View Full Version : "Why are they doing a TMNT origin again?! It's been done already!!!"
Andrew NDB
05-01-2009, 09:48 PM
1. Because by the time this movie comes out it'll have been 20 or more years since the last time a TMNT origin of any kind was seen on film. Don't lose sight of that.
2. Because while the movie can respect the existing fandom, it cannot be solely for or even largely in any way for the existing fandom -- there simply aren't enough active TMNT fans out there to fill seats in any way other than peripherally. By and large, unless they're counting on their target demographic having watched the 4Kids cartoon (and they shouldn't, for multiple reasons that seem pretty plain)... they're looking at an audience that may have a rough idea in their head of the Turtles' origins ("Ooze, mutation, sewers, right?") but certainly not any kind of grasp on the whole origin story. Beyond those that trouble themselves with Wikipedia.
3. Because the origin can be told in ways other than the way told in the first TMNT movie. It might not even need to be a flashback.
4. Because it can be done better than in the first movie. It can be done much better than in the first movie.
5. Because if they're bringing back (or redoing from page 1) the Shredder, the origin story and family history with the Orokus and Yoshi/Shen is important to giving it the gravitas it needs to work.
6. Because if necessary (depends on what the script is going for), the whole origin story needn't eat up more than 3 or 4 minutes of the film's running time. How long was the first movie's origin story? It couldn't have been longer than 5 minutes. Tops.
7. Because there's reasons to suggest this fifth movie might be a (and deservedly so, I might add) reboot of the movie-verse.
shuriken
05-01-2009, 10:12 PM
Well done. I would love to see and origin story again just for the sake of it being true to the "spirit of the comics". Maybe this time it'll include Saki's brother Nagi.
Andrew NDB
05-01-2009, 10:17 PM
Well done. I would love to see and origin story again just for the sake of it being true to the "spirit of the comics". Maybe this time it'll include Saki's brother Nagi.
I'd like to see that, too. And Nagi. And maybe even told in such a way that we get the tiniest bit of sympathy for Saki, something that the filmmakers on the first movie wanted to avoid in favor of making the TMNT-Shredder feud completely black and white ("Saki bad! TMNT good!").
I love in the comics how the whole thing is a gray area, and essentially this circle of vengeance... and it's really almost no one's fault. Nagi beats up Shen a little => Yoshi kills Nagi => Saki kills Shen & Yoshi => the TMNT kill Saki => the Foot vow vengeance for Saki's death... you know? While Shen certainly didn't deserve a beatdown, I'm not sure it was Yoshi's place to issue Nagi a death sentence... and it's hard to fault Saki for vowing vengeance against the unjust murder of his brother.
willtupper
05-01-2009, 11:03 PM
Makes me think of that quote from Tales: "May your circle be unbroken."
Something like that. But the cycle of violence puts a far darker twist on it.
EDIT: Also, Andrew: I seriously question your assertation that Nagi beats up Shen "a little." I don't have the issue in front of me, but doesn't he say something like, "Ha, Yoshi! If I can't have this wench, then no one will!"
The phrasing might be a bit different, but I think that suggests Nagi intends to murder Shen.
Nagi beats up Shen a little => Yoshi kills Nagi => Saki kills Shen & Yoshi => the TMNT kill Saki => the Foot vow vengeance for Saki's death...
Ninjinister
05-01-2009, 11:35 PM
The way I put it to a co-worker when he said it's too soon for a reboot, less time had elapsed between Burton's first Batman and Batman Begins, and the first TMNT movie and this upcoming one. So why not have a reboot?
Dragon Turtle
05-02-2009, 02:04 AM
I'd like to see that, too. And Nagi. And maybe even told in such a way that we get the tiniest bit of sympathy for Saki, something that the filmmakers on the first movie wanted to avoid in favor of making the TMNT-Shredder feud completely black and white ("Saki bad! TMNT good!").
I believe by the time the TMNT went up against the Shredder, it was basically a black and white feud, at this point in his life Oroku Saki had completely gone bad. Although that doesn't mean you can't make him a more layered character by exploring his past or have him display characteristics other then pure evil.
While Shen certainly didn't deserve a beatdown, I'm not sure it was Yoshi's place to issue Nagi a death sentence... and it's hard to fault Saki for vowing vengeance against the unjust murder of his brother.
I have to agree with Will, Nagi was going to beat her to death, and made that perfectly clear to Yoshi, as the text suggests "Yoshi's world vanished in a red haze", Yoshi flew into a blind rage, and maybe if he was fully aware of his actions may not have killed Nagi.
Saki's murder of Yoshi and Shen was premeditated, even worse if he was fully aware of the circumstances surrounding his brother's death.
Personally, I would like to see Shredder's past explored in a DTV movie tie-in, "The Rise of the Shredder", exploring Shredder's POV.
Candy Kappa
05-02-2009, 02:16 AM
having the original origin story would give the movie a more complex story rather than just good vs evil
ThirdMarioBro
05-02-2009, 02:42 AM
I don't care as long as we get a movie with real people in it again. The Turtles were never any good past the Shredder anyway. I'll be glad to just see them stay in freaking New York.
Lil G
05-02-2009, 06:15 AM
1. Because by the time this movie comes out it'll have been 20 or more years since the last time a TMNT origin of any kind was seen on film. Don't lose sight of that.
2. Because while the movie can respect the existing fandom, it cannot be solely for or even largely in any way for the existing fandom -- there simply aren't enough active TMNT fans out there to fill seats in any way other than peripherally. By and large, unless they're counting on their target demographic having watched the 4Kids cartoon (and they shouldn't, for multiple reasons that seem pretty plain)... they're looking at an audience that may have a rough idea in their head of the Turtles' origins ("Ooze, mutation, sewers, right?") but certainly not any kind of grasp on the whole origin story. Beyond those that trouble themselves with Wikipedia.
3. Because the origin can be told in ways other than the way told in the first TMNT movie. It might not even need to be a flashback.
4. Because it can be done better than in the first movie. It can be done much better than in the first movie.
5. Because if they're bringing back (or redoing from page 1) the Shredder, the origin story and family history with the Orokus and Yoshi/Shen is important to giving it the gravitas it needs to work.
6. Because if necessary (depends on what the script is going for), the whole origin story needn't eat up more than 3 or 4 minutes of the film's running time. How long was the first movie's origin story? It couldn't have been longer than 5 minutes. Tops.
7. Because there's reasons to suggest this fifth movie might be a (and deservedly so, I might add) reboot of the movie-verse.
Couldn't have said it better! Mango? :mango:
Off topic: 500th post!:rolling:
Rooish
05-02-2009, 09:37 AM
Very good reasoning, Andrew. Damn I'm excited. Why are these things always announced years before they actually happen?
There was a lot of negativity on these boards lately--some of it with just cause. Everyone was all "It's the TMNT's twenty-fifth anniversary and nothing is happening and the TMNT is going to die out" and I was starting to believe it. so this news is amazing, and with Forever War and the two games coming out, now is a great time to be a TMNT fan. I'm glad the TMNT is nowhere near dying.
Although we did think the 2007 movie would revitalize the TMNT franchise, too, and it obviously did not. Makes me wonder, with a new origin story movie, what the hell the point of TMNT 2007 was (besides looking pretty and giving us an ambiguous answer, again, to who would win in a Leo/Raph fight).
Andrew NDB
05-02-2009, 02:48 PM
what the hell the point of TMNT 2007 was (besides looking pretty and giving us an ambiguous answer, again, to who would win in a Leo/Raph fight).
Selling toys. Seeing if it was possible to make a ninja turtles movie that isn't offensive to anyone, anywhere.
Cipher
05-02-2009, 03:08 PM
Selling toys. Seeing if it was possible to make a ninja turtles movie that isn't offensive to anyone, anywhere.Didn't someone throw a sh*tstorm on here about April cohabitating with Casey?
Anyway, good thread. It was really getting tiresome trying to convince people in other topics why the movies need a reboot, so it's nice to have it all here in such a concise way.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
05-02-2009, 03:33 PM
Is any cartoon/comic book fandom really respected (except among those who are already into another fandom)?
Just watched the first movie again and seeing what could be improved and wow it can definitely be improved upon. Its a good turtles movie but its no masterpiece either. Many things are indeed dated like look, dialog etc. The turtles are too similar and obnoxious. It is indeed influenced a lot by the cartoon just to name a few things.
I think people here are just too nostalgic about it and they also want to continue the movie continuity which is why a re-boot upsets them. Also the average fan doesn't mind of it being an origin as much. I mean it hasn't been told as many times as other superhero origin. Its only "super" "fans" that think its irrelevant to tell that story again. And it does need to be a new continuity, it needs to establish itself. This could be the best thing that could happen to TMNT instead of a "sequel" to the past movies.
CyberCubed
05-02-2009, 03:49 PM
If this becomes a new trilogy, I can see the second movie turning a lot of people off if the Utroms are in it.
TMNT movies need to be as realistic as possible, because the general public doesn't give a crap about the Turtles fighting aliens or monsters. Only the fans accept that since they're all over the comics and cartoons. Seeing a bunch of brains come out of peoples bodies is definitely going to have people roll their eyes in theaters, no matter how they try to pull it off.
Generally speaking I don't think this movie is going to change the public perception of TMNT like people think it will, I'm just hoping for a good movie.
Sage Ninja
05-02-2009, 06:43 PM
I don't see why people would make a stink about a reboot. I say bring it on, I loved the orginal L.A movie and I still do, I don't get why people can't love something for it was back then and appreciate something new now. it dosen't discredit the orginalm the reboot will just be a relaunch. How many diffrent versions of A Christmas Carol have been made? This shouldn't be any diffrent.
Andrew NDB
05-02-2009, 09:31 PM
If this becomes a new trilogy, I can see the second movie turning a lot of people off if the Utroms are in it.
I'd definitely keep them the hell out of the first movie unless just the human-skinned TCRI workers as a tease for movie #2. As far as their eventual inclusion, if things go that way... I could see it working. I'm OK with them switching gears and going more sci-fi with the Utroms and telling those stories from the comics after this first movie.
And the Utroms/TCRI can be pretty grotesque. Beyond that, though, they weren't ever central characters or villains or anything... they would just be supporting cast within a Leatherhead or Triceraton film, and I'm OK with that.
Generally speaking I don't think this movie is going to change the public perception of TMNT like people think it will
I wholly believe it can... but I also wholly believe it won't. It won't even try. Much.
I desperately want to be proven wrong on this.
Dragon Turtle
05-02-2009, 11:17 PM
Although we did think the 2007 movie would revitalize the TMNT franchise, too, and it obviously did not. Makes me wonder, with a new origin story movie, what the hell the point of TMNT 2007 was (besides looking pretty and giving us an ambiguous answer, again, to who would win in a Leo/Raph fight).
The TMNT franchise was already revitalized by the 2k3 cartoon and the 2007 movie spun out of the success of the show, and that movie proved that there was a larger audience outside of just kids.
If this becomes a new trilogy, I can see the second movie turning a lot of people off if the Utroms are in it.
TMNT movies need to be as realistic as possible, because the general public doesn't give a crap about the Turtles fighting aliens or monsters. Only the fans accept that since they're all over the comics and cartoons. Seeing a bunch of brains come out of peoples bodies is definitely going to have people roll their eyes in theaters, no matter how they try to pull it off.
I doubt general public would care about Utroms if they're willing to see a TMNT movie in the first place.
Generally speaking I don't think this movie is going to change the public perception of TMNT like people think it will, I'm just hoping for a good movie.
It's not really important whether or not the next TMNT movie changes the perception of the general public, only that it does well enough to convince Mirage and others that you can produce stuff for older TMNT audiences without it being a waste of money.
I don't see why people would make a stink about a reboot. I say bring it on, I loved the orginal L.A movie and I still do, I don't get why people can't love something for it was back then and appreciate something new now. it dosen't discredit the orginalm the reboot will just be a relaunch. How many diffrent versions of A Christmas Carol have been made? This shouldn't be any diffrent.
I believe it has more to do with the general disdain that people have about comic book origin stories in general as opposed to trampling the memory of the first movie. There is the perception that the movie will spend most of its runtime on setup.
Andrew NDB
05-02-2009, 11:28 PM
The TMNT franchise was already revitalized by the 2k3 cartoon and the 2007 movie spun out of the success of the show, and that movie proved that there was a larger audience outside of just kids.
It proved no such thing. But there is a larger audience out there... you just have to make a TMNT movie that gives the non-kid audience compelling adult material.
There is the perception that the movie will spend most of its runtime on setup.
Which is an odd sort of thing. The original movie didn't spend much time on setup, did it? We kind of just jumped into things and then, smack in the middle of the movie, got a tiny little flashback.
Dragon Turtle
05-02-2009, 11:39 PM
It proved no such thing.
I could post the numbers again if you want.
Which is an odd sort of thing. The original movie didn't spend much time on setup, did it? We kind of just jumped into things and then, smack in the middle of the movie, got a tiny little flashback.
I Never said it was reasonable complaint, personally, I don't believe that would be a real problem, given how little origin the TMNT have (unless they spend a lot of time showing the ninja turtles training or go into too much detail about Shredder's backstory).
TristanHuwJones
05-02-2009, 11:46 PM
It proved no such thing.
It proved it to me. I couldn't believe my eyes when I went, at 9:30 pm on opening night, that the cinema was full of people ranging from 8-80, with most of them being in their late teens to early thirties.
ThirdMarioBro
05-03-2009, 01:09 AM
You know, the Utrom story really gets on my nerves. I really don't give a damn what's comic book cannon or not. I just want Shredder to stay human. Everytime the franchise goes into space, the whole shebang goes straight to hell. You think they'd learn. People seem more attached to the Turtles when they are grounded in NYC, but the moment they head off-planet, people start to drift. I know I sure as hell do.
Andrew NDB
05-03-2009, 01:15 AM
You know, the Utrom story really gets on my nerves. I really don't give a damn what's comic book cannon or not. I just want Shredder to stay human.
In comic book canon Shredder is human. But there's still Utroms out there.
And about the outer space bits... really the only example I like that I could imagine playing out well in a balls-to-the-walls PG-13 fashion would be the Triceraton storyline. Them getting captured on D'Hoonib, taken to the Triceraton homeworlds, and having to participate in gladitorial battles-to-the-death with the finest Triceraton warriors and then having to find a way back to Earth. I could imagine such a movie being pretty badass... but it absolutely needs to happen later on -- the bar needs to be set with a movie very grounded in our own reality.
Rooish
05-03-2009, 08:25 AM
I'm wondering how they're going to manage the timeline in the new movie?
Somehow in the first movie, they managed to get an altered version of the whole Shredder plot up until the end of "Return to New York" squeezed in, including the Raphael/Leonardo microseries stories and the Turtles' exile in the countryside.
I wonder how they'd do it in this movie? I mean, the first thing Shredder does in the comics is die and leave the picture until Leonardo's microseries. I guess this new movie could be Origin Story/TCRI Baxter Mousers/Shredder getting killed? And then the next movie (we can hope) would be ... um Leonardo microseries/RTNY/could City at War fit in? And then the next could be Turtles in Space! Huzzah!
I agree that for some reason, when the Turtles go sci-fi, it gets really boring and weird. Which is odd because the Turtles are sci-fi as is, and almost all of the comics have a sci-fi element to them.
Raph'N'Roll
05-03-2009, 12:17 PM
I really hope that this turtles movie is going to be the one!
A movie that get's great reviews, makes big money, and entertains fans all across the board.
I really won't understand the thinking if it turns out to be another TMNT, or Turtles 1/2/3.
The jokey silly Turtles have been done.
Now's the time to try something different, and if it fails to set the box office alight, well at least they tried.
But I don't think it would fail, and all we need is the powers that be to go ahead and make a movie, that shows everyone just how good the Turtles really can be.
Rooish:I agree that for some reason, when the Turtles go sci-fi, it gets really boring and weird.
I disagree, I think a sequel involving the whole TCRI/Triceraton plot, would be fantastic if done right, it would be perfect summer blockbuster entertainment.
Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-04-2009, 06:30 AM
I disagree, I think a sequel involving the whole TCRI/Triceraton plot, would be fantastic if done right, it would be perfect summer blockbuster entertainment.
As do I. A Triceraton movie would be awesome if done right. Obviously, though, that stuff would have to be done in a sequel, but it could potentially be even better than the first movie.
Sage Ninja
05-04-2009, 02:34 PM
if this where to attempt a trilogy of sort I think it should first be first an origin story with Shredder and the turtles introduced and their first battle and ultimate defeat of the Shredder, with Baxter and the mousers some how thrown in there. Just to get the whole gritty urban feel to it with the crime of new york, ninjas and power hungry mad scienctist.
Then they could get into the utroms and the TCRI building and their back story with the utroms, and maybe even have the tricertrons come in for that sci-fi angle.
Then with the third movie they could to the City at War thing with the foot finnally confronting the turtles over the defeat of Shredder and wanting vengence and having Karai come in the picture and finish things up.
Saki's murder of Yoshi and Shen was premeditated, even worse if he was fully aware of the circumstances surrounding his brother's death. How could Saki have been fully aware? He wasn't there when it happened.
Dragon Turtle
05-04-2009, 07:11 PM
How could Saki have been fully aware? He wasn't there when it happened.
He probbly didn't, but it's not out of the realm of possibility, Nagi may have told someone,a family member or friend of his intentions, or from someone else who had observed the relationship between Nagi, Yoshi, and Shen, and put two and two together. But since Shredder's past in the Mirage comics is sketchy, it's all speculation.
Sage Ninja
05-04-2009, 11:16 PM
well then before they off Shredder in the movie maybe they should go more indepth with his back ground on his brother nagi and Yoshi.
Andrew NDB
05-05-2009, 12:13 AM
well then before they off Shredder in the movie maybe they should go more indepth with his back ground on his brother nagi and Yoshi.
Absolutely. This is one area where a filmmaker with enough vision could even improve upon the source material itself... build up and deliver us a truly personal battle over the decades between the Yoshis and the Orokus with a very visceral climax.
johnnyblaze
05-05-2009, 01:44 AM
One of the things I felt was interesting about Saki's comic origin was the fact that it was the Foot who took him in after his brother's death and helped turn him into the Shredder by harnessing his anger and turning him into pretty much an assassin good enough to one day replace the 2 they had just lost. They took a child when he was weak and turned him into a soldier for their own means. They just more or less end up creating a complete monster who ends up abandoning even them and their ways to do things on his own.
Maybe they could utilize those story points to change thing up a bit. I mean if you take into account that Splinter pretty much did the same thing with the turtles by taking them when they were weak and turning them into his own soldiers for his own personal agenda then at their core,how different are the turtles from the Shredder? At the end of the day all 5 were simply manipulated children (the turtles in a nicer manor of course).
Andrew NDB
05-05-2009, 02:04 AM
Maybe they could utilize those story points to change thing up a bit. I mean if you take into account that Splinter pretty much did the same thing with the turtles by taking them when they were weak and turning them into his own soldiers for his own personal agenda then at their core,how different are the turtles from the Shredder? At the end of the day all 5 were simply manipulated children (the turtles in a nicer manor of course).
That's the crux of the story I'd love to see explored. Even if subtly. The dichotomy of it all, it could be just fascinating.
Spike Spiegel
05-05-2009, 06:34 PM
That's the crux of the story I'd love to see explored. Even if subtly. The dichotomy of it all, it could be just fascinating.
That's the kind of thing that needs to be explored, the kind of thing that really can make people look at TMNT in a much different light. The recent Batman movies put Bruce Wayne and his rogues gallery under a psychological microscope, and now people have much more respect for the characters. If that franchise could escape the horror that was "Batman and Robin," the TMNT franchise can most certainly escape whatever foul stench may have been left behind from TMNT 2k7 (compare TMNT 2k7 to "Batman and Robin." Whatever's wrong is MUCH easier to fix in this instance).
Personally, I think a revamped, all-different, fresh take on the classic origin that leans more towards the first volume of the comic series (and doesn't hold back on the action or serious/"dark" nature of the story that we all know and love) is probably the best way to go. It's what kept all of the older fans as true fans after their respective version(s) of the cartoons ended.
Dragon Turtle
05-05-2009, 07:25 PM
One of the things I felt was interesting about Saki's comic origin was the fact that it was the Foot who took him in after his brother's death and helped turn him into the Shredder by harnessing his anger and turning him into pretty much an assassin good enough to one day replace the 2 they had just lost. They took a child when he was weak and turned him into a soldier for their own means. They just more or less end up creating a complete monster who ends up abandoning even them and their ways to do things on his own.
I would like to see more of the Foot leaders and their agenda, I hope the movie elevates the Foot Clan into a more credible worldwide force, and we get to see the Shredder's bid to take over the entire Foot Clan.
I could imagine the Shredder's training as being as cruel as the ninja training in the movie "Azumi".
Maybe they could utilize those story points to change thing up a bit. I mean if you take into account that Splinter pretty much did the same thing with the turtles by taking them when they were weak and turning them into his own soldiers for his own personal agenda then at their core,how different are the turtles from the Shredder? At the end of the day all 5 were simply manipulated children (the turtles in a nicer manor of course).
The story about how the turtles feel about being raised as assassins would be a good subplot to a "City at War" type story, where they are forced to face the consequences of their actions.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.