View Full Version : Tales of the TMNT 57
Raph's Girl
04-09-2009, 05:01 PM
Midtown is listing this as coming out Wednesday April 15th. Looks like it's set between vol 1 and vol 2
"The Turtles are in turmoil, arguing amongst themselves regarding where they should reside. Raph wants to take up residence in an abandoned church, Leo wants to return to the sewers, Don wants to go to Massachusetts and Mike wants to stay in April's building to protect their friends, a plan that seems all the more necessary when a gang attacks a man living next door. The Turtles intervene and find themselves battling enemies new and old, very old!"
Andrew NDB
04-09-2009, 09:04 PM
Sounds like a quasi TMNT Vol. 1 #... 63?
CyberCubed
04-09-2009, 09:30 PM
Speak of the devil, I was just about to post a topic about why the TMNT splitting up in Vol. 2 didn't stick.
If you recall in the beginning of Vol. 2, Mike wants to stay in an apartment, Leo wants to move to the sewers, Raph goes to a church, and Don stays in the old farmhouse.
Yet when Image starts, the Turtles are all living together in the sewers again. And in Vol. 4, I'm pretty sure they were all in the sewers again too.
So this finally explains why the Turtles moved back together again after the beginning of Vol. 2? Talk about clearing up plotholes from the last 15 years!
junkboy
04-11-2009, 04:50 PM
The plot of this issue has been one to catch my attention more than other issues since i first saw it.
Looking forward to it.
TristanHuwJones
04-12-2009, 08:52 PM
Speak of the devil, I was just about to post a topic about why the TMNT splitting up in Vol. 2 didn't stick.
If you recall in the beginning of Vol. 2, Mike wants to stay in an apartment, Leo wants to move to the sewers, Raph goes to a church, and Don stays in the old farmhouse.
Yet when Image starts, the Turtles are all living together in the sewers again. And in Vol. 4, I'm pretty sure they were all in the sewers again too.
So this finally explains why the Turtles moved back together again after the beginning of Vol. 2? Talk about clearing up plotholes from the last 15 years!
C'mon! I bring it up! :P
oldmanwinters
04-15-2009, 08:17 PM
Got it today so I might as well open up the discussion:
NO SPOILERS!
It sure did feel short like a short issue, mostly due to the very drawn out fight scene. And although their decision about where to live was a little predictable, it just felt right. I can't say this was a classic issue like the last two months, but I liked it well enough. I can't wait next next month's culmination of the Moo-Mesa saga!
Ninjinister
04-15-2009, 08:20 PM
NO SPOILERS!
Nuts to you!
oldmanwinters
04-15-2009, 08:31 PM
Nuts to you!
They saved a ... Purple Dragon!!!
From Vol. 1, #1, no less!!!
trustno1
04-17-2009, 07:56 AM
got it. thought it was pretty good. the story felt a little short, and while i do think that it was a little bit of a let down after 56, i still love it when jim and dan team up.
Archon_Turtle
04-17-2009, 01:52 PM
Snape Kills Dumbledore!
oldmanwinters
04-17-2009, 02:14 PM
Snape Kills Dumbledore!
I guess I missed that part. :P
discordiatookie
04-22-2009, 01:59 PM
It sure did feel short like a short issue, mostly due to the very drawn out fight scene. And although their decision about where to live was a little predictable, it just felt right. I can't say this was a classic issue like the last two months, but I liked it well enough.
What he said!
It was enjoyable, I enjoyed it.
Bruce Willis' character is a ghost!
DrSpengler
04-22-2009, 02:18 PM
Here's my thorough review with summary and notes. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2009/04/tales-of-tmnt-vol-2-57.html)
And here's just the review part of it:
A decent issue, storywise, that leaves me wishing for a proper TMNT comic in a sequential, serial format rather than an anthology take. Stories like this are all too necessary, but lose impact when thrown in a series where all the stories are smattered randomly about the timeline. There was apparently a lot of tension building up to the Turtles' decision, but when you're not reading the series in anything approaching a coherent sequential order, that tension drops dead.
That aside, it's a nice look into the private squabbles of the Turtles and fills in a nice little gap in their continuity (when and why did they decided to ditch the apartment and go back to the sewers). Berger turns in an amusing if low-key script, though the eight pages of silent battle sort of screamed "filler" and made for breezey reading. Still, it's a twenty-eight page comic with only two ads to speak of, so you're still getting more content for your buck than from most publishers.
Nothing new to say about Lawson's art. You all know how I feel about it by now, anyway. His poor use of line-weight and two-tone inking (that is, black and white with no shades in-between) make for some very muddled fight scenes, sort of defeating the purpose of an impressive eight page brawl. Page 13 is especially difficult to comprehend, with every character garbed in a black jacket (including the TMNT), crammed together in a small apartment with broken glass fluttering everywhere. Proper use of line-weight and some better inking would have made that page a lot easier on the eyes; all I'm sayin'.
Overall, this was an okay story, but so low-key that you'll probably forget you ever read it by the time the next issue comes out.
Grade: C+ (as in, "Could Chucky be the next big status quo-destroying villain introduced into the TMNT universe!? Let's hope not.)
oldmanwinters
04-22-2009, 02:28 PM
Here's my thorough review with summary and notes. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2009/04/tales-of-tmnt-vol-2-57.html)
Well said, Spengs, well said. Although I thought the fight scene was competent enough, if not spectacular. This issue did kinda leave me especially hungry for the next two issues though!
Bruce Willis' character is a ghost!
Dang it! I haven't seen that movie yet!
Ninjinister
04-26-2009, 11:48 PM
Snape Kills Dumbledore!
What the eff does that mean?
oldmanwinters
04-26-2009, 11:53 PM
What the eff does that mean?
I think he's just being facetious of the whole spoiler debate earlier in the thread. I thought it was pretty funny.
BTW, has ANYBODY read this issue yet? It seems everyone stills wants to talk about #56 but no one chimes in about the most recent issue.:P
Ninjinister
04-27-2009, 12:04 AM
I think he's just being facetious of the whole spoiler debate earlier in the thread. I thought it was pretty funny.
I still don't get it. What are those things? I suppose I could check for myself, but... meh.
BTW, has ANYBODY read this issue yet? It seems everyone stills wants to talk about #56 but no one chimes in about the most recent issue.:P
I read the issue. Decent, and it was interesting seeing that one random dude from way back then.... but overall it seemed like just another one of those "filler" issues. Some might say that all of Tales is filler, but I like the kind that lay another brick in addition to the cement.
trustno1
04-27-2009, 12:11 AM
you wanted spoilers and he gave you a big one :P
junkboy
04-28-2009, 05:29 PM
I still don't get it. What are those things? I suppose I could check for myself, but... meh.
I read the issue. Decent, and it was interesting seeing that one random dude from way back then.... but overall it seemed like just another one of those "filler" issues. Some might say that all of Tales is filler, but I like the kind that lay another brick in addition to the cement.
To a point i agree that nearly all Tales issues are filler. But as long as i enjoy i do not care or think over it much.
In this issue not much happened, but i really enjoyed it. It is weird that i see the family values in TMNT more realistic than such things i see at a movie or such. ( with non-mutant ordinary people )
( as in.. i find splinter calling the guys "my sons" really cool )
Raph'N'Roll
04-28-2009, 07:29 PM
Good review DrSpengler,
I wasn't mad about this issue either, the main culprit being the lengthy fight scene, it was a bit hard on the eyes.
One thing I noticed though, none of the thugs seemed to receive any fatal looking blows from the Turtles, the fight seemed well... kinda reserved.
Why not have Leo put his sword through some of those psycho gang members?
They are in a life or death situation after all, and I'm not talking about mega violence or anything, just something like vol 1#1.
It makes perfect sense for the Turtles to kill these guys, no repercussions.
The Turtles are Ninjas, not members of the A-Team.
Rooish
04-30-2009, 02:50 PM
I, too, thought it was odd that no one died. Tales is so back-and-forth about violence, swearing. I mean last month every other word was ****, and this month we get, like, "imbecile" and "doofus" and stuff.
Not much to say about Jim Lawson's art this month. I wish he didn't rush so much. I really did like his art of the Turtles at the start of Vol. 4, but now everything is stylized way too much. Or too little. Please Jim, bring back rulers and rounded body parts.
I do notice, however, that Mike is getting a bit more screen time in the comics these days. I can't complain about that.
It was a cute story, but... wow, I never thought I'd say this. Tales is getting almost a little too sappy at times for me! I mean ... we know they're a family. We're never allowed to forget. ;) I really liked how, in Vol. 4, the Turtles got kind of split up for a while ... you know there will be a nice reunion when they get back together, but it won't be too maudlin.
I liked this issue. If there ever was a TMNT Vol.5 series that took place between Vol.2 and Vol.4 (as speculated in another thread) to go over the Image Vol.3 series. I wouldn't mind if it started from this type of story. 'Cause Vol. 4 started off with the Madhattan Militia seen, now this Tales issue shows us where the TMNT first met the MM gang and that group has a rivalry with the Purple Dragons. I think this is a great spot for such a new Mirage TMNT book to carry on from. The TMNT try to stay and protect thier friends where ever they go, etc. How it effects them and how do these gangs' presence effect the city. Maybe some Foot stories in there too. I think it'd be a great for a new series' foundation.
Its slipped my mind about the lack of violence and the difference from issue to issue about the language thats used. Yeah you'd think it'd be more in tone to what the TMNT world is like, something more like the real world. But its only a comic book, but it does kind of make the Mirage editors inconsistant.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.