PDA

View Full Version : Does Mikey need a personlity make over?


Jelly Bean
05-12-2009, 07:47 PM
If this movie is going to be "the one" where the opinion of the ninja turtles is changed for all time as being unpar with batman, Ironman, Super man, Spiderman, ect. Do you think that Mikey (Michelangelo) should get rehauled with it?

In every medium some one doesn't like how Mike is potrayed. I've heard it all. he's too childish, he's annoying, he has no personal growth, I can't take him seriously, he's a brat, he's a butt monkey, he's a stoner, he's too cocky, he's cowardly, he's an idiot slap stick comdey character. ect

So I was wondering do you think that this movie should break away from him being what he is in the tv shows as as this comdedy chacter that is catered to the little kids? There seems to be so many versions of Mikey out there that people have a problem with, so how should a reboot of the franchise be handled in regards to Michelangelo's character?

plastroncafe
05-12-2009, 08:24 PM
Poor Mikey, he so gets the short end of the personality stick.
Not one of the favorites, so he was left in the shadow, and then shunted to comic relief.

I don't know that Michaelangelo needs an overhaul, so much as he needs actual layers. I think he'll be okay so long as the writers give him something to do.

Coola Yagami
05-12-2009, 09:33 PM
Is... Swartzanegger hard to spell?

Rooish
05-12-2009, 09:46 PM
Man I could go crazy on this topic but I want people besides hard-core Mike fans like myself to have a say, too.

But anyway, yes, the writers need to find a good personality for Mike. I really hope they usually call him "Mike" instead of "Mikey," also, because he was Mike in the Mirage comics and I think it works better than "Mikey" for the calmer, sweeter character he was in the comics (compared to his 2k3 version).

Since Mirage Mike is kind of enigmatic, maybe they could make new movie Michelangelo kind of a mix of his Mirage and his old toon self. Hell I don't mind if they make him most like old toon Mike, spaciness and all. OT Mike was way better than 2k3 Mikey. He was a well-rounded character with a wide range of emotions (when he wasn't focused just on pizza).

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-12-2009, 10:01 PM
If they keep all those personality traits he's gathered in other media over the years, they should tone it all waaaaay down to the point where it's just subtle. Then add all the depth that the Mirage version of Michelangelo has.

plastroncafe
05-12-2009, 10:07 PM
Did the Mirage version have a tone though? I mean, my reading of the original series has Mike being the straight man in a family full of characters, with his one real break out thing being "The Barn Incident" just after Christmas.

Buslady
05-12-2009, 10:32 PM
Is... Swartzanegger hard to spell?


Schwarzenegger

*snicker* couldn't resist...

Andrew NDB
05-12-2009, 10:38 PM
If this movie is going to be "the one" where the opinion of the ninja turtles is changed for all time as being unpar with batman, Ironman, Super man, Spiderman, ect. Do you think that Mikey (Michelangelo) should get rehauled with it?

In every medium some one doesn't like how Mike is potrayed. I've heard it all. he's too childish, he's annoying, he has no personal growth, I can't take him seriously, he's a brat, he's a butt monkey, he's a stoner, he's too cocky, he's cowardly, he's an idiot slap stick comdey character. ect

So I was wondering do you think that this movie should break away from him being what he is in the tv shows as as this comdedy chacter that is catered to the little kids? There seems to be so many versions of Mikey out there that people have a problem with, so how should a reboot of the franchise be handled in regards to Michelangelo's character?

The Michelangelo as he's been seen in the children's cartoons/existing movies should have absolutely no bearing on the Michelangelo seen in the new movie/reboot. Especially the Michelangelo in the last movie... every time he opened his mouth I just wanted someone to kill him and make him go away.

Michelangelo is perhaps the most "human" of all the TMNT, with Donny a close second. He knows how to have fun, but he's also amazingly creative and even a writer (and yes, he's a writer outside of Vol. 3).

Candy Kappa
05-13-2009, 02:19 AM
I don't think he needs a make over but just being taken serious as the other turtles

Andrew NDB
05-13-2009, 02:24 AM
I don't think he needs a make over but just being taken serious as the other turtles

Which doesn't require any makeover or changing of the character. It just requires them to bring the original/Mirage Michelangelo to the screen and ignoring of all the children's spinoff stuff.

steve
05-13-2009, 10:20 AM
Mikey doesn't need a personality update.
Its the person that writes his lines that needs a personality update =D

Doc_ock_4mugen
05-13-2009, 10:51 AM
First they need to balance out the TMNT's screentime... (The 4 Turtles should share the spotlight... Not Leo and Raph, while Mike and Don are props.) Now that that's out of the way, Let's deal with Michelangelo.
Mike's a creative guy, being a writer and all that. That should be seen.
He's got a sense of humor, but please don't have him stuck on Spongebob fused with Keanu mode. a bit of skater slang could be ok as long as it's not overdone.
Also he's a very caring individual, the most empathic of the four Turtles. Mike needs Klunk and to be the peacekeeper between the Raph/Leo arguments.
he could have a few "out there" moments. They should SEEM to be "out there" and irrelevant at first sight, but deep down having them being relevant.

DougieTMNT
05-13-2009, 11:07 AM
They need to tone it down a bit, at the very least. The only bit I really liked from Mikey in the 2007 film was the "I'm smart" exchange - as it really shows him as the "everyman" of the Turtles.

He's not a leader, a genius or ready to fly into a murderous rage - he's just a regular guy who happens to be a Turtle.

Of course, the rest of the flick he was just there to spout "dude" and "awesome" every few minutes. The Mikey I want to see is sweet, a little naive but at the end of the day a pretty down to earth guy - not just a seemingly immature catchphrase spout.

I think there's some room for the spacey Mikey. Just don't over-do it, and when things get serious Mike needs to get serious too. He's not an idiot.

Ginny
05-13-2009, 12:12 PM
I'd certainly like to see them start to refer to him as Mike instead of Mikey. He should be more empathic, and creative, and way less of a slacker type. Silly jokes are fine, as long as they are part of his character, and not his whole character.

VaughnMichael
05-13-2009, 12:18 PM
I don't mind the cali surfer voice just as long as they don't do what they did in the last movie with the burps and slamming into walls.

Cipher
05-13-2009, 12:47 PM
A change from his ADHD portrayal in the 2003 cartoon and 2007 movie? Absolutely. Anyone who enjoyed those portrayals can go straight to jail. Do not pass Go. Do not collect $200.

Just give us the Mirage version of Mikey, sensitive and humorous, but also competant and artistic. Or even the old movies' version of Mikey, where he's a lovable jokester, rather than a hyperactive irritating one. Hell, even the '80s toon surfer persona would be welcome again. He can still be comic relief as long as I don't feel like I want to shove a fistful of Ritalin down his throat and make sure he's done his homework.

Rooish
05-13-2009, 08:06 PM
Maybe the movie could be from Mike's perspective.* If we're going by the Mirage personality, he was more of an observer of most of the action, anyway. He followed orders and lived in the moment. It's fascinating how different he is in each version. In the old movies he was a warm and fun character, but much more of an attention-seeker. Only in the comics, and kind of in the old toon, was he a bit overshadowed instead of in the spotlight. And I kind of think he's greatest when he's a bit overshadowed by the others. Makes his moments all the more stunning when they happen, whether he's being happy and nice and cooking for everyone, or getting depressed like in the barn scene.

I'm fairly sure we'll never see this Mike again, though ... even in the current Mirage comics (except in "The Path" by Jim Lawson, I suppose). Mike is comic relief now, and that's it. I sometimes feel he is betrayed in the new comics by the writers ... Laird and Berger and Murphy all write him as comic relief now.

The weird thing is, he wasn't in the old comics. Raph was the comic relief. Casey sometimes, although I bet we could do another thread about how badly Casey's personality has been slaughtered lately. He's a buffoon in the 2k3 show and in the new movie. Tristan writes Casey okay, but man, usually he's lost his edge.

*I know this would obviously never happen.

Cipher
05-13-2009, 08:18 PM
I'm fairly sure we'll never see this Mike again, though ... even in the current Mirage comics (except in "The Path" by Jim Lawson, I suppose). Mike is comic relief now, and that's it. I sometimes feel he is betrayed in the new comics by the writers ... Laird and Berger and Murphy all write him as comic relief now.The Tales issues vary (many of them are action-oriented and only give Mike time for a one-liner or two), but he's been pretty on in Volume 4. Mike's goes through some pretty serious sh*t in that plot, and he takes that sh*t seriously.

Rooish
05-13-2009, 08:23 PM
Hm. Good point. I do appreciate the time Laird has taken to focus on Michelangelo ... I'm not sure, but I feel like he's gotten more screen time than any of the other Turtles in Vol. 4. I guess Laird really liked Mike's subplot ... it's pretty wild!

So, I take it back about Laird. After all, if anyone should be able to write Mike the way he truly is, Laird should.

I do think Lawson writes him quite well, too, though.

I think it's odd how Mike seemed almost deliberately ignored in some parts of Vol. 1. In the first issue, Don and Raph and Leo all are kind of bantering during their fight with the Foot and Shredder, and from what I recall, all Mike says in the entire issue is "I'm tired, Leonardo."

And in the second issue, Mike stays behind while the other three meet April. It's weird.

But I digress. Mike needs a personality update!

METALHEAD
05-13-2009, 08:48 PM
Noo! 0-0 ....

Tinuvielsdreams
05-14-2009, 10:49 PM
I hate to see Mikey only used as comic relief (and used badly, in the case of the 07' film) He just gets overshadowed by everything else happening and it seems like that is all they feel is left to do with his character.
They just need to keep it more even and delve into the characters more. It would be nice to see a movie where each individual turtle is concentrated on for a period of time. I agree that I would also like to see the more pensive and serious side of Mikey from the comics shown in a film. I always liked the idea of him being a writer too.

Rooish
05-14-2009, 11:02 PM
Don't hit me, everyone.

I think Mikey's awesome. He's way smarter than he lets on.

But I have trouble imagining him as much of a writer ...

Tinuvielsdreams
05-15-2009, 01:53 PM
Don't hit me, everyone.

I think Mikey's awesome. He's way smarter than he lets on.

But I have trouble imagining him as much of a writer ...

Haha no hitting but that is exactly the point. Mikey IS smarter then anyone seems to want to let on.

plastroncafe
05-15-2009, 02:03 PM
Don't hit me, everyone.

I think Mikey's awesome. He's way smarter than he lets on.

But I have trouble imagining him as much of a writer ...

His canon go at it wasn't so bad!

CyberCubed
05-15-2009, 08:15 PM
The original trilogy movie version of Mike was pretty good. He was light-hearted without going overboard and it was pretty fun to hear him say lines like, "A little TOO Raph" where the joke actually works.

Hell, even old toon Mike was pretty laid-back.

Vincent
05-15-2009, 09:41 PM
Mike needs layers, motivation and a proper character arc with some personal growth.

And I've been saying for a very long time that Mikey has a lot of potential for depth. Depth that has been - inadvertedly or not - hinted at over the years but not fully explored. Could be a truly great character if done right. A lot could be hiding under the wise cracking party dude exterior. A lot of inner conflict.

The Big Bad
05-16-2009, 01:32 AM
A more restrained Mikey than the most recent incarnations? Possibly, maybe even probably. A "serious" Mikey? Highly unlikely, methinks. Given time constraints, the amount of characters (from eight to say...twelve, depending how much detail goes into Hamato Yoshi/Tang Shen, and how many villains besides the Shredder show up), and the familiar character dynamics, bringing the Mirage Mikey to the screen would almost certainly mean a) consigning him to being a background character, or b) taking away time from the plot and/or action.

Lets face it, sensitivity and an artistic instinct aren't really the type of character traits that are easily expressed during heated action scenes. It's also not the type of thing that really makes a character stand out, unlike a reputation as "the 'funny' one". What's more, it's somewhat redundant--Leo already has the level-headed straight-man schtick, and April has the role of "team heart". Add to that the dubious benefits--sure, we like Mirage Mikey, but would most other people--and there's little reason to believe that a director will go that route and still do the character justice. Can it be done? Possibly, but I'm not holding my breath.

Coola Yagami
05-16-2009, 02:17 AM
The bad thing is... most everyone knows Mikey as some kind of surfer. Look at the backlash from most TMNT fans about 'No Shredder and Krang' and 'the TMNT being too serious' in the TMNT movie. I can imagine all the fans bitching about Mikey being 'too serious' and 'not even saying Cowabunga once' in the 2011 movie.

Tinuvielsdreams
05-16-2009, 02:38 AM
The bad thing is... most everyone knows Mikey as some kind of surfer. Look at the backlash from most TMNT fans about 'No Shredder and Krang' and 'the TMNT being too serious' in the TMNT movie. I can imagine all the fans bitching about Mikey being 'too serious' and 'not even saying Cowabunga once' in the 2011 movie.

I don't think either extreme would be a good thing. By no means do I want to see him act just like Raph or Leo but they could tone him down a little from the most recent animated carnations.

Mr._Mutant_Man
05-16-2009, 08:48 AM
The bad thing is... most everyone knows Mikey as some kind of surfer. Look at the backlash from most TMNT fans about 'No Shredder and Krang' and 'the TMNT being too serious' in the TMNT movie. I can imagine all the fans bitching about Mikey being 'too serious' and 'not even saying Cowabunga once' in the 2011 movie.

I think people will get over it. Maybe back in 1989 there were people wondering where Robin was in the Batman movie. If the movie is good enough, it won't matter.

I think Michelangelo should be toned down from what he was like in the last movie. The only time I remember him actually being funny was when he wanted to retire his Cowabunga Carl head at the end. Other than that it was kind of the usual kid movie slapstick/gross out humor.

However, he should still have some of that comic relief side. If he's done too seriously he'll probably end up like the Michelangelo of the early comics, where it's hard to remember what he actually did do other than say "I'm tired" at the end of the first issue.

thebrownranger
05-16-2009, 11:24 AM
Yeah definitely needs a new personality makeover for this new movie to fit together. Having him just for comic relief is stupid b/c we won't be able to see his true character (vol .1).

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-16-2009, 01:42 PM
The only time I remember him actually being funny was when he wanted to retire his Cowabunga Carl head at the end. Other than that it was kind of the usual kid movie slapstick/gross out humor.

I thought the "I think it was your mom" shtick was funny. But, then again, it wasn't Michelangelo's comment that I found funny, it was Donatello's response to it that I found funny... ("Ya, that would make her your mom, too. Doofus.") so I guess that actually counts as Donatello being funny.

But, that leaves another thing here to be said. Donatello calling Michelangelo a doofus was dead-on accurate. That's NOT what I'd call the Mike from the comics. Not by a long-shot.

As I said before, some of those comedic traits that Michelangelo has outside the comics should still be intact so as to give the average Joe some familiarity with the character, but it should be very subtle and hardly there. Noticeable, but not distracting. His true personality from the comics should overshadow all that. That's the kind of Mike that should be in this movie.

Sage Ninja
05-16-2009, 01:56 PM
my God...I can't believe I didn't notice this thread before now. :o

let me just say that yes, Michaelangelo needs a personality make over. Big time. He's been warped by the media for far too long.

But color me skeptical, depending on what rating this new movie is going to be, I predict more ADHD, walking joke, childish brat Mikey coming out.

If this movie is PG, I'm not confident that he'll be any diffrent than how we've seen him. If this movie is pg-13...I'm still pretty skeptical. I think what movie writers need to realize is that Michaelangelo has adult fans and should have adult like quailites that should appeal to us. The problem with Mike's character so far as he has been used to much as a plot device. The writers 2D him too much to make him the balancing factor between his brothers and all the dark gritty stuff in the franchise.

I have more to say but I can't get into it right now. But elect Vincent to write for Michaelangelo's character. :)

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-16-2009, 08:24 PM
The way Michelangelo is depicted in everything outside of the comics is actually a pretty fair representation of everything the Mirage Turtles are not like. His favorite food is pizza, he says cowabunga, and he doesn't take things seriously. Heck, I'd wager to say that ever since the other Turtles started acting more like their Mirage counterparts, Michelangelo was only driven further into being a personification of the '87 toon. Whereas in the '87 toon, all that stuff was evenly dispersed throughout ALL the characters, it's now all contained within Mikey himself.

That's right. Michelangelo is a living universe.

Spitfire
05-16-2009, 09:10 PM
Mikey was great in Image. Honestly they need to make Mikey the character who goofs around and jokes but in the face of real danger he's the one who breaks down the most. Like if Splinter went missing, maybe even in private, I see him as being the guy who gets concerned and being goofy is just a front. When its time to get **** done he can act quickly as well.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
05-17-2009, 04:29 AM
Like if Splinter went missing, maybe even in private, I see him as being the guy who gets concerned and being goofy is just a front.

That actually sounds a bit similar to what happened in the first movie. "Pizza dude's got thirty seconds."

Rooish
05-17-2009, 08:16 PM
I think part of the issue is that all the characters have been through so many universes that it's hard to tell what is a true personality trait of a character.

Like Leo, for example, was very vocal and harsh and arrogant at times in the Mirage comics ... a real hard-ass. And now he's usually portrayed as modest, gentle, and often rather quiet.

Raph's been portrayed as completely wild and bipolar, but in the 2003 cartoon he's pretty level-headed and responsible and defends his family at all costs. He didn't seem nearly so loyal in the old comics or the new movie. And, of course, there's his old cartoon portrayal which is whacked.

Don was fairly gentle at first but he became a bit more grouchy during the years, especially in the old toon. In the new toon he is apologetic and almost childlike at times, which he isn't like in other versions.

Mike ... well, he used to be laid-back and, in the Mirage comics, usually the least talkative of the group. Now he's the complete opposite. In the new movie I'd like to see him portrayed a bit like Oz from Buffy the Vampire Slayer ... quiet, peaceful, laid-back, kind of funny and perceptive and ironic. But that's not like any other version, of course.

Folks don't know how to make up their minds about these characters ... there's too many versions of the TMNT competing at once!

The Big Bad
05-18-2009, 03:56 AM
Folks don't know how to make up their minds about these characters ... there's too many versions of the TMNT competing at once! That's assuming that making up their minds about them is a desirable thing--personally, I like having tons of different, equally valid versions of the characters.

Coola Yagami
05-18-2009, 09:04 AM
And of course, you're forgetting that whoever the director is will also be having 'their' version of the TMNT. I don't think Don ever worked in Tech Support in any other media, nor did Leo act like such an arrogant ass, nor was Mike that hyper, and nor was Raph ever the Nightwatcher.

Arcade Joe
05-18-2009, 06:32 PM
And of course, you're forgetting that whoever the director is will also be having 'their' version of the TMNT. I don't think Don ever worked in Tech Support in any other media, nor did Leo act like such an arrogant ass, nor was Mike that hyper, and nor was Raph ever the Nightwatcher.

YES!!!!!....very well said. If the director is a TMNT purist, his personality will probably change. But, in HollyWIERD, I'm not holding my breath. It's a nice dream, but then again, I won't jump into conclusions.

Jelly Bean
05-20-2009, 12:41 PM
Mike needs layers, motivation and a proper character arc with some personal growth.

And I've been saying for a very long time that Mikey has a lot of potential for depth. Depth that has been - inadvertedly or not - hinted at over the years but not fully explored. Could be a truly great character if done right. A lot could be hiding under the wise cracking party dude exterior. A lot of inner conflict.

Such as? Give us an idea of what your vision of Michelangelo with depth is?

I have to say this, and I know it's going to piss off a few fans, but what I don't want to see is the treatment of the Michelangelo in the 4KIDS cartoon had. Ever. And I saw too much of 2k3 Mikey's influence in TMNT movie Mikey.

I like Mike as a whole as a ninja turtle, but I hate him in the 4KIDS cartoon. Everything that I think was wrong with Mike as a character was done in the 4KIDS cartoon. He is what Michelangelo should never be. I hated that he was shown as an annoying little brother sterotype, that he was obnoxious, and made stupid pop culture comments.

The things that bothered me the most about Mikey in the 4KIDS toon was that he was a slacker, cowardly and self centered. Why the hell are you going to make a ninja cowardly? Whats that supposed to accomplish?

Stop making this kind of Michelangelo. Seriously.

And I have to ask, why does every one say that if Mike was done in the mirage version that he'll fall into the background?

Doc_ock_4mugen
05-20-2009, 02:08 PM
The problem with Mikey's Personality is that it's portrayed wrong. Mike's personality is deeper than the slacker, the goofball, or the random pop culture reference. Mike's the most empathic of the 4 turtles. But somehow the writers only seem to see him as "dude! whoa! cowabunga! Pizza time! dude!"

In order to avoid Mike (and maybe Don) fall into the background; the script should not be Leo/Raph centric.

Vincent
05-20-2009, 02:45 PM
Such as? Give us an idea of what your vision of Michelangelo with depth is?
Well, cherry-picking from the various interpretations, we can list a few basic, outwardly visible character traits: Quick (but reserved) fighter, witty, doesn't always take things seriously, and makes jokes in serious situations, often inappropriately. He is also kind, warm and loving and has a vivid imagination.
This raises a few questions. Most of them along the lines of "why?".
Why doesn't he take things seriously? Why is he less motivated than his brothers? It's certainly not lack of skill or intelligence. He's a fast and quick-witted fighter when he puts his mind to it, and when written right a wordsmith rather than a fool. Obviously he's holding back. Why is he holding back? Possibly because, caring as he is, he fears the family might fall apart if his brothers don't have someone to treat like a kid, which is something they've always been doing and it's sort of become the way things are, an in Mike's head unchangable status quo. This, I think, is a possible starting point for a character arc. Splinter could confront Mike about it (perceptive as he is, Splinter should have noticed a long time ago that Mike is having problems), and Mike would have to spend a couple of acts working toward "coming out of the closet", metaphorically speaking. Learning to trust his family and coming into his own. Wouldn't it be great to have a moment where Mike for once stops Raph's hand as it's about to hit the back of his head? I for one would love to see that.

And I have to ask, why does every one say that if Mike was done in the mirage version that he'll fall into the background?
I'd assume it's because of how he didn't have a whole lot to do in much of vol. 1, except in the holiday special and a couple other issues. Vol. 1 would much more often focus on Raph and Don, being the respective favorite turtles of Kev and Pete, and Leo, being the leader. Mike did have some great character moments, but they were few and far apart. Mostly he was just tagging along.

Cipher
05-20-2009, 04:47 PM
(A bunch of stuff about 4Kids Michelangelo)I completely agree with everything you said.

I was watching the 1990 movie again the other day. Honestly, that Mike is perfect for an origins era version of the character. He's goofy and genuinely funny, but serious enough to reflect on Splinter's age, cued in on family dynamics, etc. His interaction with Donatello is fantastic.

In later comics he gets even more mellow, writing and playing uncle to Shadow and whatnot, but for the early stories that movie really nailed him.

ToTheNines
05-20-2009, 10:04 PM
Yeah, him being a total chicken in alot of episodes drove me ****in nuts. No more of that.

Donny
05-21-2009, 04:01 PM
Wouldn't it be great to have a moment where Mike for once stops Raph's hand as it's about to hit the back of his head? I for one would love to see that.

I would love to see that too. I agree with most of the things you said. He needs more layers and more depth. He is actually an interesting character, so I hope that the comic version will dominate more than in the cartoon, but I still want to see Michelangelo as the "funny" one in the group.

As mentioned by others; the version in the 1990 movies is actually pretty good. He is not as exaggerated a character as in 2k3.

Jelly Bean
05-21-2009, 06:56 PM
I completely agree with everything you said.

I was watching the 1990 movie again the other day. Honestly, that Mike is perfect for an origins era version of the character. He's goofy and genuinely funny, but serious enough to reflect on Splinter's age, cued in on family dynamics, etc. His interaction with Donatello is fantastic.

you know I watched the first live action movie the turtles for the very first time, and I gotta say that I didn't see a big difference between Mikey in that movie and Mikey in the 4KIDS show. I didn't care for him that much. He might not been as friggen annoying as 2k3 Mikey but I still found him pretty 2D. He just faded into the background like Donny and Leo, but worse. :|

Rooish
05-21-2009, 11:05 PM
I agree with Jelly Bean ... regarding just about everything said.

Especially: Stop making this kind of Michelangelo. Seriously.

Also, I kinda agree about movie Mikey not being much different from 2003 Mikey. In the old movies ... he joked a lot. He was warmer than in the 2003show, but not too deep. Like when Don brings up Splinter dying, he completely changes the subject.

But Mikey wasn't always terrible in the 2003 cartoon ... he was worst in Fast Forward. In a lot of episodes he did have empathy (like for Zog, Klunk, etc.). I thought he did develop (albeit with setbacks) throughout the show.

Unfortunately, he shouldn't have been arrogant or hyperactive to begin with. That's not Michelangelo!

I think old toon Mike was the second most likeable after Mirage Mike. I mean, he was kind of Mirage Mike with a lot more personality. He came across as slow-witted (not to me, but I can see how people thought it) but I think he was just a laid-back, nice underdog. 2007 movie Mikey was a mix of the two cartoon versions, plus intellectual stunting.

Anyway, I'm rambling. With a revamping movie, Mikey should get a sweet personality change and some friggin' respect. ;)

Sage Ninja
05-22-2009, 02:40 AM
What I really want to see in a revamp of his character, is him not being stupid. Mike's character has been played up as a dumb flakey character long enough for laughs, and it needs to stop. Him being this "out there", bizzar guy with ecentric tendacies, is really tired now. People might disagree with me but for once I'd like to see a Michelangelo that is fairly lucid that is grounded in reality with a down to earth intelligence. I don't want to see any more "OMG, Mike made a lucent comment" or "Wow, Mike has a good idea", from the characters that interact with him. Wayne Grayson made a comment once (jokingly) that sometimes the writers will have Mikey say something "smart" and that it wouldn't fit his character. That shouldn't happen. It should never become an issue where a piece of dialogue or an action is considered "out of character" for Michelangelo's character to be smart.

People say that it's part of the "Michelangelo character" to be a crazy clown but really that is just a shallow plug and shouldn't be his over-all character. I know that that might not make him as flashy as he has been portrayed before and might make him fall into the background like he did in the vol.1 of the mirage, but maybe something could be worked out to give a stronger presense.

Newton Gimmick
05-22-2009, 03:35 AM
I've always thought Mike has been played well.

Yes at times in the old toon, the new toon and maybe in the movies, Mike has gotten the short end of the stick because he's had to be the comic relief.

But lets remember, in the NT while Mike often acted "scared" or "silly" at villains, he was shown at being an adept fighter. Battle Nexus anyone? So overall I think he had a decent shake at being a character, just more amped up.

Mirage has played him well, Mike is the most likely to get into a relationship, he is kind but clever and the trusting glue that holds everyone together.

In the movies he's had a nice mix. I liked his portrayal in TMNT, I thought it was a good mesh honestly. Sure there was some humor, but it was just his way of dealing with things. He was holding down the fort for the fellas bringing in the income and such. So while that might have led to him getting some goofy screen time, he got some good stuff in as well.

I think this topic could work for any of the Turtles honestly. Does Raph have to be such an ass all the time? Isn't that played out now? Does Don have to be such a tech guy? Why can't he be more of a ninja? And does Leo have to be such a... Well I have no idea what Leo does honestly. De Facto leader dude.

All of the personalities have to be amped up in the movies or TV shows because they want you to know who that Turtle is by the end of that one movie or show. So it'll always come down to:

Leo leads, Donatello tech, Raph hothead, Mike goofball.

Sage Ninja
05-22-2009, 01:28 PM
I hope you don't mind if I disagree with you Newton Gimmick but Mike is easily the worst written of the turtles in alot of mediums. Frankly him as sole comic relief is holding his character back because writers feel compelled to have him do all the things the other turtles can't do because they are the "serious" ones, which makes him inconsistent. They can assert one thing about his character (like being an awsome fighter) then make him all cowardly or screw up royaly the next just to exploit it for laughs, which kinda makes you go WTF.

odupianist
06-17-2009, 10:45 AM
Here's the characteristics of Mike that need to be in the new movie:

Light hearted
Laid back
Heart of the group
Comical, not goofy but a quip here and there
Quick to find the lighter side in most dark situations
Adept fighter, even on par with Leo in some instances
In tune with pop culture and making references from time to time
Pensive and thoughtful
Helpful to calm Raph down and any internal fighting for that matter


NOT a surfer
NOT stupid/immature/hyperactive
NOT saying something just to say it

That's just a quick list, but I'm sure I could come up with more

Side note: I don't think Mike's a slacker because that's who he is. I think he's a slacker because he's not challenged enough. Yes, he could challenge himself, but he hasn't found anything challenging enough to take on from what I've seen (except maybe an occassional video game, which I think could still be a viable attribute because of his connection with humans and human culture)

Cipher
06-17-2009, 12:33 PM
I think what people need is evidence of a proper Mike portrayal.

Volume 2 was very good to him. Anyone with those issues should crack open issue #2, where he writes down his little quips about Raph's personality. That's a good use of his humor that's actually witty and subtle.

And then look at issue #3 when he has a discussion with Leo about how everything's changing, and how he wants to stay with Shadow and live quietly in April and Casey's apartment. Then try to imagine Mike from the 4Kids cartoon or 2007 movie having that conversation. It does not work.

plastroncafe
06-19-2009, 01:50 PM
I think what people need is evidence of a proper Mike portrayal.

Volume 2 was very good to him. Anyone with those issues should crack open issue #2, where he writes down his little quips about Raph's personality. That's a good use of his humor that's actually witty and subtle.

And then look at issue #3 when he has a discussion with Leo about how everything's changing, and how he wants to stay with Shadow and live quietly in April and Casey's apartment. Then try to imagine Mike from the 4Kids cartoon or 2007 movie having that conversation. It does not work.

I swear I'm not just trying to kiss up to Tristan when I say this, but the newest issue of Tales has some awesome Mikey Moments in it.

Andrew NDB
06-19-2009, 08:30 PM
What I really want to see in a revamp of his character, is him not being stupid.

No revamp needed, per se. They just need to bring the Mirage Michelangelo to the mass media... simple as that.

Spike Spiegel
06-20-2009, 11:59 AM
If they keep all those personality traits he's gathered in other media over the years, they should tone it all waaaaay down to the point where it's just subtle. Then add all the depth that the Mirage version of Michelangelo has.

No revamp needed, per se. They just need to bring the Mirage Michelangelo to the mass media... simple as that.

I think there's an interesting part of Mike's character that is a bit more serious that not only has never really been explored to its full potential, but most of the general public seems to deny its existence...when I think of his character, I usually think of the way he was portrayed in the third live action movie or Volume One of the Mirage Comics. The Turtles are supposed to have different and interesting personalities (Leo=stoic, Don=techie, Raph=violent, Mikey=aloof), but as ninjas, there should a unifying sort of psychological motif of them having trained to be serious warriors, etc.

Ninja-Tortoise
06-22-2009, 09:54 PM
I don't think he needs a make over. If anything they can tweek him a bit. Make him like johnny storm from fantastic four. A little cocky always playing pranks etc. But I really don't see him needing a change. I like him just the way he is.

odupianist
06-25-2009, 10:10 AM
I hope you don't mean the movie versions of FF. He was borderline annoying in the movies.

Ninja-Tortoise
06-25-2009, 11:14 PM
I hope you don't mean the movie versions of FF. He was borderline annoying in the movies.

No I mean the cartoon like that one that didn't last, it was called fantastic four worlds greatest heroes and by the way the movie version of johnny was just like the comics.

Brodie
06-26-2009, 03:26 PM
I hope you don't mean the movie versions of FF. He was borderline annoying in the movies.

...More annoying than Mikey always has been?

odupianist
06-29-2009, 07:50 AM
Mikey hasn't always been annoying, a good portion of the time yes, but his annoyingness is almost predictable so it's not that bad to me because of that

Coola Yagami
06-29-2009, 02:37 PM
Mikey wasn't annoying in the OT. Hell, he was my fave Turtle. Nowadays.... eh, it's hard to tell who's my fave turtle in the NT. I'd like to say Mikey, but bleh, he got so bratty. I DO like it when he manages to be useful and save the day though, but it's mostly leftover OT Mikey fandom than anything else.

NameGoesHere1066
07-09-2009, 10:12 PM
Michelangelo's character definately needs to be rehauled for a new live action movie. Whats been allowed to be done to him since the turtles debut is horrendous. I concur with every that has said that we need to see Mirage Michelangelo on the big screen, not the Mike the surfer, or Mike the doofus ADHD brat.

Trouble is I really doubt that we'll ever see Michelangelo's character as anything than walking joke. The fact that Seth Green might even be considered as a possiblity for one of the turtles,(and you know they'll throw him in as Mike) tells me that they are going for the typicial Michelangelo that we've seen for years, that we've all had are fill of.

We all might hope for something better for Mike's character, but I seriously doubt we'll get it. Which is a shame because there is alot of things that can be done with Michelangelo as a character if they ever tried. I particially blame Kevin and Peter for this for not giving him the same presense as the other turtles. There wouldn't be a problem if they had.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
07-10-2009, 10:47 AM
No. I like Michelangelo.

Slap-Happy
07-10-2009, 01:43 PM
Like when Don brings up Splinter dying, he completely changes the subject.

I think this was Mike not beliving this would ever happen to Splinter. Like when someones father dies, it's such a shock because they always thought of their dad as a brave uy who could survive anything.

Or, I think Mike could've been scared about the said subject. I think Mike in the first movie was very sensitive. If I remember correctly, he was crying after all the turtles saw Splinter at the campfire.

I think we should have a Mike that is caring, loving, imaginative and sensitive. but still tells jokes at APPORPRIATE times. I think that Mike would be alot more serious at times when his family was in danger. That's what I like about Mike in the mirage books. When they go to the barn, he spends most of his time alone, with the punching bag. He was taking his anger out on the bag because of what had happened to Leo.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
07-11-2009, 07:05 AM
No. I like Michelangelo.

If you like Michelangelo, then why do you want what's worse for him? :P

Slap-Happy
07-11-2009, 06:43 PM
If you like Michelangelo, then why do you want what's worse for him? :P

:lol::lol:

Tora_Chan
07-19-2009, 04:14 AM
Somebody on InsaneJournal's scans_daily posted pages from Tales of the TMNT #55 ( see here (http://asylums.insanejournal.com/scans_daily/680901.html) ) and I finally know what bothers me about how Mikey is portrait in the 2k3 series and the new movie:

It's not the pranks or annoying his brothers or being lazy, it's that Mikey never does nice things like he does in the comics. I cannot recall a single moment in the series where Mikey did something nice for anybody just because he could. Maybe there were and I just can't remember them at the moment. But my point is, Mikey can joke around, pull pranks and do stupid stuff as long as you also show him as caring. And this is were the cartoon failed, especially FF and BttS. There Mikey only cares about himself, it's all about him and what he wants. And when his behaviour bites him in the ass, he still never learns a permanent lesson and is back to square one in the next episode.

Aztec General
07-19-2009, 11:31 AM
One thing I miss from his Mirage characterizations is Mikey's passion for his family. That has not been displayed in any of the films or the 2K3 show. Does he like to goof around a bit? Sure, but in the comics he would go apes#it if someone messed with one of his brothers. People forget that in the early Mirage issues it's often Mikey who loses his cool. I remember there's the one seen in the alien bar from the TCRI storyline.

Raven
07-19-2009, 01:15 PM
For me it all depends upon the story, does Mikey need an overhaul? Not really in my opinion, but if the story brings him to a point where he has to grow up or show more then what he has, then Im all for it.

I feel like we got some growth from Leo and Raph in the last film. Finally seeing the two battle it out felt like we put a end to the bitter brother rivalry between the two, so maybe we should see more growth in Mikey and Don?

Sage Ninja
07-22-2009, 01:08 AM
Somebody on InsaneJournal's scans_daily posted pages from Tales of the TMNT #55 ( see here ) and I finally know what bothers me about how Mikey is portrait in the 2k3 series and the new movie

wow, that...was just awsome. O.O What a sweet thing Mike did for Raph there. Why couldn't we have gotten that kind of Mike in the 2k3 series? What floors me is how similar the Mikey depicted in that story is to 2k3 Mikey. I could totally see 2k3 Mikey pulling something like that. You know I really would have been able to over look most of Mikey's more obnoxious behavior in the new toon if it had been balanced out by a more sweet and considerate side for his family. Mikey was just to one sided in the show.

They really do need to play up Michelangelo's more positive qualities in this up coming film. The dipiction of Michelangelo has always been very one sided and thats been the problem with his character.

odupianist
07-22-2009, 08:06 AM
For me it all depends upon the story, does Mikey need an overhaul? Not really in my opinion, but if the story brings him to a point where he has to grow up or show more then what he has, then Im all for it.

I feel like we got some growth from Leo and Raph in the last film. Finally seeing the two battle it out felt like we put a end to the bitter brother rivalry between the two, so maybe we should see more growth in Mikey and Don?

But you forget, they are rebooting the movie franchise, so now we get to see an all new Raph/Leo confrontation :roll:

Samurai Usagi
07-22-2009, 09:58 AM
Michaelangelo is the Baby brother of the group and probably jokes to get noticed and meet up with his older brothers. He is not a slacker but his high natural ability makes him bored to do the training and finds time to goof off.

odupianist
07-22-2009, 02:10 PM
Michaelangelo is the Baby brother of the group and probably jokes to get noticed and meet up with his older brothers. He is not a slacker but his high natural ability makes him bored to do the training and finds time to goof off.

I agree wholeheartedly with the second sentence. The first sentence though is off. I've always been under the impression that he jokes around to help lighten the mood when things at crazy or difficult. That's how he handles/copes with situations.

WinterMorning
07-22-2009, 06:35 PM
I don't mind the cali surfer voice just as long as they don't do what they did in the last movie with the burps and slamming into walls.

YES.

He was extremely adorable in the latest movie (oh those big ol' blues!), but his antics got old really quick.

Rooish
07-23-2009, 04:21 AM
But you forget, they are rebooting the movie franchise, so now we get to see an all new Raph/Leo confrontation :roll:

You are quite definitely right, and this sucks.

Sage Ninja
07-23-2009, 01:17 PM
Michaelangelo is the Baby brother of the group and probably jokes to get noticed and meet up with his older brothers. He is not a slacker but his high natural ability makes him bored to do the training and finds time to goof off.

I'm sorry but I've never liked this explaination. It just seems too much like a cop out. Michelangelo is a battle toughened warrior that some how has been able to hold onto to a sweet compansionate nature and a sense of humor.

I know it's all nice and well for Mikey to be classed as the "baby" brother, but I think to an extent it keeps him down in development.

In all honesty people, do you think there is even a slim chance that they'll ever show Michelangelo's character as anything other than a comic relief?

Samurai Usagi
07-23-2009, 05:16 PM
Leo is the Heart, Don is the Brain, Raph is the Muscle, and Mike is the Mouth.

saiyan_monkey
07-26-2009, 03:50 PM
Leo is the Heart, Don is the Brain, Raph is the Muscle, and Mike is the Mouth.

Thats how it is and Ive always know it.

NO...Michaelangelo is fine the way he is. My daughters favourite by FAR is Michaelangelo. When I was a kid he was my most favourite as well. I prefer if he stayed the way he is cause that is TMNT how Ive always known and will always remember it.

Sage Ninja
07-29-2009, 01:04 PM
Mike needs layers, motivation and a proper character arc with some personal growth.

This sums it up nicely. This is what Mike's been denied in every medium by being pushed in the back by just being flat comic relief. I've almost come to the point where I hate comics reliefs characters. :x

Dan
08-04-2009, 06:51 PM
Somebody on InsaneJournal's scans_daily posted pages from Tales of the TMNT #55 ( see here (http://asylums.insanejournal.com/scans_daily/680901.html) ) and I finally know what bothers me about how Mikey is portrait in the 2k3 series and the new movie I found it funny that Raph had a teddy bear and Mikey is useing the slang chillax in 1984?

MeanGreenMachine
08-07-2009, 04:44 PM
I think Mikey needs toned down a bit, hes becoming something he was never meant to be.

But he's always been my least favorite turtle anyway, the annoying immature one as far as I"m concerned.

Cipher
08-09-2009, 12:27 AM
But he's always been my least favorite turtle anyway, the annoying immature one as far as I"m concerned.See, that's the thing though. In the comics, he's not immature. In fact he's just as, if not more mature than the other Turtles, certainly leaps and bounds above Raphael. He just cracks a joke from time to time.

Vincent
08-11-2009, 03:27 PM
This sums it up nicely. This is what Mike's been denied in every medium by being pushed in the back by just being flat comic relief. I've almost come to the point where I hate comics reliefs characters. :x

Actually, it's a fairly widely taught "rule" of writing that if you've got a character whose sole function and purpose in the story is comic relief, you should consider removing the character from the story entirely.
This is very good reason to rewind Mike back to his roots as the guy who cares, who thinks about the meaning of things, who feels the weight of the situation and questions his own actions. That is a very important function, and something several incarnations of the franchise have been missing badly.

eastx
08-15-2009, 01:40 AM
Mikey's always been my favorite because of his comparatively care-free nature. But I agree that he deserves character development and fleshing out. Leo and Raph always get the character development, but Donny and Mikey could use a turn in the limelight too.

Jelly Bean
08-17-2009, 06:36 PM
Actually, it's a fairly widely taught "rule" of writing that if you've got a character whose sole function and purpose in the story is comic relief, you should consider removing the character from the story entirely.

then why does so many shows, books, and movies have stupid comic relief characters in them?

Tuxedo Moroboshi
08-18-2009, 03:52 AM
Mikey's always been my favorite because of his comparatively care-free nature. But I agree that he deserves character development and fleshing out.

Giving Mike more development and fleshing him out wouldn't mean taking away his care-free nature, though. The surfer talk (or stoner talk, like 2k7) and the skateboarding and all of that stuff aren't what make him a carefree character, afterall. He's a carefree character in the comics, too.

then why does so many shows, books, and movies have stupid comic relief characters in them?

I dunno. Why are there so many bad shows, books, and movies?

Vincent
08-18-2009, 03:35 PM
then why does so many shows, books, and movies have stupid comic relief characters in them?
Because some people just don't bloody well ever learn, do they?

mikey22
10-10-2009, 06:54 PM
He should be called Michaelangelo by Splinter (sorry I like it spelled Michael cause my name is Michael tee hee)

Mike by the other turtles

Mikey by April/Casey and other Misc. turtles


We need him to be the fun loving goof as it what's Laird created him to be. That's why all 4 of them go hand in hand together. The little kid stuff can be toned down a bit, but his love for video games and skateboards shouldn't be stopped. His COWABUNGA and pizza reference should also be used at least once.

He's my favorite turtle just because of the fact he doesn't take everything serious.


I think a cool way to introduce him since this is the beginning! Is that while the others Turtles are practicing or doing whatever, he is caught watching Stand up Comedy- be it a George Carlin or Robin Williams or a will ferrell comedy.

This way you can see he was always a jokester.

lilmotto
10-10-2009, 07:38 PM
I just found this thread and haven't read through everything so if I am restating a point sorry, but I am a big Michelangelo fan. He is my favorite turtle! The thing with Mike is he has depth/layers. Yes he can make jokes, but he wants love and to love. He is the turtle with the biggest heart I think. All we have seen on the screen is the comedian, which is fun and all but there is so much more to him. Honestly I am just excited for a TMNT movie.

Coola Yagami
10-10-2009, 07:44 PM
He should be called Michaelangelo by Splinter (sorry I like it spelled Michael cause my name is Michael tee hee)

Mike by the other turtles

Mikey by April/Casey and other Misc. turtles


We need him to be the fun loving goof as it what's Laird created him to be. That's why all 4 of them go hand in hand together. The little kid stuff can be toned down a bit, but his love for video games and skateboards shouldn't be stopped. His COWABUNGA and pizza reference should also be used at least once.

He's my favorite turtle just because of the fact he doesn't take everything serious.


I think a cool way to introduce him since this is the beginning! Is that while the others Turtles are practicing or doing whatever, he is caught watching Stand up Comedy- be it a George Carlin or Robin Williams or a will ferrell comedy.

This way you can see he was always a jokester.

That could work. Just that when it's time to get serious, he should get serious too. Maybe spit out an occasional Spidey-type one-liner, but don't make him oblivious to the seriousness of the situation. And certainly DON'T make him annoying. Make him funny cause he just is, don't make him actually try too hard to be funny and annoy his brothers in serious moments.

Hell in the older movies, Mikey was a goofy loveable jokester (using the 'time share' line between Leo and Raph to break it up before it got too ugly), but never annoying, and never overdoing it, and getting serious when it came down to it. Now that I think about it, in the old movies, Mike was just as comptetent in bustin out sweet ninja moves as his brothers. He wasn't the 'one most likely to slip on a banana peel' or whatever like the 2007 tried to make him be. I'm reffering to the into where the turtles appear 1 by 1 doing bad-ass poses while Mikey falls into a trash can.

Warhorse
10-11-2009, 01:56 PM
That could work. Just that when it's time to get serious, he should get serious too. Maybe spit out an occasional Spidey-type one-liner, but don't make him oblivious to the seriousness of the situation. And certainly DON'T make him annoying. Make him funny cause he just is, don't make him actually try too hard to be funny and annoy his brothers in serious moments.

Hell in the older movies, Mikey was a goofy loveable jokester (using the 'time share' line between Leo and Raph to break it up before it got too ugly), but never annoying, and never overdoing it, and getting serious when it came down to it. Now that I think about it, in the old movies, Mike was just as comptetent in bustin out sweet ninja moves as his brothers. He wasn't the 'one most likely to slip on a banana peel' or whatever like the 2007 tried to make him be. I'm reffering to the into where the turtles appear 1 by 1 doing bad-ass poses while Mikey falls into a trash can.

That's the ticket. This is why the old movies Mikey is my favorite. Hell, even in the third one, he had a pretty good teeth sinking role to bite into. And we saw a hint of this in The Christmas Aliens episode in the 2k3 series, but why they didn't expand on that, is beyond me.

The Stryker
10-11-2009, 04:40 PM
All of them need a personality make over to an extent. All of them are generic archetypes.

JessEH
10-13-2009, 10:36 AM
Just like you being the generic "internet troll"?

Every single post I've seen by this guy has been filled with either idiocy or venom.

The Stryker
10-13-2009, 03:23 PM
Just like you being the generic "internet troll"?

Every single post I've seen by this guy has been filled with either idiocy or venom.

Venom? I love Topher Grace!

Are you seriously telling me that they aren't generic? The smart one, The angry one, The Leader and The party dude?

Cipher
10-13-2009, 03:28 PM
Are you seriously telling me that they aren't generic? The smart one, The angry one, The Leader and The party dude?No, you're pretty much dead on.

The only incarnation where they haven't been one note "I'm angry/smart/whatever" characters are the comics. And (maybe) the first three movies. But even then they have to play into their set roles a little bit.

Michelangelo's case is particularly bad, though. If they're all going to be two dimensional stereotypes, then they should at least get a better single trait than "irritating/immature." Especially when nothing could be so removed from the pre-2003 versions of Mike.

Every single post I've seen by this guy has been filled with either idiocy or venom. The irony is palpable. I'm palpating it.

EDIT - WAIT. I know what he's gonna say next since he thinks he knows so much.

"Oh, where did you come from, eh? It's like you guys all defend each other for no reason!"

Wait and see. Yeah, hurr hurr, I get it.

Brodie
10-13-2009, 03:31 PM
Just like you being the generic "internet troll"?

Every single post I've seen by this guy has been filled with either idiocy or venom.

http://i728.photobucket.com/albums/ww286/DiscoBryan/Fatboy_reacts.gif

Flattery will get you nowhere, newbie.

Seriously though...The Turtles are essentially the New Kids on the Block.

Cure
10-13-2009, 03:33 PM
WAIT. I know what he's gonna say next since he thinks he knows so much.

"Oh, where did you come from, eh? It's like you guys all defend each other for no reason!"

Wait and see.

JessEH
10-13-2009, 03:57 PM
You can put anyone into such categories with little effort, if you wanted to.

As far as the comics go, I don't see them being so simple.

But then again we are discussing the movie incarnations (which I haven't dealt with for ages).

But honestly I posted here because I felt I needed to confront Stryker in his behavior (same goes for General Tregg). I am puzzled at how this behavior has been allowed here for so long. Have you seen their posts? It's just I thought this place was at least run by semi-mindful adults, not angry bitter little teens who think they know everything in the world.

But I guess I'm in the wrong for promoting decency on the internet, no? I'm sorry if everything in life isn't a ****ing joke to me.

This is why I can't talk with people. I don't conform to the patterns.

Carry on.

The Stryker
10-13-2009, 04:05 PM
You can put anyone into such categories with little effort, if you wanted to.

As far as the comics go, I don't see them being so simple.

But then again we are discussing the movie incarnations (which I haven't dealt with for ages).

But honestly I posted here because I felt I needed to confront Stryker in his behavior (same goes for General Tregg). I am puzzled at how this behavior has been allowed here for so long. Have you seen their posts? It's just I thought this place was at least run by semi-mindful adults, not angry bitter little teens who think they know everything in the world.

But I guess I'm in the wrong for promoting decency on the internet, no? I'm sorry if everything in life isn't a ****ing joke to me.

This is why I can't talk with people. I don't conform to the patterns.

Carry on.

Conform to patterns? What?

You're not some sort of super hero trying to stop the evils of differing opinions (You missed that boat by a few months). Calm down, You're on a ninja turtle message board.

Cure
10-13-2009, 04:25 PM
EDIT - Yeah, hurr hurr, I get it.

Actually, that wasn't at you. I didn't even see your post. I agree with you this time. I just meant that's what a lot of people like to say to us.

Brodie
10-13-2009, 06:26 PM
It's just I thought this place was at least run by semi-mindful adults, not angry bitter little teens who think they know everything in the world.

Dad's gonna be pisssssssedddddddddddd
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_4OYGjUrdllo/Sef484oQE_I/AAAAAAAAT1s/Wt19qAmY-pQ/s400/krang.jpg


But I guess I'm in the wrong for promoting decency on the internet, no? I'm sorry if everything in life isn't a ****ing joke to me.

This is why I can't talk with people. I don't conform to the patterns.


I...Hang on...there's...something that just...doesn't add up...

not angry bitter little teens who think they know everything in the world.

This is why I can't talk with people. I don't conform to the patterns.

not angry bitter little teens who think they know everything in the world.

This is why I can't talk with people. I don't conform to the patterns.

not angry bitter little teens who think they know everything in the world.

This is why I can't talk with people. I don't conform to the patterns.

not angry bitter little teens who think they know everything in the world.

This is why I can't talk with people. I don't conform to the patterns.


It makes so much sense now.

YOU think you're not falling into patterns, but you're totally one of those "you laugh cause I'm different...I laugh cause you're all the same!" kids.

It's alright little guy, I'm sure someone likes your asymmetrical haircut.

JessEH
10-13-2009, 06:55 PM
No. That isn't it.

In the end, I simply want to declare the beauty of love and honesty.

Spitting on Laird and the joy he has given you, joking about mail bombing someone, making sarcastic remarks with the sole intention of insulting someone. These are not good things. So cruel is the flesh, so unworthy is this world. It is doomed.

Darkness in jest is still darkness. Your shades of gray have no rock for foundation.

Those who make light of such things are blind. Their master is the master of the world. The master of fools.

Cure
10-13-2009, 07:04 PM
No. That isn't it.

In the end, I simply want to declare the beauty of love and honesty.

Spitting on Laird and the joy he has given you, joking about mail bombing someone, making sarcastic remarks with the sole intention of insulting someone. These are not good things. So cruel is the flesh, so unworthy is this world. It is doomed.

Darkness in jest is still darkness. Your shades of gray have no rock for foundation.

Those who make light of such things are blind. Their master is the master of the world. The master of fools.

You're scary. I'm not messing with you anymore. Seems like you take things WAY too seriously.

The Stryker
10-13-2009, 07:08 PM
No. That isn't it.

In the end, I simply want to declare the beauty of love and honesty.

Spitting on Laird and the joy he has given you, joking about mail bombing someone, making sarcastic remarks with the sole intention of insulting someone. These are not good things. So cruel is the flesh, so unworthy is this world. It is doomed.

Darkness in jest is still darkness. Your shades of gray have no rock for foundation.

Those who make light of such things are blind. Their master is the master of the world. The master of fools.

Wow. Just wow. IT'S NINJA TURTLES. CALM DOWN.

ToTheNines
10-13-2009, 07:17 PM
No. That isn't it.

In the end, I simply want to declare the beauty of love and honesty.

Spitting on Laird and the joy he has given you, joking about mail bombing someone, making sarcastic remarks with the sole intention of insulting someone. These are not good things. So cruel is the flesh, so unworthy is this world. It is doomed.

Darkness in jest is still darkness. Your shades of gray have no rock for foundation.

Those who make light of such things are blind. Their master is the master of the world. The master of fools.

You're like a poet. Only really funny.

Katie
10-13-2009, 07:32 PM
I like how he called Stryker an "angry teen". Stryker's older than you, silly....and definitely not a kid ;)


yes.....yes they need makeovers. It's boring to have single sided personalities It's boring to be able to know exactly how each will react given their archeotype.

At least add some interesting layers to their personalities

JessEH
10-13-2009, 08:19 PM
I like how he called Stryker an "angry teen". Stryker's older than you, silly....and definitely not a kid ;)


You miss the point, dear. Whether he is physically 15 or 115, it makes no difference. He rejects light.

Wow. Just wow. IT'S NINJA TURTLES. CALM DOWN.

Calm down? What am I doing that isn't calm? I'm not foaming at the mouth, running up and down the walls. My sentences are structured and coherent.

And this isn't Ninja Turtles. This is a group of people. People with thoughts... people with feelings... people with souls. Does that mean anything to you?

What IS life to you?

ToTheNines
10-13-2009, 08:24 PM
You're being melodramatic in a creepy way about a kids show... expect to hear some sh*t about it.

The Stryker
10-13-2009, 08:29 PM
Calm down? What am I doing that isn't calm? I'm not foaming at the mouth, running up and down the walls. My sentences are structured and coherent.

And this isn't Ninja Turtles. This is a group of people. People with thoughts... people with feelings... people with souls. Does that mean anything to you?

What IS life to you?

You're going on and on about moral bullsh*t when we're actually discussing giant turtles that have been known to say radical. This is serious business to you and that's alittle creepy. Wait, correction, A lot creepy.

How am I shattering lives by saying that I think these fictional characters are generic stereotypes?

Edit: BTW, I don't have a soul.

http://blogs.setonhill.edu/AmandaCochran/squidward.jpg

JessEH
10-13-2009, 08:30 PM
You're being melodramatic in a creepy way about a kids show... expect to hear some sh*t about it.

Are the eyes of your flesh as deceitful as the eyes of your heart?

This has nothing to do with the turtles. I made that abundantly clear in my second post.

Feel free to ignore me, by all means. Just know, that in the end, I do wish you all true love and and true happiness. TRUE. Not the illusion that the world has built.


How am I shattering lives by saying that I think these fictional characters are generic stereotypes?

This has nothing to do with the turtles. I made that abundantly clear in my second post.

ToTheNines
10-13-2009, 08:33 PM
Is it the end of the world if people say mean things on the internet? Also, this place is rather docile compared to alot of others.

Brodie
10-13-2009, 08:34 PM
http://marvel.com/universe3zx/images/thumb/6/61/MoleMan.jpg/440px-MoleMan.jpg*



*Also known to reject light.

Cure
10-13-2009, 08:34 PM
Looks like you've reached true enlightenment.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v245/KevMan87/128908761054012782.jpg

The Stryker
10-13-2009, 08:35 PM
http://marvel.com/universe3zx/images/thumb/6/61/MoleMan.jpg/440px-MoleMan.jpg*

Awesome. I'm Moleman?!

I demand lots of underworld bitches.

Cipher
10-13-2009, 11:50 PM
Actually, that wasn't at you. I didn't even see your post. I agree with you this time. I just meant that's what a lot of people like to say to us.Oh, a'ight then.

In other news...what in the flying blue f*ck has happened here?

The Stryker
10-14-2009, 12:50 AM
No idea. It's a shame too. I really thought this was a decent subject.

JessEH
10-14-2009, 01:11 AM
I'm finished for now (if you guys are).

You can continue your trivial banter on Michelangelo unhindered.

The Stryker
10-14-2009, 01:37 AM
Okay then, Go away.

So yeah. I believe that all of the turtles need a change in character. Nothing too crazy, Just enough to flesh them out.

Krutch
10-14-2009, 04:58 AM
OOOOOOHHhhhhh I get it!

You're LARPing, right?

Makes total sense now.

I think all your posts go in a different forum though...

odupianist
10-14-2009, 08:11 AM
Focus everyone: Mikey just needs to be shown as who he is in the comics, someone with a big heart that likes to diffuse tense situations with jokes, not the ADD surfer who can be annoying to his brothers and the audience.

Here's a thought, what if we put a new twist on Mikey. What if we made him like Deadpool in the sense that he thinks/knows he's in a movie/comic/tv show?

Tomoshibi Amatsu
10-14-2009, 06:57 PM
I think Mikey is fine as is, but I suppose they're getting there. 2k3 Mikey was a lot better than 80s Mikey, and was more sensitive and serious to things. The only shortcoming was that they also made him an egocentric jerk.

But if they can fix that he'll pretty much be close to the comic version.

Peanut
10-14-2009, 07:10 PM
Feel free to ignore me, by all means. Just know, that in the end, I do wish you all true love and and true happiness. TRUE. Not the illusion that the world has built.

I understand you, my friend. Your words do not fall upon deaf ears.

Jelly Bean
10-20-2009, 05:26 PM
I have to give this topic props for not getting derailed with emo debates earlier than what it did. :evilgrin:

Here's a thought, what if we put a new twist on Mikey. What if we made him like Deadpool in the sense that he thinks/knows he's in a movie/comic/tv show?

Oh my God man! WTF!? :-? Just when i thought you had repect for the the character!!!

Originally Posted by Tomoshibi Amatsu
I think Mikey is fine as is, but I suppose they're getting there. 80's Mikey was a lot better than 2k3's Mikey, and was more sensitive and serious to things.

there. I fixed that eye sore mistake you made there.

odupianist
10-21-2009, 07:43 AM
Oh my God man! WTF!? :-? Just when i thought you had repect for the the character!!!

Hah I do, but they used to do it in the old cartoon from time to time. (Plus it is amusing when Deadpool will do it occassionally). And I probably just defeated my earlier statement by mentioning that they did it in the OT. lol

jaymq
11-02-2009, 06:46 AM
I hate NT Mike more than anything else in the entirety TMNT. With new Movie Mike right behind him Whoever his writers were clearly didn't know or care about the classic Mikey. That is Mirage and OT. I could add movie 1, but only thing that comes to mind and him and Don making offhand comments that was probably start the Leo vs Raph war that ends up in every series now. "Fight? Fight. Kitchen? Kitchen." Mike's cut scene probably would've done justice for the character, so when I heard Judith Hoag wishing they hadn't cut that stuff, I did agree with her.

NT Mike a jackass. He learns something and 5mins later he reverts back to the idiot that was in the previous episode, he has no sense of kindness that some of his previous incarnations have given him and I didn't think the girly scream was that funny after the first time.

So... personality make-over? Probably not. But they do need to get back to basics.

Vivi
11-02-2009, 08:46 AM
Although at times the NT Mikey can seem a little off (well, excessively hyper), I think there are a lot of redeeming traits. He can be sweet, motherly, and he's pretty damn agile --> see the episode where he finds Klunk.
I like the idea that his annoyingness is an intentional way to derail the serious demeanor of his brothers, be it for relief or tactical advantage. In the Battle Nexus episode where he fights Raph it's pretty obvious that is exactly what he is doing. But it would be good if that trait was pulled short more often when Mikey realizes he has gotten through to them.

Angabariel
11-02-2009, 09:48 AM
i do not think they should give him a make over, cause I like him the way he is. To me he is a funloving, kind and caring personality that likes to make people laugh and losen up a bit. That's what so great about him. But sometimes I do think he needs to grow up a bit and learn some things.

I 2k3 series has made him more likeable cause the 80's series made me hate him. He was far to goofy and more of an clown then a ninja, but nowadays they have made him more agile, funny in a grown up way (some of the jokes a made for grown ups) and caring. He is a great warrior, cause he knows how to losen up before a fight and he is agile...

Gah I know that my english is kind of bad but I hope that you understand what I mean.

NameGoesHere1066
11-03-2009, 03:03 PM
I hate NT Mike more than anything else in the entirety TMNT. With new Movie Mike right behind him Whoever his writers were clearly didn't know or care about the classic Mikey. That is Mirage and OT. I could add movie 1, but only thing that comes to mind and him and Don making offhand comments that was probably start the Leo vs Raph war that ends up in every series now. "Fight? Fight. Kitchen? Kitchen." Mike's cut scene probably would've done justice for the character, so when I heard Judith Hoag wishing they hadn't cut that stuff, I did agree with her.

NT Mike a jackass. He learns something and 5mins later he reverts back to the idiot that was in the previous episode, he has no sense of kindness that some of his previous incarnations have given him and I didn't think the girly scream was that funny after the first time.

thankyou.

I 2k3 series has made him more likeable cause the 80's series made me hate him. He was far to goofy and more of an clown then a ninja, but nowadays they have made him more agile, funny in a grown up way (some of the jokes a made for grown ups) and caring. He is a great warrior, cause he knows how to losen up before a fight and he is agile...

god. I love the misguided 2k3 Mikey fans, making more out of him than what he was. :roll:

2k3 Mike was a chump and a complete waste of screen time. He was useless. Everything the turtles coukld have done in the series they could have done just fine with out out him. He was a filler character.

Turo602
11-03-2009, 06:20 PM
He wasn't just a dumb goofy filler, he did much more than OT Mikey. He wanted to do good and take credit for it so he became Turtle Titan. He was also Battle Nexus Champion and light hearted because he cared for Klunk and took him in and almost gave his life for him. He also had his funny and bad ass moments like when he saved all the turtles in (Notes from the underground Part 3) and he was most of the comedy in the show.

Andrew NDB
11-03-2009, 06:33 PM
OK, fine, I'll weigh in.

While many of the TMNT in the various cartoons and certainly the Archies are respectable... Mikey in pretty much any universe other than the just needs a bullet to face. With proper writing the TMNT's banter with each other can make for enough humor without, like, one designated funnyman.

And his portrayal in TMNT Part 4 was downright painful to watch.

Coola Yagami
11-03-2009, 09:20 PM
OK, fine, I'll weigh in.

While many of the TMNT in the various cartoons and certainly the Archies are respectable... Mikey in pretty much any universe other than the just needs a bullet to face. With proper writing the TMNT's banter with each other can make for enough humor without, like, one designated funnyman.

And his portrayal in TMNT Part 4 was downright painful to watch.

I hope you don't mean 80's Mikey too. He was cool. Surfer lingo aside, he was as good-natured and competent as the other guys were.

Sage Ninja
11-04-2009, 12:10 PM
He wasn't just a dumb goofy filler, he did much more than OT Mikey.

I disagree here. I believe that OT Mike did alot in old toon and was very involved in the missions and plots. Comparably, I think OT Mike was better utilized as a character than 2k3 Mike was. OT Mike was compentant and not nearly the clown that he is made out to be by fans and even the characters in the old toon series.

He wanted to do good and take credit for it so he became Turtle Titan. He was also Battle Nexus Champion and light hearted because he cared for Klunk and took him in and almost gave his life for him. He also had his funny and bad ass moments like when he saved all the turtles in (Notes from the underground Part 3) and he was most of the comedy in the show.

My problem with Mikey in the "serious" mediums of the franchise (2k3 & fourth movie) is that the writers just...don't...treat him with very much respect. They give him almost no dignity, because they use him as a punch line. All the the humor is placed on his shoulders, so the writers often have him doing or saying things they can't have the other three turtles have because it would wreck havoc with their macho personas and you wouldn't take them seriously. So the writers have Mikey act like a butt monkey to throw in that piece of "humor," to the detriment of his character. He comes off as erratic and inconsistent. One episode he will be a sweet heart and the next, to make the atmoshphere "funny" they'll have him act like a jerk.

ANd I hate to say it, but often times he does off as a filler character. And that filler character is to be this insanely annoying little brother.

With proper writing the TMNT's banter with each other can make for enough humor without, like, one designated funnyman

exactly! I completely agree. Having just one guy as the funny man is just lazy writing.

jaymq
11-05-2009, 06:15 PM
With proper writing the TMNT's banter with each other can make for enough humor without, like, one designated funnyman

exactly! I completely agree. Having just one guy as the funny man is just lazy writing.

I'm also agreeing with this. 2k3 Mike would have been much more tolerable as a whole if they had actually tried to make it funny without reducing one (and a major one at that) character to idiocy 99% of the time. Having the brothers banter off each other would have been awesome. Then there would have been more room for Mikey character development.

Turo602
11-05-2009, 06:27 PM
exactly! I completely agree. Having just one guy as the funny man is just lazy writing.

Well he's not all the comedy Leo Raph and Don get their moments like when Raph was going to smack Mikey and Leo stopped him and he did it himself. Then when Donnie cheated on finding all the turtles on the roof and Raph wanted to hit him. So Mikey wasn't always the comedy in the show the other turtles were just as funny. Hell even Splinter was funny.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
11-16-2009, 04:17 AM
I have to give this topic props for not getting derailed with emo debates earlier than what it did. :evilgrin:



Oh my God man! WTF!? :-? Just when i thought you had repect for the the character!!!



there. I fixed that eye sore mistake you made there.

Oh come on. Like 80s Mikey who had constant orgasms when thinking about pizza... which he did every five seconds is better than 2k3 Mikey? I know 2k3 Mikey was a douche but I'd say that's a step up from 80s Mikey who cried whenever the oven broke.

Doc_ock_4mugen
11-16-2009, 07:15 AM
Oh come on. Like 80s Mikey who had constant orgasms when thinking about pizza... which he did every five seconds is better than 2k3 Mikey? I know 2k3 Mikey was a douche but I'd say that's a step up from 80s Mikey who cried whenever the oven broke.

Other than the pizza obsession 80s mikey was a better character than 2k3 mikey. The 2k3 Mikey is not only annoying, but it seems as he is trying too hard to be likable and fails at that. The worst mikey is 2k7 movie mikey... They just took the worst traits of 2k3 and kicked them up a bunch of notches.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
11-16-2009, 05:28 PM
Other than the pizza obsession 80s mikey was a better character than 2k3 mikey. The 2k3 Mikey is not only annoying, but it seems as he is trying too hard to be likable and fails at that. The worst mikey is 2k7 movie mikey... They just took the worst traits of 2k3 and kicked them up a bunch of notches.

Well of course you'll think that way if you only see him as a douchebag one-man comedy routine. Obviously 2k3 has shown that he's not just that either.

I even went back and watched some of the 80s TMNT after marathoning 2k3, and I still believe 2k3 Mikey is an improvement. Just like how the other turtles are improvements over their campy counterparts as well. I'm not saying that 2k3 Mikey doesn't have his bad points, but they're mostly over exaggerated when they don't need to be.

jaymq
11-16-2009, 05:50 PM
I haven't watched the OT recently, but I do recall OT Mike watching over his three brothers when they got turned into toddlers. I won't for a second believe 2k3 Mikey could pull that off without someone getting seriously injured.

If he did, he'd only reset to jerk mode in the next episode.

*shrugs* 2k3 Mike doesn't learn anything. He knows no humility where as OT and Mirage Mike both can be fun and mature without coming off as a dick.

CyberCubed
11-16-2009, 05:56 PM
Old toon Mikey was indeed much more down to Earth than people realize.

1987 Michaelangelo just loved pizza and hanging out with the guys, instead of doing some of the irritating stuff 2k3 and 2007 movie Mike did.

Coola Yagami
11-16-2009, 07:40 PM
What was wrong with 2K7 Mike? I mean, he hardly had any screen-time to really do anything. All he had was the surfer voice, and the fact that he missed the old days of fighting crime and didn't like how the Turtles have become in Leo's absence. His Cowabunga Carl thing was Don's idea. I mean, really, what did he really do so annoying besides not having an actual fight scene with his chucks?

Turo602
11-16-2009, 09:05 PM
He acted too much of a kid. But he was alright to me.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
11-16-2009, 10:49 PM
*shrugs* 2k3 Mike doesn't learn anything. He knows no humility where as OT and Mirage Mike both can be fun and mature without coming off as a dick.

He doesn't learn *anything?* He knows no humility? If I remember correctly, there was an entire episode of Fast Forward about Mikey learning humility. In my opinion he's the hardest of the four to nail, I wouldn't want the job of writing him. I actually found him quite funny in both the 2K3 cartoon and the fourth movie.

Powder
11-16-2009, 11:03 PM
Oh a white knight! Disintegrator unit anyone?

Tomoshibi Amatsu
11-17-2009, 01:01 AM
and also he did stop bragging about his battle nexus victory after the re-match with Klub so I would think thhat also taught him humility as well.

The Turtle Titan thing is the only time I've ever really seen him as acting like a douche. But can you really blame him? He makes a lot of accomplishments yet the Justice Force shows him no respect. Heck they've even recruited his own brothers over him. Not to mention his brothers treat him as a joke. It wasn't until FF and his confrontation with the new Turtle Titan that Mikey finally got the recognition he had been craving.

Otherwise 2k3 Mikey really is a caring, sweet, compassionate soul who obviously acts obnoxious as the funny guy either out of force of habit, or because he just hates everything being serious all the time. After all could you even imagine living with brothers like Don, Raph, and Leo? Not to mention a father who expects a lot out of you when it comes to ninja training? Heck maybe it's Mikey's way of not cracking under all the pressure.

odupianist
11-17-2009, 07:57 AM
I haven't watched the OT recently, but I do recall OT Mike watching over his three brothers when they got turned into toddlers. I won't for a second believe 2k3 Mikey could pull that off without someone getting seriously injured.

If he did, he'd only reset to jerk mode in the next episode.

*shrugs* 2k3 Mike doesn't learn anything. He knows no humility where as OT and Mirage Mike both can be fun and mature without coming off as a dick.

I beg to differ about that whole "someone getting seriously injured". When Kluh threatened his family, Mike kicked in to hardcore mode and gave him what for. He learns a lot of stuff. I'd say him and Raph are tied for character development; Leo being the first with his time with the Ancient One.

He doesn't learn *anything?* He knows no humility? If I remember correctly, there was an entire episode of Fast Forward about Mikey learning humility. In my opinion he's the hardest of the four to nail, I wouldn't want the job of writing him. I actually found him quite funny in both the 2K3 cartoon and the fourth movie.

Agreed. I'm with you on this one. Although, I think Don would be the hardest to write over Mike. I found the 2k3 Mike quite entertaining. His jokes (while some say annoying) I found predictable. He's just a goof who likes to have fun even when the pressure is on. He's the light hearted one of the group who likes to see the light in things and help keeping people from cracking as Amatsu said. I think Mike makes the jokes to help keep from fallling under the pressure. It's his way of coping with it (as is mine lol).

Sage Ninja
11-17-2009, 04:05 PM
people...seriously.

jaymq
11-18-2009, 04:01 PM
I beg to differ about that whole "someone getting seriously injured". When Kluh threatened his family, Mike kicked in to hardcore mode and gave him what for.

You missed this.

If he did, he'd only reset to jerk mode in the next episode.


He nearly got himself killed in the next episode by being a jerk off 'cause he got a good blow on a bad guy. :)

NameGoesHere1066
11-24-2009, 03:45 PM
The Turtle Titan thing is the only time I've ever really seen him as acting like a douche.

the only time? You need to take off the rose colored glasses my friend.

But can you really blame him? He makes a lot of accomplishments yet the Justice Force shows him no respect.

I loathe his TT persona but even I can say that this isn't true. Silver Sentry for what ever reeason seems to tolerate him. other than that when has that justice league nock off ever not shown him any respect?

Heck they've even recruited his own brothers over him.

example?


Not to mention his brothers treat him as a joke.

uh...do you blame them? maybe they'd repect him more if he didn't act like a walking punch line or attention whore all the time, or actually helped more instead of screwing around when it's important and causing problems. half the time anything the turtles do they coukld have done just fine with out him, even if they didn't have him to play as decoy. maybe they'd respect him more if he didn't shove any accomplishment in their faces and make a deal out of it to the point they want to see him put in his place.

It wasn't until FF and his confrontation with the new Turtle Titan that Mikey finally got the recognition he had been craving.

you've got to be kidding me if you are going to argue that "clash of the turtle titans" episode did anything to make Mikey look postive? he was juvinile douche bag in that episode? It was so exgerated even for Mikey.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
11-26-2009, 09:36 PM
the only time? You need to take off the rose colored glasses my friend.

Well I meant to the point where I was annoyed by it. I personally didn't mind Mikey's Battle Nexus bragging as it was really the first time when he showed up his brothers.



I loathe his TT persona but even I can say that this isn't true. Silver Sentry for what ever reeason seems to tolerate him. other than that when has that justice league nock off ever not shown him any respect?

example?

When Raph got the mystic cape and pretty much stole Mikey's spotlight from the Justice Force. Then again Mikey's always been passed up like when Mikey wanted to sign up to become a member of the Justice Force. I remember Leo went with him and they showed more interest in Leo than in Turtle Titan, and then they just completely cockblocked Mikey by signing up Nano, and this is after all the times Mikey has saved their asses. You would think Mikey is due for some recognition. Sure they tolerate him but that isn't the same as showing him any recognition or respect. They pretty much treat him like the water boy of the Justice Force.




uh...do you blame them? maybe they'd repect him more if he didn't act like a walking punch line or attention whore all the time, or actually helped more instead of screwing around when it's important and causing problems. half the time anything the turtles do they coukld have done just fine with out him, even if they didn't have him to play as decoy. maybe they'd respect him more if he didn't shove any accomplishment in their faces and make a deal out of it to the point they want to see him put in his place.

Well maybe if his brothers actually thought he could succeed he wouldn't need to shove his accomplishments in their faces. Raph most of all deserved it when Mikey rubbed his Battle Nexus victory in his face considering Raph believed Mikey wasn't capable of becoming champion. Also he's the youngest of course the youngest will act like an attention whore.



you've got to be kidding me if you are going to argue that "clash of the turtle titans" episode did anything to make Mikey look postive? he was juvinile douche bag in that episode? It was so exgerated even for Mikey.

I never said he wasn't a juvenile douche bag throughout the entire episode, but pretty much at the end of the whole ordeal he realized that he had gotten the respect and credibility as a hero he always wanted by hearing that the new Turtle Titan became who he was because of Mikey. Mikey passing the torch after all those temper tantrums did show his humility and maturity. After all if he was as immature as people claim he wouldn't have passed the torch at all.

Oculus Orbus
12-05-2009, 04:37 PM
2k3 cartoon and 2007 movie have been way too much. Michelangelo deserves a lot better.

ryukenden
12-06-2009, 04:32 PM
In his own time, Mikey can be the laid-back, fun-loving "party dude" all he wants. During battles, Mikey should focus along with the rest of his brothers.

holy_guacamole
12-16-2009, 07:38 PM
Michelangelo has always been the most caring, fun and imaginative Turtle. The Mirage microseries is an excellent portrayal of who he is as a character. For one, of the four, he is probably the one who most wants to be human, as seen in the scene where he goes sledding with the children. He is also compassionate, as seen in his rescue and adoption of Klunk. He's also the most fun-loving and immature. This is shown when he is in the toy store, playing with Klunk. But his sense of duty and moral compass on what is right and what is wrong is on par with the others. This is why he risks his life for something as seemingly arbitrary as making sure orphans receive their Christmas presents.

In a recent issue of Tales of the TMNT, Raphael describes fighting with Mikey as "a lot of fun" and I certainly think this is true. There is a strong correlation between the weapon each Turtle wields and their attitude, and I think this is strongest with Michelangelo: The nunchucks are a flashy and agile weapon that, while certainly a effective combat instrument, are very fun to watch when properly put to use: They put on a good show. I think this really goes hand and hand with who Michelangelo is: He has been described as the most agile and athletic of the four Turtles, and the most fun.

He's also the most creative, having been a published author.

He relates to others better than the other Turtles. A social creature, Mikey lives with Casey and April in volume 2 while his brothers go their separate ways. He manages to make the other Turtles dress up for Christmas as seen in his microseries and is the closest to Shadow.

Even in the old 1987 cartoon, when one peels away the layers of the Jeff-Spicoli-likeness, there are depths to his character. Of the four, he is the only to have a kind of boyfriend-girlfriend relationship (as seen with Kala the Neutrino). He puts his neck on the line to help Bugman and the son of the toy manufacturer early in season four. He calms the robot down in "Attack of the Big MACC" without the use of violence. He's the one who decides to throw Irma a birthday party in "Attack of the Fifty-Foot Irma" and goes out and gets a job in "Pizza by the Shred".

I think the characterization of Michelangelo is already there, it's just too diluted: In the original Mirage comics, he was really a secondary character. Kevin Eastman's and Peter Laird's favorite Turtles were Donatello and Raphael so they were more prominent in the stories. Also, a good chunk of the stories, Eastman and Laird thought, needed to revolve around Leonardo since he was the leader. Because of this, Mikey is the least developed character in the Mirage universe. It's hard to get a sense of who Michelangelo is in one or two comics, but collectively, with 25 years of characterization to drawn on, In my opinion, his character is really well defined.

I don't think he needs a personality makeover, but I do think the filmmakers need to treat his existing personality with respect.

Dejablue
12-17-2009, 07:22 PM
Man I could have sworn back in the 80's Mikey was the freakin mascot of the franchise. I had no idea people hated him so much until recently. Well okay maybe Hate is too strong of a word but still... I hear people say his personality is the most far removed when it comes to being a ninja. But I think the person above eloquently put it all in perspective.

Scandia
12-17-2009, 07:36 PM
Mikey's fine.

Raph is the one that needs an attitude adjustment. Make him more like the OT Raphael. While he was still my least fave Turtle, this is the only version of him I can stomach.

Dejablue
12-17-2009, 07:39 PM
Mikey's fine.

Raph is the one that needs an attitude adjustment. Make him more like the OT Raphael. While he was still my least fave Turtle, this is the only version of him I can stomach.

Hahaha really? Almost all my friends hated OT Raph. Back when I was younger I was the only one who was totally oblivious to the comic book. They didn't like how 180 OT Raph was in that regard.

heretic888
12-17-2009, 09:44 PM
Mikey's fine.

Raph is the one that needs an attitude adjustment. Make him more like the OT Raphael. While he was still my least fave Turtle, this is the only version of him I can stomach.

OT Raph and OT Mike were basically what you get when you take Mirage Mike and rip him into two different characters and then exaggerate each side's personality traits. Raphael wasn't in the OT at all, just two different sides or aspects of Michelangelo.

As for Mikey's portrayal in the new movie, I honestly hope the writers just draw on the comics. Mirage comics, Image comics, Archie comics, Dreamwave comics... it doesn't matter. His character is reasonably consistent throughout all the comic mediums and has far more depth than any of the cartoon or movie iterations. Particularly the 2K3 series, where he was little more than a comic relief character that had a handful of shining moments.

Also, holy_guacamole is spot on. I would I only add that I feel Mike's "role" in the group, so to speak, is a sort of Everyman that humanizes and grounds the TMNT. That's also why he functions as the heart and moral center of the family.

holy_guacamole
12-17-2009, 10:08 PM
My two cents on OT Raphael...

Love him.

I'm a bit of a smartass myself and have a sarcastic wit that...well, it annoys a lot of people. I loved that about Raph. The bruiser-Wolverine-I'm-gonna-kill-everyone-who-gets-in-my-way Raph never appealed to me. In fact, if the OT version of Raph was Mirage canon, he'd be my favorite. And, as Heretic pointed out, the original version of Mike and the OT Raph are almost the same character.

Vivi
12-18-2009, 07:13 AM
Michelangelo's a hyper teen whom you know in time will become a solid, likeable adult. I think this is glimpsed at in SAINW and even the Vol 4 comics. I think a lot of his personality is shaped by the hard edges of his brothers...and like others have already mentioned, it grounds the group. He 'bends like the reed', and so forth.

heretic888
12-18-2009, 02:40 PM
Michelangelo's a hyper teen whom you know in time will become a solid, likeable adult. I think this is glimpsed at in SAINW and even the Vol 4 comics. I think a lot of his personality is shaped by the hard edges of his brothers...and like others have already mentioned, it grounds the group. He 'bends like the reed', and so forth.

Michelangelo is only a "hyper teen" in the 2K3 series and the 2007 movie in which he was little more than a dim-witted comic relief character with a few occasional shining moments.

What you describe as him being in Volume 4 of the Mirage series --- "a solid, likeable adult" --- is pretty much how he was from the beginning. Its not as if his fundamental personality suddenly changed when Laird began Volume 4, that is how Mike has always been in Mirage. Not just Mirage, that's how he has consistently been in pretty much all the comic iterations (Mirage, Archie, Image, and Dreamwave).

One of the best portrayals of him in the comics is Tales of the TMNT Vol 2 #9 "The Path". I would like to see more depictions of his character like that in the new movie and series.

Vivi
12-18-2009, 04:11 PM
Michelangelo is only a "hyper teen" in the 2K3 series and the 2007 movie in which he was little more than a dim-witted comic relief character with a few occasional shining moments.

What you describe as him being in Volume 4 of the Mirage series --- "a solid, likeable adult" --- is pretty much how he was from the beginning. Its not as if his fundamental personality suddenly changed when Laird began Volume 4, that is how Mike has always been in Mirage. Not just Mirage, that's how he has consistently been in pretty much all the comic iterations (Mirage, Archie, Image, and Dreamwave).

One of the best portrayals of him in the comics is Tales of the TMNT Vol 2 #9 "The Path". I would like to see more depictions of his character like that in the new movie and series.


I don't think it's so much a fundamental personality change as character growth. It's not unfeasible that his personality can mature...an interesting idea for Mikey in 2K3. Those occasional shining moments give evidence of this. But either way, I guess I like both the comic and 2K3 versions of him. :)

Btw, I really like the "The Path", a few eps remind me of elements of this comic.

heretic888
12-18-2009, 06:02 PM
I don't think it's so much a fundamental personality change as character growth. It's not unfeasible that his personality can mature...an interesting idea for Mikey in 2K3. Those occasional shining moments give evidence of this. But either way, I guess I like both the comic and 2K3 versions of him. :)

Btw, I really like the "The Path", a few eps remind me of elements of this comic.

I guess, for me, I don't see that much character evolution for Michelangelo in the comics. The Mikey we find in Volume 2 (at age 17-18) is for all intents and purposes the Mikey we find at the beginning of Volume 4 (at age 31-32), as far as I can tell. Perhaps this is due to his notable under-representation as a major character in the Mirage books, but whatever the case may be I don't see a major leap in maturity from the character in Volume 1/2 and the character in Volume 4.

If anything, the most recent events in Volume 4 seem to be leading to a hardening of his personality, not a softening of it. He was (seemingly) betrayed by the mother of his child, imprisoned, malnourished, beaten, escapes, is forced to survive on his own out in an alien wilderness, and then joins a Triceraton commando squad (again seemingly) bent on revenge. So he may end up being somewhat similar to the Mike we find in the 2k3 "Same As It Never Was" (sans the missing arm, hopefully). It will be interesting to see what direction Laird takes the character (assuming he ever decides to finish Volume 4).

As for 2K3 series, I really only see within-episodes character growth/maturity for Mike there. There are quite a few episodes where he purportedly "learns a lesson" about humility or respect or discipline, only to act like said lesson never happened a week later. Which, no offense, is pretty much what I would expect --- 2k3 Mike is, after all, just a comic relief character. The writers can't have the perpetual butt of their jokes actually developing some real layers or depth outside of a single episode, after all.

I just hope this newest iteration of the TMNT sees Mike as the fun-loving Everyman and sensitive Artist of the family again (and hope even moreso that they actually ARE a family under Nick), not the ultra-hyper dunce he was made out to be in the NT and 2007 movie.

Dejablue
12-19-2009, 12:05 AM
Watch. They'll do it like NM where they all know they aren't actually biological brothers. Mmmm Turtlecest....

IS EVIL BEYOND ALL IMAGININGS!


And on well whatever form Mikey takes he's always the heart of the team. That's what I like most about any incarnation of his character.

Daniel Orduna
12-19-2009, 04:04 AM
I like the mike of tales of tmnt #54 he is funny but not that gooffy like
in the cartoon,he is my fav, but it kinnda bugs me that he is not that smart on the movies or the toon,

ps where can I buy the comic when he becomes a father¿

odupianist
12-21-2009, 11:17 AM
Side note: I'm still skeptical about it being "his" child. Who knows if we'll ever find out though.

TurtleNinja
12-21-2009, 11:28 AM
I think his personality changes each time a new TMNT TV show/Movie is announced. I love the 2k3 Mikey and I hope they keep him that way forEVER...

But I've also seen him in two different lights, one being more mature, the other being more and MORE like the baby of the family. Needs hugs, plenty of sleep and yeah you get the picture <.<

I don't want Mikey to change, he's part of the major chemistry in the turtle family and I wouldn't want him of all turtles to change.

ooglafina
01-01-2010, 06:23 PM
I've always wondered if Mike's immaturity stemmed from the knowledge that he was the youngest child. Writers of 'toons and movies somehow interpretted being the youngerst into being both stupid and immature. I just thought that Leo and Raph would pick on him and try to ditch him alot.

Dejablue
01-01-2010, 08:09 PM
Mikey definitely seems to be the most radically changing of the 4 when it comes to personality. Yet at the same time he's the same guy no matter which continuity you look at. It's never as bad as say....OT Raphael. Some people think that Raphael wasn't even in that show and that he was just another version of Michelangelo. But I dunno. I happen to love OT Raphael. If I had to choose between which version I enjoy most to watch. I'm guilty to say I'm all for the sarcastic wise guy, 'always has something smart ass to say' version of him.

I guess it depends on how close to the source material this new movie is supposed to be. Like white on rice? Or like a loose adaption? Personally I like all the different adaptions of each character. I've never been able to say I outright dislike any version of the Turtles. It'd be very boring if each new movie/tv or cartoon show had the turtles acting exactly the same as they did in the previous series. The only exception being when the series or movies are supposed to be connected.

ooglafina
01-01-2010, 08:25 PM
[QUOTE=Dejablue;743829] Personally I like all the different adaptions of each character. I've never been able to say I outright dislike any version of the Turtles. It'd be very boring if each new movie/tv or cartoon show had the turtles acting exactly the same as they did in the previous series. QUOTE]

I agree with that. I think it will all come down to the director in the next addition. I don't know how closely they follow fan forums, but they ultimately follow their own muse. And I'm sure that there will plenty for people to hate/ love/ debate.

Sage Ninja
01-04-2010, 05:32 PM
ok I'm going to list the major reason I like and dislike Michelangelo in the two main mediums that I have known him in.

OT Michelangelo (likes)

the fact that he isn't pushed as the "funny" guy by the creators and his character doesn't try to be a walking punchline in the show. The surfer persona seems less grating on the nerves.

though he has his moments of being unfocused or clueless about how his actions might annoy his brothers, he's over all alot more serious and reliable in battle situations or other wise.

He's potrayed as a genuanly "nice guy" who cares about others and has actual feelings for others with out it seeming to heavy handed or forced.

When terriable or serious things are happening with the turtles he doesn't just fall into the background and act like it doesn't affect him; he's just as involved as the other turtles. And actually shows other emotions other than perpeptual happiness or stoke.

When the show turned over into red sky and becaome more gritty and intense and the turtles got more serious, he did as well and matured with the rest of them. With the exclusive exception of "Havoc in the Streets".

and the biggest thing about OT Mike that I appriciate about him is he isn't portrayed as a little brother.

Dislikes

He was constantly shown as the weakest fighter of the group. I mean he could hold his own but when compared to the others he seemed much weaker. :roll:

He was the turtle most likely to be captured or tied up or just generally in need of rescue. Which ticked me off. :x

For some bizzar reason Bebop and Rocksteady always singled him out and picked on him more than the other turtles. :-? And they didn't seem particualy intimidated by him like they where with the other turtles. :|

His pizza obbsession is annoying after like two minutes.

2k3 Michelangelo (likes)

I love, love, love 2k3 Mikey as a fighter. When he wasn't goofing off or show boating he was a pretty awsome fighter. Probalby the most redeeming quality about him.

The fact that he doesn't have a 1980/90's surfer voice. Major props for this, this show took place in present day not 20/10 years ago and he should speak as such. (unlike other present incanations of Mike)

His moments of ingenuity.

(dislikes)

the fact that he's show off brash and cocky and seems more interested in his own sense of enjoyment than others. This really makes him unsympathatic alot, when his cocky attitude blows up in his face you kind of don't want to sympathise with him.

The fact that he's written as mostly comic relief and isn't allowed to develop beyond one episode. Or that he never seems learn his lesson.

That he's portrayed as the most annoying person in the world. Seriously what the hell. Does the writers have to make it that anyone who comes across him is put off or annoyed by him. Why does his defining characteristic have to be that he's annoying? :evil:

He isn't portayed is all that nice. This is a problem with me because Michelangelo as a character has always been nice. He has some beautiful sweet moments at times in the series but I find them far inbetween. He mostly seems interested in getting rise out of people.

Dejablue
01-04-2010, 07:00 PM
That he's portrayed as the most annoying person in the world. Seriously what the hell. Does the writers have to make it that anyone who comes across him is put off or annoyed by him. Why does his defining characteristic have to be that he's annoying?


Because Annoying people need to exist. Lol

ooglafina
01-04-2010, 07:53 PM
and the biggest thing about OT Mike that I appriciate about him is he isn't portrayed as a little brother.

I guess I don't mind and kind of like him being portrayed as the little brother, as long as it isn't assumed that youngest equals most immature. I know a family of 9 children and I've noticed that the youngest is defined not by how she acts but by how much the others all boss her around. When they need something fetched, they just look at her and expect her to do it. And she does it. I'm the oldest and I still boss my sister around, even though she's married with kids.

I hope that the new screenwriter sees all these character complications and potential for Mike. He's more interesting than I used to consider him. Most people don't realize what a rich character he could be. You guys do. I mean the general populace.

heretic888
01-04-2010, 10:43 PM
He was constantly shown as the weakest fighter of the group. I mean he could hold his own but when compared to the others he seemed much weaker. :roll:

Not to nitpick, but this wasn't how I remembered OT Mike at all (although I'm hardly the hardcore OT fan than some of the other posters around here are). Even though Leo beat him in a sparring match in the first episode, I distinctly remember him gaining an upper hand on Don during sparring in one of the latter Red Season episodes and completely making Raph look like a putz ("Uh, best 2 out of 3??") in one of the middle-season episodes. I occasionally remember him destroying the odd machine that the others couldn't defeat, but its been awhile and my memories are a little fuzzy on that count.

I guess I don't mind and kind of like him being portrayed as the little brother, as long as it isn't assumed that youngest equals most immature. I know a family of 9 children and I've noticed that the youngest is defined not by how she acts but by how much the others all boss her around. When they need something fetched, they just look at her and expect her to do it. And she does it. I'm the oldest and I still boss my sister around, even though she's married with kids.

It greatly annoys me when any of the TMNT are portrayed as being a different age than the others. If they are biological brothers (which they seem to be in every medium but the Next Mutation and there were contrived story reasons for that), then they were hatched from the same set of eggs putting their births within a few days of each other.

More importantly, the TMNT's "second" birth as sentient beings (via the mutagen) occurred at exactly the same time for each of them. Portraying one as older or younger than the other makes no sense other than to force-feed contrived character roles ("oh he's the youngest so he's kinda the class clown of the family") down the throats of a naive audience.

Vivi
01-05-2010, 07:36 PM
Not to mention his brothers treat him as a joke. It wasn't until FF and his confrontation with the new Turtle Titan that Mikey finally got the recognition he had been craving.

Yes, this episode is pretty extreme in terms of the personality of Mikey. It's pretty interesting to note that as soon as Michelangelo gets some kind of positive acknowledgment that he acts more himself. I think that he is treated like a joke ergo he acts like one. Too bad, because he comes across with more depth than that to me in the 2k3 series.

Dejablue
01-05-2010, 10:58 PM
More importantly, the TMNT's "second" birth as sentient beings (via the mutagen) occurred at exactly the same time for each of them. Portraying one as older or younger than the other makes no sense other than to force-feed contrived character roles ("oh he's the youngest so he's kinda the class clown of the family") down the throats of a naive audience.

I'm not naive. I know they were all mutated at the same time. I happen to like the dynamic thank you very much. Age might not have much to do with mental maturity.

ooglafina
01-06-2010, 01:07 PM
Age amongst siblings is also a dynamic that everyone can relate to. Not many can relate to mutating at the same time. All it takes to be the oldest is a mental advantage over the other ones.

Cipher
01-07-2010, 01:33 PM
It greatly annoys me when any of the TMNT are portrayed as being a different age than the others. If they are biological brothers (which they seem to be in every medium but the Next Mutation and there were contrived story reasons for that), then they were hatched from the same set of eggs putting their births within a few days of each other.

More importantly, the TMNT's "second" birth as sentient beings (via the mutagen) occurred at exactly the same time for each of them. Portraying one as older or younger than the other makes no sense other than to force-feed contrived character roles ("oh he's the youngest so he's kinda the class clown of the family") down the throats of a naive audience.This. I know it's off topic, but it's one of my TMNT pet peeves when a version tries to establish different ages for them. When did that even start? I don't remember anything about different ages ever being in the comics, Fred Wolf cartoon, or old movies.

You know how some people are bothered by the fact that the Turtles aren't blood relatives in Next Mutation? I have no problem with that. But that's exactly how bothered I am by the "different ages" thing. And, even in a series with mutants and aliens and ninjas, it makes no damn sense.

Dejablue
01-07-2010, 02:36 PM
This. I know it's off topic, but it's one of my TMNT pet peeves when a version tries to establish different ages for them. When did that even start? I don't remember anything about different ages ever being in the comics, Fred Wolf cartoon, or old movies.

You know how some people are bothered by the fact that the Turtles aren't blood relatives in Next Mutation? I have no problem with that. But that's exactly how bothered I am by the "different ages" thing. And, even in a series with mutants and aliens and ninjas, it makes no damn sense.


Didn't you read anything I said about Mental maturity? :ohwell:

Cipher
01-07-2010, 06:00 PM
Didn't you read anything I said about Mental maturity? :ohwell:It's fine if they want to portray a certain Turtle as being less mature (well, it usually doesn't play out well, but whatever).

What I have a problem with is a few universes' explanation of "Mike is the least mature because he's the younger brother." That's just ... really lazy and makes no sense.

Dejablue
01-07-2010, 08:22 PM
It's fine if they want to portray a certain Turtle as being less mature (well, it usually doesn't play out well, but whatever).

What I have a problem with is a few universes' explanation of "Mike is the least mature because he's the younger brother." That's just ... really lazy and makes no sense.

Its not lazy it's obviously a metaphor. How is it bad that Mikey is just considered a younger brother? How does this one particular characterization ruin him? Should they all act like Leo?

Cure
01-07-2010, 09:11 PM
Its not lazy it's obviously a metaphor. How is it bad that Mikey is just considered a younger brother? How does this one particular characterization ruin him? Should they all act like Leo?

What? No, they don't mean it as a metaphor, they mean it literally. Even then, saying "this is my little bro" when he's the same age as the rest is dumb. Mikey is immature, not younger. Total difference.

Mecha Cow
01-08-2010, 05:50 PM
Its not lazy it's obviously a metaphor.
Obviously.

It's a children's cartoon. They're character archetypes.

Oculus Orbus
01-09-2010, 06:03 AM
For me, the best Mikey ever is in Tales of the TMNT Vol.2 #64, by Tristan Jones. That should be the ultimate Mikey, but at the same time, I don't think many writers can do what Tristan Jones does.

heretic888
01-09-2010, 07:17 PM
Its not lazy it's obviously a metaphor. How is it bad that Mikey is just considered a younger brother? How does this one particular characterization ruin him? Should they all act like Leo?

No, but they shouldn't act like one-dimensional comic relief characters, either.

Also, as someone with a degree in psychology, I really don't grasp the whole "maturity" argument either (or even what that really means in this context). Its not as if in a few years Mike will start acting like Leo or Don. What we are talking about are obviously differences in personality dynamics, not developmental differences. Leo is not more or less "mature" than Mike, he just has a different personality type (which, incidentally, is something you are more or less born with -- or, rather, develop at a very early age -- not something you grow into with time).

Although, all this seems besides the point to me as a weird justification for bad writing. There isn't some underlying philosophical motive for writing Mike the way they did in the 2K3 series and the 2007 movie, they just needed an idiotic comic relief character that would fall on his head and make the audience laugh at low-brow slapstick humor. There is nothing more to it than that.

I would just think that fans of the character would be at least a little offended (or at least annoyed) at this characterization. In his original characterization, Michelangelo is creative and witty, not a walking gag line.

Dejablue
01-09-2010, 07:37 PM
But people have already stated that they like different forms of Michelangelo. Some hate him across the board. You can't please them all. It seems a lot of people really loved 2k3 Mikey. So what are they? Traitorous scum? Also I think the current presentation of Mikey being 'bad writing' might be stretching it a tad. In the cartoon at least he acted serious enough when he needed to. So I don't get what people are coming from when they say he was just a walking bag of gags and jokes.

heretic888
01-09-2010, 07:39 PM
But people have already stated that they like different forms of Michelangelo. You can't please them all. It seems a lot of people really loved 2k3 Mikey? So what are they? Traitorous scum?

Most of the feedback I have seen about the 2K3 Mike on here and other places describe him as "annoying", "arrogant", and "self-centered" among other things. I mean, I found the character extremely tedious and he's my favorite TMNT (I cheered when he won the Battle Nexus). That speaks volumes.

In any case, good writing isn't a popularity contest.

heretic888
01-09-2010, 07:46 PM
Also I think the current presentation of Mikey being 'bad writing' might be stretching it a tad. In the cartoon at least he acted serious enough when he needed to. So I don't get what people are coming from when they say he was just a walking bag of gags and jokes.

The problem with Mike in the 2K3 series is when he acted "serious" (as in, demonstrated some actual depth as a character) it was portrayed as "WOW! Look at Mike now! He's being cool!!" episodes and he would 99% of the time revert back to his old ways by the next episode. I mean, the absolute number of times he resolved the "I wanna be a super hero/Turtle Titan" silliness was absurd, considering it was resolved in the very first season quite well (when he flat-out admitted he could do the most good in the shadows). That just shows what a gimmick the character was.

Dejablue
01-09-2010, 07:52 PM
The problem with Mike in the 2K3 series is when he acted "serious" (as in, demonstrated some actual depth as a character) it was portrayed as "WOW! Look at Mike now! He's being cool!!" episodes and he would 99% of the time revert back to his old ways by the next episode. I mean, the absolute number of times he resolved the "I wanna be a super hero/Turtle Titan" silliness was absurd, considering it was resolved in the very first season quite well (when he flat-out admitted he could do the most good in the shadows). That just shows what a gimmick the character was.

True but if he didn't revert back he'd be boring. Technically you could say that about any turtle in this show. They never broke their core personality traits. They didn't want to break the mold too much because it was something children could identify with quickly. But anyway I don't know why this is getting off into the cartoons anyway. This is a movie topic isn't it? And if this new movie is going to be "hardcore" or whatever it is you people want. Then it'd make the most sense that they'll follow the comic book. So you'll get what you want.

heretic888
01-09-2010, 07:59 PM
True but if he didn't revert back he'd be boring. Technically you could say that about any turtle in this show. They never broke their core personality traits. They didn't want to break the mold too much because it was something children could identify with quickly. But anyway I don't know why this is getting off into the cartoons anyway. This is a movie topic isn't it? And if this new movie is going to be "hardcore" or whatever it is you people want. Then it'd make the most sense that they'll follow the comic book. So you'll get what you want.

Leonardo and Donatello both showed character development during the series, mostly because there were multiple episode story-archs directly involving changes to them. In any event, I highly doubt many kids "identify" with the 2K3 Mike so much as they thought his antics were funny. Like I said, comic relief. Its just a shame he's supposed to be one of the protagonists --- the comic relief characters in most series like this are secondary or background characters.

I have no expectations whatsoever about this new movie. It was so early in the development stage when Nick took over that who knows what we'll be getting.

kev trashcan
01-11-2010, 03:10 AM
dont get me wrong but i think all four of them do in the new movie, i dont expect it to get better in the new toon. but as far as the new movie goes i dont want them to be so gimicky, you know? yes they all have there different personal trades, good keep them, but dont make four lines in a row like this

"its time for me too lead now"
"science, science, science. and im going to fix it"
" time to bash a skull"
"whoa dude"

im not trying to bash them, just saying take what they have and give it more depth

Powder
01-11-2010, 03:44 AM
For me, the best Mikey ever is in Tales of the TMNT Vol.2 #64, by Tristan Jones. That should be the ultimate Mikey, but at the same time, I don't think many writers can do what Tristan Jones does.

It's simply a matter of actually portraying mikey as a TEENAGER. Something most seldom do. The use of slang and imaginary storytelling is all it took.

Koi
01-12-2010, 06:59 PM
I would actually have to say no need to improve Mikey. Most kids adore his immaturity it is something for kids to relate to, and to me I love the gimmick of him being a surfer dude.

Frankly I could never see Mikey as serious, to me it is just wrong only do to the fact I grew up with a more immature, surfer dude portrayal. And I am guessing a lot load of the newer generation people think exactly the same.

I have never heard anything about him being a writer or any of that stuff. (Never read a TMNT comic in my life.) And to tell you the truth, that just boggles my mind, seems horribly wrong. Even if it is more accurate.

kev trashcan
01-12-2010, 10:00 PM
I would actually have to say no need to improve Mikey. Most kids adore his immaturity it is something for kids to relate to, and to me I love the gimmick of him being a surfer dude.

Frankly I could never see Mikey as serious, to me it is just wrong only do to the fact I grew up with a more immature, surfer dude portrayal. And I am guessing a lot load of the newer generation people think exactly the same.

I have never heard anything about him being a writer or any of that stuff. (Never read a TMNT comic in my life.) And to tell you the truth, that just boggles my mind, seems horribly wrong. Even if it is more accurate.

yeah but thats just the thing in the comic he is a writer, why cant he be both that and the surfer dude without it being a gimic next time around? there are plenty of surfer dudes who write and arnt goofy and inmatue. i say cut up all he pieces and glue'em all back together diffrently without making it another gimic character.

Koi
01-13-2010, 07:29 PM
, why cant he be both that and the surfer dude without it being a gimic next time around?

Because for some reason my mind gives me syntex error when writer and Mikey come together.... That is just so wrong to me. But, I should at least give it a try and find a comic store near by and check into this.

jaymq
01-13-2010, 07:34 PM
Because for some reason my mind gives me syntex error when writer and Mikey come together.... That is just so wrong to me. But, I should at least give it a try and find a comic store near by and check into this.

Try issue 17 of Volume 1 if you can get it.

odupianist
01-14-2010, 12:51 PM
Or you can go here...

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/mirage/seventeen/cover.html

Koi
01-14-2010, 07:21 PM
Well, I just read threw that, (don't hate my point of view) and I have to say. As cool as he was, he isn't the Mikey I grew up with,and he was very non unique to an extent that he was interchangeable with both Raph and Leo.

The comic didn't seem to have much input into Mikey's mental characteristics enough for me to say much about him. Might be do the fact that I am way more use to an over the top "no duh" characteristics that distinguish him from his brothers. Besides the ending that only hinted about it.

But the comic was fun and entertaining to read non the less, thanks for the link odupianist and suggestion Moosandra. ^_^

jaymq
01-14-2010, 08:10 PM
Well, I just read threw that, (don't hate my point of view) and I have to say. As cool as he was, he isn't the Mikey I grew up with,and he was very non unique to an extent that he was interchangeable with both Raph and Leo.

The comic didn't seem to have much input into Mikey's mental characteristics enough for me to say much about him. Might be do the fact that I am way more use to an over the top "no duh" characteristics that distinguish him from his brothers. Besides the ending that only hinted about it.

But the comic was fun and entertaining to read non the less, thanks for the link odupianist and suggestion Moosandra. ^_^

And thank you for giving it a shot. :)

***First of Two Latin Kings***
01-14-2010, 11:18 PM
Mirage Mikey is hard to get used to if you grew up with the "other" Michelangelo who seems to come through in the cartoons, movies, Archie comics, etc. I still think that Michelangelo is the hardest turtle to "get right." I may have to bring in a professional for this one though...

Cipher
01-15-2010, 02:15 PM
Or you can go here...

http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/mirage/seventeen/cover.htmlThat's not really Mike's best issue (but I love the writer stuff that comes up in Tales and Volume 3).

I still feel like Volume 2 treated him with the most respect. Talking about their living situation, chillin' with Shadow, gettin' deep with Leo, etc. Those first few issues were a really good glimpse at a laid-back, mature Mike.

heretic888
01-16-2010, 07:04 AM
Mirage Mikey is hard to get used to if you grew up with the "other" Michelangelo who seems to come through in the cartoons, movies, Archie comics, etc. I still think that Michelangelo is the hardest turtle to "get right." I may have to bring in a professional for this one though...

Mirage Mike and Archie Mike are much more similar to one another than they are to the other versions. In fact, other than saying "dude" every now and then, Archie Mike is an almost identical character to Mirage Mike.

I like Tristan Jones' take on Mike as the "everyman" of the TMNT myself.

odupianist
01-19-2010, 08:52 AM
I like Tristan Jones' take on Mike as the "everyman" of the TMNT myself.

I agree. People seem to overlook (or forget) that Mike is supposed to be able to relate the most to humans. You don't really see that in any incarnation of Mike except in some Mirage issues.

I post the link below to kind of help support the theory. Mike's "mutation" was the ability to look more human.

http://plairdblog.blogspot.com/2008/11/blast-from-past-39-repost-michelangelos.html

odupianist
02-10-2010, 10:14 AM
I apologize for the double post, but I posted this elsewhere and figured it should be here as well.

I think if you pull Mikey's characteristics from a few key comics, you could get a really good version of Mikey. Here's some of the issues, they should look at when writing Mike:

Vol 1: #4 (despite having an injured arm, he's the first to use himself as a decoy for his brothers to get away), #5 (first to attack the Federation troops, kind of shows a bit of hot headedness I think)

Tales Vol 1: #4 where he shows a bit more compassion for the Rat King

Vol 2: Where he mentions he's staying in the apartment to be close to Shadow

Vol 3: #8 where he goes and rescues Shadow, and Vol 3 in general with his writing is pretty cool

Vol 4: Last five issues or so where he escapes the prison and shows his darker side a bit as he is among the Triceratons.

Tales Vol 2: #9 (his sensitivity and his selfishness with Klunk but then coming around), #30 (him wanting to be alone, being among the humans a bit, and his curiousity), #50 (just his small quips here and there), #51 (the few panels with Raph and the teddy bear where he admits he knows he can be a handful sometimes), #64 (just his overall narration of this story)

I'm sure there are more that I'm forgetting or that others will come up with, but this is what I have so far.

Mona_Lisa
02-11-2010, 10:13 AM
I like the funny “Mikey”. I like that his brothers call him Mikey, since he is the little brother and all.
It would be nice to see Michelangelo get mad, or be sad. Maybe even show him breaking up a fight between Raph and Leo!!!:tgrin:

Cipher
02-11-2010, 10:16 AM
I like the funny “Mikey”. I like that his brothers call him Mikey, since he is the little brother and all.Says who? Since when? I swear this is an idea that didn't exist a few years ago.

ToTheNines
02-11-2010, 10:22 AM
The idea was just popularized by the 2007 movie making him take on the little brother role.

Mona_Lisa
02-11-2010, 10:23 AM
Says who? Since when? I swear this is an idea that didn't exist a few years ago.

I guess I don’t know where that comes from, but that seems to be the way he is portrayed. Oh, and I just remembered in the CGI movie Leo says something about “and while you have been playing games little brother…”
I guess that doesn’t mean he is the youngest of the 4 though.:trazz:

Koi
02-11-2010, 05:10 PM
I guess I don’t know where that comes from, but that seems to be the way he is portrayed. Oh, and I just remembered in the CGI movie Leo says something about “and while you have been playing games little brother…”
I guess that doesn’t mean he is the youngest of the 4 though.:trazz:

Mikey I do believe is the youngest. And Mikey in the newer ones is just a goof ball who can't concentrate and is just a ball of adolescence, thrown to give comedy relief and to be an icon for children.

That is why I prefer the older toon Mikey, he was goofy enough but not over the top like todays version.

My two cent anyhow of the matter.

lwizardl
02-11-2010, 06:05 PM
no I think mikey is perfect the way that he has been portrayed to be the comedy character, all the character have a role that they fit into

Leonard: leader, honor student, ninja coordinator, teacher's pet

Donatello: Brains, mechanic, electrician, scientist.

Raphael: attitude, creates fights, basically the black sheep of the family.

Michelangelo: Comic relief, loves to party, calms down tension between the brothers.

Coola Yagami
02-11-2010, 06:18 PM
We haven't seen enough of 'calms down tension between the brothers'.

Koi
02-11-2010, 07:19 PM
Michelangelo: Comic relief, loves to party, calms down tension between the brothers.

Everything that pops out of Mikey's mouth makes him get slapped in the head. He sure sounds like he calms down tension there.

Mona_Lisa
02-12-2010, 01:13 PM
Everything that pops out of Mikey's mouth makes him get slapped in the head. He sure sounds like he calms down tension there.

Good point…:D

Sage Ninja
02-12-2010, 03:02 PM
Michelangelo:calms down tension between the brothers

why, oh why, do people keep saying this? It's not true. I don't even get where fans keep getting this from. (and please don't say comics Mikey, because that version of him only exisits in the comics).

It's like they are trying to interpret his obnoxious behavior as something posetive just to excuse it. Like Drawsher said, more often than not he gets smacked or glared at when ever he opens his mouth. Mikey is more of an instigator than anything else.

Mona_Lisa
02-12-2010, 05:39 PM
Mikey Tried to use humor to smooth out a fight between Raph and Leo in the 2nd move, but it didn’t work.

Sage Ninja
02-12-2010, 09:13 PM
I was talking about the new toon.

lwizardl
02-15-2010, 05:24 PM
Mikey Tried to use humor to smooth out a fight between Raph and Leo in the 2nd move, but it didn’t work.

exactly and I remember this also happening in a few of the cartoon episodes also. I don't want to sit and watch all the ipsodes again just to find the exact episode and like timestamp.

Powder
02-16-2010, 01:44 AM
This whole thread is aggravating.

Cipher
02-16-2010, 02:38 AM
why, oh why, do people keep saying this? It's not true. I don't even get where fans keep getting this from. (and please don't say comics Mikey, because that version of him only exisits in the comics).Well, what the hell do you want? The irritating version of him only exists in the 4Kids cartoon and the Imagi movie.

Most fans who've experienced the whole gambit of Turtles media enjoy the more subdued Mike of the comics (and to a lesser extend the Fred Wolf cartoon and '90s movies).

Michelangelo: Comic relief, loves to party, calms down tension between the brothers. These. These are the attributes that we've found most favorable over the years. Doesn't matter what versions they're taken from, they've been made a part of his character and can continue to be incorporated.

This whole thread is aggravating. I really just want it to go away at this point.

turkishproverb
02-16-2010, 03:10 AM
Erm, I just want to point out that Early 4kids Mikey wasn't actually that bad. He just got flanderized.

odupianist
02-16-2010, 07:42 AM
Erm, I just want to point out that Early 4kids Mikey wasn't actually that bad. He just got flanderized.

Agreed. 2k3 Mikey got a bad rap. Can he be annoying at times? Yes, but he also has some good characteristics that the other versions didn't have. We did get to see him focus on his training (Touch and Go), be an awesome fighter, and also be humbled in the Battle Nexus rematch. Granted, you don't really see it have a lasting effect, but it's still there.

ToTheNines
02-17-2010, 08:55 AM
If they're gonna make Mike the "funny turtle" (which is totally fine), they need to actually make him funny. Hire a comedy writer just for his lines if ya have to, but just do it.

And when he does make jokes the other turtles should actually laugh. I hate when the other guys slap him, they really abused that schtick in the 2k3 show.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-17-2010, 10:48 AM
I didn't have a problem with him in the cartoon or the movie. He just came off as goofy/like he wanted attention. Some of his jokes were actually funny, but I agree that a lot of them were dumb.

Mutagen Mutant
02-18-2010, 03:22 PM
Give Michaelangelo a kind of dark humor. He can therefore be able to keep the emotional part to his personality and joking manner, but in a darker way. He needs to loose his image of being involved in romantic relationships (in comic books), his party dude attitude and surfer slang (in the cartoons), and his teasing and annoying his brothers and "innocent empathy" (in the cartoons). If he developed an attitude of comedy AND tragedy then he would have more depth - a comedy based on problems of a personal/social nature. Michaelangelo has the biggest potential and natural fighting skill of the four, but his easy-going attitude keeps him from realizing this.

The Stryker
02-18-2010, 04:03 PM
So, Michelangelo making dead baby jokes?

Cipher
02-18-2010, 04:11 PM
So, Michelangelo making dead baby jokes?God, I hope so.

I think there's a re-interpretation we can all get behind.

Mutagen Mutant
02-18-2010, 04:29 PM
So, Michelangelo making dead baby jokes?

Well, if that's the extent of your idea of dark humor, then I'm glad you wouldn't be doing the writing.

The Stryker
02-18-2010, 04:58 PM
It's a joke. of the ha-ha variety.

Doc_ock_4mugen
02-18-2010, 06:11 PM
Please no Dark Humor on Mike... But no hyperactive annoying "Cowabunga Dude!" burp and fart joke Annoying Little Brother Mikey...

Sage Ninja
02-18-2010, 10:24 PM
Well, what the hell do you want? The irritating version of him only exists in the 4Kids cartoon and the Imagi movie.

Most fans who've experienced the whole gambit of Turtles media enjoy the more subdued Mike of the comics (and to a lesser extend the Fred Wolf cartoon and '90s movies).

what the hell? Simmer down buddy, I was refering to the people that only use the 2k3 and Imagi versions of Mikey that make that claim.

If they're gonna make Mike the "funny turtle" (which is totally fine), they need to actually make him funny. Hire a comedy writer just for his lines if ya have to, but just do it

exactly. Thankyou. Actually make him clever and humourous if they are going to Michelabngelo's the funny guy thing.

And when he does make jokes the other turtles should actually laugh. I hate when the other guys slap him, they really abused that schtick in the 2k3 show

one of the most annoying things after a while in the series. at least make the boys enjoy his humor instead of seeming perpetually annoyed/disgusted with it.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
02-25-2010, 01:51 AM
I'm just really starting to think that no matter how Mikey is portrayed people will never be pleased. Say what you will but people will always find a reason to moan and complain about how badly written Mikey is no matter what medium.

jalexbrown
03-08-2010, 08:14 PM
I think that Mikey could use a personality for the new movie never captured on film before, but at the same time I hope they don't do a total recant of the character and rob him of his personality, either.

dontplaydead27
04-22-2010, 12:20 PM
I thought the original movie portrayal of him was good, funny while still serious- which lead to an awesome chemistry with Don. I think they just need to quit writing him like they have the past few years. His 2007 persona was horrible I thought- I never watched much of the 03 toon because I couldn't get past that bad animation.

He doesn't need an overhaul, just a writer and voice actor who doesn't go "over the top"...BUT...chances are, as TMNT continues on with new, dumber, lazier children as their demographic, Mike is not going to get ANY more tolerable, as he changes with the times the most, possibly because he's the biggest link to the demographic.

NameGoesHere1066
05-03-2010, 12:08 PM
pfft. the Don Mikey riffing is over rated. Don would be completely exsperated by Mike. Sorry I just don't see them being all that close.