PDA

View Full Version : Shredder being the villain for the shows entire run


CyberCubed
03-01-2009, 05:29 PM
How do you feel about this? Similar to the original 80's cartoon, Shredder was the main villain for pretty much the shows entire run, even though it was three different Shredders.

He was even in Season 4's "Bad Day" in that dream the Mystic Foot conjured up, aside from Karai being Shredder for a short time, and in FF's "Timing is Everything" when they went back in time, so he was in every season at least once.

I guess 4kids felt Shredder was too marketable a villain and that the TMNT franchise always had to have him around, so I'm glad they did it in interesting ways by giving us three different (or four, if you count Karai), Shredder's.

Unlike the Mirage comics, Shredder was always around in both cartoons until the very end, (in Season 10 Shredder/Krang get one last 3-parter during the Dregg eps), and so forth.

At the same time, it does seem like the franchise will never be like the comics, where it isn't TMNT Vs. Shredder all the time.

The Terror of Death
03-01-2009, 06:05 PM
After watching FF I thought he would be reduced to flashback and time travel appearances and thus be in a few episodes per season. But when BttS made him the main villain I was slightly angered by the decision. I like the character but continuing to make the foot major players in the series should have ended in Enter the Dragons. Shredder had five seasons to develop the legacy of himself and the foot clan so I felt making the character go any further would do more harm than good. And while I didn't hate the Cyber Shredder storyline it all felt like stuff we saw done before and done better.

Cyber Shredder, Kahn, and the new foot had little actual development so they added nothing to the Shredder legacy. They also didn't do anything of major consequence.

Despite that I thought the character was handled extremely well in seasons 1-6. I wouldn't have minded him being the major villain in BttS all that much if he was only in five episodes max.

Drtooth
03-01-2009, 06:15 PM
How do you feel about this? Similar to the original 80's cartoon, Shredder was the main villain for pretty much the shows entire run, even though it was three different Shredders.

If you'll excuse the pun, similar my Foot! We had multiple Shredders in this series... Utrom Shredder, Tengu Shredder, Karai, Cyber Shredder, and we were supposed to get a Triceriton Shredder in FF before they cut it off. Unlike the old series, Shredder takes his rightful place as a persona, not just one person. it became a title, and it was able to transfer from character to character and for different reasons.

Cipher
03-01-2009, 08:32 PM
I'm torn. I like the idea of simply killing him off as Mirage has done, as it allows the Turtles' rogues gallery to grow. It's also more realistic. In Mirage, for example, he wasn't some supervillainous force. He was simply a man whose blood fued with Splinter cast a shadow over their lives even after his death.

On the other hand they managed to keep him menacing throughout his appearences and Oroku Saki really did grow as a character. I'm also a fan of Shredder being a mantle rather than one person, so I think it's really cool that various characters filled the role.

Cyber Shredder was definately over staying his welcome as a copy of Ch'rell, though. I think it would have been much more interesting if Viral had purposefully adopted the persona.

CyberCubed
03-01-2009, 09:03 PM
Keep in mind the Mirage comics rogue gallery is terrible. They have very few recurring villains in the comics, most are one-shot aliens or monsters. Even in all those Tales issues most of them are about one-shot monsters or aliens, or random Foot fights.

There's a reason why the old toon had to come up with all those mutants, and why the 2k3 series had to expand the Foot, introduce Hun, Bishop, etc.

Cipher
03-01-2009, 09:14 PM
Keep in mind the Mirage comics rogue gallery is terrible. They have very few recurring villains in the comics, most are one-shot aliens or monsters. Even in all those Tales issues most of them are about one-shot monsters or aliens, or random Foot fights.

There's a reason why the old toon had to come up with all those mutants, and why the 2k3 series had to expand the Foot, introduce Hun, Bishop, etc.I said it "allows" the rogues gallery to grow. I didn't say it's actually been taken advantage of.

But if the Mirage recurring villains list ever does grow beyond Complete Carnage and Savanti Romero, at least they won't be constantly eclipsed by Shredder.

TristanHuwJones
03-01-2009, 09:54 PM
I said it "allows" the rogues gallery to grow. I didn't say it's actually been taken advantage of.

Has this year. March, April, June, August and November all introduce new villains who live through the end, and the villains from March, June, August and November have all appeared in previous issues (outside of new ones being introduced as well). I know May wraps up the COWBoys of Moo Mesa story, July features Nobody, but I'm not sure about September, October or December.

Cipher
03-01-2009, 10:46 PM
Has this year. March, April, June, August and November all introduce new villains who live through the end, and the villains from March, June, August and November have all appeared in previous issues (outside of new ones being introduced as well). I know May wraps up the COWBoys of Moo Mesa story, July features Nobody, but I'm not sure about September, October or December.And for this I thank you.

Also, since you brought it up, what's the official word on Nobody's death in Volume 2? Was that part of Braunze's illusion or did it really happen? I don't think we've seen him since...

Andrew NDB
03-01-2009, 10:51 PM
Also, since you brought it up, what's the official word on Nobody's death in Volume 2? Was that part of Braunze's illusion or did it really happen? I don't think we've seen him since...

That's what I've been wondering.

TristanHuwJones
03-01-2009, 11:00 PM
And for this I thank you.

Also, since you brought it up, what's the official word on Nobody's death in Volume 2? Was that part of Braunze's illusion or did it really happen? I don't think we've seen him since...

I have a feeling that's what this issue (#60) is going to deal with...

I could be wrong, but I can certainly find out.

Andrew NDB
03-01-2009, 11:52 PM
To be fair, I was never terribly interested in Nobody as a character at any point. His final fate has always just been an enigma to me.

trustno1
03-02-2009, 12:59 AM
i am more interested in why april donned his mantle. how did april even know him anyway?

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-02-2009, 09:29 AM
Unlike the Mirage comics, Shredder was always around in both cartoons until the very end, (in Season 10 Shredder/Krang get one last 3-parter during the Dregg eps), and so forth.

Even the Archie TMNT Adventures comics kicked out the concept with Shredder as main villain.

Drtooth
03-02-2009, 09:43 AM
Cyber Shredder was definately over staying his welcome as a copy of Ch'rell, though. I think it would have been much more interesting if Viral had purposefully adopted the persona.

I think so too. I really wish she became Shredder that way, adopting the persona and the knowledge as a way to psyche the Turtles out... though I think the best BTTS concept was how scared Hun was of Shredder coming back and beating him soundly.

Scandia
03-02-2009, 09:59 AM
I honestly think the best set of villains was in the Archie comic books. They had quantity and quality in their variety. I wish they could have done the same with the TV series. But in the OT it was alien du jour or the rather lame Dregg. And in the NT, other than Shredder/Foot the only major villains would be the ones in Fast Forward.

Ninjinister
03-02-2009, 10:01 AM
And in the NT, other than Shredder/Foot the only major villains would be the ones in Fast Forward.

You're kidding, right? John Bishop was a major threat throughout two seasons. Ultimate Ninja and Drako/Ultimate Drako also showed up in many episodes to f*** with the Turtles, including stealing thunder from Savanti Romero's debut episode.

Cipher
03-02-2009, 12:06 PM
But in the OT it was alien du jour or the rather lame Dregg.Or Rat King, Slash, Leatherhead, Baxter Stockman, etc.

The OT had a great collection of reccuring villains, although it could have used them a bit more often.

I could be wrong, but I can certainly find out.Would you?

CyberCubed
03-02-2009, 02:27 PM
The old toon had plenty of villains:

- Shredder/Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady/Foot
- General Traag and Rock soldiers
- Baxter Stockman
- Rat King
- Leatherhead
- Slash
- Metalhead
- Chrome Dome
- Groundchuck and Dirtbag
- Antrax and Scumbug
- Wingnut and Screwloose
- Rahzar and Tokka
- Mobsters, there were three different gangs
- Lord Dregg and his minions

Also plenty of good guys:

- Usagi
- The Punk Frogs
- Casey Jones
- Mondo Gecko
- Merdude
- The Neutrinos
- Zak the Fifth Turtle
- Lotus Blossom
- Carter
- Bugman
- The Channel 6 news crew

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-02-2009, 05:35 PM
The old toon had plenty of villains:

- Shredder/Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady/Foot
- General Traag and Rock soldiers
- Baxter Stockman
- Rat King
- Leatherhead
- Slash
- Metalhead
- Chrome Dome
- Groundchuck and Dirtbag
- Antrax and Scumbug
- Wingnut and Screwloose
- Rahzar and Tokka
- Mobsters, there were three different gangs
- Lord Dregg and his minions

Also plenty of good guys:

- Usagi
- The Punk Frogs
- Casey Jones
- Mondo Gecko
- Merdude
- The Neutrinos
- Zak the Fifth Turtle
- Lotus Blossom
- Carter
- Bugman
- The Channel 6 news crew

Yes, but Shredder/Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady/Foot were in almost every episode in season 1-8, but season 4-6 had 50 % solo adventures without them.

VaughnMichael
03-02-2009, 07:05 PM
Yes, but Shredder/Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady/Foot were in almost every episode in season 1-8, but season 4-6 had 50 % solo adventures without them.
& thank god for that!:D

CyberCubed
03-02-2009, 07:17 PM
Shredder/Krang were in every single episode of Seasons 1-3 except for Rat King's debut episode.

Anarchistguy
03-02-2009, 08:50 PM
Keep in mind the Mirage comics rogue gallery is terrible. They have very few recurring villains in the comics, most are one-shot aliens or monsters. Even in all those Tales issues most of them are about one-shot monsters or aliens, or random Foot fights.

Yeah, but the thing is, the Mirage comics weren't about the TMNT fighting evil. They were about them surviving in a world where they are alone...kinda like 2k3

Cipher
03-02-2009, 09:03 PM
Yeah, but the thing is, the Mirage comics weren't about the TMNT fighting evil. It was about them surviving in a world where they are alone.I just felt like I needed to quote this, because it sums up exactly why I prefer Mirage to all the other versions of TMNT. It also sums up why I like the controversial Volume 4, because it plays with what happens when the Turtles aren't cut off from the world.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-03-2009, 07:18 AM
Shredder/Krang were in every single episode of Seasons 1-3 except for Rat King's debut episode.

Season 3 had some more episodes like that, like "Leatherhead Meets the Rat King".

TheShowstoppa
03-04-2009, 09:43 AM
I think when you look at the character of The Shredder, you have to realize that Issue 1 and issues 10 - Return to New York established him as the pivitol and high ranking elite villian in the TMNT universe. Even though they killed him off, he was established as their strongest adversary, and the Foot as being their ultimate rivalry. So, for the series' to hold him in regards and put him in many of the seasons, I think that's not rash or wrong. I think it was a smart decision on the part of 4Kids because he's the established main villian.

No matter what form he comes in, when many people think of TMNT and you ask them who the villian is, they say Shredder. 90% of people will tell you Joker for Batman, Lex Luthor for Superman, and Green Goblin for Spider-Man (if they have half a brain for things Spidey, the other top would be Doc Oc.)

CyberCubed
03-04-2009, 11:07 AM
That is true, but considering the 2k3 series couldn't live without him, I guess every future cartoon will always have Shredder.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-05-2009, 08:11 AM
I think when you look at the character of The Shredder, you have to realize that Issue 1 and issues 10 - Return to New York established him as the pivitol and high ranking elite villian in the TMNT universe. Even though they killed him off, he was established as their strongest adversary, and the Foot as being their ultimate rivalry. So, for the series' to hold him in regards and put him in many of the seasons, I think that's not rash or wrong. I think it was a smart decision on the part of 4Kids because he's the established main villian.

No matter what form he comes in, when many people think of TMNT and you ask them who the villian is, they say Shredder. 90% of people will tell you Joker for Batman, Lex Luthor for Superman, and Green Goblin for Spider-Man (if they have half a brain for things Spidey, the other top would be Doc Oc.)

Do you believe this: If issue 10 wasn't published, would the 1987 cartoon have less Shredder-episodes the following years?

Coola Yagami
03-05-2009, 08:39 AM
Or would the Shredder have been their main foe? Would the turtles have been fighting off Triceratons and Savanti instead?

rayfillet101
03-05-2009, 01:30 PM
my gripe is if it wasnt shredder(or family) or other main villians(bishop, triceritons, ultimate drakko) it usually was a filler episode. Garbageman and Nano, and possibly the mysterious entity were the only other built up villians. As a viewer, I cant take one shot villians as seriously as others.

TheShowstoppa
03-06-2009, 09:16 AM
Do you believe this: If issue 10 wasn't published, would the 1987 cartoon have less Shredder-episodes the following years?

I actually think it was part of Laird, Eastman, and Playmates along with Fred Wolf Flims that wanted the turtles to have a main villian. If you go back and look at the main cartoons from that era, everyone had a main villian. I think the major exception would be Ghostbusters.

Because Shredder was introduced in the first comic, and because that's what Splinter was training them for - The battle and eventual death of Shredder, it was a no brainer that they would make him the main villian.

I honestly think the old series was better off having shredder as a main villian. The news series, especially season one, was acceptionally great because of the build up and lead into The Shredder as a villian, and his first appearance (in costume) in the Shredder Strikes. That first season was AMAZING for many reasons.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-06-2009, 01:11 PM
I actually think it was part of Laird, Eastman, and Playmates along with Fred Wolf Flims that wanted the turtles to have a main villian. If you go back and look at the main cartoons from that era, everyone had a main villian. I think the major exception would be Ghostbusters.

Because Shredder was introduced in the first comic, and because that's what Splinter was training them for - The battle and eventual death of Shredder, it was a no brainer that they would make him the main villian.

I honestly think the old series was better off having shredder as a main villian. The news series, especially season one, was acceptionally great because of the build up and lead into The Shredder as a villian, and his first appearance (in costume) in the Shredder Strikes. That first season was AMAZING for many reasons.

I agree. Killing off Shredder would probably have been "too violent" for a 1980's cartoon.

Dan
03-10-2009, 04:38 PM
though I think the best BTTS concept was how scared Hun was of Shredder coming back and beating him soundly.
Really? Because that made no sense why Hun would be scared of someone he was loyal to.

CyberCubed
03-10-2009, 04:46 PM
Really? Because that made no sense why Hun would be scared of someone he was loyal to.

Why? Hun didn't like Shredder anymore when he found out he was an Utrom, and he knew that Khan and the Foot were trying to take territory away from the Purple Dragons.

Hun probably thought this was the same Shredder.

Cipher
03-10-2009, 05:51 PM
Really? Because that made no sense why Hun would be scared of someone he was loyal to.The Purple Dragons had split from the Foot and were taking over their territory. Hun had basically declared open war against them.

Leogeddon
03-10-2009, 05:58 PM
I agree. Killing off Shredder would probably have been "too violent" for a 1980's cartoon.

Well, killing him off can be done though. By transporting him into another spot in space through a worm hole, they can say they killed him but not directly.
They did however have a new villain toward the end of the old series from outer space. Forget his name though...

CyberCubed
03-10-2009, 06:51 PM
Shredder/Krang get lost in Dimension X by the end of the original cartoon anyway, and then Lord Dregg comes to Earth.

Shredder/Krang re-appear for a 3-parter in Season 10 and that's the last we see of them.

So technically they were in every season except for Season 9.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-11-2009, 08:44 AM
Well, killing him off can be done though. By transporting him into another spot in space through a worm hole, they can say they killed him but not directly.

Krang and Shredder ended up in Dimension X. I would like to see a final episode set in modern Japan and Shredder be caught by his baby brother Kazou Saki and sent to a prison in Japan. Nice place? Read: http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/ASA22/004/1998/en/dom-ASA220041998en.html.