PDA

View Full Version : reboot or sequel?


Slap-Happy
09-01-2008, 01:55 PM
Should the make more sequels for TMNT, or just start completely over?

I think they should just start over, but not with a straight adaptation of number 1 (because that would be less than an hour long).

ToTheNines
09-01-2008, 02:40 PM
Both, give us a DTV sequel and a feature film re-boot.

SHREDDER-X
09-01-2008, 06:32 PM
Complete Reboot. Batman Begins and Dark Knight showed us the way. Bring the turtles back to their underground dark roots. Problem is, finding a studio with enough balls to keep it real and not succumb to Ad and Studio execs, parental groups, and fanboys who think the turtles should reflect the 87 toon or be targeted towards kids.

junkboy
09-01-2008, 06:36 PM
Reboot live action.
Sequels should be in TV cartoons or direct to dvd animated movies imo. I mean for more hardcore fans.

Drtooth
09-01-2008, 08:56 PM
I DON'T want a reboot! I don't wanna sit through the origin story a hundred more times. I want them to do something new. If I want to see the origin again, I can just re-read the first comic book. Just make a darker sequal... or a hanging sequal or something. it CAN be done.

Jester
09-01-2008, 09:04 PM
Live action plus CGI direct sequal to the original 1990 TMNT movie....but that's just me. Heck if Superman Returns (not to mention the Richard Donner cut of Superman 2) can do it why not the next TMNT film?

Cipher
09-01-2008, 10:14 PM
I DON'T want a reboot! I don't wanna sit through the origin story a hundred more times. I want them to do something new. If I want to see the origin again, I can just re-read the first comic book. Just make a darker sequal... or a hanging sequal or something. it CAN be done.Fans may have seen the origin a hundred times, but the general public hasn't. Loose sequels like Superman Returns and TMNT feel confusing and sloppy, and a radical change in tone would only aggravate that. If we want to introduce a darker Turtles movie to the public, we need to re-introduce the Turtles as well.

cup-mikey-gertha
09-01-2008, 10:20 PM
Sequel, please.

Do we have to see their origins again and again and again?

:lol:

KROW
09-01-2008, 10:41 PM
I'd rather see a sequel. Reboots are good when done right but it's a very delicate process. If not handled properly, they become disasters and the TMNT franchise can't afford that. Sequels alleviate a lot of pressure and are more fun to build on.

cup-mikey-gertha
09-01-2008, 10:59 PM
I'd rather see a sequel. Reboots are good when done right but it's a very delicate process. If not handled properly, they become disasters and the TMNT franchise can't afford that. Sequels alleviate a lot of pressure and are more fun to build on.

Now, if we can see Donny building a jet pack for Mikey in the sequel, that would be totally awesome.

:lol:

TristanHuwJones
09-01-2008, 11:49 PM
How come everyone seems to think reboot automatically means we see the origin again? You can do it without retelling everything.

KROW
09-01-2008, 11:59 PM
How come everyone seems to think reboot automatically means we see the origin again? You can do it without retelling everything.

Well, reboot usually means starting from the beginning, so the consensus view would think of an origin story. However, I do know that a reboot could spend less than 5 minutes narrating a quick explanation and have the remaining 85 or more on the real tale of the film.

cup-mikey-gertha
09-02-2008, 12:01 AM
How come everyone seems to think reboot automatically means we see the origin again? You can do it without retelling everything.

So you plan to do it in one scene? But if more than one scene, forgive me, but for me, it's a "waste" of precious running time. It's beneficial perhaps for the new generations, but I don't really think necessary. Funny. My toddler nephew to cousin automatically shouts, "Turtles! Turles!" whenever he sees me from work implying "Let's go watch The Turtles!" even if he himself have seen the CGI movie for like 20 times now. He never saw the origin, but he never seem to care. I pop the DVD in and he intently watches it until the end scene.

I love that kid.

Oh, he continues to ask me to give him my Turtle toy collectibles. Like no!

:D

AquaParade
09-02-2008, 12:12 AM
How come everyone seems to think reboot automatically means we see the origin again? You can do it without retelling everything.

That's what I have been mentioning in the "Kevin Eastman..." thread, in order to get people's thumbs up towards it. I think presenting the tmnt as some weird science mystery for the first movie with very little clue as to where they came from would come with great presence for the tmnt.

cup-mikey-gertha
09-02-2008, 12:25 AM
I beg your pardon. Sorry, but I didn't get your statement, AquaParade. Can you rephrase that, please.

:)

SHREDDER-X
09-02-2008, 07:15 PM
Here this is how I would reboot the franchise combining both Mirage and OT.

- Movie 1 : Turtles fight a crimewave in New York, committed by The Purple Dragon Gang led by Hun and his two main henchmen ( Bebop and Rocksteady in human form.) Meet Casey Jones. Meet April (Newsreporter) Realize that The Dragons were just pawns for a bigger criminal organization.

- Movie 2 : After defeat of Purple Dragons in first movie, Splinter realizes that The Foot Clan are the main culprits, and that the Shredder is the greatest threat to New York. Finally tells the turtles their origin, and sends them off to fight the Shredder. After Shredders defeat, comes back to find Splinter gone, and the lair in shambles and broken mousers.

-Movie 3 : Turtles go to live with April. Find out that mouser robots created by Dr. Baxter Stockman, and Dr. Krang, at T.C.R.I Labs. April tries to interview Stockman and finds out he's a mad man wanting to use the mousers for evil. Hold April Hostage. Turtles and Casey go to rescue April , fight mousers, defeat Stockman, find Splinter and discovers Dr. Krang is an evil Utrom warlord who sends himself, splinter, and the turtles through the transmat device to Dimension-X, leaving April and Casey behind.

-Movie 4 : Turtles land in Dimension-X, meet and rescue Proff. Honeycutt (Fugitoid)from Gen.Blaques troops. Krang holds Splinter Hostage in his huge space ship ( the technodrome), hires the Triceratons to apprehend Honeycutt to help build a larger transmat device to allow a full ledge invasion. Turtles get caught, and are force to fight Triceratons in arena. Blaques troops attack and destroy the technodrome, and Honeycutt gives his life sending the turtles and splinter home.

-Movie 5 : Turtles and Splinter return. Finds out from April and Casey that they've been gone for 2 years. The Foot has been rebuilt, led by Lady Shredder aka Karai. Foot hold Proff. Perry ( who's an Utrom), hostage and force him to create a mutant to fight the turtles, Leatherhead. Karai challenges the turtles to one final fight, at Foot Towers. Perry convinces Leatherhead to switch sides, and Helps fights the Foot while the turtles face Karai. Karai, pulls her final weapon, a Mutant turtle named Slash created from mutagen, mystic worms, and Shredder's DNA. Turtles fight Slash, and Leo decapitates him . Turtles win, Karai commits Sepukku, The Foot finally falls,and Leatherhead and Perry Utrom live deep in the sewers.


Yeah I know this will NEVER HAPPEN , but it's what I've always wanted to see in my TMNT movie.

Evilsherbear
09-02-2008, 08:04 PM
Problem is, finding a studio with enough balls to keep it real and not succumb to Ad and Studio execs, parental groups, and fanboys who think the turtles should reflect the 87 toon or be targeted towards kids.

That's exactly why I don't want a reboot, because I think this is what I envision happening (unless it was a DTV release). I say Mirage should pull a George Lucas, make the movie they want, then shop it around.

Andrew NDB
09-02-2008, 08:18 PM
How come everyone seems to think reboot automatically means we see the origin again?

I was about to ask the same thing.

Though apparently that Steve guy who posted earlier here about his fan script said he spoke to Gary Richardson not too long ago and he'd told him the new movie was being geared as "an origin movie." Take with a grain of salt.

Aztec General
09-02-2008, 09:29 PM
Reboot with no origin tale. Let's all be honest here: the story for TMNT was atrociously retarded. They really need to scrap it and get back to basics.

jerome
09-02-2008, 09:46 PM
I vote for reboot because i feel the tmnt are stuck in what i would like to call "adam west syndrome". If i remember right when the '89 batman film was coming out a lot of people were confused because batman was supposed to go "PoW!" and BaMM and so forth and this new batman was sort of dark and brooding and obviously more for adults. The burton batman pretty much flew in the face of what the general public (not comic readers. I'm talking people who didn't and still don't know or care who frank miller is) thought batman was supposed to be.

that is why we need a reboot. so the public can finally see what the turtles actually are. No technodrome, no bebop and rocksteady and krang, no surfer dude lingo (why talk like that? they live in the sewer in new york??), no cheesy jokes etc. I'd love a reboot that shows the tmnt that i love. Gritty, urban and stealthy. Or at least a movie where i actally get to see leo and raph stab or slash someone or something....

TristanHuwJones
09-02-2008, 09:53 PM
I was about to ask the same thing.

Though apparently that Steve guy who posted earlier here about his fan script said he spoke to Gary Richardson not too long ago and he'd told him the new movie was being geared as "an origin movie." Take with a grain of salt.

The guy has good intentions, but in all seriousness, I wouldn't back that horse.

thebrownranger
09-02-2008, 10:08 PM
I chose reboot and when I mean reboot, I mean that they should start off from where the first movie left off and not the other three that supposedly pass off as good comic book movies. It shouldn't get redundant by retelling exactly what the first movie explained. Just a brief summary would be nice. There should be an ideal sequel to that of the first.

Mr._Mutant_Man
09-03-2008, 12:08 AM
Sequel. The first movie was just fine as an origin movie. Maybe a sequel that ignores the other sequels, so it's a little bit of both sequel and reboot. Kind of like what Superman Returns was.

You can go back to the darker roots without completely starting over from scratch.

Andrew NDB
09-03-2008, 12:08 AM
Reboot with no origin tale. Let's all be honest here: the story for TMNT was atrociously retarded. They really need to scrap it and get back to basics.

I vote for reboot because i feel the tmnt are stuck in what i would like to call "adam west syndrome". If i remember right when the '89 batman film was coming out a lot of people were confused because batman was supposed to go "PoW!" and BaMM and so forth and this new batman was sort of dark and brooding and obviously more for adults. The burton batman pretty much flew in the face of what the general public (not comic readers. I'm talking people who didn't and still don't know or care who frank miller is) thought batman was supposed to be.

that is why we need a reboot. so the public can finally see what the turtles actually are. No technodrome, no bebop and rocksteady and krang, no surfer dude lingo (why talk like that? they live in the sewer in new york??), no cheesy jokes etc. I'd love a reboot that shows the tmnt that i love. Gritty, urban and stealthy. Or at least a movie where i actally get to see leo and raph stab or slash someone or something....


Two very sound posts in a row... I'm taken aback. :)

Sequel. The first movie was just fine as an origin movie. Maybe a sequel that ignores the other sequels, so it's a little bit of both sequel and reboot. Kind of like what Superman Returns was.

Isn't that exactly what the last movie was? From Munroe's own words it was "kind of like what Superman Returns" did.

Because we all know how much of a success Superman Returns was. So much so, WB has already issued an official public statement that Superman Returns didn't position where he needs to be, and that the next film will be a reboot en masse.

Dragon Turtle
09-03-2008, 02:10 AM
Isn't that exactly what the last movie was? From Munroe's own words it was "kind of like what Superman Returns" did.


Very tenuously, even Monroe in later interviews tries to downplay the comparison. I believe a sequel/reboot can work, especially since the turtles are entering a different medium. It would be best to forgo an origin adaption, and have April, Casey, and Karai, as established characters. And with Shredder still dead, move the story foward into a "Return to New York/City at War" style story.


Because we all know how much of a success Superman Returns was. So much so, WB has already issued an official public statement that Superman Returns didn't position where he needs to be, and that the next film will be a reboot en masse.

I believe that is WB's polite way of saying they didn't like Bryan Singer's particular direction for Superman and were not interested in carrying it forward.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-03-2008, 07:15 AM
Here this is how I would reboot the franchise combining both Mirage and OT.

- Movie 1 : Turtles fight a crimewave in New York, committed by The Purple Dragon Gang led by Hun and his two main henchmen ( Bebop and Rocksteady in human form.) Meet Casey Jones. Meet April (Newsreporter) Realize that The Dragons were just pawns for a bigger criminal organization.

- Movie 2 : After defeat of Purple Dragons in first movie, Splinter realizes that The Foot Clan are the main culprits, and that the Shredder is the greatest threat to New York. Finally tells the turtles their origin, and sends them off to fight the Shredder. After Shredders defeat, comes back to find Splinter gone, and the lair in shambles and broken mousers.

-Movie 3 : Turtles go to live with April. Find out that mouser robots created by Dr. Baxter Stockman, and Dr. Krang, at T.C.R.I Labs. April tries to interview Stockman and finds out he's a mad man wanting to use the mousers for evil. Hold April Hostage. Turtles and Casey go to rescue April , fight mousers, defeat Stockman, find Splinter and discovers Dr. Krang is an evil Utrom warlord who sends himself, splinter, and the turtles through the transmat device to Dimension-X, leaving April and Casey behind.

-Movie 4 : Turtles land in Dimension-X, meet and rescue Proff. Honeycutt (Fugitoid)from Gen.Blaques troops. Krang holds Splinter Hostage in his huge space ship ( the technodrome), hires the Triceratons to apprehend Honeycutt to help build a larger transmat device to allow a full ledge invasion. Turtles get caught, and are force to fight Triceratons in arena. Blaques troops attack and destroy the technodrome, and Honeycutt gives his life sending the turtles and splinter home.

-Movie 5 : Turtles and Splinter return. Finds out from April and Casey that they've been gone for 2 years. The Foot has been rebuilt, led by Lady Shredder aka Karai. Foot hold Proff. Perry ( who's an Utrom), hostage and force him to create a mutant to fight the turtles, Leatherhead. Karai challenges the turtles to one final fight, at Foot Towers. Perry convinces Leatherhead to switch sides, and Helps fights the Foot while the turtles face Karai. Karai, pulls her final weapon, a Mutant turtle named Slash created from mutagen, mystic worms, and Shredder's DNA. Turtles fight Slash, and Leo decapitates him . Turtles win, Karai commits Sepukku, The Foot finally falls,and Leatherhead and Perry Utrom live deep in the sewers.


Yeah I know this will NEVER HAPPEN , but it's what I've always wanted to see in my TMNT movie.

Cool, I have always thought it would be cool if to see the Technodrome being used as space station oribiting a planet and not just being stuck on one for a season or two.

SHREDDER-X
09-03-2008, 11:36 AM
i vote for reboot because i feel the tmnt are stuck in what i would like to call "adam west syndrome". If i remember right when the '89 batman film was coming out a lot of people were confused because batman was supposed to go "pow!" and bamm and so forth and this new batman was sort of dark and brooding and obviously more for adults. The burton batman pretty much flew in the face of what the general public (not comic readers. I'm talking people who didn't and still don't know or care who frank miller is) thought batman was supposed to be.

That is why we need a reboot. So the public can finally see what the turtles actually are. No technodrome, no bebop and rocksteady and krang, no surfer dude lingo (why talk like that? They live in the sewer in new york??), no cheesy jokes etc. I'd love a reboot that shows the tmnt that i love. Gritty, urban and stealthy. Or at least a movie where i actally get to see leo and raph stab or slash someone or something....

exactly !!!

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-03-2008, 01:52 PM
I vote for reboot because i feel the tmnt are stuck in what i would like to call "adam west syndrome". If i remember right when the '89 batman film was coming out a lot of people were confused because batman was supposed to go "PoW!" and BaMM and so forth and this new batman was sort of dark and brooding and obviously more for adults. The burton batman pretty much flew in the face of what the general public (not comic readers. I'm talking people who didn't and still don't know or care who frank miller is) thought batman was supposed to be.

that is why we need a reboot. so the public can finally see what the turtles actually are. No technodrome, no bebop and rocksteady and krang, no surfer dude lingo (why talk like that? they live in the sewer in new york??), no cheesy jokes etc. I'd love a reboot that shows the tmnt that i love. Gritty, urban and stealthy. Or at least a movie where i actally get to see leo and raph stab or slash someone or something....

The first TMNT movie was already a part in that direction.

jerome
09-03-2008, 02:25 PM
The first TMNT movie was already a part in that direction.

yes i agree but to keep with the batman theme lets say that TMNT 1990 is like Burton's '89 Batman. That batman was a quality film. Not my exact batman cup of tea but it wasn't horrible by any stretch. Now after years of mistreatment and down right abuse that climaxed with Batman & Robin, the franchise was so stale and gross to the general public that it needed to be completely re-done in order to drum up new interest. Hence Batman Begins.

Now lets say if Turtles 1990 is '89 batman then tmnt 2,3, next mutation, and tmnt 07 were all variations of batman forever and batman and robin and the old toon is the adam west batman. I'm not including the new toon in any of this because it just isn't what most of the general public think of when the words ninja turtles is heard. (if it was then we wouldn't have this problem and we would have already had or would for sure be getting a darker movie or at least something comparable to transformers or iron man). Point being that the property is trash to most of the general public and some sort of continuation squeezed in after the first movie just wouldn't be enough to really get people into the theatre. It would also be confusing just like superman returns was. People not sure if 2 and 3 still happened or if this replaces them or what.

We also need to assume that if they do this movie right more people than just those who know the origin of the tmnt will be filling theatre seats. So at least some attempt at an origin should be given in the movie.

SHREDDER-X
09-03-2008, 02:59 PM
yes i agree but to keep with the batman theme lets say that TMNT 1990 is like Burton's '89 Batman. That batman was a quality film. Not my exact batman cup of tea but it wasn't horrible by any stretch. Now after years of mistreatment and down right abuse that climaxed with Batman & Robin, the franchise was so stale and gross to the general public that it needed to be completely re-done in order to drum up new interest. Hence Batman Begins.

Now lets say if Turtles 1990 is '89 batman then tmnt 2,3, next mutation, and tmnt 07 were all variations of batman forever and batman and robin and the old toon is the adam west batman. I'm not including the new toon in any of this because it just isn't what most of the general public think of when the words ninja turtles is heard. (if it was then we wouldn't have this problem and we would have already had or would for sure be getting a darker movie or at least something comparable to transformers or iron man). Point being that the property is trash to most of the general public and some sort of continuation squeezed in after the first movie just wouldn't be enough to really get people into the theatre. It would also be confusing just like superman returns was. People not sure if 2 and 3 still happened or if this replaces them or what.

We also need to assume that if they do this movie right more people than just those who know the origin of the tmnt will be filling theatre seats. So at least some attempt at an origin should be given in the movie.

JEROME, you're a genius man. JEROME FOR PRESIDENT !!!

cup-mikey-gertha
09-04-2008, 06:26 PM
I'd love a reboot that shows the tmnt that i love. Gritty, urban and stealthy. Or at least a movie where i actally get to see leo and raph stab or slash someone or something....

Ah, OK. If Laird, Eastman and the guys can PROMISE that we get to see Leo and Raph stab or slash someone with the blood and all, then count me in for reboot.

8)

shuriken
09-04-2008, 07:08 PM
I don't know. I agree with all the dudes that say we need a reboot that has the gritty feel of the comics but I don't think anyone really has the power to do that right now. And If they did I think that the Movie will end up like 2004's punisher :dead:. Although the movie was gritty, it was craptastic. A violent and gritty movie doesn't always mean it will be a good movie.
They could also do a sequal like Rocky Balboa did. After the Third One Rocky Totally lost his roots. 3, 4and 5 were really over the top (no pun intended) and although I liked the films these three felt kind of forced. But in Rocky Balboa it felt like Rocky was back home in the sense that this was the same Rocky from the first two only older and more depressed. I think they could do a sequal and or an origin tale and have it be totally badass but the directors and the people invlolved have to take it seriously. Although I doubt any serious filmaker gives a rat's ass about the true Tmnt fans. But then again who knows?

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-05-2008, 04:53 AM
Why not use some Archie-inspired stuff? Archie is more exciting stories than the 1987 cartoon. I don't want to see a lot of brutal violence and blood just because of the brutal violence and blood (which I suspect some read Mirage because of).

thebrownranger
09-05-2008, 08:24 AM
The guy has good intentions, but in all seriousness, I wouldn't back that horse.

True. I feel that starting from scratch and forgetting the first flick would mean that it would kinda be an insult to the work and success of the original movie. That's why it should not be a complete reboot, just clearing the slate from the 2007 film (ain't really sure about I and III considering it took a few aspects of the comics- TCRI and the time sceptre).

The Big Bad
09-05-2008, 11:28 AM
Sequel, because I just don't see what good a reboot would do, at this point. The Shredder is a dead-end villain more useful dead than alive; there are no other villains who would benefit from a re-interpretation, given that most haven't been adapted in the first place. The origin and first meetings with Casey and April were handled adequately enough in the first film. The audience isn't interested in seeing the concept played straight, nor do I think it would make for an interesting movie--at best, I can see it done a la Kill Bill: violent, with tongue firmly in cheek. The only reason I can see for rebooting is to bring the turtles origin more in line with the comic books, and I really don't think that would play with a movie audience.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-05-2008, 04:52 PM
I chose reboot and when I mean reboot, I mean that they should start off from where the first movie left off and not the other three that supposedly pass off as good comic book movies. It shouldn't get redundant by retelling exactly what the first movie explained. Just a brief summary would be nice. There should be an ideal sequel to that of the first.

I think that also can work if they fight Baxter Stockman's mousers.

Slap-Happy
09-05-2008, 07:50 PM
why don't we have a reboot without un origin?

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-06-2008, 06:39 AM
why don't we have a reboot without un origin?

If a reboot without an origin, how will you know it's a reboot (if the TMNT don't all wear red bandanas, which I don't belive they will do since the bandana color has became a part of their character in all TMNT universe except the 1984 Mirage comics)?

Darth Shredder
09-06-2008, 07:11 AM
I think that also can work if they fight Baxter Stockman's mousers.

Are you serious? Nobody in their right mind wants the climax of a TMNT reboot to be a Turtles and mousers showdown.

thebrownranger
09-06-2008, 09:21 AM
Are you serious? Nobody in their right mind wants the climax of a TMNT reboot to be a Turtles and mousers showdown.

Yeah thats true, we should have the Shredder/Foot clan and maybe the Rat King b/c there's no telling how sinister they can make him (he's like the Joker of tmnt who hasn't had a debut). I also find that putting Baxter Stockman w/ mousers will make it kinda cheesy and boring. I don't really want to be sitting in my seat and watching the turtles fight a mad scientist and a bunch of robots.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-06-2008, 10:13 AM
Yeah thats true, we should have the Shredder/Foot clan and maybe the Rat King b/c there's no telling how sinister they can make him (he's like the Joker of tmnt who hasn't had a debut). I also find that putting Baxter Stockman w/ mousers will make it kinda cheesy and boring. I don't really want to be sitting in my seat and watching the turtles fight a mad scientist and a bunch of robots.

Do you want the Rat King to hypnotize Splinter, so the TMNT have to face their own sensei in a battle for life and death.

Mr._Mutant_Man
09-09-2008, 07:42 AM
Because we all know how much of a success Superman Returns was. So much so, WB has already issued an official public statement that Superman Returns didn't position where he needs to be, and that the next film will be a reboot en masse.

Superman Returns wasn't an excellent movie, but Marvel has come out with a lot worse...such as...well about most of what Marvel has put out in the last couple of years except for Iron Man and Incredible Hulk.

I don't like the idea of a reboot for Superman. I don't see how they can top the Richard Donner movie. Maybe a film that's another follow up to it that ignores Returns, but Richard Donner nailed Superman except for the odd ending.

R-iZZy
09-10-2008, 03:40 PM
I wouldn't have minded a sequel if the movie franchise stopped after the second movie. But the third and fourth movies have sent the Turtles in such a wacky, looney and ridiculous trip that it gave the guys such a childish tone. There's no need to keep the franchise childish, it just gives fans even more of a reason to connect the films with the original TMNT cartoon series.

This franchise needs a reboot and bad. This movie can be made dark, gritty and a bit more violent, but those aspects don't have to be the selling points of the movie. Of course, give the characters development [and don't just focus on Leo and Raph's tension anymore], give the movies an intricate plot, include a bit more serious depth and knowledge in the art of ninjutsu. As ridiculous as the idea of four mutant turtles knowing ninjutsu is, it's that unbelievability with that little slice of reality that gives this franchise such a huge chance to where not all viewers will think this is ridiculous.

And of course, make sure the stories and plots borrow a lot of material from the source [the 1984 Mirage comics].

Oh, and yes... there will have to be a re-telling of their origins. Just because we're all familiar with the many origins of TMNT, doesn't mean the general public is. Plus, even if there was a re-telling of the origins, everyone knows they'd be okay with it if done properly.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-10-2008, 04:00 PM
I wouldn't have minded a sequel if the movie franchise stopped after the second movie. But the third and fourth movies have sent the Turtles in such a wacky, looney and ridiculous trip that it gave the guys such a childish tone. There's no need to keep the franchise childish, it just gives fans even more of a reason to connect the films with the original TMNT cartoon series.

This franchise needs a reboot and bad. This movie can be made dark, gritty and a bit more violent, but those aspects don't have to be the selling points of the movie. Of course, give the characters development [and don't just focus on Leo and Raph's tension anymore], give the movies an intricate plot, include a bit more serious depth and knowledge in the art of ninjutsu. As ridiculous as the idea of four mutant turtles knowing ninjutsu is, it's that unbelievability with that little slice of reality that gives this franchise such a huge chance to where not all viewers will think this is ridiculous.

And of course, make sure the stories and plots borrow a lot of material from the source [the 1984 Mirage comics].

Oh, and yes... there will have to be a re-telling of their origins. Just because we're all familiar with the many origins of TMNT, doesn't mean the general public is. Plus, even if there was a re-telling of the origins, everyone knows they'd be okay with it if done properly.

Here in Sweden a lot of people only know the 1987 cartoon, Archie and the movies, and belive the 2003 cartoon is based on a new concept. When it came to TMNT comics, we didn't have much Mirage, just Archie and the UK Hero Turtles comics.

CJStyles
09-10-2008, 11:42 PM
The TMNT franchise is in desperate need of a reboot. Like many have said before it needs to be darker and greedier. I do believe an origins story is needed for casual fans. But I also don't want to rehashing the same old Mirage comic stories. You can take establish characters and ones who haven't been established on film and make a fresh new story with them while still sticking to the Turtles roots. Keep the multi colored bandannas cause I don't want to see them wear all read.

I'd also like to a serious story and a more martial arts rooted feel to it. Action as amazing as Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon or The Protector. That's what I really would like to see in a reboot stunning fight scenes, and that kind of thing has been missing in the series. I know some characters like Keno, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady aren't original Mirage characters but if they did use them.... does anyone think Tony Jaa would make an excellent older version of Keno?.... just a thought

If we want to see the Ninja Turtles endured by the public a reboot is seriously needed. I know some thing a reboot would be a slap in the face to the original movie and its success but I beg to differ here. Simply put it was what it was, this is something new. Two different Turtle universes.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-11-2008, 07:17 AM
The TMNT franchise is in desperate need of a reboot. Like many have said before it needs to be darker and greedier. I do believe an origins story is needed for casual fans. But I also don't want to rehashing the same old Mirage comic stories. You can take establish characters and ones who haven't been established on film and make a fresh new story with them while still sticking to the Turtles roots. Keep the multi colored bandannas cause I don't want to see them wear all read.

I'd also like to a serious story and a more martial arts rooted feel to it. Action as amazing as Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon or The Protector. That's what I really would like to see in a reboot stunning fight scenes, and that kind of thing has been missing in the series. I know some characters like Keno, Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady aren't original Mirage characters but if they did use them.... does anyone think Tony Jaa would make an excellent older version of Keno?.... just a thought

If we want to see the Ninja Turtles endured by the public a reboot is seriously needed. I know some thing a reboot would be a slap in the face to the original movie and its success but I beg to differ here. Simply put it was what it was, this is something new. Two different Turtle universes.

I belive Bebop and Rocksteady work in a darker TMNT movie if they are more cool and deadly than in the 1987 cartoon, and not so stupid.

CJStyles
09-11-2008, 08:14 AM
Exactly. It can work if you mold the characters in a different way to fit the story. It's just Laird, who the franchise belongs to and he has final say, doesn't want that kind of thing to happen(using non Mirage characters). Personally, I don't see why the man is so damn picky when his franchise has done horrible when it comes to movies as of late.

Warhorse
09-12-2008, 12:06 AM
I DON'T want a reboot! I don't wanna sit through the origin story a hundred more times. I want them to do something new. If I want to see the origin again, I can just re-read the first comic book. Just make a darker sequal... or a hanging sequal or something. it CAN be done.

I agree. I'm getting sick of these reboots too.

KROW
09-12-2008, 10:19 AM
Although a reboot could be done right and be successful, it still means starting from scratch. With a sequel, you've got more to work with and more ways to be creative. We pretty much know what a reboot might have; origin, Shredder, rehashing battles and encounters. But if you move on to something else, you expand the universe, as it were, and give the franchise more credibility in having more than one crisis to defeat.

Rebooting the movie series might lead to an audience bereft of interest, especially if Shredder becomes the lead antagonist. Shredder was in the first and second films, Shredder was in the OT, Shredder was in the 2K3 toon, Shredder was in TNM, Shredder even made a cameo in the '07 film. Yes, he's an important part of the TMNT-verse, an integral piece of what makes them a better group of heroes, the epitome of the evil they have to overcome as dedicated vigilantes. But, having Shredder in every single incarnation of a TMNT project is going to lead people to thinking, while being reminded of characters like Batman and Spider-Man, "Jeez, is he the only villain they got?"

Of course, we all know he isn't, so let's delve into that pit of slime and pull out another greaseball for them to beat. Let's see what the bigwigs can do with Baxter Stockman, Leatherhead, and Rat King, and follow Splinter's sage advice to, "leave the Shredder buried."

Cipher
09-12-2008, 10:43 AM
Exactly. It can work if you mold the characters in a different way to fit the story.Bebop and Rocksteady in a serious TMNT story would be a dream come true. I'm not sure where people got the idea that a reboot would have to be a total rehash of the first movie. You can stick anything you want in a reboot. You could introduce April, the Turtles, Casey, and a dark version of Bebop and Rocksteady all in one reboot. You can do whatever the hell you want as long as it reintroduces the Turtles with a darker tone. That's something people can swallow.

What's hard for people to swallow, is a movie series drastically changing style and tone in the middle of its continuity, being unclear on where it stands, and just alienating a whole bunch of newcomers for no good reason.

When the biggest argument against a reboot is how it narrows story options, I can only assume people are being narrow minded.

CJStyles
09-12-2008, 07:39 PM
Well if they plan to revamp the franchise and make it worth something, then a reboot to me seems like it's needed. Reintroduce the characters and make them more serious. I don't think you would need the shredder if you were to reboot, but that's just my opinion. However, it'd be cool see Orku Saki, but not under his Shredder mantle. It could possibly come later in the series. Enhance the character even bring in Pimiko or make Karai is daughter and how's he torn between the life he may lead and his daughter.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-24-2008, 06:55 AM
If reboot, why not a reboot for the 2007 movie (if it's an own TMNT universe).

PizzaPower
09-24-2008, 08:55 AM
I DON'T want a reboot! I don't wanna sit through the origin story a hundred more times. I want them to do something new. If I want to see the origin again, I can just re-read the first comic book. Just make a darker sequal... or a hanging sequal or something. it CAN be done.
I agree with you, i want a sequal.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-24-2008, 12:36 PM
I agree with you, i want a sequal.

How do you want the plot?

Lobster Mooch
10-11-2008, 10:43 AM
I would have to say reboot, for the many reasons already stated.

I know however that if we are to get the reboot we want, it has to be done independently from major studios as they only see the cash cow side and so far Turtles made the most money being a kids cartoon in the 80's.

Could Mirage afford to finance the film solo, unlikely and even if they could it would be one hell of a risk that would mean ruin if it failed.

Plot wise, I want to see the Shredder and the foot done properly for once. The closest we got was the original movie and it could only go so far thanks to the cartoons influence. But I think the Shredder should be film 2 in the series or later. Like Joker in the new batman series, it would have been stupid to throw him in the first film, mainly because it is expected by the general viewing public.

Shredder and the Foot should be set up, even having cameo appearances in the first reboot film, but that is all. Also, no more end of the universe plots please, they are not cool, fun or anything else. I hate it when they overdramatise these films, it is already a stretch of believability to have the turtles at all, they first have to be established in a normal environment to get the connection. TMNT, put them in an very unreal situation, in a very stylised and in my opinion very badly designed medium, in a series that is all over the place since the second film, and the fact the turtles look different and sound different (again) than the other films means it has to be rebooted.

And these unofficial sequals are a terrible way to go, as Superman returns showed us, nobody has any idea what the hell was going on. Superman returns...what, he left?

They have to keep the humour from the comics (none of this your mamma joke crap from the 07 film) and balance it with the darker undertones, IE no one liner quips in fight scenes. I only hope they don't try to make it too dark like in the Dark Knight, great film but they tried so hard to make Batman more edgy with his voice he sounded like Stallone with Laryngitis. The depth of the film should not come from it being Dark, but from the story and characters being great, the Dark part come to ground it in some form of seriousness without being over the top.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
10-12-2008, 08:39 AM
So you plan to do it in one scene? But if more than one scene, forgive me, but for me, it's a "waste" of precious running time. It's beneficial perhaps for the new generations, but I don't really think necessary. Funny. My toddler nephew to cousin automatically shouts, "Turtles! Turles!" whenever he sees me from work implying "Let's go watch The Turtles!" even if he himself have seen the CGI movie for like 20 times now. He never saw the origin, but he never seem to care. I pop the DVD in and he intently watches it until the end scene.

I love that kid.

Oh, he continues to ask me to give him my Turtle toy collectibles. Like no!

:D

Maybe you can show him the original films?