PDA

View Full Version : Tales treasury question


Billbeaux
04-09-2009, 05:20 PM
I'm off and running on building a collection, and for the sake of convenience I'm trying to scoop up as many of the collected books as I can. I noticed the first run of Tales has been released in trade form twice, the first one twenty-odd years ago, and the latest one just a few years back. Just wondering if they are identical in content. That is to say, does either trade contain any kind of bonus stories or creator commentaries that would make it any more preferable than the other version?

CyberCubed
04-09-2009, 07:16 PM
The second Tales trade has a brand new 27 page story with the Turtles, Renet and Savanti back in the past with the dinosaurs, a direct continuation of Tales #7.

The new one (as in the one that came out in 2007), is also easy to find, the old collected book from like 1989 is pretty rare and even I don't have a copy.

Get the 2007 one, the 27-page "Spinal Tapped" story is pretty good and its basically a freebie considering it could have been released as a stand-alone Tales issue.

Billbeaux
04-09-2009, 08:30 PM
That's what I was figuring on doing. I've seen copies of the '89 edition here and there, but the asking price has typically been insane.

TristanHuwJones
04-09-2009, 08:36 PM
The older book had a story involving Nobody that was adapted to the recent cartoons I think... I can't quite recall. Best bet is to go with the recent one to be honest.

DrSpengler
04-09-2009, 10:34 PM
The first trade collection featured an 8 page untitled story in which the Turtles meet Nobody a second time. It was adapted into the 2k3 episode "Still Nobody".

That story has never been reprinted anywhere else.


As has already been stated, the recent trade collection includes a different bonus story, the 27 page "Spinal Tapped".

So it's up to you which bonus story you think sounds more entertaining. The first trade collection can be pretty tough to find and pretty pricey. I'd say, just go for the newer collection. "Stil Nobody" wasn't that great a story; certainly not worth paying any exorbitant amount of money for it on the second hand market.

oldmanwinters
04-09-2009, 10:38 PM
The first trade collection featured an 8 page untitled story in which the Turtles meet Nobody a second time. It was adapted into the 2k3 episode "Still Nobody".

That story has never been reprinted anywhere else.


As has already been stated, the recent trade collection includes a different bonus story, the 27 page "Spinal Tapped".

So it's up to you which bonus story you think sounds more entertaining. The first trade collection can be pretty tough to find and pretty pricey. I'd say, just go for the newer collection. "Stil Nobody" wasn't that great a story; certainly not worth paying any exorbitant amount of money for it on the second hand market.

Wasn't "Still Nobody" the one where Mikey dressed up as the old lady? LOL... that was a classic!:tlol:

Spitfire
04-09-2009, 10:41 PM
I like the look of the old printings better. The new trades all look like they're printed on white printer paper. It takes away from the artwork in my opinion. I have both. One cost me like 40 bucks, the older one, and the newer one I found in the store for regular price. Like Dr.S says it's up to you which story you want. The new trades has more bonus content with the little intros by the future turtles, however the artwork is by Lawson and looks horrific.

DrSpengler
04-09-2009, 10:49 PM
Indeed, that's another difference I forgot to mention.


The original collection and the recent collection have different frontispieces (those 1-page opening segments before each issue).

The original collection maintains the frontispieces as they appeared in the original single issues, while the recent collection creates new ones which follow a storyline involving the future Turtles and ties into the bonus "Spinal Tapped" story.

As Spitfire also mentioned, these new frontispieces and "Spinal Tapped" were drawn by Jim Lawson circa 2007 and look positively wretched.

While all of the original Tales issues and "Still Nobody" were also drawn by Lawson, they were drawn by Lawson circa 1989, when he still knew how to draw and hadn't stylized his characters down to rudimentary geometric shapes.

oldmanwinters
04-09-2009, 10:56 PM
The original collection and the recent collection have different frontispieces (those 1-page opening segments before each issue).

The original collection maintains the frontispieces as they appeared in the original single issues, while the recent collection creates new ones which follow a storyline involving the future Turtles and ties into the bonus "Spinal Tapped" story.

I absolutely LOVE those old frontispieces. It just really sets the mood for me and they are all very appropriate to the stories contained inside.

Makes me feel really fortunate I grabbed the original Tales Vol. 1 Treasury for $5 from a buddy in college who was looking to sell off his old TMNT comic collection for rock bottom prices. :-D

Billbeaux
04-10-2009, 04:01 PM
Are the original frontispieces actually germane to the story? If so, I wonder why they would change them...

I'm still leaning toward the new treasury, but a quick glance at ebay showed that there's currently a copy of the '89 version up for auction. Come the deadline if the price is still reasonable I may just have to take a stab at it.

DrSpengler
04-10-2009, 04:21 PM
The frotnispieces in the original issues aren't detreimental to the story, just one-off random intros.

The frontispieces in the new trade do form their own story which ties in with TMNT future chronology, though.

CyberCubed
04-10-2009, 04:31 PM
The old ones were nice in terms of art, but considering the new ones all relate to the "old tmnt" story they seem to have going, I actually liked them more.

Especially since its hinted that old Don is the only Turtle still alive, and the others have passed away due to old age.

Given Peter Laird has stated Don is his favorite Turtle, it wouldn't surprise me if he outlives the others.

Billbeaux
04-10-2009, 04:59 PM
[QUOTE=CyberCubed;684896]

Especially since its hinted that old Don is the only Turtle still alive, and the others have passed away due to old age.

[QUOTE]

I've not read them, but I know there are a couple issues of Tales II that are set many decades in the future. Are those stories set in stone, or, to borrow a phrase from the original Terminator, do they represent one possible future?

Given that the overall story seems to be ongoing, I figure if it continued long enough we would eventually see the Turtles grow old and die. Makes me wonder how long they would live, though. I assume the mutagen slowed their aging, considering Splinter is at least fifteen years old at the start of the series and rats generally live about three or four years. Regular turtles can live for decades--some species can easily lap a hundred years--so how long would a mutated one expect to hang in there?