PDA

View Full Version : Are you disappointed or excited that Kevin Munroe is not working on the new movie?


CyberCubed
04-24-2009, 12:16 AM
So it seems Kevin Munroe won't be part of the next movie in any fashion. What are your thoughts on this matter?

R-iZZy
04-24-2009, 12:26 AM
It's not really such a bad thing. Every TMNT movie has had a different director, so it's not like we're experiencing anything new. I dunno, I think he did a pretty good job capturing the Turtles in a cheery light, but I can't say I'd be too confident in him capturing the Turtles in a darker atmosphere.

Kendamu
04-24-2009, 12:26 AM
I like Kevin Munroe. He was connected to the fanbase and he did his best with what he had to work with. However, I hope someone with a bigger name who has worked well with comic book movies before gets attached so that he doesn't get forced into the PG zone.

Jester
04-24-2009, 12:40 AM
I dunna Goonga. He didn't just direct the film...he wrote it too.

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 01:11 AM
I'm rather excited. He's a nice guy, not a good director though.

sdp
04-24-2009, 01:14 AM
I don't care. TMNT was not a bad movie but it failed to really excite me and failed to deliver. Its still a good movie but nothing to make me want him back, I'd rather have someone new.


I remember when I first read that Kevin Monroe wouldn't be in a sequel of TMNT I was very upset, but looking back now I don't see why. If it was a CGI sequel then yeah maybe I would have wanted him back just to see if he had planned things for the next movie in his mind like I believe he mentioned.

Cipher
04-24-2009, 11:52 AM
I'm ambivalent. The original movie was good in 1990. Now, should Mirage and partners choose to stick in their heels, we can do better.

EDIT- For some reason, I thought Kevin Munroe was the director of the original movie. Rewrite my take as "relieved."

cqb101
04-24-2009, 12:21 PM
Not gonna say I'm excited, more like relieved. I didn't really care for the CGI film and I'm definitely ready for a new take.

Aztec General
04-24-2009, 03:29 PM
He seemed like a really nice and very dedicated guy. He also seemed to really care about the TMNT.


BUT...
He can't write a coherent story for ****. So I'm glad he's out.

Kendamu
04-24-2009, 03:34 PM
I dunna Goonga. He didn't just direct the film...he wrote it too.
Yeah, and he still had to cut some stuff out (stuff that was in the trailer) to make it PG. Sure, outside of the fanbase the movie made little sense because the context was assumed, but it was still a decent movie.

Raven
04-24-2009, 03:51 PM
I liked how Kevin approuched the fan base, he really did try to make an all around fun version of the turtles. Problem was no one cared, he's got a good eye but his story telling was set to gentle for my taste.

He has a great nack for dialogue, thats one thing that one me over right away. Plus he help progress the turtles in film so we could get past the whole Leo and Raph fighting in every film, so if he did contunie we might have seen a different relationship amongst the brothers.

But thats a what if, Im just excited where getting another movie in live actione. Even if it is CGI turtles, I hope they do a good enough job to keep it going.

MrPliggins
04-24-2009, 04:34 PM
To be honest, I get bored while watching TMNT 2k7. I love the visuals, but it's not enough. I think it's a good idea to try someone new this time around.

Roseangelo
04-24-2009, 06:55 PM
Kevin got disassociated from any possible sequel about 2 years ago, so I'm not disappointed he's not involved because I wasn't expecting him to be.

Nelson
04-24-2009, 07:36 PM
Kevin got disassociated from any possible sequel about 2 years ago, so I'm not disappointed he's not involved because I wasn't expecting him to be.

But what IF you expected him to?

I'm with most of you. Liked the movie but felt that it lacked some punch.

willtupper
04-25-2009, 02:05 AM
I personally am more disappointed that Woody Allen isn't working on the new movie. I think that would be the most HILARIOUS THING IN HISTORY. The whole movie would be the Turtles in April's apartment, arguing about existentialism and the absence of meaning to our humdrum lives.

And Splinter could dress up as a giant sperm! Casey could wear tweed sportcoats with elbows on the patches! Raphael would wear devil horns, and take Leo in an elevator down to HELL.

It would be so funny! BEST. IDEA. EVER!

TristanHuwJones
04-25-2009, 02:44 AM
I vote David Lynch.

Cipher
04-25-2009, 02:49 AM
I personally am more disappointed that Woody Allen isn't working on the new movie. I think that would be the most HILARIOUS THING IN HISTORY. The whole movie would be the Turtles in April's apartment, arguing about existentialism and the absence of meaning to our humdrum lives.

And Splinter could dress up as a giant sperm! Casey could wear tweed sportcoats with elbows on the patches! Raphael would wear devil horns, and take Leo in an elevator down to HELL.

It would be so funny! BEST. IDEA. EVER!Actually...Yes.

cqb101
04-25-2009, 10:22 AM
I personally am more disappointed that Woody Allen isn't working on the new movie. I think that would be the most HILARIOUS THING IN HISTORY. The whole movie would be the Turtles in April's apartment, arguing about existentialism and the absence of meaning to our humdrum lives.

And Splinter could dress up as a giant sperm! Casey could wear tweed sportcoats with elbows on the patches! Raphael would wear devil horns, and take Leo in an elevator down to HELL.

It would be so funny! BEST. IDEA. EVER!

At the very least, it would be more memorable than the CGI film.

willtupper
04-25-2009, 05:20 PM
What CGI film?

(See what I did there? :D)

At the very least, it would be more memorable than the CGI film.

Dragon Turtle
04-27-2009, 10:21 PM
What CGI film?

(See what I did there? :D)



No. What did you do?:tconfuse:

jalexbrown
05-07-2009, 01:57 PM
Eh. On one hand, I really thought Munroe was attached to the source. He did seem to care about the source material, even if the fact that he was a no-name director at the time forced him into PG land with the 4th movie. Given the reception of the 4th movie, though, the reigns would be tighter on him this time if he could get on for the 5th movie at all. Overall, I'm not disappointed, but I think it's totally possible that they end up with someone even worse doing the 5th movie. It really mostly depends to me on who is replacing Munroe.

thebrownranger
05-07-2009, 02:56 PM
I'm rather excited. He's a nice guy, not a good director though.
Totally agreed.

I'd love for either Peter Jackson or Steve Barron to direct. Maybe they could work together.:D Who knows?

gobo
05-07-2009, 03:10 PM
Are you disappointed or excited that Kevin Munroe is not working on the new movie?
A little of both... He's a great guy, and I wish he had the honor of being brought back for a directorial encore, but... I find the uncertainty both exciting and horrifying. If they were to go with a popular director, I'd feel like history's repeating itself. But, if they go with Steve Barron... ^_^ No to Pete Jackson though... I don't think anyone but us hardcores would sit through a 3-hour Turtles movie.

Lil G
05-07-2009, 05:12 PM
What CGI film?

(See what I did there? :D)

I do. He's saying it's not that memorable, so willtupper's saying he doesn't remember it. That's a good one.

Andrew NDB
05-08-2009, 02:16 AM
My thoughts aren't much on the matter. While I absolutely believe that Munroe had and has a badass TMNT movie in his heart and brain that would make me and any other Mirage TMNT fan cream in our pants (that bares little resemblance to the movie with his name on it a couple of years ago)... I also know that he simply doesn't have the pull or the track record to make such a movie (or his true vision) happen without butting heads and ultimately losing to the studio bigwigs/financiers.

However, since the as-of-yet still not greenlit fifth movie is beginning studio-first with no director or anything attached yet... I have absolutely zero confidence that Munroe's successor will be even the slightest bit more esteemed or carry any more pull and will just, as Munroe did, end up as a filter for the financiers, toy fandanglers, and studio committees wanting to maximize rapage of the toddler/children's market.

Ra
05-08-2009, 05:09 AM
*pokes her head in*

Hm... I'm rather excited actually. As far as a sleep-deprived teenager can get. It'll be interesting to see what happens. As long as it doesn't go belly up in the water. (TMNT 3 anyone?).

jalexbrown
05-08-2009, 09:42 AM
@Andrew_NDB:
I'm pretty sure I've read that the movie's already been greenlit.

Andrew NDB
05-08-2009, 05:03 PM
@Andrew_NDB:
I'm pretty sure I've read that the movie's already been greenlit.

Wrong. It's not even officially in pre-production yet.

steve
05-12-2009, 12:18 PM
Kevin Monroe was a first time director and was handling a failing franchise. TNMT was a desperate attempt to regain their popularity in the theaters like the smashing first movie.

I do believe that kevin did a good job. With that said Anyone directing a movie VIA the COMMITTEE is going to have HUGE troubles. I don't care who you are when your good ideas are constantly struck down and dumbed down its worthless.

I think the more IMPORTANT question here is ... Will this next movie be made by committee? Or will they just trust the director they choose and the screenwriter they choose.

If they dont do these things Spielberg can direct this movie and it will still flop.

TMNTD
07-19-2009, 06:00 PM
Oh please NO Kevin Munroe. He's the Micheal Bay of the Turtles Franchise.

ToTheNines
07-19-2009, 09:07 PM
Oh please NO Kevin Munroe. He's the Micheal Bay of the Turtles Franchise.

That's a pretty dumb thing to say. I guess if you don't like either of them I see the connection, but they're different in so many ways I could write a novel about it.

sdp
07-20-2009, 01:51 AM
Like I mentioned earlier, the fact that we're getting a new live action movie makes up for any dissapointment.

But I LOVED the designs for the movie and now that I saw the movie for a third time I enjoyed it even more. Its a big shame we won't see anything else from this continuity, would have loved a sequel with Monroe to see how his vision of a turtles franchise turned out, though in reality I would have taken anything from Imagi...

TMNTD
07-20-2009, 01:56 PM
That's a pretty dumb thing to say. I guess if you don't like either of them I see the connection, but they're different in so many ways I could write a novel about it.

Wow, I almost forgot how sensitive cats on this forum can be when somebody actually has their OWN OPINION about things. No, Homie, I was comparing the two because Alot of TF fans felt that Bay f&*ked up their vison of transformers, just like I feel Munroe did my vison of turtles. Let me know when that " 1001 ways Kevin Munroe is different from Micheal Bay " novel comes out. I'm sure with u writing it, it will be on and poppin, and what's hot in the streets. I'm sure the girls will love it.

ToTheNines
07-20-2009, 04:17 PM
Wow, I almost forgot how sensitive cats on this forum can be when somebody actually has their OWN OPINION about things. No, Homie, I was comparing the two because Alot of TF fans felt that Bay f&*ked up their vison of transformers, just like I feel Munroe did my vison of turtles. Let me know when that " 1001 ways Kevin Munroe is different from Micheal Bay " novel comes out. I'm sure with u writing it, it will be on and poppin, and what's hot in the streets. I'm sure the girls will love it.

I'm the sensitive one? Sorry if I came off as being rude, but I'm just discussing **** with ya.

Andrew NDB
07-20-2009, 04:32 PM
I was comparing the two because Alot of TF fans felt that Bay f&*ked up their vison of transformers, just like I feel Munroe did my vison of turtles.

Difference being... Bay made exactly the movie he wanted to make and Munroe wasn't allowed to make the movie he wanted to make. At all.

If Munroe had Bay-level clout in Hollywood, I suspect we would have gotten something pretty awesome.

TMNTD
07-20-2009, 07:03 PM
I'm the sensitive one? Sorry if I came off as being rude, but I'm just discussing **** with ya.

No problem. I just kinda took offense when u said " It was a dumb thing to say " instead of just asking me to explain why I said it.

TMNTD
07-20-2009, 07:07 PM
Difference being... Bay made exactly the movie he wanted to make and Munroe wasn't allowed to make the movie he wanted to make. At all.

If Munroe had Bay-level clout in Hollywood, I suspect we would have gotten something pretty awesome.

U may be right Andrew. But I just didn't appreciate the " Ghostbusters/Pokemon" storyline, and I'm not a big fan of CGI animated movies.

Andrew NDB
07-20-2009, 08:44 PM
What CGI film?

(See what I did there? :D)

No. What did you do?:tconfuse:

What he did was he probably summed up the general moviegoing public's thoughts on the last movie.

U may be right Andrew. But I just didn't appreciate the " Ghostbusters/Pokemon" storyline

Nor did I.

and I'm not a big fan of CGI animated movies.

I could have lived with that if not for the former. And other toddler-pandering nonsense.

Ralphmacchio
07-28-2009, 08:35 PM
Nice guy to talk to when he was on here but I really didn't dig the final product.

I felt like there wasn't enough turtles and that the paper thin plot forced them to service a very poorly done science fiction story when it should have focused solely on the turtles.

I enjoy Patrick Stewart but his character was dull, boring and totally not interesting. I didn't care for the characterization of Casey Jones or April O Neil.

RAPHAEL#1fan
08-04-2009, 12:26 PM
Kevin Munroe did a great job on TMNT imo but it really doesn't bother me if he comes back or not.

CJStyles
08-05-2009, 01:00 AM
It's redundant at this point, but I do feel we need someone else on the new film. If TMNT did get a really big Hollywood director on the project that'd be awesome.

Aztec General
08-05-2009, 10:57 AM
If TMNT did get a really big Hollywood director on the project that'd be awesome.

Never going to happen. It will be some cheap, unknown, borderline hack. That seems to be the route that Mirage has been going these days unfortunately.

shuriken
09-17-2009, 10:49 AM
Never going to happen. It will be some cheap, unknown, borderline hack. That seems to be the route that Mirage has been going these days unfortunately.

I love your optimism:).
Honestly I don't really care who directs it. I will watch the damn movie regardless, just like I watched the last one. Will I enjoy it I dunno, did I enjoy the last one, not so much.
I just wish the person that directs and or writes the movie will be able to give us a good solid movie that doesn't have a sh*tty plot or ridiculously boring characters.

Warhorse
09-22-2009, 06:37 PM
I love your optimism:).
Honestly I don't really care who directs it. I will watch the damn movie regardless, just like I watched the last one. Will I enjoy it I dunno, did I enjoy the last one, not so much.
I just wish the person that directs and or writes the movie will be able to give us a good solid movie that doesn't have a sh*tty plot or ridiculously boring characters.

And someone who is familiar with the Turtles, not just someone who gets handed the job and has to do a 24 hour crash study.