PDA

View Full Version : Official: Let Tristan Jones Write the Screenplay Thread!


Aztec General
04-23-2009, 05:28 PM
Let Tristan Jones write the screenplay for the new TMNT film! He is a screenwriter after all.

Nobody has done a better job writing in the TMNT comics world then him in the last 5 years. And yes, I'm including Peter Laird's Vol. 4 in that previous comment!

If you don't believe me read Tales of the TMNT Vol. 2 #36, 50, & 56.

Could you imagine a TMNT film written by Tristan Jones, directed by Zak Snyder (a professed TMNT fanboy), based on the Mirage comics, and rated PG-13? I can and I'm foaming at the mouth! :thyper:

Cipher
04-23-2009, 05:58 PM
I'm going to humbly disagree that Tristan has been the best TMNT writer in the last five years (no offence, Tristan). But his vision of the property is definitely the kind that would be capable of shaking public opinion with a big screen debut.

So not necessarily my favorite, but probably what the property needs right now.

CyberCubed
04-23-2009, 05:59 PM
I'd love to see Tristan be the head-writer on an on-going comic series, (maybe Volume 5?), but as for a movie...eh...they're probably go with some "name" writer.

Aztec General
04-23-2009, 06:00 PM
I'd love to see Tristan be the head-writer on an on-going comic series, (maybe Volume 5?),

I'll second that.

gobo
04-23-2009, 06:15 PM
Are we sure Tristan is even willing to take on that big a project?

junkboy
04-23-2009, 06:23 PM
I really like Tristan. His issues are my fave. Tales issues. But i do not believe that he can be that free to write the script he wants for a movie. After all a movie is for everyone. Not for a small world called comics. There will be lots of ppl over your head telling you how to do it and ofc there will be a concern about profit, etc.

For a big screen adaptation, i guess they would hire a more known writer. But for a direct to dvd movie/animation , a less budget-movie , or stuff like webisodes as Ed Brubaker's Angel of Death or G.I. JOE Resolute by Warren Ellis at the moment, i guess Tristan would be perfect.

I really wonder his reaction to this thread tho. We'll see what his response will be when he comes and see this.

Roseangelo
04-23-2009, 06:49 PM
I have to humbly disagree that Tristan is the person to take on this task.

oldmanwinters
04-23-2009, 06:52 PM
I vote for Mark Martin.;)

Spitfire
04-23-2009, 07:16 PM
I think David S. Goyer would be a nice jump start the turtles.

I can't judge Tristan because I've never read a screenplay of his or seen a film he wrote.

Jester
04-23-2009, 07:31 PM
Maybe fans should write it...

What?

trustno1
04-23-2009, 07:40 PM
I have to humbly disagree that Tristan is the person to take on this task.

any particular reason?

i can understand why though. he is untested. i love his comic writing but film is different. these movies always have a number of writers working on them, perhaps if he were put in part of a group that would work on it? transformers was written by two relative newcomers to film and that worked out great. i remember reading in an interview recently that screenwriting is what he was trained to do and that he was given comic work before film work. who knows? he might do something great especially if they want to give the tmnt a modern revision. i do not think anyone outside of dan berger has really nailed the characterizations like he has.

i think david goyer is hit and miss. some of his work has been excellent, whereas others have been average. he appreciates comics though, which would definitely be a bonus.

Roseangelo
04-23-2009, 08:11 PM
any particular reason?

Untested, unpolished. And truthfully, over-rated. Good, but not the end-all-be-all people seem to treat his books as.

Archon_Turtle
04-23-2009, 08:18 PM
Untested, unpolished. And truthfully, over-rated. Good, but not the end-all-be-all people seem to treat his books as.

So that begs the question. Who would you like to see write the screenplay?

Roseangelo
04-23-2009, 08:23 PM
So that begs the question. Who would you like to see write the screenplay?

Obi-Wan Kenobi

VaughnMichael
04-23-2009, 08:28 PM
Obi-Wan Kenobi
pft Obi-wan can blow me, I think they should have Rose & Archon writing the screen play for the new movie together.:lol:

I'll have to get back to you guys on who I think really should be doing this.

trustno1
04-23-2009, 08:29 PM
untested i agree. unpolished how? i have not seen any sort of screenplay by him but his turtle scripts have been my favorites so far. even 50 which was weaker was great and if i remember right he had more to do with the script than the story. i think he is definitely the right person to give the comics to for less compressed storytelling but i think he would have to be tested for the film. his ideas would be welcomed in my mind.

Spitfire
04-23-2009, 08:40 PM
I'll have to get back to you guys on who I think really should be doing this.

We totally should, our movie idea ruled and I can write screenplays.

TristanHuwJones
04-23-2009, 08:51 PM
I wasn't going to come near this thread when I saw it, but as unlikely as it is to ever happen, I thank you for the support! Trustno1 is right though, I was working in film before I got into comics.

Jester
04-23-2009, 08:54 PM
Trist, you need to post some samples of your work. It'd be a great thing for people who are wary of your "inexperience."

TristanHuwJones
04-23-2009, 09:13 PM
To be honest, I think opinions are formed either way about my capabilities, and they aren't going to change any time soon. The other problem is that most of what I was doing was technology based -- puppetry, sound, lighting -- or assistance. Since I started studying again AND found work in comics, the film and TV work has taken a back seat. I think the only scripts I still have are for a short horror film I made and maybe a chunk of a TMNT one I wrote years ago for a class exercise (rewrite a sequence from one of your favourite movies), but I'd have to scan them in or retype them.

I dunno, it's one of those things. If I were asked to get involved, I wouldn't say no, I'd drop everything if asked, but I'm not stupid and I know how these things work.

The other thing is that anyone can write a screenplay. Anyone can write a good screenplay, it's not hard technically, but not everyone can construct a good story, and not everyone can construct a good TMNT story FOR film. Whoever they choose needs to have an appreciation of the Mirage Comics, the characters AND the current direction of films and audiences. All of that needs to be present in the script, otherwise the film is doomed to repeat the mistakes of other superhero movies and even past Turtles movies.

Kendamu
04-23-2009, 10:41 PM
EDIT: Oops, wrong thread.

On-topic: I don't care who does it as long as the source material is respected!

Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 01:48 AM
To be honest, I think opinions are formed either way about my capabilities, and they aren't going to change any time soon. The other problem is that most of what I was doing was technology based -- puppetry, sound, lighting -- or assistance. Since I started studying again AND found work in comics, the film and TV work has taken a back seat. I think the only scripts I still have are for a short horror film I made and maybe a chunk of a TMNT one I wrote years ago for a class exercise (rewrite a sequence from one of your favourite movies), but I'd have to scan them in or retype them.

I dunno, it's one of those things. If I were asked to get involved, I wouldn't say no, I'd drop everything if asked, but I'm not stupid and I know how these things work.

The other thing is that anyone can write a screenplay. Anyone can write a good screenplay, it's not hard technically, but not everyone can construct a good story, and not everyone can construct a good TMNT story FOR film. Whoever they choose needs to have an appreciation of the Mirage Comics, the characters AND the current direction of films and audiences. All of that needs to be present in the script, otherwise the film is doomed to repeat the mistakes of other superhero movies and even past Turtles movies.

Good, youre a piece of crap anyway!

*Shakes his fist as he jumps on the band wagon*

TristanHuwJones
04-24-2009, 01:56 AM
Good, youre a piece of crap anyway!

*Shakes his fist as he jumps on the band wagon*

Y'know, with all the pieces of crap out there, you ever wonder what the sum of all of us would be like?

Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 02:02 AM
Y'know, with all the pieces of crap out there, you ever wonder what the sum of all of us would be like?

It would be like...Dungeons and Dragons the movie.

P.S. How dare you not be on facebook for further heckling.

TristanHuwJones
04-24-2009, 02:09 AM
Dungeons and Dragons and Twilight.

I am so there.

Kendamu
04-24-2009, 06:02 AM
In all actuality, I like your work a lot! I especially loved Tales #36 and I also liked Tales #56! I wouldn't mind you writing a TMNT movie.

VaughnMichael
04-24-2009, 06:57 AM
We totally should, our movie idea ruled and I can write screenplays.
I can't lie, I was thinking about it at work lastnight.

trustno1
04-24-2009, 06:35 PM
In all actuality, I like your work a lot! I especially loved Tales #36 and I also liked Tales #56! I wouldn't mind you writing a TMNT movie.

i would love to see your hun ideas worked into the movie. they feel like they would work. miller too!

tortugapower
04-24-2009, 06:50 PM
So that begs the question. Who would you like to see write the screenplay?

Christopher and Jonathan Nolan, Charlie Kaufman or Paul Dini.

funatic
04-24-2009, 07:07 PM
Christopher and Jonathan Nolan, Charlie Kaufman or Paul Dini.

Charlie Kaufman? Now THAT would be interesting... I think he'd do best adapting something from the Mark Martin stories in v1 tho, instead of the origins... time travel and plot loops seem right up his alley.

trustno1
04-24-2009, 09:13 PM
i just saw the horrendous travesty that was wovlerine:origins and i do not want some person doing the script for tmnt to be someone disconnected from the brand. the person writing this movie really has to have some genuine love of the characters. you can see it all through the other movies that have done well: x-men 1 and 2, spiderman 1 and 2, begins, dark knight... all these people working on the movie knew and loved the characters and stories, the writers, the directors, producers, ALL of them (not just one or two of them and the rest being out to cash in).

we know galen loves the tmnt as he put the money forward for the animated one, peter and gary are both on as producers and i assume kevin might front some money and it seems like this other guy peter had on his blog really has a lot of love for the turtles. what it needs now is a writing team (if tristan were part of it i would be very happy) with the same passion and a director of like mind.

Roseangelo
04-24-2009, 09:18 PM
and i assume kevin might front some money

Um, no. I have no idea why you would assume that.

Candy Kappa
04-25-2009, 03:19 AM
I'd be intresting if a dvd with short movies was released with stories from different writers and different art workers, simmilar to Gotham Knight.

trustno1
04-25-2009, 03:28 AM
Um, no. I have no idea why you would assume that.

um, because, um I thought he might want to um get involved as a producer um somehow.

I'd be intresting if a dvd with short movies was released with stories from different writers and different art workers, simmilar to Gotham Knight.

that's a cool idea! "tales of the tmnt"!

Aztec General
04-26-2009, 09:07 PM
I too would love a "Tales of the TMNT" animated anthology to coincide with this film. But I still think Tristan is the man for the screenplay job!

Lord Nightwalker
04-27-2009, 11:23 PM
Look, It's hard to say who they'll end up with, or that it would be any of our fan favorite choices. I think there are several who could do it justice, Tristan included, But I would be happy if they put together a team of talented writers/Directors and work with Pete, Tristan, Murph...(I know Murph would probably not want to get involved now, but the guy wrote some realy good stuff) and just crank out the coolest true to the heart of the Mirage TMNT story they possibly can.
Think outside the box a bit, if necessary...Just make sure it's something enjoyible. And not pandering to every fanboy whim...That does not always turn out to well.... To many differing opinions and all...
But make a collaborative effort to kick ass.
Man...I could picture them fighting a realy pissed off psychotic RatKing in an epic free for all in the follow up....
There is so much potential...I just do not want them to waste it.

Andrew NDB
04-28-2009, 02:06 AM
Tristan Jones could deliver a hell of a screenplay but the truth is that it doesn't matter who writes it... unless there's a director with some clout attached, it's going to be written (or rewritten) by committee to appeal to toddlers and toy-fandanglers.

Aztec General
05-09-2009, 04:23 PM
Tristan Jones could deliver a hell of a screenplay but the truth is that it doesn't matter who writes it... unless there's a director with some clout attached, it's going to be written (or rewritten) by committee to appeal to toddlers and toy-fandanglers.

There is always that potential, but if you start off with quality you are more likely to end up with quality. Look at the last film: Kevin Munroe promised us a return to TMNT "roots"; instead his storyline made ZERO sense, was entirely stupid, and didn't feel like a TMNT story at all. At least by having a writer who has written Mirage TMNT exceptionally well before hand, we'll be more likely to get a story that resembles the TMNT that we all know and love.

The 2007 film was a clear example of what happens when Mirage let's outsiders unfamiliar with the source material (or at least unwilling to use the source material) do the story writing.

trustno1
05-09-2009, 09:02 PM
they were also willing to give kevin a shot and he had less to do with the turtles than tristan does. he also wrote a live show that is touring australia as part of the 25th anniversary and came up through film school (at least that is what he says in his interviews). i do not see how the two are all that different, except that kevin gave us an okay movie with some characterizations that were spot on and tristan has given us asskicking comics that have hit just about every mark so far.

Scandia
05-10-2009, 07:37 PM
Add me to the list of people who think Tristan should write the script indeed.

The Shelf
05-25-2009, 12:02 PM
There is always that potential, but if you start off with quality you are more likely to end up with quality. Look at the last film: Kevin Munroe promised us a return to TMNT "roots"; instead his storyline made ZERO sense, was entirely stupid, and didn't feel like a TMNT story at all. At least by having a writer who has written Mirage TMNT exceptionally well before hand, we'll be more likely to get a story that resembles the TMNT that we all know and love.

The 2007 film was a clear example of what happens when Mirage let's outsiders unfamiliar with the source material (or at least unwilling to use the source material) do the story writing.

Anyone else find this ironic coming from a guy named Aztec General? :P

Aztec General
05-25-2009, 01:18 PM
Anyone else find this ironic coming from a guy named Aztec General? :P

1) The origin of my use of this name long predates the 2007 film (although not on these boards).

2) The film featured Mayan warriors from Guatemala, not Aztec warriors.

Dan
07-24-2009, 12:55 PM
[QUOTE=Aztec General;686816]
Could you imagine a TMNT film written by Tristan Jones, directed by Zak Snyder (a professed TMNT fanboy), based on the Mirage comics, and rated PG-13?[QUOTE/] Synder doesn't even know who Shredder is. And why doesn't Jones call up and say he wants to do the screenplay?

Aztec General
07-24-2009, 04:07 PM
Synder doesn't even know who Shredder is. And why doesn't Jones call up and say he wants to do the screenplay?

I'm not sure why you bumped this thread but to correct your errors:

1) Yes he does. He has stated that he is a HUGE fan of Mirage TMNT comics.

2) That's his business. I suppose they wanted to go another direction. The Young Guns, Hidalgo direction apparently...:roll:

The Shelf
07-24-2009, 04:54 PM
1) Yes he does. He has stated that he is a HUGE fan of Mirage TMNT comics.

He claimed to be a big fan, but didn't he have a hard time even remembering that Shredder was called Shredder? I'm pretty sure that's what Dan is referring to.