05 PM
I can understand that, and I'd agree, but how much of a straight adaptation are we talking? All red bandannas adaptation?
As far as the bandannas go, they could probably be all red, but keep this in mind as far as movies are concerned, there really isn't such a thing as a "straight adaptation" there will always be changes, whether due to the insistence of the writers, the director, or the studio, there will likely be some nods to the old cartoon(since the fact remains it was the most popular version of the turtles).
boy, STFU and sit down before you start running your mouth about what I said about "my people". And for your FYI, when I posted that, Jester or whoever, hadn't put up the picture of the book cover with the authors name on it so I didn't know who wrote it or what their gender was until after I had posted my responce; also I was being sarcastic. Why don't you mind your own bussiness and stop jumping on every one and what they post. I notoice you do that alot and you started a fight between two memebers in the New Toon section when it wasn't even your bussiness. Piss off and stop acting like the police around here montering what every one says.
I'm just saying you need to keep an open mind. Maybe the author had very sound and credible reasons for writing a book about that stuff. Sure, it seems a bit weird, but don't go labeling a person only for writing something you disagree with.
Also, when you say "for your FYI", you're saying "for your" twice. Just sayin'.
Jester
09-04-2008, 11:16 PM
Your sig is too large. As is that wall of text that no one probably cares about.
If you don't care....oh never mind, I don't care to expend the energy to refute you...wait, I just spent the energy to half refute you...Damn you Brodie!
Hey Dragon Turtle, I have a thought. What if they did a TMNT direct to video movie adaptation of TMNT 1.1, in traditional animation, E&L style, black and white (and maybe red for blood and masks)? You think that'd work, or would it only really sell to fan boys like us?
I can understand that, and I'd agree, but how much of a straight adaptation are we talking? All red bandannas adaptation?
I don't think we'll ever get a legitimate red bandana project short of fan-made films. If anything, we'll have an atmosphere and style similar to the grass roots of the turtles' original structure. The dark tone, the close-quarters combat (with a dash of blood), and the gritty undertones might be the closest thing that'd be released.
Andrew NDB
09-04-2008, 11:40 PM
Just a stab in the dark here (and the link definitely does not show any evidence of this), but perhaps Eastman is plotting to get Bodycount as a film somehow.
That's... crazy. Laird would shoot that down lickity split.
Not that I wouldn't like to see such a thing... but it's neither the direction a TMNT reboot should go nor a realistic expectation of the people ponying up the money (financiers, big studios). Rather, it's just the extreme end of an extreme.
Sage Ninja
09-04-2008, 11:44 PM
yikes! Every one needs to calm down here.
**parenting mode**
Play nice kids. :o Or they'll be no ninja turtles sequal in any form, you hear! Now The Cure, ad NameGoesHere1066, you two kiss and make up. Bordie don't atagonise others when it has nothing to do with you. Every one put your heads down on your desks and have some quite time.
**end parenting mode**
Dr. Doom
09-05-2008, 12:23 AM
Well I'm very glad I'm not trying to deal with the thread for this going on in the TMNT forums, let me tell you that. It's a good thing, although redundant, that one was made here.
Well, s***.
Jester
09-05-2008, 12:32 AM
Yep, you're stuck with us. BTW, I agree with you about TMNT, the only real down side was the 13 monsters.
Krang
09-05-2008, 12:35 AM
In regards to a few posts back, like Sage Ninja said, let's please keep the arguing off the forums.
although redundant
Sorry, but that's why the threads had to be merged.
Andrew NDB
09-05-2008, 01:14 AM
In regards to a few posts back, like Sage Ninja said, let's please keep the arguing off the forums.
Arguing is indicative of debate... which is the bread and butter of every message board with a pulse I've ever been aware of. I mean, let's say we've got a Batman message board here. Someone posts, "Which is the best Batman on film?" You get some heated discussion with empassioned fans of Keaton, Kilmer, Clooney, and Bale, arguing back and forth with valid points. Someone leaning in and saying, "Hey. Dudes. You can't argue about this!" seems more than a little bit puzzling.
If you mean flaming and name-calling and the insults, yes, that shouldn't have any place. Though I see no problem with taking extreme issue with an idea/a concept/a thing, as soon as it becomes directed at a person or an individual (even one of TPTB)... this is where lines are crossed and good taste becomes... not.
Krang
09-05-2008, 01:28 AM
If you mean flaming and name-calling and the insults, yes, that shouldn't have any place.
Yep, that's what I meant. On-topic arguments are fine as long as they don't resort to personal insults.
Andrew NDB
09-05-2008, 01:30 AM
Yep, that's what I meant. On-topic arguments are fine as long as they don't resort to personal insults.
Cool. I agree.
Sage Ninja
09-05-2008, 01:30 AM
I think what alot of people need to stop doing is being so sensetive and prickly over little thing and also to stop being know it alls.
The Cure: you came off high handed in your first post, coming across like that sets people off. Try not to jump to conclusions on where people are coming from then lecturing them on it with out knowing why they said it.
NameGoesHere1066: get anger managment. I can understand why you where annoyed, but you flew completly off the handle, and you started throwing insults around.
thats my opinion on this. :ohwell:
Andrew NDB
09-05-2008, 01:34 AM
I think what alot of people need to stop doing is being so sensetive and prickly over little thing and also to stop being know it alls.
I think by this point you'd be scarce to find a 20, 30-something year-old TMNT fan that's been around the block (so to speak) with the franchise since childhood that doesn't have a pretty particular way they envision the "Ideal" TMNT in one fashion or another. It's natural. It's to be expected, especially something like TMNT which -- depending on the universe -- has two radically different epicenters as far as tone and take.
I think the differences in fans and their tastes should be celebrated, not shunned. But reality still kept in check nonetheless.
Mecha Cow
09-05-2008, 09:25 AM
Yes, but how many people don't know that Batman is also a balls to the wall comic book hero? Heck, Mark Hammill has said in interviews that as a kid he both read the comics and watch the Adam West series. Batman's fan base is much larger, and older. TMNT is a much smaller fan base, and fewer people probably even knew it was based on a comic book.
And I'm not saying it should be ignored, but you can't ignore that the OT is what made the TMNT a house hold name. Batman was already that when Adam West camped it up.
The Batman thing was just an example, I don't care if it's accurate or not. In any case I don't see your point at all. Of course most people know the TMNT from the OT, so what? How is that relevant to anything, let alone a potential adaption of the Mirage TMNT? The OT has nothing to do with this topic whatsoever. I'm quite aware that it's what made the TMNT famous, but that doesn't suddenly make it the original version or the one I and many others like best.
Andrew NDB
09-05-2008, 01:17 PM
The Batman thing was just an example, I don't care if it's accurate or not. In any case I don't see your point at all. Of course most people know the TMNT from the OT, so what? How is that relevant to anything, let alone a potential adaption of the Mirage TMNT? The OT has nothing to do with this topic whatsoever. I'm quite aware that it's what made the TMNT famous, but that doesn't suddenly make it the original version or the one I and many others like best.
Or ought to have anything to do with an attempt to -- finally -- bring the Mirage TMNT to the screen. Not a god damn thing.
Dragon Turtle
09-05-2008, 07:35 PM
Hey Dragon Turtle, I have a thought. What if they did a TMNT direct to video movie adaptation of TMNT 1.1, in traditional animation, E&L style, black and white (and maybe red for blood and masks)? You think that'd work, or would it only really sell to fan boys like us?
It would probably only sell to diehard Mirage fans, however, something like that would make a good promotional tie in to a movie, similar to Batman: Gotham Knights, as it would get more exposure and perhaps be use to circumvent the need for a origin story.
Jester
09-05-2008, 07:46 PM
The Batman thing was just an example, I don't care if it's accurate or not. In any case I don't see your point at all. Of course most people know the TMNT from the OT, so what? How is that relevant to anything, let alone a potential adaption of the Mirage TMNT? The OT has nothing to do with this topic whatsoever. I'm quite aware that it's what made the TMNT famous, but that doesn't suddenly make it the original version or the one I and many others like best.
There will never be a Mirage-style TMNT movie, it's too big a risk. Most people know the TMNT through the OLD TOON!!! Just because you love it and your mom loves it doesn't mean the general audience who goes to movies will like it.. They'll be asking questions the whole damn time...Why are they wearing all red? Is that blood? The Turtles don't kill, do they?
As much as you say the OT is irrelevant to a Mirage movie, everyone is going to take it into account because it is what made TMNT a household name. It's how they took an indie comic and made it a phenomenon. No OT, then the TMNT may have never blew up and we wouldn't even be here.
I'm just saying a Mirage styled TMNT movie wouldn't be easy to market, because everyone associated the characters to the comedic 90's cartoon and not the gritty 80's comic.
Peanut
09-05-2008, 08:03 PM
There will never be a Mirage-style TMNT movie, it's too big a risk.
Give me a break. If a movie looks good, people will go see it. Sin City was a graphic novel hardly anyone knew about, it was in black and white, yet it did really well. So obviously the visual style of the old Mirage comics isn't going to make the movie any more or less likely to succeed. Just because there are preconceptions about the Ninja Turtles doesn't mean it will automatically turn people off. That's just ridiculous.
Look at something like Transformers. Aside from transforming robots from space, what the hell does it have to do with the G1 cartoons everyone knows and loves? About as much as a Mirage style Turtles movie would have to do with the OT. Did that stop people from going to see a more mature, different approach to the Transformers franchise? Sure as hell didn't.
All you're doing is making assumptions based on the fact that you can't let go of something you loved as a kid. To quote you:
Just because you love it and your mom loves it doesn't mean the general audience who goes to movies will like it..
Clearly, the general audience didn't rave over TMNT, so why the hell should they head down that path again?
Jester
09-05-2008, 08:18 PM
I'm not saying make another TMNT. I liked it to a point and was annoyed with it to a point. I'm just saying that the preconceived notions about TMNT make an attempt to make a Mirage based film tough. Sin City had no cheesy kids series spun off of it to make it a hit, it was a gritty graphic novel turned gritty comic book adaptation. People had never even heard of Sin City, you're right, but people have heard of the TMNT, and what they've heard is it's a kiddy property. It's gonna be hard to get around that preconception.
EDIT:
*thinks hard about Transformers....* Not sure really what to say, not having been a Transformers fan, but the only retort I can come up with is it was a movie made for the fans of the old G1 Transformers, who are now young adults, and wasn't a return to the gritty roots. If they made a TMNT movie that was more adult, geared for the audience who were once kids and are now grown ups, it'd be great, but I don't see them going to a straight Mirage adaptation, because it's still trying to capitalize on the old fandom...but then again most of us have migrated to the Mirage universe, at least a little...maybe it'd work. *shrugs*
Peanut
09-05-2008, 08:29 PM
I was referencing Sin City for the style, nothing else.
My comparison for a goofy kids series turned into a more serious movie was Transformers. Which was not only a show for kids, but also a franchise that is inevitably linked with nerds and losers, kind of a turn-off for your average mainstream audience.
Last I heard, the Transformers movie was a huge success...
Edit: I don't think a direct Mirage translation is the best approach, either, but to say that something along those lines would be a hard sell because of preconceived notions people having concerning the Turtles and the OT is a stretch.
Jester
09-05-2008, 08:37 PM
Well, if I hadn't said it the thread would have been boring...:P
Mecha Cow
09-05-2008, 08:44 PM
I'm just saying a Mirage styled TMNT movie wouldn't be easy to market, because everyone associated the characters to the comedic 90's cartoon and not the gritty 80's comic.
You weren't saying this at all, you kept stating the obvious fact that most people only knew the OT TMNT, which -again- has nothing to do with a discussion about the Mirage TMNT.
But now that you've finally made your point, what of it? Of course a Mirage adaption is going to be a risk, and if you want to be entirely realistic, yes, that does lessen its changes of becoming a reality, but that does mean it shouldn't happen? That's a terrible attitude.
Besides, I doubt it would even matter much. Most of the casual fans you keep mentioning would just see 'TMNT' and check out the movie anyway.
Sure, afterwards they'd go online and bitch about the property 'selling out', but who cares? Who cares about the people asking about the red bandanas? It's not for them. They can watch their cartoon DVDs and let the other side of the fanbase have some big-budget fun for the first time in 25 years.
Jester
09-05-2008, 08:46 PM
That's just it, no studio, especially Warner Bros., is going to make a movie just for the hard core Turtle fans. We aren't a big enough fan base to warrant such a risk of money.
Mecha Cow
09-05-2008, 08:55 PM
Maybe, maybe not. Stranger things have happened. Let's just let the producers worry about that one.
I don't see why a new movie would have to be 'just for the hardcore fans' anyway. I don't know about you, but I've gone to see plenty of comic book movies based on source material I wasn't familiar with.
Jester
09-05-2008, 09:02 PM
I have too, I'm just saying that those comic book movies strayed from the source material to be marketable to more than just the core base. To make a ninja turtle movie that is marketable to more than just the members of this forum, lets say, some concessions have to be made. And with TMNT those concessions were made years ago.
"Then again," he said almost making his whole point moot, "if they marketed it as such, a total departure from what you'd expect, something like, 'These ain't the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles you grew up with...' maybe it'd work."
Peanut
09-05-2008, 09:11 PM
I don't know about you, but I've gone to see plenty of comic book movies based on source material I wasn't familiar with.
Which is exactly what I'm saying. Just because a Mirage film would cater to the hardcore fans doesn't mean it's only FOR the hardcore fans, or that those are the only people who would see it. I hate to bring it up again, but Sin City was so hardcore, it was essentially the graphic novel, matched shot for shot, panel for panel, and that was a mainstream success. The fact that the TMNT brand is so easily recognizable is in no way a knock against a Mirage style movie, it would easily give it more recognition and exposure than if it was as "underground" as Sin City.
I have too, I'm just saying that those comic book movies strayed from the source material to be marketable to more than just the core base. To make a ninja turtle movie that is marketable to more than just the members of this forum, lets say, some concessions have to be made. And with TMNT those concessions were made years ago.
But those changes were made to make the movies reflect the popular cartoon of that time period, not to make the Mirage comics appeal to a wider audience. We're not in a Turtles craze right now. They aren't instantly recognizable to any kid aged 1-15 at this point. If they had gone Mirage at that point in time, when the OT was ruling the world, it would have been suicide, but at this point, there's nothing to stop them. Kids have no preconceived notions of what a Ninja Turtles movie should be like, and those of us old enough to remember the OT and movies of old would likely be glad to see the Turtles in a more grown up fashion.
That's just what I think, anyways.
Mecha Cow
09-05-2008, 09:12 PM
The first movie did a fine job of conveying the Mirage grittiness while still appealing to the cartoon fans, I don't think swaying slightly closer to the Mirage side would be that much of a problem. People'd spend half a second wondering where the rainbow bandanas went (should things go that far) and that'd be it. It's perfectly feasible.
*E*
The fact that the TMNT brand is so easily recognizable is in no way a knock against a Mirage style movie, it would easily give it more recognition and exposure than if it was as "underground" as Sin City.
Bingo. Brand recognition is never a bad thing.
Jester
09-05-2008, 09:22 PM
I dunna, I'm still not sure. I totally understand where you both are coming from, but I still think that the 90's TMNT craze is almost a detrement to getting a Mirage based movie, but if it weren't for the 90's craze the Turtles may not have been popular enough to warrant a movie that is a fanservice to the hard-core fans (and people who would like to see an awesome action movie, with hints of parody, satire and homage comedy thrown in).
Here's an example:
My girlfriend knew of the TMNT as an 80's child, but only knew of them as a toy and TV franchise, not a comic book series. I had to be the one to mention they were in fact a comic book.
I'd love a Mirage 1.1 adaptation for a Turtle movie, the style alone in my head would be awesome! But I can't get over the fact that people would look at it and go, "Ninja Turtles, I remember that, that show was great." and walk in, see it, and maybe they'd like it, but maybe because of their prior experience with TMNT, walk out hating it and telling all their friends about how the new Ninja Turtle movie "sux!"
It could slice either way, which may be while we're still debating it. :P
Andrew NDB
09-05-2008, 09:32 PM
Even if every person that's bought a DVD of the old cartoon showed up for tickets on opening weekend of a Fred Wolf cartoon-based TMNT movie... we're talking peanuts here. We're talking infinitesimal box office numbers.
A TMNT movie isn't going to be made or broken by ANY still-existing fandom. Not the Bebop fans, not the Technodrome fans, or the Pizza Thrower fans.
It needs to reach out beyond any still existing TMNT fandom, and for the TMNT in the mass media, this pretty much means redefining the wheel. From a business standpoint the still-existing TMNT fandom shouldn't even be a consideration... no part of it.
Since trying another toddler approach with TMNT Part 4 didn't do anything anyone of sound mind would call gangbusters they might as well reboot and play the one card they've never really played (a card that seems to be working well in Hollywood these days)... a relatively faithful, comic book-deriven movie of the Mirage TMNT source material. This plus at least a mid-level director with pull and a vision.
"I know this guy standing in front of Best Buy, I walked up to him and mentioned 'TMNT' and he knew them from the original cartoon and laughed." Who cares? Hollywood shouldn't, and hell, 90% of the people that grew up on the original cartoon aren't even in Hollywood's target demographic anymore. The fact that most of our generation (not the small pocket of people that are actually still active fans) remembers the TMNT as kind of a nostalgic joke should be all the more reason that sort of material and approach should be avoided in a second run-through anew.
Mecha Cow
09-05-2008, 09:40 PM
But I can't get over the fact that people would look at it and go, "Ninja Turtles, I remember that, that show was great." and walk in, see it, and maybe they'd like it, but maybe because of their prior experience with TMNT, walk out hating it and telling all their friends about how the new Ninja Turtle movie "sux!"
Well, if that's your problem, you're going to lose either way. There's always gonna be people like that. No one cares about them.
Also, you're not exactly the most objective person to make these kinds of assumptions. You're a grown man who still likes the OT in his adulthood, and that's fine, but your view of it is different than that of the people who watched it as kids and then grew out of it.
Think about it. When you were a kid you didn't watch TMNT, He-Man or Transformers because it was funny or because you liked the voice acting or whatever. You watched it because it was f*cking badass, and if you ask an average '80s kid about TMNT he'll tell you that it was 'the sh*t'. For all the people that'll complain about the lack of Dimension X or some sh*t there'll be people who'll say the TMNT are just as 'badass' as they remembered. It's a different kind of nostalgia, but I think it's there.
Andrew NDB
09-05-2008, 09:46 PM
But I can't get over the fact that people would look at it and go, "Ninja Turtles, I remember that, that show was great." and walk in, see it, and maybe they'd like it, but maybe because of their prior experience with TMNT, walk out hating it and telling all their friends about how the new Ninja Turtle movie "sux!"
Most of the friends I know that grew up on TMNT with me, if I could even drag them to the theatre at all (me: "No, no, trust me, these TMNT are gritty!") would probably walk out of the theatre going, "Holy sh*t, the TMNT grew up. That was badass." Assuming, of course, that apart from being a faithful TMNT movie to the Mirage material, it is also a good movie with a solid script and doesn't look like ass.
Folks actually walking out bemoaning the presence of a serious approach, actual ninja violence and semi-adult content and absence of a great abundance of over-the-top camp and infantile humor... I'm not sure about these folks. I guess I'd be apt to wonder if everything went OK in their childhood that they're still so married at the hip to such an approach in their late 20s, early 30s.
Peanut
09-05-2008, 09:49 PM
I'd love a Mirage 1.1 adaptation for a Turtle movie, the style alone in my head would be awesome! But I can't get over the fact that people would look at it and go, "Ninja Turtles, I remember that, that show was great." and walk in, see it, and maybe they'd like it, but maybe because of their prior experience with TMNT, walk out hating it and telling all their friends about how the new Ninja Turtle movie "sux!"
The flaw I see in that is that these kinds of dark, gritty, brutal action movies go over so well with audiences these days. If anyone were to walk out and tell their friends it was terrible, it wouldn't likely be because they were disappointed it wasn't like the cartoons they grew up with, but because it actually did suck.
Andrew NDB
09-05-2008, 09:52 PM
The flaw I see in that is that these kinds of dark, gritty, brutal action movies go over so well with audiences these days.
Peanut, just stop it. There are no examples in the past few years of any comic book movies getting gritty, balls-out movie adaptions on the big screen and making any money. And none that ever had TV shows about them that were camp-based.
Peanut
09-05-2008, 09:53 PM
I know, man. I'm just pulling this **** outta my ass. I guess I dreamed it all up.
Mecha Cow
09-05-2008, 09:56 PM
Yeah, I guess the real horror of it is that no matter what it'd be based on, the movie could still end up sucking. Of course, we musn't think of such things. Happy thoughts!
Jester
09-05-2008, 09:59 PM
The flaw I see in that is that these kinds of dark, gritty, brutal action movies go over so well with audiences these days. If anyone were to walk out and tell their friends it was terrible, it wouldn't likely be because they were disappointed it wasn't like the cartoons they grew up with, but because it actually did suck.
True, true, I guess I'll just shut up now.
Like I mentioned somewhere before, I really doubt a Mirage fan will get the movie he/she wants. It's just not in the cards. Movie moguls are going to go for what puts the most cash in their pockets, and that means colored bandanas, cartoony action, and the occasional "Cowabunga!" Although I would like to see a more grimy flick about the turtles as much as the next Mirage follower, I just don't see it happening.
Jester
09-05-2008, 10:41 PM
EXACTLY!! Thank you. I, obviously, couldn't have said it better.
Peanut
09-05-2008, 11:08 PM
But...that has nothing to do with what you were saying. You were defending the OT idea based on the fact that people wouldn't like it due to preconceived notions on how the Turtles should be presented. Talking about a studio, producers, whatever, actually picking up the Mirage idea, is an entirely different can of worms. I would never argue that anyone looking to make a quick cash-in would do anything aside from go with what the Turtles are famous for, but that isn't at all what we we're talking about, unless I've been reading everything incorrectly.
And even agreeing with KROW, it's still just an assumption, and it isn't even an easily defensible one. All any interested party would have to do is look at the lukewarm reception of TMNT and take note that the franchise may have run its course at the kids table. The other option would be to turn the well-known franchise in a different direction to see if they can squeeze something more out of it. Batman, anyone? And even then, the more logical choice would just be to not get involved with a floundering franchise in the first place.
Of course, these are all assumptions, and as we're all kinda just riffing here, none of us is right or wrong. It makes for interesting conversation, at the very least.
Jester
09-05-2008, 11:38 PM
Ok, let me try to clear the air. Here's my warped logic:
1. People know the TMNT from the toon more so than the comics.
2. The studios want to make a movie that garners broad appeal.
3. The studios shy away from the "Hard-core Mirage adaptation" and instead go the the "proven" cash cow that is multi-colored masks and belching since TMNT is always viewed as a children's franchise.
I totally understand people wouldn't want a TMNT movie that's as cheesy as the old toon, but how many people still were like "Where's Krang?" with Turtles 1, "Are those Bebop and Rocksteady?" in SotO, or were "Where's Shredder?" with TMNT. People who don't know any better will gripe.
Then again, if they did a GOOD TMNT movie it could work, but are there any big named directors/writers who know the Turtles roots and would make the Turtle movie they want to make, that would be entertaining, profitable, and also the right thing to reinvent (or at least resurface) the wheel that is TMNT?
Andrew NDB
09-06-2008, 12:23 AM
1. People know the TMNT from the toon more so than the comics.
We've established this as irrelevant. Though it's good for name recognition, regardless of what "take" a new movie has.
2. The studios want to make a movie that garners broad appeal.
But these same people you mention that know the TMNT from the toon more than the comics (not to be confused with the actual, active TMNT fandom today... which you delude yourself if you believe is substantially above "ain't much") tend to think of TMNT as a joke. This isn't "appeal"... it's a sham.
3. The studios shy away from the "Hard-core Mirage adaptation" and instead go the the "proven" cash cow that is multi-colored masks and belching
In an alternate reality where the last movie was anything resembling a cash cow, sure.
are there any big named directors/writers who know the Turtles roots and would make the Turtle movie they want to make, that would be entertaining, profitable, and also the right thing to reinvent (or at least resurface) the wheel that is TMNT?
Dunno. Hopefully. Still waiting on the Director's Guild Census on TMNT fans.
Jester
09-06-2008, 01:03 AM
We've established this as irrelevant. Though it's good for name recognition, regardless of what "take" a new movie has.
I'm just saying that since the TMNT have been campy for so long and it is what people think when you mention "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" it's going to be very difficult to turn it all back and make a true to the original dark gritty film.
But these same people you mention that know the TMNT from the toon more than the comics tend to think of TMNT as a joke. This isn't "appeal"... it's a sham.
Yes, because a comic book PARODY about anthropomorphic Turtles who know martial arts is the height of seriousness.
In an alternate reality where the last movie was anything resembling a cash cow, sure.
I wasn't referring to TMNT so much as the success of the original TMNT mania back in the day.
Dunno. Hopefully. Still waiting on the Director's Guild Census on TMNT fans.
Funny...seriously.
Dragon Turtle
09-06-2008, 01:59 AM
I'm just saying that since the TMNT have been campy for so long and it is what people think when you mention "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" it's going to be very difficult to turn it all back and make a true to the original dark gritty film.
I feel the TMNT franchise has moved away from the campy (perhaps not as much as some might have liked) 80‘s/90‘s cartoon, so getting a movie that has the type of tone and feel of the Mirage comic wouldn’t be to far fetched, the effect of the OT on the general audience (the people who are not real fans of the TMNT but are willing to go see a movie based on them) may not be that strong, also there are many fans of the old cartoon who wouldn’t mind seeing a more mature version of the cartoon they grew up with.
One thing I think needs to be pointed out is what level of “dark gritty” are people looking for, Something similar to the 1990 movie? The Dark Knight? Something darker? Everyone has their own idea of what is an acceptable level of “darkness” for TMNT film.
Funny...seriously.
Kevin Smith…although he himself has shied away from such projects.
Krang
09-06-2008, 02:08 AM
Yes, because a comic book PARODY about anthropomorphic Turtles who know martial arts is the height of seriousness.
I think that right there is a much bigger stumbling block for a Mirage-style movie than the general public's preconceptions of everyone's favorite scapegoat, the original cartoon.
Mecha Cow
09-06-2008, 09:20 AM
The original concept may have been a parody, but I don't think it's accurate to say the early Mirage comics are. Hints of satire, maybe, but not flat-out parody. In any case I think the TMNT have been around long enough for people to get over the fact that they're, well... Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
everyone's favorite scapegoat, the original cartoon.
That's not fair. No one here is bashing the OT.
Anyway, it seems we're just going in circles now. :lol:
Andrew NDB
09-06-2008, 07:06 PM
We're splitting hairs now.
The original concept may have been a parody
The original concept of certain aspects... of only the first issue. And the way they're done (the Hand = Foot, Stick = Splinter, Matt Murdoch saving the old man and getting hit "near the eyes" with the radioactive canister that blinds him, all from Daredevil... a bit of the "look" and paneling of Frank Miller's Ronin, same font in TMNT title... eh, was there other "parody" in TMNT?) read more as homages than anything resembling parody. It doesn't poke fun at anything, which is pretty much the essence of parody... quite the contrary.
OK, there was that one issue with the Justice Force or whatever it was in Vol. 1 that parodied the Justice League. Kind of.
Mecha Cow
09-06-2008, 07:47 PM
Yeah, that's what I meant. It's more pastiche than parody.
Jelly Bean
09-06-2008, 10:41 PM
holy heck!! All this debating and contraversy is worse than politics. :o
Jester
09-06-2008, 10:49 PM
I'd have never debated politics that hard....man I haver no life. :P
Andrew NDB
09-06-2008, 11:09 PM
Yeah, that's what I meant. It's more pastiche than parody.
I agree. My "splitting hairs" comment wasn't directed at you.
turkishproverb
09-07-2008, 04:00 AM
Peanut, just stop it. There are no examples in the past few years of any comic book movies getting gritty, balls-out movie adaptions on the big screen and making any money. And none that ever had TV shows about them that were camp-based.
For grim and gritty balls out movie adaptions on the big screen making money while being INSANELY true to source:
Sin. City. (http://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?id=sincity.htm)
For one that had a camp based show with a movie that was gritty, relatively brutal (for the rating)..oh, why do i think there is something i should be remembering? oh (http://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?id=batmanbegins.htm), well (http://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?id=darkknight.htm).
of course, that's just without looking.
Why so serious?
:evilgrin:
Andrew NDB
09-07-2008, 04:12 AM
http://images.art.com/images/-/National-Sarcasm-Society--C10106736.jpeg
SHREDDER-X
09-07-2008, 02:59 PM
Bottom line is this. TMNT Fans have grown up, and now it's time for TMNT to grow up. Kids these days aren't really that familiar with the Original TMNT series ( unless they watched the dvd's) and are more familiar with the Mirage based NT. This is the video game age. These kids don't ride bikes, skate boards, and play with action figures like we did as kids in the 80's. They play Ultra-violent video games, read dark ass comics, and watch videos with half-naked women in them. Based on the success of SIN CITY, 300, BATMAN BEGINS, and DARK KNIGHT, a MIRAGE based TMNT movie would sell like hotcakes. You'll have the original OT fanbase going to the see the movie, the mirage fanbase, comic book fanboys in general, and the general public, curious to see what this dark version on the turtles ( which would be new to them), would be like. And as far as Hollywood not wanting to take a chance on a dark TMNT, thats bullsh@t. Take Masters of the Universe for example. Probably one of the biggest toy and animated franchises in the 80's. Spawned two motion pictures, one animated, neither did very well at the box office. Did that stop the 2002 reboot ? No it didn't. And even though the 2002 show was very good and critcally acclaimed, and the new action figures were kick-ass, it didn't take well with todays audience ( the studio claimed that most people who watched the show and bought the action figures where adults who grew up with the show, and not their target audience of today's youth.) But guess what there is a NEW MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE MOVIE in production now, regardless of it's reboot flop. So there is no excuse for us not to have a Mirage based, gritty TMNT.
VaughnMichael
09-07-2008, 05:25 PM
TMNT Fans have grown up
You sure about that?:lol:
ToTheNines
09-07-2008, 05:29 PM
read dark ass comics
Sorry dude, but kids do NOT read comics these days.
SHREDDER-X
09-07-2008, 05:51 PM
Sorry dude, but kids do NOT read comics these days.
Most read manga. I'm sure there are kids who still read comics, not like they use to, but there are some that still do, and those that do, don't have that many light hearted comics to choose from since most comics chose to go the dark route after The Death of Superman, The Bad Girl phase, and the rise of Image.
Slap-Happy
09-07-2008, 06:25 PM
oh noez, Raphael said DAMN! And April got slapped in the face by a male ninja :o Get the FCC!!
seriously that's all pretty tame from what I heard rumoured was supposed to happen in the movie. Wasn't April supposed to raped in the first concept of 1990 movie? And the turtles where supposed to swear more.
where did you find that out?
Peanut
09-07-2008, 06:55 PM
Most read manga.
Uh...no? The only kids who read manga are the ones I see getting beat up outside my window, and in most cases, they're outnumbered 10 to 1.
Kids just don't read comics anymore. I can't remember the last time I saw a kid in my local comic books tore.
SHREDDER-X
09-07-2008, 09:01 PM
Uh...no? The only kids who read manga are the ones I see getting beat up outside my window, and in most cases, they're outnumbered 10 to 1.
Kids just don't read comics anymore. I can't remember the last time I saw a kid in my local comic books tore.
If you say so dude. I'll just leave it alone. I Don't want to start an argument like I did about TMNT and rap on the BTTS post in the New Toon Thread.
turkishproverb
09-07-2008, 10:53 PM
That is...kinda rediculous. To say nthing of the fact your sitting there watching a kid get beaten up...
Spend time in a library, or a retail store (or even an actual school)
Plenty of kinds read manga these days. Minority or not, its a fairly large marketed group.
Whitewolf89
09-08-2008, 12:56 PM
Getting back on topic here, a friend of mine over at Tigerfog's O.Z. forums posted the link to an online article about this that pretty much puts a rather abrupt END to this particular rumor. Read on:
"No Live-Action TMNT 2
Rumor control is in order.
by Jim Vejvoda
US, September 4, 2008 - Remember those rumors we relayed the other day about a live-action TMNT movie sequel? Sounds like you shouldn't get your hopes up for one after all.
According to Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles writer Stephen Murphy's blog the 5th turtle, the claims made by TMNT co-creator Kevin Eastman at his Heavy Metal forum that a live-action movie was in the works are "complete nonsense and entirely untrue." (Eastman reportedly sold his interests in TMNT years ago and is no longer involved with it.)
Murphy had several months earlier quashed a statement initially posted at the official site of TMNT license holder Playmates Toys claiming that a live-action movie was in the works. Playmates later revised their statement and removed the "live-action" part. Murphy "can wholeheartedly confirm" that there will indeed be a sequel to TMNT, "although it's more likely to be early 2011" rather than 2010 as stated by Playmates.
Furthermore, Imagi Studios, the outfit behind last year's TMNT, may or may not be involved with the sequel. The 5th turtle posted this official statement a few months ago: "Imagi's unilateral option to produce and distribute a sequel to the 2007 TMNT CG-animated movie expired on April 30, 2008. As a result, while Mirage continues to speak with Imagi, Mirage has begun discussions with several other movie companies regarding the production of a new TMNT film for distribution sometime in the not-too-distant future."
Calls to Imagi for comment on the status of their talks with Mirage were not returned by time of publish."
So I guess THIS means that we can safely put ANY news/rumors of a new LIVE-action TMNT to bed permanently.
Dragon Turtle
09-08-2008, 01:46 PM
So I guess THIS means that we can safely put ANY news/rumors of a new LIVE-action TMNT to bed permanently.
No, just the news/rumors surrounding Kevin Eastman's comments about the live-action movie.
The Stryker
09-08-2008, 01:46 PM
Yay!!!
What?
Dragon Turtle
09-08-2008, 02:05 PM
Yay!!!
What?
Mirage is still in talks with the studio/production company about doing the next TMNT movie, whoever they are, they most certainly want to do next movie as a live action/CGI hybrid movie.
Recently Kevin Eastman made comments on the the Heavy Metal Forums about a live action TMNT movie(including specific information about direction, studios,..ect), that Murphy later denounced.
http://the-5th-turtle.blogspot.com/2008/09/rumor-fatigue.html
Peanut
09-08-2008, 03:20 PM
That is...kinda rediculous. To say nthing of the fact your sitting there watching a kid get beaten up...
Spend time in a library, or a retail store (or even an actual school)
Plenty of kinds read manga these days. Minority or not, its a fairly large marketed group.
1) I live across the street from a high school. If I was to go out and save every kid who got the **** kicked out of them, I'd be there all day.
2) I often go to the library and plenty retail stores, what does this have to do with anything?
3) I never said they didn't, but to say that most kids do is stupid.
Drtooth
09-08-2008, 04:06 PM
Kids just don't read comics anymore. I can't remember the last time I saw a kid in my local comic books tore.
Probably in your area... Free Comics day, every place I went to was mobbed with kids and adults. Sure, the adults outnumbered the kids... but then again, maybe kids are lazy and can't even bother reading when there are pictures on the page. Man, we're screwed, if this is the next generation.
the fixer
09-09-2008, 02:16 AM
maybe kids are lazy and can't even bother reading when there are pictures on the page. Man, we're screwed, if this is the next generation.
As usual, I blame the Power Rangers... ;)
Hey,
I hyave been reading all these posts recently. On September 2nd, it was announced for a sequel, maybe live action/cgi format.
Now, on September 4th, it says that the sequel is untrue or something.
Can anyone please give me a heads up? I am not constantly on this forum, but I would like to get an update on the sequel. I am a huge TMNT fan, and is very anxious to get an announcement on the new movie.
Thanks,
Ron
The Stryker
09-09-2008, 02:57 AM
Probably in your area... Free Comics day, every place I went to was mobbed with kids and adults. Sure, the adults outnumbered the kids... but then again, maybe kids are lazy and can't even bother reading when there are pictures on the page. Man, we're screwed, if this is the next generation.
Yes, as usual. Everything about the current generation is trash, everything you remember from your "time" is awesome and is head and shoulders above everything today.
Shut the hell up already.
Drtooth
09-09-2008, 08:16 AM
Yes, as usual. Everything about the current generation is trash, everything you remember from your "time" is awesome and is head and shoulders above everything today.
Hey... the kids in my generation made homophobic AIDS jokes, beat the shizz out of everything that moved, and made life a living hell for the other half of the kids, but at LEAST they stole someone's lunch money to buy comics....
I blame Blues Clues and Teletubbies....
Voltron
09-09-2008, 06:59 PM
Your sig is too large. As is that wall of text that no one probably cares about.
He's right. I don't care about a single word of it.
Dragon Turtle
09-10-2008, 01:35 PM
Kevin Eastman posted this at the Heavy Metal forums in response to the recent TMNT sequel talks:
"Hey Gang,
Over the many years of my working in Hollywood I get, see, and hear a lot of information about a great many projects from many good friends, producers, directors, and writers, working in the business--and having a direct connection with the TMNT's I hear even more of what is going on with them--AND recently shared some information with MANY excited fans at the Toronto Fan Expo as well as in this Forum that has ticked off a bunch of folks, and gotten others in trouble unfairly--meaning; in the future--if there is any cool TMNT news that comes my way, true or not, I think I'll keep that information to myself, and wait to let the Mirage guys decide what they choose to tell you or not.
My apologies to all those pissed off, or hurt by "just another excited fan sharing good news" and I wish all at Mirage Studios, and those related to them in Hollywood, the best of luck with all their projects--and like all (or most) of you--hope to see them back on the big screen in the near future.
Many respects and warm regards, Kevin"
ZariusTwo
09-10-2008, 01:48 PM
As usual, I blame the Power Rangers... ;)
It'd be so simple if the thirty year olds still watching it didnt have such a goddamn attentive monopoly on it.:lol:
Blame Barney like everyone else.
NameGoesHere1066
09-10-2008, 02:22 PM
He's right. I don't care about a single word of it.
I guess it's a good thing I wasn't talking to eighther one you then, and same here about me not caring about anything you guys just typed. :roll:
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.