PDA

View Full Version : It's a shame the Archie stuff is being re-printed in B&W


CyberCubed
03-18-2009, 12:52 PM
The Archie universe just isn't the same without color. The Turtles have different color bandanas, the villains are all nice and colorful, and its just more enjoyable in color.

It's a shame the old reprints and The Forever War will be in B&W.

How can I tell which Turtle is talking if their bandanas are not color-coded? In Mirage, they all have their weapons with them on all times which is how we can tell them apart. In Archie they don't always do that, and they're all drawn to look the same.

How would we know Slash had a black bandana if not for color? Or that Null was a tan demon? Or that Ninjara's fur was brown? Or that Armaggon was gray?

It just won't be the same. Maybe I'll buy two copies of these new Archie stuff, and "color" some of them on my own while keeping a extra copy of the original in mint condition.

Brodie
03-18-2009, 01:16 PM
Don't the archie books have their belts with the letters on them? You could tell that way.

When is this stuff getting reprinted, anyway?

Spitfire
03-18-2009, 01:17 PM
I'm very interested in seeing it printed in black and white. As much as I love color I have them all in color and unless their going to recolor it there's a lot of coloring errors in Archie where the ink is all messed up or something is colored wrong.

I think it comes out September. Or maybe that's forever war.

gobo
03-18-2009, 01:21 PM
Old news... Where have you been? We knew to expect this unfortunate detail for a year, I think it was. Why wait until now to break out the violin?
When is this stuff getting reprinted, anyway?
TMNT Future Tense

Ship Date: July 28, 2009

Format: 200 B&W pages, full color cover, soft cover trade paperback

Retail Price: $19.95

Cover art by Chris Allan; scripts by Dean Clarrain, art by Chris Allan, Paul D'Agostino and others

Mirage Studios' first trade paperback collection of Archie Comics' "TMNT Adventures," collecting 8 issues of the classic comic book series: #42-44 ("The Future Shark Trilogy") and #62-66 (the "Dreamland" 5-issue story arc). All issues feature the "future Turtles" and act as a lead-in to the upcoming all-new "Forever War" mini-series!

TristanHuwJones
03-18-2009, 03:23 PM
How would we know Slash had a black bandana if not for color? Or that Armaggon was gray?

You do realise how odd those two things sound in the context of what you're trying to say, don't you?

It just won't be the same. Maybe I'll buy two copies of these new Archie stuff, and "color" some of them on my own while keeping a extra copy of the original in mint condition.

In all seriousness, that would probably actually help raise the likelihood of seeing more Archie collections happen.

Archon_Turtle
03-18-2009, 03:49 PM
You do realise how odd those two things sound in the context of what you're trying to say, don't you?

I get it! LOL :rolling:

TristanHuwJones
03-18-2009, 04:14 PM
*cookie for Archon!

Jester
03-18-2009, 04:22 PM
Jester wants a cookie...Jester gets joke.

CyberCubed
03-18-2009, 04:52 PM
LOL, I didn't even mean for it to come out like that. :lol:

Cipher
03-18-2009, 06:55 PM
How would we know Slash had a black bandana if not for color? Or that Null was a tan demon? Or that Ninjara's fur was brown? Or that Armaggon was gray?The same way we know that the Turtles all wear red in the Mirage comics?

Seriously, if it bothers you that much, color it yourself. I might make a summer project out of it.

Andrew NDB
03-18-2009, 08:08 PM
Couldn't care less about the reprints in black and white, though it does strike me as odd that they wouldn't colorize the Forever War.

Roseangelo
03-18-2009, 08:10 PM
Couldn't care less about the reprints in black and white, though it does strike me as odd that they wouldn't colorize the Forever War.

It's not odd, it's stupid. But that's Gary for you.

IamtheKnight
03-18-2009, 08:19 PM
Why are you all gloom and doom?

gobo
03-18-2009, 08:31 PM
CyberCubed was just making an attempt at refreshing this outrage even though we've known about it for almost a year. His argument was almost comical though, hot what I'd call gloom and doom.

TMNT-Leonardo
03-18-2009, 08:35 PM
I wounder if they mean black and white by printing all the color pages in black and white, leaving gray tones and stuff that look odd, or black and white as in printing it using only the black and white inks part.

Forgive me if I sound confusing lol. But it doesn't really bother me, cause I would just be glad to get a hold of it.

Mr._Mutant_Man
03-18-2009, 08:37 PM
Old news... Where have you been? We knew to expect this unfortunate detail for a year, I think it was. Why wait until now to break out the violin?

Have you read the board lately? People are "breaking out the violin" about everything.

I'm not saying that some of it isn't deserved. The Archie reprints would be great in color, and that Shredder figure wasn't the greatest looking thing in the world. However, I still think the fans are lucky to be getting what we are getting. Who knew years ago that any of the comics would get reprinted, or the figures re-released, or that the franchise would be getting any attention at all? There are things to complain about, but there's some good stuff coming too.

Eiko
03-19-2009, 02:18 AM
It won,t be that bad im looking forward to them color or not i have most of the Archie turtle comics but most of them have fire damage from when my house burnt down.

Candy Kappa
03-19-2009, 03:01 AM
*cookie for Archon!

I got it too...:D

Coola Yagami
03-19-2009, 09:54 AM
I think what he means is... when it's Mirage, the guys drawing it already know it's gonna be black and white and all 4 turtles wear red, so they do the best they can with personalities and showing their weapons as much as they can so the reader can always know who is who.


But the Archie comics were in color and drawn with color in mind, so they can the turtles however they please, knowing their colors will set them apart. They had no idea their stories would be re-printed 10 years later in b&w. If all you see is one turtle's close-up without any defining features or dialogue or weapon being visible, while the artist takes for granted that it'll be in color, fast forward years later, same story is printed but in black and white.... how will the reader know which turtle is which?

Roseangelo
03-19-2009, 09:58 AM
I think what he means is... when it's Mirage, the guys drawing it already know it's gonna be black and white and all 4 turtles wear red, so they do the best they can with personalities and showing their weapons as much as they can so the reader can always know who is who.


But the Archie comics were in color and drawn with color in mind, so they can the turtles however they please, knowing their colors will set them apart. They had no idea their stories would be re-printed 10 years later in b&w. If all you see is one turtle's close-up without any defining features or dialogue or weapon being visible, while the artist takes for granted that it'll be in color, fast forward years later, same story is printed but in black and white.... how will the reader know which turtle is which?

I do think this is what was meant by the OP, but in the case of "Future Tense" all of the Future TMNT have defining features that will make it near impossible to be confused over who's who.

notebook
03-19-2009, 10:02 AM
what happened in the moon eyes story? that was the last storyline before the forever war. is teh year of teh turtle considered canon?

gobo
03-19-2009, 10:17 AM
is teh year of teh turtle considered canon?
No. That was impostor continuity added by the folks who actually worked at Archie.

CyberCubed
03-19-2009, 12:53 PM
I consider "Year of the Turtle" canon. Just because Murphy didn't write it doesn't mean it wasn't part of Archie continuity.

In that mini-series Splinter even says, "This is the last Turtle story. After this one you'll have heard them all."

It was obviously meant to bring closure to the book. It may not have been the way Murphy was going to end it, but it's canon nonetheless.

Although I'm curious as to what happens to Shredder after "The Forever War," because in "Year of the Turtle" Shredder is back in present day.

VaughnMichael
03-19-2009, 01:27 PM
No. That was impostor continuity added by the folks who actually worked at Archie.
YES!
I consider "Year of the Turtle" canon. Just because Murphy didn't write it doesn't mean it wasn't part of Archie continuity.

In that mini-series Splinter even says, "This is the last Turtle story. After this one you'll have heard them all."

It was obviously meant to bring closure to the book. It may not have been the way Murphy was going to end it, but it's canon nonetheless.

Although I'm curious as to what happens to Shredder after "The Forever War," because in "Year of the Turtle" Shredder is back in present day.
NO NO NO NO *Burne Thompson voice*

CyberCubed
03-19-2009, 02:07 PM
I gather the people who refuse to see "Year of the Turtle" as canon are people who have fanboy bias for Murphy or something.

It was clearly in the same continuity as everything that came before it. Hence Splinter being Hamato Yoshi, Shredder on his own with new henchmen (without Krang who was still on the toxic waste planet), and Mike loving pizza.

New creative team, same continuity. The only Archie books not canon are the movie adaptions, considering they're well...movie adaptions.

gobo
03-19-2009, 02:31 PM
Well, I didn't say Year Of The Turtle was an unworthy addition. But, it has been said that Forever War will disregard this unauthoritative miniseries. I took that to mean that if Forever War somehow makes it impossible for Year Of The Turtle to fit in continuity any longer, so be it. It's the same debate as which Mirage Vol. 1 issues are canon. Just because they were all official products does not make them all canon. You can consider Year Of The Turtle is just on a probationary period until the writers completely disown it (like Mirage and the Image Vol. 3), but the orthodox answer is that it's non-canonical.

CyberCubed
03-19-2009, 02:36 PM
As long as Shredder doesn't die in "The Forever War," I don't see how it could effect "Year of the Turtle."

And why would Splinter say, "This is the last Turtle story. After this one you'll have heard them all." if it wasn't intended to be closure?

Saying, "it's the last Turtle story" implies there was some huge epic storyline before it, which is clearly referencing the entire regular Archie run.

gobo
03-19-2009, 02:56 PM
Obviously... But, no one is arguing that it wasn't meant as closure, are they?

VaughnMichael
03-19-2009, 05:41 PM
I gather the people who refuse to see "Year of the Turtle" as canon are people who have fanboy bias for Murphy or something.

It was clearly in the same continuity as everything that came before it. Hence Splinter being Hamato Yoshi, Shredder on his own with new henchmen (without Krang who was still on the toxic waste planet), and Mike loving pizza.

New creative team, same continuity. The only Archie books not canon are the movie adaptions, considering they're well...movie adaptions.
Nope, while Murph is a good friend of mine I don't ever let that cloud my opinions of anyone's work, I'll flat out say when I don't like what someone is doing like allot of Lawsons art in recent years (though I think it's gotten allot better).

The archie series was to end with the forever war and that is how it is going to end.

The year of the turtle story was to be a new series that didn't have anything to do with the series that the orig. group worked on, but it sold very poorly and it was quickly ended with the 3 issue mini series.

CyberCubed
03-19-2009, 05:53 PM
It may have been intended that way, but it did wind up as proper closure to Archie. I know when I was a kid, after I got issue #72 in the mail (I had the monthly subscription back then), the next issue I got was "Year of the Turtle."

And in all seriousness, does it really matter? Year of the Turtle fits in perfectly with the Archie continuity, and I like the way Shredder's mind gets wiped at the end.

When "The Forever War" comes out, I'll consider that the ending of the regular Archie run, but I'll consider "Year of the Turtle" to be the final Archie story....if that makes any sense.

As long as Shredder isn't killed by Murphy then it'll fit right into the next story perfectly.

TristanHuwJones
03-19-2009, 05:59 PM
It may have been intended that way, but it did wind up as proper closure to Archie. I know when I was a kid, after I got issue #72 in the mail (I had the monthly subscription back then), the next issue I got was "Year of the Turtle."

And in all seriousness, does it really matter? Year of the Turtle fits in perfectly with the Archie continuity, and I like the way Shredder's mind gets wiped at the end.

When "The Forever War" comes out, I'll consider that the ending of the regular Archie run, but I'll consider "Year of the Turtle" to be the final Archie story....if that makes any sense.

As long as Shredder isn't killed by Murphy then it'll fit right into the next story perfectly.

So long as Shredder doesn't die in Forever War, you'll put it before Year of the Turtle in your collection. That's like me with my Mirage books -- probably got a few in there in places others either wouldn't have them usually, or wouldn't have at all.

Roseangelo
03-19-2009, 06:21 PM
No way is "Year of the Turtle" in the same continuity as the rest of Archie. There is absolutely nothing within the context of the story to even suggest this. Splinter having a human origin doesn't mean it's the Archie universe.

And why would Splinter say, "This is the last Turtle story. After this one you'll have heard them all." if it wasn't intended to be closure?

Saying, "it's the last Turtle story" implies there was some huge epic storyline before it, which is clearly referencing the entire regular Archie run.

The reason he says that is because in the context of the story he's telling Mike of all their stories as he slowly returns to his mutant state. He can't tell him any more because that would require telling him of future events that haven't even happened yet.

CyberCubed
03-19-2009, 07:14 PM
No way is "Year of the Turtle" in the same continuity as the rest of Archie. There is absolutely nothing within the context of the story to even suggest this. Splinter having a human origin doesn't mean it's the Archie universe.

Yet...there's nothing that contradicts it. Just because we didn't see a bunch of mutants running around in "Year of the Turtle" doesn't mean it wasn't in the same universe.

Ninjara had already broken up with Raph back in the "Moon Eyes" arc, which is why she wasn't there. April was a reporter, Splinter had his human origin, and Shredder was back on his own again in the present with new mercenaries after his failure in the future. Likewise how do you explain the Turtles/Splinter and Shredder already knowing each other if it were something new?

I honestly can't think of any reason why it can't take place, again assuming Shredder doesn't die in "The Forever War" which we'll have to wait and see.

It almost seems as if it angers some people that Archie hired a new creative team to wrap up the series instead of letting Murphy write it.

Are you honestly going to say the "Red Sky seasons" and Fast Forward/BTTS are not in the same universe as the original cartoon and TMNT 2k3 respectively? Because this is very similar to what you're implying. What is the difference between that and "Year of the Turtle" being published by Archie?

The reason he says that is because in the context of the story he's telling Mike of all their stories as he slowly returns to his mutant state. He can't tell him any more because that would require telling him of future events that haven't even happened yet.

Yeah, I know, but the way it was worded, and the fact that it wound up being the last story Archie published, makes it seem that way.

gobo
03-19-2009, 09:32 PM
The year of the turtle story was to be a new series that didn't have anything to do with the series that the orig. group worked on, but it sold very poorly and it was quickly ended with the 3 issue mini series.
Seriously?? O_o I seem to recall that even Previews was calling it a 3-ish mini before it was released. Do you mean like it was meant to be a miniseries to test the waters for the continuation of that continuity perhaps?
It almost seems as if it angers some people that Archie hired a new creative team to wrap up the series instead of letting Murphy write it.
I mostly get that it angers you that we won't consider it canon. Only other reason you'd even be arguing this point is for the sake of [insert definition of 'trolling' here]. I'm sure you have more class than that though. ;)

Roseangelo
03-20-2009, 12:33 AM
It almost seems as if it angers some people that Archie hired a new creative team to wrap up the series instead of letting Murphy write it.

As someone who actually read these books as they were published and knew NOTHING of the political climate at Mirage/Archie at the time, let alone really not knowing anything about "Dean Clarrain," I can absolutely guarantee you this is not the case. The series ended at book 72; this was always very clear to me. The "Year of the Turtle" mini-series was a bit of an afterthought and had no connection to the "Archie Universe" even though it was published by Archie.

Buslady
03-20-2009, 09:02 AM
Ahhhh be glad yer gettin it

CyberCubed
03-20-2009, 11:36 AM
So am I "wrong" in wanting to count "Year of the Turtle" in continuity with the Archie series?

When the Forever War comes out, I'm going to place it after issue #72 but before "Year of the Turtle" where I keep my comics. I suggest everyone do the same.

Ninjinister
03-20-2009, 01:08 PM
You can place it in your own personal canon if you want; nobody's going to stop you. There are issues of the Mirage that I have in my 'personal canon' that seem to have been rejected for canon by Laird and/or the world at large. But to try to force it on other people is ludicrous.

sdp
03-20-2009, 05:05 PM
Archie Fanboys? In my Technodrome?

No way.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-20-2009, 08:16 PM
It's like the movie "Schindler's List". It was black-and-white even if it came out in 1993 (according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schindler%27s_List). How fun would the TMNT cartoons be in black-and-white?

Andrew NDB
03-20-2009, 09:14 PM
Obviously... But, no one is arguing that it wasn't meant as closure, are they?

I'll argue that. "Year of the Turtle" wasn't meant for closure in any way, shape, or form... it was a relaunch mini intended to drum interest back up in the Archie TMNT... but it tanked pretty badly.

It was literally touted as "A New Beginning!"

gobo
03-21-2009, 05:16 AM
There are issues of the Mirage that I have in my 'personal canon' that seem to have been rejected for canon by Laird and/or the world at large.
My own personal canon is where I keep my bowling balls.

darthsmozers
03-23-2009, 08:48 AM
Old news... Where have you been? We knew to expect this unfortunate detail for a year, I think it was. Why wait until now to break out the violin?

your quote with the details of Future Tense prompted me to look at the Books of the Future page on ninjaturtles.com. Thank you! Because I see a nice new piece of Chris Allan artwork there :D

CyberCubed
03-23-2009, 06:26 PM
Is "The Forever War" even going to have the present day Turtles in it?

Or does it only have the Future TMNT fighting Shredder? Did Murphy ever say anything about this?

darthsmozers
03-24-2009, 07:58 AM
Is "The Forever War" even going to have the present day Turtles in it?

Or does it only have the Future TMNT fighting Shredder? Did Murphy ever say anything about this?

Good question. The original cover artwork showed "present-day" characters, and the original opening pages posted on Murphy's blog contained the present day turtles and Splinter. But any of that could be subject to change.... ?

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
03-24-2009, 08:26 AM
Good question. The original cover artwork showed "present-day" characters, and the original opening pages posted on Murphy's blog contained the present day turtles and Splinter. But any of that could be subject to change.... ?

I belive at least the "present" will appear.

Spitfire
03-24-2009, 01:09 PM
I'll argue that. "Year of the Turtle" wasn't meant for closure in any way, shape, or form... it was a relaunch mini intended to drum interest back up in the Archie TMNT... but it tanked pretty badly.

It was literally touted as "A New Beginning!"

So will I. I hardly saw anything that made it feel like a closing. It came out several months after the series had ended and like Andrew said felt more like an attempt to breath life back into the series. The series ended with a story of them as young kids and Forever War being meant to end it all just seemed fitting.

The fact we're getting it rules and I personally love that it's gonna be in black and white. We've seen Archie in color before, personally I've always wanted to see it black and white.