PDA

View Full Version : Mikey's behavior


NameGoesHere1066
09-23-2008, 03:47 PM
ok, I've been watching the new series since it's started in 2003, and since then I've seen Mikey act in a many number of ways that range from inappropiate to just plain disgraceful. He never seems to be reprimanded or punished for his antics eighther. He's almost never taken to task for his behavior and he's allowed to continue to do so. He continues to act selfish, inconsiderate, and obnoxious to every one and there is never any real effert on Splinter or his brothers part to curb that.

If there is than what they're doing simply isn't working because Mikey never seems to learn. It's like Mikey never learned theres a time and place for certain behavior and it's not ok to be on over drive all the time and act like an ass. Or oif he did, he didn't follow up on it.

I find it baffling that when Mikey is acting up during serious moments that he never really get chatised for it. At most he'll get a disgusted look or slap upside the head, but other than that he never really gets disiplined for his behavior, or it's not followed up. Alot of times Splinter will just shake his head and sigh when Mikey starts acting outragious. What the heck is Splinter's problem he should have nipped Mikey's inapropiate behavior in the bud a long time ago before he reached his teen years. I would think with Splinter's old school parental ways that he would cinsider the behavior of his child, no matter what age, to be a reflection of his parenting skills, and would keep any way wardness in sons at bay so as not to embarrass him.

I just find it unbelievable that Mikey gets away with half the things he does with out his brothers or Splinter reacting more strongly than what they do to his behavior. Jeez, Mikey is like what 18 years old now? He still acts like a eight year old and every one caters to him and doesn't expect any thing from him, that's a big ass mistake right there. Mikey acts beyond spolied at times and it shows up in his demeaner of self entitlement. The closest I saw of Mikey getting seriously disiplined was Splinter's refusal to help him in "Grudge Match" when he was challenged. But of course Leo had to ruin the sting of abandonment by offering to help him out, so the lesson lost it's message. To bad that happened for the he acted I think Mikey desereved have his whole family abandon him for being cocky to them and suffering the agony of defeat. He that happened that way maybe Mikey would have wised up on his behavior and he would have matured and he would be all the better now.

Cipher
09-23-2008, 04:40 PM
YEAH, OUTRAGE!

Seriously though, it's just lazy, child-oriented writing.

I wonder sometimes whether the show's bible requires the writers to add a certain quota of Mikey jokes per episode or something, because otherwise I can't imagine it being so consistantly heavy-handed.

I also wonder if child viewers really find Mikey's antics funny.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-23-2008, 04:54 PM
It's probably something from the 1987 cartoon that's still around, and the writers feel a pressure.

triplexxx
09-23-2008, 05:15 PM
He still acts like a eight year old and every one caters to him and doesn't expect any thing from him, that's a big ass mistake right there.Well maybe that is the biggest mistake, he's part of the team and contributes to their survival every day just like the others...and if his necessity on the team is still questioned in spite of that, well if I was him, I probably wouldn't be too happy or be able to stand being Mr. Nice and Unselfish while everyone else thinks of me as useless (maybe that's exaggerated a bit, but you get my point).

Cipher
09-23-2008, 06:48 PM
It's probably something from the 1987 cartoon that's still around, and the writers feel a pressure.We must not have been watching the same 1987 cartoon...

Jester
09-23-2008, 09:27 PM
Indeed, Mikey cracked jokes....heck Raph cracked more jokes, but they were funny, not unbearably annoying.

Cure
09-23-2008, 09:30 PM
Yeah, if Mikey was more like Old Toon Raph, I think it'd be much better.

Jester
09-23-2008, 09:37 PM
I dunna....maybe. OT Raph was played very sarcastic and cynical, Mikey's sence of humor isn't that dry.

CyberCubed
09-23-2008, 09:42 PM
Old toon Mike loved to cook pizza's and was always hungry.

Some of the funniest moments of the original cartoon is Mikey eating all the pizza's in the fridge or trying to cook his own pizza only to burn the thing to a crisp.

I also loved his toppings for pizzas, wasn't one of them peanut butter and broccoli or something?

I almost wish *this* Michelangelo had a pizza fetish, at least then he could just stuff his mouth with food.

Sage Ninja
09-23-2008, 09:44 PM
**sigh**

writing aside and thinking with in the context of the show it self, I don't really know why Mikey is never really called out on his behavior. The only thing I can think oif is that Splinter gave up a long time ago on trying to change that aspect of Mikey out of weariness. Or maybe he feels that unless he forces a confrontation on every occassion Mikey acts out that it would cause to much chaos and friction between himself and his son. I mean really, whats he going to do every time Mikey does or says something out of line, if dirty looks and lectures and occassional whacks upside the head having done anything then what? Beat him to with in an inch of his life? Some how I don't think that would do anything to teach Mikey a lesson, if anything I think it might cause him to resent Splinter and act out more and rebel.

If we where to get deep down into Mikey's psychy maybe we could figure out why exactly Mikey acts out the way he does, one thing is clear he does have a sence of entitlement, it's evident in the way he boasts about himself and gets a swelled head anytime he does something cool, and the unhealthy aspect of him that enjoys atagonising people and sees nothing wrong with it. Maybe it's that disipline isn't consistent. If he thinks he can do things and be reprimanded sometimes and gets away with it unscathed others he probably thinks he can get away with most stuff with out consequnces. Over-all I agree that Mikey's disipline is pretty light handed for the most part when he does something really out of line he never gets in trouble but whe he does something mildly annoying he gets slammed.

In that Fast Forward episode where he beat up some officers then stole a police car and chased down some truck of video games nearly getting his brothers and Cody killed, he got off scott free with out reprimand for his behavior in that episode. All Splinter did was sigh and say "where did I go wrong with that boy", which leads me to think that Splinter gave up on Mikey a long time ago.

Jester
09-23-2008, 09:45 PM
I remember anchovies and peanut butter from Turtle Tracks.

To be fair Sage, in Tough and Go we see some Splinter/Mikey bonding...that seems to be undone by >> and other things.

Jelly Bean
09-23-2008, 10:42 PM
I don't get why so many people want to see Mikey get punished, by being abandoned or humilated, oisn't that pretty damn harsh even if he is an annoying prick sometimes? I know Mikey has gotten on every ones nerves (my self included especially in the last episode) but I don't get why so many people want to see him punished.

in the episode Grudge Match Mikey acted horriable to his brothers and Splinter, but I still would have felt sorry for him if no one had been on his side. Does every one else here feel that Mikey should have been completely abandoned in that episode?

Well maybe that is the biggest mistake, he's part of the team and contributes to their survival every day just like the others...and if his necessity on the team is still questioned in spite of that, well if I was him, I probably wouldn't be too happy or be able to stand being Mr. Nice and Unselfish while everyone else thinks of me as useless (maybe that's exaggerated a bit, but you get my point).

dude, what are you talking about here?

oldmanwinters
09-23-2008, 10:44 PM
I wonder if the death of Klunk would sober up this version of Mikey. No such luck for the "death" of the his own father. But his cat? Maybe....

triplexxx
09-24-2008, 01:25 AM
dude, what are you talking about here?I'm just stating that some of his lack of discipline and appropriate behavior may stem from not feeling like he's an appreciated part of the team, but not that he's completely unnappreciated, just not enough.

Aneras713
09-24-2008, 04:51 AM
Dudes, it's Mikey, he's a mook, we all know it. He gets disciplined enough when his brothers smack him over the head (like they have been for the past 142 episodes....give or take an episode or three), even if it doesn't work. Anything else and 4kids would censor it.

Or that could just apply to anime and I'm just rammbling off here. Feel free to ignore me.

silverdragon
09-24-2008, 06:53 AM
I wonder if the death of Klunk would sober up this version of Mikey. No such luck for the "death" of the his own father. But his cat? Maybe....

you might have a point, it's been a while since I've seen the episode but wasn't Mikey more upset about the loss of Klunk than the death of April and Casey in Bad Day?

Drtooth
09-24-2008, 09:53 AM
I wonder if the death of Klunk would sober up this version of Mikey. No such luck for the "death" of the his own father. But his cat? Maybe....

Clearly he's deeply troubled, and he's trying to ignore his feelings. I find it a bit too subtle, but the fact that Mikey tries to change the subject when they talk about what happened to Splinter is the tip off.

The problem is that Mikey should be portrayed as a jokester that can become serious in battle. Like how he ran out of the battle to drive the battle shell into the building to save the day. He's the one that no one should take seriously, until it's important. Or even in his Battle Nexus fight with Raph. He annoys Raph BECAUSE he knows that's the way to get to him, so he'll be too frustriated and tired in battle.... sort of a Freakazoid type deal.

I think FF really was the worst we've seen of the character. Especially his Darkwing Duck-esque behavior with the new Turtle Titan. And the Graduation Day episode was just... unnecessary. It just retread things we already knew.

Jelly Bean
09-24-2008, 12:13 PM
The closest I saw of Mikey getting seriously disiplined was Splinter's refusal to help him in "Grudge Match" when he was challenged. But of course Leo had to ruin the sting of abandonment by offering to help him out, so the lesson lost it's message. To bad that happened for the he acted I think Mikey desereved have his whole family abandon him for being cocky to them and suffering the agony of defeat. He that happened that way maybe Mikey would have wised up on his behavior and he would have matured and he would be all the better now.

ok, this is just my opinion but why does things have to escalate to that stage before Mikey is put in line? I agree that Splinter and Don and Raph refusing to help Mikey after he just bragged about not needing to train was the closest Mikey ever came to really getting punished/disiplined for his behavior. But why didn't Splinter pull something like this earlier to stop Mikey's behavior befre it got that bad? He couldn't have known that Mikey was going to get rechallenged for his title that would make him put his money where his mouth is, so why didn't he stop Mikey's behavior before this? If Kluh hadn't rechallenged him and that situation never came up, would Splinter had let Mikey's behavior carry on that way? Splinter should have done something way before the rematch thing about Mikey's behavior with his battle nexus win.

I'm just stating that some of his lack of discipline and appropriate behavior may stem from not feeling like he's an appreciated part of the team, but not that he's completely unnappreciated, just not enough.

Yeah, but maybe his brothers don't appreciate him because he acts the way does. If I knew some one who strutted around and acted cocky when I gave them compliment or they did something great, I would stop appreciating him as well.

terran631
09-24-2008, 12:37 PM
I don't think there's an easy answer to this question mainly because..I don't think there IS an answer to this question. And I know I'm missing the point of the discussion because I'm not thinking about it "in character". But...

Why was Mikey not taken to task for bragging and being disrespectful of his master and training in Grudge Match---because if he WAS, there'd be no story to write about it.

Why did Mike skateboard around the lair acting like an idiot when his brothers were trying to help Mike find their father/see if their father was even ALIVE---because if he was being serious there'd be no humor at the beginning of the ep for the audience to laugh at.


It reminds me of the old "Turtle Power" song. "Raphael, he's the leader of the group" Um. No he's not and never has been. The writer of the song forsaked accuracy for a rhyme. It's the same with the show. The writers forsake accuracy or characterization for the sake of a laugh. I don't think the writers delve into these characters' heads as much as we do (although I really think they should) because their target audience (kids) would rather laugh at Mike falling from his skateboard than hear Mike is grieving for his father.

In the first movie when Mike and Don were speaking of potentially being without Splinter, Mike changed the subject Purposely. But if you watch when Splinter is talking about it (after Mike ordered the pizza) Mike sits down hard on the couch with a "don't talk about this now" look. That's why I can't say that Mike's skateboarding was a result of grief. The writers never gave me that glimpse into Mike's head and I'm not about to assume it.

ToTheNines
09-24-2008, 02:22 PM
I also wonder if child viewers really find Mikey's antics funny.

They do. I took all of my cousins to see TMNT 07; and of the 6, four of them are 6-9... they all came out of the theatre in love with Mikey.

Honestly I like him beeing a goof-off as long as its funny, but 90 percent of the time I'm rolling my eyes because his jokes are so cheap, predictable and over-used.

Basically I feel that he's a wasted character.

NameGoesHere1066
09-24-2008, 03:07 PM
eh, you know what? I'm just as tired of this excuse that "Mikey's comic relief" as I'm tired of hearing "he acts out to hide his real emotions", to excuse his behavior. Because it rarely does come off funny. Other versions of Michaelangelo have been comic relief with out being a dick like New toon Mikey. Mirage Mikey was the humourous turtle and he never acted out during serious moments, Orginal toon Mike was huge comic relief but he still acted appropiately during serious and tense moments. And Live action Mikey was one that tried changing the subject when talk of Splinter dying came up but actually cried when he thought he was gone. Being comic relief doesn't mean ambivilant dick head.

There was no need to have him acting the way he was in the beginning of the episode and then with Serling. I don't think the writers are trying to make him funny, because if they where it would be recieved better by the characters in the show rather than with quite disgust. All you had to do was look at Raph and Leo's reactions when he called their attention that he was "helping" and then started messing with Serling. They both had disgusted scowls on their faces, and where not pleased with his antics, because it was a tense moment where they where trying to calm Don down from his "it's my fault" tirade. It was misplaced. And it's certainly not funny to small children eighther because my seven year neighbor watches the turtles with me and she's never found Mikey funny.

I'm just tired of Mikey forever acting like a mindless ape that's stuck on over drive, and Don, Raph, and Leo letting him with out comment.

Sage Ninja
09-25-2008, 12:10 PM
To be fair Sage, in Tough and Go we see some Splinter/Mikey bonding...that seems to be undone by >> and other things.

in what way where they bonding? Maybe it'd because it's been a while since I saw this episode but from what I recall mostly Splinter just kept critising Mikey and basically calling him stupid? :-? Am I the only one that noticed that the more Splinter talked down too and critisised Mikey the more distracted and uncoropertive Mikey became in this episode? It was almost like Mikey was doing it on purpose as a subtle way of sticking it to Splinter for ragging on him.

I'm just stating that some of his lack of discipline and appropriate behavior may stem from not feeling like he's an appreciated part of the team, but not that he's completely unnappreciated, just not enough.

mm, I'm not sure I agree with this. Knowing Mikey's personality and how he hates to be ignored, wouldn't he consider feeling "unappreciated" as a form of "ignoring him" and try to his brother opinion of him and listen to him more?

And I would go so far as to call New Toon Mike a dick head NameGoesHere1066. :o

terran631
09-25-2008, 12:16 PM
I agree that there is no NEED to write them the way that he is being written. But it's certainly not an excuse for his behavior. It's a statement of opinion on why New Toon Mike is being written the way that he is.
MIke's comedy act is not for the benefit of his brothers or the other characters in the show. It's for the benefit of the audience watching the show. In my opinion, the writers of the show want to balance out the seriousness of the situation with levity for the kids who are watching it. Why have Mike puke in the truck? Mike skateboards, does backflips, scales buildings, and does any number of things that makes him getting sick from the flying truck pretty ludicrous. He's a NINJA. Ninja aren't known for having a weak stomach. But so many people (adults as well as kids) found that hysterical, especially Mike's comment about corn.

Most youngsters don't care much about in depth emotion of characters. Look at most of the cartoons on television now. My kids and students watch mainly Nick shows. These cartoons have no character depth, no character growth, and very little in the way of drama. But from what I've seen, Most kids like:
1. Action
2. Humor

Kids tolerate: (as long as it doesn't interfere with the first two)
1. life messages
2. Character drama

I don't think Mike's attitude is funny. It's not just immature, it's downright stupid in some instances. But I'm an adult watching a child's television program. I'd like to see someone tell Mike to stop acting so selfish, but I don't see it happening. I think Mike's character is a slapstick character who has moments of maturity, but they're few and far between and the lesson doesn't stick from episode to episode. But because the other characters "have to be" serious, they need someone to be the clown as opposed to the "straight man."

The writers are inconsistent in a lot of things. Ie: Don't contaminate the time stream in "The Journal" But let's tell April and Casey about the future in "Karate Schooled." SO the guys didn't GET the lesson or Leo decided to ignore it. Either way, doesn't make them seem very smart. Mike's character's inconsistency is no different.

I hated Mike in this past week's ep. I hated his ambivalence toward Splinter's "death." So either Mike is

1. Repressing--I don't buy it. The writers have given me no reason to think Mike gives a damn about Splinter beyond the two seconds he looked sad.

2. Immature and selfish--Whether or not it was the writers' intentions (I'm thinking it wasn't) this is how Mike is coming across. I can take the immaturity in small doses. But even Peter frickin Pan knew the concept of death well enough to clap for Tinkerbell. And I never thought of Mike as being selfish. Self-centered at times, yes. But never so self-absorbed that he cares nothing for everyone around him.

3. Stupid--Which I also don't buy.

And I also don't buy the line of reasoning that this has happened before and everything turned out alright so they don't care as much. It wasn't just numbness Mike was showing in the beginning. He was having a PARTY. And my dad had a heart attack last year and it freaked me out. Everything turned out ok. But two months ago when he started having chest pain, I freaked out again. If the characters are becoming numb to emotional pain... then I think I need to find a new fandom.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
09-25-2008, 01:02 PM
Well Mikey's also the youngest. It's natural for him to act less mature than the o ther three. Gloating about his accomplishments, irritating and embarrassing the rest of his family. It's just what younger siblings do.

Sure I know that most of the time Mikey isn't funny and can become a bit grating sometimes, but he's still the same laid-back party dude he's always been. Besides that Mikey has had his good points. Such as the christmas episode and Grudge Match. Sure he's a goof but when it counts he does step up and that is what's important.

In a way I see Mikey as being the type of person who just sits back and let things play out because he knows that in the end everything will be alright. I guess that's why I don't mind too much how he's acting with the whole spinter situation. Mikey cares but knows there's not much he can do besides trying to cheer everyone up.

From reading the thread I've been seeing a lot that people want Mikey to be more serious. However, if he did that he wouldn't really be Mikey anymore It may be my opinion but I think saying he's a jerk or an ass is just being a little too harsh.

Drtooth
09-25-2008, 03:17 PM
I still say Mikey should be written as the one that shouldn't be taken seriously, UNTIL it's the heat of battle. Sort of like Monkey D Luffy or Naruto or someone (best examples off the top of my head). the writers go way too overboard with his goofy side, that it now dominates the character...

ToTheNines
09-25-2008, 03:24 PM
Well Mikey's also the youngest. It's natural for him to act less mature than the o ther three.

So if I go to a funeral and the average age there is about 40, it's ok to make bad jokes and scream like a ninny while riding a skateboard since I'm 17?

KROW
09-25-2008, 03:36 PM
So if I go to a funeral and the average age there is about 40, it's ok to make bad jokes and scream like a ninny while riding a skateboard since I'm 17?

As long as there's a cemetery with awesome half-pipes, yes.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
09-25-2008, 03:41 PM
So if I go to a funeral and the average age there is about 40, it's ok to make bad jokes and scream like a ninny while riding a skateboard since I'm 17?

I don't think I was saying it quite like that.

As I said he probably figures that everything will turn out all right so there's no need to act all gloomy about it. I think he has complete faith that they'll find Splinter that he's just going to ride it out.

Besides Leo and Raph aren't letting the situation get them down either. The only one it's really affecting is Don. I personally don't see Mikey as the type of character to get all serious anyways unless he has too. The closest we got to that was in "same as it never was."

Rooish
09-25-2008, 04:54 PM
At least in BTTS they are trying to put in some character development and emotional situations, but it's just not working as well as it did before >>. I mean, emotional moments were always kind of awkward in the show, just because ... it's a kid's show, and the voice actors sounded embarrassed to act out emotional parts (that is my totally subjective option, though). But it's good that they're trying again, with BTTS. I rolled my eyes a little at Don's initial "It's all my fault" moment, just because Don is always doing that. He's a sweetheart and he takes on way too much responsibility. But now I realize that Don's angst might be the "character development" arc of the BTTS season, for better or for worse, and I think that Sam Regal has progressed as a voice actor quite well--well enough to make Don's angst believable.

But that is neither here nor there. About Mikey. Yeah, I wondered why the hell he was skateboarding and goofing off with Splinter gone. Mike makes me laugh a lot (he doesn't seem to have that effect on most people my age, but ... well sue me, he's my favourite turtle, and I can't help to like him even if he is a tool in the new cartoon). The thing is, in every other version of the TMNT, Mikey jokes around ... but he is likeable. In the new toon, he jokes around, but is selfish and immature. In the new toon he doesn't have much to redeem himself; he's constantly just too self-absorbed to show empathy for anyone. In the Mirage comics, he jokes--and then he gets serious when he needs to. And he writes. And he makes moving little comments that add humanity to the story. In the new toon, he jokes at the wrong times. Plus I think he actually hampers Raph's character development. Raph has had a huge progression from the first episodes, and now all he seems to do is get annoyed at Mikey.

I wonder if Wayne Grayson gets annoyed with the one-dimensional character he has to act for every episode?

terran631
09-25-2008, 07:16 PM
a goof but when it counts he does step up and that is what's important.

In a way I see Mikey as being the type of person who just sits back and let things play out because he knows that in the end everything will be alright. I guess that's why I don't mind too much how he's acting with the whole spinter situation. Mikey cares but knows there's not much he can do besides trying to cheer everyone up.

That'd be great if his attitude was actually cheering people up. HIs brothers are/were annoyed with him at best, Ticked off at worse. MIke wasn't cheering anyone up and what's worse, Mike didn't seem to care that his attitude was hurting more than helping.

From reading the thread I've been seeing a lot that people want Mikey to be more serious. However, if he did that he wouldn't really be Mikey anymore It may be my opinion but I think saying he's a jerk or an ass is just being a little too harsh.

No, I don't want Mike to be anywhere near as serious as his brothers. I like the light hearted attitude in Mike. However..given the current situation, Mike should have been trying to cheer up his brothers. He wasn't. He was being lazy, inconsiderate, downright rude to Serling, and completely clueless that his attitude was inappropriate. I always thought of Mike as being highly sensitive. Definitely not inconsiderate or rude.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
09-25-2008, 07:42 PM
That'd be great if his attitude was actually cheering people up. HIs brothers are/were annoyed with him at best, Ticked off at worse. MIke wasn't cheering anyone up and what's worse, Mike didn't seem to care that his attitude was hurting more than helping.

When he tried giving Don the plant I took that as him trying to get Don to lighten up which just plain backfired. But he kept trying which is why he was all "Hey guys! Look over here I'm helping!" To me it was just obvious he was trying to loosen up the tension and make his brothers smile despite the situation.

He wasn't doing it to be a dick. He just didn't want his brothers to stay all depressed.



No, I don't want Mike to be anywhere near as serious as his brothers. I like the light hearted attitude in Mike. However..given the current situation, Mike should have been trying to cheer up his brothers. He wasn't. He was being lazy, inconsiderate, downright rude to Serling, and completely clueless that his attitude was inappropriate. I always thought of Mike as being highly sensitive. Definitely not inconsiderate or rude.

Meh maybe he was coming off that way, but perhaps that wasn't really his intention. Honestly most of the time Mikey does something aggravating or annoying to his brothers he does it unintentionally. I think that's why they whap him upside the head constantly. Mikey doesn't really think before he speaks. The only time he was purposefully being annoying was when he fought Raph in the battle nexus. Cause he knew how to push Raph's buttons.

All in all I think Mikey does know the seriousness of the situation, but feels that being serious or depressed about it isn't going to do any good. So he's just trying to do what he does best. Goof around. and lift everyone's spirits. I doubt he's trying to be rude or insensitive.

terran631
09-25-2008, 07:59 PM
Which is why I'm saying that he seems immature and/or insensitive.

I won't touch the "unintentionally annoying" thing because that's a whole 'nother debate. But..

I know that Mike's "job" is to keep things light and not let his brothers take themselves too seriously. But really, everything else aside, this is his father we're talking about. It's not like Don blew up one of his inventions. Don (viral and serling) blew up Splinter.

One of the things that struck me during this episode is Raph's question. "Is it possible he's still alive?" This got me thinking that they were assuming he was gone, but MAYBE there's a chance in hell that he made it.
The writers gave me nothing to base an assumption that Mike thought Splinter was alive. And even if they thought he might be alive, he was still gone. Maybe hurt. Maybe seriously hurt.
Mike's skateboarding was inappropriate. He wasn't trying to lighten up his brothers, he was trying (maybe) to annoy them or maybe he just didn't care what they thought as long as he was doing what he wanted to. It's like doing stand-up at a funeral.

Maybe we shall agree to disagree. I am enjoying the debate though...

Spitfire
09-26-2008, 01:05 AM
He acts the way he does because he's the comic relief. That is a valid reason because the shows not for adults who over analyze, it's for 9 year olds. Kids think he's funny if you don't believe me look at the 4Kids post where they asked kids to post questions to Mikey and Raph. A bunch of them said something along the lines of "Mikey your funny and my favorite turtle."

Mikey's always been like this what's really new? Sometimes he's more annoying then others but from the start of the series he's acted exactly the same. The only reason you notice it more now is because they toned the rest of the show down around him so his annoying behavior sticks out more.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
09-26-2008, 01:45 AM
Which is why I'm saying that he seems immature and/or insensitive.

I won't touch the "unintentionally annoying" thing because that's a whole 'nother debate. But..

I know that Mike's "job" is to keep things light and not let his brothers take themselves too seriously. But really, everything else aside, this is his father we're talking about. It's not like Don blew up one of his inventions. Don (viral and serling) blew up Splinter.

One of the things that struck me during this episode is Raph's question. "Is it possible he's still alive?" This got me thinking that they were assuming he was gone, but MAYBE there's a chance in hell that he made it.
The writers gave me nothing to base an assumption that Mike thought Splinter was alive. And even if they thought he might be alive, he was still gone. Maybe hurt. Maybe seriously hurt.
Mike's skateboarding was inappropriate. He wasn't trying to lighten up his brothers, he was trying (maybe) to annoy them or maybe he just didn't care what they thought as long as he was doing what he wanted to. It's like doing stand-up at a funeral.

Maybe we shall agree to disagree. I am enjoying the debate though...

Well all I want to say is that. I think Mikey trusts and believes that Don can find and bring back Splinter while the others have their doubts. I don't know if it ties into it but it kinda reminds me of how in season 4 Mikey made the comment the he was able to relax more because Leo took on the responsibility of the whole team during the time Leo was having his anger issues.

Finding Splinter and everything is Don's department, and Mikey has full confidence in him. After all if Don can't find Master Splinter who can?

But yeah I guess in the end we're just going to agree to disagree. I was more trying to shed a more positive light on Mikey's character despite all the negativity that's all. Not really trying to debate or argue. Still I'm enjoying the conversation all the same.

Jelly Bean
09-26-2008, 11:38 AM
When he tried giving Don the plant I took that as him trying to get Don to lighten up which just plain backfired. But he kept trying which is why he was all "Hey guys! Look over here I'm helping!" To me it was just obvious he was trying to loosen up the tension and make his brothers smile despite the situation.

He wasn't doing it to be a dick. He just didn't want his brothers to stay all depressed.

Meh maybe he was coming off that way, but perhaps that wasn't really his intention. Honestly most of the time Mikey does something aggravating or annoying to his brothers he does it unintentionally. I think that's why they whap him upside the head constantly. Mikey doesn't really think before he speaks. The only time he was purposefully being annoying was when he fought Raph in the battle nexus. Cause he knew how to push Raph's buttons.

All in all I think Mikey does know the seriousness of the situation, but feels that being serious or depressed about it isn't going to do any good. So he's just trying to do what he does best. Goof around. and lift everyone's spirits. I doubt he's trying to be rude or insensitive.

dude, I think that you are just way off here. Mikey never does any thing for the benefit of his brothers peace of mind. Mikey loves to bait people, he does things for the sole purpose of getting a rise out of someone for his own amusment. And really the vibe I get off this version of Mikey is that his own amusment is all he really cares about.

All those things you mentioned of him handing a plant instead of what Don asked for, of doing the "look I'm helping" schtick, to the him having a total party on his skate board, had nothing to do with him trying to keep his brothers spirits high or even being confident that Donatello would fix the problem with Splinter. And even if he does have complete faith in Donatello's abilites to fix the problem, wouldn't you think the fact that Don is obviously in a state of turmoil and is taking it very hard be at least of little concern to him? He never once approuched Don to support him or to calm him down like Raph and Leo did, and when he did have a comment to make about Don it was a complaint that he was worse than Leo/Raph when their pissy.

I mean when Leo and Raph went to go talk to Don they where asking him if it was possiable that Splinter might be alive. Meaning for all they knew Splinter was dead and they where sad, how come Mikey didn't show any concern? It's just dissapointing that all.

I always felt that Mikey should be alot more perceptive and senctive than that, every one can say what they want about CGI Mikey but he did show concern and saddness over the bigger events in the movie.

I like that you are defending Mikey, and normally I'm very tolerant of Mikey and feel sorry when he gets bashed but I don't see any evidense that he is doing what you say that he is doing. I hope Klunk is in this season, because the only time unfortunately when Mikey shows he cares about soimething other than having a good time.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
09-26-2008, 03:37 PM
dude, I think that you are just way off here. Mikey never does any thing for the benefit of his brothers peace of mind. Mikey loves to bait people, he does things for the sole purpose of getting a rise out of someone for his own amusment. And really the vibe I get off this version of Mikey is that his own amusment is all he really cares about.

All those things you mentioned of him handing a plant instead of what Don asked for, of doing the "look I'm helping" schtick, to the him having a total party on his skate board, had nothing to do with him trying to keep his brothers spirits high or even being confident that Donatello would fix the problem with Splinter. And even if he does have complete faith in Donatello's abilites to fix the problem, wouldn't you think the fact that Don is obviously in a state of turmoil and is taking it very hard be at least of little concern to him? He never once approuched Don to support him or to calm him down like Raph and Leo did, and when he did have a comment to make about Don it was a complaint that he was worse than Leo/Raph when their pissy.

I mean when Leo and Raph went to go talk to Don they where asking him if it was possiable that Splinter might be alive. Meaning for all they knew Splinter was dead and they where sad, how come Mikey didn't show any concern? It's just dissapointing that all.

I always felt that Mikey should be alot more perceptive and senctive than that, every one can say what they want about CGI Mikey but he did show concern and saddness over the bigger events in the movie.

I like that you are defending Mikey, and normally I'm very tolerant of Mikey and feel sorry when he gets bashed but I don't see any evidense that he is doing what you say that he is doing. I hope Klunk is in this season, because the only time unfortunately when Mikey shows he cares about soimething other than having a good time.

Well that's your opinion and I respect it.

As for what you were saying. Mikey's always been more of a free spirit to me. Sure Raph and Leo showed some concern for Don's behavior but they also didn't want Don to stay that way either. I don't think we needed Mikey to join in the "it's not your fault Don" pity party that was going on. It may seem inappropriate with Mikey skateboarding around and everything, but at least he was trying to cut down on the tension. Maybe he'll show some more appropriate sensitivity down the road it's not like Mikey's always been insensitive throughout the entire 2k3 series. He's shown tons of sensitivity and care for others. Yeah he can be annoying and immature sometimes but that just comes with being the youngest. I don't expect him to be as mature adn serious as his older brothers. To me that's just not Mikey you know?

Besides that Mikey has always been the turtle who always looks at the bright side of things. I don't think he's worried if Splinter's alive or not. Not because he doesn't care, but because he probably doesn't even want to think about the possibility. After all when Splinter was missing way back in season 1 it was Raph who cared the most. Leo and Don showed care and concern as well. Mikey just kept doing his own thing.

Honestly at this point I think I'm just rambling. I just don't think Mikey's as bad as people are saying and I don't think he deserves all the negativity is all. Mikey has his faults but he has his many good points too, and I think that's what I'm trying to express here. The positive side of Mikey. If I'm being way off then I'm sorry.

Jelly Bean
09-28-2008, 01:35 AM
It's not that Mikey is light hearted or comic relief that people have a problem with, it's just...we want his character to have more integrity than what he's written. And too often his actions and character make it seem like he doesn't have any and he's too shallow.

He's one of the main characters and yeah he has a role to play in the show but as a main character, being one of the four title characters, he should have more to his character than just being the butt of the joke and entertaining children under six. And being comic relief doesn't mean he can't have deeper emotions or feelings or act serious. Right now Mikey comes off too one sided and it shallow.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
09-28-2008, 03:29 AM
It's not that Mikey is light hearted or comic relief that people have a problem with, it's just...we want his character to have more integrity than what he's written. And too often his actions and character make it seem like he doesn't have any and he's too shallow.

He's one of the main characters and yeah he has a role to play in the show but as a main character, being one of the four title characters, he should have more to his character than just being the butt of the joke and entertaining children under six. And being comic relief doesn't mean he can't have deeper emotions or feelings or act serious. Right now Mikey comes off too one sided and it shallow.

I'll agree with you that Mikey should be able to mix his comedy relief with his sensitive and compassionate side, but I just get the impression that people want Mikey to turn into an angst machine like his brothers. But angst isn't instant character development and it shouldn't be the sure-fire solution.

Come on now. Outside of FF which was pretty much about the jokes anyways. Mikey has shown a serious side when fighting along side his brothers. Not to mention tense situations. He may goof off, but it's not like all he does is crack jokes, and BTTS has only just begun. I think it's unfair to judge Mikey right now.

Look my point is that I agree that the writers should write in more of Mikey's sensitive and compassionate side that he showed in The Christmas Aliens for instance, but I don't think Mikey needs to go through some traumatic event and go through an intense amount of angst like Leo and Don in order to gain that development. That's all I'm saying. If I'm still off than maybe I went wrong persuing this line of thinking. Or maybe I'm just playing devil's advocate. Heck if I know.

NameGoesHere1066
10-03-2008, 12:40 PM
has any one thought that maybe Mikey would benefit from shock treatments? I'm sure a few jolts of electricity could curb any ones personality quirks after a while. I'm sure Don could invent something like that hecould hook up to Mikey that automatically jolts him when he acts inappropiately. I juist saw an episode of Futurama where the Professor hooks Bender up to a machine to teach him empathy by making him feel other's feelings.

Eighther that or a time out room.

Aneras713
10-03-2008, 02:31 PM
......I'd go with the time out.

Sage Ninja
10-03-2008, 10:56 PM
Eighther that or a time out room.

and...just how the hell are they going to make Mikey stay in "time out"? Heck he's not a helpless child he's a capable teenager. Some how I don't see staying put in a room just because he's told too. Not even if they lock the door or something. I know this is off topic but when I see Nanny 911 there techniques seem to work on the little ones but I don'y know how the're methods where work on a teenager or something. Actually I don't see how "time out" can work at all on small kids. :roll:

terran631
10-04-2008, 07:57 AM
Guess it depends on who the one is putting Mike in timeout. His brothers? I don't see him listening to his brothers. He'd whine, protest, and in the end just ignore them. Splinter? He'd whine, but in the end would still go. My kids aren't teenagers yet (the oldest is ten), but I know when I say "go to your room", they go.

I don't see any of the turtles showing such disrespect to Splinter to ignore him if he sent them to their rooms for whatever reason. Would it work? Depends on the purpose behind him sending them to their rooms. Really, putting one of the turtles in "Time out" would be no different than sending them to the dojo to meditate. Heh heh, meditation just sounds less toddlerish. :lol:

Sage Ninja
10-06-2008, 11:03 AM
why couldn't Mikey be put in "time out" by his brothers for acting out? Raph was put in "time out" by his brothers in Cousin Sid for saying thw wrong thing to Leo by being put in the closet. And Splinter didn't have much to say about it.

Jelly Bean
10-06-2008, 12:18 PM
um, ok, when did this happen? I don't remember Raph being put in time out in Cousin Sid?

Machias Banshee
10-06-2008, 01:15 PM
I don't think it was a 'time out' as much as a 'you're too hurt to fight' measure.. but seeing Mike (or any of them) being put into 'time out' would be funny... :lol:

Jelly Bean
10-06-2008, 03:49 PM
I have a question. what do you you Mikey fans think of Mikey and his antics? I feel I've mostly heard from the people who don't care for him very much. I think their opinion on what to do with Mikey would be more reasonable and less prejiduse than some one who can't stand him.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-07-2008, 02:46 AM
While he can be annoying and grating sometimes. He's still the funny guy, he's still a sensitive and good soul, he's still Mikey to me. Maybe I just don't take Mikey seriously enough but I still like him even if almost everyone hates him.

Rooish
10-07-2008, 09:37 AM
Well I'm a Mikey fan, and I think his recent antics are deplorable. It sometimes makes me wonder why he's my favourite. I do think he has a lot of funny lines ("Can I be the maid of honor?" comes to mind) but I hate, absolutely hate, any moment when he is unruly or attention-seeking. Because that's really not what Mikey's personality was about when he was designed. In the Mirage comics, he was a bit rambunctious and short-sighted (picking a fight with a Triceraton, for example) but ... that didn't seem to be done in 2k3's annoying attention-seeking way. It was more bravado. Or something. And usually he was pretty calm and kind of observant, nice, funny, a bit of a goofball but not at inappropriate times. So yeah, seeing this histrionic, narcissistic Mikey in 2k3 is pretty discouraging. His voice bothers me (doesn't have any warmth), and ... I don't know, he used to seem to care about people a bit (as shown in some episodes ... um "The Unconvincing Turtle Titan," "Rogue in the House Pt. 2," and ... some more examples??). But ever since Fast Forward, I'm just ... waiting for him to go back to normal again. Not that he was ever particularly great in 2k3.

But I found something interesting. Check out Issue #9 of old Mirage comics. It's found at the official site > Comic Books (in the sidebar) > scroll down to "Read Vol. 1 #9."

Even as early as the ninth issue, Splinter was whacking a misbehaving pre-teen Mikey on the head!! So I guess it's not entirely ridiculous that they put this misbehaving Mikey thing into the 2k3 cartoon. Maybe he's always been annoying. :(

I think it's pretty sad just how frustrating they've made Mikey for the adult TMNT fans. I mean, Tigerfog's MNT Gaiden (http://www.obscurezodiac.com/chapterindex.php) -- an amazing fan manga that everyone should read -- it's kind of funny because the author describes each of the Turtles' personalities, and the description he gives Mikey is: "super annoying." And that's it. I can't find those descriptions now; I guess he removed them from the page. But they stuck with me!

Oh yeah, in "Cousin Sid," Raph wasn't on time out. His ribs were broken so they put him somewhere safe so he wouldn't try to fight. Doesn't explain how Mikey could fight with two broken legs though ...

Drtooth
10-07-2008, 10:18 AM
Somehow I think they should treat Mikey simililar to Dale from Rescue Rangers, but lately, they treat him more like Pinky... NARF...

NameGoesHere1066
10-08-2008, 12:30 AM
hey, don't diss Pinky he is one awsome lab mouse man. :D :P

ok, I will fess up and say that I really can not stand that little bugger Mikey in the new series. Like I almost find nothing redeemable about his character and often I wonder what the point of him is other than to be really stupid and annoying. But being a ninja turtle and the fact that I love my ninja turtles, save him from being completely loathed by me. I actually do like him for being a ninja turtle and all and I want to see him have some characteristics that might make me respect and adore him. The thing is is that he does have alot of redeemable characteristics that are present in other muduims but he doesn't seem to have them in the the new toon.

I think what I respected the most aboout Michaelangelo in the comics and the movies and old toon was his big heart. Michaelangelo is portrayed as the easy going guy you can be comfertable with thats really nice and has a humanised way about him the other turtles don't have that makes him relatable to the reader/viewer. All New toon Mikey does is alienate people he comes across or ticks them off and never seems to care about anything but his own pursuits. This version just isn't...nice like the other versions of Mike are. He's lost his big heart. People can argue till they're blue in the face that Mikey acts out the way he does because thats how he deals with grief but it just doesn't come across as that way and only seems like he is just entertaining him self. Whats wrong with Mikey is that his character isn't consistent and they'll change how he acts just at a whim. I wish the show would balance him out more and give him more integrity.

Somehow I think they should treat Mikey simililar to Dale from Rescue Rangers

refresh my memory here, who is Dale and how did he act? :-?

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-08-2008, 04:48 AM
refresh my memory here, who is Dale and how did he act? :-?

Dale was basically the goofy side kick to Chip in rescue rangers. He'd screw up, joke around, etc. It even got to the point that Dale was thrown out of the team for an episode where he developed his evil persona Ramdale. However, there were many episodes that showed that despite his flaws Dale could step up when he needed too. He also showed a a much more compassionate side than Chip did, and even showed that he was not only a very intelligent member of the team when he wasn't getting distracted by video games, TV, and comic books. He also showed that he was a very useful, innovative, and creative member of the team as well. Such as his exploit as the Red Badger and Double O Dale. In fact there were many times when it was Dale who saved the day.

To be honest. I have to agree then. I'd love to see Mikey more like that.

EDIT: Actually now that I' think about it. It'd be pretty hard to pull that off with Mikey. You have ot understand that Chip and Dale long before Rescue Rangers were more of a comedy duo like Dean Martin and Jerry Lewis. Chip was the straight man while Dale was more of the comedian. In Rescue Rangers Chip is the hero, the leader, Mr. Indiana Jones. Dale is more like Chip's foil in that sense since he represents everything Chip is not. In regards to Mikey he doesn't really have a character to be a foil too. The closest one would be Leo but Leo has a strong relationship with Raph so trying to fit Mikey into that would be pretty difficult. Although we did see traces of it in Grudge Match which was pretty cool. Donny gets along with Mikey way too much for there to be any tension. Now Raph is probably the one who has a real relationship with Mikey in the new toon but even then Raph has a stronger connection with Leo and Casey than Mikey so again it just doesn't work. So since it's hard to really connect Mikey with another character in a way to give him more depth. I can understand why the writers feel like they should just keep Mikey as the constant comedian.

Mandi-chan
10-10-2008, 08:57 AM
I'm a huge Mikey fan as a whole...but I'm not much of a fan of New Toon Mikey anymore.

In the Mirage comics, Archie comics, Old Toon (from what I recall), Live-Action movie trilogy, and the 2007 CGI film Mikey's the light-hearted and laid-back funny guy. He's warm, emotional, easy to love, smart (although the 2007 cgi film portrays him more as an airhead, he's still a lovable and funny airhead who can take care of himself no problem!), kick-ass in battle, reliable, open-hearted, and overall a great character.

All those qualities shine in every universe EXCEPT the New Toon...where he's not even funny, but just annoying and (lately) a dick as well.


Mikey never does any thing for the benefit of his brothers peace of mind. Mikey loves to bait people, he does things for the sole purpose of getting a rise out of someone for his own amusment. And really the vibe I get off this version of Mikey is that his own amusment is all he really cares about.

All those things you mentioned of him handing a plant instead of what Don asked for, of doing the "look I'm helping" schtick, to the him having a total party on his skate board, had nothing to do with him trying to keep his brothers spirits high or even being confident that Donatello would fix the problem with Splinter. And even if he does have complete faith in Donatello's abilites to fix the problem, wouldn't you think the fact that Don is obviously in a state of turmoil and is taking it very hard be at least of little concern to him? He never once approuched Don to support him or to calm him down like Raph and Leo did, and when he did have a comment to make about Don it was a complaint that he was worse than Leo/Raph when their pissy.

I mean when Leo and Raph went to go talk to Don they where asking him if it was possiable that Splinter might be alive. Meaning for all they knew Splinter was dead and they where sad, how come Mikey didn't show any concern? It's just dissapointing that all.




eh, you know what? I'm just as tired of this excuse that "Mikey's comic relief" as I'm tired of hearing "he acts out to hide his real emotions", to excuse his behavior. Because it rarely does come off funny. Other versions of Michaelangelo have been comic relief with out being a dick like New toon Mikey. Mirage Mikey was the humourous turtle and he never acted out during serious moments, Orginal toon Mike was huge comic relief but he still acted appropiately during serious and tense moments. And Live action Mikey was one that tried changing the subject when talk of Splinter dying came up but actually cried when he thought he was gone. Being comic relief doesn't mean ambivilant dick head.

I totally agree with your comments, they are very true. Over the seasons (although...it seems Fast Forward brought out the worst of him and never looked back...) Mikey's become less funny, less warm/compassionate/careing, less creative/serious in battle...and instead has become more immature, more annoying, more selfish, stupid, and an overall dick.

I hate to say it (as a huge fan of the character in all the OTHER universes)...but it's sadly true. Really embarrassing, to be honest.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-11-2008, 09:12 PM
I know I've felt that there were some points when I just wanted to groan because of how Mikey was behaving because it did come out as being inappropriate for the situation, but I really see no point in hating him. Seems to me like most of the hatred stems from the people who actually have read the comics. Now I'm not familiar with Mirage Mikey. I mean I know somethings about him from reading TMNT sites and all but I never read the comics. So hey call me ill-informed if you must, but I'd rather have NT Mikey over Stoner-pizza-obsessed-Mikey from the old toon.

Jelly Bean
10-11-2008, 11:38 PM
So hey call me ill-informed if you must, but I'd rather have NT Mikey over Stoner-pizza-obsessed-Mikey from the old toon.

OMG are you sh*tin' me!? I'm fairly new to the 80's cartoon but from what I've seen Mikey in that version so far trumps 4KIDS Mikey in almost every way. How does being obsessed with pizza more horriable than being obsessed with annoying your family and acting out at inappropiate times or just being a self centered brat? Mikey in the 80's toon may have thought the sun rose and set in pizza, but thats hardly anything compared to the things 4KIDs Mikey routinely does. **shakes head**

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-12-2008, 12:48 AM
OMG are you sh*tin' me!? I'm fairly new to the 80's cartoon but from what I've seen Mikey in that version so far trumps 4KIDS Mikey in almost every way. How does being obsessed with pizza more horriable than being obsessed with annoying your family and acting out at inappropiate times or just being a self centered brat? Mikey in the 80's toon may have thought the sun rose and set in pizza, but thats hardly anything compared to the things 4KIDs Mikey routinely does. **shakes head**

I don't hate OT Mikey by any means. That's what I at least want you to understand first, but after watching the NT. I honestly just can't take Mikey from the OT seriously.

and it's not like OT Mikey never acted out at inappropriate times either. Heck that's why there was an entire episode based arorund hypnotising Mikey to "crave pizza no more"

I'll at least agree with you that Mikey in the old toon was a little more sensitive. After all when the oven died he was pretty much in tears, but all in all I prefer the NT incarnation of the turtles over the OT turtles.

Besides if Mikey is such a horrible incarnation in the NT then why would people keep going on about it? Seems to me that even if he was written wrong he was still written good enough for people to actually give a damn about his character depth or lack there of. You don't see many people bitching about how Raphael in the OT is an eyesore or anything considering that OT Raph was nothing like his Mirage comic counterpart. Hey I know lets make NT Raph try to be a stand up comedian in an episode. That's totally what he'd do in the comics. :roll:

Kunoichi_Haruko
10-12-2008, 09:00 AM
Okay, I've read through the entire topic, and as a Mikey fan, I'm afraid I'll have to side with the others in terms of how Mikey's been portrayed in the NT. Over the last five years, he's gone from being mildly annoying to just plain cringeworthy. This version is very inconsistent with the other incarnations-- He is a caricature of his self. And the worst thing-- just when it looks like the character is about to evolve, they return him to being an uncaring, self-absorbed brat, more or less. And I'm sorry, but the "he's the youngest" argument doesn't fly, either. He's done more in his young life than other teenagers. He's a freaking ninja. He's seen incredible, horrific things. You'd think his experiences would help him grow up a little, but it's like nothing seems to affect him in the NT universe. I'm not saying he has to be as serious as the others. Goodness knows, as much as they go through, they could use a morale booster. But NT Mike fails to do that. He just ticks them off.


I don't hate OT Mikey by any means. That's what I at least want you to understand first, but after watching the NT. I honestly just can't take Mikey from the OT seriously.

I don't really believe anyone was supposed to take him too seriously, hence the whole "laid-back stoner" version.


Besides if Mikey is such a horrible incarnation in the NT then why would people keep going on about it? Seems to me that even if he was written wrong he was still written good enough for people to actually give a damn about his character depth or lack there of.

We go on about it because he's ONE OF THE MAIN CHARACTERS! If he had a bit part and only showed up 4 times in the series, it'd be completely different. As it stands, we've known NT Mike for about 5 years, and what have we learned? That he's a boastful braggart who thoroughly loves attention and lives to annoy his brothers. His "jokes" produce more groans and whacks to the head than laughs.

You don't see many people bitching about how Raphael in the OT is an eyesore or anything considering that OT Raph was nothing like his Mirage comic counterpart. Hey I know lets make NT Raph try to be a stand up comedian in an episode. That's totally what he'd do in the comics.

The reason no one complains about either version of Raphael is because neither version failed the "amiable" test. OT Raph had a dry sense of humor and was sarcastic. NT Raph is more of a kick butt, ask questions later type of guy. But both versions managed to be likable in their own way. This version of Mike completely drops the ball in that category. We can't feel connected to the character because we get nothing but jokes from him, most of which fall flat. And when something does happen to him that should evoke sympathy, it doesn't trigger much of a response (at least, not from me).


I believe Mandi-Chan summarized it best-- the best things about Michelangelo are missing from NT Mike. Yes, Mikey has his funny moments, but he shouldn't be just a walking punch-line. A little more depth to counterbalance the cheap one-liners would be nice, that's all.

And just to be clear, I'm no comic-purist. The version of the Turtles I know best is from Movie 1. I didn't get into the comics until I found this forum. Also, I don't believe anyone here really hates Mike; on the contrary, we love the turtle, which is why most of the people who've commented here are frustrated with the way he's being portrayed.

Drtooth
10-12-2008, 09:33 AM
Dale was basically the goofy side kick to Chip in rescue rangers. He'd screw up, joke around, etc. It even got to the point that Dale was thrown out of the team for an episode where he developed his evil persona Ramdale. However, there were many episodes that showed that despite his flaws Dale could step up when he needed too. He also showed a a much more compassionate side than Chip did, and even showed that he was not only a very intelligent member of the team when he wasn't getting distracted by video games, TV, and comic books. He also showed that he was a very useful, innovative, and creative member of the team as well. Such as his exploit as the Red Badger and Double O Dale. In fact there were many times when it was Dale who saved the day.

To be honest. I have to agree then. I'd love to see Mikey more like that.


I once recall reading in the back of a Rescue Rangers, someone was defending Dale... something to the extent of "Dale isn't stupid, but more a special kind of Naive." Of course, someone also once mentioned that Mikey should be more like Sock from Reaper... another good comparison.

But then again, I had a problem with Raph in FF too... they took his tough guy personality, and over exaggerated the grouchiness... so every line out of his mouth was "Gahh... I hate the future!" "The Future stinks" and "I hate the Future again!"

Cipher
10-12-2008, 06:37 PM
I'm sick to death of this topic, but...

Besides if Mikey is such a horrible incarnation in the NT then why would people keep going on about it? Seems to me that even if he was written wrong he was still written good enough for people to actually give a damn about his character depth or lack there of.What? Plain and simple: People complain about Mikey's writing in the new toon because he's easily the worst written of the bunch. I care about other versions of Mikey, and I'd love for this one to live up to those expecations. Wanting him to be written better does not mean I love or care for the character as he is. It means... Well, it means I can't stand him and want him to be written better.

You don't see many people bitching about how Raphael in the OT is an eyesore or anything considering that OT Raph was nothing like his Mirage comic counterpart. Hey I know lets make NT Raph try to be a stand up comedian in an episode. That's totally what he'd do in the comics. :roll:No one cares if the characters are different from the Mirage comics. No one complains about old toon Raph because he wasn't irritating. Different? Yes. Irritating? No.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-13-2008, 01:49 PM
I'm sick to death of this topic, but...

What? Plain and simple: People complain about Mikey's writing in the new toon because he's easily the worst written of the bunch. I care about other versions of Mikey, and I'd love for this one to live up to those expecations. Wanting him to be written better does not mean I love or care for the character as he is. It means... Well, it means I can't stand him and want him to be written better.

No one cares if the characters are different from the Mirage comics. No one complains about old toon Raph because he wasn't irritating. Different? Yes. Irritating? No.

Plain and simple. If Mikey is written so horribly then he should be a forgettable character, which I guess is hard since he's a main character, but all I'm saying is that you wouldn't really remember much of Mikey in this incarnation if he was written horribly. Yet NT Mikey is rememberable. In that sense he's not written horribly. Maybe there's a bad choice here and there used on NT Mikey but he's not a horribly butchered shell of his former self or anything. Not to mention that NT MIkey isn't a bland character either. Annoying sometimes? Yes, but he's nowhere near being a bland or forgettable character either. In that sense NT Mikey is also written well especially because he can invoke the emotions of the audience. A badly written Mikey wouldn't be able to do that. He'd be so bland and boring that people would just forget him and never care enough to bitch about how much of a douche Mikey's gotten.

So yeah you may think he's badly written just because he's lost some of the things his mirage counterpart possesses, but that in no way makes Mikey in the NT a horribly written character that's all I'm saying, and heck despite Mikey's character flaws I still like him. I honestly don't care if he's an annoying douche.

Oh and yeah people do care if he's like his Mirage counterpart. That's why most of the arguments are based around comparing NT Mikey to Mirage Mikey... But you know what? I'm done. I don't have to prove anything. I just like Mikey. Douche or not he's still one of my favorite turtles and I just wanted to defend him. That's all. I'm not here to make enemies or anything.

Cipher
10-13-2008, 03:21 PM
Plain and simple. If Mikey is written so horribly then he should be a forgettable character, which I guess is hard since he's a main character, but all I'm saying is that you wouldn't really remember much of Mikey in this incarnation if he was written horribly. Yet NT Mikey is rememberable. In that sense he's not written horribly.I also remember the Ancient One, simply because he's a terrible stock character that I wish wasn't in the show. I remember the main character from the 1998 American Godzilla movie because all of it was so laughably bad. Remembering or expressing dissatisfaction with a character does not mean they are well written. That you think so is just...mind boggling.

In that sense NT Mikey is also written well especially because he can invoke the emotions of the audience. A badly written Mikey wouldn't be able to do that. He'd be so bland and boring that people would just forget him and never care enough to bitch about how much of a douche Mikey's gotten.A well written character evokes the emotions that they're supposed to evoke. If a character is funny and well written, the audience will laugh. If a character is sympathetic and well written, the audience will feel for them. If a character is mean and well written, the audience will hate them (and maybe enjoy them.)

As things would have it, new toon Mikey is supposed to be funny, but most of the audience hates him. That's wrong. That's bad writing. (The word "audience" here refers to the adults who the show isn't aimed at, but who started this discussion anyway.)

So yeah you may think he's badly written just because he's lost some of the things his mirage counterpart possesses.I miss two aspects of his Mirage counterpart: layers and likability. Those can be done in anyway. He could be a mutant firefighter astronaut jokester, and as long as he showed depth and wasn't a douchebag, I'd like him.

I don't have to prove anything. I just like Mikey. Douche or not he's still one of my favorite turtles and I just wanted to defend him. That's all. I'm not here to make enemies or anything.That's totally fine. Other people just want to defent their dislike of this version, or their hope that he could be written differently. If anyone's actually getting angry over this discussion, I think I might just have to cry myself to sleep.

Rooish
10-13-2008, 03:28 PM
I find Mikey really inconsistently written. As in, sometimes he just makes lots of jokes and impressions and just acts kind of outrageous and screams like a girl, etc. All of that I can deal with, although I don't quite understand why they chose to make him so annoying.

But when he's this attention-seeking, hyperactive, cowardly, selfish brat, I want to smash something and shove any previous piece of TMNT merchandise in the writers' faces and yell: "Look, this is Mikey. See him, you idiots? He's kind of a nice guy."

It used to not bother me as much, but also I find that his voice acting is pretty bad ... it's so scratchy and lacking in warmth. It's like his voice is a caricature of... whatever he's supposed to be. He sounds mean when he talks.

It freaks me out that this is the kind of character that kids admire these days.

But yeah, I think 4kids has done a pretty serious disservice to Michelangelo. He makes Michelangelo fans look bad. And everyone else who sort of enjoyed Mikey before, but he wasn't their favourite Turtle--everyone else hates him, now.

He has made me smile a lot of times, and I have cared about his accomplishments (e.g. "Grudge Match"), but that's just because I like funny characters and he was always my favourite Turtle. I recognise that he is not a very good character. And it's not freakin' fair that he gets nothing positive to set him apart from the others. Don's the smart one and the nice one (if they must be distinguished by subjective characteristics like that). Not fair.

In every other version, he was nice. That's the whole damn point.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-13-2008, 03:49 PM
I also remember the Ancient One, simply because he's a terrible stock character that I wish wasn't in the show. I remember the main character from the 1998 American Godzilla movie because all of it was so laughably bad. Remembering or expressing dissatisfaction with a character does not mean they are well written. That you think so is just...mind boggling.

A well written character evokes the emotions that they're supposed to evoke. If a character is funny and well written, the audience will laugh. If a character is sympathetic and well written, the audience will feel for them. If a character is mean and well written, the audience will hate them (and maybe enjoy them.)

As things would have it, new toon Mikey is supposed to be funny, but most of the audience hates him. That's wrong. That's bad writing. (The word "audience" here refers to the adults who the show isn't aimed at, but who started this discussion anyway.)

I miss two aspects of his Mirage counterpart: layers and likability. Those can be done in anyway. He could be a mutant firefighter astronaut jokester, and as long as he showed depth and wasn't a douchebag, I'd like him.

That's totally fine. Other people just want to defent their dislike of this version, or their hope that he could be written differently. If anyone's actually getting angry over this discussion, I think I might just have to cry myself to sleep.

I see that the more I try to defend Mikey the more shoddy my arguments become. Alright I give up. I wanted to prove that Mikey wasn't as bad as people were saying. I wanted to prove that Mikey is still a likable character and the same Mikey we all know and love despite his childish behavior sometimes. When I couldn't prove that I at least wanted to prove that Mikey wasn't horribly written. That despite his flaws he's still a well written character. However, it seems like no matter what I say I'm going to be considered wrong so... I quit. I give up on this debate.

Maybe I just didn't wanna sit back and watch people bash NT Mikey because I actually like him douche or not... I don't know. But there's no point to continuing as I said I don't have to prove anything really. I just wanted to stop all the Mikey hate.

Kunoichi_Haruko
10-13-2008, 03:52 PM
No one hates Mikey. We just hate what the writers have done to him. If you really want to defend his behavior, list some memorable moments where Mikey is something other than obnoxious, corny, rude or selfish, please.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-13-2008, 04:01 PM
No one hates Mikey. We just hate what the writers have done to him. If you really want to defend his behavior, list some memorable moments where Mikey is something other than obnoxious, corny, rude or selfish, please.

The christmas alien episode for one. I think that overall debunks the Mikey is always crude and rude thing.

I'd also say the touch and go episode as Mikey proved that he was creative and intelligent.

I also think Grudge Match was a good episode. Not just because Mikey got what he deserved for rubbing his victory in everyone's faces but because he showed he did care about his family when Klub threatened to kill them and it showed that even if Mikey is nothing but a childish douche most of the time. He can step up.

Plus I think the episodes where Mikey and Leo were teamed up with Nobody proved that Mikey does have a serious side. Heck honestly the only time I remember Mikey not being serious during an actual fight was the first Garbageman episode, but I hate garbageman anyways so I didn't really care. Even then Junklantis proved that Mikey and Don worked well together.

Also I'd say that Mikey's relationship with Leatherhead proves that despite how much of a douche he is. Mikey is still sensitive and caring to others.

Also Bad Day showed off that Mikey wasn't just a douche that always cracked unfunny jokes.

I feel there are tons of moments when Mikey is not a douche. Maybe his bad behavior overshadows his good traits but it's not like he doesn't have them at all.

Cipher
10-13-2008, 08:10 PM
ExamplesI'll grant you that pre-season six Mikey is better written. He's never been great, but yeah, his jokes came less often and with better delivery in past seasons, and the comic adaptations helped.

Since Fast Foward his character has devolved even further. I notice none of your examples come from seasons six or seven. Ordering Serling around in "Karate Schooled" after both he and Serling had suffered a major tragedy was something no likable character should ever do, and something that even the semi-irritating seasons one through five Mikey wouldn't have done.

Jelly Bean
10-13-2008, 11:40 PM
I see that the more I try to defend Mikey the more shoddy my arguments become. Alright I give up. I wanted to prove that Mikey wasn't as bad as people were saying. I wanted to prove that Mikey is still a likable character and the same Mikey we all know and love despite his childish behavior sometimes. When I couldn't prove that I at least wanted to prove that Mikey wasn't horribly written. That despite his flaws he's still a well written character. However, it seems like no matter what I say I'm going to be considered wrong so... I quit. I give up on this debate.

Maybe I just didn't wanna sit back and watch people bash NT Mikey because I actually like him douche or not... I don't know. But there's no point to continuing as I said I don't have to prove anything really. I just wanted to stop all the Mikey hate.

mm, you don't have to sound so melodramatic about it. What you don't seem to under stand is that it's not Mikey the character people hate it's how he's being written. Fans like Mikey if they didn't there wouldn't be so much dissatisfaction over how he is handled because we think his character deserves better.

Truth is I do like NT Mikey, in fact I felt sorry for him in the beginning of the series because I thought his brothers where to mean to him and that fans seemed a little harsh of him. But even then I thought that Mikey could be written better than what he was and this is with me not ever read the mirage comics. The 4KIDs version of the turtles was the only version of the turtles I had ever seen until rather recently, I had no other version to compare 4KIDs Mikey to. I've been watching the 80's cartoon version of the turtles, and he's my first major exposure to Michaelangelo's character other than the current toon, and honestly I'm finding my self liking 80's toon Michaelangelo alot more than the current toon, and this was with me taking a conceince effert not to like him to. Sure he talks funny and uses dated lingo and gets too excited and even royally screws up sometimes, but I'm finding his over all personality and character better handled. I still like 4KIDs Mikey but now that I've seen other versions of him I'm starting to see where others are coming from.

I think the problem with Mikey's character is that he is too inconsistant. He acts one way in one episode then another in the next.

It used to not bother me as much, but also I find that his voice acting is pretty bad ... it's so scratchy and lacking in warmth. It's like his voice is a caricature of... whatever he's supposed to be. He sounds mean when he talks.

ooh, I've never heard any one say that before. :o

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-14-2008, 02:21 AM
I'll grant you that pre-season six Mikey is better written. He's never been great, but yeah, his jokes came less often and with better delivery in past seasons, and the comic adaptations helped.

Since Fast Foward his character has devolved even further. I notice none of your examples come from seasons six or seven. Ordering Serling around in "Karate Schooled" after both he and Serling had suffered a major tragedy was something no likable character should ever do, and something that even the semi-irritating seasons one through five Mikey wouldn't have done.

Meh well in all honesty I know Fast Forward is supposed to be light-hearted so I didn't think I had to mention it, but I really didn't mind Mikey in that season either. I mean Mikey did have his shining moments like the episode where Mikey had to prove himself to graduate with his brothers, and even though Mikey was a douche to the new Turtle Titan can you realy blame him? I mean Turtle Titan was very underappreciated back in his time, and to Mikey someone taking his patented superhero name and getting all the glory. it just seemed wrong to him. Besides Mikey redeemed himself at the end of the episode. Also it was Mikey's video game skills that helped them survive when the turtles were trapped in the game console. Mikey has shown that he can even step up in the fast forward season as well. Though considering it was mostly a light-hearted humor season. I don't think there was much room to give Mikey super serious moments, but hey he had some and that's better than nothing you know?

and as far as Karate Schooled goes. I think people are taking that a little too far. I mean I never saw anyone have much of a problem with Mikey until Karate Schooled. Suddenly he's a super douche that's written badly. I mean sheesh. I kinda expected Mikey to be like that. It doesn't suit him to be moping around like the rest of his brothers. That doesn't mean I think he doesn't care about splinter. I think he does. I just don't think he has to be full of angst and crap to show it. Also Mikey did prove himself later on in the episode a capable and serious turtle. So just because he was messing around with Don and Serling doesn't mean he's the world's biggest asshole that never takes anything seriously.

mm, you don't have to sound so melodramatic about it. What you don't seem to under stand is that it's not Mikey the character people hate it's how he's being written. Fans like Mikey if they didn't there wouldn't be so much dissatisfaction over how he is handled because we think his character deserves better.

Truth is I do like NT Mikey, in fact I felt sorry for him in the beginning of the series because I thought his brothers where to mean to him and that fans seemed a little harsh of him. But even then I thought that Mikey could be written better than what he was and this is with me not ever read the mirage comics. The 4KIDs version of the turtles was the only version of the turtles I had ever seen until rather recently, I had no other version to compare 4KIDs Mikey to. I've been watching the 80's cartoon version of the turtles, and he's my first major exposure to Michaelangelo's character other than the current toon, and honestly I'm finding my self liking 80's toon Michaelangelo alot more than the current toon, and this was with me taking a conceince effert not to like him to. Sure he talks funny and uses dated lingo and gets too excited and even royally screws up sometimes, but I'm finding his over all personality and character better handled. I still like 4KIDs Mikey but now that I've seen other versions of him I'm starting to see where others are coming from.

I think the problem with Mikey's character is that he is too inconsistant. He acts one way in one episode then another in the next.

Well if it makes you feel better I'm not trying to be melodramatic about it. I'm just admitting that I'm fighting a losing battle that's all. Nothing more.

i guess to me NT Mikey while an unfunny, annoying, douche sometimes is still a serious character and has proven himself on many occasions. I'm just tired of people blowing his character out of proportion where it's made out like Mikey is an unfunny, annoying, douche all the time. I'm not saying he's never that way. I'm just saying he's rarely that way and people just need to chill. I admit that maybe he can be written better, but overall I don't think he's written as horribly as many think. But even though he can be annoying sometimes I can still take Mikey seriously when Mikey gets serious, and honestly I've seen characters in other series that outclass Mikey in the douche factor.

I've seen the other versions of Mikey too based on the official site and fansites for the comic, but even then I don't hate NT Mikey. It's my opinion that most of the reasons people even hate NT Mikey are minor at best. Most of them you can just shrug off. Or at least I can. Maybe I'm just not taking it personally enough as a Mikey fan. I don't know. I can see where others are coming from, but I still don't see it as reason enough to hate NT Mikey. He has his flaws but he also has his redeemable qualities too, but I feel that people are forgetting his redeemable qualities and are magnifying his flaws to ridiculous levels. Even if Mikey is inconsistent I just believe that people are blowing it way out of line, but then again what do I know right?

Jelly Bean
10-15-2008, 11:01 PM
I have a question, even though NT Mikey doesn't seem to have the respect of alot of the fans, do you think he has the respect of his friends and family? Like do you think Splinter respects Mikey like he does Don or leo or even Raph? Or Leo, Raph and Don respect him like they do each other? How about April and Casey do they respect him as much as they respect the other turtles?

triplexxx
10-15-2008, 11:11 PM
Well, I should hope so, 'cause regardless of his personality, he still contributes to their survival and helps saves the lives of innocent people and his own family just as much as the others do.

Jelly Bean
10-15-2008, 11:20 PM
well I'm sure they respect him as a ninja and as memeber of their clan, but as person I mean. I notice people can respect people proffionally but not respect them very much as an individual person.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-15-2008, 11:44 PM
I feel he does have their respect. Splinter could have easily let Mikey not graduate with his brothers but he chose to allow Mikey the chance. I think Splinter does see Mikey's potential, but thinks he has to be harder on him than he is with the others because he is the least focused. Touch and Go kinda makes that point. Splinter has sort of the "I'm only hard on you because I know you have the potential to be better." attitude. Obviously Splinter doesn't need that with leo and he rarely needs to scold Raph and Don.

With Raph. I think Raph does respect and love Mikey... Even if his relationship with Leo is stronger. Even so Raph and Mikey have kind of a sibling rivalry relationship like during the battle nexus tournament, but they would still stand up for each other if they had too. Not to mention they love pulling pranks on each other.

While Mikey and Don's relationship isn't really shown all that much. They seem to get along good despite Don getting annoyed with Mikey's immaturity, or rolling his eyes when Mikey doesn't get something everyone else does. Not to mention that when Mikey and Don do work together such as in Junklantis. They do make a good team.

I think Leo also loves and respects Mikey. Leo does his best to be the wise and responsible older brother. He gives Mikey advice and would always jump in to save him if he had too. Just like he would any of his brothers..

As for April and Casey why wouldn't they love Mikey? They seem to enjoy having him around and he seems to make them laugh sometimes.