PDA

View Full Version : Who should direct?


Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 12:41 AM
An Opinion piece up on GGM. Think I'm right, tell me. Think I'm wrong? Tell me.

http://gogreenmachine.wordpress.com/2009/04/24/speculation-o-rama-why-zack-snyder-should-and-probably-is-going-to-direct-the-next-ninja-turtles-movie/

[Mod Edit: Merged with the "Who should direct?" poll thread beginning here.]

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 01:04 AM
Is it just me or did this part stick out to anyone else?

ZS: The only title I really collected to this day is the original TMNT (Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles).

NRAMA: The Eastman and Laird black and white series from Mirage?

ZS: Exactly. All that stuff, what’s the guy’s name they always fought?

NRAMA: Shredder.

It worries me that a fan would forget Shredder Lol

I see this potentially happening but honestly I am not a fan of the idea. 300 had my interest for about a half hour before I had enough.
I am not even going to go into Watchmen but it was largely disappointing.

I am not going to discredit him as far as style because he definitely has it but style just isn't enough in my book.

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:05 AM
As I've said else where, he does tend to be pretty faithful when he does adaptations, but his previous works were adaptations of graphic novels, how is he gonna deal with a 25 year old comic series with over 2 decades of continuity and stories?

EDIT and Tinnsy, Shredder wasn't even "that guy they always fought" in the comics...they blew him up in issue one and he wasn't dealt with again for another 13 (including "microseries" issues...which is really no time in comics isn't it. But yeah, any true Turtle fan, even if it's just an old toon guy like me would know Tin Skin.

Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 01:07 AM
Differing opinions already! I love this stuff <3

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 01:09 AM
You saw "Watchmen" right? I wasn't even that close to the course material of it and I could still say he raped it. Turtles is about as close as I can possibly get to source material, him touching it will only lead to disaster.

If Zack Snyder directs the movie this is what will happen
1. Every action sequence will be in slow motion.
2. There will be gallons of unnecessary blood.
3. Inappropriate music thrown in.
4. The film will be hallow and lifeless.
5. He doesn't even know the turtles main villain is Shredder.

He's the only director on the planet who can create a film that makes me feel nothing. I felt nothing watching either of his movies. Not a single scene sparked any form of emotion in me, be it excitement or sadness. That's pathetic in my book, film is all about emotion and every scene is supposed to be carried by it. If there's no emotion behind a scene then it shouldn't be present. I wasn't the only one who noticed this, the people I went with to those films also felt the same way. I'd rather see an actual director do the film not some putz like him.

Thankfully it'll never happen because his dance card is full for the next few years
Cobalt 60 (2011) (announced)
Heavy Metal (2010) (announced)
The Illustrated Man (2010) (announced)
Untitled 300 Sequel (2010) (announced)
Sucker Punch (2010) (pre-production)
Guardians of Ga'Hoole (2010) (filming)

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 01:18 AM
As I've said else where, he does tend to be pretty faithful when he does adaptations, but his previous works were adaptations of graphic novels, how is he gonna deal with a 25 year old comic series with over 2 decades of continuity and stories?

EDIT and Tinnsy, Shredder wasn't even "that guy they always fought" in the comics...they blew him up in issue one and he wasn't dealt with again for another 13 (including "microseries" issues...which is really no time in comics isn't it. But yeah, any true Turtle fan, even if it's just an old toon guy like me would know Tin Skin.

I know what you are saying but you also know that is exactly who he meant (Just because notoriously it is Shredder). I wouldn't have even pointed it out if he had named off a few characters instead of the interviewer filling in the blanks lol

Good point about the graphic novels adaptions, I didn't even think about that.

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:19 AM
I wonder what Kevin Smith's take on TMNT would be...
*pictures Clerks/TMNT hybrid*
Ok, never mind...

But that said, who? TMNT isn't a Spider-man or a Batman. What name (read-good) directer is gonna sign on to an indy comic movie that is more well known as a cartoon with an evil brain and mutant boar and rhino henchmen?

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 01:25 AM
But that said, who? TMNT isn't a Spider-man or a Batman. What name (read-good) directer is gonna sign on to an indy comic movie that is more well known as a cartoon with an evil brain and mutant boar and rhino henchmen?

Lexi Alexander hands down. I could also name off some others I think would do a good job and might even do it but they are all busy with other projects at the moment.

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:26 AM
Call up Steve Barron. I'm sure he'd do it...:P

EDIT: Wait? The director of Punisher: War Zone? O...k...

Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 01:27 AM
But that said, who? TMNT isn't a Spider-man or a Batman. What name (read-good) directer is gonna sign on to an indy comic movie that is more well known as a cartoon with an evil brain and mutant boar and rhino henchmen?

Uwe Boll! <3

sdp
04-24-2009, 01:29 AM
I really liked 300 and Watchmen, thought he did a great job in both.


However I definitely do not want him doing TMNT, his style just wouldn't work for the movie.

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:31 AM
Uwe Boll! <3
Well heck Steve why not just have Ulli Lommel (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0518579/) do it?

That man is the worst director ever...I don't know how many movies of his I got tricked into by titles. I now know to check and see if he's the director....GAHHH just awful.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 01:33 AM
Lexi Alexander was Oscar nominated for a short film and she has also done a comic adaption. This is where I fear mentioning this but Punisher War zone.
Just hear me out for a moment.
Sure the critics ripped the movie a new one but she did her part right.
If you have ever read Punisher then you would know that her version came closest to the Marvel vision. She used the color scheme from the comics in the setup of every scene, she was meticulous right down to the color of the props in the movie. Yes the action was over the top but so was the violence in the comic book.
She was also a world karate and kickboxing champion and fight choreographer.
She also favors green in her films :P you see it in green street hooligans and Punisher

I hear Green Street Hooligans is a great film btw, I have yet to watch it but I did watch her behind the scenes on set and she is pretty darn amazing. She even went through military boot camp training with the lead actor in Punisher. Now that is dedication!

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 01:34 AM
Call up Steve Barron. I'm sure he'd do it...:P

EDIT: Wait? The director of Punisher: War Zone? O...k...

Yes she directed that, but she didn't write it. While every critic slammed it there wasn't one of them who doubted the production value was top notch. She also directed "Green Street Hooligans" which had a good script and was a great movie.

She can make a good film, liking Punisher and appreciating it for what it was, a film that obviously didn't take itself seriously, is a matter of opinion but you can't dispute that it was well made. She even went as far to shoot every scene with only 3 colors so it looks like a comic panel. She loves to play with color and her favorite color is green. Either way she shot the script she was handed so I can hardly blame her for the story. Though personally I thought the movie was hilarious.

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:38 AM
Lexi Alexander was Oscar nominated for a short film and she has also done a comic adaption. This is where I fear mentioning this but Punisher War zone.
Just hear me out for a moment.
Sure the critics ripped the movie a new one but she did her part right.
If you have ever read Punisher then you would know that her version came closest to the Marvel vision. She used the color scheme from the comics in the setup of every scene, she was meticulous right down to the color of the props in the movie. Yes the action was over the top but so was the violence in the comic book.
She was also a world karate and kickboxing champion and fight choreographer.
She also favors green in her films :P you see it in green street hooligans and Punisher

I hear Green Street Hooligans is a great film btw, I have yet to watch it but I did watch her behind the scenes on set and she is pretty darn amazing. She even went through military boot camp training with the lead actor in Punisher. Now that is dedication!

Yes she directed that, but she didn't write it. While every critic slammed it there wasn't one of them who doubted the production value was top notch. She also directed "Green Street Hooligans" which had a good script and was a great movie.

She can make a good film, liking Punisher and appreciating it for what it was, a film that obviously didn't take itself seriously, is a matter of opinion but you can't dispute that it was well made. She even went as far to shoot every scene with only 3 colors so it looks like a comic panel. She loves to play with color and her favorite color is green. Either way she shot the script she was handed so I can hardly blame her for the story. Though personally I thought the movie was hilarious.

Do you 2 plan these things or do they just happen? :P

Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 01:40 AM
Do you 2 plan these things or do they just happen? :P

*Psst* They live together (I think?)

I'm pretty sure they are cheating :-P

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 01:41 AM
yeah...funny enough we talked about it last night after we heard the movie news. We were discussing directors and Zack Snyder was actually in our "dread" pile. I mentioned Lexi because I thought she could pull of City at War if we ever got it.

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:42 AM
*Psst* They live together (I think?)

I'm pretty sure they are cheating :-P
See I thought that, but they are on 2 separate machines or logging out and in....

True, a director doesn't the story make....always (Again, looking at you Munroe!!) and I am only going on Punisher and my dislike of balls-out action movies in general, but her filmography isn't very large...then again Marvel did think she was worthy of Punisher...wait...is "worthy" the right word?

TristanHuwJones
04-24-2009, 01:43 AM
Joe Johnson. Just putting that out there. Gavin Hood as another contender.

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 01:44 AM
See I thought that, but they are on 2 seperate machines or loging out and in....

We don't discuss forum related things in real life so anything similar said by us is coincidence. Did get a good laugh out of me though.

Joe Johnson. Just putting that out there.
I'm really interested in his upcoming "Wolfman" film. He might be a good one to tackle it.

TristanHuwJones
04-24-2009, 01:45 AM
Yes she directed that, but she didn't write it. While every critic slammed it there wasn't one of them who doubted the production value was top notch. She also directed "Green Street Hooligans" which had a good script and was a great movie.

She can make a good film, liking Punisher and appreciating it for what it was, a film that obviously didn't take itself seriously, is a matter of opinion but you can't dispute that it was well made. She even went as far to shoot every scene with only 3 colors so it looks like a comic panel. She loves to play with color and her favorite color is green. Either way she shot the script she was handed so I can hardly blame her for the story. Though personally I thought the movie was hilarious.

Wasn't she fired from that movie at some point?

Dragon Turtle
04-24-2009, 01:46 AM
But that said, who? TMNT isn't a Spider-man or a Batman. What name (read-good) directer is gonna sign on to an indy comic movie that is more well known as a cartoon with an evil brain and mutant boar and rhino henchmen?


How many comic book movies get "name" directors with a track record for doing comic book movies? And who knows what other directors out there like TMNT.

We'll likely get a director who may have directed a somewhat acclaimed film, who you wouldn't think about directing a TMNT film.

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:47 AM
How many comic book movies get "name" directors with a track record for doing comic book movies? And who knows what other directors out there like TMNT.

We'll likely get a director who may have directed a somewhat acclaimed film, who you wouldn't think about directing a TMNT film.
I guess my mind goes to Sam Rami...not a comic book director, loves Spidey, and a fairly well respected director.

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 01:47 AM
Wasn't she fired from that movie at some point?

No that was a rumor.

Her absence at San Diego Comic Con 2008 helped fuel rumors that she has been taken off the project due to creative differences, but these rumors were dispelled by the film's cinematographer Steve Gainer. In a subsequent December 2008 interview[1] Alexander confirmed that she had had serious battles with Lionsgate, but denied that she was ever officially off the movie. "My name was never off, nor would I want it taken off, nor did I ever get a pink slip. The truth is that we had probably the same discussions that any other film has."

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 01:49 AM
Joe Johnson. Just putting that out there. Gavin Hood as another contender.

I did like Hidalgo very much but it looks like he is doing Capt. America slated to come out in 2011.

There were a lot of rumors about Punisher when Tom Jane and the director decided to leave for creative difference (I read somewhere way back during pre-production of the film) I think she stepped in after all that happen.

Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 01:51 AM
Peter Jackson. Discuss.

TristanHuwJones
04-24-2009, 01:51 AM
Cool. Thanks for clearing that up. I still say Joe Johnson though. I'll be honest in saying that I wouldn't have a problem with Snyder though. I really, thoroughly enjoyed Dawn of the Dead and dug Watchmen. But it's unlikely with the schedule he has.

So long as the Anderson fool that made Death Race doesn't get it. He's only one up from Uwe Boll but still got Aliens VS Predator for some ridiculous reason.

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:53 AM
Peter Jackson. Discuss.
That name crossed my mind....as a joke. He'd never touch it...I don't think...

My crazed sleep deprived mind also lept to TIM BURTON!!

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 01:54 AM
Peter Jackson. Discuss.
Peter Jackson is booked solid for awhile with Hobbits lol

Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 01:55 AM
Peter Jackson is booked solid for awhile with Hobbits lol

Ah, but the question remains...would he be good for it?

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:56 AM
Uh...That Steven Spielberg guy? Is he available?

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 01:56 AM
James Cameron would rock all your worlds.

Wait I got it....

George Lucas! Come on he made "Howard the Duck" that's a comic movie right?

Jester
04-24-2009, 01:57 AM
Orsen Wells....ORSEN WELLS...wait....:( He's dead.

TristanHuwJones
04-24-2009, 01:58 AM
James Cameron would rock all your worlds.

Not these days, he's more likely to drown it than anything else. I swear the man is really a mermaid that made some deal with a sea witch.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 01:58 AM
Ah, but the question remains...would he be good for it?

Nah too much the fantasy epic guy but give me Guillermo Del Torro :tthumbsu:
Also, a busy man (darn those Hobbits) but I love him!

Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 01:58 AM
Uh...That Steven Spielberg guy? Is he available?

He already was part of that other childhood crushing sh*tfest...that thing with the robots.... So he might as well come full circle and completely decimate it.

Do I think he WOULD do it? Maybe...hes been getting him hands on stuff that isnt par for the course for him lately (the previously mentioned suckfest, as well as casual gaming like Boomblox)

Edit: is the drome not auto senoring anymore? I had to bleep myself

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 02:00 AM
Orsen Wells....ORSEN WELLS...wait....:( He's dead.

Jester you are cracking me up hahaha every time I refresh the thread I am laughing

Jester
04-24-2009, 02:02 AM
It's the sleep deprivation talking...I assure you.

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 02:02 AM
War Of the Worlds was a great film, so was Munich, Minority Report, and like almost every other movie he's made. He evolved as a director in my opinion. You can bag on Tom Cruise all you want those films were solid. I don't take my childhood into consideration when watching movies. Also he didn't make it like the original because he didn't want people to think he was ripping off "Independence Day".

Wait why am I getting serious?

Anyways I say again George Jar Jar Lucas. "Howard the Duck" totally ruled...
http://blogs.e-rockford.com/movieman/files/2009/03/howard-the-duck_l.jpg

Archon_Turtle
04-24-2009, 02:03 AM
Orsen Wells....ORSEN WELLS...wait....:( He's dead.

I almost said Zombie Jim Henson...too soon?

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 02:05 AM
Alright last one...

Stuart Gillard!

Points to whoever gets that one.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 02:07 AM
I almost said Zombie Jim Henson...too soon?

Aww Jim Henson, that hurt Archon :P
The Henson Company should get involved, someone get Brian Henson on the line!

Jester
04-24-2009, 02:08 AM
Gah....why did you remind me...Human Jukebox Syndrome, kicking in....DAMN IT!!!
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3215/3148290765_f9b8428a71.jpg
Ohhhh Duck Tits. OooooOoooo!
Curse you Nostalgia Critic!!

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 02:09 AM
Alright last one...

Stuart Gillard!

Points to whoever gets that one.

Blasphemer!!!!

Secondly...God Jester, why? I am going to have nightmares about that picture.

Jester
04-24-2009, 02:09 AM
I actually liked that movie...better than 2....story wise that is.

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 02:13 AM
I actually liked that movie...better than 2....story wise that is.

You dead to me can opener!
http://z.about.com/d/animatedtv/1/0/h/C/harvey_in_court1.jpg

Jester
04-24-2009, 02:14 AM
What can I say, I'm a slave to the time travel story line...TO THE DELORIAN!!!
http://i2.current.com/images/epg/ride/BackToTheDeLorean/1_400x300.jpg

Dragon Turtle
04-24-2009, 02:32 AM
I guess my mind goes to Sam Rami...not a comic book director, loves Spidey, and a fairly well respected director.

But before Spider-Man he wasn't a big time director, just a cult favorite.

funatic
04-24-2009, 04:14 AM
Robert Rodriguez anyone? I thought he did an excellent job with Sin City - recapturing the nitty-gritty black and white style and stories. I mean, the first Turtles comic paid considerable homage to the Frank Miller method... Plus, Rodriguez has proved to be successful in the kids movie market with his Spy Kidz series... If he could hit the middle ground between his stylized violent adult movies and campy creative kids movies - I think we would be in perfect turtle territory. (Though he may be a bit busy with Sin City sequels the next coupe years...)

TristanHuwJones
04-24-2009, 04:20 AM
I like the way you think... but I don't want Rose MacGowan as April :P

Candy Kappa
04-24-2009, 04:58 AM
Robert Rodriguez anyone?
yes please:D

Ralphmacchio
04-24-2009, 07:04 AM
When the new producer mentioned at the gallabunga that he was in on 300, I seriously started to think of a Zack Snyder Turtles movie. You might be dead right on this one dude. But, maybe Spike Jonze will want it.

VaughnMichael
04-24-2009, 07:06 AM
I honestly hope not, I hate 300 and have yet to see watchmen but I'm sure i'll agree with spitfire, he and i have very similar tastes.

Jester
04-24-2009, 07:34 AM
Robert Rodriguez anyone? I thought he did an excellent job with Sin City - recapturing the nitty-gritty black and white style and stories. I mean, the first Turtles comic paid considerable homage to the Frank Miller method... Plus, Rodriguez has proved to be successful in the kids movie market with his Spy Kidz series... If he could hit the middle ground between his stylized violent adult movies and campy creative kids movies - I think we would be in perfect turtle territory. (Though he may be a bit busy with Sin City sequels the next coupe years...)
Hmmm....that's a good point. Can I change my vote to Rodriguez?

Ralphmacchio
04-24-2009, 07:58 AM
I honestly hope not, I hate 300 and have yet to see watchmen but I'm sure i'll agree with spitfire, he and i have very similar tastes.

Yeah, but 300 was exactly how it was in the comic book. 300 is just a bad source material and Watchmen is too cryptic for the general movie going audience. If he's faithful as that to the story of the TMNT then it should be golden.

gobo
04-24-2009, 09:46 AM
I sure wouldn't be happy about it. The man doesn't seem to remember squat about TMNT. It might even turn out enjoyable, but I'd still feel like they've been sold out again (like they were with Saban and Image).

cqb101
04-24-2009, 10:04 AM
I said it in the other thread, but I'll say it again...If Zack Snyder is directing, I'm not watching. It's unlikely that he'll even be available to direct though, with his upcoming Sucker Punch movie.

I'm going to agree with whoever said Robert Rodriguez earlier in the thread. I really think he could bring this to the mainstream. Too bad he's way too busy.

I'd also like to see Lexi Alexander direct it. Green Street Hooligans is a great ****ing film and Punisher: War Zone was easily the best Punisher film. She really knows how to direct action and has a strong gritty style.

For some reason John Carpenter keeps coming to mind. No idea why, but he could be an interesting choice.

jerome
04-24-2009, 01:04 PM
rodriguez would be cool. especially since if he directs it he will most likely shoot some of it at austin studios which is literally on the other side of my backyard and I'll be starting my internship there right about time i figure this thing would be shooting...

but he still wouldn't be my first choice. plus his slate is pretty full just like snyders.

how about richard kelly? that might be interesting. or paul greengrass or timur bekmambetov.

and watchmen wasn't bad. 300 was a one trick pony but it worked. You have to admit if snyder did this it would at least look cool...

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 01:52 PM
I said it in the other thread, but I'll say it again...If Zack Snyder is directing, I'm not watching. It's unlikely that he'll even be available to direct though, with his upcoming Sucker Punch movie.

I'm going to agree with whoever said Robert Rodriguez earlier in the thread. I really think he could bring this to the mainstream. Too bad he's way too busy.

I'd also like to see Lexi Alexander direct it. Green Street Hooligans is a great ****ing film and Punisher: War Zone was easily the best Punisher film. She really knows how to direct action and has a strong gritty style.

For some reason John Carpenter keeps coming to mind. No idea why, but he could be an interesting choice.

:tthumbsu: to Lexi

I would be very excited if Rodriguez would have the time/interest to be able to direct Turtles 5.

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 01:59 PM
He doesn't because he's making...

http://www.variety.com/article/VR1118002792.html?categoryid=1237&cs=1

****ing Predator!

Mindy
04-24-2009, 02:14 PM
Uwe Boll! <3

And all around the world, children are crying crimson tears <3 :P

Tinuvielsdreams
04-24-2009, 02:20 PM
He doesn't because he's making...

http://www.variety.com/article/VR1118002792.html?categoryid=1237&cs=1

****ing Predator!

Oh Geesus I bet that just made your entire day :lol:

ToTheNines
04-24-2009, 03:02 PM
Slow-mo blows, that's all I have to say.

Aztec General
04-24-2009, 03:37 PM
Lexi Alexander? You can't possibly be serious? She's AWFUL!!! I'd sooner have Roland Emmerich than Lexi Alexander.

Zak Snyder would be perfect, but his plate looks very full for the foreseeable future so it's unlikely.

Besides people this is Mirage. They are going to get a no name to direct it. Hopefully a no name that can craft a story better than Munroe did.

Raven
04-24-2009, 03:47 PM
I could careless who directs it, just as long as they understand who the turtles are and know the best possible way to bring them to the big screen.

So..dear lord please dont ever let Uwe Boll get his nasty hands on this!

Blade Raider
04-24-2009, 03:51 PM
I hated Watchmen and 300, so no, just no.

odupianist
04-24-2009, 04:27 PM
What can I say, I'm a slave to the time travel story line...TO THE DELORIAN!!!

Where's Zemeckis when you need him?

I hated 300 but enjoyed Watchmen and Dawn of the Dead, so I'm mixed on ZS.

Sam Raimi would be an interesting take on it.

I agree with the Rodriguez bit though.

Bottom line: Story has to kick ass more so than director IMO.

Nelson
04-24-2009, 06:22 PM
People in charge of the new movie, if you are reading this forum...

PLEASE IGNORE THIS THREAD!!


(No, I don't like Snyder. I enjoyed Dawn of the Dead but I'm now I'm sure that it was a fluke)

tortugapower
04-24-2009, 06:47 PM
My bet is on Steve Barron.

He attended the movie screening yesterday in NY which the producers of the new TMNT picture were also at. I have also heard that Peter Laird really likes the guy and has brought him up in the past.

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 09:30 PM
Lexi Alexander? You can't possibly be serious? She's AWFUL!!! I'd sooner have Roland Emmerich than Lexi Alexander.

You've already established that you know absolutely nothing about good film or production value so your opinion is null void. If Lexi was so "awful" she wouldn't have won an oscar for best short film. If you can't appreciate a film for it's production value so be it but don't trash her because you didn't like Punisher: War Zone.

Jester
04-24-2009, 09:46 PM
To be fair, I had a similar reaction, but I'm a story man. Technical stuff aside, the story is key to me. But you're right, Lexi didn't have that to do with Punisher.

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 09:52 PM
To be fair, I had a similar reaction, but I'm a story man. Technical stuff aside, the story is key to me. But you're right, Lexi didn't have that to do with Punisher.

I'm a story man as well, acting is also key. Which the film had terrible acting and a pretty weak story. However I watched it as a dark comedy/B-movie camp spoof and enjoyed it because honestly there's no way in hell you can take the film seriously. Trying to is what's gonna make you hate it. I also apparently have a sick sense of humor because I was one of the few people laughing my ass off at the rocket launcher scene.

I also thought "American Psycho" was funny, I guess I'm a rare breed.

Anyways judging her based off that one film isn't fair cause that movie takes the right kind of person to enjoy it for what it is. I can see why so many people didn't, like I said not everyone finds violence funny. I would however recommend judging her based off of "Green Street Hooligans". I think that movie has both good technical aspects and a good story.

TristanHuwJones
04-24-2009, 09:55 PM
I was one of the few people laughing my ass off at the rocket launcher scene.


The bit at the start with the roofjumpers? I thought that was ****ing hilarious!

Jester
04-24-2009, 09:56 PM
*shrugs*
I watched The Undertaker and his Pals recently and that was a spoof that tried to hard and was a groaner...but I loved every minute.

Aztec General
04-24-2009, 10:22 PM
You've already established that you know absolutely nothing about good film or production value so your opinion is null void. If Lexi was so "awful" she wouldn't have won an oscar for best short film. If you can't appreciate a film for it's production value so be it but don't trash her because you didn't like Punisher: War Zone.

I'll choose to take the high road and not insult you back, even though you've already personally attacked me twice.

How have I "established that I know absolutely nothing about good film or production value"? Because I think Lexi's latest film was awful (and I'm certainly not alone there)? Because I want TMNT treated like the real comic book franchise that it is? Because I want the film to be action packed and serious, in addition to being fun and humorous? Because I fell in love with the source material and I've been waiting forever for it to be properly presented on screen?

I want a well written story aimed for the target audience. Which for this franchise, like other comic book franchises, should be everyone from early teens to young adults. Pumping out a PG film with goofy "monsters" from ancient Guatemala is not exactly what I have in mind. My version of a perfect TMNT reboot film has the urban noir and origin focus of Batman Begins, and the fun filled action feel of Iron Man.

I want this film to be character driven and to take itself seriously. Which is EXACTLY the opposite of what Lexi's Punisher was. If I'm not allowed to judge a director based upon the movies that he/she directs then what am I allowed to judge his/her directing abilities on?

I stand behind my statement: Keep Lexi away from this franchise.

Ralphmacchio
04-24-2009, 10:34 PM
If Del Toro wasn't wrapped up in The Hobbit, he'd be perfect.

Spitfire
04-24-2009, 10:36 PM
I want this film to be character driven and to take itself seriously. Which is EXACTLY the opposite of what Lexi's Punisher was. If I'm not allowed to judge a director based upon the movies that he/she directs then what am I allowed to judge his/her directing abilities on?

I stand behind my statement: Keep Lexi away from this franchise.

To put it bluntly Punisher fans loved the film because it was exactly how the comics are. Therefore she succeeded in making a movie for fans of the franchise. You can take that as you will. As for the rest of your statements more often then not the director has little to do with the story being told in the film. The script is handed to them and they decide if they want to do it or not. From there they apply their style to it and you get your movie. They are also not in charge of casting. Directors do not write action sequences, not even the script witter does there's a whole other person around for that. The things your talking about aren't really a directors job. The few popular directors that do do everything have people confused about what a directors actual job is now a days. It's very seldom one does do all of those things.

What floors me is if someone doesn't like a film it's always the directors fault. I blame the producer for a bad movie because the producer is the one who hires the crew and if you hire a ****** crew you get a ****** movie. The director is one person in a group of a hundred or more who work on the film.

Blade Raider
04-24-2009, 11:44 PM
You saw "Watchmen" right? I wasn't even that close to the course material of it and I could still say he raped it. Turtles is about as close as I can possibly get to source material, him touching it will only lead to disaster.

If Zack Snyder directs the movie this is what will happen
1. Every action sequence will be in slow motion.
2. There will be gallons of unnecessary blood.
3. Inappropriate music thrown in.
4. The film will be hallow and lifeless.
5. He doesn't even know the turtles main villain is Shredder.

He's the only director on the planet who can create a film that makes me feel nothing. I felt nothing watching either of his movies. Not a single scene sparked any form of emotion in me, be it excitement or sadness. That's pathetic in my book, film is all about emotion and every scene is supposed to be carried by it. If there's no emotion behind a scene then it shouldn't be present. I wasn't the only one who noticed this, the people I went with to those films also felt the same way. I'd rather see an actual director do the film not some putz like him.
I agree, his movies are lifeless and boring. It's like I'm watching a bad anime dub where their just reading their lines. At the end of the day, I feel nothing from them.

On a side note, I refuse to pay to see this movie if he's directing. His movies are the only movies I've ever seen where I actually want my money back after it's over.

Slap-Happy
04-26-2009, 02:17 PM
If Del Toro wasn't wrapped up in The Hobbit, he'd be perfect.

I don't know about Del Toro. I keep thinking he would go the Hellboy route and make it a fantasy.

Slap-Happy
04-26-2009, 02:24 PM
Out of all these people who should direct the new movie?Don't know about Snyder, movies are kinda good, but kinda bad

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
04-26-2009, 02:46 PM
It's Steven Spielberg, not "Steven Speilberg" as this poll misspells.

Slap-Happy
04-26-2009, 02:54 PM
It's Steven Spielberg, not "Steven Speilberg" as this poll misspells.
sorry :ohwell:

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
04-26-2009, 03:03 PM
sorry :ohwell:

I begun to hesitate, thinking "Is Steven Speilberg another person"?

Peanut
04-26-2009, 04:35 PM
I voted for Michael Bay because I want Shredder to explode at the end.

Jester
04-26-2009, 04:38 PM
I voted for Michael Bay because I want Shredder to explode at the end.
Nutty-Buddy, you have no idea how that made me laugh....
Man, I need some sleep.

ToTheNines
04-26-2009, 05:50 PM
I begun to hesitate, thinking "Is Steven Speilberg another person"?

Oh yeah, Spielberg has all kinds of dopplegangers floating around Hollywood... Spilberg, Spielbburg, Speeelbirg, Stephon Spielberg, Zpielburgh, Speelyburger.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-26-2009, 06:18 PM
I went on about this for a few pages in the other thread but my vote is in. I would be happy with a few of the people on the poll.

:lol: to Bay exploding Shredder. SO true...

joe-eyeball
04-26-2009, 06:21 PM
The most important thing about this movie is: How big is the budget? Because that wil make a difference in who directs it.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-26-2009, 06:22 PM
The first Hellboy wasn't as stylistic as the second one. He is capable of going less fantastical. I bet if, hypothetically, he did do turtles he would keep in mind just how much fantasy is appropriate.

Jester
04-26-2009, 06:29 PM
I voted Barron, but only because I'd like to see him take another crack at the Turtles. He did do the best of the 4 movies, after all.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-26-2009, 06:41 PM
I voted Barron, but only because I'd like to see him take another crack at the Turtles. He did do the best of the 4 movies, after all.

I do agree the first was my favorite of the 4 films. I wouldn't mind at all if Barron came back. He would all new resources and technology to work with so it would be exciting.

Jester
04-26-2009, 06:52 PM
And a new story...don't forget the new story!

One thing though, rumors swirl that Henson may once again be brought in for this in some copasity. That said, anyone think Kevin Clash will reprise his role as Splinter?

Tinuvielsdreams
04-26-2009, 06:54 PM
And a new story...don't forget the new story!

One thing though, rumors swirl that Henson may once again be brought in for this in some copasity. That said, anyone think Kevin Clash will reprise his role as Splinter?

Well of course!

Sure, why not? He needs a break from Elmo every now and again right?

Vincent
04-26-2009, 07:02 PM
I vote Guillermo. I like his visual style and he's good at balancing fun characters with dark environments and weird creatures and action/adventure. However, I must say that I wouldn't necessarily want him to write it alone. Not sure he could give it the emotional and philosophical depth it needs to truly shine.
I would vote Tarantino, except he's not big on special effects, which might be a limitation.
Joss Whedon should be on the list, methinks. He might be a bit busy, but so's Del Toro. Whedon knows how to write fun and interesting characters with depth and arcs, he knows how to construct a compelling and intellectually stimulating genre story, and his dialogue is simply golden. Fun, pain and philosophy is kind of exactly what the movie needs, and Joss Whedon is pretty much the master of those things. And he knows how to get the best out of the people he works with, as well as how to get as much as possible out of a budget. Also, huge comic geek.

ToTheNines
04-26-2009, 07:03 PM
And a new story...don't forget the new story!

One thing though, rumors swirl that Henson may once again be brought in for this in some copasity. That said, anyone think Kevin Clash will reprise his role as Splinter?

He's my favorite Splinter so that would be cool, but I'm pulling for Ken Watanabe.

Vincent
04-26-2009, 07:18 PM
As much as I look up to Kevin Clash, his accent for Splinter was all over the place, often more Jamaican and Irish than Japanese. I'd prefer if someone who's actually Japanese got the part.

Vincent
04-26-2009, 07:50 PM
Make it fantasy? Wasn't Hellboy fantasy to begin with? I've only read a couple volumes, but I seem to remember it being pulp fantasy, as were the movies. I doubt he'd make TMNT into fantasy, as it's not a fantasy comic. Guillermo worked closely with Mignola in making the Hellboy movies. I'm sure he'd do the same with Laird.

Anyway, him aside, I'd like to mention Joss Whedon. Isn't Laird a fan of Firefly? I seem to remember hearing that somewhere, correct me if I'm wrong. And Joss has proven in his works that he's more than capable of handling an ensemble cast of interesting characters, hitting all the emotional buttons and he has an excellent grasp on genre (he'd pay much attention to the noir and martial arts genre elements of the franchise, as well as balancing funny dialogue with dark emotional drama and philosophical questions). And he proved with Serenity that he knows how to shoot amazing fight scenes. And he's a huge comic book geek. The dude was practically born to do Ninja Turtles.

trustno1
04-26-2009, 08:54 PM
He's my favorite Splinter so that would be cool, but I'm pulling for Ken Watanabe.

ken watanabe should be the voice.

TristanHuwJones
04-26-2009, 09:08 PM
I was just watching Begins again and rechecked The Last Samurai, and I am convinced Watanabe could be a fantastic Splinter. Get him to voice it on set with the puppeteer nearby. One thing I would like to see is a more mobile Splinter though.

Is there a casting thread yet?

Aztec General
04-26-2009, 09:12 PM
Quentin Tarantino? Tim Burton? For a TMNT film? You can't be serious?

Tinuvielsdreams
04-26-2009, 09:20 PM
Anyway, him aside, I'd like to mention Joss Whedon. Isn't Laird a fan of Firefly? I seem to remember hearing that somewhere, correct me if I'm wrong. And Joss has proven in his works that he's more than capable of handling an ensemble cast of interesting characters, hitting all the emotional buttons and he has an excellent grasp on genre (he'd pay much attention to the noir and martial arts genre elements of the franchise, as well as balancing funny dialogue with dark emotional drama and philosophical questions). And he proved with Serenity that he knows how to shoot amazing fight scenes. And he's a huge comic book geek. The dude was practically born to do Ninja Turtles.

I am pretty sure I remember his name popping up in one of the movie threads, there are just too many to find it at this point.

Anyway, I love Joss and am a huge fan of his shows (especially Firefly, I have even been getting the comics) I like his writing very much but I am not sure if I can imagine him directing the next TMNT movie.

I do wonder if he reads the TMNT comics though??

Tinuvielsdreams
04-26-2009, 09:32 PM
Quentin Tarantino? Tim Burton? For a TMNT film? You can't be serious?

It's just a poll for fun, I am sure someone mentioned these directors in other threads.

and yes Tristan I think Jester just started one actually

Doc_ock_4mugen
04-26-2009, 09:45 PM
M. Night Shyamalan?
Mel Gibson?
Michael Bay?

Jester
04-26-2009, 09:54 PM
I am pretty sure I remember his name popping up in one of the movie threads, there are just too many to find it at this point.

Anyway, I love Joss and am a huge fan of his shows (especially Firefly, I have even been getting the comics) I like his writing very much but I am not sure if I can imagine him directing the next TMNT movie.

I do wonder if he reads the TMNT comics though??
Maybe Joss could write the new TMNT then.

Vincent
04-26-2009, 09:58 PM
Anyway, I love Joss and am a huge fan of his shows (especially Firefly, I have even been getting the comics) I like his writing very much but I am not sure if I can imagine him directing the next TMNT movie.

I do wonder if he reads the TMNT comics though??
I don't think I've heard him mention it. He's mostly into Marvel, from what I understand, but he does read underground stuff too, so I wouldn't be too surprised if he's read some Turtles. I could totally see him both writing and directing TMNT better than probably anyone else, whether he's read the title before or not. He'd read up on it and he'd figure out what makes it tick, and he'd write something really thought provoking that explores the moral implications of revenge, the meaning of justice, et.c.. And he'd probably be tempted to stick around for sequels so he could kill both Gabrielle and Splinter in the most emotionally devastating ways he can think of. Can't see any reason why he wouldn't be perfect for it. He's the master of genre salad, and TMNT is the most delicious genre salad out there, just waiting to be mastered.
And what's wrong with his directing? Have you seen Serenity? It's a gorgeous movie, with a pretty noir look - he'd probably bring the same cinematographer onto TMNT. That cinematographers's name? Jack Green. It's meant to be!
Somebody call Laird and tell him to call Whedon, right now! If Dollhouse gets cancelled, there'll be a slight opening.

TristanHuwJones
04-26-2009, 10:41 PM
I'm throwing Martin Campbell into the ring.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-27-2009, 01:13 AM
The Casino Royale director huh? Now that was a great "reboot", if you want to call it that, for the Bond franchise.
I see he is also listed for Director of a Green Lantern movie, unless that is still a rumor

Tinuvielsdreams
04-27-2009, 01:45 AM
I don't think I've heard him mention it. He's mostly into Marvel, from what I understand, but he does read underground stuff too, so I wouldn't be too surprised if he's read some Turtles. I could totally see him both writing and directing TMNT better than probably anyone else, whether he's read the title before or not. He'd read up on it and he'd figure out what makes it tick, and he'd write something really thought provoking that explores the moral implications of revenge, the meaning of justice, et.c.. And he'd probably be tempted to stick around for sequels so he could kill both Gabrielle and Splinter in the most emotionally devastating ways he can think of. Can't see any reason why he wouldn't be perfect for it. He's the master of genre salad, and TMNT is the most delicious genre salad out there, just waiting to be mastered.
And what's wrong with his directing? Have you seen Serenity? It's a gorgeous movie, with a pretty noir look - he'd probably bring the same cinematographer onto TMNT. That cinematographers's name? Jack Green. It's meant to be!
Somebody call Laird and tell him to call Whedon, right now! If Dollhouse gets cancelled, there'll be a slight opening.

:lol: wow Joss Bandwagon member number 1.
Of course I have seen Serenity (Although I didn't like it nearly as much as the show)I could have done without them killing both Wash and Book

It's not that I don't have confidence in him but he has been more of a tv series director and more often then not he writes original stories. In the example of Firefly, I think what makes him such a great writer is partially because he uses original characters too. He has complete control without the worries of portraying an already existing character inaccurately.
Comic adaptions are just tricky but if he did do it I would be excited and behind him 100%

On an unrelated note, You should watch the Don Bluth Animated feature Titan AE if you haven't seen it because Joss co wrote for it. :)

Vincent
04-27-2009, 11:01 AM
I could have done without them killing both Wash and Book
Hey now, that was a dramatic necessity. If everybody survived, there wouldn't be any real peril, and peril was very important to the central conflict. In dangerous situations, people die. That's a fact of life. And the situation in Serenity was particularly dangerous. If everybody had been fine, the threat wouldn't have had any impact, the villain wouldn't be scary, and the story would have been less realistic. Everything doesn't have to have a completely happy ending. Completely happy endings have been done to death.

You should watch the Don Bluth Animated feature Titan AE if you haven't seen it because Joss co wrote for it. :)
Seen it. Liked it. Not perfect, but enjoyable. Much better than Rock-A-Doodle. (Have you seen Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog, by the way? My puppet was in the DVD extras.)

...But let's get back on topic. I'd suggest Kevin Smith for writing (he's a TMNT fan, and a pretty good writer) except he might have some trouble with the action. His scripts tend to be more dialogue-driven.

cqb101
04-27-2009, 11:17 AM
I'd have no qualms with Smith writing the script, as long as he stays away from the director's chair.

Tinuvielsdreams
04-27-2009, 06:46 PM
Hey now, that was a dramatic necessity. If everybody survived, there wouldn't be any real peril, and peril was very important to the central conflict. In dangerous situations, people die. That's a fact of life. And the situation in Serenity was particularly dangerous. If everybody had been fine, the threat wouldn't have had any impact, the villain wouldn't be scary, and the story would have been less realistic. Everything doesn't have to have a completely happy ending. Completely happy endings have been done to death.

Well yes but I meant BOTH of them. One or the other, come on! Poor Zoe, and I hope more comes to light about book in the comics because he was such an interesting character with a lot of hidden secrets.


...But let's get back on topic. I'd suggest Kevin Smith for writing (he's a TMNT fan, and a pretty good writer) except he might have some trouble with the action. His scripts tend to be more dialogue-driven.

Back on topic... I do like Kevin Smith's writing, true that he is dialogue heavy but hilarious. He is definitely a comic guy, he even had that little cameo in TMNT 4.

Arcade Joe
04-27-2009, 06:58 PM
I also agree that Del Toro would be amazing. But I guess he's tied up with a lot of projects. But then there's the Wachowski brothers. I only recommend this because they arent really doing anything... I believe. May not be bad, but I'm all for Steve Barron again too...

Archon_Turtle
04-27-2009, 07:12 PM
I think there are more Zack Snyder fans then are letting on :-P Or...I have the power to manipulate your feeble minds! ....but I think you're just closet Snyder fans :-P

Spitfire
04-27-2009, 10:55 PM
I'd rather see Eli Roth make a turtles movie then Zack Synder, that's how much I hate him.

cqb101
04-28-2009, 09:24 AM
I'd rather see Eli Roth make a turtles movie then Zack Synder, that's how much I hate him.

I'd also take Eli Roth over Snyder. Bit that's because I genuinely think Roth would make a better, more faithful turtles film. I also really like the guy.

thebrownranger
04-28-2009, 09:57 AM
Well out of this list I would definitely pick Peter Jackson and Steve Barron. :tthumbsu: I'd love for PJ to bring the same look he had from Kong and maybe LOTR into a turtles film. I have complete faith in Peter and Steve for directing a new movie. They're both great directors!

Seriously people, Zack Snyder?? 300 sucked. Watchmen sucked (God I can't believe how much he f****d that up). Why are more people even voting for him on this list?

cqb101
04-28-2009, 10:56 AM
Seriously people, Zack Znyder?? 300 sucked. Watchmen sucked (God I can't believe how much he f****d that up). Why are more people even voting for him on this list?

Yea, I really don't get all this love for Zack Snyder.l

Tinuvielsdreams
04-28-2009, 02:05 PM
agreed, I don't want TMNT to be added to the Snyder fail pile.

Dan
05-13-2009, 06:28 PM
I agree I don't want big green wangs in the film.

Vincent
05-15-2009, 09:52 PM
I agree I don't want big green wangs in the film.

To be fair to Snyder, there was blue wang in the Watchmen comic. However, there was also moral ambiguity. And a story. So there are definitely very good reasons not to want Snyder. But genitals is not it.