View Full Version : Casey, Gabrielle, April
The Big Bad
02-27-2009, 09:40 PM
So I was all set to mention our favorite twice-married vigilante on TV Tropes' "Second Love" (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SecondLove) page, and then I came across a dilemma: is it April, or Gabrielle?
Personally, I'm not all too certain of the details to give an informed answer (although I do have a particular preference). While I have read most of "City at War", I haven't read the issues that preceded it nor the stories conclusion, so I'm missing quite a bit of context. Here's what I know:
1) At the beginning of "CaW", Casey made some romantic advances towards April, which were rebuffed.
2) Casey headed west, meets Gabrielle.
3) Casey and Gabrielle fall in love, marry, and live happily enough until Gabrielle dies during childbirth.
4) Casey and April separately decide to move back to New York, where they coincidentally meet.
Some time later--I don't know exactly when--April and Casey become a couple, and eventually marry.
So, what do y'all think? Was Casey in love with April when "CaW" began, or was he merely interested? Is Gabrielle Casey's "first" love, or is she his second? Or is their room for interpretation?
Coola Yagami
02-27-2009, 09:44 PM
Hmmm probably a little of both. I mean, he gave it a shot towards April, it failed, he decided he'd never get another chance and found love elsewhere.
Cipher
02-28-2009, 12:57 AM
I think he was fairly interested in April before City at War. There's nothing concrete, but they're relationship had been budding for sometime.
What I think is undeniable, though, is that he remains just as, if not more committed to Gabrielle's memory as he is to April. He mentions her several times in Volume 2, and he really flips his lid in the Image series when Mike loses Shadow. Not because she's his daughter, but because she's "all he has left of Gabrielle."
If you want to really summarize his arc:
Attraction to April -----> Strong love for Gabe -----> Strong love for April (and Gabe's memory)
Andrew NDB
03-08-2009, 06:06 PM
Seemed pretty straight-forward to me.
Casey loved April before CaW, but he wasn't ready or mature enough emotionally for any such relationship.
Then he got into a relationship with Gabrielle and... yeah, suffice to say, he grew substantially as a result of that.
Then, eventually, April and Casey got together, with Casey more level-headed now.
Mr._Mutant_Man
03-08-2009, 06:41 PM
Wouldn't Spider-Man be another comic example? Gwen Stacy was his main serious love interest first before Mary Jane.
Anyway, with the TMNT comic, I'd say the order would be Gabrielle and then April. However, you have an interesting case in that he was interested in April first. Nothing much happened until City at War though, so it would probably still be Gabrielle and then April.
I guess Casey Jones' situation is kind of similar to Spider-Man's. They both found love, then their love interests died. Later on, they end up together with someone they had some interest in before.
Andrew NDB
03-08-2009, 07:06 PM
April. However, you have an interesting case in that he was interested in April first.
He was. He tried to hold her hand, then when she didn't reciprocate he stomped off like a little brat.
When he came back to the table a little more mature (after Gabrielle) they were able to both be adults about things.
ZariusTwo
03-09-2009, 10:30 AM
Wouldn't Spider-Man be another comic example? Gwen Stacy was his main serious love interest first before Mary Jane.
Peter didnt have a clue what real love was at the time. Betty Brant was his first crush, and later he even called her his "first love" AFTER Gwen's death (typically Peter) ..and nobody except Stan liked Gwen's character as it developed anyway, everyone loved MJ and how she didnt judge Peter for his secrecy, and got along with everyone, where as Gwen did judge Peter and also seemed to be become excessively possesive and vindicative towards everyone she cared about. That was why they infamously killed her off when Stan was on vacation
When the first Clone Saga began, Peter realized MJ was his true love, she had been visiting his Aunt on and off for years during the Lee/Ditko era, her face unseen, before he even met Gwen, she was entirely selfless, and didnt seem to have any emotional problems (mainly because she good at hiding her conflicted family life), the original clone of Gwen told Peter to move on. I don't even like to think that a clone cheapens this peice of character development, hell the saga's so damn convulted it might as well have been the real Gwen anyway brainwashed into thinking she was a clone (just as she was brainwashed into thinking she was Joyce Delaney by The High Evolutionary)
In Ultimate Spider-Man, the modern version of Gwen is Peter's surrgoate sister. Bendis had the right idea...sooner or later, Peter and Gwen simply realize that there more like siblings than lovers, or in USM's case, Gwen realized this instantly because she's more headstrong. What makes Ultimate Gwen unique is that she's the responsible "older sister" to Peter and MJ, where as Peter had the role of the responsible "older brother" in the original continuity.
Interesting thread. Reading these posts made think about Caseys love life and who he really cares about among his 2 ladies. Really had to give it a thought myself.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.