PDA

View Full Version : Deaths of the TMNT


Cipher
03-22-2009, 02:21 AM
This discussion began in another thread, but I think it deserves it's own topic. Looking at all the evidence in the Mirage continuity, what do you think is the order of the Turtles' deaths.

Here's where I stand on the Turtles' lifespans: Raph, Mike, Leo, Don. The hugest pieces in the argument are the Tales collected book frontispieces and a few allusions in various Tales issues.

About Raph. We know he continues to fight after the other Turtles, taking on Foot robots in Tokyo, hunting in the swamp, etc. In the Tales fronispieces, he appears far younger than any of the other Turtles. I know some people have said "Maybe that's just the last they saw of him." But I highly doubt that Lawson sat down with such a complicated intent when the most obvious conclusion from the drawings is that Rapheal died at a younger age.

It suits the series thematically as well, to have continued violence lead to a violent end. Every single violent or vengeful character in TMNT has either calmed themselves or met some horrible end. It's a running motif.

Mike's a mystery. We don't even know if he'll return home from his current star voyage. Future Raph ends Tales #55 by saying "Good night, Mikey. Wherever you are." The issue then ends with a picture of the moon. This could imply any number of things. Perhaps Raph has severed contact with his brothers. Perhaps Mikey is on an extended space voyage or never returns (although old Mikey's appearence in Donatello's hologram implies that he does return to Earth at some point).

Of all the Turtles, we have the most information on Leo's life. His entire journey from middle-age to old-age is revealed in Tales #41, "Swan Song" and #13-14, "Loops." We know he travels the world for years after Radical's death, and attains a state of zen like peace after killing Complete Carnage. On his 100th birthday, Donatello gives him a techno-katana. He continues to meditate in a hut outside a major city, and vows never to take another life. At the end of "Loops," Leonardo solioquizes that no one can cheat death. "Not even a Turtle. Not as far as I know." Plainly visible in the background are two tombstones. It's easy to read this as implying only he and Donatello are left alive. Their peaceful lifestyles support this as well.

Donatello is all guess work. But from his sullen, lonesome demeanor in "Plastron Cafe" and the Tales collected book, it seems clear that he's the last of his kind. He has a virtual reunion with his brothers, and Renet cries just watching him. I don't know how less subtle they could be about it.

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 03:32 AM
Here's what I honestly think. Leonardo is the first to bite the dust. Raphael dying first is just way too obvious. I think the thing with Raph is, the more he fights, the better he is at it. Which it is in reality. You get your ass kicked, but you eventually wise up and learn where your faults are. I think Leo's decision to stop killing will be his undoing.

We know Don goes blind, but we also know that Don is somewhat against the life chosen by Raph and Leo, who clearly continue fighting to an extent after Don does. I think Don's yearning to continue going back to Northampton instead of staying in NYC (as expressed in #55) is a good example of this, and the fact that he is on his own further down the road is another. His longing for a reunion with his brothers could mean a couple of things. It could very well mean that they're all dead, but it could also mean that something terrible happened and the likelihood of them ever reuniting is virtually non-existent. It could be that either Mike or Leo was killed and that tore them all apart. It might not even have anything to do with the brothers or their deaths, but something else altogether.

We know Mikey goes missing at somepoint, and that Raph has no idea what happened to him. The implication being that he's amongst the stars, but all this could be before any of them have died. Raph seems to be on a flooded earth. The same thing could be implied by the Leatherhead issue (the Turtle toddler story bookends). I'm not sure which Turtle that is, I assume it's Don, but that could even be the same flooded Earth, but a number of years down the track and somewhere else on the flooded globe. Then again, it could be an entirely different planet.

I'm standing by Raph outliving all the others, but as I said, I don't want to say why just yet. Someone will come across it the same way I did, and it really is smack-your-head-obvious when you see it. It's like poisons or toxins, or just about anything that kills you in that respect -- the more you expose yourself to it in controlled doses, the less damage you take each time after.

Ninjinister
03-22-2009, 03:55 AM
I'm standing by Raph outliving all the others, but as I said, I don't want to say why just yet. Someone will come across it the same way I did, and it really is smack-your-head-obvious when you see it. It's like poisons or toxins, or just about anything that kills you in that respect -- the more you expose yourself to it in controlled doses, the less damage you take each time after.

Please tell me you're not talking about Road Hogs....

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 04:08 AM
**** no. Something happens to Raph in the current time line. It isn't something that's seen in the future stuff.

Ryona
03-22-2009, 04:26 AM
I have to go with Cipher's list.

Raph is easily the first one to kick the bucket because of his bad habits such as leaping before he looks. You can only be lucky for so long. I see him getting killed rather young.

Mikey I'm totally uncertain with him.

Leo definetly lives right into old age, and I'm certain that he passes away by natural death like Splinter rather than getting killed like Raph (and posibly Mikey).

Don I'm betting he uses science to help extend his life, which makes him the last mutant turtle, as suggested by that one comic story Cipher mentioned.


I think Leo's decision to stop killing will be his undoing.


That's absolutely ridiculous. Considering the martial arts master.. no, martial arts god that Leo becomes after 100 years of worldy training and experience, is more than enough to make Leo pretty much untouchable and a force to be reckoned with by anyone on Earth, even if he chooses to subdue rather than kill.
He developes an unnatural level of ESP, and he can even levitate for crying out loud (among other abilities he may have that are not revealed to us). He's pretty much on a super-human level.

The fact that Leo chooses to never kill again may very well be not only a humanitarian decision, but also a decision made because he's simply powerful enough that he doesn't have to kill what isn't a threat to him anymore.

Vivi
03-22-2009, 04:51 AM
I can see Mikey dying young, as has been mentioned before in these forums. His nature is too sweet, the loss would be the driving force behind the turtles separation. At a time much later, Leonardo will fight a final battle, but allow himself to be killed when realising his time to join his brothers has come.

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 05:04 AM
I have to go with Cipher's list.

Raph is easily the first one to kick the bucket because of his bad habits such as leaping before he looks. You can only be lucky for so long. I see him getting killed rather young.

He also learns from his mistakes. You look at EVERYTHING that's happened to Raph. EVERY time he's gone off on his own, he's turned up trumps. Every time Leo says he's being stupid, he comes out on top. It's always close, but he always comes out on top.

Leo definetly lives right into old age, and I'm certain that he passes away by natural death like Splinter rather than getting killed like Raph (and posibly Mikey).

I'd say it, but I'd blow it. I want to see who figures it out. Raph can, and likely will, outlive the others.

Don I'm betting he uses science to help prolong his life, which makes him the last mutant turtle, as suggested by that one comic story Cipher mentioned.

It's never suggested he's the last one. It's suggested that he doesn't see his brothers for an extended amount of time. You're assuming he's the last one based on what you see. There are a number of interpretations. You'd also think that if he could use science to prolong his life, he'd use science to keep his vision. Clearly he doesn't.

That's absolutely ridiculous. Considering the martial arts master.. no, martial arts god that Leo becomes after 100 years of worldy training and experience, is more than enough to make Leo pretty much untouchable and a force to be reckoned with by anyone on Earth, even if he chooses to subdue rather than kill.

It's pretty well established that the Turtles are constantly up against things that AREN'T of this Earth. Saying "that's absolutely ridiculous" is absolutely ridiculous.

He developes an unnatural level of ESP, and he can even levitate for crying out loud. He's pretty much on a super-human level.

Splinter could levitate. A heart attack got him (from the looks of things). So he's super-human... so was Superman. Along came Doomsday and the dude got his ass served.

Ninjinister
03-22-2009, 05:12 AM
You seem to be quite adamant about this, Tristan. Other than this thing with Raph you keep alluding to, there's got to be something that you know that we don't....

Ryona
03-22-2009, 05:15 AM
He also learns from his mistakes. You look at EVERYTHING that's happened to Raph. EVERY time he's gone off on his own, he's turned up trumps. Every time Leo says he's being stupid, he comes out on top. It's always close, but he always comes out on top.

When it comes to Leo, I'm usually a little biased because he's my fave, but I always go strictly be facts as well.

That said, I do believe you're being biased with Raph. I mean honestly... Raph the last one to die? There's simply no way. Raph's way of doing things is like a constant game of Russion roullette. He's been lucky many times, but his mentality is going to get him killed one day.
Warriors like Raph are the expendable type. They're amazing at war, but life of valor are always short. They either die young, or they retire young and live long.


I'd say it, but I'd blow it. I want to see who figures it out. Raph can, and likely will, outlive the others.

That above statement just shouts BIASED RAPH FAN.

You're a fan of Raph. That's cool. But Saying he'll outlive the others is really pushing it. It's your opinion and that's fine... but... come on...

Are we talking about the right Raph? Mirage Raph? Because really, the only Raph I could see outliving any of the other turtles is the Raph from the original 80s tv series. That Raph is the only one of all the Raphs who is level-headed and cool under fire.

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 05:19 AM
You seem to be quite adamant about this, Tristan. Other than this thing with Raph you keep alluding to, there's got to be something that you know that we don't....

Nope, it's right there in Volume 4, this Raph thing. I'm just going by what's in the books, but ultimately you have to look beyond what's actually on the page. What's there on the page is just the face value stuff. If you read into it, certain things become rather obvious, especially with Raph. I was actually kicking myself when I picked up on the Raph thing, because I couldn't believe it didn't hit me earlier.

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 05:30 AM
When it comes to Leo, I'm usually a little biased because he's my fave, but I always go strictly be facts as well.

Fair enough, but in all honesty, I'm totally Mike biased. If I had my way, he'd be the one that outlives all of them, which he may, nobody knows...

That said, I do believe you're being biased with Raph. I mean honestly... Raph the last one to die? There's simply no way.
Raph's way of doing things is like a constant game of Russion roullette.[/QUOTE] Not really. If it weren't for Raph, they probably would've had a much harder time taking down the Foot in Return to New York. He's the one that turned Zog into a weapon for them.

but his mentality is going to get him killed one day.

But who's it say he doesn't realise that? And who is to say that that day is before all the other turtles? Most warriors realise they're expendable, but they also get better at what they're doing. It's just a matter of knowing your enemy, and the only REAL way you can do that is by taking him on. Look at the Punisher. That mother****er should be dead. Based on the **** he does EVERY day, he should be dead, but it's reached the point where he's so good at it that, yeah he might take a hiding every now and then, but he knows what he has to do to get by it. I think Raph is very similar. I think he's strong willed enough that he would keep going simply through sheer force of will.

Also, now that I think about it, Raph is very similar to Bruce Wayne in his early days as Batman. Batman learnt how to fight villains, how to be smart about it. There's nothing to suggest that Raph can't do the same.

Anyway, this is all hypothetical, and ultimately boils down to whoever writes these things. As it stands, I am adamant that if all the Turtles were to throw down their arms and go into peaceful lives, Raph would still outlive his brothers by a mile. I am also equally as adamant, that unless he gives his own life, or a villain becomes REALLY clever, he will be the last to die. And this isn't based on something I have cooking as a writer, or something I've heard from inside Mirage, this is based on something that's happened in the comics themselves that everyone's overlooked (c'mon Cipher, you should have this by now :P!)

Ryona
03-22-2009, 05:45 AM
Your argument is pretty frail, and this is why...

First off, they're all warriors, all doing the same thing. Training in the arts, and kicking ass on the side for experience. Your speech there makes it sound like Raph is the only one who trains and fights.

Secondly, Raph would obviously become a better warrior over time, I'll give you that. But so will ALL of the ninja turtles. So again, you're singling out Raph as the only warrior of the four.

Third, Raph's tough, but Don's smart, and hell, Leo is both tough and smart. Raph might survive past Mikey (though Mikey is actually smarter than Raph), but Raph has extremely little chance to survive past Leo and Don. Your mind is your best weapon, and Leo and Don beats Raph in that department by miles. On top of that, Leo is simply a better warrior than Raph. This is FACT and this is CANON. It's undebatable.

Fourth, if the other turtles retire while Raph continues, this simply means that the odds of the other turtles dying first are extremely slim since they don't live dangerous lives anymore, where as Raph would still continue a dangerous lifestyle and have a high chance of getting killed, thus giving Raph great odds that he'll go first.

Simply put, chances of Raph being the last one to die are about as equal as you or I winning a free trip to the moon this week.



Oh, and saying Raph will live long because he's similar to characters like The Punisher, who happens to survive all sorts of **** is simply weak. There's a reason why characters like The Punisher never die. Because they're the bloody main character! Main characters almost never die. And if they do die, they're always brought back to life with some far-fetched solution.

Scandia
03-22-2009, 06:18 AM
Tristan- Are you talking about when Raph gets turned into a Gamera?

Anyhow, I still think Don is the last one to die.

However, something strikes me as Mikey dying first, then Raph, then Leo, and finally Donnie.

Ryona
03-22-2009, 06:30 AM
I could actually see a posibility of Mikey dying before Raph. Only because he can be rather careless. Odds are Raph will surely die first, but there is that little chance that Mikey might go first.
Leo and Don will obviously be the last ones to go. It's the way of nature... The smartest and wisest of any givin species are typicly the ones who survive.

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 06:44 AM
I want to make it VERY clear here that I'm not taking shots at you here, and there's no hard feelings or anything, this is just a difference of opinions. We're not calling each other idiots or anything here.

Excuse me for saying this and excuse the language, but that's quite a load of horseshit.
First off, they're all warriors, all doing the same thing. Training in the arts, and kicking ass on the side for experience. Your speech there makes it sound like Raph is the only one who does that.

He certainly seems to do it a lot more than the others. It's a very clear trait of his character that he actually enjoys going out, be it with Casey or his brothers, and kicking ass in the downtime between training.

Secondly, Raph would obviously become a better warrior over time, I'll give you that. But so will ALL of the ninja turtles. So again, you're singling out Raph as the only warrior of the four.

It's pretty well established in #55 of Tales that Don wants nothing to do with the NYC lifestyle anymore. That he thinks they're better off in Northampton.

Third, Raph's tough, but Don's smart, and hell, Leo is both tough and smart. Raph might survive past Mikey (though Mikey is actually smarter than Raph), but Raph has extremely little chance to survive past Leo and Don. Your mind is your best weapon, and Leo and Don beats Raph in that department by miles. On top of that, Leo is simply a better warrior than Raph. This is FACT and this is CANON. It's undebatable.

If it came down to the Turtles fighting each other to the death, then I'd agree with you, but it doesn't matter how good you are or how smart you are, there's always a bigger fish. A lot of what happens in life ultimately comes down to chance, so just because one is better than the other doesn't mean that he'll outlive the other.

If you want to go by what's fact and what's canon:
Leo was beaten nearly to death by the Foot in his one shot. Raph is caught under similar circumstances (being hunted by the Foot) in #19, and he deals with them pretty easily. In that same issue, Raph beats Leo, hand-to-hand in the opening pages.

Yes, Raph takes on the Elite and fails, Leo cleans up what's left, but then we jump forward to City at War. Leo gets is subdued and captured by Karai and a group of regular old Foot Ninjas. I'd also argue that what Raph does when he gets caught by the chain and jumps off the edge of the broken flooring is pretty smart fighting. Especially after one pulled the same stunt with the chains earlier (Raph also beat the Elite that caught him off guard too).

There's also The Survival Game, in which Raph outsmarts all his brothers (taking Leo down first by the way).

Based on what's there in the comics, I'd say that in the early days, they're fairly even when it comes to fighting abilities.

But the fact remains; there's something that happens in volume 4 that can be backed up by the Collected Tales openers that indicates that Raph can and most likely will outlive the others. This isn't opinion, it's something that's right there on the page, and unless Peter completely eradicates this in his last few issues of Volume 4, it stands up pretty solidly.

Fourth, if the other turtles retire while Raph continues, this simply means that the odds of the other turtles dying first are extremely slim since they don't live dangerous lives anymore, where as Raph would still continue a dangerous lifestyle and have a high chance of getting killed, thus giving Raph great odds that he'll go first.

Is that likely to stop a villain with a vendetta though? If the others retire, they fall out of form. Someone or something could get to them first and they might be helpless. At least Raph, doing his thing would have that edge. He'd more than likely be fitter, and again, what happened to him is likely to see him come out on top, no matter how bad the beating he takes (unless, as I said, the villain is clever).

Simply put, chances of Raph being the last one to die are about as equal as you or I winning a free trip to the moon this week.

You can't say that. Ultimately, the decision isn't up to either of us. Reread Volume 4. It's right there. Plain as day.

Oh, and saying Raph will live long because he's similar to characters like The Punisher, who happens to survive all sorts of **** is simply weak. There's a reason why characters like The Punisher never die. Because they're the bloody main character! Main characters almost never die. And if they do die, they're always brought back to life with some far-fetched solution.

I think it's valid. Since when has Raph not been a main character? It wouldn't be hard to replace the Punisher. It won't happen, but it wouldn't be hard. Batman just got killed. He'll be back of course, but they're filling his shoes for the time being. It's just the fanbase that keeps these characters who they are. Any costumed hero can have a legacy. A ninja Turtle, not so much. Unless Raph is cloned or has kids of course...

funatic
03-22-2009, 06:54 AM
As it stands, I am adamant that if all the Turtles were to throw down their arms and go into peaceful lives, Raph would still outlive his brothers by a mile. I am also equally as adamant, that unless he gives his own life, or a villain becomes REALLY clever, he will be the last to die. And this isn't based on something I have cooking as a writer, or something I've heard from inside Mirage, this is based on something that's happened in the comics themselves that everyone's overlooked

Gee thanks Tristan, now you have me examining vol 4 with a fine-toothed comb. Making a turtles fan re-read his comics, just shameful... are you sure this isn't just a gimmick to boost interest before issue 30 comes out? :P

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 06:57 AM
I promise you it's not. It's just a ridiculous coincidence that this conversation came up the day after I realised what I did. I have absolutely no idea what happens in Vol.4. All I know is that Peter said that something like two scenes take place, and that it's pretty much Mike centric (if I remember right)...

funatic
03-22-2009, 07:15 AM
Don't worry, I believe you... :tshifty:

I've been scaning the issues these last few minutes and am already coming up with wild theories about vampire immortality & robot host-bodies... though it might hurt my case that I don't have the Collected Tales bits to compare and contrast.

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 07:39 AM
To be honest, the only Future Raph stuff we've really seen was him on the rooftop in Tales #55, him up against an aged Karai in #40, and the same Jacket-Cap-Eyepatched Raph appearing MUCH younger than his brothers in a few of the openers of the new Tales Collection. He appears the same in a holographic simulation of a reunion they must share at some point. Actually, now that I think about it and look closer at that particular part of the story, I don't think Don is actually blind. The can could just be a balance thing, and a holographic simulation of something would be kind of redundant to a blind individual...

Cipher
03-22-2009, 11:31 AM
I am also equally as adamant, that unless he gives his own life, or a villain becomes REALLY clever, he will be the last to die. And this isn't based on something I have cooking as a writer, or something I've heard from inside Mirage, this is based on something that's happened in the comics themselves that everyone's overlooked (c'mon Cipher, you should have this by now :P!)Jesus, Tristan, a guy's gotta sleep eventually.

I've read through Volume 4 at least a twice, and I just can't think of anything that implies Raph will outlive the others, unless violent aggression and bodily mutations are theraputic. I haven't seen anything that has made me change my mind yet, and for the most part I've agreed with Ryona's posts.

For the sake of discussion (and this has become a pretty good one), why don't you share your epiphany with us?

It's pretty well established in #55 of Tales that Don wants nothing to do with the NYC lifestyle anymore. That he thinks they're better off in Northampton.Are you thinking of the right issue? Tales #55 is placed years before they first go to Northampton.

oldmanwinters
03-22-2009, 12:52 PM
The only thing I can speculate on with any degree of support is that Michelangleo is most likely to die first, according the morbid statement of Splinter in Tales 2.9

The obvious choice is that Raph's recklessness finally does him in first but I think he gains the strong mental fortitude through his fighting. I think old Raph would be significantly craftier than young Raph, as evidenced by his Future Archie counterpart.

PAAATE
03-22-2009, 12:57 PM
I've read through Volume 4 at least a twice, and I just can't think of anything that implies Raph will outlive the others

I too read it once quickly and the only thing I found is that Splinter's spirit managed to calm down Raph after his continued mutation... You (Tristan) previously wrote something about Raph possibly calming down, and all that... At least I think you did, I didn't really feel like reading through the topic again before posting, but yeah... Anyway, I assume this isn't what you mean, since it would be kinda far-fetched to say that he'll outlive the others because of that...

For the sake of discussion (and this has become a pretty good one), why don't you share your epiphany with us?

Um.. Agreed.. I can't have any rest until I know wtf you're talking about :dead:

Ryona
03-22-2009, 02:41 PM
I want to make it VERY clear here that I'm not taking shots at you here, and there's no hard feelings or anything, this is just a difference of opinions. We're not calling each other idiots or anything here.

I'm aware of that. This is simply a debate we're having of clashing opinions.

I want to add that my opinions are strongly supported by logic and the general nature of things according to animal nature (humans included).

Raph has always been a rather difficult member of the team with his poor habits and behavior.
In the animal kingdom, if a member of a pack is being difficult, they typicly get disowned by the pack or killed by the alpha. And once the outcast is off on their own, they typicly die soon after because of their weak habits and recklessness.

I understand that your opinion that Raph will outlast the others is based off of some hunch that you personally believe to have encrypted in volume 4 (and I do believe also fueled by some degree of biased favoritism), but if you will, for a moment, let's step out of the realm of fantasy and take a walk in the realm of reality...
Realisticly speaking, warriors like Raph are the expendable type and typicaly die young. Raph's way of doing things, and his inability to function well in a team, as well as his reckless superman delusions that he can't be killed is actually going to get him killed.

I also want to add that, in the battlefeild, I do believe that the one to have the best odds to survive is Leo. You go on about Raph like he's the best in the group, but you and I both know very well that Leo is simply the superior warrior.
There's a reason why he's Splinter's star pupil and why Splinter asigned Leo as the clan leader.
Leo is far more skilled, far smarter, has keener senses, weilds far more deadlier weapons, and Leo is also a master tactition & strategist.
He's also the only one who's ever been a real threat to Shredder (killing him solo even), and Leo is a natural born warrior.
Also, the fact that Leo is the alpha male says enough, as the alpha of any pack is always the most powerful member. Otherwise they wouldn't be the alpha!

That said, I want to add that Don is most likely the second one to survive in the battlefeild.
Don and Raph basicly have the same amont of training. The way they use it is the real difference.
Raph's method is "As long as I'm agressive and forceful, I'll get through anything".
Don's method is "As long as I stay one step ahead of my oponent by making smart, careful dessions, I'll get through anything".
I think it's safe to say that if early humanity, as a whole, did things the way Raph would do, we'd still be in the stone age or extinct even.

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 03:24 PM
I don't want to to give away too much, because I'm working an idea up around it, but I'm talking about something that is biological. It has nothing to do with who the better fighter is in the end, or how someone lives there life. Ultimately it comes down to what Peter chooses to do with it, but it really is right there. Once you see it, and think about it, you'll see where I'm going... it has something to do with his secondary mutation.

PAAATE
03-22-2009, 04:10 PM
I don't want to to give away too much, because I'm working an idea up around it, but I'm talking about something that is biological. It has nothing to do with who the better fighter is in the end, or how someone lives there life. Ultimately it comes down to what Peter chooses to do with it, but it really is right there. Once you see it, and think about it, you'll see where I'm going... it has something to do with his secondary mutation.

I really hope Peter reads this and just goes "Wtf is that Aussie talking about?" :P

TristanHuwJones
03-22-2009, 04:33 PM
I really hope Peter reads this and just goes "Wtf is that Aussie talking about?" :P

I think he might already know (considering he wrote it in there)...

PAAATE
03-22-2009, 04:38 PM
I think he might already know (considering he wrote it in there)...

Yeah, but since you're not telling what it is I don't know whether it's something that he meant to write, or if it's something you found that you think is the key... :P

Buuut... I guess it's the former... Or at least you think it is... Now I'll read V4 again.. o.o

RossMay
03-22-2009, 05:21 PM
While I follow the future snapshots and stories like everyone else and understand the interest, I think the true end of the turtles is something even farther away from the futures we've seen.

Being an optimist, while I know the turtles split up, I think there's something happy for them after what we've seen too.

oldmanwinters
03-22-2009, 06:39 PM
Alright, Tristan, I've got a theory on why Raph will outlive the rest of the turtles. I'll PM you to see if I'm right.

Cipher
03-23-2009, 03:44 PM
Tristan, I have also PM'd you to see if I've caught your line of thinking.

And holy hell, I just noticed that Don is blind in the epilogue of the Tales book. Or at least, he seems to be. He's the only one drawn without pupils, he's placing his finger on the book in the first page (a la braille), and at the end he walks with his cane far in front of him like a blind person.

Candy Kappa
03-24-2009, 03:44 AM
reading the collected tales book, I thought the first one to hit the bucket was Raph, mike, leo and then Don.

but I don't think they'll had an unatural death, I just think they'll outlived each other, like Raph getting in his late 70-80's, mikey round his 90's leo get over 100 and donny might get 120's or something.

It also (for me) it seems like Don are passing away when he falls to sleep when Renet are there.

Leo dying of a heartattack would be fitting since he was more like Splinter.

Raph would go grinning, it'd suit him to die smilling regreting nothing.

discordiatookie
03-26-2009, 02:54 PM
Y'know, I never hit upon Don being blind on they Tales frontispieces. I can see how it can be interpreted that way, but i'm not 100% convinced. And in my opinion, just because Raph looks younger than the others in the simulation, doesn't mean he died years before the others. Perhaps its based on when Don seen him last. Or, for all we know, a side effect from going from Gamera Raph back to normal.

Also, and this is from memory, (i'm at my sisters and don't have the book in front of me,) but we don't know for sure that the simulation is based on what the turtles looked like when, or around they died. Could it be that it was a simulation of an event that actually happened? The last time that they were all together, happy and alive? Their final reunion?

Its all about interpretation, I believe.

Rooish
05-14-2009, 02:44 PM
Woah! I had to bump this because it's super intriguing.

Tristin, I currently agree with Cipher for all the reasons he mentioned, but I will read Vol. 4 to find your clue. Will someone PM me, though, if it's in issues 22, 25, or 26? Because I don't own those so I shouldn't bother.

plastroncafe
05-14-2009, 08:05 PM
Okay first off I haven't re-read the whole series in a very long time, so it's more likely than not that my facts and memories are all...messed up.

It was always my belief that Raph outlives everyone. Not because of some secondary mutation that's only now seeing print, and not because he's a better fighter than his brothers, but because the jerk is just too stubborn to die.

Time and again we get images of future Raph, and every single one of them, Archie included, have him missing an eye and horribly scarred. In two instances we see him in the Bayou wearing a straw hat.

Why is he there when we have images of Don in Japan and Leo living in New York? Because Mike is the first to die. How he dies, I have no idea. But in life he is one of the few things that keep Don, Leo, and Raph together. Without Mike the three of them would drift off without even noticing they're doing it. They're just...too different, there's nothing to ground them.

I really do need to re-read the books to see about this Don being Blind thing. I love little Easter Egg touches in books.

My question for the the thread is this:
Do you consider the RPGs to be canon source material?

Rooish
05-14-2009, 09:27 PM
I consider the character descriptions to be fairly spot-on in the RPG source material. They could always be expanded on, of course, but they are a fairly good foundation for the character's personalities. Some of the ability scores are a bit wonky, though. From what I recall, Mike's "physical attractiveness" score is like 15 and Raph's is 5, or something. Dude, they are giant mutated Turtles. Except for a few extra scars here or there, they probably would look about the same! I can't imagine that much variation in attractiveness.

Anyway, this speculation thing isn't working very well. Back in the day, when I imagined writing some sort of TMNT fan fiction, I thought the death order would be Leo first (in some self-sacrificing or against unbeatable odds way), then Mike (probably some accident), then Raph (he doesn't have much to live for with Mike and Leo gone), then Don. I do think the order implied in the collected Tales Vol. 1 indicates the order is Raph, then Mike, then Leo, then Don. I can definitely see why Don and Leo would live a long time.

It's not implausible to me that Mike dies first, though, because we haven't seen much of his future. I hope they all live to at least 100 though. :)

I wouldn't have expected Raph to live longest, but maybe his discontented spirit would keep him fighting to live for a very long time. I'd love to know Tristan's theory but don't really know if I could stomach reading Vol. 4 all the way through (not that I dislike it, but there's a lot of different plot threads and I don't know in which one I would find this clue to Raph's longevity. Or immortality? Someone's gotta tell me).

Ryona
05-14-2009, 10:04 PM
It was always my belief that Raph outlives everyone. Not because of some secondary mutation that's only now seeing print, and not because he's a better fighter than his brothers, but because the jerk is just too stubborn to die.

Buddy, are you a complete newbie to TMNT, or just delusional?
Every TMNT fan knows that Leo is the best fighter. This is fact and this is canon.
My god... pay attention.

plastroncafe
05-14-2009, 10:14 PM
Buddy, are you a complete newbie to TMNT, or just delusional?
Every TMNT fan knows that Leo is the best fighter. This is fact and this is canon.
My god... pay attention.

7/10
Cute, but overall just average.

Ryona
05-14-2009, 10:21 PM
http://img31.imageshack.us/img31/3719/blankstare.jpg

Rooish
05-14-2009, 10:22 PM
Buddy, are you a complete newbie to TMNT, or just delusional?
Every TMNT fan knows that Leo is the best fighter. This is fact and this is canon.
My god... pay attention.

Um ... you notice how he said "NOT because Raph is the best fighter"?

Ryona
05-14-2009, 10:23 PM
Her wording suggested that she was implying that Raph is the better fighter than his brothers, which is false.

and not because he's a better fighter than his brothers,

plastroncafe
05-14-2009, 10:27 PM
Her wording suggested that she was implying that Raph is the better fighter than his brothers, which is false.

I believe the word you're looking for there is "debatable", not "false."

Ryona
05-14-2009, 10:30 PM
Actually no, it's not debatable. It's fact and canon.

Suggesting that Raph is a better fighter than Leo is just as absurd as suggesting that Hun is a better fighter than Shredder.

plastroncafe
05-14-2009, 10:34 PM
Um ... you notice how he said "NOT because Raph is the best fighter"?

Really what I was doing was riffing on stuff other people had said in order to set up my punchline, but thanks for the assist just the same.

:-)

Rooish
05-14-2009, 11:01 PM
Sorry for saying you're a "he" though ... I was lazy and didn't check. I'm female too. :)

plastroncafe
05-14-2009, 11:12 PM
Sorry for saying you're a "he" though ... I was lazy and didn't check. I'm female too. :)

Hee, no problem. Not to worry.

TristanHuwJones
05-14-2009, 11:55 PM
Actually no, it's not debatable. It's fact and canon.

You said that before, but you seem to have ignored what I said in response to that:

If you want to go by what's fact and what's canon:
Leo was beaten nearly to death by the Foot in his one shot. Raph is caught under similar circumstances (being hunted by the Foot) in #19, and he deals with them pretty easily. In that same issue, Raph beats Leo, hand-to-hand in the opening pages.

Yes, Raph takes on the Elite and fails, Leo cleans up what's left, but then we jump forward to City at War. Leo gets is subdued and captured by Karai and a group of regular old Foot Ninjas. I'd also argue that what Raph does when he gets caught by the chain and jumps off the edge of the broken flooring is pretty smart fighting. Especially after one pulled the same stunt with the chains earlier (Raph also beat the Elite that caught him off guard too).

There's also The Survival Game, in which Raph outsmarts all his brothers (taking Leo down first by the way).

Based on what's there in the comics, I'd say that in the early days, they're fairly even when it comes to fighting abilities.

Suggesting that Raph is a better fighter than Leo is just as absurd as suggesting that Hun is a better fighter than Shredder.

Did you not read Tales #56? The Shredder also kicked the bucket in his first appearance. He had his Foot ninjas wear the TMNT down, and ultimately the dude fell back on using a hand grenade to finish them off. That's actually kinda cowardly if you ask me.

Cipher
05-14-2009, 11:58 PM
Kind of glad this thread was bumped. Tristan had a theory about Raph's secondary mutation affecting his longevity and aging.

Now, I'll still stick by my suggested order, as I think it has as sufficient evidence as anything else and I rather like it myself. But one thing confounds me and could totally take things in another direction: The flooded city we sometimes see future Raph inhabit (for example, Tales #55).

Not only does the ruined, water-logged city contrast with the futuristic buildings seen in other future stories, Raph appears far younger than Leo or Don in "Swan Song" and the collected book frontispieces respectively. This could imply three things:

1) Certain cities become ruined while others advance.

2) Earth undergoes a period of ruin followed by technological advances (which...doesn't make much sense).

3) The ruined city is set far after Don and Leo's old age, implying that Raph does indeed have slower aging and is the last to die.

Not my favorite interpretation, and for theme's sake I'd still like to imagine Raph dies first. But there is sufficient evidence so that, should a future issue reveal him to outlive the others, I could accept it.

Discuss.

Also, no one cares which Turtle is a better fighter. Goku is still stronger.

TristanHuwJones
05-15-2009, 12:09 AM
Godzilla pwns Goku.

Cipher
05-15-2009, 12:11 AM
Godzilla pwns Goku.Then by the trastitive property, Hedorah was the strongest character in all Dragon Ball.

TristanHuwJones
05-15-2009, 12:20 AM
Then by the trastitive property, Hedorah was the strongest character in all Dragon Ball.

Dunnoooo... Godzilla's been workin' out, as he does return favors to Hedorah in Final Wars :P

plastroncafe
05-15-2009, 12:23 AM
Then by the trastitive property, Hedorah was the strongest character in all Dragon Ball.

Can I just say that this whole conversation is only made better by the fact that it reads in my head as an "Oh yeah?!" "YEAH!" fight between Hun and El Shreddor!

Please...carry on.

Ninjinister
05-15-2009, 12:30 AM
Dunnoooo... Godzilla's been workin' out, as he does return favors to Hedorah in Final Wars :P

Everybody was nerfed in Final Wars, except for Gigan. Well, and GINO/Zilla, who was nerfed just by existing.

Cipher
05-15-2009, 12:30 AM
Dunnoooo... Godzilla's been workin' out, as he does return favors to Hedorah in Final Wars :PYou mean the same movie with a washed up American wrestler and bullet time fights? Doesn't count.

Also, Hedorah has the power of vagina-eyes. The greatest power of all.

Ninjinister
05-15-2009, 12:33 AM
You mean the same movie with a washed up American wrestler and bullet time fights? Doesn't count.


Dude, Captain Gordon was the greatest addition to the Godzilla series since Godzilla himself.

He's also a total shoo-in for Mike Haggar in a Final Fight movie.

Ryona
05-15-2009, 12:37 AM
Did you not read Tales #56? The Shredder also kicked the bucket in his first appearance. He had his Foot ninjas wear the TMNT down, and ultimately the dude fell back on using a hand grenade to finish them off. That's actually kinda cowardly if you ask me.

I'm aware of Shredder's downfall. I'm not going by timelines. I'm just saying in general.

And dispite your few points, Leo is still the better fighter. I can put in ten times more examples of Leo owning Raph than you got in your little bag, but it's unecessary because it IS a clear fact that Leo is the better warrior, whether you want to admit it or not.
I think it's natural that even Leonardo will have a few bad days. You're pointing out minor technicalities.

There's no need to make this a debate, because there is none. You're a Raph fan, I get it. But regardless, you can't ignore 25 years of TMNT history in which Leonardo, the leader of the TMNT, is the superior warrior in every TMNT universe out there.

Splinter himself says (not in exact words) that Leo is the best. And he points this out in every universe.

And let's not get fan-fiction involved as a counter. Doesn't count.

TristanHuwJones
05-15-2009, 02:19 AM
I'm aware of Shredder's downfall. I'm not going by timelines. I'm just saying in general.

What does timelines have to do with it? And you didn't really answer my question either, because if you'd read #56, you'd be thinking twice about the Hun example.

And dispite your few points, Leo is still the better fighter. I can put in ten times more examples of Leo owning Raph than you got in your little bag, but it's unecessary because it IS a clear fact that Leo is the better warrior, whether you want to admit it or not.

No, I'm not wanting to admit it, and I'm not willing to admit that Raph is a better fighter. I said, plain as day, that when you look at everything, they're all pretty evenly matched in those early days. The exception being Don, which is why he stays he with Splinter at the end of City at War.

If you can deliver at least 20 examples, which isn't even ten times as many as I "got in my little bag", then I will write an issue of Tales where it can be proven, once and for all, without a shadow of a doubt that Leo is best and outlives them all. I'm saying SOLID, INARGUABLE examples of Leo owning Raph as a better fighter.


I think it's natural that even Leonardo will have a few bad days. You're pointing out minor technicalities.

No I'm not. I'm pointing out major flaws in your argument :P
By that logic it's also completely fair to say that every moment you decide to give me in response is Raph on a bad day.

There's no need to make this a debate, because there is none.

...riiight...

You're a Raph fan, I get it.

Wrong. Mike fan, all the way. Raph is actually my least favourite Turtle.



But regardless, you can't ignore 25 years of TMNT history in which Leonardo, the leader of the TMNT, is the superior warrior in every TMNT universe out there.

...except in the future... where he's dead.:evilgrin:
Oh! And Battle Nexus, where he doesn't win (or was that just another bad day?).
And Volume 3, where his hand is eaten off.
And the last movie.

Splinter himself says (not in exact words) that Leo is the best. And he points this out in every universe.

I'm positive he says he is his best student.

And let's not get fan-fiction involved as a counter. Doesn't count.

When did I do that?

willtupper
05-15-2009, 04:35 AM
Raphael always reminds me of this Bruce Lee quote:

"The worst opponent you can come across is one whose aim has become an obsession. For instance, if a man has decided that he is going to bite off your nose no matter what happens to him in the process, the chances are he will succeed in doing it. He may be severely beaten up, too, but that will not stop him from carrying out his objective. That is the real fighter."

Whereas Leonardo always reminds me of Bruce Lee. Does that make sense? It becomes a question of rage versus brains (skill). Who will win?

I say, it depends on the situation. Perhaps Leonardo is incredibly focussed, and Raphael is physically spent. Maybe Leonardo is distracted, while someone just ticked Raph off bad.

To say one is ultimately better than the other, I feel, ultimately does a disservice to both characters.

Doc_ock_4mugen
05-15-2009, 07:43 AM
Godzilla pwns Goku.

Thanks to evolution now EVERYONE can pwn Goku... Even Disney folk can pwn him.
But I'm starting to see why Raph could survive longer than expected for a Hotheaded character.

Rooish
05-15-2009, 08:08 AM
I can't believe this stupid Leo/Raph debate is still going on. Just drop it, guys. Who gives a ****? It has nothing to do with who would live longest. If there were a population of impulsive Raphs and a population of level-headed Leos, maybe the Raph population would go extinct first. I personally agree with that. But it depends on how you interpret Raph ... just because he was idiotically impulsive as a teenager doesn't mean he didn't mellow out and get craftier evenutally. Maybe he'd be a tenacious weasel or badger, and Leo would be, like, a leopard or something, and neither are extinct yet.

How long an average Leo or Raph would live, compared to the other, have no bearing on which Turtle will live longest, because they all encounter many different and dangerous situations. Everyone screws up and hey, maybe they might just get cancer or something. They do have massive DNA mutations, after all.

Tristin, I believe that Mikey's your favourite. But if we're going by canon, Laird has said that Leo is "just barely" the best fighter. If you're believing Laird's canonical claim (or hint) that Raph lives the longest, ya gotta believe his other claim, too (although Eastman would probably disagree).

That being said, Leo could die first by mistake (although he did give up fighting, so it would have to be an unusual mistake). And Raph can beat Leo in a fight, because he already has ... doesn't mean he always would. Probably depends on the situaion.

Comparing their abilities based on the situations where they fought other people is pointless. Leo got taken down by some ordinary Foot and Karai--but he was shot with tasers! Raph got pwned by some Foot and Leo had to save his ass in RtNY--but Raph tired them out for Leo, so Leo had an easier time! Can you see how these comparisons are meaningless and completely subjective? And completely off-topic?

"Best fighter" is a pretty irrelevant term in a family of phenomenal fighters, at least when debating who would live longest.

As for their death orders. Reading "A Day in the Life" over, it does really seem to imply that Mikey's dead ... at first I thought he was missing, but the final panel is of the sky, so ... dead. Or lost in space, maybe. Raph is in a flooded city at that point, which we don't ever see Don and Leo in (I think?), but for all the reasons Cipher gave, that doesn't necessarily mean that it happens later than when we see Leo or Don in old age. Raph also seems to have aged quite a lot by that point. He's also talking to a missing Donny, and not in a depressed way (more an annoyed way), so that need not suggest that Don is dead. It kind of does, however, suggest that Raph is crazy. ;)

Does the whole Mirage team know Laird's theories on all this? Has Laird bothered to work it out (he seems way less analytical about the Turtles than we are)? Are the hints in Tales supposed to be canonical?

To me, for what it's worth, Raph looks no older than his brothers in "Swan Song." One fewer forehead wrinkle, but he's not frowning.

So, anyway, Tristan, can you give me a clue about Raph's hinted longevity? Unless it was just ... Raph was bitten by vampire-things; vampire-things live a long time?

TristanHuwJones
05-15-2009, 09:00 AM
I can't believe this stupid Leo/Raph debate is still going on. Just drop it, guys. Who gives a ****?
I do! She does! RAARH!!
It has nothing to do with who would live longest.

Zactly! But the thing here is that Ryona SEEMS to be interpreting the idea that because Leo may be "the superior warrior", he'll live longest, which simply doesn't work.

But it depends on how you interpret Raph ... just because he was idiotically impulsive as a teenager doesn't mean he didn't mellow out and get craftier evenutally.

ZACTLY!!

Tristin, I believe that Mikey's your favourite. But if we're going by canon, Laird has said that Leo is "just barely" the best fighter. If you're believing Laird's canonical claim (or hint) that Raph lives the longest, ya gotta believe his other claim, too (although Eastman would probably disagree).

Can you point me in the direction of where it's said? Not a stab or doubting, I just want closure! :lol:


That being said, Leo could die first by mistake (although he did give up fighting, so it would have to be an unusual mistake). And Raph can beat Leo in a fight, because he already has ... doesn't mean he always would. Probably depends on the situaion.

Exactly, but you gotta look at it the other way around too, just because Leo could beat Raph, doesn't mean he always would. As I said, in their prime years, they're all pretty even, except Don.


Comparing their abilities based on the situations where they fought other people is pointless. Leo got taken down by some ordinary Foot and Karai--but he was shot with tasers! Raph got pwned by some Foot and Leo had to save his ass in RtNY--but Raph tired them out for Leo, so Leo had an easier time! Can you see how these comparisons are meaningless and completely subjective? And completely off-topic?

I've been saying that, but the reason my arguments look so lopsided is because I'm simply presenting Raph's side of things. All we were hearing was how awesome Leo was under Leo-centric circumstances without factoring in the variables and logical elements surrounding said circumstances.


"Best fighter" is a pretty irrelevant term in a family of phenomenal fighters, at least when debating who would live longest.

This is what I said AGES ago, but the argument went into who was the better fighter. I simply laid out facts for Raph. If someone were arguing for another Turtle, I'd probably be presenting different arguments.


As for their death orders. Reading "A Day in the Life" over, it does really seem to imply that Mikey's dead ... at first I thought he was missing, but the final panel is of the sky, so ... dead. Or lost in space, maybe.

I took it to mean he was POSSIBLY dead, but PROBABLY missing.

Raph is in a flooded city at that point, which we don't ever see Don and Leo in (I think?), but for all the reasons Cipher gave, that doesn't necessarily mean that it happens later than when we see Leo or Don in old age. Raph also seems to have aged quite a lot by that point. He's also talking to a missing Donny, and not in a depressed way (more an annoyed way), so that need not suggest that Don is dead. It kind of does, however, suggest that Raph is crazy.

Well, here's the thing. Jim drew both the Tales collected book pieces where we see all the old TMNT (with the younger looking Raph) and I'd argue that THAT Raph is younger looking than the one at the end of "Day in the Life", and if Raph really does have a decelerated aging process at that point, it'd have to be a decent stretch of time AFTER the other Turtles. So if they're still alive, chances are, they're really, REALLY old.


Does the whole Mirage team know Laird's theories on all this? Has Laird bothered to work it out (he seems way less analytical about the Turtles than we are)? Are the hints in Tales supposed to be canonical?

Nope. Dan has no idea. I don't, and as far as I'm aware, EVERYTHING in Tales is canonical... at least until it gets retconned or Pete says no.


To me, for what it's worth, Raph looks no older than his brothers in "Swan Song." One fewer forehead wrinkle, but he's not frowning.

You don't think he looks substantially younger though?


So, anyway, Tristan, can you give me a clue about Raph's hinted longevity? Unless it was just ... Raph was bitten by vampire-things; vampire-things live a long time?

That's all it was in my mind. He's been bitten by a vampire. Vampires live forever (unless you kill 'em proper like). I see it this way:

Raph was bitten by pseudo vampires. They may not be true vampires, but if they're carrying the vampire "virus" and are transferring it traditionally -- which we can see when Raph undergoes the secondary mutation -- then logic would dictate that he's inherited traits that come with the vampire virus (bloodthirsty, transformation, extended life-expectancy). We know he changes back, but because he's been changed on a cellular level, his genetics would've been altered slightly by the virus. He may not be immortal in the traditional sense of the vampire, but I'd certainly put money down on it being a decent enough reason for his aging process to be slower than the others. But that's just me looking at things the way they are now, taking them at face value. There could be an entirely different reason for it. The Raph we know might be dead by that time and it could be one from another dimension or timeline or something.

Rooish
05-15-2009, 09:38 AM
Zactly! But the thing here is that Ryona SEEMS to be interpreting the idea that because Leo may be "the superior warrior", he'll live longest, which simply doesn't work.

I definitely agree that there's no strong reason to believe that just because Leo is the "superior fighter," he would live longer than Raph. That's a very faulty argument. But I think that Ryona also said somewhere that it was because Leo gave up fighting and chose a peaceful lifestyle that he would live longer. And I tend to agree; although Raph has a survivor's instinct, if he keeps fighting when Leo gives up, he's more likely to get killed in a fight at some point, while Leo would die of old age or something. But we don't know if Raph mellowed and got more careful. He seems (somewhat) less irrational in Vol. 4.


Can you point me in the direction of where it's said? Not a stab or doubting, I just want closure! :lol:

Yes, because I'm super nice I looked it up. In the letters column of Vol. 4, Issue 10, a fan says:

Dear Mr. Laird,

I gots a question for yah. I know this is pretty blunt and you probably can't "officially" answer it or whatever, but here goes: which o' the TMNT is the "best fighter" (or ninja or whatever)?? I was arguin' with a buddy about this. I'm gunnin' for Mikey (as he is my fave), mostly because of what is said in the Paladium RPG.

Thanks for your time,

[email protected]

To which Laird says,

Even though Donatello is my favorite Turtle, I would have to give the nod to Leonardo ... just barely. --PL

So there you go. The "just barely" official answer. Probably Eastman would say Raph is the best, though. :lol:

Exactly, but you gotta look at it the other way around too, just because Leo could beat Raph, doesn't mean he always would. As I said, in their prime years, they're all pretty even, except Don.

I've been saying that, but the reason my arguments look so lopsided is because I'm simply presenting Raph's side of things. All we were hearing was how awesome Leo was under Leo-centric circumstances without factoring in the variables and logical elements surrounding said circumstances.

Agreed. Raph has beaten Leo. I don't see the point in comparing their fights with other people to decide who is the better fighter, but I can see why you do it because it was being done to argue Leo's better, and neither argument makes sense because comparing those fights is like comparing apples and oranges.

Well, here's the thing. Jim drew both the Tales collected book pieces where we see all the old TMNT (with the younger looking Raph) and I'd argue that THAT Raph is younger looking than the one at the end of "Day in the Life", and if Raph really does have a decelerated aging process at that point, it'd have to be a decent stretch of time AFTER the other Turtles. So if they're still alive, chances are, they're really, REALLY old.

Cool, with your arguments about the secondary mutation, I can definitely imagine Raph aging by far the slowest. This seems backed up by the Tales collected books frontispieces, although I also interpreted it showing the order they died.

In fact, it could still be the case. Raph might age slowest. However, he still might also get killed earlier, although he looks younger. Hard to tell, since he's shown in flooded cities when the other Turtles aren't. I wouldn't think his slow aging necessarily means he outlives the others, just that he could if he's not killed. Just playing devil's advocate here. He very well may live the longest. Although I think the Tales collected book strongly suggests that Don does.

You don't think he looks substantially younger though?

In "Swan Song," no. The art is too sketchy to tell. In the Tales collected book frontispieces, obviously yes, although there's different ways to interpret that.

I guess I'm just trying to say ... a) it's all ambiguous and will probably stay that way, b) the Turtles' personalities and fighting skills could be correlated with their death order, but do not definitely determine it by any means, c) Raph's secondary mutation could indeed make him age more slowly, and d) although Leo may be the best fighter, it's "just barely," and therefore makes little difference.

It's fun to debate, though! But fans tend to get caught up in favourtism, and that is blinding.

TristanHuwJones
05-15-2009, 10:03 AM
I definitely agree that there's no strong reason to believe that just because Leo is the "superior fighter," he would live longer than Raph. That's a very faulty argument. But I think that Ryona also said somewhere that it was because Leo gave up fighting and chose a peaceful lifestyle that he would live longer. And I tend to agree; although Raph has a survivor's instinct, if he keeps fighting when Leo gives up, he's more likely to get killed in a fight at some point, while Leo would die of old age or something. But we don't know if Raph mellowed and got more careful. He seems (somewhat) less irrational in Vol. 4.

See, there's the thing, we don't know anything... yet. We don't know what enemies Leo made between the time we see him now and the time we see him as an aged Turtle. Who's to say (besides Peter) that there isn't some villain out there with a grudge against Leo and a big f*ck-off lazer, or some kinda neat-o Scanners style head-explody powers? Like I said earlier... there's always a bigger fish. It's a circular debate.


Yes, because I'm super nice I looked it up. In the letters column of Vol. 4, Issue 10, a fan says:

So there you go. The "just barely" official answer. Probably Eastman would say Raph is the best, though. :lol:

Ah! Thanks for that! But that then begs the argument, are what's said in the letter columns considered canon? Considering that was a fair while ago, Peter may have changed his mind... too many variables to this whole debate :P




Agreed. Raph has beaten Leo. I don't see the point in comparing their fights with other people to decide who is the better fighter, but I can see why you do it because it was being done to argue Leo's better, and neither argument makes sense because comparing those fights is like comparing apples and oranges.

Zactly!



Cool, with your arguments about the secondary mutation, I can definitely imagine Raph aging by far the slowest. This seems backed up by the Tales collected books frontispieces, although I also interpreted it showing the order they died.

In fact, it could still be the case. Raph might age slowest. However, he still might also get killed earlier, although he looks younger. Hard to tell, since he's shown in flooded cities when the other Turtles aren't. I wouldn't think his slow aging necessarily means he outlives the others, just that he could if he's not killed. Just playing devil's advocate here. He very well may live the longest. Although I think the Tales collected book strongly suggests that Don does.

I play devil's advocate all the time, so no harm there!
No, you're right though, it could mean anything. He most certainly could die the youngest. Ultimately, my argument is that, provided no one kills and they're left to live their lives peacefully without interruption, Raph would outlive the rest based purely on the secondary mutation/vampire theory.

I guess I'm just trying to say ... a) it's all ambiguous and will probably stay that way, b) the Turtles' personalities and fighting skills could be correlated with their death order, but do not definitely determine it by any means, c) Raph's secondary mutation could indeed make him age more slowly, and d) although Leo may be the best fighter, it's "just barely," and therefore makes little difference.

Exactly. Nothing is absolute. NOTHING. NO-THING!!

It's fun to debate, though! But fans tend to get caught up in favourtism, and that is blinding.

You think? ;)

plastroncafe
05-15-2009, 10:20 AM
That's all it was in my mind. He's been bitten by a vampire. Vampires live forever (unless you kill 'em proper like). I see it this way:

Raph was bitten by pseudo vampires. They may not be true vampires, but if they're carrying the vampire "virus" and are transferring it traditionally -- which we can see when Raph undergoes the secondary mutation -- then logic would dictate that he's inherited traits that come with the vampire virus (bloodthirsty, transformation, extended life-expectancy). We know he changes back, but because he's been changed on a cellular level, his genetics would've been altered slightly by the virus. He may not be immortal in the traditional sense of the vampire, but I'd certainly put money down on it being a decent enough reason for his aging process to be slower than the others. But that's just me looking at things the way they are now, taking them at face value. There could be an entirely different reason for it. The Raph we know might be dead by that time and it could be one from another dimension or timeline or something.

I was thinking this just after you made the previous allusion.
Dang, just dang!

TristanHuwJones
05-15-2009, 10:31 AM
Haha! Glad to see someone else picked up on it :)

Archon_Turtle
05-15-2009, 03:12 PM
a big f*ck-off lazer

This is quite possibly the best name for a weapon ever. Where can I purchase my own big f*ck-off lazer?

Cipher
05-15-2009, 04:28 PM
In "Swan Song," no. The art is too sketchy to tell. In the Tales collected book frontispieces, obviously yes, although there's different ways to interpret that.Looking at Raph compared to the other Turtles in "Swan Song" was something I didn't even think of. Good catch. However, I'm inclined to disregard that. "A Day in the Life" and the Tales collected pieces are drawn by the same, regular Mirage artist, so I think the discrepencies between those pieces are the ones that should be looked at.

And whoever it was (either Rooish or Tristan) that pointed out how much older Raph looks at the end of "A Day in the Life" than he does in the Tales book made a seriously good catch. That scene is slowly destroying the order I proposed at the beginning of this thread. We can really only conclude that either the holographic Raph in the Tales book represents the last time any of his brothers saw him, or that Tristan's theory is indeed correct.

If there's one thing I want to know from Mirage publishing before it ends its run (and hopefully that won't be anytime soon), it's the answer to this thread.

TristanHuwJones
05-15-2009, 07:57 PM
This is quite possibly the best name for a weapon ever. Where can I purchase my own big f*ck-off lazer?

Wal-mart.



**** you, you stupid ten character limit.

Rooish
05-17-2009, 05:37 PM
And whoever it was (either Rooish or Tristan) that pointed out how much older Raph looks at the end of "A Day in the Life" than he does in the Tales book made a seriously good catch. That scene is slowly destroying the order I proposed at the beginning of this thread. We can really only conclude that either the holographic Raph in the Tales book represents the last time any of his brothers saw him, or that Tristan's theory is indeed correct.

Oh, yikes. Good call. Well, if Raph outlives Don, it's weird that Don had to call up those holographic images in the Tales collected book story. I guess maybe they're just all separated then or something?

If there's one thing I want to know from Mirage publishing before it ends its run (and hopefully that won't be anytime soon), it's the answer to this thread.

Me too, although it's kind of morbid, and will kill all the suspense and wonder of it. Probably everyone should be left to decide such a thing for themselves, since very few people will be truly happy with the official order and may decide it's not canon, anyway. :roll:

Ah! Thanks for that! But that then begs the argument, are what's said in the letter columns considered canon? Considering that was a fair while ago, Peter may have changed his mind... too many variables to this whole debate

I'd say that, as Peter said it, it's about as close to canon as it gets. And it wasn't that long ago... a few years. Granted the 2007 movie where Raph beats Leo has happened since then, but is that any more canon than what Peter Laird himself said not long before that?

CyberCubed
05-24-2026, 04:41 PM
Man, this is an old good thread from 2009. Very interesting posts here, and this was before Mirage stopped publishing TMNT comics entirely.