View Full Version : So, TMNT 2003 Was Actually Really Good
Cipher
02-22-2009, 02:30 PM
Apparently sarcasm is out of vogue these days, so let's honestly look back at how brilliantly well done this series was. I was watching a few episodes last night and I realized that this series has been fantastic. This was a great addition to the Turtles mythos.
The continuity was so strong, with everything building off of previous events. When you sit down to watch the episodes en masse, it's really impressive, yet each is self contained enough to keep things from dragging.
Alot of the original story arcs are fantastic, right up there with the best of Turtles fiction. The entirety of season three, from the Triceraton invasion to Saki's retrieval operation, to Bishop, to in-fighting among the villains is terrific. Even season five, when placed in context with the rest of the series, is suitably epic.
The animation, with the exceptions of seasons five and seven, is jaw-droppingly well done. It really peaks in seasons two and three where almost every episode is incredibly detailed and fluid. Certain episodes like "The Golden Puck" and "Return of the Justice Force" I felt like were carried on animation alone. Fast Foward may not be as detailed, but you can still catch some really fluid movement in it.
It's brought some major contributions to the rogues gallery. Bishop, Hun, Sh'Okanabo, Viral, and so many more were great contributions that I'd like to see again. Ch'rell was also a very cool reinvention of the Shredder, and while I'm not sure I'd like to see the Utrom idea carried over into other versions, it was used to great effect in this series, and really saved the character for me.
So it's not the best cartoon ever made. It's not even my favorite version of TMNT. But damn, it's alot better than it had any right to be.
CyberCubed
02-22-2009, 02:53 PM
I think the 2k3 series actually did a better job with some of the comic storylines, to be honest. Sure, we didn't get to see blood or Leo/Raph actually stab any Foot or anything, but I much like the way the 2k3 series handled the Foot than the comics.
Baxter and Karai also have so much more depth in the cartoon than in the Mirage universe, its not even funny.
Also I really did like the way the 2k3 series had a unique take on Shredder. Never would anyone imagine something like an Utrom Shredder, or a Demon Shredder, or a Cyber Shredder.
I also love how the continuity makes sense. Things from Season 5 were foreshadowed as early as Season 1. Continuity even continued into FF and BTTS.
My only gripe is the lack of closure or a well-defined ending.
The Terror of Death
02-22-2009, 04:46 PM
I liked practically every aspect of the show but what really got me was the presentation of the cinematography and fight scenes. The staff always seemed to come up with some new way to keep things looking fresh. Its rare to find that much detail and innovation in a cartoon. Even Fast Forward had it, although to a lesser extent.
Scandia
02-22-2009, 06:08 PM
There is a reason why I like the 2k3 series so much. And it is not just because it is very Leonardo-centric. The comic adaptations are great. The original episodes are very good as well. They make a great job of keeping the viewers hooked. Of balancing humor and serious aspects. I think this is the best Turtles universe so far.
Buslady
02-22-2009, 07:22 PM
the 1-4 seasons were bitchin...you got story, character, nice animation, everything...I loved it.
It did annoy me that it was about a 85% Leo focus, not enough Raph but there was some great Raph stuff like my favorite quote "Someone once said, if the difference between a man and a boy are the size of their toys, then I think I just became a man!" That is classic, you dont get that anymore with this pseudoTMNT crap FF & BTTS....
CyberCubed
02-22-2009, 07:37 PM
I wish Rat King got more screentime, but what can you do. It just seems odd to see a popular villain only given one episode.
As for TMNT screentime, it was stretched out almost evenly. Mike and Leo seemed to get the most attention, but Raph and Don had plenty of moments and character eps too.
They did a great job with April/Casey, two of the best versions of their characters in any medium.
FF had some interesting new villains. I loved Zukko, Zixx, and they managed to make the arc worthwhile. Shame it didn't get proper closure though.
BTTS seems like it needed more room to grow. The cyberworld plot was so-so, but I did enjoy most of the individual eps and the new character designs were great.
I think the problem is both FF and BTTS ended before their time, they needed more episodes to properly wrap it up. I still hope that maybe the 2k3 series is revived a few years later even if they let it rest for awhile, since 4kids is seemingly hanging onto the TMNT license for awhile.
FlawedCoil82
02-22-2009, 07:49 PM
It's just driving me bonkers that they won't announce anything about when Season 3 Part 1 will be out on dvd. I don't care about anything else until they announce something.
But yea, TMNT BEFORE FF and BTTS was amazingly good. My second favorite action cartoon, behind only the 90's X-Men cartoon.
TMNT seasons 1 - 5 as a whole I would rate a 9.0
FF I would rate a 5.5
BTTS I would rate a 3.0
Jack
The Terror of Death
02-22-2009, 07:58 PM
It's just driving me bonkers that they won't announce anything about when Season 3 Part 1 will be out on dvd. I don't care about anything else until they announce something.
Me too. The lack of any information yet makes me fear were not going to get it until mid or late 09. Which means part 2 probably wont be released until 2010.
ToTheNines
02-22-2009, 08:17 PM
It's just driving me bonkers that they won't announce anything about when Season 3 Part 1 will be out on dvd. I don't care about anything else until they announce something.
But yea, TMNT BEFORE FF and BTTS was amazingly good. My second favorite action cartoon, behind only the 90's X-Men cartoon.
TMNT seasons 1 - 5 as a whole I would rate a 9.0
FF I would rate a 5.5
BTTS I would rate a 3.0
Jack
I feel ya, it's getting ridiculous.
Second favorite action cartoon tho? I'm guessing you've never seen Cowboy Bebop or Justice League Unlimited.
The Terror of Death
02-22-2009, 08:44 PM
Second favorite action cartoon tho? I'm guessing you've never seen Cowboy Bebop or Justice League Unlimited.
Yu Yu Hakusho yes. Cowboy Bebop no.
Cipher
02-22-2009, 08:48 PM
Guys, Yu Yu Hakusho and Cowboy Bebop were made under a completely different set of standards and censors than TMNT. They shouldn't even be a part of this discussion.
The Terror of Death
02-22-2009, 09:07 PM
Guys, Yu Yu Hakusho and Cowboy Bebop were made under a completely different set of standards and censors than TMNT. They shouldn't even be a part of this discussion.
I know, I know. Just thought I would correct the guy.
But back to the original topic. What I also liked about 2k3 was the Mirage crossovers. Marvel and DC do it all the time in their cartoons so it was nice to see it done so many times in TMNT.
Revan
02-22-2009, 11:45 PM
I think the 2k3 series actually did a better job with some of the comic storylines, to be honest. Sure, we didn't get to see blood or Leo/Raph actually stab any Foot or anything, but I much like the way the 2k3 series handled the Foot than the comics.
For sure. There are definately some 2k3 eps that I prefer to the original comics. One that comes to mind (and I may catch hell for this) is return to new york. Call me crazy but the 2k3 version made it look much harder than it looked in the comics. I read it like a cakewalk. Zog coincidentally shows up and kicks @$$. The turtles find shredder and own him.
But the 2k3 version shows them busting their tails up shredder's skyscrapper in a desperate attempt. Just seemed more exciting to me.
This is not the norm though. In general, the volume 1 books are more exciting.
My only gripe is the lack of closure or a well-defined ending.
Seconded. And not only closure to the series as a whole but there were a few "stand alone" episodes that left interesting story lines hanging in the wind.
Drtooth
02-23-2009, 09:04 AM
I think the problem is both FF and BTTS ended before their time, they needed more episodes to properly wrap it up. I still hope that maybe the 2k3 series is revived a few years later even if they let it rest for awhile, since 4kids is seemingly hanging onto the TMNT license for awhile.
Exactly the problem. FF was written like there was over 26 episodes, and BTTS was written like there was going to be another season. And as such, they built up things they couldn't possibly finish, all the while padding the run with OT style disconnected episodes. Look at season 5... it was clearly written like that was the end. Nothing outside the plot was set up... nothing was left behind. Sure, a couple characters left the show the previous season with only one appearance. But they tied almost everything else up. Karai, while not defeated, left for better things. The foot supposedly fell under her departure... you could have ended the show right then and there.
ZariusTwo
02-23-2009, 09:34 AM
Had they not been so concerned with "standalone" episodes (that was a mandate from 4Kids wasnt it?), they'd have finished the series on their terms.
CyberCubed
02-23-2009, 10:28 AM
Most of the main villains do have closure.
FF gave Bishop and Baxter endings, too bad we didn't get to see Baxter get his own body though.
Karai and Dr. Chaplain left the Foot after the Demon Shredder was killed.
Hun got the crap beat out of him by Cyber Shredder.
Khan and maybe Cyber Shredder are in the finale, so we'll see what happens.
Cipher
02-23-2009, 12:16 PM
For sure. There are definately some 2k3 eps that I prefer to the original comics. One that comes to mind (and I may catch hell for this) is return to new york. Call me crazy but the 2k3 version made it look much harder than it looked in the comics. I read it like a cakewalk. Zog coincidentally shows up and kicks @$$. The turtles find shredder and own him.
But the 2k3 version shows them busting their tails up shredder's skyscrapper in a desperate attempt. Just seemed more exciting to me.In most cases I'm a comics guy, but I can totally see where you're coming from with this. There was alot more build up in the cartoon, and the fights with the invisible ninjas, Shredder clones, and Foot Mystics were alot more interesting than Zog shooting enemy after enemy. I did think Leo's duel with Saki was better done in the comics, though. And I preferred Zog's insanity in the comics to his more collected appearence in "Rogue in the House."
And I can totally acknowledge that in terms of plot organization, the cartoon did alot of things better than the comics. I still have alot more love for the anthology feel and subtle nuances of the comic writing, but those don't work in a kid's show. I can easily see why people would prefer the series' story structure.
Seconded. And not only closure to the series as a whole but there were a few "stand alone" episodes that left interesting story lines hanging in the wind.Now this, I disagree with. There is nothing wrong with a well executed stand alone episode. They provide an opportunity for more unusual outings and really broaden the universe.
And so help me, I like to have a few mysteries left over from those episodes.
FF gave Bishop and Baxter endings, too bad we didn't get to see Baxter get his own body though.
We would have. He was planned to meet a Triceraton Shredder (Zukko?) in the second season of FF.
Revan
02-23-2009, 12:24 PM
And I can totally acknowledge that in terms of plot organization, the cartoon did alot of things better than the comics...
...I can easily see why people would prefer the series' story structure.
A lot of that has to do with the different writers and de-centralized production structure.
There are some books that were simply out of place. Especially vol 1. If Mirage could go back and do it all over they may be able to find more common ground between issues.
Now this, I disagree with. There is nothing wrong with a well executed stand alone episode. They provide an opportunity for more unusual outings and really broaden the universe.
And so help me, I like to have a few mysteries left over from those episodes.
To each his own I suppose. Nothing wrong with a little mystery. I guess I just want to see everything tied up. :ohwell:
DISTURBEDStheMOL
02-24-2009, 03:21 PM
We would have. He was planned to meet a Triceraton Shredder (Zukko?) in the second season of FF.
Wait, how do you know this?
Cipher
02-24-2009, 03:27 PM
Wait, how do you know this?A while back, an anonymous storyboard artist at 4kids posted the boards to some cancelled episodes of FF. Among them was an episode about Baxter meeting a Triceraton Shredder, which looked awesome, and I harbor a deep seated belief that it had something to do with Zukko, who is also awesome.
He disabled the links after a few days, but I'm pretty sure someone around here has the storyboards saved on their computer, and maybe they'd be awesome enough to share.
The Terror of Death
02-24-2009, 09:11 PM
Among them was an episode about Baxter meeting a Triceraton Shredder, which looked awesome, and I harbor a deep seated belief that it had something to do with Zukko, who is also awesome.
Zukko probably met up with Utrom Shredder. And Shredder probably decided to go after Baxter so that he could build something no one else could.
Cipher
02-24-2009, 11:35 PM
Zukko probably met up with Utrom Shredder. And Shredder probably decided to go after Baxter so that he could build something no one else could.That's the theory I subscribe to as well.
Or maybe he didn't actually find Ch'rell, but at the very least Zukko would've heard of him with his connections. I'm set that it was Zukko though. There'd be no reason to bring in another random Triceraton antagonist, and he already called the Turtles his "Enemies for life."
PrometheusUFO
02-25-2009, 12:22 AM
He disabled the links after a few days, but I'm pretty sure someone around here has the storyboards saved on their computer, and maybe they'd be awesome enough to share.
A little while back, I went into my old Win 98 computer that barely works anymore, salvaged them, and shared them in a thread here. And here's that link again:
http://www.mediafire.com/?2qeqojzepkg
These storyboards are apparently from episode 149: "The Devil and Dr. Stockman", one of the ten episodes that make up the unproduced (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?p=650679#post650679) Season 7 (aka Fast Forward Season 2).
^
swoon at the storyboards. i would really have loved to have seen these episodes made...perhaps one day there will be a second lost season...
As for the original q, i love the 2k3 series, and I think as someone said, it's not that i didn't like some episodes, it's just that i liked some eps (and seasons) better than others. Particularly season 3 and 4.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.