PDA

View Full Version : Bishop or Shredder


godzod
09-10-2008, 11:58 PM
In the next film who would you rather have as the next antagonist.

The Stryker
09-11-2008, 03:17 AM
Well I would want a villain that wouldn't bore me to tears.

I vote Shredder.

funatic
09-11-2008, 04:51 AM
We already saw bishop in the last 3 Matrix films, cleverly 'disguised' as Agent Smith... so my vote is for the Shred Head :shredder:

godzod
09-11-2008, 12:55 PM
Well I would want a villain that wouldn't bore me to tears.

I vote Shredder.

So i guess you prefer one dimensional villain like the Shredder.:roll:

Jester
09-11-2008, 01:48 PM
So is this a thread where we're given a choice, but there is oviously a "right" one? :roll:



I like the idea of Bishop, the plot of the movie being a goverment official tracking down the TMNT to study them, all based on rumors flying around New York. I mean if they tweaked Bishop it could work. Heck, I'd like both. I could see Saki using a Bishop-like character to "DESTROY THE TURTLES!"

FearlessLeader
09-11-2008, 02:00 PM
I would be happy with either honestly.

(which is not a choice so I did not vote *laughs*)

I like Shredder for his "ultimate nemesis" vibe he has with the Turtles, plus I could be interested to see how they would present him in a modern (hopefully hybrid) film. And I don't see the Shredder as one dimensional either. As proven in the 4Kids cartoon many interesting and different things can be done with his character and still keep the Shredder spirit.

Bishop I actually ending up liking more then I thought I would when he was first introduced. I think I like his character because unlike Shredder Bishop sees himself as the "good guy". He is saving humanity from threats most people can't even dream of, hence he finds all of his actions justified. He reminds me a bit of Magneto from X-Men fandom in that way.

One thing I don't think I would like is Bishop and Shredder working together. Unless it really is just one using the other, but somehow they don't seem like that would make good allies.

Tinuvielsdreams
09-11-2008, 02:04 PM
So is this a thread where we're given a choice, but there is oviously a "right" one? :roll:



I like the idea of Bishop, the plot of the movie being a goverment official tracking down the TMNT to study them, all based on rumors flying around New York. I mean if they tweaked Bishop it could work. Heck, I'd like both. I could see Saki using a Bishop-like character to "DESTROY THE TURTLES!"

I just don't imagine a stand alone Bishop as villian movie I always imagine him as a secondary antagonist.
If Shredder used a Bishop-like character then I am betting it would get interesting. I don't see Bishop being so easily controlled by Shredder as some others are. He would go all rogue and the turtles would have to fight him and Shredder. It could be a cool what if scenerio

cup-mikey-gertha
09-11-2008, 02:57 PM
Shredder. But it has to be a human Shredder and not an utrom or a paranormal version.

:)

DTBlack
09-20-2008, 02:19 AM
I'm kind of tired of the fact that ever since The Incredible Hulk came out people won't shut up about reboots. TMNT was a breath of fresh air after the atrocity that was Turtles III, why would they reboot? They seem to have a good thing going, I want to see them run with it, not start from scratch.

syk_skillz
09-20-2008, 08:03 AM
People talk about rebooting the franchise so it can go back to it's roots and be more like the first movie from 1990 and not be directly made as a kids movie.

thebrownranger
09-20-2008, 01:56 PM
I'm kind of tired of the fact that ever since The Incredible Hulk came out people won't shut up about reboots. TMNT was a breath of fresh air after the atrocity that was Turtles III, why would they reboot? They seem to have a good thing going, I want to see them run with it, not start from scratch.

That's what I've been kind of saying. What I mean is that they should start from after the first movie b/c that's the only storyline where a continuing story w/ secondary villains could happen. And yeah, Bishop would be a horrible idea for a turtles movie.

shuriken
09-20-2008, 09:03 PM
I'd like Bishop. But I doubt many people( the non dromers and non hardcore fans) would know who he is so they'll be like WTF where's the Shredder?

KROW
09-21-2008, 10:11 AM
Neither. Shredder's been done to death and Bishop is just filler.

blue_angel99
09-21-2008, 07:08 PM
Neither. Shredder's been done to death and Bishop is just filler.

I agree.

But if I had to choose between the two, Bishop.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-22-2008, 09:23 AM
Shredder. How many non-TMNT fans know who Bishop is?

SassyGal
09-22-2008, 11:42 AM
Since we had to chose either or, I chose Shredder, simply because I felt his death at the end of Secret of the Ooze was pretty crappy. He survived a garbage truck as a normal man, but a pier killed him after he had been mutated...so lame.

I just don't imagine a stand alone Bishop as villian movie I always imagine him as a secondary antagonist.
If Shredder used a Bishop-like character then I am betting it would get interesting. I don't see Bishop being so easily controlled by Shredder as some others are. He would go all rogue and the turtles would have to fight him and Shredder. It could be a cool what if scenerio

I agree with you. Having the turtles fight Bishop and Shredder after a partnership between them falls to crap would be a cool scenario!

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-22-2008, 01:14 PM
Since we had to chose either or, I chose Shredder, simply because I felt his death at the end of Secret of the Ooze was pretty crappy. He survived a garbage truck as a normal man, but a pier killed him after he had been mutated...so lame.



I agree with you. Having the turtles fight Bishop and Shredder after a partnership between them falls to crap would be a cool scenario!

But he's alive in "Next Mutation", and Next Mutation is considered by some to follow the movies.

Wolf Ninja
09-22-2008, 01:14 PM
I say Shredder, but not as an alien or robotic or something like that.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-22-2008, 01:21 PM
I say Shredder, but not as an alien or robotic or something like that.

I hope so. I hope the TMNT creators leared something about the Utrom Shredder in the 2003 cartoon, and how many disliked him (even if they liked the show).

SassyGal
09-22-2008, 02:22 PM
But he's alive in "Next Mutation", and Next Mutation is considered by some to follow the movies.

Really? I never saw Next Mutation. I thought because Leonardo had said in the CGI movie that Shredder was dead, the movies were following each others' timeline and not integrating the events of the different tv incarnations.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-22-2008, 04:16 PM
Really? I never saw Next Mutation. I thought because Leonardo had said in the CGI movie that Shredder was dead, the movies were following each others' timeline and not integrating the events of the different tv incarnations.

But the TMNT live in an abandoned subway station and that stuff.

Jester
09-22-2008, 05:26 PM
Next Mutation is kinda loosly based on the movies, as some one said in another thread, much like Archie comics are loosly based on the OT.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-23-2008, 08:49 AM
Really? I never saw Next Mutation. I thought because Leonardo had said in the CGI movie that Shredder was dead, the movies were following each others' timeline and not integrating the events of the different tv incarnations.

There's some debate if even the 2007 movie follow the three original movies, or is an own TMNT version.

SassyGal
09-23-2008, 10:17 AM
There's some debate if even the 2007 movie follow the three original movies, or is an own TMNT version.

Either way, I always thought Shredder's "death" in Secret of the Ooze was lame and would like to see him come back for another movie.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-23-2008, 11:08 AM
Either way, I always thought Shredder's "death" in Secret of the Ooze was lame and would like to see him come back for another movie.

I recall that, and thought: "Bad guys in films always come back, in the next film he will probably team up with Krang". I was disappointed when it didn't happen.

Andrew NDB
09-23-2008, 02:23 PM
Bishop or Shredder? I guess it's better than asking "Bebop or Krang?" but unless we're talking about a reboot (in which case Shredder is logically going to be involved), it's like asking me which side of the jaw I'd like to get punched.

Shredder if I had to choose, and though I agree enough time has passed to see Saki on the screen again, I don't have enough confidence in TPTB in bringing about not only his return/resurrection but his portrayal on screen properly. In a sequel.

And about NT:TNM, it's absolutely a continuation of the first three films. You can figure that out not only by the TMNT having the same lair as in TMNT II and III and Splinter's ear (the only universe he has a severed ear is the theatrical), but by plenty of press releases and Eastman's own interviews that confirm it. Though some of those interviews are a little head-scratching... I seem to remember Eastman talking about how the Turtles were older and grittier and meaner than in the movies, and the whole show would be so edgy and dark. I'm not sure what he was smoking at the time, but the chances are it was pretty potent stuff.

About TMNT 2007 we have Kevin Munroe's own press release about it, flat-out telling us TMNT 1 and 2 were in-canon and serving as "a loose history" (meaning, and he brought up the Superman Returns example, that the films happened, they just needn't be referenced the hell out of in the movie). Then we saw the movie and they actually snuck in artifacts from TMNT 3 in there, so it's a logical leap to then assume the "loose history" was actually extended to encompass all 3 movies, not just the first 2. And why not, really? Though shoddy production values, TMNT 3 doesn't exactly damage anything from TMNT 1 and 2.

So basically... you have the first three movies, and then you have two different continuations, neither of which agree with the other. So you can follow two different paths and end up at either TMNT 4 or NT:TNM as the final destination.

Continuity 1) TMNT 1 => TMNT 2 => TMNT 3 => NT:TNM

Continuity 2) TMNT 1 => TMNT 2 => TMNT 3 => TMNT 4

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-23-2008, 02:40 PM
Bishop or Shredder? I guess it's better than asking "Bebop or Krang?" but unless we're talking about a reboot (in which case Shredder is logically going to be involved), it's like asking me which side of the jaw I'd like to get punched in.

Shredder if I had to choose, and though I agree enough time has passed to see Saki on the screen again, I don't have enough confidence in TPTB in bringing about not only his return/resurrection but his portrayal on screen properly. In a sequel.

And about NT:TNM, it's absolutely a continuation of the first three films. You can figure that out not only by the TMNT having the same lair as in TMNT II and III and Splinter's ear (the only universe he has a severed ear is the theatrical), but by plenty of press releases and Eastman's own interviews that confirm it. Though some of those interviews are a little head-scratching... I seem to remember Eastman talking about how the Turtles were older and grittier and meaner than in the movies, and the whole show would be so edgy and dark. I'm not sure what he was smoking at the time, but the chances are it was pretty potent stuff.

About TMNT 2007 we have Kevin Munroe's own press release about it, flat-out telling us TMNT 1 and 2 were in-canon and serving as "a loose history" (meaning, and he brought up the Superman Returns example, that the films happened, they just needn't be referenced the hell out of in the movie). Then we saw the movie and they actually snuck in artifacts from TMNT 3 in there, so it's a logical leap to then assume the "loose history" was actually extended to encompass all 3 movies, not just the first 2. And why not, really? Though shoddy production values, TMNT 3 doesn't exactly damage anything from TMNT 1 and 2.

So basically... you have the first three movies, and then you have two different continuations, neither of which agree with the other. So you can follow two different paths and end up at either TMNT 4 or NT:TNM as the final destination.

Continuity 1) TMNT 1 => TMNT 2 => TMNT 3 => NT:TNM

Continuity 2) TMNT 1 => TMNT 2 => TMNT 3 => TMNT 4

As Jester said, it's the same like the 1987 cartoon and the Archie comics have the same background before becoming two separate TMNT universes.

Andrew NDB
09-23-2008, 02:46 PM
As Jester said, it's the same like the 1987 cartoon and the Archie comics have the same background before becoming two separate TMNT universes.

That's not really comparing apples to apples at all.

While Archie began grounded in the Fred Wolf cartoon universe, after #5, introduced/reintroduced characters that ended up flying in the face/directly contradicting those same characters over in the Fred Wolf universe... it was made very, very clear that Archie was in its own universe and TPTB even made mention of it.

With NT:TNM, it was loudly voiced by TPTB as a continuation of the first three films. And like it or hate it, nothing in NT:TNM flew in the face of or contradicted events in TMNT 1-3. Rather the opposite.

Same story with TMNT 4. We were told flat out by the showrunner in the beginning that it was keeping at least the first two movies in-continuity. We get the movie and yes, nothing in it is really contradicted by the first three movies.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-23-2008, 02:54 PM
That's not really comparing apples to apples at all.

While Archie began grounded in the Fred Wolf cartoon universe, after #5, introduced/reintroduced characters that ended up flying in the face/directly contradicting those same characters over in the Fred Wolf universe... it was made very, very clear that Archie was in its own universe and TPTB even made mention of it.

With NT:TNM, it was loudly voiced by TPTB as a continuation of the first three films. And like it or hate it, nothing in NT:TNM flew in the face of or contradicted events in TMNT 1-3. Rather the opposite.

Same story with TMNT 4. We were told flat out by the showrunner in the beginning that it was keeping at least the first two movies in-continuity. We get the movie and yes, nothing in it is really contradicted by the first three movies.

It looks correct, but why is Next Mutation sometimes said to follow the 1987 cartoon. Maybe this: http://www.ninjaturtles.com/cartoon/synopses.htm (it has been there for many years).

Andrew NDB
09-23-2008, 03:22 PM
It looks correct, but why is Next Mutation sometimes said to follow the 1987 cartoon.

Because tonally it's closest to it? Fans not thinking things through? Take your pick.

Maybe this: http://www.ninjaturtles.com/cartoon/synopses.htm (it has been there for many years).

If I remember back to 1997, 1998, I think Dan was just listing up "TMNT on TV" when he was putting that onto the site. The 4Kids show wasn't even out when he did that. If it was, it'd probably be on that same listing, too.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-23-2008, 04:04 PM
Because tonally it's closest to it? Fans not thinking things through? Take your pick.



If I remember back to 1997, 1998, I think Dan was just listing up "TMNT on TV" when he was putting that onto the site. The 4Kids show wasn't even out when he did that. If it was, it'd probably be on that same listing, too.

I don't know how the site was back in those days.

Andrew NDB
09-23-2008, 04:31 PM
I don't know how the site was back in those days.

With the Wayback Machine website, now you can:

http://web.archive.org/web/19971210193444/http://www.ninjaturtles.com/

That's www.ninjaturtles.com in December of 1997.

Note how the old cartoon is lumped into "TMNT TV!" with NT:TNM because... well, they're both TV shows, not because they're in the same universe.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-23-2008, 04:48 PM
With the Wayback Machine website, now you can:

http://web.archive.org/web/19971210193444/http://www.ninjaturtles.com/

That's www.ninjaturtles.com in December of 1997.

Note how the old cartoon is lumped into "TMNT TV!" with NT:TNM because... well, they're both TV shows, not because they're in the same universe.

Thank you very match :), I think it's interesting to study how the Internet looked in the past and comapre it to our own time.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-23-2008, 06:22 PM
So i guess you prefer one dimensional villain like the Shredder.:roll:

There is NOTHING one-dimensional about Oroku Saki/Ch'rell!

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-24-2008, 12:47 PM
Since we had to chose either or, I chose Shredder, simply because I felt his death at the end of Secret of the Ooze was pretty crappy. He survived a garbage truck as a normal man, but a pier killed him after he had been mutated...so lame.



I agree with you. Having the turtles fight Bishop and Shredder after a partnership between them falls to crap would be a cool scenario!

To this day, it's still up to you if Shredder died or survived and swam over to UK and tried to replace John Major and Elizabeth II... :)

Shark_Blade
09-27-2008, 12:32 PM
Shredder of course (and I want human Shred head).

Bishop = snore-fest.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-27-2008, 01:17 PM
Shredder of course (and I want human Shred head).

Bishop = snore-fest.

Do you want Krang too?

thebrownranger
09-27-2008, 02:17 PM
With the Wayback Machine website, now you can:

http://web.archive.org/web/19971210193444/http://www.ninjaturtles.com/

That's www.ninjaturtles.com (http://www.ninjaturtles.com) in December of 1997.

Note how the old cartoon is lumped into "TMNT TV!" with NT:TNM because... well, they're both TV shows, not because they're in the same universe.

Holy crap! I must have forgot, but is that how the site originally looked back then in '97?

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-27-2008, 07:50 PM
With the Wayback Machine website, now you can:

http://web.archive.org/web/19971210193444/http://www.ninjaturtles.com/

That's www.ninjaturtles.com in December of 1997.

Note how the old cartoon is lumped into "TMNT TV!" with NT:TNM because... well, they're both TV shows, not because they're in the same universe.

I don't think they thought much about it, back in 1997 surfing the Internet was still a sensation.

Shark_Blade
09-28-2008, 07:35 AM
Do you want Krang too?
Nope. He can stay in the OT universe.

To me Shredder is an important character in TMNT. He's such an icon that whenever people mentioned the turtles they always relate to their arch enemy = The Shredder. Imagine telling them 'Bishop' their reaction probably be like 'Who is that?', 'Does he works for the church?' etc..


To not see the Shredder for two movies now (though we get gists of references to him) is truly upsetting for me :cry: and I keep on hoping that one day he will return in his true glory, being one of the badass villain of all time.:)

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-28-2008, 10:15 AM
Nope. He can stay in the OT universe.

To me Shredder is an important character in TMNT. He's such an icon that whenever people mentioned the turtles they always relate to their arch enemy = The Shredder. Imagine telling them 'Bishop' their reaction probably be like 'Who is that?', 'Does he works for the church?' etc..


To not see the Shredder for two movies now (though we get gists of references to him) is truly upsetting for me :cry: and I keep on hoping that one day he will return in his true glory, being one of the badass villain of all time.:)

How do you want the storyline for an adventure like that.

KROW
09-28-2008, 10:25 AM
To me Shredder is an important character in TMNT. He's such an icon that whenever people mentioned the turtles they always relate to their arch enemy = The Shredder. Imagine telling them 'Bishop' their reaction probably be like 'Who is that?', 'Does he works for the church?' etc..

But that's the thing, when you think about it. When you think of Spider-Man or Batman, you immediately don't think of Green Goblin and Joker, respectively. Your mind comes up with nearly the whole rogues gallery of each character. With the turtles, Shredder pops up all the time because he's been overused as the main villain. Even in the current cartoon they're coming up with different versions to try and keep it fresh, having four different Shredders already.

Sure, E&L emphasized Shredder in the book because he was the coolest villain they created for the turtles. But, if used right, other enemies (like Stockman and Rat King) can get some exposure and expand on the turtles' universe.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-28-2008, 01:15 PM
But that's the thing, when you think about it. When you think of Spider-Man or Batman, you immediately don't think of Green Goblin and Joker, respectively. Your mind comes up with nearly the whole rogues gallery of each character. With the turtles, Shredder pops up all the time because he's been overused as the main villain. Even in the current cartoon they're coming up with different versions to try and keep it fresh, having four different Shredders already.

Sure, E&L emphasized Shredder in the book because he was the coolest villain they created for the turtles. But, if used right, other enemies (like Stockman and Rat King) can get some exposure and expand on the turtles' universe.

Baxter Stockman and Rat King are also much more well-known to non fans than Bishop.

Leogeddon
09-28-2008, 03:55 PM
How about Bishop AND Shredder AND Baxter Stockman? I just hope they don't make him some stupid machine like in the new series.

It'd be awesome if they brought back a lot of the classic (87) show baddies to come in.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-28-2008, 04:50 PM
How about Bishop AND Shredder AND Baxter Stockman? I just hope they don't make him some stupid machine like in the new series.

It'd be awesome if they brought back a lot of the classic (87) show baddies to come in.

If the stuff shall be from the 1987 cartoon, I would lik to see Krang and Shredder.

Andrew NDB
09-28-2008, 05:12 PM
If the stuff shall be from the 1987 cartoon,

It won't. And it shouldn't.

thebrownranger
09-28-2008, 09:37 PM
I would lik to see Krang and Shredder.

I still don't understand as to why people are thinking of all these Bishop and Krang plots that would supposedly be good ideas for a movie. An approach like this would make it seem so childish, downgrading and toony.

godzod
09-28-2008, 10:21 PM
I still don't understand as to why people are thinking of all these Bishop and Krang plots that would supposedly be good ideas for a movie. An approach like this would make it seem so childish, downgrading and toony.

What are you talking about the plot being childish man ,Bishop is arguably the most complex villain.His goal is to saves mankind but he believe end justifies the means. :-?

thebrownranger
09-28-2008, 10:37 PM
What are you talking about the plot being childish man ,Bishop is arguably the most complex villain.His goal is to saves mankind but he believe end justifies the means. :-?

It's not like I'm saying I hate him, but I feel that characters like him should stay in the cartoon. Staying with the comics is the better way to go, but I highly doubt Laird will care anyways.

godzod
09-29-2008, 12:05 AM
It's not like I'm saying I hate him, but I feel that characters like him should stay in the cartoon. Staying with the comics is the better way to go, but I highly doubt Laird will care anyways.

But the turtles have a very limited rogues gallery in the mirage universe.
Neither Stockman and Rat King are Shredder equal but Bishop is.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-29-2008, 07:05 AM
But the turtles have a very limited rogues gallery in the mirage universe.
Neither Stockman and Rat King are Shredder equal but Bishop is.

Baxter Stockman can be a real threat for the TMNT and the entire future of the Earth if he has the inventions he needs.

godzod
09-29-2008, 01:01 PM
Baxter Stockman can be a real threat for the TMNT and the entire future of the Earth if he has the inventions he needs.

He alway been more of a supporting villain anyway, he nowhere near the threat than Bishop and Shredder.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-29-2008, 01:51 PM
He alway been more of a supporting villain anyway, he nowhere near the threat than Bishop and Shredder.

But in Mirage Baxter Stockman works only for himself?

godzod
09-29-2008, 02:07 PM
But in Mirage Baxter Stockman works only for himself?

I know he for himself mirage universe, but what others motive does he has than using mousers to steal money from banks

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-29-2008, 02:10 PM
I know he for himself mirage universe, but what others motive does he has than using mousers to steal money from banks

Give him a new ambition in a movie: to conquer the Earth.

Leogeddon
09-29-2008, 03:01 PM
I still don't understand as to why people are thinking of all these Bishop and Krang plots that would supposedly be good ideas for a movie. An approach like this would make it seem so childish, downgrading and toony.

If they pull it off, they can make Krang very freaky and scary. They don't have to make him all goofy like they did in the old cartoons. If they play their cards right, people could get nightmares of Krang and his goons.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-29-2008, 06:02 PM
If they pull it off, they can make Krang very freaky and scary. They don't have to make him all goofy like they did in the old cartoons. If they play their cards right, people could get nightmares of Krang and his goons.

Maybe something like Arhie Krang would work?

KROW
09-29-2008, 08:50 PM
I know he for himself mirage universe, but what others motive does he has than using mousers to steal money from banks

A spurned scientist is capable of a lot of things. Economical domination comes to mind. He can start with Mousers to gain trust, use them to steal money, then use that money to fund his publicly-announced crusade to rid the city of the mysterious culprit. He could rise to Norman Osbourne status with that.

NightwatchersOnlygirl
09-30-2008, 05:20 AM
I voted for Bishop

thebrownranger
09-30-2008, 07:42 AM
If they pull it off, they can make Krang very freaky and scary. They don't have to make him all goofy like they did in the old cartoons. If they play their cards right, people could get nightmares of Krang and his goons.

So I guess you want it to look like this right?:
http://features.cgsociety.org/gallerycrits/16676/16676_1168911876_medium.jpg

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-30-2008, 07:48 AM
A spurned scientist is capable of a lot of things. Economical domination comes to mind. He can start with Mousers to gain trust, use them to steal money, then use that money to fund his publicly-announced crusade to rid the city of the mysterious culprit. He could rise to Norman Osbourne status with that.

That sounds cool.

NYShell
09-30-2008, 07:09 PM
The Shredder obviously... and people who aren't familiar with the Turtles won't know who the hell Bishop is, just like TMNT... no one knew who Max Winters was either...he was probably one of the corniest characters I've ever seen. The Shredder also should not be an Utrom... I hate this sci-fi crap...

cowabunga14
09-30-2008, 07:23 PM
Shredder for me. He's the villain that I tend to associate with the Turtles the most.

Berthelo
10-01-2008, 01:53 AM
Bishop, if developed more, would be a creepy ass bad guy to have in a next tmnt movie. I'd go see that in 3D lol
:D He was such a complex and interesting character. Heck I would love to see I movie made just of John Bishop. heck I would love to make that movie. (hint hint film student here ranting lol) Give him some background... I thought it was a cheap way out of developing Bishop's character, how in the fast forward series he had a super revelation after being rescued by a random alien that led to him becoming a good guy.. hahaha the president. It made me laugh.
Shedder is a cool character and if theyd bring him back into a movie I think the Utrom shredder would be the best choice. But hes on an astroid somewhere.
I can see how Bishop's character would be a problem. Because it would be dry if the rating stayed at PG. I'm surprised FOXKids aired the scene when he switched clone bodies. Damn that was great. lol

Berthelo
10-01-2008, 01:54 AM
I totally agree.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
10-01-2008, 06:45 AM
The Shredder obviously... and people who aren't familiar with the Turtles won't know who the hell Bishop is, just like TMNT... no one knew who Max Winters was either...he was probably one of the corniest characters I've ever seen. The Shredder also should not be an Utrom... I hate this sci-fi crap...

But Max Winters was not known even by fans before the film, Bishop is. I say Shredder, but I think a lot of villains could be more interesting than Bishop and Max Winters.

Revan
10-01-2008, 06:48 AM
If they decided to go with Bishop they could pretty much do anything they wanted. What I mean is, a fresh take. I would like to see another movie take the tone like movie 1. Realism at the core (4 humanoid turtles notwithstanding). Bishop could be an agent trying to find the turtles who "pose a threat to humanity," or whatever.

I don't really need to see Bishop or Shredder in another turtle movie though. Shredder is a good villian but there are other villians just waiting for a chance to shine.:D

Shedder is a cool character and if theyd bring him back into a movie I think the Utrom shredder would be the best choice. But hes on an astroid somewhere.
I can see how Bishop's character would be a problem. Because it would be dry if the rating stayed at PG. I'm surprised FOXKids aired the scene when he switched clone bodies. Damn that was great. lol

Careful not to mix up continuities. The kiddy cartoon on 4kids is not the same as the movie-verse. (Though TMNT's continuity still confuses me :lol:)

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
10-08-2008, 01:29 PM
If they decided to go with Bishop they could pretty much do anything they wanted. What I mean is, a fresh take. I would like to see another movie take the tone like movie 1. Realism at the core (4 humanoid turtles notwithstanding). Bishop could be an agent trying to find the turtles who "pose a threat to humanity," or whatever.

I don't really need to see Bishop or Shredder in another turtle movie though. Shredder is a good villian but there are other villians just waiting for a chance to shine.:D



Careful not to mix up continuities. The kiddy cartoon on 4kids is not the same as the movie-verse. (Though TMNT's continuity still confuses me :lol:)

I would only be happy if they skip the Utrom Shredder.

Shark_Blade
10-12-2008, 01:13 AM
Utrom Shredder is lame in my opinion, to sci-fi. This is Ninja Turtles were talking about, make it ninja-esque, with black arts, tengu and the sort. It'll be great if Oroku Saki can return with his daughter Karai as his right hand-man, er..woman.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
10-12-2008, 08:26 AM
Utrom Shredder is lame in my opinion, to sci-fi. This is Ninja Turtles were talking about, make it ninja-esque, with black arts, tengu and the sort. It'll be great if Oroku Saki can return with his daughter Karai as his right hand-man, er..woman.

I hope his impopularity will make them skip Utrom Shredder in the future, use Krang if you want science fiction.

Ryona
11-09-2008, 01:15 PM
I can't believe there's actually votes for Bishop. While he was a good villian, Shredder is still infinetly better.

A trully excellent antagonist never gets old, just like trully excellent protagonists never get old either.
I don't see any arguments of "Oh, let's swap Raph for Zack the fifth "turtle" this time, just so it doesn't get old". Because that would be stupid.

There's no need to swap any of the turtles with new characters because they got "old", just like there's no need to swap Shredder with a new super villian because he got "old".

If the writers are good at their job, they could make a classic like Shredder still refreshingly exciting.

locke007
12-04-2008, 12:35 AM
Oh, i prefer the Shredder.

Ninjinister
12-04-2008, 10:30 AM
I can't believe there's actually votes for Bishop. While he was a good villian, Shredder is still infinetly better.

A trully excellent antagonist never gets old, just like trully excellent protagonists never get old either.
I don't see any arguments of "Oh, let's swap Raph for Zack the fifth "turtle" this time, just so it doesn't get old". Because that would be stupid.

There's no need to swap any of the turtles with new characters because they got "old", just like there's no need to swap Shredder with a new super villian because he got "old".

If the writers are good at their job, they could make a classic like Shredder still refreshingly exciting.

That's what I'm talkin' about. Shredder is a timeless foe. If you ask anyone outside of the fandom for a Turtles villain, who do you think they're going to come up with off the top of their head? Bishop? Savanti Romero? Complete Carnage? Lord Norinaga? Not quite. One out of one-hundred might say Krang or Stockman, but I'm confidant everyone else would think of Shredder.

Coola Yagami
12-04-2008, 07:12 PM
But Max Winters was not known even by fans before the film, Bishop is. I say Shredder, but I think a lot of villains could be more interesting than Bishop and Max Winters.

That's cause Max Winters was made up for the movie. He wasn't some classic obscure Mirage comics foe that the movie directors digged up.-

shuriken
12-09-2008, 10:24 PM
That's cause Max Winters was made up for the movie. He wasn't some classic obscure Mirage comics foe that the movie directors digged up.-

Why not dig up some obscure mirage foe? I think it'll be awesome to see the Leech monster, or Savanti Romero, or Complete Carnage on the big screen.
Although if it's SHredder vs Bishop in terms of TMNT enemies, Shredder will always be the top dog. Like X-men, Magneto is the staple bad guy, even though there is still Mr. Sinister and Apocolypse.

Da5thTurtle
12-14-2008, 12:17 AM
But he's alive in "Next Mutation", and Next Mutation is considered by some to follow the movies.

I was under the impression that "Next mutation" is widely considered to be non-canon.

Jester
12-14-2008, 12:25 AM
Yes it is, but if it were, there is still some debate as to where it fits in.

shuriken
12-14-2008, 11:57 PM
Yes it is, but if it were, there is still some debate as to where it fits in.

In the darkest region of Peter Laird's nightmares.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
12-15-2008, 10:21 PM
As great as Shredder is. I'm rather bored of him to be honest. I mean the whole shredder thing has been done over and over and over again that it's just getting repetitive. Nothing against those who really like shredder and all.

Personally I'd rather have Bishop. It'd just be interesting to see more of him.

Jester
12-15-2008, 10:26 PM
Exactly, Shredder has been done to death, and yes creative writters could make a great story, but I'd like to see other villians. The Turtles do have other strong villians besides the Shredder.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
12-16-2008, 10:07 PM
Heck they could even make another original villain and I wouldn't mind. I just don't want another shredder escapade. Heck the 2k3 cartoon has more shredder than necessary already. Let the movies at least do something different.

EctoShredder57
01-17-2009, 02:13 PM
id have to say i dont want a human shredder, it would be cool to have the demon shredder but for the sake of things I know that wnt happen, id rather have an alll new villian. actual i want tokka and slash to be the main villians

Chrissie Terrapin
01-17-2009, 02:39 PM
The Shredder in all his glory

Vivi
02-16-2009, 11:07 AM
Even though I don't see Bishop as especially villainous, I would like for him to appear as the protaganist, initially. Maybe we could see him turn a leaf in the movie. Shreddy Bear could still be there for evil candy, but I would actually prefer to see his alter ego Oroku Saki and rubbing shoulders with the big wigs of NYC.

Ryona
03-04-2009, 06:46 PM
The Shredder in all his glory

Simple, pure, and true. Well said. TMNT + Shredder = Excellence.

I didn't see anyone complaining about the new Batman movie series using Joker. I can't recall anyone going "Oh but Joker was in the 1989 Batman movie! Don't use him again! Blarg!".

Just sayin'..

Ginny
03-04-2009, 07:18 PM
Simple, pure, and true. Well said. TMNT + Shredder = Excellence.

I didn't see anyone complaining about the new Batman movie series using Joker. I can't recall anyone going "Oh but Joker was in the 1989 Batman movie! Don't use him again! Blarg!".

Just sayin'..

Exactly! Shredder is to the TMNT as Joker is to Batman or Lex Luthor is to Superman. When you think of the Turtles, you just think Shredder.

Alex
03-18-2009, 01:46 PM
The Shredder ofc :)

Tomoshibi Amatsu
04-09-2009, 08:26 PM
Simple, pure, and true. Well said. TMNT + Shredder = Excellence.

I didn't see anyone complaining about the new Batman movie series using Joker. I can't recall anyone going "Oh but Joker was in the 1989 Batman movie! Don't use him again! Blarg!".

Just sayin'..

The only difference is that Joker wasn't in every Batman movie between the first one and Dark Knight.

Having Shredder all the time would be no different from having Joker all the time, but that's the point. That's why Batman has a whole Rogues Gallery to work with. One villain all the time gets boring after a while. Heck that's why Superman has Darkseid and Braniac besides Luthor and all the other villains that come around.

Roland
04-10-2009, 04:10 PM
I voted shredder. But this time the turtles get sucked into dimension x. They have to fight crangs rock soldiers and find the portal to go home. Shredder meanwhile is taking over the city and only splinter, casey and april is left to defend the city. Will the turtles find the portal and will the shredder be stopped??

Or if you don't like this how about bringing triceraton back. "He came to rock our world off coarse"or "In search of a new home planet because their planet part few decades back". Will the turtle stop the invasion.